History YMMV / Sixteen

19th May '16 7:10:53 AM TMNTFanGirl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Serena is definitely this: text message aside, her breaking up with a NiceGuy like Wyatt (practically out of the blue) just to get back together with her ex-boyfriend, a guy who's arguably--and ironically--way less mature than Wyatt is ([[EveryoneHasStandards and who also felt it was pretty low that Serena dumped Wyatt via text message]]), didn't exactly go well with fans. And neither did Serena's ClingyJealousGirl-antics when Wyatt finally got over his feelings for her and moved on to other girls, even though Serena was the one who dumped him in the first place.
** Jude's ex-girlfriend, Starr, after she became a {{Goth}} and dumped Jude for largely superficial reasons. And later, when she became an InsufferableGenius and got even worse.
* ValuesDissonance: Canada legalized gay marriage in July 2005, so "Role Reversal" was justified there; the US didn't legalize gay marriage in all 50 states until nearly ''10 years later'', which was why that episode was definitely banned there.

to:

** Serena Wyatt's ex-girlfriend, Serena, is definitely this: text message thing aside, her breaking up with a NiceGuy like Wyatt (practically (pretty much out of the blue) blue and for a largely superficial reason) just to get back together with her ex-boyfriend, a guy who's arguably--and ironically--way less mature than Wyatt is ([[EveryoneHasStandards and who also felt it was pretty low that Serena dumped Wyatt via text message]]), didn't exactly go well with fans. And neither did Serena's ClingyJealousGirl-antics when Wyatt finally got over his feelings for her and moved on to other girls, even though Serena she was the one who dumped him in the first place.
** Jude's ex-girlfriend, Starr, after she is this (although perhaps to a lesser extent)--she became a {{Goth}} all of sudden and dumped broke up with Jude for largely superficial reasons. And later, when reasons (although she at least admitted that she still cared a lot about Jude). It got worse after she adopted a nerd-persona and became an InsufferableGenius and got even worse.
InsufferableGenius--she decided not to pursue a relationship with Jude after deeming not to be "intelligent enough" for her (she claimed that a person has to have an IQ of at least 130 to join her new nerd clique), but it later turns out that Jude actually has an IQ of 175.
* ValuesDissonance: Canada legalized gay marriage in July of 2005, so "Role Reversal" was justified there; the US didn't legalize gay marriage in all 50 states until nearly just less than ''10 years later'', which was why that the episode was definitely banned there.from airing in the States.
18th May '16 2:20:49 PM Monolaf317
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* ValuesDissonance: Canada legalized gay marriage in 2005, so "Role Reversal" was justified there; the US didn't legalize gay marriage in all 50 states until nearly ''10 years later'', which was why that episode was definitely banned there.

to:

* ValuesDissonance: Canada legalized gay marriage in July 2005, so "Role Reversal" was justified there; the US didn't legalize gay marriage in all 50 states until nearly ''10 years later'', which was why that episode was definitely banned there.
18th May '16 2:20:32 PM Monolaf317
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* ValuesDissonance: Canada legalized gay marriage in 2005, so "Role Reversal" was justified there; the US didn't legalize gay marriage in all 50 states until nearly ''10 years later'', which was why that episode was definitely banned there.
23rd Mar '16 4:02:05 AM TMNTFanGirl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Serena is definitely this: text message aside, breaking up with a NiceGuy like Wyatt just to get back together with her ex-boyfriend, who's arguably--and ironically--way less mature than Wyatt is, didn't exactly go well with fans. And neither did Serena's ClingyJealousGirl-antics when Wyatt finally got over his feelings for her and moved on to other girls, even though Serena was the one who dumped him in the first place.

to:

** Serena is definitely this: text message aside, her breaking up with a NiceGuy like Wyatt (practically out of the blue) just to get back together with her ex-boyfriend, a guy who's arguably--and ironically--way less mature than Wyatt is, is ([[EveryoneHasStandards and who also felt it was pretty low that Serena dumped Wyatt via text message]]), didn't exactly go well with fans. And neither did Serena's ClingyJealousGirl-antics when Wyatt finally got over his feelings for her and moved on to other girls, even though Serena was the one who dumped him in the first place.
20th Mar '16 3:52:40 PM TMNTFanGirl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Serena is definitely this: Breaking up with a NiceGuy like Wyatt (through a ''text message'') just to get back together with her ex-boyfriend who's arguably--and ironically--way less mature than Wyatt is didn't go well with fans.[[spoiler: Neither did Serena's ClingyJealousGirl-antics when Wyatt finally got over his feelings for her and moved on to other girls, even though Serena was the one who dumped him in the first place.]]

to:

