Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / PuellaMagiMadokaMagica2

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Or a pre-op FtM transexual could've met with an incubator. His contract wish was to get the right body.

to:

* Or a pre-op FtM [=FtM=] transexual could've met with an incubator. His contract wish was to get the right body.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
red link fixing


In episode 9 Kyubey states that there are some things about magical girls that even his creators can't explain. Then, in episode 12, he states that he has no idea why Soul Gems disappear when they're used up. My theory is that at first magical girl powers were completely explainable, and somehow the rules were even worse than they are now. But then a powerful magical girl made a wish to change the rules and managed to move the SlidingScaleOfIdealismAndCynicism just ''slightly'' more towards idealism. She, like Madoka, AscendedToAHigherPlaneOfExistence, resulting in Kyubey forgetting both her and the wish. This could have happened multiple times, with each girl adding a new wrinkle to the rules that Kyubey can't explain.

to:

In episode 9 Kyubey states that there are some things about magical girls that even his creators can't explain. Then, in episode 12, he states that he has no idea why Soul Gems disappear when they're used up. My theory is that at first magical girl powers were completely explainable, and somehow the rules were even worse than they are now. But then a powerful magical girl made a wish to change the rules and managed to move the SlidingScaleOfIdealismAndCynicism SlidingScaleOfIdealismVsCynicism just ''slightly'' more towards idealism. She, like Madoka, AscendedToAHigherPlaneOfExistence, resulting in Kyubey forgetting both her and the wish. This could have happened multiple times, with each girl adding a new wrinkle to the rules that Kyubey can't explain.



* (From the messageboards) UsefulNotes/AmeliaEarhart manifested herself as the UsefulNotes/BermudaTriangle (or one of several other "vortex zones" throughout the world). The crew of the ''[[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MV_Joyita MV Joyita]]'' may have fallen into one of them (especially since Amelia disappeared in the Pacific, not the Atlantic). In keeping with GratuitousGerman ThemeNaming of the Witches, let's call her form "Ehrhardt".

to:

* (From the messageboards) UsefulNotes/AmeliaEarhart manifested herself as the UsefulNotes/BermudaTriangle BermudaTriangle (or one of several other "vortex zones" throughout the world). The crew of the ''[[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MV_Joyita MV Joyita]]'' may have fallen into one of them (especially since Amelia disappeared in the Pacific, not the Atlantic). In keeping with GratuitousGerman ThemeNaming of the Witches, let's call her form "Ehrhardt".



* Music/JanisJoplin murdered Music/JimiHendrix (who was 27 at the time) in a fit of despair in her last month of life, much like Sayaka possibly murdered those two misogynists on the train. After becoming a Witch herself (at age 27), she began the 27-year curse which of course later took [[Music/TheDoors Jim Morrison]] (who was a possible one-night stand lover of hers) and later Music/KurtCobain]] and Music/AmyWinehouse.

to:

* Music/JanisJoplin murdered Music/JimiHendrix (who was 27 at the time) in a fit of despair in her last month of life, much like Sayaka possibly murdered those two misogynists on the train. After becoming a Witch herself (at age 27), she began the 27-year curse which of course later took [[Music/TheDoors Jim Morrison]] (who was a possible one-night stand lover of hers) and later Music/KurtCobain]] Music/KurtCobain and Music/AmyWinehouse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Disambiguating Fullmetal Alchemist


* [[spoiler:Adolf Hitler]] probably is one of said Puer Magi, who lived through and created a major influence of mass despair and misery in history ([[Anime/FullmetalAlchemist enough to power another Alternate Universe]]) and "died" (I mean witched out) on the day of [[spoiler:Walpurgisnacht (fitting because Hitler viewed his life as a bombastic Wagnerian theatre,]] and Walpurgisnacht represents reality turning into theatrics). This is the reason for [[spoiler:HitlersTimeTravelExemptionAct because Hitler[=/=]Walpurgisnacht will accumulate ever more power from Homura, The Doctor and other countless time travel assassins that plan to kill him]].

to:

* [[spoiler:Adolf Hitler]] probably is one of said Puer Magi, who lived through and created a major influence of mass despair and misery in history ([[Anime/FullmetalAlchemist ([[Anime/FullmetalAlchemist2003 enough to power another Alternate Universe]]) and "died" (I mean witched out) on the day of [[spoiler:Walpurgisnacht (fitting because Hitler viewed his life as a bombastic Wagnerian theatre,]] and Walpurgisnacht represents reality turning into theatrics). This is the reason for [[spoiler:HitlersTimeTravelExemptionAct because Hitler[=/=]Walpurgisnacht will accumulate ever more power from Homura, The Doctor and other countless time travel assassins that plan to kill him]].
Tabs MOD

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Kill Em All was renamed Everybody Dies Ending due to misuse. Dewicking


* Madoka in pain: KillEmAll

to:

* Madoka in pain: KillEmAllpain
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Up To Eleven is a defunct trope


In episode 9 Kyubey states that there are some things about magical girls that even his creators can't explain. Then, in episode 12, he states that he has no idea why Soul Gems disappear when they're used up. My theory is that at first magical girl powers were completely explainable, and somehow the rules were [[UpToEleven even worse than they are now]]. But then a powerful magical girl made a wish to change the rules and managed to move the SlidingScaleOfIdealismAndCynicism just ''slightly'' more towards idealism. She, like Madoka, AscendedToAHigherPlaneOfExistence, resulting in Kyubey forgetting both her and the wish. This could have happened multiple times, with each girl adding a new wrinkle to the rules that Kyubey can't explain.

to:

In episode 9 Kyubey states that there are some things about magical girls that even his creators can't explain. Then, in episode 12, he states that he has no idea why Soul Gems disappear when they're used up. My theory is that at first magical girl powers were completely explainable, and somehow the rules were [[UpToEleven even worse than they are now]].now. But then a powerful magical girl made a wish to change the rules and managed to move the SlidingScaleOfIdealismAndCynicism just ''slightly'' more towards idealism. She, like Madoka, AscendedToAHigherPlaneOfExistence, resulting in Kyubey forgetting both her and the wish. This could have happened multiple times, with each girl adding a new wrinkle to the rules that Kyubey can't explain.



