History YMMV / FushigiYuugi

29th May '16 8:56:47 PM BatmanKalEl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* TheScrappy: The anime's portrayal of Miaka tends to get disliked. The manga portrays her in a more realistic way. Ironically, [[ReplacementScrappy Mayo Sakaki]] from ''Eikoden'' actually [[RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap replaced Miaka as the Scrappy in the eyes of some fans]] with the release of ''Eikoden''. Ashitare, Yui and Tomo have also gained a degree of Scrappydom.
** In fact, Miaka is one of the most ''hated'' female characters in anime/manga -- to the degree when fans used a "Level of Suck" meter to measure other shoujo heroines. "At least she's not a Miaka".

to:

* TheScrappy: The anime's portrayal of Miaka tends to get disliked. The manga portrays her in a more realistic way. Ironically, [[ReplacementScrappy Mayo Sakaki]] from ''Eikoden'' actually [[RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap replaced Miaka as the Scrappy in the eyes of some fans]] with the release of ''Eikoden''. Ashitare, Yui and Tomo have also gained a degree of Scrappydom.
**
Scrappydom. In fact, Miaka is one of the most ''hated'' female characters in anime/manga -- to the degree when fans used a "Level of Suck" meter to measure other shoujo heroines. "At least she's not a Miaka".
6th Apr '16 3:25:53 PM MagBas
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Madoka Ohtori from the ''Suzaku Ibun'' game, for [[NoexportForYou the few who have played the game]]. Some complain that she's few more than a bland self-insert, and more MarySue-ish than Miaka herself. Others say that since she's more savvy and sensible, she's much better written than Miaka ever was.

to:

** Madoka Ohtori from the ''Suzaku Ibun'' game, for [[NoexportForYou the few who have played the game]]. Some complain that she's few more than a bland self-insert, and more MarySue-ish than Miaka herself.self-insert. Others say that since she's more savvy and sensible, she's much better written than Miaka ever was.



* RonTheDeathEater: Miaka's hatedom just ''loves'' to do this to her so they can pair themselves/their Mary Sue with Tamahome instead.
* TheScrappy: The anime's portrayal of Miaka tends to get her slammed as a Purity Sue. The manga portrays her in a more realistic way. Ironically, [[ReplacementScrappy Mayo Sakaki]] from ''Eikoden'' fits the Mary Sue bill ''more'', technically speaking, and actually [[RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap replaced Miaka as the Scrappy in the eyes of some fans]] with the release of ''Eikoden''. Ashitare, Yui and Tomo have also gained a degree of Scrappydom.

to:

* RonTheDeathEater: Miaka's hatedom just ''loves'' to do this to her so they can pair themselves/their Mary Sue OC with Tamahome instead.
* TheScrappy: The anime's portrayal of Miaka tends to get her slammed as a Purity Sue.disliked. The manga portrays her in a more realistic way. Ironically, [[ReplacementScrappy Mayo Sakaki]] from ''Eikoden'' fits the Mary Sue bill ''more'', technically speaking, and ''Eikoden'' actually [[RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap replaced Miaka as the Scrappy in the eyes of some fans]] with the release of ''Eikoden''. Ashitare, Yui and Tomo have also gained a degree of Scrappydom.
2nd Mar '16 12:19:36 PM BatmanKalEl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* TheScrappy: The anime's portrayal of Miaka tends to get her slammed as a PuritySue. The manga portrays her in a more realistic way. Ironically, [[ReplacementScrappy Mayo Sakaki]] from ''Eikoden'' fits the MarySue bill ''more'', technically speaking, and actually [[RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap replaced Miaka as the Scrappy in the eyes of some fans]] with the release of ''Eikoden''. Ashitare, Yui and Tomo have also gained a degree of Scrappydom.

to:

* TheScrappy: The anime's portrayal of Miaka tends to get her slammed as a PuritySue.Purity Sue. The manga portrays her in a more realistic way. Ironically, [[ReplacementScrappy Mayo Sakaki]] from ''Eikoden'' fits the MarySue Mary Sue bill ''more'', technically speaking, and actually [[RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap replaced Miaka as the Scrappy in the eyes of some fans]] with the release of ''Eikoden''. Ashitare, Yui and Tomo have also gained a degree of Scrappydom.
2nd Mar '16 12:17:22 PM BatmanKalEl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Most of the bad guys have gotten this at some point

to:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Most of the bad guys have gotten this at some pointpoint.
2nd Mar '16 12:16:48 PM BatmanKalEl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Most of the bad guys have gotten this at some point.

