History YMMV / CardcaptorSakura

1st Jan '18 2:24:16 AM sayaleviathan
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* ValuesDissonance: This series has an astonishingly casual view of May/December teacher/student relationships. Sakura's mother and father met when he was a high school teacher and she was a highschool student. Sakura's older brother and his (student) teacher had a brief romance, but dropped it for reasons that had nothing to do with age inappropriateness and more with [[spoiler: her leaving ''and'' knowing that they'd fall for others]]. One of Sakura's prepubescent classmates has a crush on their teacher... and in the manga, he returns it! And this is shown as romantic and dreamy. Nelvana even changed a line about Rika liking Mr. Terada to her ''fearing'' him, which is rather needless anyway since the anime has him completely oblivious to her PrecociousCrush. Upon the release of the ''Clear Card'' arc in 2016, Rika Sasaki is written out in the sequel as CLAMP is aware that her relationship with her teacher would be seen as uncomfortable and inappropriate in the 21st century considering the people have been very critical with MayDecemberRomance portrayed in the media.

to:

* ValuesDissonance: This series has an astonishingly casual view of May/December teacher/student relationships. Sakura's mother and father met when he was a high school teacher and she was a highschool student. Sakura's older brother and his (student) teacher had a brief romance, but dropped it for reasons that had nothing to do with age inappropriateness and more with [[spoiler: her leaving ''and'' knowing that they'd fall for others]]. One of Sakura's prepubescent classmates has a crush on their teacher... and in the manga, he returns it! And this is shown as romantic and dreamy. Nelvana even changed a line about Rika liking Mr. Terada to her ''fearing'' him, which is rather needless anyway since the anime has him completely oblivious to her PrecociousCrush. Upon the release of the ''Clear Card'' arc in 2016, Rika Sasaki is written out in the sequel as CLAMP is aware that her relationship with her teacher would be seen as uncomfortable and inappropriate in the 21st century considering that the people have been very critical with MayDecemberRomance portrayed in the media.
31st Dec '17 1:17:50 PM MiracleChange
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* AuthorsSavingThrow: The relationship between Rika and Terada is very controversial which lead to countless debate whether it is considered sweet or disgusting. The 2016 sequel, the ''Clear Card'' arc, removes Rika to prevent further controversy.

to:

* AuthorsSavingThrow: The relationship between Rika and Terada is very controversial which lead to countless debate whether it is considered sweet or disgusting. The 2016 sequel, the ''Clear Card'' arc, removes Rika and Terada to prevent further controversy.
30th Dec '17 8:38:55 AM MiracleChange
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* AmericansHateTingle: Many fans outside Japan [[TheScrappy hate Terada-sensei]] due to the very common AlternateCharacterInterpretation that he is a pedophile. This also extends to Rika to an extent.

to:

* AmericansHateTingle: Many fans outside Japan [[TheScrappy hate Terada-sensei]] due to the very common AlternateCharacterInterpretation that he is a pedophile.pedophile/predator. This also extends to Rika to an extent.
21st Dec '17 8:04:57 PM sayaleviathan
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* AuthorsSavingThrow: The relationship between Rika and Terada is very controversial which lead to countless debate whether it is considered sweet or disgusting. The 2016 sequel, the ''Clear Card'' arc, removes Rika to prevent further controversy.



** The TeacherStudentRomance between an adult man and a fourth grade girl is seen as either adorable or the single most disgusting thing in all of manga. There is no middle ground on this one.

to:

** The TeacherStudentRomance between an adult man and a fourth grade girl is seen as either adorable or the single most disgusting thing in all of manga. There is no middle ground on this one. The girl is AdaptedOut from the sequel which saves everybody the trouble of discussing it.



* ValuesDissonance: This series has an astonishingly casual view of May/December teacher/student relationships. Sakura's mother and father met when he was a high school teacher and she was a highschool student. Sakura's older brother and his (student) teacher had a brief romance, but dropped it for reasons that had nothing to do with age inappropriateness and more with [[spoiler: her leaving ''and'' knowing that they'd fall for others]]. One of Sakura's prepubescent classmates has a crush on their teacher... and in the manga, he returns it! And this is shown as romantic and dreamy. Nelvana even changed a line about Rika liking Mr. Terada to her ''fearing'' him, which is rather needless anyway since the anime has him completely oblivious to her PrecociousCrush.

to:

* ValuesDissonance: This series has an astonishingly casual view of May/December teacher/student relationships. Sakura's mother and father met when he was a high school teacher and she was a highschool student. Sakura's older brother and his (student) teacher had a brief romance, but dropped it for reasons that had nothing to do with age inappropriateness and more with [[spoiler: her leaving ''and'' knowing that they'd fall for others]]. One of Sakura's prepubescent classmates has a crush on their teacher... and in the manga, he returns it! And this is shown as romantic and dreamy. Nelvana even changed a line about Rika liking Mr. Terada to her ''fearing'' him, which is rather needless anyway since the anime has him completely oblivious to her PrecociousCrush. Upon the release of the ''Clear Card'' arc in 2016, Rika Sasaki is written out in the sequel as CLAMP is aware that her relationship with her teacher would be seen as uncomfortable and inappropriate in the 21st century considering the people have been very critical with MayDecemberRomance portrayed in the media.
4th Dec '17 12:07:55 AM SheldonDinkleburg
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* FandomBerserkButton: Don't mention ''[[{{Macekre}} Cardcaptors]]'' particuarly to hardcore fans, and Yue help you if you say that you like that version specifically.