** Serena is definitely this: Breaking text message aside, breaking up with a NiceGuy like Wyatt (through a ''text message'') just to get back together with her ex-boyfriend ex-boyfriend, who's arguably--and ironically--way less mature than Wyatt is is, didn't exactly go well with fans.[[spoiler: Neither fans. And neither did Serena's ClingyJealousGirl-antics when Wyatt finally got over his feelings for her and moved on to other girls, even though Serena was the one who dumped him in the first place.]]
18th Feb '16 4:06:25 AM TMNTFanGirl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Serena is definitely this: Breaking up with a NiceGuy like Wyatt (through a ''text message'') just to get back together with her ex-boyfriend--who, ironically, is way less mature than Wyatt is--didn't go well with fans.[[spoiler: Neither did Serena's ClingyJealousGirl-antics when Wyatt finally got over his feelings for her and moved on to other girls, even though Serena was the one who dumped him in the first place.]]
** Jude's ex-girlfriend, Starr, after she became a {{Goth}} and dumped Jude for largely superficial reasons. And later, when she became an InsufferableGenius and she got even worse.
* VindicatedByHistory: When the show was airing on CN, many fans dismissed it as a less interesting, economy cast take on Total Drama, which was one of the channel's flagship franchises. Nowadays long after the series finale was aired, its seen renewed interest for having much the same humor and teenage melodrama, but drastically decreased to fit a smaller cast prone to SliceOfLife misadventures. The more grounded tone and cast allowed for consistent characterization, as apposed to Total Drama which tended to stretch the focus thin to try and have time for everyone. In short, the reasons for its initial dismissal were the same that earned it a solid fanbase and a better lasting reputation.

to:

** Serena is definitely this: Breaking up with a NiceGuy like Wyatt (through a ''text message'') just to get back together with her ex-boyfriend--who, ironically, is way ex-boyfriend who's arguably--and ironically--way less mature than Wyatt is--didn't is didn't go well with fans.[[spoiler: Neither did Serena's ClingyJealousGirl-antics when Wyatt finally got over his feelings for her and moved on to other girls, even though Serena was the one who dumped him in the first place.]]
** Jude's ex-girlfriend, Starr, after she became a {{Goth}} and dumped Jude for largely superficial reasons. And later, when she became an InsufferableGenius and she got even worse.
* VindicatedByHistory: When the show was airing on CN, many fans dismissed it as a less interesting, economy cast take on Total Drama, which was one of the channel's flagship franchises. Nowadays Nowadays, long after the series finale was aired, its seen renewed interest for having much the same humor and teenage melodrama, but drastically decreased to fit a smaller cast prone to SliceOfLife misadventures. The more grounded tone and cast allowed for consistent characterization, as apposed to Total Drama which tended to stretch the focus thin to try and have time for everyone. In short, the reasons for its initial dismissal were the same that earned it a solid fanbase and a better lasting reputation.
13th Feb '16 5:05:26 AM TMNTFanGirl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Serena--breaking up with a NiceGuy like Wyatt through a ''text message'' to get back together with her ex-boyfriend (who, ironically, is way more immature than Wyatt is) didn't go well with fans.[[spoiler: Neither did Serena's ClingyJealousGirl-antics when Wyatt finally got over his feelings for her, even though Serena was the one who dumped him in the first place.]]

to:

** Serena--breaking Serena is definitely this: Breaking up with a NiceGuy like Wyatt through (through a ''text message'' message'') just to get back together with her ex-boyfriend (who, ex-boyfriend--who, ironically, is way more immature less mature than Wyatt is) didn't is--didn't go well with fans.[[spoiler: Neither did Serena's ClingyJealousGirl-antics when Wyatt finally got over his feelings for her, her and moved on to other girls, even though Serena was the one who dumped him in the first place.]]
15th Nov '15 7:53:43 PM darkabomination
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* VindicatedByHistory: When the show was airing on CN, many fans dismissed it as a less interesting, economy cast take on Total Drama, which was one of the channel's flagship franchises. Nowadays long after the series finale was aired, its seen renewed interest for having much the same humor and teenage melodrama, but drastically decreased to fit a smaller cast prone to SliceOfLife misadventures. The more grounded tone and cast allowed for consistent characterization, as apposed to Total Drama which tended to stretch the focus thin to try and have time for everyone. In short, the reasons for its initial dismissal were the same that earned it a solid fanbase and a better lasting reputation.
7th Oct '15 5:23:29 AM TMNTFanGirl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Serena. Breaking up with nice guy Wyatt over a text message did not go well with fans. [[spoiler: Neither did her ClingyJealousGirl antics when Wyatt moved on.]]
** Jude's ex-girlfriend Starr after she became a {{Goth}} and dumped Jude for superficial reasons. Later when she became an InsufferableGenius she got even worse.

to:

** Serena. Breaking Serena--breaking up with nice guy a NiceGuy like Wyatt over through a text message did not ''text message'' to get back together with her ex-boyfriend (who, ironically, is way more immature than Wyatt is) didn't go well with fans. fans.[[spoiler: Neither did her ClingyJealousGirl antics Serena's ClingyJealousGirl-antics when Wyatt moved on.finally got over his feelings for her, even though Serena was the one who dumped him in the first place.]]
** Jude's ex-girlfriend Starr ex-girlfriend, Starr, after she became a {{Goth}} and dumped Jude for largely superficial reasons. Later And later, when she became an InsufferableGenius and she got even worse.
29th Sep '15 11:08:12 AM BatmanKalEl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* TheScrappy: Serena. Breaking up with nice guy Wyatt over a text message did not go well with fans. [[spoiler: Neither did her ClingyJealousGirl antics when Wyatt moved on.]]

to:

* TheScrappy: TheScrappy:
**
Serena. Breaking up with nice guy Wyatt over a text message did not go well with fans. [[spoiler: Neither did her ClingyJealousGirl antics when Wyatt moved on.]]
This list shows the last 10 events of 61. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=YMMV.Sixteen