It exists and infests outside of known reality, ''[[UpToEleven is even more alien than the Incubators themselves, infinitely worse than our limited scientific conception of entropy]]'', [[SpacetimeEater and is eating]] [[ApocalypseHow Reality alive]]. Its [[YouCannotGraspTheTrueForm true form is completely]] Inconceivable, and the Incubators can only describe it vaguely to us laypersons by paralleling with the scientific concept of entropy we learned from ordinary middle school Science (hence why they refer to it as Entropy. The abomination's presence accelerates the decomposition process of Reality, there this Abomination is basically Entropy, as expected with the Incubators who are pathological users of MetaphoricallyTrue).

to:

It exists and infests outside of known reality, ''[[UpToEleven is ''is even more alien than the Incubators themselves, infinitely worse than our limited scientific conception of entropy]]'', entropy'', [[SpacetimeEater and is eating]] [[ApocalypseHow Reality alive]]. Its [[YouCannotGraspTheTrueForm true form is completely]] Inconceivable, and the Incubators can only describe it vaguely to us laypersons by paralleling with the scientific concept of entropy we learned from ordinary middle school Science (hence why they refer to it as Entropy. The abomination's presence accelerates the decomposition process of Reality, there this Abomination is basically Entropy, as expected with the Incubators who are pathological users of MetaphoricallyTrue).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG:Incubators are AI running on the same tech as the Magical Girls.]]
(I need to preface this by saying I know WordOfGod regarding how Kyubey's powers work [[DeathOfTheAuthor and I don't care]].)

Something that often comes up in robot stories is the idea of the robot body being like [[ComputerEqualsMonitor a computer monitor]] with the actual brain elsewhere. If you've played ''VisualNovel/VirtuesLastReward'' you know what I'm talking about. At some point I wondered if this is how Kyubey came back in a new body (he can make extras) and [[SpotTheThread everything else just fell into place]]. Lack of emotion, difficulty understanding others and unwillingness to learn, single-minded focus on a single task, and most importantly, CreativeSterility. His race has been gathering energy using the same methods for what is implied to be eons and it gets rendered obsolete by a pair of random high-school girls. This also suggests his claim that without his race humans would be "living naked in caves" isn't true; he ''thinks'' it is because he or his race are projecting their own lack of innovation.

Since having your consciousness outside your body is exactly how Soul Gems work, it's possible the Incubators and Magical Girls operate the same way but the Incubators get better tech with a far longer range. [[FridgeHorror This also implies]] Kyubey has access to technology that could have prevented at least one death but chose not to use it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

**** Israel gaining independence had always been a theme in the Bible, the Roman Empire was just one of the latest to subjugate it. The Book of Revelation was anti-Roman propaganda work that compared Rome (the seven-headed beast) with Babylon, and even the number "666" for the Antichrist was after the gematria interpretation of the name ''Nero Caesar''. One of the reasons why Jesus appealed to believers before is that he, as the promised Messiah, was to lead Israel to independence, that the Jewish faith shall dominate the world, not just for Jews but for Gentiles as well. But turned out He was too much of a pacifist, while the Pharisees were in league with the Roman government. Thus he was betrayed, crucified, and ultimately witched out. Still, like Jesus wished, Judaism did dominate the world... it's called Christianity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG:Kyubey is the same Incubator that contracted [[Manga/PuellaMagiTartMagica Joan of Arc]]]]
He ''does'' shows hints of emotions... And if they were the result of recovering from that harrowing experience, it would explain them: he was a "mentally ill" Incubator and is now recovering.

Changed: 576

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Improbable, for the simple reason that the Romans ''weren't'' oppressing the Jews, not during Jesus' lifetime: Mark Anthony had demanded excessive taxes from the Judaean protectorate but that ended after Augustus defeated him, and while the Romans started taxing directly once Judaea became a province they were careful to not cause oppression and get the province in full rebellion, even removing Pilate for being too heavy handed in suppressing a Samaritan revolt (Roman attitude was usually "So what?")

to:

*** Improbable, for the simple reason that the Romans ''weren't'' oppressing the Jews, not during Jesus' lifetime: Mark Anthony had demanded excessive taxes from the Judaean protectorate but that ended after Augustus defeated him, and while the Romans started taxing directly once Judaea became a province they were careful to not cause oppression and get the province in full rebellion, even removing Pilate for being too heavy handed in suppressing a Samaritan revolt (Roman attitude was usually "So what?")
what?"). While the tax collectors often demanded more money than they were supposed to (hence the Bible repeatedly referring to them as the lowest of the low), during Jesus' lifetime independentists were seen as misguided ''at best'', with breaks between Jews and Romans only starting when Caligula tried to have his statue placed in the Temple (something the Roman legate opposed fearing a revolt), and Roman oppression started only when Nero installed the oppressive Gessius Florus as procurator of Judaea and refused to remove him (directly leading to the First Jewish–Roman War).

Top