History Main / SlidingScaleofFreeWillVsFate

1st May '16 4:56:47 AM erforce
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* The ''Franchise/{{Terminator}}'' films absolutely cannot make up their minds about where they stand on this because of the TimeyWimeyBall. The dominant theme overtly stated in the second film was "No Fate But What We Make," but the film's ScrewDestiny finale was offset by film three which just showed it as delaying the inevitable, and then there's the fact that none of the series should work if not for the StableTimeLoop.

to:

* The ''Franchise/{{Terminator}}'' films absolutely cannot make up their minds about where they stand on this because of the TimeyWimeyBall. The dominant theme overtly stated in the [[Film/Terminator2JudgmentDay second film film]] was "No Fate But What We Make," but the film's ScrewDestiny finale was offset by film three which just showed it as delaying the inevitable, and then there's the fact that none of the series should work if not for the StableTimeLoop.
28th Apr '16 8:13:44 AM molokai198
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/WingsOfFire'' is type 4. [=NightWings=] [[spoiler:though far fewer of them then the [=NightWings=] would have you believe]]have the power of prophecy, but there are multiple potential futures even when it comes to random events and they are ultimately just predictions. Even the most talented seers are marked by being able to see all of the potential futures, not a single one.
* ''Literature/TheSight'' is type 2 - characters can have visions of the future and it is difficult and requires effort to change them, though it is still possible. [[spoiler:Larka realizes this just a bit too late to save herself]], but it does provide some hope given that [[spoiler:it turns out the most likely future is humanity nuking everyone and destroying the environment.]]
25th Apr '16 5:52:23 PM Mayhavecontrol
Is there an issue? Send a Message


->'''Jojo''': Free will! By the Titans' toe-cheese, they told me you were sharp but I had ''no idea''. Yes, Parson Gotti, Lord of Hamsters, do you believe Fate is a mighty wind? One that propels us inexorably to our final destination? Or do you believe... that the ''individual'' can steer the ship of self, to the port of his ''choice'', however emphatically the world may try to blow him?

to:

->'''Jojo''': Free ->Free will! By the Titans' toe-cheese, they told me you were sharp but I had ''no idea''. Yes, Parson Gotti, Lord of Hamsters, do you believe Fate is a mighty wind? One that propels us inexorably to our final destination? Or do you believe... that the ''individual'' can steer the ship of self, to the port of his ''choice'', however emphatically the world may try to blow him?
18th Mar '16 4:13:49 PM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* ''XxxHOLIC'' ranks quite high: "There is no such thing as coincidence in this world - there is only inevitability."
* ''TsubasaReservoirChronicle'' is considered high in the fate scale.

to:

* ''XxxHOLIC'' ''Manga/XxxHolic'' ranks quite high: "There is no such thing as coincidence in this world - there is only inevitability."
* ''TsubasaReservoirChronicle'' ''Manga/TsubasaReservoirChronicle'' is considered high in the fate scale.



* The ''{{Naruto}}'' manga can't seem to make up its mind where it is on the scale. Naruto's fight with Neji contrasts the viewpoints of ScrewDestiny and YouCantFightFate, with Neji advocating a belief that everyone's abilities are determined from birth, and only those with great parentage can truly excel, with Naruto contesting that anyone can succeed [[{{Determinator}} if they try hard enough]]. Naruto wins the fight, which would seem to vindicate his position, but it turns out that Naruto is the son of the Fourth Hokage [[spoiler:and his mother was the previous Kyuubi jinchuriki and a descendent of the [[PhysicalGod Sage of Six Paths]].]] Furthermore, Naruto's own skill proved insufficient to overcome Neji's and he won that fight entirely because of the inherent advantages of being a [[SealedInsideAPersonShapedCan jinchuriki]]. On the other hand, Neji didn't know who Naruto's parents were, and based his opinion of Naruto primarily on his academic performance. The issue is definitely worthy of debate. YMMV on whether it's simply a BrokenAesop or if the message all along was that it's not as easy to determine the future's possibilities as Neji presumed.

to:

* The ''{{Naruto}}'' ''Manga/{{Naruto}}'' manga can't seem to make up its mind where it is on the scale. Naruto's fight with Neji contrasts the viewpoints of ScrewDestiny and YouCantFightFate, with Neji advocating a belief that everyone's abilities are determined from birth, and only those with great parentage can truly excel, with Naruto contesting that anyone can succeed [[{{Determinator}} if they try hard enough]]. Naruto wins the fight, which would seem to vindicate his position, but it turns out that Naruto is the son of the Fourth Hokage [[spoiler:and his mother was the previous Kyuubi jinchuriki and a descendent of the [[PhysicalGod Sage of Six Paths]].]] Furthermore, Naruto's own skill proved insufficient to overcome Neji's and he won that fight entirely because of the inherent advantages of being a [[SealedInsideAPersonShapedCan jinchuriki]]. On the other hand, Neji didn't know who Naruto's parents were, and based his opinion of Naruto primarily on his academic performance. The issue is definitely worthy of debate. YMMV on whether it's simply a BrokenAesop or if the message all along was that it's not as easy to determine the future's possibilities as Neji presumed.
6th Mar '16 2:51:26 AM Niria
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Similarly, "The Father Will Kill The Son" relating to Angel and Connor, even though it was placed in a prophecy book to mislead, nevertheless came true, though again just literally: Angel "killed" Connor, but as part of a deal that gave Connor a new, more normal, life. The demon who planted the fake prophecy to try to stop the real one that Connor would kill him, nevertheless was in fact killed by Connor. The only aversion of literal fate in the two series might have been Jasmine's defeat in Angel Season 4; and while the Tro-Clon prophecy sort of suggested something like Jasmine's rise, whether it ruled out her eventual defeat is questionable.