to:

* FandomBerserkButton: Don't mention Simply mentioning ''[[{{Macekre}} Cardcaptors]]'' particuarly is enough to provoke many hardcore fans, fans' ire. While other highly edited dubs such as ''Anime/SailorMoon'' and Yue help you if you say that you like that version specifically.''Anime/YuGiOh'' still have substantial fanbases who defend them primarily on the basis of nostalgic value, this happens less often for ''Cardcaptor Sakura'' since its English fanbase is significantly smaller.
28th Nov '17 3:45:12 PM ryanasaurus0077
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* OvershadowedByControversy: Rika Sasaki, who her teacher infamously had a crush on, was written out of the Clear Card arc in a conscious effort to defy this in the wake of the growing backlash against the sexualization of underage girls in Japan. A relationship like this, while it might have been OK in the late '90s with a justification that appeared in the manga (specifically, a mutual agreement that Rika would wait until she was old enough to officially hook up with him), would not be anywhere near as kosher in the new tens.
6th Nov '17 4:30:13 PM Cieloazul
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Kero's voice in Spain by Creator/JaimeRoca is a huge breaking point even among people who unambiguously approve the entire dub. Some think that turning his KansaiAccent into a pseudo-Mexican accent was an error and ruins the character, others like it because it gives flavour to Kero and was the most logic decision to keep the original language cues (the alternative, as said in the Kansai-ben article, would have been giving him an Andalusian accent, and that's not exactly a popular idea among Spanish pundits) and others just think of it as NarmCharm.

to:

** Kero's voice in Spain by Creator/JaimeRoca is a huge breaking point even among people who unambiguously approve the entire dub. Some think that turning his KansaiAccent KansaiRegionalAccent into a pseudo-Mexican accent was an error and ruins the character, others like it because it gives flavour to Kero and was the most logic decision to keep the original language cues (the alternative, as said in the Kansai-ben article, would have been giving him an Andalusian accent, and that's not exactly a but that wouldn't have been popular idea among with Spanish pundits) pundits either) and others just think of it as NarmCharm.



** The series was also extremely popular in Spain, to the point it is one of the few anime series that people who are not into the genre can recognize when not thinking on AllAnimeAreNaughtyTentacles. Along with ''Anime/DigimonAdventure'', ''Anime/{{Pokemon}}'', ''LightNovel/{{Slayers}}'' and others, ''CCS'' was one of the most popular anime series brought in TheNineties, and it is pretty much the first thing a Spaniard sees in his mind when thinking of the MagicalGirl genre (that even considering that ''Manga/SailorMoon'' was also a part of the mentioned batch). Its [[SuperlativeDubbing particularly well made dub and adaptation]] makes it stand out as well.

to:

** The series was also extremely popular in Spain, to the point it is one of the few anime series that people who are not into the genre can recognize when not thinking on AllAnimeAreNaughtyTentacles. Spain. Along with ''Anime/DigimonAdventure'', ''Anime/{{Pokemon}}'', ''LightNovel/{{Slayers}}'' and others, ''CCS'' was one of the most popular anime series brought in TheNineties, and it is pretty much the first thing a Spaniard sees in his mind when thinking of the MagicalGirl genre (that even considering that ''Manga/SailorMoon'' was also a part of the mentioned batch). Its [[SuperlativeDubbing particularly well made well-made dub and adaptation]] makes it stand out as well.
26th Oct '17 2:11:17 PM MiracleChange
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* AmericansHateTingle: Many fans outside Japan hate Terada-sensei due to the very common AlternateCharacterInterpretation that he is a pedophile. This also extends to Rika to an extent.

to:

* AmericansHateTingle: Many fans outside Japan [[TheScrappy hate Terada-sensei Terada-sensei]] due to the very common AlternateCharacterInterpretation that he is a pedophile. This also extends to Rika to an extent.
4th Oct '17 11:27:11 AM ThomasProofreader
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Any time Syaoran calls [[FirstNameBasis Sakura by her name]] instead of the dismissal HeyYou starting from episode 57 as it demonstrates just how far [[TookALevelInKindness Syaoran has developed from and arrogant rival to a close friend of Sakura]]. Possibly subverted in Episode 60 where it is used for TearJerker purposes.

to:

** Any time Syaoran calls [[FirstNameBasis Sakura by her name]] instead of the dismissal HeyYou starting from episode 57 as it demonstrates just how far [[TookALevelInKindness Syaoran has developed from and an arrogant rival to a close friend of Sakura]]. Possibly subverted in Episode 60 where it is used for TearJerker purposes.
12th Sep '17 11:12:36 AM Sakubara
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* FriendlyFandoms: With ''Franchise/{{Pokemon}}'', given the similar optimistic tone and friendship themes between the two. The ''{{Anime/Pokemon}}'' anime even [[http://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/DP077 paid homage to this show.]]

to:

* FriendlyFandoms: With ''Franchise/{{Pokemon}}'', given the similar optimistic tone and friendship themes between the two. The ''{{Anime/Pokemon}}'' anime even [[http://bulbapedia.[[https://cdn.bulbagarden.net/wiki/DP077 net/upload/5/5b/Sakura_and_Tomoyo_DP077.png paid homage to this show.]]
This list shows the last 10 events of 240. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=YMMV.CardcaptorSakura