Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / MyBravePonyStarfleetMagic

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A modification to my theory: The human and pony who would come to be known as Celesto Grandruler and Grand Ruler Celesto respectively came across something that granted them the ability to warp reality when they were just small boys. However, due to their youths, they were completely unaware that they had acquired said ability, sort of like LightNovel/HaruhiSuzumiya. From that moment on, they would unknowingly shape their worlds as they, mere children, saw it, with one-dimensional people, species that were exclusively good or evil, somewhat different laws of physics, etc. Thus, upon encountering these, they would believe that was the way the worlds are and thus keep them shaped that way, creating a horrid cycle. Because they both, in a way, didn't want to grow up, their reality warping abilities ensured their mentalities stayed pretty much the same as they were when they were kids. As kids naturally think they're special or at least desire to be so, they acquired attributes that made them so thanks to their reality warping, even unwittingly modifying their own memories so that the latter thinks he was born with three golden horns and wings, instead of accidentally giving himself those. It seems that they might have come into contact with each other at one point (although they might not remember or realize this) and the human left an impact on the pony, making him obsessed with humanoid bodies and such. They'll also subconsciously deal with those who they unknowingly deem a threat to their powers, such as [[spoiler:Twilight Sparkle]].

to:

A modification to my theory: The human and pony who would come to be known as Celesto Grandruler and Grand Ruler Celesto respectively came across something that granted them the ability to warp reality when they were just small boys. However, due to their youths, they were completely unaware that they had acquired said ability, sort of like LightNovel/HaruhiSuzumiya.Literature/HaruhiSuzumiya. From that moment on, they would unknowingly shape their worlds as they, mere children, saw it, with one-dimensional people, species that were exclusively good or evil, somewhat different laws of physics, etc. Thus, upon encountering these, they would believe that was the way the worlds are and thus keep them shaped that way, creating a horrid cycle. Because they both, in a way, didn't want to grow up, their reality warping abilities ensured their mentalities stayed pretty much the same as they were when they were kids. As kids naturally think they're special or at least desire to be so, they acquired attributes that made them so thanks to their reality warping, even unwittingly modifying their own memories so that the latter thinks he was born with three golden horns and wings, instead of accidentally giving himself those. It seems that they might have come into contact with each other at one point (although they might not remember or realize this) and the human left an impact on the pony, making him obsessed with humanoid bodies and such. They'll also subconsciously deal with those who they unknowingly deem a threat to their powers, such as [[spoiler:Twilight Sparkle]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG:Barring [[SelfInsert Celesto and Lightning]], [[RhymesOnADime Rhymey]] is the author's [[CreatorsPet favorite character]].]]

to:

[[WMG:Barring [[SelfInsert [[AuthorAvatar Celesto and Lightning]], [[RhymesOnADime Rhymey]] is the author's [[CreatorsPet favorite character]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Applejack will hook up with Buddy Rose, and Mykan will most likely rip off something from WesternAnimation/TeenTitans that involved Beast Boy and Terra, and use some cheesy love songs from one or more Creator/{{Disney}} movies in the process.

to:

** Applejack will hook up with Buddy Rose, and Mykan will most likely rip off something from WesternAnimation/TeenTitans WesternAnimation/TeenTitans2003 that involved Beast Boy and Terra, and use some cheesy love songs from one or more Creator/{{Disney}} movies in the process.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jossed, it's implied it's not even a bad guy.

to:

** Jossed, it's implied it's not even a bad guy. In fact, he is actually [[spoiler:the benevolent Sir Arien.]]
Tabs MOD

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Kill Em All was renamed Everybody Dies Ending due to misuse. Dewicking


* Assuming Celesto wasn't already smart enough to have it invented prior (being a GodModeSue and all), it's entirely possible that... well, [[KillEmAll you know]]. [[EarthShatteringKaboom BOOM!]]

to:

* Assuming Celesto wasn't already smart enough to have it invented prior (being a GodModeSue and all), it's entirely possible that... well, [[KillEmAll you know]].know. [[EarthShatteringKaboom BOOM!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Baleful Polymorph is no longer a trope


