Line #49 BrokenAesop/Literature


1	%%
2	%%
3	%%
4	%%
5	%%
6	%% This list of examples has been alphabetized. Please add your example in the proper place. Thanks!
7	%%
8	%%
9	%%
10	%%
11	%%
12	%%
13	!!Works with their own page:
14	* ''BrokenAesop/HarryPotter''
15	* ''BrokenAesop/TheHungerGames''
16	----
17	* ''Literature/The8thSonAreYouKiddingMe'' has the main moral that one's birth doesn't determine their status in life, as emphasized by the protagonist going from the youngest son of an ImpoverishedPatrician family [[SelfMadeMan to a powerful player in the kingdom on his own]], and several other characters are motivated to make their own way in the world upon seeing his journey. However, Wendelin also has [[TheGift magic]], which is almost one-in-a-million rare, extremely powerful, and a talent that someone has to be born into as it can't be learned. So your birth decides everything about your success in life--the mistake of the nobles is judging it on the wrong thing.
18	* ''Literature/{{Animorphs}} [[Recap/AnimorphsTheExperiment #28: The Experiment]]'' has a deliberate example: most of the book consists of a long diatribe about how slaughterhouses and meatpacking plants are evil, terrifying places. Then in the last chapter all the kids get burgers. This was written by Applegate, who hated what the ghostwriter had done with the book.
19	** The same book also features Cassie preaching about how free will is impossible to eradicate, and she's supposed to be proven right at the end when the human-Controller in charge of the "feed humans mind control hormones through beef" reveals the project was an impossible task. Thing is, even her claim that human hosts can still feel their own emotions and think their own thoughts fell flat as far back as ''[[Recap/AnimorphsTheCapture #6: The Capture]]'', where Temrash 114 spent three days mentally torturing Jake for [[ThoughtCrime thinking thoughts Temrash disapproved of]], and showing him memories of the broken shell Tom became after months of this treatment.
20	* The proverb ''Luck favours the bold'', which is in original Latin ''audaces Fortuna iuvat''. Unfortunately this proverb is also a LostInTranslation in the original language. The stem word is ''audax'', which means "bold" in the sense of "insolent", "impudent", "uppity", "rude" and "outrageous", giving English language the word "audacious". The proverb is intended to mean "know when it is time to break the rules and not get caught", not that "be brave and you will succeed". Luck favours the impudent and outrageous, not the virtuous and courageous.
21	* ''Literature/{{Arthur}}'': In the first book ''Arthur's Nose'', Arthur faces bullying for his long snout and considers cosmetic surgery to reduce its size before realizing he should ignore the bullies and accept himself as he is, proclaiming "I'm just not me without my nose!". However, Arthur's nose [[ArtEvolution would get shorter and shorter with every succeeding book]], and by the time of [[WesternAnimation/{{Arthur}} the cartoon]], he barely had a nose at all -- presumably ''because'' it looked so awkward. Did his entire family get those nose jobs after all? Nowadays, the most popular incarnation of Arthur is the one with a short nose.
22	* ''Literature/TheBelgariad'': Barak and Merel fall in love and mend their AwfulWeddedLife the instant Barak lays eyes on his newborn son. BabiesMakeEverythingBetter... except the birth of their older daughters didn't help their relationship any, and furthermore, the son is implied to be the product of {{Marital Rape\|License}}.
23	* The moral introduced in ''Toys/{{Bionicle}} Legends #1: Island of Doom'': "You don't have to be a Toa to be a hero", meaning that even a small and powerless [[{{Hobbits}} Matoran]] is able to do great deeds, something that the earlier and later storylines had and would show quite well. There are two groups of Matoran characters who independently make this their mantra, Jaller's team and the Voya Nui Resistance lead by Garan. Yet, the message is undermined by the next novel, ''Dark Destiny''. Jaller's gang is [[MidSeasonUpgrade zapped into Toa]] because they needed Toa-level powers not only to beat the villains but also to simply survive their journey to Voya Nui, as they were traveling in Toa canisters that were deadly to their frail Matoran bodies. Garan's team are meanwhile knocked unconscious and dumped into a trash container by the villains, though at least they don't become fully useless and briefly act as helping hands for Jaller's Toa team later on.
24	* The Dr. Seuss story ''Literature/{{The Bippolo Seed\|AndOtherLostTales}}'' has a moral against being greedy. However, the cat and the duck only lost because the duck dropped his seed while doing a HappyDance. If he hadn't danced, they would have gotten away with being greedy ''and'' gotten all the things they wanted to sell.
25	* In ''Literature/BloodPromise'', [[spoiler:Dimitri]] is turned into a [[AlwaysChaoticEvil Strigoi]], a FateWorseThanDeath. Rose is deeply hurt by this and abandons her education to trek through Russia [[spoiler:so she can stake him]], and thereby find closure. It's a long and dangerous journey that ends with Rose learning that she has to let go of [[spoiler:Dimitri]]'s memory and return to her friends and family, because mourning him in such a obsessive way sabotages her own life. It's a good lesson that is ''shot to hell'' by the book's closing chapter, which reveals that Spirit wielders have a completely [[DeusExMachina unforeshadowed]] ability that allows them to resurrect [[spoiler:Strigoi as the people they were]], despite ''nothing'' else in the books even hinting that was possible. And after she learns this, Rose turns right back around and vows to get [[spoiler:Dimitri]] resurrected this way, even planning to break a serial killer out of prison so it can happen!
26	* Intentional in ''Literature/TheBrightestShadow'': The Hero explicitly draws moral lessons from events that are horrifying to the characters (and presumably the reader). The fact that they often don't make perfect sense is emphasized.
27	* ''Literature/BrownsPineRidgeStories'': Gary is agonizing over the prospect of the Dodge Dart he disliked being the one his father would buy, but then he arrives with a [[CoolCar Ford Starliner]] instead. The aesop at the end of this chapter is, to quote Gary, "Never give up and maybe the ugly ducklings you're expecting will become beautiful swans." Nowhere in the story does it involve any action on the part of the protagonist himself to change an unenviable outcome. It would be hoped that it was intended as a SpoofAesop and not one [[{{Narm}} meant to be taken seriously]].
