History WMG / Primer

[[Tropers/IuraCivium My]] father came up with this. Aaron is shown in the film as being selfish and willing to do anything to get ahead—he even cheats at Scrabble. He doesn't want so much to actually save Rachel as he does to look the hero in order to impress Granger and get some [=VC=] funds from him.

Both require N amount of "personal time" spent inside in order to travel N amount of time into the past/future, suggestion a sort of Law of Conservation of Time Progression.

This has been kind of/sort of confirmed. CloneDegeneration does effect Abe and Aaron according to the WordOfGod. But it could be assumed that their souls or consciousness was transferred to the new body. At least that's perhaps what Abe and Aaron are telling themselves. What might really be happening is that when Abe and Aaron have those moments in the box when they feel content or start to have visions, that's when their original selves are dying and their dopplegangers are spontaneously coming into being. If an afterlife exists in the movie's universe, then the final versions of Abe and Aaron (when they finally die) will find themselves sharing it with dozens of "clones", some of whom were only alive for a few hours or days.

This has been kind of/sort of confirmed. CloneDegeneration does effect Abe and Aaron according to the WordOfGod. But it could be assumed that their souls or consciousness was transferred to the new body. At least that's perhaps what Abe and Aaron are telling themselves. What might really be happening is that when Abe and Aaron have those moments in the box when they feel content or start to have visions, that's when their original selves are dying and their dopplegangers are spontaneously coming into being. If an afterlife exists in the movie's universe, then the versions of Abe and Aaron (when they finally die) will find themselves sharing it with dozens of "clones", some of whom were only alive for a few hours or days.

This has been kind of/sort of confirmed. CloneDegeneration does effect Abe and Aaron according to the WordOfGod. But it could be assumed that their souls or consciousness was transferred to the new body. At least that's perhaps what Abe and Aaron are telling themselves. What might really be happening is that when Abe and Aaron have those moments in the box when they feel content or start to have visions, that's when their original selves are dying and their dopplegangers are spontaneously coming into being. If an afterlife exists in the universe, then the versions of Abe and Aaron (when they finally die) will find themselves sharing it with dozens of "clones", some of whom were only alive for a few hours or days.

!! Aaron's motivation for intervening at the party is to get money from Granger.

* [[Tropers/IuraCivium My]] father came up with this. Aaron is shown in the film as being selfish and willing to do anything to get ahead—he even cheats at Scrabble. He doesn't want so much to actually save Rachel as he does to look the hero in order to impress Granger and get some [=VC=] funds from him.

!! The last scene of the movie appears to be an Aaron directing the construction of a warehouse-sized Box. What for???

* [[Tropers/IuraCivium My]] father came up with this. Aaron is shown in the film as being selfish and willing to do anything to get ahead—he even cheats at Scrabble. He doesn't want so much to actually save Rachel as he does to look the hero in order to impress Granger and get some [=VC=] funds from him.

* [[{{Tropers}}/IuraCivium My]] father came up with this. Aaron is shown in the film as being selfish and willing to do anything to get ahead—he even cheats at Scrabble. He doesn't want so much to actually save Rachel as he does to look the hero in order to impress Granger and get some [=VC=] funds from him.

* My father came up with this. Aaron is shown in the film as being selfish and willing to do anything to get ahead—he even cheats at Scrabble. He doesn't want so much to actually save Rachel as he does to look the hero in order to impress Granger and get some [=VC=] funds from him.

