Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / MilitarySalute

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* ''Radio/OurMissBrooks'': TheMovie GrandFinale retells Miss Brooks' first arrival at Madison High School. Mr. Boynton warns Miss Brooks that Mr. Conklin had served in the army during the war. Boynton warns Conklin was strict and had a military demeanor. Miss Brooks states that she's willing to meet Mr. Conklin halfway, but if he expects to treat her like a buck private he's mistaken. Mr. Conklin then walks up and introduces himself. Miss Brooks immediately stands as straight as a ramrod and salutes.

Added: 941

Changed: 324

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One ''Literature/CiaphasCain'' has him saluted by Kasteen and Broklaw (The Valhallan 597th's Colonel and Major respectively). He mentions in his narration that being ThePoliticalOfficer (and outside the chain of command), they don't have to salute him at all; it's just that [[HundredPercentHeroismRating he's unusually well liked for a Commissar]].

to:

* ''Literature/CiaphasCain'':
**
One ''Literature/CiaphasCain'' story has him saluted by Kasteen and Broklaw (The Valhallan 597th's Colonel and Major respectively). He mentions in his narration that being ThePoliticalOfficer (and outside the chain of command), they don't have to salute him at all; it's just that [[HundredPercentHeroismRating he's unusually well liked for a Commissar]].Commissar]].
** Meanwhile, his aide Jurgen can at best give a halfhearted shrug to civilians he's been told are important, and his salutes to officers are little better. It doesn't help that Jurgen's actual rank is quite vague: Cain presents him as Guinner First Class (there's only one rank of gunner), but as a commissar's aide he is clearly of some importance, but commissars are theoretically outside the Guard command structure, so... Cain actually mentions that Jurgen is quite good at exploiting people's ignorance of where he is exactly as the need arises.

Added: 384

Changed: 203

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Anime/MobileSuitGundamSEED'', in order to steal ZAFT's new prototype Freedom Gundam, Lacus Clyne dressed Kira up in the ZAFT pilot uniform and taught him their salute so that he could get past security.

to:

* ''Franchise/{{Gundam}}''
** In ''Anime/MobileSuitGundam'', Char does an ironic salute for [[spoiler:his supposed friend Garma Zabi after having just tricked him into a trap, laughing all the while]].
**
In ''Anime/MobileSuitGundamSEED'', in order to steal ZAFT's new prototype Freedom Gundam, Lacus Clyne dressed Kira up in the ZAFT pilot uniform and taught him their salute so that he could get past security.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The [[UsefulNotes/{{Austria}} Austrian]] (and formerly [[UsefulNotes/TheSoundOfMartialMusic Austro-Hungarian]]) salute is similar to the mainstream Naval one, but otherwise distinct: the right hand's fingertips are laid flatly across the right eyebrow, with the elbow being kept relatively at the front. This results in the hand and arm partially covering the eye.

to:

* The [[UsefulNotes/{{Austria}} Austrian]] (and formerly [[UsefulNotes/TheSoundOfMartialMusic Austro-Hungarian]]) salute is similar to a variation of the mainstream Naval one, but otherwise distinct: one: the right hand's fingertips are laid flatly across the right eyebrow, with the elbow being kept relatively at the front. This results in the hand and arm partially covering the eye.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The [[UsefulNotes/{{Austria}} Austrian]] (and formally [[UsefulNotes/TheSoundOfMartialMusic Austro-Hungarian]]) salute is similar to the mainstream Naval one, but otherwise distinct: the right hand's fingertips are laid flatly across the right eyebrow, with the elbow being kept relatively at the front. This results in the hand and arm partially covering the eye.

to:

