History YMMV / Arcadia

7th Jan '15 1:09:20 PM SolipSchism
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Cutting the panther example because the logic is essentially "Calling anything a panther is incorrect because 'panther' is not a species", which doesn't make sense. This example is only correct if the work actually claims that "panther" is a species. Commenting out the adder/viper example as a ZCE. Please explain how they are "treated like two different things" before uncommenting it.
* CriticalResearchFailure: Alessandro's big cat form is called a "panther". Panthers are not a separate species, though, but a name for black jaguars and leopards. He also purrs, which is something big cats are uncapable of. Could be justified by saying that the big cat forms of the Carnevares don't correspond to real species of animals 100%. The Alcantaras' snake forms are described as having heads the size of a crocodile's, so this is pretty likely. ** Adders and vipers are treated like two different things when they aren't.
to:
* %% ZeroContextExample entries are not allowed on wiki pages. All such entries have been commented out. Add context to the entries before uncommenting them. %%* CriticalResearchFailure: Alessandro's big cat form is called a "panther". Panthers are not a separate species, though, but a name for black jaguars and leopards. He also purrs, which is something big cats are uncapable of. Could be justified by saying that the big cat forms of the Carnevares don't correspond to real species of animals 100%. The Alcantaras' snake forms are described as having heads the size of a crocodile's, so this is pretty likely. ** Adders and vipers are treated like two different things when they aren't.
7th Jan '15 11:49:20 AM Morgenthaler
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Per ATT, these were deemed to be invalid links for UI criteria.
** Adders and vipers are treated like two different things when they aren't. * UnfortunateImplications: [[spoiler:The only two lesbian characters]] are the only ones in the entire book who smoke pot. there are plenty of stereotypes branding [[spoiler:[[http://addictions.about.com/od/howaddictionhappens/fl/The-Gay-Drug-Use-Stereotype.htm gay people as drug abusers]]]] and these two are portrayed as silly and light-headed for doing so. This may come off as [[spoiler:[[http://glrl.org.au/index.php/Rights/Workplace/Harassment-and-Discrimination discrimination against homoexuals]]]]. ** Not in the books itself, but regarding the cover: Of course, covers don't necessarily represent the protagonist, but who thought it was a good idea for a book about a [[spoiler:rape victim to sport [[http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1309184055l/11595072.jpg a cover depicting]] a naked young woman with covered eyes [[http://omgrey.wordpress.com/2013/05/01/ptsd-dissociation-depersonalization/ (when dissociation and depersonalisation are very real problems of rape victims)]] getting strangled by a [[FreudWasRight snake]], a very obvious [[http://www.snakedreams.org/freud.html phallic symbol]], just to look cool]]? ** Judging by what Stefania did, it is better to [[spoiler:shoot oneself than to go into therapy, when [[http://www.guidetopsychology.com/fear.htm fear of psychotherapy is not healthy behaviour, but indeed another psychohygienic problem]].]]
to:
** Adders and vipers are treated like two different things when they aren't. * UnfortunateImplications: [[spoiler:The only two lesbian characters]] are the only ones in the entire book who smoke pot. there are plenty of stereotypes branding [[spoiler:[[http://addictions.about.com/od/howaddictionhappens/fl/The-Gay-Drug-Use-Stereotype.htm gay people as drug abusers]]]] and these two are portrayed as silly and light-headed for doing so. This may come off as [[spoiler:[[http://glrl.org.au/index.php/Rights/Workplace/Harassment-and-Discrimination discrimination against homoexuals]]]]. ** Not in the books itself, but regarding the cover: Of course, covers don't necessarily represent the protagonist, but who thought it was a good idea for a book about a [[spoiler:rape victim to sport [[http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1309184055l/11595072.jpg a cover depicting]] a naked young woman with covered eyes [[http://omgrey.wordpress.com/2013/05/01/ptsd-dissociation-depersonalization/ (when dissociation and depersonalisation are very real problems of rape victims)]] getting strangled by a [[FreudWasRight snake]], a very obvious [[http://www.snakedreams.org/freud.html phallic symbol]], just to look cool]]? ** Judging by what Stefania did, it is better to [[spoiler:shoot oneself than to go into therapy, when [[http://www.guidetopsychology.com/fear.htm fear of psychotherapy is not healthy behaviour, but indeed another psychohygienic problem]].]]aren't.
