Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / MerlinS02E07TheWitchfinder

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


By night, a large horse-drawn cage rattles into the courtyard of the castle. An intimidating man in [[BadassLongcoat dark clothes]] and a [[NiceHat wide-brimmed hat]] jumps down from the driver's seat. And if none of that is scary enough, it turns out that he's played by [[Series/BleakHouse Charles]] [[Series/GameOfThrones Dance]]. Yeah, ''that'' Creator/CharlesDance. Be afraid. Morgana watches in terror from her bedroom window, looking especially horrified at the sight of the cage.

to:

By night, a large horse-drawn cage rattles into the courtyard of the castle. An intimidating man in [[BadassLongcoat dark clothes]] and a [[NiceHat wide-brimmed hat]] hat jumps down from the driver's seat. And if none of that is scary enough, it turns out that he's played by [[Series/BleakHouse Charles]] [[Series/GameOfThrones Dance]]. Yeah, ''that'' Creator/CharlesDance. Be afraid. Morgana watches in terror from her bedroom window, looking especially horrified at the sight of the cage.

Added: 121

Changed: 686

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* BurnTheWitch

to:

%%* BurnTheWitch* BurnTheWitch: Gaius almost ends up burnt at the stake as a sorcerer until Arthur calls it off in the nick of time.



%%* ClearTheirName

to:

%%* ClearTheirName* ClearTheirName: Gaius is accused of being a sorcerer and Merlin must clear his name before he is burned at the stake.
* ColdBloodedTorture: Aredian uses both physical and emotional torture to force {{false confession}}s out of his victims.



%%* FramingTheGuiltyParty

to:

%%* FramingTheGuiltyParty* FramingTheGuiltyParty: Gaius, Merlin and Morgana ''actually are'' magic users, but Aredian, whose MO is to frame innocent people as magic users, never realizes this.



%%* WitchHunt
%%* TheWitchHunter

to:

%%* WitchHunt
%%* TheWitchHunter
* WitchHunt: A literal example; Uther calls in a witchfinder when one of his subjects reports seeing someone conjure a horse made of magic smoke, and receives Aredian, who conducts a search for anyone who could conceivably be a magic user and thus a threat to the kingdom.
* TheWitchHunter: Aredian's job as a "witchfinder" is this in everything but name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnachronismStew: If he ever existed, Arthur was probably a late 5th/early 6th century warlord. The world of Merlin is aesthetically and technologically mostly 13th century, with castles and knights and so on. So far, so PurelyAestheticEra HighMiddleAges. This episode takes it a step further, however, by adding the decidedly ''17 century'' Witchfinder.

to:

* AnachronismStew: If he ever existed, Arthur was probably a late 5th/early 6th century warlord. The world of Merlin ''Merlin'' is aesthetically and technologically mostly 13th century, with castles and knights and so on.century. So far, so PurelyAestheticEra HighMiddleAges. This episode takes it a step further, however, by adding the decidedly ''17 ''17th century'' Witchfinder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* AnachronismStew: If he ever existed, Arthur was probably a late 5th/early 6th century warlord. The world of Merlin is aesthetically and technologically mostly 13th century, with castles and knights and so on. So far, so PurelyAestheticEra HighMiddleAges. This episode takes it a step further, however, by adding the decidedly ''17 century'' Witchfinder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatTheHellHero: Gaius gives Uther a dressing down on how his paranoia about magic allows people Aredian to tortue innoncent people in order to root out magic. And he gets ''away'' with it.

to:

* WhatTheHellHero: Gaius gives Uther a dressing down on how his paranoia about magic allows people like Aredian to tortue torture innoncent people in order to root out magic. And he gets ''away'' with it.

Added: 182

Changed: 168

Removed: 475

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BadassLongcoat: The Witchfinder
* BurnTheWitch

to:

* AntagonistTitle: Aredian, the titular witch hunter, is this episode's VillainOfTheWeek.
* BadassLongcoat: The Witchfinder
*
Witchfinder.
%%*
BurnTheWitch



* ClearTheirName

to:

* %%* ClearTheirName



* DisneyVillainDeath

to:

* DisneyVillainDeathDisneyVillainDeath: Aredian falls out the window after he is cornered.



%%* FramingTheGuiltyParty
* FullNameUltimatum: When Gwen calls Arthur: "Arthur Pendragon", he knows she means business.