28	* ''Literature/TheCandyShopWar'' has a pretty loud aesop, to the extent that John even states it, after having written it out for everyone in chalk. '''DON'T TAKE CANDY FROM STRANGERS!''' Great, but the kids ''don't'' take candy from random creeps on the side of the road. They get candy from a woman who owns a candy shop and a man who runs an ice-cream truck, having either paid for them or worked to earn them.
29	* OlderThanPrint: Chaucer [[TheParody parodies]] this trope in ''Literature/TheCanterburyTales'', by having the Pardoner tell a tale about the evils of greed... and then close the story with a sales pitch for all his crummy fake relics, because the Pardoner himself loves money above all else.
30	* The book ''Careful What You Wish For'' falls into the trap of Ruth (the main character) not actually ''getting'' what she wished for. First, she has a supposedly perfect life only her parents have dead eyes and her brothers are in stasis (which she never wished for, and she could clearly make her second wish "The same, but without the dead eyes and keep the brothers") and then she gets sent to a Catholic BoardingSchoolOfHorrors in the fifties... which, again, she didn't wish for.
31	* The popular poem "Literature/{{Casabianca}}" ("The boy stood on the burning deck") retells the story of a young son of Commander Louis de Casabianca who perished at his post during the Battle of the Nile, supposedly [[HonorBeforeReason heeding his father's order to remain until summoned]] while unaware that his father was already dead, and was a staple of British schoolboy education for at least a century despite its most obvious takeaway being "Don't obey your parents." A character in Samuel Butler's novel ''The Way of All Flesh'' observes that "the moral of the poem was that young people cannot begin too soon to exercise discretion in the obedience they pay to their papa and mamma."
32	* The Dutch book ''Literature/TheChatroomTrap'' tries to convey the Aesop that chatrooms are dangerous place for underage users, by having Floor and Marcia, two 15 year old girls, do a lot of dumb things in chatroom, culminating in Marcia posing naked for various persons. The catch is, all of this has no negative consequences whatsoever (even Marcia's naked photos are kept private). Instead, the reason the girls are targeted by the criminals (which leads to them being molested) is that they post their profile on a (legit) site for aspiring models, with the entire baiting process happening via e-mails.
33	* John Wyndham novel ''Literature/TheChrysalids'' initially has quite a powerful message against racism and xenophobia, being set in a backwards, post-apocalyptic theocracy in which mutants are brutally murdered for blaspheming against the likeness of God. Too bad the apparent message is fatally undermined in the last ten pages or so by having an airship full of technologically advanced mutants rescue the heroes by cheerfully massacring all of the primitive people surrounding them while talking about how it is moral and good for inferior races to be killed by their superiors.
34	** An alternative interpretation is that the telepaths are the visionary elements of the counterculture, while the "normal" people are oldthinkers and the mutant tribe are the mass of stoners, drop-outs, and wastrels in the counterculture. The message then becomes that neither ordinary people nor visionaries should fear the counterculture, but that ultimately the ordinary people and the drop-outs are dead-ends, and the visionaries need to just wait for them to die. John Wyndham's stories tend to hover somewhere between {{Metaphorgotten}} and mixed metaphor, which means you can find a lot of different messages, sometimes even several at once.
35	* Tom Godwin's short story ''Literature/TheColdEquations'' attempts to tell AnAesop about the uncaring nature of the universe, and how even an innocent mistake can cost a life, with no fault but that of universal law. Unfortunately, the basic thrust is undercut because of the setup of the situation. The only protection to keep someone from walking onto a spaceship where stowaways meet certain death is a sign saying "UNAUTHORIZED PERSONNEL. KEEP OUT!" This is especially bad, because it's flat-out stated that stowaways have happened before -- indeed, the pilot of the ship has a ''gun'' and explicit orders to ''shoot them'' -- yet the entire situation is treated as the fault of nothing but the physical laws of the universe. Readers are left to wonder why the craft had absolutely zero margin for error when modern lifeboats and transport craft are capable of handling far more than their generally required loads. (Part of the problem is ExecutiveMeddling: the magazine editor wanted a story where science ''doesn't'' save the day, and Godwin [[WriterRevolt kept finding ways to save the girl]].)
36	* Happens in-universe in the first ''Literature/DiaryOfAWimpyKid'' book. Greg's school puts out a PSA encouraging kids to BeYourself, but a bemused Greg notes that most of the school's bullies took this as an excuse not to change their behavior.
37	* One of the lessons in Creator/DrSeuss' ''Literature/DaisyHeadMayzie'' is "What good is money without all your friends?" Except Mayzie ''has no friends''--all we see are [[KidsAreCruel bratty children who taunt her]] in school about her daisy. And while the adults don't torment her, they don't exactly stick up for her either. But suddenly they all love her again once she's back to normal.
38	* ''Literature/DirtyBertie'': In the first book, Bertie learns that NatureTinkling is not allowed, however, in "Twitter!" when he has to pee while birdwatching, he's allowed to pee in the woods.
39	* In-universe example in the ''Literature/DreamPark'' novel ''The Barsoom Project''. A live-action adventure about Myth/InuitMythology is re-staged as a "Fat Ripper", in which players are psychologically conditioned to overcome their eating disorders and other dependencies while completing their mission. This could've been a real coup for the Park's operators, if one of the game's challenges hadn't required them to ''smoke cigarettes'' as part of a magical ritual. So we're training Gamers to trade one unhealthy habit for another.
40	* ''The Dreamers'' tetralogy by Creator/DavidEddings has a powerful one at the end. The series appears to build on the Aesop that the gods are supposed to barely affect people and use their powers sparingly and let things go naturally; so, after the gods are given children, [[spoiler:who are their replacements]], who are said to be able to save the world, they collect people from around the planet to help them fight off a HiveMind force of super insects. How is the Aesop broken? During the last two chapters of the last book, [[spoiler:the new gods in turn go back in time, render the original Hive Mother infertile, and give the man who almost single-handedly won the war because the loss of his wife caused him not to care about dying and made him want unending revenge his wife back. All this actively Unmakes all four books, and the main character's life is removed from existence. ]] Now, that is first-class meddling!