* The [[UsefulNotes/{{Austria}} Austrian]] (and formally formerly [[UsefulNotes/TheSoundOfMartialMusic Austro-Hungarian]]) salute is similar to the mainstream Naval one, but otherwise distinct: the right hand's fingertips are laid flatly across the right eyebrow, with the elbow being kept relatively at the front. This results in the hand and arm partially covering the eye.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The [[UsefulNotes/{{Austria}} Austrian]] (and formally [[UsefulNotes/TheSoundOfMartialMusic Austro-Hungarian]]) salute is similar to the mainstream Naval one, but otherwise distinct: the right hand's fingertips are laid flatly across the right eyebrow, with the elbow being kept relatively at the front. This results in the hand and arm partially covering the eye.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the first ''VideoGame/GalaxyAngel'' game, one of the [=GCs=] depicts Tact, Lester and the five members of the Angel Wing saluting as a send-off to Comodore Luft, who's leaving with the Criom fleet to act as a decoy so the Elsior can get away from their enemies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**In the later "Second Great War" books, POV character Sam Carsten has risen through the ranks from naval seaman to full lieutenant commanding a destroyer escort. As a middle aged lieutenant, he is amused by the disconnect other officers have when he goes ashore at port, with his superiors starting to salute given his age, then stopping when they realize his rank. Occasionally they complete the action and Carsten gravelly returns the salute with the dignity of an admiral.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This gesture was commonly ([[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_salute though mistakenly]]) believed to be an ancient Roman salute, which was why the Italian Fascists adopted it (and the Nazis took it from them). Expect to see it in films set in AncientGrome, especially if they were made before World War II. In fact, that gesture was originally the one used by [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bellamy_salute American civilians giving the Pledge of Allegiance]], until the Nazis put it dead out of fashion, at which place it was replaced by the modern right-hand-over-heart gesture.

to:

** This gesture was commonly ([[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_salute though mistakenly]]) believed to be an ancient Roman salute, which was why the Italian Fascists adopted it (and the Nazis took it from them). Expect to see it in films set in AncientGrome, especially if they were made before World War II. In fact, that gesture was originally the one used by [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bellamy_salute American civilians giving the Pledge of Allegiance]], until the Nazis put it dead out of fashion, at which place it was replaced by truncated, with the modern right-hand-over-heart gesture.gesture being kept throughout the Pledge, instead of moving to the straight-arm salute at the words "to the Flag" as prescribed originally.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Oddly enough, Mexicans uses ''both Nazi and American salutes'', when honoring the Mexican flag in both official ceremonies and schools. The American salute is used when singing the Mexican anthem and the Nazi one for honoring the flag. Unlike with the rest of the world, Mexicans doesn't see any problem using the Nazi salute, since it was used for years before World War II, albeit it doesn't prevent many people to lampshade that fact.[[note]]More than one Mexican kid went punished by yelling ''[[DudeNotFunny Heil Hitler!]]'' after honoring the flag.[[/note]]

to:

** Oddly enough, Mexicans uses use ''both Nazi and American salutes'', when honoring the Mexican flag in both official ceremonies and schools. The American salute is used when singing the Mexican anthem and the Nazi one for honoring the flag. Unlike with the rest of the world, Mexicans doesn't don't see any problem using the Nazi salute, since it was used for years before World War II, albeit it doesn't prevent many people to lampshade that fact.[[note]]More than one Mexican kid went punished by yelling ''[[DudeNotFunny Heil Hitler!]]'' after honoring the flag.[[/note]]

Added: 790

Changed: 820

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cleaned up Battallion Wars example


* The ending of ''VideoGame/BatallionWars 2'' shows us different salutes of the armies in the game. The Solar Empire salute is the left hand raised to the chest, palm open and pointing up, followed by a short bow. The Western Frontier and The Anglo Isles share the same salute, similar to real life Britain. The difference is how it is carried out. The Western Frontier soldiers bring their hand to the forehead, before straightening their hand to a Roman salute. The Anglo Isles salute is the same, but in reverse (Hand straight to the Roman salute, then to the head). Finally, the Tundran Territories has the right hand closed to a fist, the arm straight forward before bringing it to the chest, held vertically. It should be noted that apart from the Solar Empire, all CO's do this salute with their right hand, while soldiers (who carry their weapons in the right hand) do them with the left hand.

to:

* The ending of ''VideoGame/BatallionWars 2'' ''[[VideoGame/BattalionWars BattalionWars 2]]'' shows us different salutes of the armies in the game. game.
**
The Solar Empire salute is the left hand raised to the chest, palm open and pointing up, followed by a short bow. It should be noted that apart from the Solar Empire, all CO's do this salute with their right hand, while soldiers (who carry their weapons in the right hand) do them with the left hand.
**
The Western Frontier and The Anglo Isles share the same salute, similar to real life Britain. The difference is how it is carried out.Britain, with minor difference. The Western Frontier soldiers bring their hand to the forehead, before straightening their hand to a Roman salute. The Anglo Isles salute is the same, but in reverse (Hand straight to the Roman salute, then to the head).
**
Finally, the Tundran Territories has the right hand closed to a fist, the arm straight forward before bringing it to the chest, held vertically. It should be noted that apart from the Solar Empire, all CO's do this salute with their right hand, while soldiers (who carry their weapons in the right hand) do them with the left hand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


