Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / MajorDundee

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HoYay: A lot of the scenes of Dundee and Tyreen arguing evoke the image of bitter ex-boyfriends, bordering on FoeYay. Gomez and Potts have moments of drunken bonding suggesting this, too.

to:

* HoYay: A lot of the scenes of Dundee and Tyreen arguing evoke the image of bitter ex-boyfriends, bordering on FoeYay.ex-boyfriends. Gomez and Potts have moments of drunken bonding suggesting this, too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Narm}}: [[spoiler:Everyone referring to O.W. Hadley as a boy before and after his death becomes incredibly, unintentionally hilarious due to the fact that it's blatantly obvious that actor Warren Oates was clearly in his mid-late 30s and no amount of make up could hide that fact.]]
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: With so many beloved character actors on hand, including but not limited to Ben Johnson, Creator/BrockPeters, R.G. Armstrong, Slim Pickens, Warren Oates and Dub Taylor, there is sadly only so much screen time that can go around for them. In the case of Lt. Graham we even get TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot, which is only glimpsed in the scene where Dundee, after returning from surgery and a drunken bender, chastises Graham for not carrying out his orders but Graham shuts him up with "You gave me a command. From then on ''I'' gave the orders." Graham says it with an unexpected forcefulness and pride, forcing Dundee to give him a cigar as a sign of respect. With all the scenes that weren't shot we can only wonder what happened with Graham in charge of the command.

to:

* {{Narm}}: [[spoiler:Everyone referring to O.W. Hadley as a boy before and after his death becomes incredibly, unintentionally hilarious due to the fact that it's blatantly obvious that actor Warren Oates Creator/WarrenOates was clearly in his mid-late 30s and no amount of make up could hide that fact.]]
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: With so many beloved character actors on hand, including but not limited to Ben Johnson, Creator/BrockPeters, R.G. Armstrong, Slim Pickens, Warren Oates Creator/WarrenOates and Dub Taylor, there is sadly only so much screen time that can go around for them. In the case of Lt. Graham we even get TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot, which is only glimpsed in the scene where Dundee, after returning from surgery and a drunken bender, chastises Graham for not carrying out his orders but Graham shuts him up with "You gave me a command. From then on ''I'' gave the orders." Graham says it with an unexpected forcefulness and pride, forcing Dundee to give him a cigar as a sign of respect. With all the scenes that weren't shot we can only wonder what happened with Graham in charge of the command.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FanPreferredCutContent: The deleted opening featuring an Apache massacre which Ryan narrowly escapes is somewhat legendary among Western fans, who praise the scene's execution in the original script and mourn how the filmed footage has yet to see a home video release.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: With so many beloved character actors on hand, including but not limited to Ben Johnson, Brock Peters, R.G. Armstrong, Slim Pickens, Warren Oates and Dub Taylor, there is sadly only so much screen time that can go around for them. In the case of Lt. Graham we even get TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot, which is only glimpsed in the scene where Dundee, after returning from surgery and a drunken bender, chastises Graham for not carrying out his orders but Graham shuts him up with "You gave me a command. From then on ''I'' gave the orders." Graham says it with an unexpected forcefulness and pride, forcing Dundee to give him a cigar as a sign of respect. With all the scenes that weren't shot we can only wonder what happened with Graham in charge of the command.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: With so many beloved character actors on hand, including but not limited to Ben Johnson, Brock Peters, Creator/BrockPeters, R.G. Armstrong, Slim Pickens, Warren Oates and Dub Taylor, there is sadly only so much screen time that can go around for them. In the case of Lt. Graham we even get TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot, which is only glimpsed in the scene where Dundee, after returning from surgery and a drunken bender, chastises Graham for not carrying out his orders but Graham shuts him up with "You gave me a command. From then on ''I'' gave the orders." Graham says it with an unexpected forcefulness and pride, forcing Dundee to give him a cigar as a sign of respect. With all the scenes that weren't shot we can only wonder what happened with Graham in charge of the command.
Tabs MOD