41	* ''Franchise/{{Dune}}'' is supposedly about the dangers of following charismatic religious leaders, as the protagonist Paul Atreides manipulates an army of desert nomads into thinking he is TheChosenOne according to their religious beliefs, which were actually engineered by a cult his mother belongs to, and unleashes a holy war that kills tens of billions, with his son Leto becoming a nigh-immortal GodEmperor who is even ''more'' tyrannical than his father. The problem is, said prophecy is fulfilled very much ''in spite'' of the desires of said cult and Paul himself (or his son, or both) seems to be the genuine article despite it being supposedly artificial, and both Paul and Leto develop genuine powers of prescience that let them see into the far future and are utterly certain that the atrocities they commit are the '''only''' path to avoid the extinction of the human race, so it comes off to many readers that everything is a necessary evil and the characters literally do not have any choice (and if they do, their despicable actions are still the "least bad"). It doesn't help that most of their atrocities [[ShowDontTell happen offscreen]], or that their enemies are [[BlackAndGrayMorality not much better]] and often just short-sighted and selfish, with Paul himself being the only character who angsts over his genocides half the time. The actual aesop arguably comes off more as "religious zealotry is dangerous, sure, but it's better than the alternative and works out in the long run."
42	* ''Literature/EightCousins'' criticizes adventure books where, supposedly, boy protagonists become rich by finding a treasure or get adopted by a millionaire because he happened to find and return the millionaire's purse. [[MoralGuardians Why can't we have wholesome books that teach children the value of hard work?]] Fair enough, but Literature/EightCousins itself has a heroine who is a rich heiress through no action of her own, and she "adopts" a poor orphan girl as her sister just because she sings beautifully and delivered an encouraging talk to the protagonist.
43	* The children's picture book ''The Elephant and the Bad Baby'' has an Aesop about the importance of being polite. The Elephant has taken the Bad Baby for a ride down the High Street, and asks him if he wants something from each of the shops they pass. The Bad Baby always says "Yes", and the a Elephant then steals it for him. They end up chased by a group of angry shopkeepers until the Elephant suddenly stops and complains that the Bad Baby never said "Please". The shopkeepers are appalled and side with the Elephant against the Bad Baby, even though he was the one stealing from them! Apparently, not saying "Please" is a worse offence than stealing. And babies don't deserve to cut any slack when they forget their manners.
44	* Creator/OrsonScottCard's ''Literature/{{Empire}}'' is about the dangers of divisiveness in American political discourse and the evils of extremism at both ends of the political spectrum. Fair enough. Unfortunately, it's fatally undermined by the fact that the heroes all unambiguously share "Red State values" whereas the villains are a bunch of [[StrawCharacter craven liberals.]] Er, if the message is that people of both political opinions should work together, you probably shouldn't have all the protagonists be on one side of the aisle, and all the villains on the other like that...
45	* The Creator/RobertHeinlein novel ''Literature/FarnhamsFreehold''. It's supposed to be an anti-racism novel, but given that Heinlein was an upper-class white man from pre-Civil Rights Era California, he really didn't have a great handle on what race issues actually ''were''. He just flipped things around so that the protagonists ended up in a society where black people (who were [[IAmAHumanitarian also cannibals]]) were now the masters of enslaved white people, so the Aesop came across as something along the lines of "given half a chance, black people will turn around and be even worse to white people than white people currently are to them." Or as one reviewer put it in a retrospective of Heinlein's work, it was "[[https://newrepublic.com/article/118048/william-pattersons-robert-heinlein-biography-hagiography an anti-racism novel only a Klansman could love]]."
46	** Heinlein's post-1960 works tend to have protagonists who preached against blindly accepting organized religion and cultural norms, and they instead encouraged freethought and individualism. These same protagonists would also strongly chastise anyone who didn't blindly accept their beliefs. For example, while the characters in ''Literature/StrangerInAStrangeLand'' happily preached free love, it also demonized homosexuality.
47	* ''Literature/FelicityFlooVisitsTheZoo'': The moral is [[DiseasePreventionAesop to blow your nose when you have a cold and not wipe your nose on your hands.]] However, Felicity was already breaking rules by going to the zoo while sick and petting the animals despite no one being allowed to anyway. Had she followed those rules, she could have still wiped her nose on her hands without any consequences.
48	* ''Literature/FiftyShadesOfGrey'':
49	** Anastasia and Christian's relationship is meant to be seen as an ideal relationship, which everyone should strive for. Yet Christian ''physically'' abuses Anastasia, be it by raping or hitting her with tools like riding crops or belts, manipulates her thoughts and actions through his words, and never takes her No as an answer. In turn, Anastasia is actively ''scared'' of him and admits to this multiple times in the narrative, often stating that she is 'enduring' things for his sake, rather than wanting it herself. She actually ''left'' him, after initially realizing that she cannot consent to his fetishes in the bedroom, yet he forces his way into her life only a few days after, before she returns to him. Their relationship is anything but healthy and consensual and the fact that the [[FourthDateMarriage eleven days marriage]] is dropped very soon by Christian further portrays that they are rushing their relationship horribly, Christian even admitting in ''Fifty Shades Freed'' that he ''actually doesn't know a thing about Anastasia''.
50	** The other Aesop of the book is supposed to be about a woman discovering her sexuality and enjoying it. Completely broken by the fact that Anastasia can only properly admit to herself that she is feeling horny by attributing anything regarding arousal to her [[GoodAngelBadAngel Inner Goddess]], a mental representation of her sexuality that she depicts as the epitome of [[SlutShaming a perpetually horny woman]]. She considers sex dirty and disgusting, unless one is absolutely in love with their partner, and often shames people who have casual sex mentally; including her best friend Kate. Anastasia's discovery of BDSM is also done improperly: she isn't taught anything, doesn't understand safe words, and she's actively scared of the majority of what BDSM entails. The Aesop is less 'a woman discovers her sexuality and enjoys it' and more 'a woman submits to the old {{lie back and think of England}} trope'.
