Follow TV Tropes

Following

History TearJerker / StarTrekDeepspaceNine

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** And remember, Kira's only in her late twenties at this point - twelve years ago? [[ChildSoldier She was a teenager.]] And she was part of the Resistance cell who liberated Gallitep, and witnessed all of this firsthand.

to:

*** And remember, Kira's only in her late twenties at this point - twelve years ago? [[ChildSoldier [[ChildSoldiers She was a teenager.]] And she was part of the Resistance cell who liberated Gallitep, and witnessed all of this firsthand.

Added: 201

Changed: 82

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The battle in "The Siege of AR-558." The haunting, mournful music playing over the phaser fire and screams of battle makes it even harder to watch dry-eyed as the away team and the Starfleet officers who have been slowly dying, both physically and psychologically, fight a brutal and ugly battle for the sake of a hunk of technology and many of the episode's characters are killed.
** One of the soldiers recounts to Bashir how his arm was bandaged by a guy he despised for being a motor mouth. By the time the soldier finishes the story and proclaims that the man finally shut up after having a hole shot into his chest, he's practically shouting at Bashir and sobbing.

to:

* The battle in "The Siege of AR-558." The haunting, mournful music playing over the phaser fire and screams of battle makes it even harder to watch dry-eyed as the away team and the Starfleet officers who have been slowly dying, both physically and psychologically, fight a brutal and ugly battle for the sake of a hunk of technology and many of the episode's characters are killed.
killed. The director called on his experience from the Vietnam War ''and it shows''.
** One of the soldiers recounts to Bashir how his arm was bandaged by a guy he despised for being a motor mouth.MotorMouth. By the time the soldier finishes the story and proclaims that the man finally shut up after having a hole shot into his chest, he's practically shouting at Bashir and sobbing.


Added DiffLines:

*** Quark spends the whole episode admonishing humans for their war-mongering ways. Then he shoots an attacking soldier on instinct when he tries to go for Nog. The horror on Quark's face is palpable.

Removed: 581

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
However the Dominion are still on the other side and in the prime timeline they were still planning to invade. Also things are not better for the Bajorans who are now worse off and are so desperate they are allied with Cardassians. The timeline was peaceful but not at peace. Also without the Federation \ Dominion war the Founders would never be infected, made to heel preventing further threats to the Alpha quadrandt and their continued brutal domination ( the quickening etc) of the Dominion quadrandt


** In its own way, seeing the alternate future for the [=DS9=] characters is this as well, knowing that it won't come to pass - despite losing Captain Sisko, the future isn't all that bad. Sure, the Klingons annexed the Bajoran system, but there was no Dominion War, Nog's gotten a captaincy, Bashir and Dax are married, Jadzia survived to have a long and happy life, Quark finally got his own moon, Morn's running the bar on [=DS9=]... For all the reasons to feel sympathy for Jake, one could also think that his selfishness in getting his father back undid a lot of good as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* During "Cardassians," Garak has brought Bashir to an orphanage on Bajor, seeking the file of Rugal, a Cardassian boy who was left behind, whose father turns out to be a political rival of Dukat, who has set about trying to bring the boy back to Cardassia. Garak wanders around the orphanage smuggly, as he knows the Bajoran who runs the facility has no reason to offer any Cardassian any sympathy, so he gives her exactly what she expects. But as he and Bashir prepare to leave with the files, he's brought up short as a young Cardassian girl leads several other Cardassian children out to see him, and gently asks if he's there to bring them back to Cardassia. All of Garak's facade crumbles as he looks at her pleading face.

to:

