History Main / OverTookTheManga

24th May '16 2:14:35 PM Smeagol17
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* ''Manga/{{Berserk}}'' is a monthly ([[ScheduleSlip mostly]]) series that had already run for several years by the time its animated TV adaptation came out in 1997. That anime was a single season that covered only one arc of the manga (10 volumes worth of material nowadays that's less than a third of the total story). Rather than a GeckoEnding, it stops at a large CliffHanger (technically it's a [[WholeEpisodeFlashback whole series flashback]] that doesn't tell the viewer how we got to where we started). It's been described as "the world's most elaborate ad for the manga" for the way it drives viewers desperate for resolution back to the original. TheNewTens' film trilogy adaptation re-adapts that same plot arc, ending only very slightly further on in the plot roughly one chapter's worth, which fortunately is enough to ''finally'' resolve that cliffhanger. The creators of the trilogy have expressed the desire to continue adapting the manga story up through the ([[LongRunner currently unwritten]]) ending, but details of what form that will take (more films, a new TV series, [=OVAs=]) are not forthcoming. Due to Kentaro Miura's notorious {{Schedule Slip}}page, if they were to continue releasing films at the same pace as the Golden Age trilogy, they could easily find themselves Overtaking the Manga yet again.

to:

* ''Manga/{{Berserk}}'' is a monthly ([[ScheduleSlip mostly]]) series that had already run for several years by the time its animated TV adaptation came out in 1997. That anime was a single season that covered only one arc of the manga (10 volumes worth of material nowadays that's less than a third of the total story). Rather than a GeckoEnding, it stops at a large CliffHanger (technically it's a [[WholeEpisodeFlashback whole series flashback]] that doesn't tell the viewer how we got to where we started). It's been described as "the world's most elaborate ad for the manga" for the way it drives viewers desperate for resolution back to the original. TheNewTens' film trilogy adaptation re-adapts that same plot arc, ending only very slightly further on in the plot roughly one chapter's worth, which fortunately is enough to ''finally'' resolve that cliffhanger. The creators of the trilogy have expressed the desire to continue adapting the manga story up through the ([[LongRunner currently unwritten]]) ending, but details of what form that will take (more films, with a new TV series, [=OVAs=]) are not forthcoming. series. Due to Kentaro Miura's notorious {{Schedule Slip}}page, if they were to continue releasing films content at the same pace as the Golden Age trilogy, they could easily find themselves Overtaking the Manga yet again.
24th May '16 2:04:05 PM Anddrix
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Nearly avoided in ''Literature/HarryPotter'' when the [[Film/HarryPotterAndTheSorcerersStone first movie]] was released in 2001 after the [[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheGobletOfFire fourth book]] was published in 2000. Creator/JKRowling told Creator/AlanRickman about the true nature of Severus Snape, his character, which made him the few people who knew about Snape's motives until the publication of the seventh book. Hence, Movie!Snape appeared to be nicer than his book counterpart. Though Rowling did supervise the scripts, she made the final word about the characters such as Kreacher's importance in the last book and Dumbledore's sexual orientation. Though the movie managed to catch up with the books with [[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheDeathlyHallows the seventh book]] released in the same month as [[Film/HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix the fifth movie]]'s release date, the movies had a problem with the official pairings. It seemed that the production staff thought that Harry and Hermione are going to be a couple due to the chemistry between the Creator/DanielRadcliffe and Creator/EmmaWatson except they're confirmed as LikeBrotherAndSister in the final book. When Harry is finally paired with Ginny Weasley, it's more of an extreme case of StrangledByTheRedString where the movies had fewer scenes of Harry and Ginny being together than in the books and that shoe-tying scene in [[Film/HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince the sixth movie]] only confirmed that their status as a couple.

to:

* Nearly avoided in ''Literature/HarryPotter'' when the [[Film/HarryPotterAndTheSorcerersStone [[Film/HarryPotterAndThePhilosophersStone first movie]] was released in 2001 after the [[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheGobletOfFire fourth book]] was published in 2000. Creator/JKRowling told Creator/AlanRickman about the true nature of Severus Snape, his character, which made him the few people who knew about Snape's motives until the publication of the seventh book. Hence, Movie!Snape appeared to be nicer than his book counterpart. Though Rowling did supervise the scripts, she made the final word about the characters such as Kreacher's importance in the last book and Dumbledore's sexual orientation. Though the movie managed to catch up with the books with [[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheDeathlyHallows the seventh book]] released in the same month as [[Film/HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix the fifth movie]]'s release date, the movies had a problem with the official pairings. It seemed that the production staff thought that Harry and Hermione are going to be a couple due to the chemistry between the Creator/DanielRadcliffe and Creator/EmmaWatson except they're confirmed as LikeBrotherAndSister in the final book. When Harry is finally paired with Ginny Weasley, it's more of an extreme case of StrangledByTheRedString where the movies had fewer scenes of Harry and Ginny being together than in the books and that shoe-tying scene in [[Film/HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince the sixth movie]] only confirmed that their status as a couple.
4th May '16 7:40:49 PM sayaleviathan
Is there an issue? Send a Message



to:

