History Main / BeggingTheQuestion

7th Nov '15 10:17:33 AM safari169
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Removed a non-example.
[[AC:{{Literature}}]] * When Van Helsing and company are investigating Lucy's grave in ''{{Literature/Dracula}}'', Dr. Seward argues "I am satisfied that Lucy's body is not in that coffin, but that only proves... that it is not there."
7th Oct '15 4:30:48 PM mynameis:
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Flamebait real life section
[[AC:{{Real Life}}]] * Watch the TV show ''Series/AncientAliens'' and marvel at how the proof there were aliens visiting the Earth in the past is how the theory there were aliens that visited the Earth in the past explains problems in history that are problems if you assume there were aliens who visited Earth in the past. * Descartes' so-called "proof" of the existence of God. Raymond Smullyan demonstrated that the only thing really proved by Descartes is that ''if'' there are one or more gods who fit Descartes' definition, then their properties must include existence; not that there necessarily is/are such a god or gods. * Today, even in Christian circles, it is considered a poor argument that a "proof" of the existence of God is that The Bible says there's a God, and then when pressed on why the Bible should be believed, to answer "Because it's God's word and God doesn't lie." Of course, those statements necessarily require that God exist in order for them to be true. ----
18th Sep '15 7:57:49 AM FerrousWill
Is there an issue? Send a Message
See also NoTrueScotsman. If you are arguing with someone and each of you thinks the other is BeggingTheQuestion, then your definitions are different and/or there is mutual ValuesDissonance.
to:
See also NoTrueScotsman. If you are arguing with someone and both parties accuse each of you thinks the other is of BeggingTheQuestion, then your definitions are different and/or there is mutual it's a philosophical impasse -- no one can agree on a common set of premise; compare ValuesDissonance.
24th Jul '15 6:01:55 PM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message
* Similar to the "mushrooms" example above, in MetalGearSolid3, Snake wants to know the difference between two snakes who look very similar, but one of which will poison him if he eats them. [[VoiceWithAnInternetConnection Para-Medic]] suggests an easy way to tell them apart: eat one. If it's poisonous, then he knows it's the poisonous one.
to:
* Similar to the "mushrooms" example above, in MetalGearSolid3, ''VideoGame/MetalGearSolid3SnakeEater'', Snake wants to know the difference between two snakes who look very similar, but one of which will poison him if he eats them. [[VoiceWithAnInternetConnection Para-Medic]] suggests an easy way to tell them apart: eat one. If it's poisonous, then he knows it's the poisonous one.
27th Mar '15 2:33:16 PM jmparker78
Is there an issue? Send a Message
* A common "proof" of the existence of God is that The Bible says there's a God. Fair enough on the surface, but pressed on why one should believe the Bible, the most common answer a follower of God will give is, "Because it's God's word and God doesn't lie." Of course, those statements necessarily require that God exist in order for them to be true.
to:
* A common Today, even in Christian circles, it is considered a poor argument that a "proof" of the existence of God is that The Bible says there's a God. Fair enough on the surface, but God, and then when pressed on why one the Bible should believe the Bible, the most common be believed, to answer a follower of God will give is, "Because it's God's word and God doesn't lie." Of course, those statements necessarily require that God exist in order for them to be true.
8th Mar '15 3:55:06 AM Fireblood
Is there an issue? Send a Message
* Descartes' so-called "proof" of the existence of God. Creator/RaymondSmullyan demonstrated that the only thing really proved by Descartes is that ''if'' there are one or more gods who fit Descartes' definition, then their properties must include existence; not that there necessarily is/are such a god or gods.
to:
* Descartes' so-called "proof" of the existence of God. Creator/RaymondSmullyan Raymond Smullyan demonstrated that the only thing really proved by Descartes is that ''if'' there are one or more gods who fit Descartes' definition, then their properties must include existence; not that there necessarily is/are such a god or gods.
24th Nov '14 11:59:05 AM Anorgil
Is there an issue? Send a Message
Added DiffLines:
[[AC:{{Literature}}]] * When Van Helsing and company are investigating Lucy's grave in ''{{Literature/Dracula}}'', Dr. Seward argues "I am satisfied that Lucy's body is not in that coffin, but that only proves... that it is not there."
24th Nov '14 11:43:27 AM Anorgil
Is there an issue? Send a Message
"Begging the question" is often used to mean "leading inevitably to the question" (similar to how something can be said to "invite criticism" or someone can be "asking for a smack") in popular media, though this usage is a common BerserkButton for academics aware of the original use noted above (It doesn't help that the academic meaning is not only horribly counter-intuitive[[note]]There's neither any question nor any begging involved[[/note]], but also a mistranslation). Nevertheless, to avoid confusion, this fallacy is sometimes referred to by its Latin name, ''petitio principii'' in more formal settings.
to:
"Begging the question" is often used to mean "leading inevitably to the question" (similar to how something can be said to "invite criticism" or someone can be "asking for a smack") in popular media, though this usage is a common BerserkButton for academics aware of the original use noted above (It doesn't help that the academic meaning is not only horribly counter-intuitive[[note]]There's neither any question nor any begging involved[[/note]], but also a mistranslation).mistranslation; as stated above, the original Latin means something more like "arguing the source"). Nevertheless, to avoid confusion, this fallacy is sometimes referred to by its Latin name, ''petitio principii'' in more formal settings.
24th Nov '14 11:40:35 AM Anorgil
Is there an issue? Send a Message
* Petitio principii (Latin: "pursuit of the source")
to:
* Petitio principii (Latin: "pursuit "pursuit/attack of the source")
24th Nov '14 11:38:49 AM Anorgil
Is there an issue? Send a Message
* Petitio principii
to:
* Petitio principii principii (Latin: "pursuit of the source")
This list shows the last 10 events of 57. Show all.