* FramingTheGuiltyParty
* FullNameUltimatum: When Gwen calls Arthur: "Arthur Pendragon", he knows she means business.



* MagnificentBastard: Aredian



* OutOfOrder: This episode was originally meant to take place directly after ''[[Recap/MerlinS02E03TheNightmareBegins The Nightmare Begins]]''.



* SpecialGuest: Creator/CharlesDance as Aredian.



* ThrowItIn: When Aredian interrogates Morgana, he casually rearranges torture equipment around the room. This was Charles Dance's impromptu idea, which was naturally kept in the episode.



* WitchHunt
* TheWitchHunter

to:

* %%* WitchHunt
* %%* TheWitchHunter
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


By night, a large horse-drawn cage rattles into the courtyard of the castle. An intimidating man in [[BadassLongcoat dark clothes]] and a [[NiceHat wide-brimmed hat]] jumps down from the driver's seat. And if none of that is scary enough, it turns out that he's played by [[Series/BleakHouse Charles]] [[Series/GameOfThrones Dance]]. Yeah, ''that'' Charles Dance. Be afraid. Morgana watches in terror from her bedroom window, looking especially horrified at the sight of the cage.

to:

By night, a large horse-drawn cage rattles into the courtyard of the castle. An intimidating man in [[BadassLongcoat dark clothes]] and a [[NiceHat wide-brimmed hat]] jumps down from the driver's seat. And if none of that is scary enough, it turns out that he's played by [[Series/BleakHouse Charles]] [[Series/GameOfThrones Dance]]. Yeah, ''that'' Charles Dance.Creator/CharlesDance. Be afraid. Morgana watches in terror from her bedroom window, looking especially horrified at the sight of the cage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dangerously Genre Savvy is being merged with Genre Savvy. Misuse and zero context examples will be cut.


* DangerouslyGenreSavvy: Aredian is like an expert lawyer when questioning Merlin, he gets the boy to admit that he ''can't'' prove he didn't use magic. He also seems aware that Morgana's dreams might be a sign of her magic, or at the very least he's able to pick up on her general uneasiness throughout the episode.
** He's able to use Uther's hatred of magic to his advantage knowning the king won't dare question any one he decrees of using magic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Misuse. It\'s Genre Savvy, not just \"savvy\".


* GenreSavvy: The Dragon warns Merlin if he confesses to save Gauius, Aredian will just burn them both. He's right, when Gaius confesses Aredian reveals that Morgana and Merlin are his next victims.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ThrowItIn: When Aredian interrogates Morgana, he casually rearranges torture equipment around the room. This was Charles Dance's impromptu idea, which was naturally kept in the episode.

Added: 60

Changed: 14

Removed: 60

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Renamed some tropes.


--> '''Aredian''': [[IronicEcho I have nothing to hide]].

to:

--> '''Aredian''': [[IronicEcho I have nothing to hide]].
hide.]]



--> '''Gaius''': [[JustFollowingOrders But I did not suffer at his hands, Uther. I suffered at yours. He worked for you, My Lord. He was merely following your orders]].

to:

--> '''Gaius''': [[JustFollowingOrders But I did not suffer at his hands, Uther. I suffered at yours. He worked for you, My Lord. He was merely following your orders]].orders.]]



--> '''Gaius''': [[WhatTheHellHero No. You were deceived long before Aredian, for you deceived yourself. You see foes where there are friends, you see sorcerers where there are but servants. I am not the first to be wrongly accused in your war against magic, and not all have been as lucky as I]].

to:

--> '''Gaius''': [[WhatTheHellHero No. You were deceived long before Aredian, for you deceived yourself. You see foes where there are friends, you see sorcerers where there are but servants. I am not the first to be wrongly accused in your war against magic, and not all have been as lucky as I]].I.]]



* DamselInDistress: Morgana, held at knife-point by Aredian.



* DistressedDamsel: Morgana, held at knife-point by Aredian.



* GenreBlind: Aredian thinks he can sucessfully convince Uther that Morgana his beloved ward has magic.

to:

* GenreBlind: GenreBlindness: Aredian thinks he can sucessfully convince Uther that Morgana his beloved ward has magic.



