Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / DoubleConsciousness

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/CharlieChan'': In ''Keeper of the Keys'', Charlie brings up how he is considered "Americanized" by other Chinese who cling more closely to their cultural identity:
-->'''Charlie Chan:''' It overwhelms me with sadness to admit it ... for he is of my own origin, my own race, as you know. But when I look into his eyes I discover that a gulf like the heaving Pacific lies between us. Why? Because he, though among Caucasians many more years than I, still remains Chinese. As Chinese to-day as in the first moon of his existence. While I – I bear the brand – the label – Americanized... I traveled with the current... I was ambitious. I sought success. For what I have won, I paid the price. Am I an American? No. Am I, then, a Chinese? [[NoTrueScotsman Not in the eyes of Ah Sing]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Billionaire playboy Bruce Wayne is a completely different identity than crime fighting BadassNormal Franchise/{{Batman}}. Which one is the real identity and which is the facade, however, depends from writer to writer. Then there's the suggestion that, like Superman, Batman has three identities: the Playboy, the Dark Knight, and the "real" Bruce.

to:

* Billionaire playboy Bruce Wayne is a completely different identity than crime fighting BadassNormal Franchise/{{Batman}}. Which one is the real identity and which is the facade, however, depends from writer to writer. Then there's the suggestion that, like Superman, Batman has three identities: the Playboy, the Dark Knight, and the "real" Bruce.Bruce (possibly best portrayed by Creator/ChristianBale in ''Film/TheDarkKnightTrilogy''.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Since the main villains of the series are {{Puppeteer Parasite}}s, this also comes up with [[MagnificentBitch Visser One]] and [[TortureTechnician Taylor]]. The former was the first long-term Human-Controller, along with an assistant, and discovered that HumanityIsInfectious, especially when [[spoiler:the two had twins through their human hosts]]. Meanwhile, Taylor the Yeerk cannot differentiate between herself and her human host as easily as most Controllers, causing (or caused by?) her and possibly both of them becoming insane.

to:

** Since the main villains of the series are {{Puppeteer Parasite}}s, this also comes up with [[MagnificentBitch Visser One]] One and [[TortureTechnician Taylor]]. The former was the first long-term Human-Controller, along with an assistant, and discovered that HumanityIsInfectious, especially when [[spoiler:the two had twins through their human hosts]]. Meanwhile, Taylor the Yeerk cannot differentiate between herself and her human host as easily as most Controllers, causing (or caused by?) her and possibly both of them becoming insane.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added more useful trope references


People sometimes have trouble defining who they truly are. Sometimes this is a result of social labels, whether those categories are national, cultural, professional, ethnic, sexual, or any other frame of reference. When [[ChildOfTwoWorlds these things come into conflict with one another]], a person may feel divided, as if containing two or even more separate identities. This can also easily happen on a more personal level, as someone may present radically different faces and attitudes to friends, family, coworkers, and any other acquaintances in life.

In the realm of fantasy and sci-fi, there can be even more types of conflicting identities. The superhero for example that must live double lives: one as a hero and the other as a normal citizen. Often leads into an IdentityBreakdown when maintaining the delicate balance between these identities becomes too difficult to bear.

to:

People sometimes have trouble defining who they truly are. At some time or other, most people know what it is to feel like somebody different BeneathTheMask. Sometimes this is a result of social labels, whether those categories are national, cultural, professional, ethnic, sexual, or any other frame of reference. When [[ChildOfTwoWorlds these things come into conflict with one another]], a person may feel divided, as if containing two or even more separate identities. This can also easily happen on a more personal level, as someone may present radically different faces and attitudes to friends, family, coworkers, and any other acquaintances in life.

In the realm of fantasy and sci-fi, there can be even more types of conflicting identities. The superhero for example that must live double lives: one as a hero and the other as a normal citizen. Often leads into an IdentityBreakdown when maintaining the delicate balance between these identities becomes too difficult to bear.
bear. Or a monstrous character might have to put on a MonsterFacade that masks a gentle and complex personality.



Compare SecretIdentityIdentity, LivingADoubleLife, TheWhitestBlackGuy, ConflictingLoyalty. In extreme cases this can lead to SplitPersonality. See also DoubleThink.

to:

This character can be a PaperTiger, or they may have a HiddenHeartOfGold, but it only applies to this trope if the character feels a true conflict of identity from those different sides. Compare SecretIdentityIdentity, LivingADoubleLife, TheWhitestBlackGuy, ConflictingLoyalty. In extreme cases this can lead to SplitPersonality. See also DoubleThink.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Corrected grammar, added more humanistic and less reductive language, emphasized the actual trope


People sometimes have trouble defining who they truly are. Factors such as race, gender, culture, country origin, sexuality, class, and occupation can all play a role in a person's identity. But when [[ChildOfTwoWorlds these things come into conflict with one another]], a person may feel as if they are torn inside. They may feel as if they have two separate identities, or that their identity is divided into multiple facets.