51	* ''Literature/TheFruitOfEvolution'' has the overarching moral of [[PrejudiceAesop judging others based on their character instead of their appearance]], starting early when Seiichi has to realize he was wrong about judging Saria for being an ugly gorilla monster when she [[TakingTheBullet takes an almost-fatal strike]] to save him. Later on, the series uses TheEmpire and the armies of MaouTheDemonKing to explore and show the problems of bigotry and discrimination. Unfortunately, this moral is broken because BeautyEqualsGoodness is in full effect in this series--Seiichi and various members of his harem get ProgressivelyPrettier with every power upgrade, and reasonable characters on each side of the various issues are portrayed as attractive while jerks and incompetents are nearly always [[{{Gonk}} ugly]]. It takes a good while for the story to show a heroic character that is not conventionally attractive. So in this universe, you get the sense that it's entirely reasonable to judge based on appearance.
52	* ''Literature/TheFountainhead'' has the message that all charity is evil, until the end, when Roark only succeeds in his dream because of his rich friend's charity. The friend even says that the one purpose of his fortune is to help someone like Roark, completely undermining the "people should live for themselves only" Aesop. The actual Aesop of the book seems to be "Howard Roark is awesome and everyone should do whatever he wants them to", or alternatively "Charity is a stupid and ultimately harmful sentiment...unless you're the one getting it, in which case take all you can get."
53	* ''Literature/{{Goosebumps}}'': In ''Literature/DontGoToSleep'' has a moral that is appreciate what you have, yet this moral falls apart, because what Matt had made him miserable (a small bedroom, [[BigBrotherBully older siblings who pick on him]] [[ForTheEvulz for fun]], [[AnimalsHateHim the family dog who hates only his guts]]). Really, Matt had ''NOTHING'' to appreciate in his regular life.
54	* The main antagonists in ''Literature/GuardiansOfGaHoole'' are Nazi expies whose belief that barn owls are superior to all other owls and the rightful rulers of the land appalls every heroic character. However, main protagonist Soren, who leads a group of other owls and [[TheCall initiated their quest]], is a barn owl. The next true king of Ga'Hoole, [[TheChosenOne who's destined to rule all owls and usher in a golden age]], is also foretold to be and ends up being a barn owl (and his uncle of the same species inherits the crown later). These coincidences come off less as 'No race is any better or worse than another' than 'Non-Aryans can't do anything without the guidance and virtue of Aryans'. The heroic barn owls just have more ''noblesse oblige''.
55	* ''Literature/HalfwayAcrossTheGalaxyAndTurnLeft'' finishes with the curious alien family deciding that life on Earth is preferable to the life they lived before on an alien planet. Well, yes, life on Earth is great.. if your entire family has PsychicPowers and includes two [[ChildProdigy Child Prodigies]] and a ProudBeauty (none of which would be unusual on Zyrgon).
56	* While ''Literature/HighSchoolProdigiesHaveItEasyEvenInAnotherWorld'' goes out of its way to try to show [[GoodRepublicEvilEmpire how much better democracy is in contrast to the classist, abusive feudal system]], the protagonists don't do many democratic things throughout the story. Instead of negotiating with others or letting the people decide what is best, the protagonists form a ScamReligion to take charge of government and decide what is best for the people and force other countries to bend the knee through superior military technology. In the Yamato arc, the protagonists allow their citizens to vote on the issue of helping Yamato and try not to state their opinion, but this is long after the voters have been influenced by said religion. Worse yet, the Republic of Elm's democratic system would have been subverted by malicious actors without the protagonists' interference.
57	* ''Literature/{{Hobgoblin}}'' was written to cash in on the craze over ''TabletopGame/DungeonsAndDragons'' players ostensibly going crazy and believing they were their characters. Scott, the main character, is portrayed as clinging to childish things by valuing his RPG sessions over more traditional high school pursuits. When given a chance, he starts emulating his bloodthirsty Celtic warrior character. And... by doing so, he saves the lives of multiple people and goes on to be more well-adjusted than his peers.
58	* ''Literature/HollowKingdom'' suggests that human activity is unbalancing nature and will ultimately result in nature correcting itself. However, the correction in question produces zombies that are still negatively affecting the balance of nature because they're attacking and eating the wildlife, [[spoiler:especially after they start mutating into forms capable of taking on apex predators and winning]].
59	* Kevin J. Anderson does this in ''Literature/{{Hopscotch}}''. One of the parallel story threads follows a girl who joins an increasingly abusive cult whose founder is obsessed with the idea of sharing everything--this being a soft sci-fi story, this includes [[FreakyFridayFlip sharing bodies]]. [[spoiler:The group is quickly set up to be "bad," and the girl is forced out of it and forced to leave her original body behind. She finds another leader-type to follow, a fellow who claims that body-swapping is bad and should never be practiced, and he gets a lengthy CharacterFilibuster on the subject. The astute reader might notice that this moral is actively contradicted in the other story threads, so it seems like a broken aesop. Later on, however, she discovers that her original body is dead, and gets to decide whether or not to trade for a body similar, but not identical, to the one she had. For a few seconds, she considers which choice would be more in line with the precepts she's adopted--then she realizes that she's still blindly doing whatever she's told, and for the first time in the book, she makes her decision based on her own instincts rather than someone else's advice.]]
60	* According to ''Literature/TheHost2008'' free will is more important than a utopia, and living parasitically in a host body is immoral. [[spoiler:Which is why Wanderer gets moved against her express wishes into a different host body, ruining another alien's happy life in the process.]]
61	* Racial prejudice is a recurring theme in ''Literature/TheIcewindDaleTrilogy'', ''Literature/TheDarkElfTrilogy'', and the ''Literature/LegacyOfTheDrowSeries'' by R.A. Salvatore. Drizzt Do'Urden is a ChaoticGood dark elf who rejects the ways of his otherwise AlwaysChaoticEvil people and goes to live among the "good" races. He is subjected to FantasticRacism, which would work better as an analogue to RealLife racism if every other dark elf in the series bar one or two weren't evil, and if drow society as a whole weren't even worse than others assume it to be. The racists are still right 99% of the time.