28th Dec '14 12:02:29 AM AntiqueGarden
Is there an issue? Send a Message
** Adders and vipers are treated like two different things when they aren't.
to:
** Adders and vipers are treated like two different things when they aren't.aren't. * UnfortunateImplications: [[spoiler:The only two lesbian characters]] are the only ones in the entire book who smoke pot. there are plenty of stereotypes branding [[spoiler:[[http://addictions.about.com/od/howaddictionhappens/fl/The-Gay-Drug-Use-Stereotype.htm gay people as drug abusers]]]] and these two are portrayed as silly and light-headed for doing so. This may come off as [[spoiler:[[http://glrl.org.au/index.php/Rights/Workplace/Harassment-and-Discrimination discrimination against homoexuals]]]]. ** Not in the books itself, but regarding the cover: Of course, covers don't necessarily represent the protagonist, but who thought it was a good idea for a book about a [[spoiler:rape victim to sport [[http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1309184055l/11595072.jpg a cover depicting]] a naked young woman with covered eyes [[http://omgrey.wordpress.com/2013/05/01/ptsd-dissociation-depersonalization/ (when dissociation and depersonalisation are very real problems of rape victims)]] getting strangled by a [[FreudWasRight snake]], a very obvious [[http://www.snakedreams.org/freud.html phallic symbol]], just to look cool]]? ** Judging by what Stefania did, it is better to [[spoiler:shoot oneself than to go into therapy, when [[http://www.guidetopsychology.com/fear.htm fear of psychotherapy is not healthy behaviour, but indeed another psychohygienic problem]].]]
21st Dec '14 3:01:57 AM Morgenthaler
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Unfortunate Implications require citations from secondary sources.
** Adders and vipers are treated like two different things when they aren't. * UnfortunateImplications: [[spoiler:The only two lesbian characters]] are the only ones in the entire book who smoke pot. ** Not in the books itself, but regarding the cover: Of course, covers don't necessarily represent the protagonist, but who thought it was a good idea for a book about a [[spoiler:rape victim to sport [[http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1309184055l/11595072.jpg a cover depicting]] a naked young woman with covered eyes getting strangled by a [[FreudWasRight snake]]]]? ** Judging by what Stefania did, it is better to [[spoiler:shoot oneself than to go into therapy.]]
to:
** Adders and vipers are treated like two different things when they aren't. * UnfortunateImplications: [[spoiler:The only two lesbian characters]] are the only ones in the entire book who smoke pot. ** Not in the books itself, but regarding the cover: Of course, covers don't necessarily represent the protagonist, but who thought it was a good idea for a book about a [[spoiler:rape victim to sport [[http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1309184055l/11595072.jpg a cover depicting]] a naked young woman with covered eyes getting strangled by a [[FreudWasRight snake]]]]? ** Judging by what Stefania did, it is better to [[spoiler:shoot oneself than to go into therapy.]]aren't.
25th Aug '14 11:09:17 AM AntiqueGarden
Is there an issue? Send a Message
** Not in the books itself, but regarding the cover: Of course, covers don't necessarily represent the protagonist, but who thought it was a good idead for a book about a [[spoiler:rape victim to sport [[http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1309184055l/11595072.jpg a cover depicting]] a naked young woman with covered eyes getting strangled by a [[FreudWasRight snake]]]]?
to:
** Not in the books itself, but regarding the cover: Of course, covers don't necessarily represent the protagonist, but who thought it was a good idead idea for a book about a [[spoiler:rape victim to sport [[http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1309184055l/11595072.jpg a cover depicting]] a naked young woman with covered eyes getting strangled by a [[FreudWasRight snake]]]]?
28th Jun '14 1:58:39 AM AntiqueGarden
Is there an issue? Send a Message
** Adders and vipers are treated like two different things when they aren't.

** Not in the books itself, but regarding the cover: Of course, covers don't necessarily represent the protagonist, but who thought it was a good idead for a book about a [[spoiler:rape victim to sport [[http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1309184055l/11595072.jpg a cover depicting]] a naked young woman with covered eyes getting strangled by a [[FreudWasRight snake]]]]?
to:
** Not in the books itself, but regarding the cover: Of course, covers don't necessarily represent the protagonist, but who thought it was a good idead for a book about a [[spoiler:rape victim to sport [[http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1309184055l/11595072.jpg a cover depicting]] a naked young woman with covered eyes getting strangled by a [[FreudWasRight snake]]]]?snake]]]]? ** Judging by what Stefania did, it is better to [[spoiler:shoot oneself than to go into therapy.]]
11th Jun '14 7:43:44 AM AntiqueGarden
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Added DiffLines:
* CriticalResearchFailure: Alessandro's big cat form is called a "panther". Panthers are not a separate species, though, but a name for black jaguars and leopards. He also purrs, which is something big cats are uncapable of. Could be justified by saying that the big cat forms of the Carnevares don't correspond to real species of animals 100%. The Alcantaras' snake forms are described as having heads the size of a crocodile's, so this is pretty likely.
11th Jun '14 7:40:21 AM AntiqueGarden
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Added DiffLines:
* UnfortunateImplications: [[spoiler:The only two lesbian characters]] are the only ones in the entire book who smoke pot. ** Not in the books itself, but regarding the cover: Of course, covers don't necessarily represent the protagonist, but who thought it was a good idead for a book about a [[spoiler:rape victim to sport [[http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1309184055l/11595072.jpg a cover depicting]] a naked young woman with covered eyes getting strangled by a [[FreudWasRight snake]]]]?
This list shows the last 8 events of 8. Show all.