* OutOfOrder: This episode was originally meant to take place directly after ''[[{{Recap/MerlinS02E03TheNightmareBegins}} The Nightmare Begins]]''.

to:

* OutOfOrder: This episode was originally meant to take place directly after ''[[{{Recap/MerlinS02E03TheNightmareBegins}} ''[[Recap/MerlinS02E03TheNightmareBegins The Nightmare Begins]]''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


By night, a large horse-drawn cage rattles into the courtyard of the castle. An intimidating man in [[BadassLongcoat dark clothes]] and a [[NiceHat wide-brimmed hat]] jumps down from the driver's seat. And if none of that is scary enough, it turns out that he's played by [[Series/BleakHouse Charles]] [[GameOfThrones Dance]]. Yeah, ''that'' Charles Dance. Be afraid. Morgana watches in terror from her bedroom window, looking especially horrified at the sight of the cage.

to:

By night, a large horse-drawn cage rattles into the courtyard of the castle. An intimidating man in [[BadassLongcoat dark clothes]] and a [[NiceHat wide-brimmed hat]] jumps down from the driver's seat. And if none of that is scary enough, it turns out that he's played by [[Series/BleakHouse Charles]] [[GameOfThrones [[Series/GameOfThrones Dance]]. Yeah, ''that'' Charles Dance. Be afraid. Morgana watches in terror from her bedroom window, looking especially horrified at the sight of the cage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FantasticRacism: Aredian to magic users.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ItsPersonal: It's implied there's some sort of history between Gaius and Aredian, which is partly why Aredian persecutes him so vehemently.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NeverMyFault: Uther tries to swift responsibility on Gaius' torment to Aredian. Gaius has none of it, and points out everything Aredian did was with the King's permission and that he allowed Aredian to '''torture''' him.

Added: 867

Removed: 41

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DangerouslyGenreSavvy: Aredian is like an expert lawyer when questioning Merlin, he gets the boy to admit that he ''can't'' prove he didn't use magic. He also seems aware that Morgana's dreams might be a sign of her magic, or at the very least he's able to pick up on her general uneasiness throughout the episode.
** He's able to use Uther's hatred of magic to his advantage knowning the king won't dare question any one he decrees of using magic.



* {{Frameup}}: How Aredian does business. He doesn't care if the people are guilty of using magic or not, he just wants money.
* GenreBlind: Aredian thinks he can sucessfully convince Uther that Morgana his beloved ward has magic.



* {{Frameup}}: How Aredian does business.


Added DiffLines:

* IdiotBall: Merlin grabs it firmly in the first few minutes by using his magic to make a horse in the smoke in the middle of the forest where it can be seen for miles, kicks off the plot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GenreSavvy: The Dragon warns Merlin if he confesses to save Gauius, Aredian will just burn them both. He's right, when Gaius confesses Aredian reveals that Morgana and Merlin are his next victims.


Added DiffLines:

* PetTheDog: Even though they spend most of this season hating each other, the Dragon is actually sorry that he can't help Merlin in this episode because he just doesn't know how.


Added DiffLines:

* WhatTheHellHero: Gaius gives Uther a dressing down on how his paranoia about magic allows people Aredian to tortue innoncent people in order to root out magic. And he gets ''away'' with it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


By night, a large horse-drawn cage rattles into the courtyard of the castle. An intimidating man in [[BadassLongcoat dark clothes]] and a [[NiceHat wide-brimmed hat]] jumps down from the driver's seat. And if none of that is scary enough, it turns out that he's played by [[BleakHouse Charles]] [[GameOfThrones Dance]]. Yeah, ''that'' Charles Dance. Be afraid. Morgana watches in terror from her bedroom window, looking especially horrified at the sight of the cage.

to:

By night, a large horse-drawn cage rattles into the courtyard of the castle. An intimidating man in [[BadassLongcoat dark clothes]] and a [[NiceHat wide-brimmed hat]] jumps down from the driver's seat. And if none of that is scary enough, it turns out that he's played by [[BleakHouse [[Series/BleakHouse Charles]] [[GameOfThrones Dance]]. Yeah, ''that'' Charles Dance. Be afraid. Morgana watches in terror from her bedroom window, looking especially horrified at the sight of the cage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CassandraTruth: A variant. The Witchfinder correctly names the three people in Camelot who use magic (Gaius, Merlin, and Morgana), but he seems largely unaware that he has.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DistressedDamsel: Morgana, held at knife-point by Aredian.