There are also situations in which saluting is NOT recommended. When in the field or in a forward operation base, soldiers are instructed not to salute, since it identifies the officer/VIP, which can [[StraightForTheCommander provide a sniper with an easy target]]. Most forces allow people operating vehicles to refrain from doing so if it would be unsafe to take their hand off the controls. Many forces find it inappropriate to salute when not in uniform; for example, in the US Navy if you are out of uniform you simply stand at attention instead of saluting in situations that normally call for it.

to:

There are also situations in which saluting is NOT recommended. When in the field or in a forward operation base, soldiers are instructed not to salute, since it identifies the officer/VIP, which can [[StraightForTheCommander provide a sniper with an easy target]]. Most forces allow people operating vehicles to refrain from doing so if it would be unsafe to take their hand off the controls. Many forces find it inappropriate to salute when not in uniform; for example, in the US Navy if you are out of uniform you simply stand at attention instead of saluting in situations that normally call for it.
it. Some sailors at stations on the bridge of British submarines are apparently exempted from standing up to salute in the presence of officers - even if the current ''Monarch'' happens to be present - because of the overhead hazards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The first time John Levene played Benton, his botching of the salute was bad enough that actual British Army men wrote to the producers demanding he be turned over to them for training so he could get it ''right''. The training apparently involved everyone drinking quite a lot of Scotch, and the Army men [[DrillSergeantNasty yelling instructions at Levene]] until his salute was more regulation (and apparently included some tips on ''when'' to salute, resulting in the above).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Disambiguating Fullmetal Alchemist


* In an issue of the ''Anime/FullmetalAlchemist'' manga, Edward Elric gives a left-handed salute because his artificial right arm was destroyed.

to:

* In an issue of the ''Anime/FullmetalAlchemist'' manga, ''Manga/FullmetalAlchemist'', Edward Elric gives a left-handed salute because his artificial right arm was destroyed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Fanfic/ADipInTheInkwell'': In "Mr. and Mrs. O", both Oxley and Ossie give one to Olive when she clears her throat to get their attention, something she notes as having last been made mandatory in the 1927 edition of the Odd Squad Training Manual.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Anime/LegendOfGalacticHeroes'' ''Die Neue These'', the Free Planets Alliance salute is somewhere between the French salute and British Army salute. The Galactic Empire uses a variation of the British Navy version.

to:

* In ''Anime/LegendOfGalacticHeroes'' ''Die ''Literature/LegendOfTheGalacticHeroes: Die Neue These'', the Free Planets Alliance salute is somewhere between the French salute and British Army salute. The Galactic Empire uses a variation of the British Navy version.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** As mentioned above, on a couple of occasions, [=UNIT=], most notably Col. Mace, attempted to salute The Doctor (as they do seemingly hold some sort of official rank in [=UNIT=] as the Scientific Adviser). These were almost always rebuffed with an annoyed "oh, don't salute..." during the Tenth Doctor's tenure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The "don't salute superior officers in the field" custom is namechecked and played for laughs in "[[Recap/MashS3E1TheGeneralFlippedAtDawn The General Flipped at Dawn]]" as ''Frank'', of all people (a man so military he was described once as "bleeding khaki") tries to talk General Steele (a senile officer who makes life miserable for the M*A*S*H over the course of the episode) out of requesting a salute while they're scouting out locations for a new site for the 4077th. He points out that it's unwise as it lets snipers know who to shoot at. Steele dismisses the concerns out of hand and [[ThatsAnOrder orders]] Frank and Henry to salute him. Cue snipers. Steele [[UnflinchingWalk casually gets into his jeep under fire]] while [[{{Cloudcukoolander}} singing, no less,]] while Frank and Henry scramble into it trying not to be shot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** In "/Recap/MashS6E2FallenIdol", when Hawkeye personally presents Radar with the Purple Heart;

to:

*** In "/Recap/MashS6E2FallenIdol", "[[Recap/MashS6E2FallenIdol Fallen Idol]]", when Hawkeye personally presents Radar with the Purple Heart;