Characters in fiction are no different. They too can sometimes suffer from a clash of identities. The superhero for example that must live double lives; one as a hero and the other as a normal citizen. Often leads into an IdentityBreakdown when maintaining the delicate balance between these identities becomes too difficult to bear.

to:

People sometimes have trouble defining who they truly are. Factors such as race, gender, culture, country origin, sexuality, class, and occupation can all play Sometimes this is a role in a person's identity. But when result of social labels, whether those categories are national, cultural, professional, ethnic, sexual, or any other frame of reference. When [[ChildOfTwoWorlds these things come into conflict with one another]], a person may feel divided, as if they are torn inside. They may feel as if they have containing two or even more separate identities, or that their identity is divided into multiple facets.

Characters in fiction are no different. They too
identities. This can sometimes suffer from also easily happen on a clash more personal level, as someone may present radically different faces and attitudes to friends, family, coworkers, and any other acquaintances in life.

In the realm
of fantasy and sci-fi, there can be even more types of conflicting identities. The superhero for example that must live double lives; lives: one as a hero and the other as a normal citizen. Often leads into an IdentityBreakdown when maintaining the delicate balance between these identities becomes too difficult to bear.



This term was coined by W.E.B. Du Bois in ''The Souls of Black Folk'' (1903). He used it in reference to African-Americans who struggle between the identities of being both American and Black in a country built off of their enslavement and dehumanization.

to:

This term was coined by W.E.B. Du Bois in ''The Souls of Black Folk'' (1903). He used it in reference to African-Americans who struggle between the identities of being both American and Black African in a country built off culture of their enslavement and dehumanization.
rigid racial discrimination.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**The idol singer Rise from Persona 4 goes through a bit of an identity crisis in her social link about finding a genuine personality outside of her stage name. By the end, she concludes that none of her fronts are inauthentic, and they are all her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


!!!'''In General:'''
* Characters of [[HalfHumanHybrid mixed species]] often feel this way. [[Franchise/StarTrek Spock]], for example.
!!!'''Series:'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The ''WesternAnimation/BatmanTheBraveAndTheBold'' version of Ted Kord, the second Comicbook/BlueBeetle, is a rare example of a superhero who has double consciousness ''without'' it overlapping with SecretIdentityIdentity: when he's working with Comicbook/{{Batman}} he's a tech-minded ScienceHero, when he's with Comicbook/BoosterGold, he's a fun-loving goof. When the three of them end up on an adventure together, he's visibly uncomfortable, since he doesn't know what register he's supposed to be in.

Added: 521

Changed: 1433

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''ComicBook/TheTransformers'' had a few examples of this. Early on in the series, the Autobot Skids is injured and goes MIA. He's tempted to ''stay'' missing so that he won't have to keep on fighting as a warrior and can go back to his true love, anthropology. In a later issue ("The Monstercon From Mars"), the Decepticon Pretender Skullgrin somehow winds up a genuine movie star thanks to using his monstrous appearance to play the role of a monster in an upcoming blockbuster. Despite the average Decepticon's opinion of humans tending to either be "target practice" or "totally irrelevant", Skullgrin actually quite enjoys the attention.
** The best example is likely Lord Zarak during the Headmasters limited series. He initially allied with the Decepticons in order to drive the Autobots off his homeworld of Nebulous, going so far as to become the Headmaster partner of Decepticon commander Scorponok. However, by the end of the limited series he is horrified that he's starting to lose his sense of where Zarak ends and Scorponok begins. In fact, by the time of his death in battle against Unicron, Zarak actually refers to ''himself'' as "Scorponok".

to:

* ''ComicBook/TheTransformers'' had a few examples of this. ''ComicBook/TheTransformersMarvel'':
**
Early on in the series, the Autobot Skids is injured and goes MIA. He's tempted to ''stay'' missing so that he won't have to keep on fighting as a warrior and can go back to his true love, anthropology. In a later issue ("The Monstercon From Mars"), the Decepticon Pretender Skullgrin somehow winds up a genuine movie star thanks to using his monstrous appearance to play the role of a monster in an upcoming blockbuster. Despite the average Decepticon's opinion of humans tending to either be "target practice" or "totally irrelevant", Skullgrin actually quite enjoys the attention.
** The best example is likely Lord Zarak during the Headmasters ''Headmasters'' limited series. He initially allied with the Decepticons in order to drive the Autobots off his homeworld of Nebulous, going so far as to become the Headmaster partner of Decepticon commander Scorponok. However, by the end of the limited series he is horrified that he's starting to lose his sense of where Zarak ends and Scorponok begins. In fact, by the time of his death in battle against Unicron, Zarak actually refers to ''himself'' as "Scorponok".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And some report even more, due to, among other things, associating and dealing with heavily diverse social circles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added link to identity breakdown


