Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / BooksOfSamuel

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Evil Is Sexy TRS; this has become an objective, in-universe trope.


* EvilIsSexy: Saul is described as handsome and he became a villain. It is unknown whether he kept his looks, though. There is also Absalom, who was as handsome as his father David.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Saul lost his divine support after disobeying divine orders by being [[PunishedForSympathy insufficiently thorough committing a genocide]] in which every man, woman, child, and animal of the nation of Amalek was to be exterminated. In fact, God himself says he ''repents'' choosing Saul for not killing enough in his ordered FinalSolution.

to:

** Saul lost his divine support after disobeying divine orders by being [[PunishedForSympathy insufficiently thorough committing a genocide]] in which every man, woman, child, and animal of the nation of Amalek was to be exterminated. In fact, God himself Himself says he He ''repents'' choosing Saul for not killing enough in his ordered FinalSolution.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NeverLiveItDown: "David did what was right in the eyes of the LORD and did not turn aside from anything that he commanded him all the days of his life, '''''[[UriahGambit except in the matter of Uriah the Hittite]]'''''" ([[Literature/BooksOfKings 1 Kings 15:5]]).

to:

* NeverLiveItDown: "David did "For David had done what was right in the eyes of pleasing to the LORD and did not turn aside never turned throughout his life from anything all that he He had commanded him all the days of his life, him, '''''[[UriahGambit except in the matter of Uriah the Hittite]]'''''" ([[Literature/BooksOfKings 1 Kings 15:5]]).



** Basically, Saul lost his divine support after disobeying divine orders by being [[PunishedForSympathy insufficiently thorough committing a genocide]] in which every man, woman, child, and animal of the nation of Amalek was to be exterminated. In fact, God himself says he ''repents'' choosing Saul for not killing enough in his ordered FinalSolution.

to:

** Basically, Saul lost his divine support after disobeying divine orders by being [[PunishedForSympathy insufficiently thorough committing a genocide]] in which every man, woman, child, and animal of the nation of Amalek was to be exterminated. In fact, God himself says he ''repents'' choosing Saul for not killing enough in his ordered FinalSolution.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OneSceneWonder: Abigail. She appears in only one chapter, but ends up saving her entire household from David’s wrath and her (first) husband’s stupidity. Once he dies, she marries the future king of Israel. Along with Jonathan, she’s the only named character in the Books of Samuel about which only positive things are said.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** While many see David's actions in the land of the Phillistines as him pretending to defect, others have interpreted it as David legitimately turning against his people (while not actually attacking them) and that God had to give him a wake-up call by having the city of Ziklag captured.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FairForItsDay: The narrative doesn't explicitly describe the encounter between David and Bathsheba as rape, but it ''definitely does'' suggest that it was, at best, QuestionableConsent. Nathan even compares her to an innocent lamb stolen from its owner by a rich man who already had his own sheep. Given that the prevailing view of women at the time this was written was that AllWomenAreLustful, the very notion that she ''didn't'' want to have sex with David, or to go along with his plan to try and pass of her pregnancy as being from her own husband (but couldn't really say no to the king) would have been pretty radical. It's also notable that it doesn't condemn her for going to the palace, or even for hiding her pregnancy from Uriah.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NeverLiveItDown: "David did what was right in the eyes of the LORD and did not turn aside from anything that he commanded him all the days of his life, '''''[[UriahGambit except in the matter of Uriah the Hittite]]'''''" (1 Kings 15:5).

to:

* NeverLiveItDown: "David did what was right in the eyes of the LORD and did not turn aside from anything that he commanded him all the days of his life, '''''[[UriahGambit except in the matter of Uriah the Hittite]]'''''" (1 ([[Literature/BooksOfKings 1 Kings 15:5).15:5]]).