*** In "Recap/MashS8E13CaptainsOutrageous", Hawkeye salutes the newly-minted Captain Fr. John Mulcahey.
*** In "Recap/MashS11E16GoodbyeFarewellAndAmen" both Hawkeye and BJ give a formal and fully military salute to Colonel Potter as a farewell, a sign of the respect they had for him.
** In "Recap/MashS3E24AbyssiniaHenry", Radar salutes the departing Col. Blake and holds the salute even after Blake returned it and as his chopper lifts off.

to:

*** In "Recap/MashS8E13CaptainsOutrageous", "[[Recap/MashS8E13CaptainsOutrageous Captains Outrageous]]", Hawkeye salutes the newly-minted Captain Fr. John Mulcahey.
*** In "Recap/MashS11E16GoodbyeFarewellAndAmen" "[[Recap/MashS11E16GoodbyeFarewellAndAmen Goodbye, Farewell, and Amen]]" both Hawkeye and BJ give a formal and fully military salute to Colonel Potter as a farewell, a sign of the respect they had for him.
** In "Recap/MashS3E24AbyssiniaHenry", "[[Recap/MashS3E24AbyssiniaHenry Abyssinia, Henry]]", Radar salutes the departing Col. Blake and holds the salute even after Blake returned it and as his chopper lifts off.

Added: 782

Changed: 441

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** One of the only non-mocking salutes Hawkeye ever gave was to Radar when he was shipping out - Hawk was busy in the OR but gave Radar a salute in lieu of the going away party that the casualties canceled.
** In the finale, BJ and Hawkeye give Col. Potter formal full salute with full attention as their final gesture to him before they depart their separate ways.

to:

** One of Hawkeye however did give non-ironic salutes, even if on rare occasions. [[https://screenrant.com/mash-questions-hawkeye/ Screenrant]] lists four occasions:
*** In "/Recap/MashS6E2FallenIdol", when Hawkeye personally presents Radar with
the only non-mocking Purple Heart;
*** In "Goodbye, Radar, Pt. 2", when as Radar is about to leave, he takes one last look at the operating theater (the camp was going to throw a big "going-away" party for him, but the war had other plans, unfortunately). As he peers through the window, Hawkeye looks at him, stops his surgery for a moment and gives a sincere salute to Radar.
*** In "Recap/MashS8E13CaptainsOutrageous", Hawkeye
salutes the newly-minted Captain Fr. John Mulcahey.
*** In "Recap/MashS11E16GoodbyeFarewellAndAmen" both
Hawkeye ever gave was to Radar when he was shipping out - Hawk was busy in the OR but gave Radar and BJ give a formal and fully military salute in lieu to Colonel Potter as a farewell, a sign of the going away party that the casualties canceled.
respect they had for him.
** In "Recap/MashS3E24AbyssiniaHenry", Radar salutes the finale, BJ and Hawkeye give departing Col. Potter formal full Blake and holds the salute with full attention even after Blake returned it and as their final gesture to him before they depart their separate ways.his chopper lifts off.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

->''"We salute the rank, not the man."''
-->-- '''Major Dick Winters''', ''Series/BandOfBrothers''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The Military Salute is a long-standing tradition of military forces around the world, and it is obviously the most visible and known gesture of military protocol to the average civilian. There is an urban myth that it evolved out of a custom in which mediaeval knights opened their visors with their weapon-hand to be recognised and to show that they were not armed; in fact it evolved from the former custom of men removing their hats as a sign of respect. This is the reason that in some military outfits (such as the US Marine Corps and Navy) it is incorrect to salute when you are not wearing a "cover". (In other outfits customs are different, and salutes are given when bare-headed; meanwhile, in many armies, including the Russian one, it is expressly forbidden to salute without a hat on) The salute evolved because of the introduction of headwear that could no longer be taken off easily with just one hand, especially bearskin caps and mitre-shaped grenadier caps. In the 18th century, when the military salute was first introduced, there were situations when it was still possible to give it with the left hand, e.g. on parade when the saluting officer was holding a spontoon in his right hand.

to:

The Military Salute is a long-standing tradition of military forces around the world, and it is obviously the most visible and known gesture of military protocol to the average civilian. There is an urban myth that it evolved out of a custom in which mediaeval knights opened their visors with their weapon-hand to be recognised and to show that they were not armed; in fact it evolved from the former custom of men removing their hats as a sign of respect. This is the reason that in some military outfits (such as the US Marine Corps and Navy) Navy), it is incorrect to salute when you are not wearing a "cover". "cover." (In other outfits outfits, customs are different, and salutes are given when bare-headed; meanwhile, in many armies, including the Russian one, it is expressly forbidden to salute without a hat on) on.) The salute evolved because of the introduction of headwear that could no longer be taken off easily with just one hand, especially bearskin caps and mitre-shaped grenadier caps. In the 18th century, when the military salute was first introduced, there were situations when it was still possible to give it with the left hand, e.g. on parade when the saluting officer was holding a spontoon in his right hand.



