History Main / AnimalAthleteLoophole

20th Aug '16 11:15:48 AM Adeon
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Inverted in ''WebOriginal/{{Qwerpline}}'' with the sport of [[CalvinBall Sideball]]. Sideball teams are allowed to field up to six non-human players although raccoons ''are'' specifically banned.
18th Jul '16 10:25:07 PM PaulA
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* ''Film/{{Babe}}'': Ain't no rule that says a pig can't compete in a sheep herding dog trial! Actually, that one's more a trick of semantics, as the trial registration form requires "Name of Animal". The narrator even mentions that had it been "Name of Dog", [[WillNotTellALie they couldn't have entered Babe]]. This also happens in [[AdaptationDisplacement the book]]. The fields on the form there were "Name of Owner" and "Name of Entry".

to:

* ''Film/{{Babe}}'': Ain't no rule that says a pig can't compete in a sheep herding dog trial! Actually, that one's more a trick of semantics, as the trial registration form requires "Name of Animal". The narrator even mentions that had it been "Name of Dog", [[WillNotTellALie they couldn't have entered Babe]]. This also happens in [[AdaptationDisplacement the book]]. The fields on the form there were "Name of Owner" and "Name of Entry".



* ''Film/RacingStripes'', a kids' movie about a zebra that wants to be a racehorse. To quote TheOtherWiki's summary, ''It is similar in the style to the 1995 movie ''{{Babe}}'', in that the protagonist is a talking animal who lives on a farm and succeeds at an activity not expected of his species.'' While there's a greater similarity between horses and zebras than there are in most examples of the trope, even most ''horses'' can't compete as racehorses, because races are generally limited to a very specific breed of horse (thoroughbreds, quarter horses, ''etc.'') and these terms are minutely defined (often even to how the animal was ''conceived''); funny as it might sound, there's no way you could enter a zebra as a [[ExactWords "quarter horse"]] (with the implication being that [[ComicallyMissingThePoint the other three quarters are zebra]][[note]]The "quarter horse" is actually a breed of horse that is exceptionally good at sprinting short distances, so that stands a good chance of beating other breeds in a race of a ''quarter'' mile or less[[/note]]).

to:

* ''Film/RacingStripes'', a kids' movie about a zebra that wants to be a racehorse. To quote TheOtherWiki's summary, ''It is similar in the style to the 1995 movie ''{{Babe}}'', ''Film/{{Babe}}'', in that the protagonist is a talking animal who lives on a farm and succeeds at an activity not expected of his species.'' While there's a greater similarity between horses and zebras than there are in most examples of the trope, even most ''horses'' can't compete as racehorses, because races are generally limited to a very specific breed of horse (thoroughbreds, quarter horses, ''etc.'') and these terms are minutely defined (often even to how the animal was ''conceived''); funny as it might sound, there's no way you could enter a zebra as a [[ExactWords "quarter horse"]] (with the implication being that [[ComicallyMissingThePoint the other three quarters are zebra]][[note]]The "quarter horse" is actually a breed of horse that is exceptionally good at sprinting short distances, so that stands a good chance of beating other breeds in a race of a ''quarter'' mile or less[[/note]]).


Added DiffLines:

* ''The Sheep-Pig'' by Creator/DickKingSmith: Ain't no rule that says a pig can't compete in a sheep herding dog trial! Actually, that one's more a trick of semantics, as the trial registration form requires "Name of Entry", saving Babe's owner from the implicit lie that would have been involved had it been "Name of Dog".
23rd Jun '16 5:13:24 AM Doug86
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Subverted in ''{{Peanuts}}'', where there ain't no rule that says a dog can't play baseball... but he plays just like every other member of the team (and it's ''[[ButtMonkey Charlie Brown's]]'' team), and Snoopy sometimes gets mistaken for a short kid with a big nose. Except in the TV specials ''Charlie Brown's All Stars'' and ''It's Spring Training, Charlie Brown'', where in order to get into an organized league, the team must abide by its rules against animal players. In the latter, Lucy was not allowed as a girl, but [[RealLifeWritesThePlot Little League Baseball had changed its policies]] just in time for Lucy to play.

to:

* Subverted in ''{{Peanuts}}'', ''ComicStrip/{{Peanuts}}'', where there ain't no rule that says a dog can't play baseball... but he plays just like every other member of the team (and it's ''[[ButtMonkey Charlie Brown's]]'' team), and Snoopy sometimes gets mistaken for a short kid with a big nose. Except in the TV specials ''Charlie Brown's All Stars'' and ''It's Spring Training, Charlie Brown'', where in order to get into an organized league, the team must abide by its rules against animal players. In the latter, Lucy was not allowed as a girl, but [[RealLifeWritesThePlot Little League Baseball had changed its policies]] just in time for Lucy to play.
17th Jun '16 2:22:19 PM margdean56
Is there an issue? Send a Message


Just then, the power of plot reveals that the new kid owns TropeyTheWonderDog, an animal with astounding abilities which could make him a contender in this very sport! He petitions the team coach to try Tropey, where the dog's natural aptitude makes him an instant success. Come the night of the big game, out trots Tropey -- the other team may rant and rave, but there's nothing they can do about it. Why? [[AintNoRule Ain't no specific rule again' it!]] This is the Animal Athlete Loophole.