* FridgeLogic: So, when you go back in time.. does the previous timeline keep going, making it semi-pointless, or... do six billion people die?
** Keep going, objective collapse(one world) QM and time travel don't mix, ergo you must be using Many world QM. It's not semi-pointless though, it still affects your perception down that probability pathway.
** This troper thought the movie took the Cloverfield path on that issue. Any of the above could be true, or could be false. Either way, it's not like the protagonists would know. Part of the reason [[spoiler: they stop using the time machine is because they could be seriously messing up the world, or themselves and wouldn't even know.]]
** The time-box reset mechanism guarantees that the return time always advances on every box (the best someone can do on exiting the box is to turn it off immediately and set a timer to turn it back on, so those minutes are lost forever). Therefore [[spoiler:Abe should not be fooled for a second when he uses his fail-safe -- he could see by a glance at the running timer that Aaron had used it before him]].
*** This may actually be FridgeBrilliance instead. [[spoiler: It shows that the mechanism for "recycling" a box is not by switching it off and on, but by using the same setting and getting out "early" (which means exiting after the other person has left). Abe didn't notice a timer change, or he would have sought out and confronted Aaron instead of going back. The amount of oxygen he took (three tanks of 625 liters each) is consistent with the given breathing rate (.3 liters/minute) and the time shown on the fail-safe box (3 days, 22 hours, 8 minutes), so he will use 2.7 tanks worth of air. If he expected a substantially longer travel time, he would have brought four tanks of air. An engineer would safe-side something as important as air to breathe).]]
*** Told you it was a geeky movie...
** Near the beginning of the movie, Abe sets up a closed time loop where he comes out of the time machine from the old timeline, then the Abe from the present timeline goes in. Most of the movie takes place after this, which means it isn't ending the Universe.
** The process of getting into (or out of) the box doesn't make sense. Suppose you're about to get into the box. That means there's another "you" already in the box, going backwards. So someone outside watching should see the two of you combine and annihilate. Instead, we see a ''single'' person crawling into an ''empty'' box.
*** That's what the timers were for!
*** Presumably the field "leaks" in such cases, preserving local causality.
*** It's similar to the classic Schrödinger's cat thought experiment. Whoever is currently in the box is in a state of quantum uncertainty while they are completely separated from the external environment. i.e. they may or may not actually exist at any given point in time to an external viewer. When they again interact with the external world outside of the box, their quantum state collapses because they are now a viewer of their own state as part of the external environment. The way the machines work don't allow their quantum state to collapse from an external perspective into a stable state except at either end of a cycle which is why an external viewer wouldn't see anything inside a box in action. Since everything in QM is based on probability of particle interactions, whatever mechanism causes the boxes to work gives what's inside the box a zero probability of quantum collapse to a viewer outside the internal quantum state. Getting out of the box early (forcing an interaction with the external environment) or having two entangled quantum states at once inside the box (i.e. Granger) leaves the field in an uncertain state for the external viewer as well. Abe collapsed near Granger because they were both in a prolonged state of quantum uncertainty/out of phase quantum state to the rest of the universe - it still wasn't sure whether they existed or not.
**** No, sorry, it isn't anything like Schrodinger's Cat. Like the man said, that's what the timers are for. You get in the box, and the timer turns on. The timer turns (on/off) in the past and you get out. And earlier someone (probably you) set the timer. You aren't getting in while the field is active and presumably you aren't getting out while it is either. And what makes you think either that someone could be in 'a prolonged state of quantum uncertainty' (when uncertainty is resolved by observation) or that being so would make one have earbleeds?
**** When you get in, the field must still be partly active, otherwise you'd miss the boat and just end up sitting in a box moving forward through time (the machine isn't going to turn itself on; you get in while it's turning off). So at some point you get time-reversed; probably not all at once, because you're not a single particle. For several hours ''before'' whenever some part of you got reversed, that part of you is in the box...and, when it first enters, from its point of view that same part of you is trying to leave the box (it sees itself getting into the box, in reverse). Even if your whole self somehow got reversed all at once, you have to deal with the fact that you're entering (from the outside) and leaving (from your POV) the box in the same period of time; either you get [[BodyHorror duplicated right then and there]], or you end up [[NightmareFuel entering and leaving the box forever]], or, if you're lucky, the box just spits you back out and finishes turning off. Getting out of the box after time-travelling has similar issues. I don't see a way around these problems, besides teleporting in/out of the box, which they didn't do.
** Okay. I may be wrong but this is the best interpretation I can come up with. According to Einstein's theory of special relativity the space-time continuum exists as 4 ''base'' dimensional axes where movement across any given axis for any given variable determines velocity, acceleration etc. Hence although the continuum is basically (basically, people!) invariable, ''movement'' across the dimensional axes is relative. Hence movement through the continuum is relative for any given object (or sentient entity, as the case might be). So, when, for example, Aaron initiates the first temporal paradox that impacts upon his original timeline, he is not in fact changing anything relative to him, and for the ''other'' him at the same time frame nothing is changed either. You simply have multiple different movements through time-space which are congruent with a determined iteration. Now, if you ascribe to the theory that a temporal paradox can't exist (due to negation of the original timeline), I postulate the theory that if individual A2 impacts the timeline of him/herself as individual A1 (where A1 must become A2 at some undetermined point in time) that results in the deviation of A1 from the path of becoming A2, then A2 would not exist, and, as per the premise, A1 would become variant individual A3 instead. HOWEVER, if A2 does not now exist (as A1 becomes A3 instead of A2), then A2 could not have influenced the original timeline in order for A1 to become A3, and hence A1 would have become A2 instead. The result? You have a projected outcome where both A2 and A3 must exist as per a stable time-loop. Hence you could technically have an infinite number of the same individual A existing in the same time-space continuum simply at different points on the axes (i.e. different co-ordinates in 4-D space-time). The limitation of course is the individual. So each time Abe and Aaron use the boxes they are simply reinforcing a different iteration of the time-line which exists concurrently with the original timeline with both existing in the same space-time continuum. However, it's fair to say that with each congruent iteration and each new paradox, each movement is relative according to the individual. Hence, if we assume that the Aaron narrating is the original, then we can assume that he has observed the entire result of his selves' iterations. Kinda sets it self up as FridgeBrilliance if you think of it that way, "the past is always the future for someone." Anyway, that's what I got.... feel free to correct me if I'm wrong....
*** Oh, and just to add on that thing with the timers; relative passage of time per iteration where movement is determined by position in time, not space, as position in space is (relative to the earth) the same. Hence, movement in time is the determinant of movement within 4-D continuum.
**** Another note: I mentioned Einstein's theory of special relativity to maintain the local impact. No way in hell am I gonna try to rationalise it with the general theory.
***** Please try. You'll be watching porn anyway in the next tab.
****** .... -/-........ still not gonna! * sulk*
*** The way you explain it (or the way I understand what you're trying to explain) is the same idea as the mechanism used in Creator/RobertAHeinlein's "Literature/TheNumberOfTheBeast" for moving between universes. They invent a [[AppliedPhlebotinum widget]] that allows them to shift any of the four axes with each other. Shift the X axis with the T axis and move around in time by physically moving back and forth. Starting getting more complex and move forward along X, up along T, over along Y and back down X and you're not just somewhere and somewhere else, but in a different universe entirely. (The problem with this in reality is that there is no "T axis." It was just a metaphor Einstein used to describe how time can be thought of as another measurable property of the universe.)
**** Unfortunately, we have to presume that our current hypothetical model of the universe is correct until either pure or applied maths and physics advance to come up with something new to explain the current phenomena better. Let's face it, we're all making up hypothesis to fit how we view the universe, that currently works. Until something comes up to disprove it, we have to go with what we've got (which is really stuff someone else made up to explain what they saw, or discovered, or observed, about reality). Two thousand years ago, humans saw the earth as flat because according to immediate visual perception, it was. However, that hypothesis was proved wrong, because we found out the earth is spherical. Whose to say our current model won't be as equally absurd to humans in another two millennia? According to M-theory the universe apparently has 11 dimensions. However, we can only account for 3 in physical space, because all dimensions must be at right angles to each other and our limited senses can only detect length, depth and height. We hypothesize that time must exist because to us memories exist of previous moments. However, we cannot actually verify those memories from an in-universe perspective. Time may or may not exist. So the hypothesis that time is a measurable variable may or may not be valid. However if it is measurable, then we are moving through it at an alternate dimension to those physically observable to us. If Time is a changing variable, an axis on which it travels must exist. Hence according to the objective reality that humans apparently share, there must be a fourth dimension. Exactly where it fits into an extrapolated exponent dimension model is something I can't comment on. Mostly 'cause I'm really not caught up on the math... The more lack of proof there is, or the more countering proof there is, the more unlikely a hypothesis becomes, but you can't really provide a negative proof. No one's seen little blue aliens from andromeda but that doesn't mean they don't exist. Time ''seems'' to be measurable currently, and they're aren't really that many contraindications, so I'm sticking with the "4 basic dimensions" theory. Okay, I went on a bit of a ramble there (I have a terrible tendency to do that). My point was... oh right: reality may or may not be real, but according to what we subjectively know/understand/think to be real, time as another dimension is the most likely hypothesis. That said, insanity is pretty much by definition a perception of reality deviating from an objective consensus, so if you walk up to a psychiatrist and say that there are little blue aliens from Andromeda and that their tinkering in world affairs is most likely going to bring about World War Three, they may give you a shot of thorazine and stick you in a padded cell. So let's all just pretend they're not listening in, ok?
** Shouldn't this be a JustBugsMe page?
*** Probably... With this film they both kinda roll into one complicated page-thing. Shh. Don't tell anyone.
*** The two pages are [[CollectiveGroan in a state of quantum superposition]].