Think about it: you end up getting knocked out for what seems like a day, and you wake up to find yourself and your entire species [[BalefulPolymorph mutated]] into something else and your entire planet having [[EarthShatteringKaboom blown up]] and [[ReplacementGoldfish been replaced by a new one]]. That's not even getting into discovering that not only are the heroes of your land praising these ponies who came clear out of nowhere, but their ruler is now married to your own.

to:

Think about it: you end up getting knocked out for what seems like a day, and you wake up to find yourself and your entire species [[BalefulPolymorph [[ForcedTransformation mutated]] into something else and your entire planet having [[EarthShatteringKaboom blown up]] and [[ReplacementGoldfish been replaced by a new one]]. That's not even getting into discovering that not only are the heroes of your land praising these ponies who came clear out of nowhere, but their ruler is now married to your own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
On second thought, this comes off as complaining to me, so I removed it.


Think about it: you end up getting knocked out for what seems like a day, and you wake up to find yourself and your entire species [[BalefulPolymorph mutated]] into something else and your entire planet having [[EarthShatteringKaboom blown up]] and [[ReplacementGoldfish been replaced by a new one]]. That's not even getting into discovering that not only are the heroes of your land praising these ponies who came clear out of nowhere, but their ruler is now married to your own. [[JerkJustifications No wonder Ace Ray's so quick to hate on Starfleet]]! [[DesignatedHero You know, aside from the other obvious reasons.]]

to:

Think about it: you end up getting knocked out for what seems like a day, and you wake up to find yourself and your entire species [[BalefulPolymorph mutated]] into something else and your entire planet having [[EarthShatteringKaboom blown up]] and [[ReplacementGoldfish been replaced by a new one]]. That's not even getting into discovering that not only are the heroes of your land praising these ponies who came clear out of nowhere, but their ruler is now married to your own. [[JerkJustifications No wonder Ace Ray's so quick to hate on Starfleet]]! [[DesignatedHero You know, aside from the other obvious reasons.]]
own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Up To Eleven is a defunct trope


As a way of [[TakeThatCritics getting back at his critics]], Mykan will make another character based on his critics and torture them so horribly, [[UpToEleven Ace Ray and Brass Bolt's punishments will pale in comparison]].

to:

As a way of [[TakeThatCritics getting back at his critics]], Mykan will make another character based on his critics and torture them so horribly, [[UpToEleven Ace Ray and Brass Bolt's punishments will pale in comparison]].comparison.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I fixed Chained Sinkholes. Also, while I do find that gross, "Eww" in this case is Word Cruft. Lastly, I deleted a couple unneeded spaces.


* Twilight and a PaletteSwap of Shining Armor?! '''[[{{Squick}} E]][[UnfortunateImplications w]][[BrotherSisterIncest w]]!'''

to:

* Twilight and a PaletteSwap of Shining Armor?! '''[[{{Squick}} E]][[UnfortunateImplications w]][[BrotherSisterIncest w]]!'''Armor?!



[[WMG: The author is an avatar of Discord.]]

to:

[[WMG: The [[WMG:The author is an avatar of Discord.]]



[[WMG: Titan is not dead.]]

to:

[[WMG: Titan [[WMG:Titan is not dead.]]



* Which would make Celesto a MultiversalConqueror taking over one planet at a time with his mindless slaves. Nothing would stand in his way because all potential resistance would either join his empire or be rendered too dumb to fight back. [[Franchise/StarTrek WE ARE THE SPACE PONIES. YOU WILL BE ASSIMILATED. RESISTANCE IS FUTILE.]] [[NightmareFuel Yeesh...]]

to:

* Which would make Celesto a MultiversalConqueror taking over one planet at a time with his mindless slaves. Nothing would stand in his way because all potential resistance would either join his empire or be rendered too dumb to fight back. [[Franchise/StarTrek WE ARE THE SPACE PONIES. YOU WILL BE ASSIMILATED. RESISTANCE IS FUTILE.]] FUTILE]]. [[NightmareFuel Yeesh...]]