Added: 660

Changed: 170

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralEventHorizon: Saul crossed it when he killed the priests of Nob and their family and livestock. His act was so grave that only Doeg the Edomite of his troops supported him in that act.

to:

* MoralEventHorizon: MoralEventHorizon:
**
Saul crossed it when he killed the priests of Nob and their family and livestock. His act was so grave that only Doeg the Edomite of his troops supported him in that act.
** Amnon crossed it by raping his sister Tamar.
** Absalom arguably started out as a WellIntentionedExtremist, since David had refused to punish Amnon for Tamar's rape so it could be argued that Absalom had good reason to see him as a weak king; however, he undeniably went too far by publicly raping his father's concubines to show who was in charge now.
** David himself crossed it by ordering Joab to arrange for Uriah to be killed in battle, originating the UriahGambit in the process.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Bathsheba has been traditionally described as participating in a mutual romantic affair with David, even possibly intentionally seducing him by bathing naked outside. Alternately, she may be a cautionary tale about the need to dress modestly to avoid the MaleGaze. Conversely, it's becoming more common to point out that even in the best case scenario, the circumstances were QuestionableConsent at best, since David ordered her to be brought to him and she didn't exactly have the free choice to refuse the king's orders.

to:

** Bathsheba has been traditionally described as participating in a mutual romantic affair with David, even possibly intentionally seducing him by bathing naked outside. Alternately, she may be a cautionary tale about the need to dress modestly to avoid the MaleGaze. Conversely, it's becoming more common to point out that even in the best case scenario, the circumstances were QuestionableConsent at best, best since David ordered her to be brought to him and she didn't exactly have the free choice to refuse the king's orders.



** Later, tens of thousands of people die in a plague because David took a census. When God ''gave him the idea in the first place'' (Chronicles retcons it to Satan).

to:

** Later, tens of thousands of people die in a plague because David took a census. When God ''gave him the idea in the first place'' place'', (Chronicles retcons it to Satan).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateAesopInterpretation: As many people have remarked down the centuries, the lesson of DavidVersusGoliath can easiy be read as "NeverBringAKnifeToAGunFight".

to:

* AlternateAesopInterpretation: As many people have remarked down the centuries, the lesson of DavidVersusGoliath can easiy easily be read as "NeverBringAKnifeToAGunFight".



** Absalom. Was he [[TheUsurper an arrogant usurper]], or was he motivated by vengeance for his sister, Tamar? David did nothing to punish Amnon for raping Tamar, and Absalom’s sense of wounded justice seemed to be his StartOfDarkness. That, however, does not excuse the fact that he in turn publicly raped many of David’s concubines—[[QuestionableConsent or at minimum, had sex with them under very coercive circumstances]].

to:

** Absalom. Was he [[TheUsurper an arrogant usurper]], usurper]] or was he motivated by vengeance for his sister, sister Tamar? David did nothing to punish Amnon for raping Tamar, and Absalom’s sense of wounded justice seemed to be his StartOfDarkness. That, however, does not excuse the fact that he in turn publicly raped many of David’s concubines—[[QuestionableConsent or or, at minimum, had sex with them under very coercive circumstances]].



** The theory that the two women named Ahinoam, one of them Saul's wife (and the mother of Jonathan and Michal) and one of them David's wife (and the mother of Amnon), were actually the same person, and that the angry Saul was serious when he called Jonathan a "son of a perverse and rebellious woman" because David had eloped with his own mother-in-law offscreen.
* BestKnownForTheFanservice: David is commonly remembered as the king who [[OutdoorBathPeeping saw Bathsheba bathing on the roof]], and who... did some other things too? The dancing is an aversion, since David in the text wasn't even shirtless but Michal's words mislead people into thinking he was naked or undressed.

to:

** The theory that the two women named Ahinoam, one of them Saul's wife (and the mother of Jonathan and Michal) and one of them David's wife (and the mother of Amnon), were actually the same person, person and that the angry Saul was serious when he called Jonathan a "son of a perverse and rebellious woman" because David had eloped with his own mother-in-law offscreen.
* BestKnownForTheFanservice: David is commonly remembered as the king who [[OutdoorBathPeeping saw Bathsheba bathing on the roof]], and who... did some other things too? The dancing is an aversion, aversion since David in the text wasn't even shirtless but Michal's words mislead people into thinking he was naked or undressed.