to:

** Similarly, "The Father Will Kill The Son" relating to Angel and Connor, even though it was placed in a prophecy book to mislead, nevertheless came true, though again just literally: Angel "killed" Connor, but as part of a deal that gave Connor a new, more normal, life. The demon who planted the fake prophecy to try to stop the real one that Connor would kill him, nevertheless was in fact killed by Connor. The only aversion of literal fate in the two series might have been Jasmine's defeat in Angel ''Angel'' Season 4; and while the Tro-Clon prophecy sort of suggested something like Jasmine's rise, whether it ruled out her eventual defeat is questionable.
6th Mar '16 2:49:42 AM Niria
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* In the universe of ''Series/BuffyTheVampireSlayer'' and ''Series/{{Angel}},'' it comes very close to "you can't fight fate" (although you certainly ''can'' make it literally true but mean different things). Prophecy showed Buffy was destined to die fighting The Master. Despite Buffy's attempt to avert it by not fighting him (she changes her mind), Giles' attempt to avert it by wanting to be the one to fight The Master, and an attempt by Xander to fight it as well, it happens...but then Xander brings her back to life with mouth to mouth.
** Similarly, "The Father Will Kill The Son" relating to Angel and Connor, even though it was placed in a prophecy book to mislead, nevertheless came true, though again just literally: Angel "killed" Connor, but as part of a deal that gave Connor a new, more normal, life. The demon who planted the fake prophecy to try to stop the real one that Connor would kill him, nevertheless was in fact killed by Connor. The only aversion of literal fate in the two series might have been Jasmine's defeat in Angel Season 4; and while the Tro-Clon prophecy sort of suggested something like Jasmine's rise, whether it ruled out her eventual defeat is questionable.
12th Feb '16 7:38:22 AM Dravencour
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* ''WesternAnimation/KungFuPanda2'' reinforces this as when the villain tried to stop his fate, being defeated by a warrior of black and white, he instead sealed it for [[spoiler: when he massacered the Panda village and Po escaped, he just simply transferred him to where he would be in prime postion to stop him.]]

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/KungFuPanda2'' reinforces this as when the villain tried to stop his fate, being defeated by a warrior of black and white, he instead sealed it for [[spoiler: when he massacered massacred the Panda village and Po escaped, [[GenocideBackfire he just simply transferred him to where he would be in a prime postion position to stop him.him]].]]
7th Feb '16 9:10:57 AM Ryn14
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* The premise of EarlyEdition is that the mysterious paper Gary receives every day shows what will happen if Gary does not intervene. It's intended for Gary to use the knowledge to save people, putting it firmly in the "prophecies are guides, not rules" category.

to:

* The premise of EarlyEdition "Series/EarlyEdition" is that the mysterious paper Gary receives every day shows what will happen if Gary does not intervene. It's intended for Gary to use the knowledge to save people, putting it firmly in the "prophecies are guides, not rules" category.
7th Feb '16 9:08:02 AM Ryn14
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

*The premise of EarlyEdition is that the mysterious paper Gary receives every day shows what will happen if Gary does not intervene. It's intended for Gary to use the knowledge to save people, putting it firmly in the "prophecies are guides, not rules" category.
25th Nov '15 8:10:27 AM SeraphimSwordmaster
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Whole point and theme of the aptly named ''VideoGame/ExitFate''. "Fate" merely refers to a non-universal way of pre-determining someone's life. The game is (among other things) about the main character's discovery that his life is fated and his struggle to break the control over him.

to:

* Whole point and theme of the aptly named ''VideoGame/ExitFate''. "Fate" merely refers to a non-universal way of pre-determining someone's life. The game is (among other things) about the main character's discovery that his life is fated and his struggle to break the control over him. [[spoiler:Interestingly enough, the game ''does'' feature a supernatural entity called "the Hand of Fate" that has the power to manipulate destiny in whatever way it wants but, since it's part of the BigBadDuumvirate, it's actually working with the mortals to create their own naturalistic system of destiny.]]
This list shows the last 10 events of 188. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Main.SlidingScaleofFreeWillVsFate