Removed: 414

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EarWorm: The jaunty "Major Dundee March" featured in the original release is very dopey and inappropriate for the material, sounding more like the ''Series/FTroop'' theme song than anything else. It's easy to see why Peckinpah hated it. But it's just so damn catchy, in a NarmCharm way.
-->''Fall in behind the Major!\\
Fall in and mind the Major!\\
Fall in and I will wager\\
That the Major brings all of us back!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatDoYouMeanItsNotPolitical: Pretty much every article written about the 2005 restoration/re-release connected the film with the UsefulNotes/VietnamWar. While Creator/SamPeckinpah later became an outspoken opponent of that conflict, the original script had been written in the early '60s while full-scale American intervention was barely underway when ''Dundee'' began filming.

to:

* WhatDoYouMeanItsNotPolitical: Pretty much every article written about the 2005 restoration/re-release connected the film with the UsefulNotes/VietnamWar. While Creator/SamPeckinpah later became an outspoken opponent of that conflict, the original script had been written in the early '60s while full-scale American intervention was barely underway when ''Dundee'' began filming.filming (of course, many of the eventual issues with Vietnam were similar to what had already happened in UsefulNotes/TheKoreanWar).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EarWorm: The jaunty "Major Dundee March" featured in the original release is very dopey and inappropriate for the material. It's easy to see why Peckinpah hated it. But it's just so damn catchy, in a NarmCharm way.

to:

* EarWorm: The jaunty "Major Dundee March" featured in the original release is very dopey and inappropriate for the material.material, sounding more like the ''Series/FTroop'' theme song than anything else. It's easy to see why Peckinpah hated it. But it's just so damn catchy, in a NarmCharm way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EarWorm: The jaunty "Major Dundee March" featured in the original release is very dopey and inappropriate for the material. It's easy to see why Peckinpah hated it. But it's just so damn catchy, in a NarmCharm way.
-->''Fall in behind the Major!\\
Fall in and mind the Major!\\
Fall in and I will wager\\
That the Major brings all of us back!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GeniusBonus: If you pay attention to the dates Ryan mentions in his narration, and you know the timeline of the Civil War, it creates some major DramaticIrony for the climax: the final battle takes place just days after both Lee's surrender and the assassination of UsefulNotes/AbrahamLincoln, but the characters aren't aware of it.

Added: 371

Changed: 343

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CultClassic: Not one of the more famous films for either Creator/CharltonHeston or Creaotr/SamPeckinpah, or the who's who of character actors who populate the film, but between its director, cast, its legendary TroubledProduction and its reputation as "dress rehearsal" for Peckinpah's more famous ''Film/TheWildBunch'' has made it an object of interest among fans.

to:

* BetterOnDVD: The Extended Edition restores the film to Peckinpah's original vision.
* CultClassic: Not one of the more famous films for either Creator/CharltonHeston or Creaotr/SamPeckinpah, Creator/SamPeckinpah, or the who's who of character actors who populate the film, but between its director, cast, its legendary TroubledProduction and its reputation as "dress rehearsal" for Peckinpah's more famous ''Film/TheWildBunch'' has made it an object of interest among fans.



* WhatDoYouMeanItsNotPolitical: Pretty much every article written about the 2005 restoration/re-release connected the film with the UsefulNotes/VietnamWar. While Creator/SamPeckinpah later became an outspoken opponent of that conflict, the original script had been written in the early '60s while full-scale American intervention was barely underway when ''Dundee'' began filming.

to:

* WhatDoYouMeanItsNotPolitical: Pretty much every article written about the 2005 restoration/re-release connected the film with the UsefulNotes/VietnamWar. While Creator/SamPeckinpah later became an outspoken opponent of that conflict, the original script had been written in the early '60s while full-scale American intervention was barely underway when ''Dundee'' began filming.filming.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CultClassic: Not one of the more famous films for either CharltonHeston or Sam Peckinpah, or the who's who of character actors who populate the film, but between its director, cast, its legendary troubled production and its reputation as "dress rehearsal" for Peckinpah's more famous ''TheWildBunch'' has made it an object of interest among fans.

to:

* CultClassic: Not one of the more famous films for either CharltonHeston Creator/CharltonHeston or Sam Peckinpah, Creaotr/SamPeckinpah, or the who's who of character actors who populate the film, but between its director, cast, its legendary troubled production TroubledProduction and its reputation as "dress rehearsal" for Peckinpah's more famous ''TheWildBunch'' ''Film/TheWildBunch'' has made it an object of interest among fans.