62	** Compounding this moral is the fact that Drizzt is a dark elf -- a member of a race with a powerful and advanced (if dysfunctional) society, physically attractive and looking no different from a regular elf bar his darker skin, and possessing agelessness, enhanced skill and reflexes, and low-level magic powers. Races like orcs, goblins, and kobolds, which possess none of these things, are shown exactly the same way they are in every other ''D&D'' book ever -- i.e. ugly, murderous, stupid, barbaric cannon fodder, and the few times he does try to extend mercy to them, it's treated as naïveté. It's rather disingenuous to complain about being judged by your appearance and your genes when you're a black-painted ubermensch slaughtering the degenerates.
63	* One particular instance in ''Literature/IGotACheatSkillInAnotherWorldAndBecameUnrivaledInTheRealWorldToo'' stands out as pretty disturbing [[FridgeHorror when you think about it.]] At one point, Lexia is targeted by a female assassin. Said assassin is the [[DevilInPlainSight fairly obvious]] [[spoiler: Luna, who was befriended by Yuuya previously but turns out to have a DarkAndTroubledPast involving her being essentially groomed from her orphaned beginnings into an assassin for [[MurderInc an evil organization.]]]] The assassination attempt is foiled by Yuuya, and the assassin prepares for her inevitable comeuppance. However, because Yuuya [[spoiler: had befriended her previously and grew attached to her without knowing of her true occupation,]] he decides he wants her to live, disregarding her protests that TheseHandsHaveKilled and she shouldn't be allowed to keep going. Lexia agrees to spare the assassin, who [[DefeatMeansFriendship is taken in as Lexia's new guard.]] All well and good, and everyone's happy... except, presumably, the families of the many people that the assassin mercilessly hunted down over the past years. See, here's the thing: it's intended as a sweet moment about being able to forgive oneself via ThePowerOfFriendship, but what happens in practice is that what's essentially a SerialKiller (who's ''just confessed'' to murdering a bunch of people, and is [[TheDreaded well-known as a mass-murderer]]) avoids any form of repercussion, barring some light RestrainedRevenge in the form of [[{{Unishment}} getting a new less murderous job]]. This, of course, occurs with no consultation from any of the people she's harmed and the country that Lexia is supposed to represent, or any consequences from the laws she's broken, and only happens because [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality a single random dude who]] ''[[ProtagonistCenteredMorality barely even lives in their world]]''[[ProtagonistCenteredMorality , and his love interest who happens to be royalty, decide unilaterally]] that she should be EasilyForgiven as one of their buddies. Thus, it looks less like "forgiving" someone who deserves it and more like a nasty example of [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveConnections good old cronyism]]. This is especially jarring because just a few episodes before, the show made a point that Yuuya's {{Jerkass}} siblings ''shouldn't'' simply be EasilyForgiven for their actions, merely prevented from brutally being murdered (and raising the question of whether Yuuya thinks that while bullies and abusers shouldn't be forgiven, mass murderers should; or alternatively that only the people who haven't wronged him, personally, deserve a chance). So in other words, it feels like the message here is not [[RousseauWasRight "Everyone deserves a second chance"]] or "Learn to forgive yourself", but rather "If you're friends with Yuuya and/or someone that rules the country, then maybe slaughtering a bunch of people isn't all that bad after all."
64	* ''Literature/ImInLoveWithTheVillainess'': Early on, some of the characters have a frank discussion about LGBT issues, and one of the topics touched upon is how such people aren't going to [[DepravedHomosexual immediately sexually assault anyone who fits their orientation]], prompted by Claire being called out for acting like Rei, the main character, was about to molest her the moment the latter verbally confirmed she's a lesbian. It's a good, sensible, and important lesson, but it is slightly undermined by the fact that Rei had just spent the story up to that point acting within that stereotype towards Claire; stalking her, openly lusting after her, aggressively seeking physical contact, etc. While much of this was Rei [[TheGadfly deliberately messing with her]] and she does cease this behavior shortly after this discussion, it doesn't change the fact that those prior interactions mean Claire was justified in worrying about Rei's actions, completely irrespective of any prejudice on her part. Rei herself even mused in a previous chapter that her staring at an uncomfortably nude Claire, after blackmailing the latter's father so she could become Claire's personal maid no less, was unmistakably an example of sexual harassment. This comes across as worse in the manga adaptation, which lacks many of the self-aware internal monologues Rei frequently has during these moments in the original light novel and anime adaptation.
65	* ''Literature/IWasATeenageFairy'', by Francesca Lia Block: tattooing your lover's name on your chest is stupid, especially if you fail to learn from it and do it twice more - but the fourth time is okay, because now it's ''really'' true love.
66	* ''Literature/IrinaTheVampireCosmonaut'' wants to make a statement about racism through having a vampire suffering bigotry in a stand-in for the Soviet space program, but falls flat because it tries to have things both ways - it starts by telling us several legitimate reasons for why humans would hate and fear a race that's faster, stronger, and regularly kills them for food, but then [[InformedAttribute fails to actually show any of these]] with the eponymous Irina, who has [[OurVampiresAreDifferent almost no vampire-like attributes]], much less any of the ones that would ''warrant'' all the hatred thrown her way, so as to make her more appealing as a protagonist. And that's not even getting into Irina's ''own'' arrogance and bigotry toward humans, [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality which the story never really addresses]].
67	* ''Literature/TheIrregularAtMagicHighSchool'':
68	** The series spares no effort to criticize classism and make the point that a person's status should be decided by their own merits and not their birth, which is supposed to be exemplified by the protagonist saving the day despite being looked down upon by his fellow students and most of society as a whole. The problem is that said protagonist is [[PersonOfMassDestruction a comically-overpowered genetically-engineered super-mage]] from a rich family, and being literally created to have ridiculous powers that hardly anyone on else on earth can match is the definition of being born into privilege. Later arcs show that despite the story taking great pains to convince the reader that everyone has worth and can contribute, even Tatsuya's friends can't save the day on their own, and have to rely on him to rescue them from certain defeat.