* And then he pinned the blame on [[spoiler:Twilight for dying]], even going so far as to have her own mentor say the same thing (or at least a vision of her mentor, if [[Fanfic/FallOfStarfleetRebirthOfFriendship FoS]] is any indication), all so any future resistors would be quelled. [[MoralEventHorizon Everyone, I think we have the most evil character since]] [[VideoGame/MegaManZero Dr. Weil]]... [[DesignatedHero except he's supposed to be the]] ''BigGood'' [[UnintentionallyUnsympathetic of this fic]].

to:

* And then he pinned the blame on [[spoiler:Twilight for dying]], even going so far as to have her own mentor say the same thing (or at least a vision of her mentor, if [[Fanfic/FallOfStarfleetRebirthOfFriendship FoS]] is any indication), all so any future resistors would be quelled. [[MoralEventHorizon Everyone, I think we have the most evil character since]] character]] since [[VideoGame/MegaManZero Dr. Weil]]... [[DesignatedHero except he's supposed to be the]] ''BigGood'' [[UnintentionallyUnsympathetic of this fic]].



Think about it: you end up getting knocked out for what seems like a day, and you wake up to find yourself and your entire species [[BalefulPolymorph mutated]] into something else and your entire planet having [[EarthShatteringKaboom blown up]] and [[ReplacementGoldfish been replaced by a new one]]. That's not even getting into discovering that not only are the heroes of your land praising these ponies who came clear out of nowhere, but their ruler is now married to your own. [[JerkJustifications No wonder Ace Ray's so quick to hate on Starfleet!]] [[DesignatedHero You know, aside from the other obvious reasons.]]

to:

Think about it: you end up getting knocked out for what seems like a day, and you wake up to find yourself and your entire species [[BalefulPolymorph mutated]] into something else and your entire planet having [[EarthShatteringKaboom blown up]] and [[ReplacementGoldfish been replaced by a new one]]. That's not even getting into discovering that not only are the heroes of your land praising these ponies who came clear out of nowhere, but their ruler is now married to your own. [[JerkJustifications No wonder Ace Ray's so quick to hate on Starfleet!]] Starfleet]]! [[DesignatedHero You know, aside from the other obvious reasons.]]



Considering Mykan's habit of [[RecycledScript copying his]] [[SelfPlagiarism own works]], it wouldn't be surprising for him to recycle the plot with Castor and Lelliani from Season IV. In a season of ''Starfleet Magic'', Shining Light's future self will arrive to the present time, psychologically torture an MLP character(s) because they [[IDidWhatIHadToDo "had]] [[TautologicalTemplar to"]] and hand out [[DeusExMachina Dei Ex Machina]] to Starfleet on a silver platter so that they can defeat the [[MonsterOfTheWeek Monsters of the Week]] and the BigBad.

to:

Considering Mykan's habit of [[RecycledScript copying his]] copying]] his [[SelfPlagiarism own works]], it wouldn't be surprising for him to recycle the plot with Castor and Lelliani from Season IV. In a season of ''Starfleet Magic'', Shining Light's future self will arrive to the present time, psychologically torture an MLP character(s) because they [[IDidWhatIHadToDo "had]] [[TautologicalTemplar "had to"]] and hand out [[DeusExMachina Dei Ex Machina]] to Starfleet on a silver platter so that they can defeat the [[MonsterOfTheWeek Monsters of the Week]] and the BigBad.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
wick cleaning


[[WMG:[[IncestIsRelative Grand Ruler is closely related to Celestia.]]]]

to:

[[WMG:[[IncestIsRelative Grand [[WMG:Grand Ruler is closely related to Celestia.]]]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


He is the main villain of the series after all.

to:

He is the main villain of the series after all.all.
** Jossed, it's implied it's not even a bad guy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In this universe, Grand Ruler Celesto stole the powers of the alternate universe equivalents of Luna and Candace to become a "Tri-Horned Winged Unicorn", and developed the Uniforce to defeat and seal away Titan. This gave Titan severe brain damage, and over thousands of years his mental state deteriorated to the point that his only emotion became hatred of Unicornicopia. Grand Ruler Celesto, meanwhile gave into paranoia, and instituted all the implied ethnic cleansings and totalitarian policies in fear that Titan's eyes and ears were everywhere, Eventually leading to him making Lightning as a living weapon against Titan (since of course the Ruler is to afraid of Titan to face him again).