* WhatDoYouMeanItsNotPolitical: Pretty much every article written about the 2005 restoration/re-release connected the film with the UsefulNotes/VietnamWar. While Sam Peckinpah later became an outspoken opponent of that conflict, the original script had been written in the early '60s while full-scale American intervention was barely underway when ''Dundee'' began filming.

to:

* WhatDoYouMeanItsNotPolitical: Pretty much every article written about the 2005 restoration/re-release connected the film with the UsefulNotes/VietnamWar. While Sam Peckinpah Creator/SamPeckinpah later became an outspoken opponent of that conflict, the original script had been written in the early '60s while full-scale American intervention was barely underway when ''Dundee'' began filming.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just expanding the page

Added DiffLines:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: With so many beloved character actors on hand, including but not limited to Ben Johnson, Brock Peters, R.G. Armstrong, Slim Pickens, Warren Oates and Dub Taylor, there is sadly only so much screen time that can go around for them. In the case of Lt. Graham we even get TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot, which is only glimpsed in the scene where Dundee, after returning from surgery and a drunken bender, chastises Graham for not carrying out his orders but Graham shuts him up with "You gave me a command. From then on ''I'' gave the orders." Graham says it with an unexpected forcefulness and pride, forcing Dundee to give him a cigar as a sign of respect. With all the scenes that weren't shot we can only wonder what happened with Graham in charge of the command.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just expanding the page

Added DiffLines:

* CultClassic: Not one of the more famous films for either CharltonHeston or Sam Peckinpah, or the who's who of character actors who populate the film, but between its director, cast, its legendary troubled production and its reputation as "dress rehearsal" for Peckinpah's more famous ''TheWildBunch'' has made it an object of interest among fans.

Added: 189

Changed: 202

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HoYay: A lot of the scenes of Dundee and Tyreen arguing evoke the image of bitter ex-boyfriends, bordering on FoeYay.

to:

* AntiClimaxBoss: [[spoiler:Sierra Charriba, after evading Dundee's command for months, is dispatched rather abruptly (by Tim the bugler, no less) late in the movie]].
* HoYay: A lot of the scenes of Dundee and Tyreen arguing evoke the image of bitter ex-boyfriends, bordering on FoeYay. Gomez and Potts have moments of drunken bonding suggesting this, too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Narm}}: [[spoiler:Everyone referring to O.W. Hadley as a boy before and after his death becomes incredibly, unintentionally hilarious due to the fact that it's blatantly obvious that actor Warren Oates was clearly in his mid-late 30s and no amount of make up could hide that fact.]]

to:

* {{Narm}}: [[spoiler:Everyone referring to O.W. Hadley as a boy before and after his death becomes incredibly, unintentionally hilarious due to the fact that it's blatantly obvious that actor Warren Oates was clearly in his mid-late 30s and no amount of make up could hide that fact.]]]]
* WhatDoYouMeanItsNotPolitical: Pretty much every article written about the 2005 restoration/re-release connected the film with the UsefulNotes/VietnamWar. While Sam Peckinpah later became an outspoken opponent of that conflict, the original script had been written in the early '60s while full-scale American intervention was barely underway when ''Dundee'' began filming.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just expanding the page

Added DiffLines:

** Was Dundee actually justified in [[spoiler:sentencing O.W. Hadley to death for desertion, or was he stubbornly clinging to an unfair rule in the middle of an extreme situation]]?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just expanding the page

Added DiffLines:

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: Did Dundee really betray Tyreen by voting against him for a promotion as Tyreen claims, or did he really do what he thought was right by not showing favoritism towards his friend?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just expanding the page.


* {{Narm}}: [[spoiler:Everyone referring to O.W. Hadley as a boy before and after his death becomes incredibly, unintentionally hilarious due to the fact that it's blatantly obvious that actor Warren Oates was clearly in his mid-late 30s.]]

to:

* {{Narm}}: [[spoiler:Everyone referring to O.W. Hadley as a boy before and after his death becomes incredibly, unintentionally hilarious due to the fact that it's blatantly obvious that actor Warren Oates was clearly in his mid-late 30s.30s and no amount of make up could hide that fact.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Just creating a page

Added DiffLines:

* HoYay: A lot of the scenes of Dundee and Tyreen arguing evoke the image of bitter ex-boyfriends, bordering on FoeYay.
* {{Narm}}: [[spoiler:Everyone referring to O.W. Hadley as a boy before and after his death becomes incredibly, unintentionally hilarious due to the fact that it's blatantly obvious that actor Warren Oates was clearly in his mid-late 30s.]]

Top