History YMMV / CSINY

22nd May '18 11:26:22 PM AlternativeCola
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Also subverted in "Some Buried Bones". You'd think that Music/NellyFurtado is the killer since she plays a professional thief who removes security tags on stuff she steals and becomes a suspect for a murder that occured at a department store that she was stealing a purse but it turns out that she isn't the killer and in fact, only [[FreudianExcuse became a professional thief]] after [[JerkassWoobie suffering]] DomesticAbuse from her husband and took part in a propranolol medical trial for women who were victims of domestic abuse, which as a result compassionately suggests the women reveal her past abuse at the hands of her husband, to get leniency from the judge, and offers Ava her card if she wants to talk, given the fact Stella was a victim of domestic abuse in the season before at the hands of her ex-boyfriend Frankie.

to:

** Also subverted in "Some Buried Bones". You'd think that Music/NellyFurtado is the killer since she plays a professional thief who removes security tags on stuff she steals and becomes a suspect for a murder that occured at a department store that she was stealing a purse but it turns out that she isn't the killer and in fact, only [[FreudianExcuse became a professional thief]] after [[JerkassWoobie suffering]] DomesticAbuse from her husband and took part in a propranolol medical trial for women who were victims of domestic abuse, which as a result Stella compassionately suggests the women reveal her past abuse at the hands of her husband, to get leniency from the judge, and offers Ava her card if she wants to talk, given the fact Stella was a victim of domestic abuse in the season before at the hands of her ex-boyfriend Frankie.
8th May '18 12:16:08 PM AlternativeCola
Is there an issue? Send a Message
8th May '18 12:15:42 PM AlternativeCola
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* TheScrappy: Reed

to:

* TheScrappy: ReedReed, with fans finding him to be a bland character.
8th May '18 12:03:35 PM AlternativeCola
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Also subverted in "Some Buried Bones". You'd think that Music/NellyFurtado is the killer since she plays a kleptomaniac professional thief who removes security tags on stuff she steals and becomes a suspect for a murder that occured at a department store that she was stealing a purse but it turns out that she isn't the killer and in fact, only [[FreudianExcuse became a professional thief]] after [[JerkassWoobie suffering]] DomesticAbuse from her husband and took part in a medical trial for propranolol along with women who were victims of domestic abuse.

to:

** Also subverted in "Some Buried Bones". You'd think that Music/NellyFurtado is the killer since she plays a kleptomaniac professional thief who removes security tags on stuff she steals and becomes a suspect for a murder that occured at a department store that she was stealing a purse but it turns out that she isn't the killer and in fact, only [[FreudianExcuse became a professional thief]] after [[JerkassWoobie suffering]] DomesticAbuse from her husband and took part in a propranolol medical trial for propranolol along with women who were victims of domestic abuse.abuse, which as a result compassionately suggests the women reveal her past abuse at the hands of her husband, to get leniency from the judge, and offers Ava her card if she wants to talk, given the fact Stella was a victim of domestic abuse in the season before at the hands of her ex-boyfriend Frankie.
6th May '18 11:10:49 PM AlternativeCola
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* DesignatedHero: InUniverse example in "The Thing About Heroes" as after revealing himself to be the [[spoiler:333 Stalker]], Drew tells Mac that he didn't deserve to gain a hero status for his actions in the season three finale, all because he couldn't save his older brother Will.
5th May '18 11:31:22 PM AlternativeCola
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* HarsherInHindsight: Season 10 features an episode where a little girl dies by her friend accidentally shooting her. He'd already removed the magazine, so assumed it would be safe. Cut to a previous episode featuring Jo finally taking down a rapist she's been trying to catch since her days in the FBI. Hr words at that time may echo in your head watching the scene with the kids. "They always forget the [bullet] in the chamber."

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: Season 10 9 features an episode where a little girl dies by her friend accidentally shooting her. He'd already removed the magazine, so assumed it would be safe. Cut to a previous episode featuring Jo finally taking down a rapist she's been trying to catch since her days in the FBI. Hr words at that time may echo in your head watching the scene with the kids. "They always forget the [bullet] in the chamber.""
** Sid being diagnosed with non-Hodgkins' lymphona becomes this when you realise that Hawkes' actor Hill Harper battled thyroid cancer at one point and did a book about it, but thankfully has since gone into remission.
30th Apr '18 4:36:00 AM AlternativeCola
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Also subverted in "Some Buried Bones". You'd think that Music/NellyFurtado is the killer since she plays a kleptomaniac professional thief who removes security tags on stuff she steals and becomes a suspect for a murder that occured at a department store that she was stealing a purse but it turns out that she isn't the killer and in fact, only [[FreudianExcuse became a professional thief]] after [[JerkassWoobie suffering]] DomesticAbuse from her husband and took part in a medical trial for propranolol along with women who were victims of domestic abuse.
30th Apr '18 3:56:26 AM AlternativeCola
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* BrokenBase: Danny and Lindsay's relationship in general. Lindsay herself.

to:

* BaseBreakingCharacter: Lindsay is either one of the interesting characters of the show or one of the least interesting.
* BrokenBase: Danny and Lindsay's relationship in general. Lindsay herself.



* TheProblemWithLicensedGames: The game wasn't as good as the others in the franchise. It isn't totally awful, but for some reason was mostly puzzles and hidden item stuff as opposed to the more detailed evidence collecting,tests,interviewing ect of the other two shows. Plus, the puzzles can frustrate to no end, especially the "draw a line without touching the non matching items" one and the "draw the outline" one for some. Plus,each case was short,and Mac and Stella were the only player characters,as opposed to either all of the team at various points or a original player character like the rest. And fans tend to view it as yet another example of the show getting the short end of the stick.
* TheScrappy: Reed. Jo is also turning into one of these after her first episode, replacing Stella.
** Peyton.

to:

* TheProblemWithLicensedGames: The game wasn't as good as the others in the franchise. It isn't totally awful, but for some reason was mostly puzzles and hidden item stuff as opposed to the more detailed evidence collecting,tests,interviewing collecting, tests, interviewing ect of the other two shows. Plus, the puzzles can frustrate to no end, especially the "draw a line without touching the non matching items" one and the "draw the outline" one for some. Plus,each Plus, each case was short,and short and Mac and Stella were the only player characters,as characters, as opposed to either all of the team at various points or a original player character like the rest. And fans tend to view it as yet another example of the show getting the short end of the stick.
* TheScrappy: Reed. ReplacementScrappy: Jo is also turning into one of these this to Stella fans after her first episode, replacing Stella.
episode.
* TheScrappy: Reed
** Peyton.Peyton, to Mac/Stella fans.


Added DiffLines:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: Some fans felt that it would've been interesting to have a CSI: New Orleans spin-off focusing on Stella, following her departure betweem season six and seven.
22nd Aug '17 9:24:39 AM PrincessSolarFlare
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* WhatAnIdiot: The criminals from time to time. [[spoiler: Susan]] from "Turbulence" is a prime example. [[spoiler: She very easily could have gotten away with murder, if only she had stuck with the lie that Greenway was a hijacker and her actions saved the plane.]]
1st Jan '17 7:35:21 PM WaggishPony
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* HideYourPregnancy: When actress Anna Belknap, who plays Lindsay, became pregnant, they used the close-up method with varying success. The second time around, they wrote it into the storyline.


Added DiffLines:

* OnlyBarelyRenewed: Getting season nine came down to it being cheaper to make than ''Series/CSIMiami'' and wanting it for a [[BigApplesauce New York]] themed night of programming.
This list shows the last 10 events of 82. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=YMMV.CSINY