to:

In this universe, Grand Ruler Celesto stole the powers of the alternate universe equivalents of Luna and Candace to become a "Tri-Horned Winged Unicorn", and developed the Uniforce to defeat and seal away Titan. This gave Titan severe brain damage, and over thousands of years his mental state deteriorated to the point that his only emotion became hatred of Unicornicopia. Grand Ruler Celesto, meanwhile gave into paranoia, and instituted all the implied ethnic cleansings and totalitarian policies in fear that Titan's eyes and ears were everywhere, Eventually leading to him making Lightning as a living weapon against Titan (since of course the Ruler is to too afraid of Titan to face him again).



*** Jossed, Spike and Rarity are a couple as of the end of season 4. That, and Human!Artie ends up with Sunset Shimmer.

to:

*** Jossed, Spike and Rarity are a couple as of the end of season 4. That, and Human!Artie ends up with Sunset Shimmer. Besides, considering the author likes Spike more than Rarity, there was no way he would kill him off first.




to:

* Maybe you are the Insecto? There is a second villain named Slick...




to:

** Jossed, Beaker does get a KangarooCourt and a rant, and life sentence, but he does never get brainwashed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


On El Mundo, [[HereditaryRepublic it's flat out confirmed that the president's family is considered nobility,]] and it's likely the same way with other Starfleet presidents. Furthermore, Vistula shows what presidents are not elected by the public in any meaningful capacity, but chosen by Celesto before getting approved, not to mention how [[ContrivedCoincidence every president seen so far is a Space Pony]]. Combined with the suspicious circumstances of Calista's death and the possibility that Celesto can alter personalitites and memories, there arises a nightmarish likelihood that [[ControlFreak Celesto]] is doing this to pull his planets even tighter under his rule under the guise of [[WhiteMansBurden kindness]], [[ParanoiaFuel one "accident" at a time...]]

to:

On El Mundo, [[HereditaryRepublic it's flat out confirmed that the president's family is considered nobility,]] and it's likely the same way with other Starfleet presidents. Furthermore, Vistula shows what presidents are not elected by the public in any meaningful capacity, but chosen by Celesto before getting approved, not to mention how [[ContrivedCoincidence every president seen so far is a Space Pony]]. Combined with the suspicious circumstances of Calista's death and the possibility that Celesto can alter personalitites and memories, there arises a nightmarish likelihood that [[ControlFreak Celesto]] is doing this to pull his planets even tighter under his rule under the guise of [[WhiteMansBurden kindness]], [[ParanoiaFuel one "accident" at a time...]]]]

[[WMG:The Great One Zadovia talks about is Titan]]

He is the main villain of the series after all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** While Celesto did make sure none of the original Space Ponies is genetically the exact same to the other, so initially there was no inbreeding, they were still only 100, so it's still possible unless the first generation had many children.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Maybe it's his Accord form? Starfleet is overly lawful, not chaotic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
spelling


In this universe, Grand Ruler Celesto stole the powers of the alternate universe equivlents of Luna and Candace to become a "Tri-Horned Winged Unicorn", and developed the Uniforce to defeat and seal away Titan. This gave Titan severe brain damage, and over thousands of years his mental state deteriorated to the point that his only emotion became hatred of Unicornicopia. Grand Ruler Celesto, meanwhile gave into paranoia, and instituted all the implied ethnic clensings and totalitarian policies in fear that Titan's eyes and ears were everywhere, Eventually leading to him making Lightning as a living weapon against Titan (since of course the Ruler is to afraid of Titan to face him again).

to:

In this universe, Grand Ruler Celesto stole the powers of the alternate universe equivlents equivalents of Luna and Candace to become a "Tri-Horned Winged Unicorn", and developed the Uniforce to defeat and seal away Titan. This gave Titan severe brain damage, and over thousands of years his mental state deteriorated to the point that his only emotion became hatred of Unicornicopia. Grand Ruler Celesto, meanwhile gave into paranoia, and instituted all the implied ethnic clensings cleansings and totalitarian policies in fear that Titan's eyes and ears were everywhere, Eventually leading to him making Lightning as a living weapon against Titan (since of course the Ruler is to afraid of Titan to face him again).