69	** This aesop is broken in perhaps the most blatant way during the first battle between the Bloom and Weed classes. Tatsuya and the others start the conflict and go to great lengths to prove that someone's worth can't be decided by something as simple as a power level number, and that everyone has unique skills and traits that make them valuable in their own way. However, instead of using creative methods that make use of their skills to defeat the arrogant Blooms, the Weeds simply win through brute force. The Weeds are just outright better than the Blooms, and win because they are stronger than them instead of having overlooked talent.
70	* ''Literature/JohnnyTheWalrus'' is a children's book by conservative commentator Matt Walsh, which is supposed to deal with the topic of gender transition in minors. A brief summary of the story: Johnny's mom shares pictures of her son pretending to be a walrus online, and she is pressured to make him live as a "real" walrus, culminating in trying to make him move to a zoo, where the AuthorAvatar zookeeper speaks some sense into her and makes her realize that Johnny pretending to be a walrus is different from him actually being one. However, the anti-transition moral doesn't work, as Johnny himself never says he truly identifies as a walrus, and complains about the things he's forced to do in order to "transition", such as eating worms and wearing makeup. At one point, surgery is even brought up, even though any medical transition procedure (especially surgery, and ''especially'' in a minor) would require a months-long psychological evaluation to confirm that such treatment would be beneficial; during this period, any trans healthcare specialist would quickly realize that Johnny doesn't actually want to go through with the transition. Ironically, this ends up giving the book the complete opposite message from what is intended: children ''do'' know their own identity better than anyone, and their parents shouldn't force them to dress or act in a way that goes against what they want.
71	* ''Literature/KumaKumaKumaBear'':
72	** Yuna believes that AristocratsAreEvil based on their portrayal in the media she has consumed, and because all the nobles she meets are decent people who genuinely care about the well-being of their territories and people, she has to repeatedly learn the lesson to not judge them based on their birth because classism goes both ways. However, the series then goes on to portray the merchant class as universally corrupt, repulsive, greedy individuals who are extorting the common people through tactics that range from unfair price manipulation all the way up to conspiring with organized crime--exactly as universally despicable as Yuna falsely believes the nobles to be.
73	** Yuna, being shown as fairly self-centered at the start of the series, gradually learns that taking care of other people is rewarding on its own terms, which is especially shown in her care for Fina and her family. When she visits the seaside town of Millela though, she only takes measures against the bandits raiding the surrounding roads because they dare interfere with her sleep, and she only reason she considers ridding the town of the kraken is that it forms an obstacle in getting the fish she needs to make her favorite dishes.
74	* ''Lady in Waiting'' by Jackie Kendall and Debby Jones, a religious self-help book, states first that a single woman was encouraged to pursue a doctorate, and that the spirit-filled woman is interesting and has goals for herself. But later it says that seeking fulfillment through a career is wrong and that a single woman should only seek fulfillment in serving God in whatever way, method, location, and time God wants.
75	* In Martin Lake's ''Literature/ALoveMostDangerous,'' which focuses on a fictional mistress of Henry VIII, the Aesop is supposed to be "Be true to yourself and you will be happy." Fine--except that Alice Petherton ''is'' happy at the beginning before she is stalked and nearly raped by [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Rich,_1st_Baron_Rich#Chancellor Sir Richard Rich]]. Even her threat [[EyeScream to stick a pin in his eye]] doesn't stop him for long, and no matter who she goes to for help, no one will lift a finger against Rich. Alice then gets involved with the king (on the grounds that he will be able to protect her from Rich, who is very powerful), and all goes swimmingly until [[spoiler:she begs Henry to spare a man whom Henry had condemned to death for following his own orders]]. As a result, Henry banishes her from the palace, and Rich takes advantage of the situation in a vicious way. At the end, Alice is back at court, back in the king's favor (having decided to be much more agreeable and never contradict the king) and is finally profiting from being the king's mistress. So the real moral seems to be "Always tell men exactly what they want to hear, because if you refuse them or contradict them, they will hurt you."
76	* The Scottish children's book ''Literature/MaxPowerAndTheBagpipes'' is about a family who run a wind farm, intended to provide the GreenAesop that renewable energy is awesome ... except that in order to provide a story, the ''actual'' message becomes "wind power is chancy and unreliable, unless you have magic bagpipes that can make the wind blow harder".
77	* ''Literature/MonsterHunterInternational'':
78	** The series has numerous borderline {{Author Filibuster}}s about the importance of the 2nd Amendment and owning guns. The reason that the main characters own guns is because they hunt zombies and werewolves for a living, which is obviously not an argument that applies well to the real world.
79	* ''Literature/MyYouthRomanticComedyIsWrongAsIExpected'': Hachiman's character arc is supposed to be about him growing to learn that [[CruelToBeKind tough love]] and [[ZeroApprovalGambit making yourself the target of hatred]] under the guise of helping people is ultimately arrogant, needlessly cynical, ill-informed, and most importantly just plain wrong--problems that are solved with harshness are able to be solved a million times easier with true compassion. However, this is called into question when Hayato and Yukino are shown being as harsh as Hachiman if not more so, and don't suffer any karmic backlash. This makes the Aesop look like it has less to do with the morals of the act, and more with who's carrying it out.
80	* Peter F. Hamilton's ''Literature/TheNightsDawnTrilogy'' is most infamous for its DeusExMachina ending, but the story (particularly the third book) also attempts to promote an anti-racism message, with the Possessed as a metaphor for victims of bigotry. Unfortunately, this message is sort of lost when the victims of oppression are body-snatching ghosts who use rape and torture to increase their numbers.
81	* The moral of ''Pants on Fire'' is apparently [[HonestyAesop not to lie]], since the main character gets a pair of underwear that ignite whenever he lies. However, the problem is solved by him ''telling more lies'' until the undies completely burn up.
82	* ''Literature/ThePoisonwoodBible'': The author goes to great lengths to show that judging people without trying to understand where they're coming from is bad. But then paints all Americans as greedy, materialistic pigs except for her {{Author Avatar}}s and paints Africans as saints who only ever do anything bad because they were corrupted by white people.
83	* ''Literature/RaceAgainstTime'' by Creator/PiersAnthony attempts AnAesop on how having a lot of different cultures is a good thing, but it gets broken by a moral on how you shouldn't mix romantically with other races.