* During "Cardassians," Garak has brought Bashir to an orphanage on Bajor, seeking the file of Rugal, a Cardassian boy who was left behind, whose father turns out to be a political rival of Dukat, [[Characters/StarTrekDeepSpaceNineGulDukat Dukat]], who has set about trying to bring the boy back to Cardassia. Garak wanders around the orphanage smuggly, as he knows the Bajoran who runs the facility has no reason to offer any Cardassian any sympathy, so he gives her exactly what she expects. But as he and Bashir prepare to leave with the files, he's brought up short as a young Cardassian girl leads several other Cardassian children out to see him, and gently asks if he's there to bring them back to Cardassia. All of Garak's facade crumbles as he looks at her pleading face.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The ending of "Empok Nor" is a very [[BittersweetEnding bitter]] one. The mission does succeed, but it has clearly traumatized Garak. Even though he was drugged into paranoid insanity against his will. Garak still clearly blames himself for Amaro's death and knows he will be living with the guilt of what happened to him for a long time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Another heart-wrenching detail is how ''Garak'' ends up breaking before Odo. He literally begs Odo to talk, even lie if he must, just to see it end, because he can't stand seeing a man he respects go through so much agony.
** Even worse is Garak ''succeeds'' in prying Odo's DarkSecret out of him, and it's [[AllForNothing not tactically useful or strategically important]] -- it's the simple fact that after everything, Odo still misses his people and wants to go home to them.

to:

** * Another heart-wrenching detail is how ''Garak'' ends up breaking before Odo. He literally begs Odo to talk, even lie if he must, just to see it end, because he can't stand seeing a man he respects go through so much agony.
** Even worse is
agony. Worse, Garak ''succeeds'' in prying Odo's DarkSecret out of him, and it's [[AllForNothing not tactically useful or strategically important]] -- it's the simple fact that after everything, Odo still misses his people and wants to go home to them. them.
* When Odo breaks and says he wants to go back to the Founders, Garak's tone is angry, believing that Odo has been loyal to the Dominion after all. But when Odo says that he wants to go back and be ''with his people'', no matter how hard he's tried to forget, Garak's expression changes to one of pain because he's just tortured Odo into confessing what he himself has been feeling ever since his own, far less voluntary exile.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Before that, while sulking and DrowningMySorrows at Quark's after his experience with the Orb. Mirror Bareil finally snaps at the curious Bajoran's gawking at him, thanks his resemblance to the deceased Vedek Bareil.
--> '''Mirror Bareil''': What are you two staring at? Same goes for the rest of you! I am not Vedek Bareil! I just want to be left alone.

to:

** Before that, while sulking and DrowningMySorrows at Quark's after his experience with the Orb. Mirror Bareil finally snaps at the curious Bajoran's gawking at him, thanks to his resemblance to the deceased Vedek Bareil.
--> '''Mirror Bareil''': What are you two staring at? Same goes for the rest of you! I am not ''not'' Vedek Bareil! I just want to be left alone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ending of "Resurrection", when Mirror Bareil decides to take the Intendent back with him to the Mirror Universe. He reveals to Kira that he doesn't want too. Rather because even after being tempted by the happy future he saw in his Orb vision, of himself and Kira settling down. He thinks that he's not good enough for her and will ruin their relationship, The poor man is convinced he can never be anything better than a thief.

to:

* The ending of "Resurrection", when Mirror Bareil decides to take the Intendent back with him to the Mirror Universe. He reveals to Kira that he doesn't want too. Rather it's because even after being tempted by the happy future he saw in his Orb vision, of himself and Kira settling down. He thinks that he's not good enough for her and will ruin their relationship, relationship. The poor man is convinced he can never be anything better than a thief.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