In the English speaking world, which here means the US and the commonwealth there are two types of salutes. The first, with palm facing outwards, is the "British military salute." This is used by the armies and air forces of most Commonwealth countries. Its origins are with the British Army. The other which is palm downwards, originating with the Royal Navy, is the British "Naval" salute (this was originally introduced because sailors' and officers' hands were often stained with tar through life aboard ship, and showing a dirty palm was considered to reduce the dignity of the gesture). This is used by the Naval forces of the Commonwealth and the US Armed Forces. This is often in popular parlance seen as an American salute, even in the commonwealth. There has been examples of nitpickers and scolds attacking works (or real life) where British or Australians are depicted as saluting palm downwards as an example of EaglelandOsmosis.

to:

In the English speaking world, which here means the US and the commonwealth Commonwealth of Nations, there are two types of salutes. The first, with palm facing outwards, is the "British military salute." This is used by the armies and air forces of most Commonwealth countries. Its origins are with the British Army. The other which is palm downwards, originating with the Royal Navy, is the British "Naval" salute (this was originally introduced because sailors' and officers' hands were often stained with tar through life aboard ship, and showing a dirty palm was considered to reduce the dignity of the gesture). This is used by the Naval forces of the Commonwealth and the US Armed Forces. This is often in popular parlance seen as an American salute, even in the commonwealth.Commonwealth. There has been examples of nitpickers and scolds attacking works (or real life) where British or Australians are depicted as saluting palm downwards as an example of EaglelandOsmosis.



* '''Saluting with a rifle.''' Usually done by holding the weapon vertically in front of you, muzzle up, with the underside of the weapon presented towards the person being saluted.

to:

* '''Saluting with a rifle.''' Usually rifle''' is usually done by holding the weapon vertically in front of you, muzzle up, with the underside of the weapon presented towards the person being saluted.



There are also situations in which saluting is NOT recommended. When in the field or in a forward operation base, soldiers are instructed not to salute, since it identifies the officer/VIP, which can [[StraightForTheCommander provide a sniper with an easy target.]] Most forces allow people operating vehicles to refrain from doing so if it would be unsafe to take their hand off the controls. Many forces find it inappropriate to salute when not in uniform; for example, in the US Navy if you are out of uniform you simply stand at attention instead of saluting in situations that normally call for it.

to:

There are also situations in which saluting is NOT recommended. When in the field or in a forward operation base, soldiers are instructed not to salute, since it identifies the officer/VIP, which can [[StraightForTheCommander provide a sniper with an easy target.]] target]]. Most forces allow people operating vehicles to refrain from doing so if it would be unsafe to take their hand off the controls. Many forces find it inappropriate to salute when not in uniform; for example, in the US Navy if you are out of uniform you simply stand at attention instead of saluting in situations that normally call for it.



* '''The Head of State'''. Often the Commander-In-Chief of the armed forces, the Head Of State is the highest-ranked representative of the country, and is always to be saluted, regardless whether or not he/she is the real boss or a mere figurehead. This also applies to foreign heads of state on state and/or official visits.

to:

* '''The Head of State'''. State''': Often the Commander-In-Chief of the armed forces, the Head Of State is the highest-ranked representative of the country, and is always to be saluted, regardless whether or not he/she is the real boss or a mere figurehead. This also applies to foreign heads of state on state and/or official visits.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Franchise/MassEffect'' features this at several points; given that TheAlliance shares several similarities with the USMC and US Navy, the salute is American style. However, multiple times, they are shown saluting with their left hand, which is improper for pretty much every single military on Earth, which means it should be improper for a military force derived from those Earth militaries.

to:

* ''Franchise/MassEffect'' features this at several points; given that TheAlliance shares several similarities with the USMC and US Navy, the salute is American style. However, multiple times, they are shown saluting with their left hand, which is improper for pretty much every single military on Earth, which means it should be improper for a military force derived from those Earth militaries. This isn't even getting into the amount of times someone salutes indoors outside of an official capacity (much less wears a cover indoors).

Top