84	* The ''[[Literature/TheRailwaySeries Railway Series]]'' story "[[Recap/TheRailwaySeriesB16BranchLineEngines Thomas Comes to Breakfast]]" (and [[Recap/ThomasAndFriendsS2E18ThomasComesToBreakfast its TV adaptation]]) goes for a cautionary tale about {{pride}} -- Thomas takes a joke his driver made about not needing him anymore seriously, tries to start and stop on his own, and crashes into a stationmaster's house. However, Thomas was only able to start because a careless cleaner obliviously changed his controls, so his humiliating experience with the stationmaster's house would have happened anyway.
85	* In the [[Literature/TheRiftwarCycle Riftwar saga]] we get hammered about how the end doesn't justify the means, and that evil actions are irrational, by the heroes. Then [[ProtagonistCentredMorality they start torturing enemies, in full knowledge of this being evil, in the name of the greater good]].
86	* The ''Series/RizzoliAndIsles'' series runs on this. One of its protagonists, Jane Rizzoli, relentlessly complains about how she's dismissed or ignored because of her plain looks, especially in favor of an attractive woman. Fair enough... except she does ''the exact same thing'' by taking an instant dislike to every beautiful woman that she meets, automatically assuming that she's a bitch or an idiot, and treating her as such. She also has nothing but contempt for the men who fall in love with these women, believing them to be shallow. Aside from being a grossly unfair and stereotypical assumption, she herself spends all of the first book lusting after her handsome partner and in the next book, falls for (and eventually marries) an equally handsome FBI agent. Apparently it's only shallow when beautiful people fall in love with beautiful people. When unattractive people do, it's just fine.
87	* ''Literature/SaveThePearls'' is a somewhat controversial novel that is -- ''ostensibly'' -- a fable about the foolishness of racism, set in a world where [[PersecutionFlip an environmental catastrophe has left melanin content as a prized thing, with blacks on top and whites on the bottom, with an interracial romance to drive home the point]]. What it ''is'', however, is a novel where white people are called "Pearls" and blacks are called "Coals," the white female lead starts off severely uncomfortable around black people (to the point of using slurs like "haughty Coal" in inner monologue), white people often wear blackface to "pass," the white lead is threatened with rape at the hands of a giant ScaryBlackMan, and the love story is described as a "Beauty and the Beast" fable (and the black love interest ''turns into a beast'' thanks to genetic engineering).
88	* The novel ''Literature/SuchAPrettyGirl'' is so devoted to portraying pedophilia as a serious issue that it portrays it as an ''insurmountable'' one. It more or less goes; 'Don't tell your parents you were raped, because they're abusive assholes who will blame you for it. Don't tell the cops, because AdultsAreUseless. Don't run away from your rapist, because then he will abuse other children in your place (and you don't want to be ''selfish'', right?)' Also, none of the many characters in the novel who have been raped ever recover from it. ThereAreNoTherapists, and no point in ever trying to be happy again. Pretty bleak, given that in RealLife thousands of rapists are jailed ''per year''.
89	* The ''Literature/SweetValleyHigh'' series (and its numerous spinoffs) ran on the power of being {{hypocrite}}s. If "bad" twin Jessica dated a different boy every night, she was blasted for being promiscuous, but if "good" twin Elizabeth cheated on her boyfriend, it was glossed over to the point where HE was apologizing to HER. If Jessica acted stuck-up, she was a heartless bitch, but if Elizabeth did the same thing, she must have a good reason for it. Additionally, Elizabeth would practically demand that HER friends be forgiven for their misdeeds and given a chance to redeem themselves. Needless to say, she had no such compassion for any of Jessica's friends--not until big brother Steve blasts her for this does she even realize how insensitive and hypocritical she's being. An even better, if not outright literal, example of this trope is the fact that Jessica never once learned her lesson. She'd try to pull a zany scheme which would fall apart and leave her with egg on her face, but by the next book, would be doing it all over again, despite everyone under the sun warning her about what happened the last time.
90	** With Jessica, the writers often seemed to confuse being mischievous with being a sociopath.
91	** Never mind when Elizabeth was in a motorcycle accident at the end of one book, then in the next wakes out of her coma. She proceeds to act almost exactly like Jessica does--until she gets [[TapOnTheHead bonked on the head]] again, in a minor fall. She pops back to her normal self, gets forgiven by her boyfriend, and by everyone else. Jessica, who has spent the whole book picking up after Elizabeth's behavior, not only doesn't get any sort of apology or thanks, but is back to ''her'' normal self, no lesson learned or maturity earned, in the next book.
92	* The first few books the ''Literature/SwordOfTruth'' series have Richard being told that most people who end up doing great evil [[WellIntentionedExtremist honestly believed that they were doing the right thing]], and that unquestioning belief in the rightness of one's cause is the most dangerous thing in the world. Later on in the series, the author takes the opposite position: some things really are [[BlackAndWhiteMorality as simple as black and white]], and if you really are Right, taking [[KnightTemplar extreme measures]] when fighting against those who really are Evil is not only justifiable, but ''necessary''. However, the protagonists end up doing some, well, morally questionable things in the process, to the point where the protagonists can end up looking like textbook examples of what the first few books warned against becoming.
93	** ''Naked Empire'', spends a good chunk of time preaching that you have to work for things, and that knowledge doesn't just come to you when you need it. In the last pages of the book, Richard's dying of poison and the knowledge of how to make the antidote just shows up in his head. Another particularly obvious one is the repeated exhortation to live your own life and think for yourself - but if you don't think Richard is right you're wrong, probably evil, and are going to die.
94	* ''Very'' few people would consider white supremacy to be an aesop, so it's a testament to both how odious it is as an ideology and how poorly written the Neo-Nazi propaganda tract ''Literature/TheTurnerDiaries'' is that it ends up unwittingly making a better argument ''against'' racism than for it. The protagonists are psychopathic terrorists who eventually escalate to being {{Omnicidal Maniac}}s and triggering a nuclear holocaust to eliminate all non-white races, resulting in an irradiated planet that their totalitarian all-white ethnostate would presumably have a very hard time surviving in. The message it delivers is that white supremacists will end the world unless stopped. [[NotHelpingYourCase Not exactly helping the author's case]].