[[WMG:The author is an avatar of Discord.]]

to:

[[WMG:The [[WMG: The author is an avatar of Discord.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





* Confirmed. He's back in "The Movie".

to:

* Confirmed. He's back in "The Movie".
Movie". And "Human In United Equestria". And the tenth season.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





Think about it; despite being the ruler of Vistula, she wasn't given armour, only two soldiers were assigned to guard her, said soldiers didn't keep an eye out for any danger and none of the folks with armour tried to shield her from Von Devilor's attacks. The result: a Space Pony is put in charge of Vistula as president, therefore bringing another planet under Starfleet's control.

to:

Think about it; despite being the ruler of Vistula, she wasn't given armour, only two soldiers were assigned to guard her, said soldiers didn't keep an eye out for any danger and none of the folks with armour tried to shield her from Von Devilor's attacks. The result: a Space Pony is put in charge of Vistula as president, therefore bringing another planet under Starfleet's control.control.

[[WMG:Starfleet's presidents are a way of exerting (even more) control over other planets.]]
On El Mundo, [[HereditaryRepublic it's flat out confirmed that the president's family is considered nobility,]] and it's likely the same way with other Starfleet presidents. Furthermore, Vistula shows what presidents are not elected by the public in any meaningful capacity, but chosen by Celesto before getting approved, not to mention how [[ContrivedCoincidence every president seen so far is a Space Pony]]. Combined with the suspicious circumstances of Calista's death and the possibility that Celesto can alter personalitites and memories, there arises a nightmarish likelihood that [[ControlFreak Celesto]] is doing this to pull his planets even tighter under his rule under the guise of [[WhiteMansBurden kindness]], [[ParanoiaFuel one "accident" at a time...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Think about it; despite being the ruler of Vistula, she wasn't given armour, only two soldiers were assigned to guard her, said soldiers don't keep an eye out for any danger and none of the folks with armour try to shield her from Von Devilor's attacks. The result: a Space Pony is put in charge of Vistula as president, therefore bringing another planet under Starfleet's control.

to:

Think about it; despite being the ruler of Vistula, she wasn't given armour, only two soldiers were assigned to guard her, said soldiers don't didn't keep an eye out for any danger and none of the folks with armour try tried to shield her from Von Devilor's attacks. The result: a Space Pony is put in charge of Vistula as president, therefore bringing another planet under Starfleet's control.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Confirmed. They return and take on new names and appearances. Mysterious becomes "Specter", Rep-Stallion becomes "Razor" and Dementia becomes "Waverline".

to:

* Confirmed. They return and take on new names and appearances. Mysterious becomes "Specter", Rep-Stallion becomes "Razor" and Dementia becomes "Waverline"."Waverline".

[[WMG:Starfleet let Calista die.]]
Think about it; despite being the ruler of Vistula, she wasn't given armour, only two soldiers were assigned to guard her, said soldiers don't keep an eye out for any danger and none of the folks with armour try to shield her from Von Devilor's attacks. The result: a Space Pony is put in charge of Vistula as president, therefore bringing another planet under Starfleet's control.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Confirmed. They return and take on new names and appearances. Mysterious becomes "Specter", Rep-Stallion becomes "Razor" and Dementia becomes 'Waverline".

to:

* Confirmed. They return and take on new names and appearances. Mysterious becomes "Specter", Rep-Stallion becomes "Razor" and Dementia becomes 'Waverline"."Waverline".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In Season X, Starlight Glimmer has three minions. The description of their voices and their lines fit the Trio perfectly, plus Titan himself is back.

to:

In Season X, Starlight Glimmer has three minions. The description of their voices and their lines fit the Trio perfectly, plus Titan himself is back.back.
* Confirmed. They return and take on new names and appearances. Mysterious becomes "Specter", Rep-Stallion becomes "Razor" and Dementia becomes 'Waverline".

Top