History YMMV / Gormenghast

15th Jan '16 12:00:20 PM SantosLHalper
Is there an issue? Send a Message
** It's more the [[FilmOfTheBook BBC Adaptation]] version of Steerpike who gets this treatment, and seems to encourage some fans to interpret the character differently. Although he was still [[MagnificentBastard pretty damn evil]], he was deliberately portrayed as genuinely loving Fuchsia (albeit in a warped and very disturbing way) and given a great stinking FreudianExcuse to boot [[note]] - a sob story wherein he had been abandoned at the age of six, sent to work in the kitchens and abused (emotionally, physically and sexually) throughout his childhood. In the novel, Steerpike, at seventeen, had arrived in the kitchens only a few months ago, so Swelter could not have abused him as a child. Peake tells us absolutely nothing about Steerpike's upbringing or origins (beyond the fact that he came from beyond Gormenghast) so we don't actually know if he has a tragic past to explain his extreme sociopathy[[/note]]. Casting the rather handsome Creator/JonathanRhysMeyers -- who ''really'' [[AdaptationalAttractiveness doesn't fit the picture of the ugly, hunch-backed albino]] Peake described -- apparently didn't hurt either. ** Bear in mind that this was EXACTLY THE POINT, as Fuschia was a young girl looking for escape in the arms of an outsider to her world. Steerpike is an unredeemable monster, that he's sociopathic enough to think playing to the girl's fantasies will get him ahead in life, he'll do it, with aplomb.
24th Nov '15 2:10:37 PM LahmacunKebab
Is there an issue? Send a Message
** Steerpike was a bit of a woobie early on, particularly when you consider his non-person status among the other members of the castle. And most especially when you consider that Swelter was not only tremendously abusive to the kitchen boys (including Steerpike), but it is implied that he also sexually molested and cannibalised them. A childhood like that has to mess you up a little. Even if he didn't fit his leather pants quite so well, Steerpike would have started out as a SympatheticVillain, at least until his first or second MoralEventHorizon.
to:
** Steerpike was a bit of a woobie early on, particularly when you consider his non-person status among the other members of the castle. And most especially when you consider that Swelter was not only tremendously abusive to the kitchen boys (including Steerpike), but it is implied that he also sexually molested and cannibalised them. A childhood like that has to mess you up a little. Even if he didn't fit his leather pants quite so well, Steerpike would have started out as a SympatheticVillain, SympatheticMurderer, at least until his first or second MoralEventHorizon.
22nd Jul '15 7:46:27 PM OutrageousSpectre
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Added DiffLines:
* OrWasItADream: Cheeta's mind games near the end of ''Titus Alone'' are convincing enough to trouble even the reader, [[spoiler:who saw the castle Gormenghast through a narrator's eyes in ''Titus Groan'' and ''Gormenghast'']]. The marked discontinuity between [[spoiler:the archaic medieval nightmare of Gormenghast itself and the CrystalSpiresAndTogas of the outside world combined with the fact that Titus ultimately turns away rather than returning home in the end leaves the reader wondering if Steerpike, Fuchsia, Prunesquallor and all the others ever existed in the first place]].
5th May '15 11:04:00 AM DoktorvonEurotrash
Is there an issue? Send a Message
spelling fix
*** A lot of the aristocracy also deserve Woobie status, because although they are completely batshit insane and a little stupid, they aren't bad people. The [[TheOphelia Opheliac]] CreepyTwins Cora and Clarice didn't deserve such a prolonged and brutal death at Steerpike's hands. And Fuschia was just in love and insanely sheltered, with the hereditary insanity that seems to possess everybody in her family. You've got to feel a little sorry for her, too.
to:
*** A lot of the aristocracy also deserve Woobie status, because although they are completely batshit insane and a little stupid, they aren't bad people. The [[TheOphelia Opheliac]] CreepyTwins Cora and Clarice didn't deserve such a prolonged and brutal death at Steerpike's hands. And Fuschia Fuchsia was just in love and insanely sheltered, with the hereditary insanity that seems to possess everybody in her family. You've got to feel a little sorry for her, too.
28th Jul '14 4:58:32 PM Morgenthaler
Is there an issue? Send a Message
** It's more the [[FilmOfTheBook BBC Adaptation]] version of Steerpike who gets this treatment, and seems to encourage some fans to interpret the character differently. Although he was still [[MagnificentBastard pretty damn evil]], he was deliberately portrayed as genuinely loving Fuchsia (albeit in a warped and very disturbing way) and given a great stinking FreudianExcuse to boot [[note]] - a sob story wherein he had been abandoned at the age of six, sent to work in the kitchens and abused (emotionally, physically and sexually) throughout his childhood. In the novel, Steerpike, at seventeen, had arrived in the kitchens only a few months ago, so Swelter could not have abused him as a child. Peake tells us absolutely nothing about Steerpike's upbringing or origins (beyond the fact that he came from beyond Gormenghast) so we don't actually know if he has a tragic past to explain his extreme sociopathy[[/note]]. Casting the rather handsome JonathanRhysMeyers -- who ''really'' [[AdaptationalAttractiveness doesn't fit the picture of the ugly, hunch-backed albino]] Peake described -- apparently didn't hurt either.