to:

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Most of the bad guys have gotten this at some point.point



** Nakago has proved to be an extremely controversial character on this very wiki. He's a MagnificentBastard and sympathetic WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds for some, a VillainSue for others. There's ''very'' little in-between, and him being the ([[WordOfGod confessed!]]) series CreatorsPet doesn't help.

to:

** Nakago has proved to be an extremely controversial character on this very wiki. He's a MagnificentBastard and sympathetic WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds for some, a VillainSue an InvincibleVillain for others. There's ''very'' little in-between, and him being the ([[WordOfGod confessed!]]) series CreatorsPet doesn't help.
2nd Mar '16 12:15:39 PM BatmanKalEl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* CanonSue: The priestesses, especially Miaka, are sometimes considered to be this. Nakago could count as a [[VillainSue villainous version]].



* CryForTheDevil: Nakago, again, if you buy his FreudianExcuse.



* TastesLikeDiabetes
* VillainSue: Nakago, if you ask a good chunk of fandom.
24th Feb '16 1:44:14 PM MsChibi
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* CanonSue: The priestesses, especially Miaka, are sometimes considered to be this. Nakago could count as a [[VillainSue villainous version]].
22nd Dec '15 12:06:16 PM Discar
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* AntiSue: Mayo from the ''Eikoden'' OAV.



* TheScrappy: The anime's portrayal of Miaka tends to get her slammed as a PuritySue. The manga portrays her in a more realistic way. Ironically, [[ReplacementScrappy Mayo]] [[AntiSue Sakaki]] from ''Eikoden'' fits the MarySue bill ''more'', technically speaking, and actually [[RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap replaced Miaka as the Scrappy in the eyes of some fans]] with the release of ''Eikoden''. Ashitare, Yui and Tomo have also gained a degree of Scrappydom.

to:

* TheScrappy: The anime's portrayal of Miaka tends to get her slammed as a PuritySue. The manga portrays her in a more realistic way. Ironically, [[ReplacementScrappy Mayo]] [[AntiSue Mayo Sakaki]] from ''Eikoden'' fits the MarySue bill ''more'', technically speaking, and actually [[RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap replaced Miaka as the Scrappy in the eyes of some fans]] with the release of ''Eikoden''. Ashitare, Yui and Tomo have also gained a degree of Scrappydom.
17th May '15 2:28:59 PM RainFairy
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* BaseBreaker: Nakago has proved to be an extremely controversial character on this very wiki. He's a MagnificentBastard and sympathetic WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds for some, a VillainSue for others. There's ''very'' little in-between.
** Also, the fact that he is the ([[WordOfGod confessed!]]) series CreatorsPet doesn't help.

to:

* BaseBreaker: BaseBreaker:
**
Nakago has proved to be an extremely controversial character on this very wiki. He's a MagnificentBastard and sympathetic WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds for some, a VillainSue for others. There's ''very'' little in-between.
** Also, the fact that he is
in-between, and him being the ([[WordOfGod confessed!]]) series CreatorsPet doesn't help.help.
** Madoka Ohtori from the ''Suzaku Ibun'' game, for [[NoexportForYou the few who have played the game]]. Some complain that she's few more than a bland self-insert, and more MarySue-ish than Miaka herself. Others say that since she's more savvy and sensible, she's much better written than Miaka ever was.



** Miboshi is a CreepyChild who [[OlderThanTheyLook is truly far older than he appears]]. Miboshi's MO is to [[DemonicPossession possess his victims]] and turn them against their friends, forcing the friends to experience the pain of betrayal and delighting at the agony he causes to his host by forcing them to harm the ones they love the most.

to:

** Miboshi is a CreepyChild who [[OlderThanTheyLook is truly far older than he appears]]. Miboshi's MO is to [[DemonicPossession possess his victims]] and turn them against their friends, forcing the friends to experience the pain of betrayal and delighting at the agony he causes to his host by forcing them to harm the ones they love the most. [[spoiler: Made even worse by how the ''Byakko Ibun'' prequel hints that [[FallenHero he did not start this way]].]]
12th Mar '15 11:21:32 PM Scabbard
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** In ''Eikou Den'', [[spoiler:Mayo stealing Miaka's unborn baby and trying to erase her from existence.]])

to:

** In ''Eikou Den'', [[spoiler:Mayo stealing Miaka's unborn baby and trying to erase her from existence.]])]]
This list shows the last 10 events of 49. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=YMMV.FushigiYuugi