Added: 101

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


By night, a large horse-drawn cage rattles into the courtyard of the castle. An intimidating man in [[BadassLongcoat dark clothes]] and a [[NiceHat wide-brimmed hat]] jumps down from the driver's seat. And if none of that is scary enough, it turns out that he's played by [[BleakHouse Charles]] [[GameOfThrones Dance]]. Yeah, ''that'' Charles Dance. Morgana watches in terror from her bedroom window, looking especially horrified at the sight of the cage.

to:

By night, a large horse-drawn cage rattles into the courtyard of the castle. An intimidating man in [[BadassLongcoat dark clothes]] and a [[NiceHat wide-brimmed hat]] jumps down from the driver's seat. And if none of that is scary enough, it turns out that he's played by [[BleakHouse Charles]] [[GameOfThrones Dance]]. Yeah, ''that'' Charles Dance. Be afraid. Morgana watches in terror from her bedroom window, looking especially horrified at the sight of the cage.


Added DiffLines:

* FalseConfession: Gaius confesses to a litany of magical spells in order to save Merlin and Morgana.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> '''Gaius''': [[WhatTheHellHero But I did not suffer at his hands, Uther. I suffered at yours. He worked for you, My Lord. He was merely following your orders]].

to:

--> '''Gaius''': [[WhatTheHellHero [[JustFollowingOrders But I did not suffer at his hands, Uther. I suffered at yours. He worked for you, My Lord. He was merely following your orders]].



--> '''Gaius''': No. You were deceived long before Aredian, for you deceived yourself. You see foes where there are friends, you see sorcerers where there are but servants. I am not the first to be wrongly accused in your war against magic, and not all have been as lucky as I.

to:

--> '''Gaius''': [[WhatTheHellHero No. You were deceived long before Aredian, for you deceived yourself. You see foes where there are friends, you see sorcerers where there are but servants. I am not the first to be wrongly accused in your war against magic, and not all have been as lucky as I.I]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> '''Gaius''': [[WahtTheHellHero But I did not suffer at his hands, Uther. I suffered at yours. He worked for you, My Lord. He was merely following your orders]].

to:

--> '''Gaius''': [[WahtTheHellHero [[WhatTheHellHero But I did not suffer at his hands, Uther. I suffered at yours. He worked for you, My Lord. He was merely following your orders]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Merlin and Gwen race through the lower town and bang on a door. An older man opens it, wondering what they're doing in the middle of the night. The two friends shoulder their way into the apothecary shop, and demand to know whether he's selling a tincture of belladonna. The apothecary tells them that it can be found in his range of eyedrops, which women use to brighten their eyes. The mysterious solved, Gwen coaxes a confession out of him: that Aredian gave him the eyedrops to sell.

to:

Merlin and Gwen race through the lower town and bang on a door. An older man opens it, wondering what they're doing in the middle of the night. The two friends shoulder their way into the apothecary shop, and demand to know whether he's selling a tincture of belladonna. The apothecary tells them that it can be found in his range of eyedrops, [[AluminumChristmasTrees which women use to brighten their eyes. eyes]]. The mysterious mystery solved, Gwen coaxes a confession out of him: that Aredian gave him the eyedrops to sell.



--> '''Gaius''': But I did not suffer at his hands, Uther. I suffered at yours. He worked for you, My Lord. He was merely following your orders.

to:

--> '''Gaius''': [[WahtTheHellHero But I did not suffer at his hands, Uther. I suffered at yours. He worked for you, My Lord. He was merely following your orders.orders]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


By night, a large horse-drawn cage rattles into the courtyard of the castle. An intimidating man in dark clothes and a wide-brimmed hat jumps down from the driver's seat. And if none of that is scary enough, it turns out that he's played by [[BleakHouse Charles]] [[GameOfThrones Dance]]. Yeah, ''that'' Charles Dance. Morgana watches in terror from her bedroom window, looking especially horrified at the sight of the cage.

to:

By night, a large horse-drawn cage rattles into the courtyard of the castle. An intimidating man in [[BadassLongcoat dark clothes clothes]] and a [[NiceHat wide-brimmed hat hat]] jumps down from the driver's seat. And if none of that is scary enough, it turns out that he's played by [[BleakHouse Charles]] [[GameOfThrones Dance]]. Yeah, ''that'' Charles Dance. Morgana watches in terror from her bedroom window, looking especially horrified at the sight of the cage.

Top