--> '''Mirror Bareil''': What are you two staring at? Same goes for the rest of you! I am not Vedek Bareil! I just want to be left alone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The ending of "Resurrection", when Mirror Bareil decides to take the Intendent back with him to the Mirror Universe. He reveals to Kira that he doesn't want too. Rather because even after being tempted by the happy future he saw in his Orb vision, of himself and Kira settling down. He thinks that he's not good enough for her and will ruin their relationship, The poor man is convinced he can never be anything better than a thief.
** Before that, while sulking and DrowningMySorrows at Quark's after his experience with the Orb. Mirror Bareil finally snaps at the curious Bajoran's gawking at him, thanks his resemblance to the deceased Vedek Bareil.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* During "Cardassians," Garak has brought Bashir to an orphanage on Bajor, seeking the file of Rugal, a Cardassian boy who was left behind, whose father turns out to be a political rival of Dukat, who has set about trying to bring the boy back to Cardassia. Garak wanders around the orphanage smuggly, as he knows the Bajoran who runs the facility has no reason to offer any Cardassian any sympathy, so he gives her exactly what she expects. But as he and Bashir prepare to leave with the files, he's brought up short as a young Cardassian girl leads several other Cardassian children out to see him, and gently asks if he's there to bring them back to Cardassia. All of Garak's facade crumbles as he looks at her pleading face.
--> '''Garak:''' I'm afraid not, child.
** And, as we later learn, both in a subsequent scene and in later episodes, while Cardassians claim to prize and value their families, when a child is orphaned, they have lost all their connections to their family as a result, and Garak is correct in saying that these children have no place in Cardassian society. Which means that they will never have a place in Cardassian society.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* "Today the guns are silent. A great tragedy has ended... we have known the bitterness of defeat and the exultation of triumph, and from both we have learned there can be no going back. We must move forward to preserve in peace what we've won in war". Doubly sad as these words also closed out the the Second World War.

to:

* "Today the guns are silent. A great tragedy has ended... we have known the bitterness of defeat and the exultation of triumph, and from both we have learned there can be no going back. We must move forward to preserve in peace what we've won in war". Doubly sad as these words also closed out the the Second World War.

Added: 745

Changed: 2

Removed: 745

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





* "Afterimage": Ezri Dax tries to settle in at Deep Space Nine, but besides Sisko and Quark, everybody, especially Worf, is uncomfortable having her there. Then, while she's trying to help Garak with his claustrophobia, he delivers a brutal TheReasonYouSuckSpeech that utterly [[BreakTheCutie crushes her spirit]], leaving her so devastated that she heads to the Bajoran chapel where Jadzia was killed and cries.
** The sheer relief on Worf's face when Ezri tells him that Jadzia loved him as much as he did her, at hearing that just one more time, from the only person who would know for certain, speaks to how much that little fear in the back of his mind had been gnawing at him. It's like he lets out a breath he'd held since Jadzia had died.



* "Afterimage": Ezri Dax tries to settle in at Deep Space Nine, but besides Sisko and Quark, everybody, especially Worf, is uncomfortable having her there. Then, while she's trying to help Garak with his claustrophobia, he delivers a brutal TheReasonYouSuckSpeech that utterly [[BreakTheCutie crushes her spirit]], leaving her so devastated that she heads to the Bajoran chapel where Jadzia was killed and cries.
** The sheer relief on Worf's face when Ezri tells him that Jadzia loved him as much as he did her, at hearing that just one more time, from the only person who would know for certain, speaks to how much that little fear in the back of his mind had been gnawing at him. It's like he lets out a breath he'd held since Jadzia had died.



* Right up until she turns around and accepts them, Winn is sympathetic in her horror about the Pai-Wraiths speaking to her - these are, effectively, the devils of her faith, asking her to believe in them and to give up the love of the Prophets. Of course, that still ends up going out the airlock once she realizes that the only way to turn away from the Pah-Wraiths is to give up her position as Kai, but up to the point she makes her choice, you legitimately do feel sympathy for her in her crisis of faith.

to:

* Right up until she turns around and accepts them, Winn is sympathetic in her horror about the Pai-Wraiths Pah-Wraiths speaking to her - these are, effectively, the devils of her faith, asking her to believe in them and to give up the love of the Prophets. Of course, that still ends up going out the airlock once she realizes that the only way to turn away from the Pah-Wraiths is to give up her position as Kai, but up to the point she makes her choice, you legitimately do feel sympathy for her in her crisis of faith.

Top