History YMMV / DragonQuestV

1st Feb '16 2:05:27 PM lalalei2001
Is there an issue? Send a Message
The abd end was a prank by soemoen trlasnating the game, and in both versions the ones you dont' choose end up happy.
** Despite being added into the DS version as a "joke character", many players pick Deborah as the protagonist's wife for her [[MsFanservice looks]], HiddenHeartOfGold (which becomes more obvious late in the game in party conversations) and for having some of the funniest dialogue in the game (such as when she tells the priest blessing their wedding to hurry up with his speech).
to:
** Despite being added into the DS version as a "joke character", many Many players pick Deborah as the protagonist's wife for her [[MsFanservice looks]], HiddenHeartOfGold (which becomes more obvious late in the game in party conversations) and for having some of the funniest dialogue in the game (such as when she tells the priest blessing their wedding to hurry up with his speech).

* RelationshipWritingFumble: A rather strange example centered on the FridgeLogic of the romance angle itself. The original game very clearly wanted to have the central relationship of the story between the hero and Bianca, a clear case of ChildhoodFriendRomance... which raises the question of why make the hero choose a bride ''at all''. The choice doesn't particularly affect anything except to introduce [[GuiltBasedGaming a rather pointless and cruel]] BadEnd to the intended arc. The oddity of the very premise is emphasized by adding Deborah to the remake, generally ensuring that, no matter -whom- you choose, somebody will be walking away from the situation unhappy. * RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: Nera goes from a worthless party member who triggers the MOTHER of GuiltBasedGaming if you '''dare''' choose her over Bianca in the original version, to a completely viable romance option who doesn't unintentionally ruin the Whitaker family if chosen in the remake.
1st Feb '16 1:54:23 PM Tavernier
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Added DiffLines:
* RelationshipWritingFumble: A rather strange example centered on the FridgeLogic of the romance angle itself. The original game very clearly wanted to have the central relationship of the story between the hero and Bianca, a clear case of ChildhoodFriendRomance... which raises the question of why make the hero choose a bride ''at all''. The choice doesn't particularly affect anything except to introduce [[GuiltBasedGaming a rather pointless and cruel]] BadEnd to the intended arc. The oddity of the very premise is emphasized by adding Deborah to the remake, generally ensuring that, no matter -whom- you choose, somebody will be walking away from the situation unhappy.
24th Oct '15 2:13:59 PM Cakeman
Is there an issue? Send a Message
* BreatherBoss: Grandmaster Nimzo, at least in comparison to other bosses in the franchise. However, he was made harder in the DS version due to players having access to 4 party members instead of merely three.
to:
* BreatherBoss: Grandmaster Nimzo, at least in comparison to other final bosses in the franchise. However, he was made harder in the DS version due to players having access to 4 party members instead of merely three.
24th Oct '15 2:13:37 PM Cakeman
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Added DiffLines:
* JerkassDissonance: Debora is considered to be an EnsembleDarkhorse despite being abrasive in comparison to Bianca and her sister Nera.
22nd Oct '15 10:47:38 PM Cakeman
Is there an issue? Send a Message
* CompleteMonster: Bishop Ladja, despite only being TheDragon, becomes one of the vilest characters in the series in [[UpdatedRerelease the DS remake]]. He specializes in committing an even more horrific atrocity than his last in most of his appearances. His first scene alone has him brutally beating the hero and Harry ([[WouldHurtAChild who are six years old at the time]]) to within an inch of their lives, laughing sadistically all the while. Then, when the hero's father, Pankraz, arrives to save the day, he threatens to murder the hero if Pankraz tries to fight back against his enforcers. After the enforcers are done beating him, Ladja coldly finishes off the dying Pankraz with a giant fireball, then carts the hero and Harry off to a brutal slave labor camp for over ten years. He's also at least somewhat successful at being TheStarscream, killing off one person ahead of him (King Korol) in the chain of command for the power. Finally, he makes sure to wait until the main character reunites with his mother (after over 18 years apart) to kill said mother, just for maximum emotional impact.
to:
* CompleteMonster: Bishop Ladja, despite only being TheDragon, becomes one of the vilest characters in the Dragon Quest series in [[UpdatedRerelease the DS remake]]. He specializes in committing an even more horrific atrocity than his last in most of his appearances. His first scene alone has him brutally beating the hero and Harry ([[WouldHurtAChild who are six years old at the time]]) to within an inch of their lives, laughing sadistically all the while. Then, when the hero's father, Pankraz, arrives to save the day, he threatens to murder the hero if Pankraz tries to fight back against his enforcers. After the enforcers are done beating him, Ladja coldly finishes off the dying Pankraz with a giant fireball, then carts the hero and Harry off to a brutal slave labor camp for over ten years. He's also at least somewhat successful at being TheStarscream, killing off one person ahead of him (King Korol) in the chain of command for the power. Finally, he makes sure to wait until the main character reunites with his mother (after over 18 years apart) to kill said mother, just for maximum emotional impact.
22nd Oct '15 10:46:31 PM Cakeman
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Added DiffLines:
* BreatherBoss: Grandmaster Nimzo, at least in comparison to other bosses in the franchise. However, he was made harder in the DS version due to players having access to 4 party members instead of merely three.
20th May '15 3:53:52 AM Trigger-of-Sorrow
Is there an issue? Send a Message
** Pankraz is also one, mostly for being [[MemeticBadass Badass]].
to:
** Pankraz is also one, mostly for being one of the [[GoodParents best fathers ever]] and a [[MemeticBadass Badass]].Badass]] at that. ** Despite being added into the DS version as a "joke character", many players pick Deborah as the protagonist's wife for her [[MsFanservice looks]], HiddenHeartOfGold (which becomes more obvious late in the game in party conversations) and for having some of the funniest dialogue in the game (such as when she tells the priest blessing their wedding to hurry up with his speech).
11th Dec '14 8:52:37 AM RainFairy
Is there an issue? Send a Message
* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: Nera goes from a worthless party member who makes Bianca's life terrible in the original version to a completely viable romance option who doesn't completely ruin the Whitaker family if chosen in the remake.
to:
* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: Nera goes from a worthless party member who makes Bianca's life terrible triggers the MOTHER of GuiltBasedGaming if you '''dare''' choose her over Bianca in the original version version, to a completely viable romance option who doesn't completely unintentionally ruin the Whitaker family if chosen in the remake.remake.
22nd Nov '14 2:44:26 PM MagBas
Is there an issue? Send a Message
unfortunate implications need citations
* UnfortunateImplications: The game text pretty much states that you're still a teenager by the time you become a father. ** Of course, [[DeliberateValuesDissonance that kind of thing would hardly be as frowned upon in a medieval world]], such as the one in the game. ** Sancho's heavily stereotyped accent in the DS translation is rather... unfortunate, particularly given his role. ** You can equip your 8-year old daughter with a lacy bustier, a silk bustier, the dancer's costume, etc.
16th Aug '14 8:52:57 PM Angeldeb82
Is there an issue? Send a Message
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharater: Ladja in the original game, with his initial MoralEventHorizon when he first appears seem like a great way to set him up as a major villain, but he ends up being nothing more than a flunky for King Korol, whose actions have far less of an emotional impact on the player. * {{Too Cool to Live}}: [[spoiler:Pankraz.]]
to:
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharater: TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: Ladja in the original game, with his initial MoralEventHorizon when he first appears seem like a great way to set him up as a major villain, but he ends up being nothing more than a flunky for King Korol, whose actions have far less of an emotional impact on the player. * {{Too Cool to Live}}: TooCoolToLive: [[spoiler:Pankraz.]]
This list shows the last 10 events of 43. Show all.