History Manga / Judge

22nd Jan '16 3:46:05 PM aye_amber
Is there an issue? Send a Message
22nd Nov '15 10:38:34 PM EternityofSpirits
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* CluelessMystery: Big time. Over the course of the entire series only one very subtle moment hints that [[spoiler: Hiro is the culprit.]] The rest of the manga actually does little but point ''away'' from this idea, since [[spoiler: the reader is shown Hiro's thoughts and actions, much of which contradicts him being the culprit.]] Many other important points to the mystery are also never once hinted at before the final volume.
23rd Aug '15 2:41:59 AM EternityofSpirits
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* PlotHole: TheReveal makes one of the scenes in the beginning completely nonsensical. In the first chapter [[spoiler: Hiro wakes up in a room (there is no reason for him to be unconscious), reacts with shock at the rabbit mask (even though he would of been the one who put it on), is handcuffed (no reason given), mentions being knocked out by someone on the way from school (which never happened) and reacts in horror when he sees the Pig Guys corpse (even though he orchestrated his death, has killed a man and is planning to kill several more).]]

to:

* PlotHole: One gets the impression that TheReveal makes one was not planned out by Tonogai, given that there quite a lot of the scenes in the beginning completely nonsensical. events that contradict it:
**
In the first chapter [[spoiler: Hiro wakes up in a room (there is no reason for him to be unconscious), reacts with shock at the rabbit mask (even though he would of been the one who put it on), is handcuffed (no reason given), mentions being knocked out by someone on the way from school (which never happened) and reacts in horror when he sees the Pig Guys corpse (even though he orchestrated his death, has killed a man and is planning to kill several more).]]
23rd Aug '15 2:39:33 AM EternityofSpirits
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Near the end, it is shown that [[spoiler: Hiro was the one who killed Nobuyuki and was standing outside the room pushing the door forwards when Kazu committed suicide.]] Problem is that [[spoiler: every scene between their last appearances and when their corpses are shown are from Hiro's perspective and there is no gap of time for him to be there.]]
** Indeed, there are numerous instances where [[spoiler: Hiro is shown thinking about his desire to survive and acts like he has no idea what's going on, when there is no one else in the room. One wonders why he acts like that when he's the culprit.]]
20th Aug '15 12:50:13 AM EternityofSpirits
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* PlotHole: TheReveal makes one of the scenes in the beginning completely nonsensical. In the first chapter [[spoiler: Hiro wakes up in a room (there is no reason for him to be unconscious), reacts with shock at the rabbit mask (even though he would of been the one who put it on), is handcuffed (no reason given), mentions being knocked out by someone on the way from school (which never happened) and reacts in horror when he sees the Pig Guys corpse (even though he orchestrated his death, has killed a man and is planning to kill several more).]]
17th Aug '15 9:16:06 PM EternityofSpirits
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* LateArrivalSpoiler: Best not to look at the covers for anything after the first volume. They show who's died.
28th May '15 2:17:12 PM Endless_Despair
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* AnyoneCanDie: Just like its predecessor ''Manga/{{Doubt}}'' [[spoiler: Of the nine teens that participate, Rina is the only one alive at the end.]]
* AssholeVictims: Of all the victims that died, most of them deserved it. [[spoiler: With Ryuhei and Hiro being the most blatant two.]]



* BigBad: The mastermind behind the ''Judge'' game [[spoiler: Are Hikari and Hiro]]



* KilledOffForReal: So far [[spoiler:Atsuya, the pig male, Nobuyuki (the bear), Kazu (the male cat), Ryuhei (the horse), Asami (the female cat), Miku (the female pig), Hayato (the lion), his father and Hiro.]]

to:

* KilledOffForReal: So far [[spoiler:Atsuya, By the pig male, Nobuyuki (the bear), Kazu (the male cat), Ryuhei (the horse), Asami (the female cat), Miku (the female pig), Hayato (the lion), his father end of it.. [[spoiler: Everyone except Hikari, Rina and Hiro.her mother are dead.]]



* RevengeByProxy: Aside from [[spoiler: Kazu, Rina and her mother]], this turns out to be the reason behind the ''Judge'' game. It's not the group themselves who have committed huge sins that are being judged, but their parents are punished for ''their'' sins by having to see their children dying.

to:

* RevengeByProxy: Aside from [[spoiler: Kazu, Kazu (as he's TheMole), Rina and her mother]], mother (She was the only one who refused the bribe) who are most likely only there to complete the 9.]], this turns out to be the reason behind the ''Judge'' game. It's not the group themselves who have committed huge sins that are being judged, but their parents are punished for ''their'' sins by having to see their children dying.



** Lion: Pride
** Rabbit: Envy
** Cat: Lust
** Bear: Sloth
** Pig: Gluttony
** Fox: Greed
** Horse: Wrath

to:

** Lion: Pride
Pride [[spoiler: Hayato and his father were both prideful men. The former for believing he was better than everyone else and scheming to take his father's place and the latter for being a judge and how he feels all his trails are fair and just.]]
** Rabbit: Envy
Envy [[spoiler: Of the seven sins in this story, {{Envy}} has the most importance. Hiro changed the time of Atsuya's date with Hikari, purely because he was jealous of their relationship, which lead not only to Atsuya's death but also to the creation of the game ''Judge''.]]
** Cat: Lust
Lust [[spoiler: Asami was sexually abused by her father, which in turn led her to becoming a rather seductive women as shown when done to Hiro. Kazu was actually [[StraightGay homosexual]] and is disowned by his family.]]
** Bear: Sloth
Sloth [[spoiler: Nobuyuki was a {{Hikkikomori}} who kills his mother because she has nothing good to say to her neighbours about her son.]]
** Pig: Gluttony
Gluttony [[spoiler: Miku was rather fat and unattractive who despised her appearance and so forced her grandfather to pay money for her to have plastic surgery.]]
** Fox: Greed
Greed [[spoiler: ''Unknown'' as Rina's sin was never revealed (she may not even have one), in fact if anything this sin is subverted as Rina's mother refused to accept the bribe from the trial.]]
** Horse: WrathWrath [[spoiler: Ryuhei was the vocalist of a boys' band who [[{{Wrath}} hates]] being looked down upon.]]
16th May '15 5:45:41 AM erforce
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* [[DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything Does This Remind You Of Anything?]]: ''Film/{{Saw}}'', anyone?

to:

* [[DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything Does This Remind You Of Anything?]]: ''Film/{{Saw}}'', ''Franchise/{{Saw}}'', anyone?
26th Mar '15 7:26:48 AM catmuto
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* {{Foreshadowing}}: The unknown man found in Chapter 16 [[spoiler: shows that Hiro ''might'' not be as good as the reader is supposed to believe. When he sees Hiro, he begins to scream in horror and blame himself for everything. And as it turns out, Hiro is actually ''not'' a hero, he's a VillainProtagonist who likely caused the injuries to this man]].
26th Mar '15 6:47:22 AM catmuto
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* OrdinaryHighSchoolStudent

to:

* OrdinaryHighSchoolStudentOrdinaryHighSchoolStudent: Several of the characters are these before being brought to ''Judge''.


Added DiffLines:

* TheReveal: Quite a handful of them. [[spoiler: Hiro and Hikari are the masterminds behind the ''Judge'' game. The unknown man who they find is the driver who ran over Atsuya. And the group are all the children of the jury, and judge, of the trial to determine the driver's sentence.]]
This list shows the last 10 events of 42. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Manga.Judge