to:

Just then, the power of plot reveals that the new kid owns TropeyTheWonderDog, an animal with astounding abilities which could make him a contender in this very sport! He petitions the team coach to try Tropey, where the dog's natural aptitude makes him an instant success. Come the night of the big game, out trots Tropey -- the other team may rant and rave, but there's nothing they can do about it. Why? [[AintNoRule Ain't no specific rule again' agin' it!]] This is the Animal Athlete Loophole.
16th Jun '16 12:30:45 PM Jake
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/WorldWarZ'' has an example that's close to this trope in spirit when a wheelchair user shows up at a recruitment office for the local [[HomeGuard volunteer anti-zombie militia]] guarding a suburban neighbourhood in the SafeZone. It takes a certain amount of arm-twisting on his part, but the recruiters do eventually concede that anyone who can slog their way to said SafeZone through a ZombieApocalypse probably meets the definition of 'able-bodied' whether their legs work or not.
15th Jun '16 3:40:18 AM Snicka
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* In the short story "A verhetetlen tizenegy" ("The unbeatable eleven") by Hungarian writer György Moldova, a Hungarian football trainer [[AssignedToAntarctica assigned to Africa]] recruits a team of athletically talented great apes and returns with them to Hungary. The apes enter the football league and quickly become champions. Then the trope gets {{inverted}} when the team's manager tries to convince the trainer to get his not-too-bright son in the team, saying that there ain't no rule a human can't play in an all-ape team (and suggests that his son might wear a gorilla suit to not stand out too much).

to:

* In the short story "A verhetetlen tizenegy" ("The unbeatable eleven") by Hungarian writer György Moldova, a Hungarian football trainer [[AssignedToAntarctica [[ReassignedToAntarctica assigned to Africa]] recruits a team of athletically talented great apes and returns with them to Hungary. The apes enter the football league and quickly become champions. Then the trope gets {{inverted}} when the team's manager tries to convince the trainer to get his not-too-bright son in the team, saying that there ain't no rule a human can't play in an all-ape team (and suggests that his son might wear a gorilla suit to not stand out too much).
15th Jun '16 3:39:47 AM Snicka
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* In the short story "A verhetetlen tizenegy" ("The unbeatable eleven") by Hungarian writer György Moldova, a Hungarian football trainer [[AssignedToAntarctica assigned to Africa]] recruits a team of athletically talented great apes and returns with them to Hungary. The apes enter the football league and quickly become champions. Then the trope gets {{inverted}} when the team's manager tries to convince the trainer to get his not-too-bright son in the team, saying that there ain't no rule a human can't play in an all-ape team (and suggests that his son might wear a gorilla suit to not stand out too much).
2nd Apr '16 3:07:30 AM Morgenthaler
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* MisterEd steps up to the plate for the Los Angeles Dodgers in an episode.

to:

* MisterEd Series/MisterEd steps up to the plate for the Los Angeles Dodgers in an episode.
8th Feb '16 11:28:43 AM Ccook1956
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** 1936's ''Boulevardier From The Bronx'' had this all over the place. Dizzy Dan (rooster) has his Giants (players including a turtle, a pig and a dachshund) in Hickville for an exhibition game. A real cock-o'-the-walk, his team leads 3-0 going to the bottom of the ninth. Pitching, Dan loads the bases deliberately so he can get to Hickville's Claude (another rooster) and strike him out. On an 0-2 pitch, Claude hits a grand slam, winning for Hickville and getting the last laugh on Dan.

to:

** 1936's ''Boulevardier From The Bronx'' had this all over the place. Dizzy Dan (rooster) has his Giants (players including a turtle, a pig and a dachshund) in Hickville for an exhibition game. A real cock-o'-the-walk, his team leads 3-0 going to the bottom of the ninth. Pitching, Dan loads the bases deliberately with two out so he can get to Hickville's Claude (another rooster) and strike him out. On an 0-2 pitch, Claude hits a grand slam, winning for Hickville and getting the last laugh on Dan.
8th Feb '16 11:27:44 AM Ccook1956
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** 1936's ''Boulevardier From The Bronx'' had this all over the place. Dizzy Dan (rooster) has his Giants (players including a turtle, a pig and a dachshund) in Hickville for an exhibition game. A real cock-o'-the-walk, his team leads 3-0 going to the bottom of the ninth. Pitching, Dan loads the bases deliberately so he can get to Hickville's Clause (another rooster) and strike him out. On an 0-2 pitch, Claude hits a grand slam, winning for Hickville and getting the last laugh on Dan.

to:

** 1936's ''Boulevardier From The Bronx'' had this all over the place. Dizzy Dan (rooster) has his Giants (players including a turtle, a pig and a dachshund) in Hickville for an exhibition game. A real cock-o'-the-walk, his team leads 3-0 going to the bottom of the ninth. Pitching, Dan loads the bases deliberately so he can get to Hickville's Clause Claude (another rooster) and strike him out. On an 0-2 pitch, Claude hits a grand slam, winning for Hickville and getting the last laugh on Dan.
This list shows the last 10 events of 104. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Main.AnimalAthleteLoophole