*** The way you explain it (or the way I understand what you're trying to explain) is the same idea as the mechanism used in RobertHeinlein's "Numer of the Beast" for moving between universes. They invent a [[AppliedPhlebotinum widget]] that allows them to shift any of the four axes with each other. Shift the X axis with the T axis and move around in time by physically moving back and forth. Starting getting more complex and move forward along X, up along T, over along Y and back down X and you're not just somewhere and somewhere else, but in a different universe entirely. (The problem with this in reality is that there is no "T axis." It was just a metaphor Einstein used to describe how time can be thought of as another measurable property of the universe.)

*** Probably... With this film they both kinda roll into one complicated page-thing. Shh. Don't tell anyone.

*** It's similar to the classic Schrödinger's cat thought experiment. Whoever is currently in the box is in a state of quantum uncertainty while they are completely separated from the external environment. i.e. they may or may not actually exist at any given point in time to an external viewer. When they again interact with the external world outside of the box, their quantum state collapses because they are now a viewer of their own state as part of the external environment. The way the machines work don't allow their quantum state to collapse from an external perspective into a stable state except at either end of a cycle which is why an external viewer wouldn't see anything inside a box in action. Since everything in QM is based on probability of particle interactions, whatever mechanism causes the boxes to work gives what's inside the box a zero probability of quantum collapse to a viewer outside the internal quantum state. Getting out of the box early (forcing an interaction with the external environment) or having two entangled quantum states at once inside the box (i.e. Granger) leaves the field in an uncertain state for the external viewer as well. Abe collapsed near Granger because they were both in a prolonged state of quantum uncertainty/out of phase quantum state to the rest of the universe - it still wasn't sure whether they existed or not.