95	* There are quite a few broken aesops in ''Literature/TheTwilightSaga'':
96	** One of the themes is abstinence before marriage, yet all their waiting is all made irrelevant during the final installment. The first time they actually sleep together after their wedding, it's a violent event that leaves Bella injured and the bed destroyed. To make matters worse, the pregnancy turns out bloody, gruesome, and nearly fatal. Marriage does not protect from sexually transmitted infections, nor does it physically or emotionally prepare one for pregnancy.
97	** According to WordOfGod, the Bella/Edward/Jacob love triangle was intended to show Bella's choice in the matter of love, namely that she had the option of Jacob but chose Edward. The "love through choice" moral is shot to hell through most of the other couples though, particularly in the case of imprinted couples (the guy can't ''help'' but feel attracted to the girl, and while the girl technically is able to refuse him, there is a ton of pressure not to. To given an idea of just how much pressure, in the very first imprinted couple the books show, the girl ''did'' try to refuse the guy, which caused him to fly into a rage and rip her face off.). Especially egregious is the case of Jacob, who made a number of speeches about how imprinting is essentially the loss of free will and he hopes to never have it [[spoiler:and then finds himself happily imprinted on Renesmee, even though he absolutely hated her not five minutes prior.]] Which kind of contradicts everything the author said about Jacob being an option since it's implied if not outright stated that Jacob's interest in Bella was apparently [[spoiler: only due to him being subconsciously drawn to her because he was meant to imprint on Renesmee in the first place.]]
98	** One Aesop seems to be that a girl as plain and unassuming as Bella can find true love, but Bella's flaws fall mostly into the category of InformedFlaw, [[spoiler:and are almost entirely removed at the end of the series.]] Though Bella is intended to be plain and unassuming, nearly every man she runs into falls for her and Edward himself states that most of the boys in the school find her attractive. Clearly, not so plain. However, maybe the intended Aesop here was that if you hold off on sex until you get married and then [[spoiler:die in childbirth,]] you will become a saint and absolutely perfect in every way.
99	** The Cullens are portrayed as saintly vampires who value human life and therefore maintain a "vegetarian" diet of animal blood. But they never once object to other vampires killing humans -- the closest they ever come is politely asking some non-veggie vamps who are staying with them to go out of town to feed, which has little to do with protecting human life and more to do with not blowing their cover. When there's a huge murder spree going on in Seattle caused by a vampire army, the Cullens never lift a finger to help until they realize the vampires are coming for them.
100	*** Some of the deaths the Cullens cause are ''glorified'', the most obvious example being Rosalie murdering her fiance and his friends. This would otherwise be a pretty badass moment, if it weren't for the fact that Carlisle is supposed to be an absolute pillar of morality. Yet he stands by and allows his new adoptive daughter to murder humans, which is something he's strongly against.
101	*** In the first novel Edward briefly mentions that before he went full "vegetarian" he was sort of a vigilante vampire superhero; he would make meals out of muggers and rapists when they were in the middle of attacking someone. This is presented as wrong because he's inevitably still killing, despite the fact he would also often be ''saving'' people who would have otherwise been murdered, assaulted, or raped. The option of remaining a vigilante and just not feeding on the criminals he captures is never even considered.
102	*** The reason "pillar of morality" Carlisle saves Rosalie's life is that he sees her lying raped and dying in the street and thinks it would be a shame to let beauty such as hers go to waste. And then he tries to give her to Edward as a girlfriend.
103	* ''Literature/WarriorCats'': When Firestar has to choose between reinstating his old deputy Graystripe or keeping Brambleclaw, [=StarClan=] tells Leafpool that Firestar should make his decision with his head rather than his heart, completely ignoring all the times in the series characters have been told to listen to their heart or do what they feel is right. In fact, the reason Graystripe was originally chosen to be deputy was because Firestar was told to follow his heart.
104	* Downplayed in ''What if Everyone Did That?''. It mainly gets its morals straight, yet the page about interrupting the teacher has one boy who interrupted because he had to go to the bathroom, which is a perfectly logical reason to interrupt, and one girl who interrupted by snoring, yet falling AsleepInClass isn't intentional.
105	* Bowman, Kestrel, and their friend Mumpo spend the first ''Literature/WindOnFire'' book learning that if they work together, they can make things happen and nothing can hurt them. In the book's two parallel plots, the twin's father convinces downtrodden people that they need to stand up and peacefully insist on being given their rights, and their mother makes her views heard and gets the town to listen to her and consider her ideas. Then... the MacGuffin shows up and makes it all better. Or at least makes them happy for the remainder of the book.
106	* Kaala, protagonist of ''Literature/TheWolfChronicles'', spends the entire series being bullied and manipulated by its various [[TheChessmaster chessmasters]]. There is much talk about how she can't trust anybody--[[GreyAndGreyMorality even her allies]]--to tell her the whole truth, and must fight for her independence. Then in the finale she...[[EasilyForgiven suddenly]] trusts one of these chessmasters ([[spoiler:Gaanan]]) to safeguard the future of humanity. Even though he's lied to her before. Even though she has no reason to believe he's being honest now.
107	* There's a children's poem about a little girl whose father brags that [[WomenDrivers men are better drivers]] and are "built with speed and strength". He ends up driving his car straight into a truck and the poem starts to make a gender equality Aesop... which then gets completely broken by having the little girl remark, "Men are built with speed and strength [[GenderIncompetence but hardly any brains]]" showing she's just as sexist as her father.
108	* There's an old story, occasionally found in some advice books, about a business owner who would take his prospective employees out for a meal. If the prospect put salt on the food before tasting it, he'd know they were someone who made assumptions, and therefore not someone he wanted to hire. [[ConvictionByCounterfactualClue Problem is]], the prospect could simply be familiar with the restaurant and how they season their food. Or they could be someone who seasoned their food by reflex, out of nervousness. Plus, business and brunch are two different things. It would be like assuming someone who forgets to use their turn signal once has memory problems. The story ''is'' about false assumptions, but not in the intended way.
109

Context BrokenAesop / Literature