* Nearly avoided in ''Literature/HarryPotter'' when the [[Film/HarryPotterAndTheSorcerersStone first movie]] was released in 2001 after the [[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheGobletOfFire fourth book]] was published in 2000. Creator/JKRowling told Creator/AlanRickman about the true nature of Severus Snape, his character, which made him the few people who knew about Snape's motives until the publication of the seventh book. Hence, Movie!Snape appeared to be nicer than his book counterpart. Though Rowling did supervise the scripts, she made the final word about the characters such as Kreacher's importance in the last book and Dumbledore's sexual orientation. Though the movie managed to catch up with the books with [[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheDeathlyHallows the seventh book]] released in the same month as [[Film/HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix the fifth movie]]'s release date, the movies had a problem with the official pairings. It seemed that the production staff thought that Harry and Hermione are going to be a couple due to the chemistry between the Creator/DanielRadcliffe and Creator/EmmaWatson except they're confirmed as LikeBrotherAndSister in the final book. When Harry is finally paired with Ginny Weasley, it's more of an extreme case of StrangledByTheRedString where the movies had fewer scenes of Harry and Ginny being together than in the books and that shoe-tying scene in [[Film/HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince the sixth movie]] only confirmed that their status as a couple.
1st May '16 4:28:42 PM CaptainCrawdad
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Interestingly, "The Lost World" has little in common with its novel counterpart. Ian Malcolm in a Godzilla movie vs a semi-remake, fight!
25th Apr '16 11:32:15 AM ironballs16
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* ''Manga/TheSevenDeadlySins''' anime adaptation is experiencing some delays due to needing the manga to progress further before they can adapt the next arc fully.
24th Apr '16 12:00:55 PM KiraDoom
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* ''Manga/ShamanKing'' is a bit more balanced between the manga and anime, but the anime seems to overtake the manga by a nose.
22nd Apr '16 10:10:52 PM aye_amber
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* After the fifth season of ''Series/GameOfThrones'' the show had mostly caught up with the published ''Series/ASongOfIceAndFire'' novels. This is based on a version of the problem that plagues anime although the show only airs ten episodes per season, it might have given another writer time to finish, the problem is that Creator/GeorgeRRMartin writes his {{Doorstopper}} novels ''[[ScheduleSlip veeeeerrrry sloooowwwwly]]''. This has led to Bran's storyline being left out of season 5 of the show, because his character has actually caught up entirely with his book plot line. Martin has given the show's writers a detailed explanation of events in the final two novels, as the showrunners have made it clear they will not and cannot stop and wait for Martin to catch up. The season 4 episode "[[Recap/GameOfThronesS4E4Oathkeeper Oathkeeper]]" featured a revelation before it came in the novels, that [[spoiler:reveals the Others/White Walkers have a society and hierarchy, that they create new Others/White Walkers by transforming human babies, and that they are led by the Night's King, an evil figure from Westeros mythology who was not previously confirmed to actually exist]]. The final two episodes of the fifth season were the first to adapt material confirmed to be from upcoming novels and revealed that [[spoiler:Stannis Baratheon would burn his daughter as a sacrifice and fail in his attempt to take Winterfell]]. It's becoming clear that the series is an AlternateContinuity from the books, with a mix of simplified situations, BroadStrokes, and several major events being completely different than their equivalents in the novels. The two will most likely split even more dramatically before the end.

to:

* After the fifth season of ''Series/GameOfThrones'' the show had mostly caught up with the published ''Series/ASongOfIceAndFire'' ''Literature/ASongOfIceAndFire'' novels. This is based on a version of the problem that plagues anime although the show only airs ten episodes per season, it might have given another writer time to finish, the problem is that Creator/GeorgeRRMartin writes his {{Doorstopper}} novels ''[[ScheduleSlip veeeeerrrry sloooowwwwly]]''. This has led to Bran's storyline being left out of season 5 of the show, because his character has actually caught up entirely with his book plot line. Martin has given the show's writers a detailed explanation of events in the final two novels, as the showrunners have made it clear they will not and cannot stop and wait for Martin to catch up. The season 4 episode "[[Recap/GameOfThronesS4E4Oathkeeper Oathkeeper]]" featured a revelation before it came in the novels, that [[spoiler:reveals the Others/White Walkers have a society and hierarchy, that they create new Others/White Walkers by transforming human babies, and that they are led by the Night's King, an evil figure from Westeros mythology who was not previously confirmed to actually exist]]. The final two episodes of the fifth season were the first to adapt material confirmed to be from upcoming novels and revealed that [[spoiler:Stannis Baratheon would burn his daughter as a sacrifice and fail in his attempt to take Winterfell]]. It's becoming clear that the series is an AlternateContinuity from the books, with a mix of simplified situations, BroadStrokes, and several major events being completely different than their equivalents in the novels. The two will most likely split even more dramatically before the end.
5th Apr '16 12:40:17 AM adonzo
Is there an issue? Send a Message



to:

* ''Film/ScottPilgrimVsTheWorld'' was filmed before [[ComicBook/ScottPilgrim the comic's]] final volume had been written, so while most of the film is fairly faithful the endings are quite different.
30th Mar '16 10:26:46 AM igordebraga
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* After the fifth season of ''Series/GameOfThrones'' the show had mostly caught up with the published ''Series/ASongOfIceAndFire'' novels. This is based on a version of the problem that plagues anime although the show only airs ten episodes per season, it might have given another writer time to finish, the problem is that Creator/GeorgeRRMartin writes his {{Doorstopper}} novels ''veeeeerrrry sloooowwwwly''. This has led to Bran's storyline being left out of season 5 of the show, because his character has actually caught up entirely with his book plot line. Martin has given the show's writers a detailed explanation of events in the final two novels, as the showrunners have made it clear they will not and cannot stop and wait for Martin to catch up. The season 4 episode "[[Recap/GameOfThronesS4E4Oathkeeper Oathkeeper]]" featured a revelation before it came in the novels, that [[spoiler:reveals the Others/White Walkers have a society and hierarchy, that they create new Others/White Walkers by transforming human babies, and that they are led by the Night's King, an evil figure from Westeros mythology who was not previously confirmed to actually exist]]. The final two episodes of the fifth season were the first to adapt material confirmed to be from upcoming novels and revealed that [[spoiler:Stannis Baratheon would burn his daughter as a sacrifice and fail in his attempt to take Winterfell]]. It's becoming clear that the series is an AlternateContinuity from the books, with a mix of simplified situations, BroadStrokes, and several major events being completely different than their equivalents in the novels. The two will most likely split even more dramatically before the end.

to:

* After the fifth season of ''Series/GameOfThrones'' the show had mostly caught up with the published ''Series/ASongOfIceAndFire'' novels. This is based on a version of the problem that plagues anime although the show only airs ten episodes per season, it might have given another writer time to finish, the problem is that Creator/GeorgeRRMartin writes his {{Doorstopper}} novels ''veeeeerrrry sloooowwwwly''.''[[ScheduleSlip veeeeerrrry sloooowwwwly]]''. This has led to Bran's storyline being left out of season 5 of the show, because his character has actually caught up entirely with his book plot line. Martin has given the show's writers a detailed explanation of events in the final two novels, as the showrunners have made it clear they will not and cannot stop and wait for Martin to catch up. The season 4 episode "[[Recap/GameOfThronesS4E4Oathkeeper Oathkeeper]]" featured a revelation before it came in the novels, that [[spoiler:reveals the Others/White Walkers have a society and hierarchy, that they create new Others/White Walkers by transforming human babies, and that they are led by the Night's King, an evil figure from Westeros mythology who was not previously confirmed to actually exist]]. The final two episodes of the fifth season were the first to adapt material confirmed to be from upcoming novels and revealed that [[spoiler:Stannis Baratheon would burn his daughter as a sacrifice and fail in his attempt to take Winterfell]]. It's becoming clear that the series is an AlternateContinuity from the books, with a mix of simplified situations, BroadStrokes, and several major events being completely different than their equivalents in the novels. The two will most likely split even more dramatically before the end.
23rd Feb '16 1:52:09 PM dangerdan97
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* The ''Franchise/StarTrek'' comic books often suffered from overtaking the movies. For example, in the movies, ''Film/StarTrekIVTheVoyageHome'' follows immediately after ''Film/StarTrekIIITheSearchForSpock'', with a gap of days or less in-between. In the comics, they adapted ''Search,'' then had Spock make a full recovery, Kirk and crew take command of the ''Excelsior,'' and Starfleet send them all on a bunch of far-away missions while they decided what to do with the captain who stole the ''Enterprise'' and got it blown up. When it came time to adapt ''Voyage,'' Spock started having a mental breakdown, so Kirk swapped the ''Excelsior'' for the Klingon ship they'd apparently kept in a parking orbit somewhere for all those months, took him back to Vulcan for treatment, and managed to set things up exactly the way they had been at the end of ''Search,'' just in time for a huge cylinder to start asking Earth about whales.

to:

* The ''Franchise/StarTrek'' comic books often suffered from overtaking the movies. For example, in the movies, ''Film/StarTrekIVTheVoyageHome'' follows immediately after ''Film/StarTrekIIITheSearchForSpock'', with a gap of days or less only 2 months in-between. In the comics, they adapted ''Search,'' then had Spock make a full recovery, Kirk and crew take command of the ''Excelsior,'' and Starfleet send them all on a bunch of far-away missions while they decided what to do with the captain who stole the ''Enterprise'' and got it blown up. When it came time to adapt ''Voyage,'' Spock started having a mental breakdown, so Kirk swapped the ''Excelsior'' for the Klingon ship they'd apparently kept in a parking orbit somewhere for all those months, took him back to Vulcan for treatment, and managed to set things up exactly the way they had been at the end of ''Search,'' just in time for a huge cylinder to start asking Earth about whales.
This list shows the last 10 events of 131. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Main.OverTookTheManga