**** Unfortunately, we have to presume that our current hypothetical model of the universe is correct until either pure or applied maths and physics advance to come up with something new to explain the current phenomena better. Let's face it, we're all making up hypothesis to fit how we view the universe currently works. Until something comes up to disprove it, we have to go with what we've got (which is really stuff someone else made up to explain what they saw, or discovered, or observed, about reality). Two thousand years ago, humans saw the earth as flat because according to immediate visual perception, it was. However, that hypothesis was proved wrong, because we found out the earth is spherical. Whose to say our current model won't be as equally absurd to humans in another two millennia? According to M-theory the universe apparently has 11 dimensions. However, we can only account for 3 in physical space, because all dimensions must be at right angles to each other and our limited senses can only detect length, depth and height. We hypothesize that time must exist because to us memories exist of previous moments. However, we cannot actually verify those memories from an in-universe perspective. Time may or may not exist. So the hypothesis that time is a measurable variable may or may not be valid. However if it is measurable, then we are moving through it at an alternate dimension to those physically observable to us. If Time is a changing variable, an axis on which it travels must exist. Hence according to the objective reality that humans apparently share, there must be a fourth dimension. Exactly where it fits into an extrapolated exponent dimension model is something I can't comment on. Mostly 'cause I'm really not caught up on the math... The more lack of proof there is, or the more countering proof there is, the more unlikely a hypothesis becomes, but you can't really provide a negative proof. No one's seen little blue aliens from andromeda but that doesn't mean they don't exist. Time ''seems'' to be measurable currently, and they're aren't really that many contraindications, so I'm sticking with the "4 basic dimensions" theory. Okay, I went on a bit of a ramble there (I have a terrible tendency to do that). My point was... oh right: reality may or may not be real, but according to what we subjectively know/understand/think to be real, time as another dimension is the most likely hypothesis. That said, insanity is pretty much by definition a perception of reality deviating from an objective consensus, so if you walk up to a psychiatrist and say that there are little blue aliens from Andromeda and that their tinkering in world affairs is most likely going to bring about World War Three, they may give you a shot of thorazine and stick you in a padded cell. So let's all just pretend they're not listening in, ok?

*** Well because it's discussing theories that allow for understanding of the concepts and ideals within the movie, it's more suited to WMG. I mean, it may bug us, but it's still theorizing, not ranting or complaining so much (and hey, I love a good rant as much as the next person!). I mean, it's not a JustBugsMe page if you're trying to explain away localised phenomena within the scope of the movie.

*** This is the same idea as the mechanism used in RobertHeinlein's "Numer of the Beast" for moving between universes. They invent a [[AppliedPhlebotinum widget]] that allows them to shift any of the four axes with each other. Shift the X axis with the T axis and move around in time by moving back and forth. Starting getting more complex and move forward along X, up along T, over along Y and back down X and you're not just somewhere and somewhere else, but in a different universe entirely. (The problem with this in reality is that there is no "T axis." It was just a metaphor Einstein used to describe how time can be thought of as another measurable property of the universe.)

*** It's the classic Schrödinger's cat thought experiment. Whoever is currently in the box is in a state of quantum uncertainty. They may or may not actually exist at any given point in time from an external viewer. It happens that the way the machines work don't allow their quantum state to collapse into a stable state except at either end of a cycle. Getting out of the box early or having two entangled quantum states at once inside the box (i.e. Granger) causes the field to collapse into an uncertain state for the external viewer as well. Abe collapsed near Granger because they were both in a prolonged state of quantum uncertainty where they may or may not actually exist.

*** It's the classic Schrödinger's cat thought experiment. Whoever is currently in the box is in a state of quantum uncertainty. They may or may not actually exist at any given point in time. It happens that the way the machines work don't allow their quantum state to collapse into "Exist" until the box has quit cycling. I would guess that that state only collapses into a stable state at either end of a cycle. Getting out of the box early or having two entangled quantum states at once inside the box (i.e. Granger) causes the field to collapse into an uncertain state for the external viewer as well. Abe collapsed near Granger because they were both in a prolonged state of quantum uncertainty where they may or may not actually exist.

** Shouldn't this be a JustBugsMe page?

****** .... -/-........ still not gonna! *sulk*

***** Please try. You'll be watching porn anyway in the next tab.