Characters in fiction are no different. They too can sometimes suffer from a clash of identities. The superhero for example that must live double lives; one as a hero and the other as a normal citizen.

to:

Characters in fiction are no different. They too can sometimes suffer from a clash of identities. The superhero for example that must live double lives; one as a hero and the other as a normal citizen.
citizen. Often leads into an IdentityBreakdown when maintaining the delicate balance between these identities becomes too difficult to bear.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This term was coined by W.E.B. Du Bois in ''The Souls of Black Folk'' (1903). He used it in reference to African-Americans who struggle between the identities of being both American and Black.

to:

This term was coined by W.E.B. Du Bois in ''The Souls of Black Folk'' (1903). He used it in reference to African-Americans who struggle between the identities of being both American and Black.
Black in a country built off of their enslavement and dehumanization.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Mightily Oats in ''Literature/CarpeJugulum'' doesn't quite have the SplitPersonality of Agnes/Perdita, but is both a faithful Omnian priest, and a rationalist who questions everything. At one point Granny Weatherwax returns to the land of the living by focusing on his prayers ... and the undercurrent of commentary about how much good praying's going to do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Intellectually Supported Tyranny is not supposed to have real life examples; also, the first example seems too objectively stated


* African-Americans and other minorities, immigrants, transgender people and many others often feel a double consciousness.

to:

* Many intellectuals have suggested that African-Americans and other minorities, immigrants, transgender people and many others often feel a double consciousness.



--> ''The important thing is that [[WrittenByTheWinners the glory of the winners’ ascendant fortune]] gives everything of theirs -- [[YouAreTheNewTrend even their dress]], [[StiffUpperLip their gait]], [[QuintessentialBritishGentleman their conversation]] -- [[MightyWhitey a radiance that makes them desirable]]. And people do not merely adopt them, [[YouWillBeAssimilated but are proud to adopt them]]. Then they bring forth, [[IntellectuallySupportedTyranny by means of intellectual arguments, many benefits of this]].''

to:

--> ''The important thing is that [[WrittenByTheWinners the glory of the winners’ ascendant fortune]] gives everything of theirs -- [[YouAreTheNewTrend even their dress]], [[StiffUpperLip their gait]], [[QuintessentialBritishGentleman their conversation]] -- [[MightyWhitey a radiance that makes them desirable]]. And people do not merely adopt them, [[YouWillBeAssimilated [[TheAssimilator but are proud to adopt them]]. Then they bring forth, [[IntellectuallySupportedTyranny by means of intellectual arguments, many benefits of this]].this.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Niko Bellic, protagonist of ''VideoGame/GrandTheftAutoIV'', is a veteran of UsefulNotes/TheYugoslavWars who immigrated to America, and is thus possessed of conflicting worldviews. On the one hand, he [[PapaWolf cares]] about his family and friends from Serbia, but is too [[ShellShockedVeteran traumatized]] by [[SociopathicSoldier war]] to live a normal life. On the other, he wants to build a [[UsefulNotes/TheAmericanDream new life]] in America, but is also [[PunchClockVillain hungry]] for wealth and believes he can only achieve it through [[BecauseImGoodAtIt crime]]. This can explain the {{Moral Dilemma}}s the game presents and even some instances of GameplayAndStorySegregation.

to:

* Niko Bellic, protagonist of ''VideoGame/GrandTheftAutoIV'', is a veteran of UsefulNotes/TheYugoslavWars who immigrated to America, and is thus possessed of conflicting worldviews. On the one hand, he [[PapaWolf cares]] about his family and friends from Serbia, but is too [[ShellShockedVeteran traumatized]] by [[SociopathicSoldier war]] to live a normal life. On the other, he wants to build a [[UsefulNotes/TheAmericanDream new life]] in America, but is also [[PunchClockVillain hungry]] for wealth and believes he can only achieve it through [[BecauseImGoodAtIt crime]]. This can explain the {{Moral Dilemma}}s Moral Dilemmas the game presents and even some instances of GameplayAndStorySegregation.

Top