** Basically, Saul lost his divine support after disobeying divine orders by being [[PunishedForSympathy insufficiently thorough committing a genocide]] in which every man, woman, child and animal of the nation of Amalek was to be exterminated. In fact God himself say he ''repents'' choosing Saul for not killing enough in his ordered FinalSolution.

to:

** Basically, Saul lost his divine support after disobeying divine orders by being [[PunishedForSympathy insufficiently thorough committing a genocide]] in which every man, woman, child child, and animal of the nation of Amalek was to be exterminated. In fact fact, God himself say says he ''repents'' choosing Saul for not killing enough in his ordered FinalSolution.



** Michal, Saul's daughter, because David is such an incredible jerk to her. Early in the story, she loves him and marries him, and saves his life from her own father when he wants to have David killed, risking her own in the process. Then, David runs away and never even tries to contact her for years, and marries other women instead. All right. Michal is then married to another man, and is apparently happy with him -- but then David (who is now the king) suddenly wants her back again and has her dragged away from her new family, with her husband following her along the way [[TearJerker crying for her]] as she is taken away. ''Then'' David publicly humiliates Michal by saying he really prefers slave girls to her, and boasts that he is now king instead of her father and brothers (who were killed in the meantime), and there's nothing she can do about it--"And I will yet be more vile than thus." And he is, because, as one final atrocity against her, [[WouldHurtAChild he has her sister's five sons murdered and left to rot]].[[note]]In some manuscripts, they was Michal's sons, but some translations have written it as her sister Merab's upon checking discrepancies. One interpretation is that they are possibly stepsons or adopted by Michal, but does that make it much better?[[/note]] How Michal must regret that she saved him, that time many years ago...

to:

** Michal, Saul's daughter, because David is such an incredible jerk to her. Early in the story, she loves him and marries him, and she saves his life from her own father when he wants to have David killed, risking her own in the process. Then, Then David runs away and never even tries to contact her for years, and he marries other women instead. All right. Michal is then married to another man, man and is apparently happy with him -- but then David (who is now the king) suddenly wants her back again and has her dragged away from her new family, with her husband following her along the way [[TearJerker crying for her]] as she is taken away. ''Then'' David publicly humiliates Michal by saying he really prefers slave girls to her, her and boasts that he is now king instead of her father and brothers (who were killed in the meantime), and there's nothing she can do about it--"And I will yet be more vile than thus." And he is, because, as one final atrocity against her, [[WouldHurtAChild he has her sister's five sons murdered and left to rot]].[[note]]In some manuscripts, they was were Michal's sons, but some translations have written it as her sister Merab's upon checking discrepancies. One interpretation is that they are possibly stepsons or adopted by Michal, but does that make it much better?[[/note]] How Michal must regret that she saved him, that time many years ago...



** Poor, poor Tamar. Her half-brother Amnon rapes her and David does nothing to punish him. Her brother Absalom is the only one to care about her, and even he tells her to be quiet about the rape.

to:

** Poor, poor Tamar. Her half-brother Amnon rapes her and David does nothing to punish him. Her brother Absalom is the only one to care about her, her and even he tells her to be quiet about the rape.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The theory that the two women named Ahinoam, one of them Saul's wife (and the mother of Jonathan and Michal) and one of them David's wife (and the mother of Amnon), were actually the same person, and that the angry Saul was serious when he called Jonathan a "son of a perverse and rebellious woman" because David had eloped with his own mother-in-law offscreen.

Added: 516

Changed: 347

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ValuesDissonance: Basically, Saul lost his divine support after disobeying divine orders by being [[PunishedForSympathy insufficiently thorough committing a genocide]] in which every man, woman, child and animal of the nation of Amalek was to be exterminated. In fact God himself say he ''repents'' choosing Saul for not killing enough in his ordered FinalSolution.

to:

* ValuesDissonance: ValuesDissonance:
**
Basically, Saul lost his divine support after disobeying divine orders by being [[PunishedForSympathy insufficiently thorough committing a genocide]] in which every man, woman, child and animal of the nation of Amalek was to be exterminated. In fact God himself say he ''repents'' choosing Saul for not killing enough in his ordered FinalSolution.FinalSolution.
** Later, tens of thousands of people die in a plague because David took a census. When God ''gave him the idea in the first place'' (Chronicles retcons it to Satan).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RonTheDeathEater: The later notion that Uriah deserved to die because calling Joab his superior was an act of lèse-majesté/he committed treason by disobeying David's order to go home. Oh, and David didn't ''really'' commit adultery because his wife was conditionally divorced at the time, so he would've had nothing to be mad about! According to these people, Nathan castigated David over ''procedural errors.''

to:

* RonTheDeathEater: The later notion that Uriah deserved to die because calling Joab his superior was an act of lèse-majesté/he committed treason by disobeying David's order to go home. Oh, and David didn't ''really'' commit adultery because his wife was Bathsheba and Uriah were conditionally divorced at the time, so he would've had nothing to be mad about! According to these people, Nathan castigated David over ''procedural errors.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RonTheDeathEater: The later notion that Uriah deserved to die because calling Joab his superior was an act of lèse-majesté/he committed treason by disobeying David's order to go home.

to:

* RonTheDeathEater: The later notion that Uriah deserved to die because calling Joab his superior was an act of lèse-majesté/he committed treason by disobeying David's order to go home. Oh, and David didn't ''really'' commit adultery because his wife was conditionally divorced at the time, so he would've had nothing to be mad about! According to these people, Nathan castigated David over ''procedural errors.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RonTheDeathEater: The later notion that Uriah deserved to die because calling Joab his superior was an act of lèse-majesté/he committed treason by disobeying David's order to go home.


Added DiffLines:

** Similarly, Saul's former concubine Rizpah. At the same time David has Merab's sons sent off to die at the hands of the Gibeonites, he also hands over Rizpah's two sons by Saul. Rizpah sits with the bodies for months, keeping the scavengers away, until David finally has them buried. And given the talk elsewhere about David being given Saul's women for his own, she's probably stuck married to him, like Michal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Michal, Saul's daughter, because David is such an incredible jerk to her. Early in the story, she loves him and marries him, and saves his life from her own father when he wants to have David killed, risking her own in the process. Then, David runs away and never even tries to contact her for years, and marries other women instead. All right. Michal is then married to another man, and is apparently happy with him -- but then David (who is now the king) suddenly wants her back again and has her dragged away from her new family, with her husband following her along the way [[TearJerker crying for her]] as she is taken away. ''Then'' David publicly humiliates Michal by saying he really prefers slave girls to her, and boasts that he is now king instead of her father and brothers (who were killed in the meantime), and there's nothing she can do about it--"And I will yet be more vile than thus." And he is, because, as one final atrocity against her, [[WouldHurtAChild he has Michal's five sons from her second marriage murdered and left to rot]].[[note]]They are possibly stepsons, but does that make it much better?[[/note]] How Michal must regret that she saved him, that time many years ago...

to:

** Michal, Saul's daughter, because David is such an incredible jerk to her. Early in the story, she loves him and marries him, and saves his life from her own father when he wants to have David killed, risking her own in the process. Then, David runs away and never even tries to contact her for years, and marries other women instead. All right. Michal is then married to another man, and is apparently happy with him -- but then David (who is now the king) suddenly wants her back again and has her dragged away from her new family, with her husband following her along the way [[TearJerker crying for her]] as she is taken away. ''Then'' David publicly humiliates Michal by saying he really prefers slave girls to her, and boasts that he is now king instead of her father and brothers (who were killed in the meantime), and there's nothing she can do about it--"And I will yet be more vile than thus." And he is, because, as one final atrocity against her, [[WouldHurtAChild he has Michal's her sister's five sons from her second marriage murdered and left to rot]].[[note]]They [[note]]In some manuscripts, they was Michal's sons, but some translations have written it as her sister Merab's upon checking discrepancies. One interpretation is that they are possibly stepsons, stepsons or adopted by Michal, but does that make it much better?[[/note]] How Michal must regret that she saved him, that time many years ago...

Top