to:
** It's more the [[FilmOfTheBook BBC Adaptation]] version of Steerpike who gets this treatment, and seems to encourage some fans to interpret the character differently. Although he was still [[MagnificentBastard pretty damn evil]], he was deliberately portrayed as genuinely loving Fuchsia (albeit in a warped and very disturbing way) and given a great stinking FreudianExcuse to boot [[note]] - a sob story wherein he had been abandoned at the age of six, sent to work in the kitchens and abused (emotionally, physically and sexually) throughout his childhood. In the novel, Steerpike, at seventeen, had arrived in the kitchens only a few months ago, so Swelter could not have abused him as a child. Peake tells us absolutely nothing about Steerpike's upbringing or origins (beyond the fact that he came from beyond Gormenghast) so we don't actually know if he has a tragic past to explain his extreme sociopathy[[/note]]. Casting the rather handsome JonathanRhysMeyers Creator/JonathanRhysMeyers -- who ''really'' [[AdaptationalAttractiveness doesn't fit the picture of the ugly, hunch-backed albino]] Peake described -- apparently didn't hurt either.
15th Feb '14 10:19:15 AM thenutintheushanka
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Added DiffLines:
** Or detached, like Lord Sepulchrave.
19th Aug '13 7:51:17 AM Viira
Is there an issue? Send a Message
** It's more the [[FilmOfTheBook BBC Adaptation]] version of Steerpike who gets this treatment, and seems to encourage some fans to interpret the character differently. Although he was still [[MagnificentBastard pretty damn evil]], he was deliberately portrayed as genuinely loving Fuchsia (albeit in a warped and very disturbing way) and given a great stinking FreudianExcuse to boot [[hottip:*: - a sob story wherein he had been abandoned at the age of six, sent to work in the kitchens and abused (emotionally, physically and sexually) throughout his childhood. In the novel, Steerpike, at seventeen, had arrived in the kitchens only a few months ago, so Swelter could not have abused him as a child. Peake tells us absolutely nothing about Steerpike's upbringing or origins (beyond the fact that he came from beyond Gormenghast) so we don't actually know if he has a tragic past to explain his extreme sociopathy]]. Casting the rather handsome JonathanRhysMeyers -- who ''really'' [[AdaptationalAttractiveness doesn't fit the picture of the ugly, hunch-backed albino]] Peake described -- apparently didn't hurt either.
to:
** It's more the [[FilmOfTheBook BBC Adaptation]] version of Steerpike who gets this treatment, and seems to encourage some fans to interpret the character differently. Although he was still [[MagnificentBastard pretty damn evil]], he was deliberately portrayed as genuinely loving Fuchsia (albeit in a warped and very disturbing way) and given a great stinking FreudianExcuse to boot [[hottip:*: [[note]] - a sob story wherein he had been abandoned at the age of six, sent to work in the kitchens and abused (emotionally, physically and sexually) throughout his childhood. In the novel, Steerpike, at seventeen, had arrived in the kitchens only a few months ago, so Swelter could not have abused him as a child. Peake tells us absolutely nothing about Steerpike's upbringing or origins (beyond the fact that he came from beyond Gormenghast) so we don't actually know if he has a tragic past to explain his extreme sociopathy]].sociopathy[[/note]]. Casting the rather handsome JonathanRhysMeyers -- who ''really'' [[AdaptationalAttractiveness doesn't fit the picture of the ugly, hunch-backed albino]] Peake described -- apparently didn't hurt either.
7th Apr '13 6:01:14 PM AnnoNimus
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Added DiffLines:
* DumbIsGood: With the exception of Prunesquallor, the intellectual characters are depicted as cold, calculating and ruthless, most notably Steerpike and Cheeta.
27th Apr '12 3:51:41 AM SeptimusHeap
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Nightmare Fuel Unleaded is going to be cut
* ParanoiaFuel and NightmareFuelUnleaded: The companion novella ''Boy in Darkness''. In its entirety.
to:
* ParanoiaFuel and NightmareFuelUnleaded: NightmareFuel: The companion novella ''Boy in Darkness''. In its entirety.
29th Mar '12 9:11:49 PM videogmer314
Is there an issue? Send a Message
* MagnificentBastard: If Steerpike had only had a DeathNote, the books would have been over very, ''very'' quickly.
to:
* MagnificentBastard: If Steerpike had only had a DeathNote, Manga/DeathNote, the books would have been over very, ''very'' quickly.
This list shows the last 10 events of 13. Show all.