Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / PrisonersOfPower

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* TheLostWoods: One of the major locations of the book is a huge forest that was once a battlefield for two of the states. By the time of the story, it is filled with minefields, camouflaged sentry guns, autonomous tanks and ballistic missile launchers, most still running on nuclear power and carrying out their patrols. The state, where most of the books story takes place, sends convicts into the forest to disarm the machinery, essentially making the convict camps throughout the woods death camps.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* KillerRobot: Of a UsedFuture, DieselPunk variety (but also relatively [[MohsScaleOfScienceFictionHardness realistic]] in that they are neither humanoid nor particularly intelligent). Saraksh is mostly at a 20th-century level of development, but has [[SchizoTech unusually advanced]] computer and nuclear technology -- so autonomous nuclear-powered robots were used during the War that turned it into a CrapsackWorld. When Maxim arrives, the planet's wilderness is filled with rusting, malfunctioning machines that are still attempting to follow their original instructions, attacking anything they perceive as an enemy while leaking poisonous radiation wherever they go. Maxim is originally stranded when his starship is shot down by an autonomous AA platform. He later comes across a rusting, highly radioactive robot tank rumbling through the landscape; fortunately it is too stupid and broken down to react to Maxim's presence. The evil government routinely sends political prisoners into the wilderness to try and disarm all the dangerous machinery, which generally amounts to a death sentence.

to:

* KillerRobot: Of a UsedFuture, DieselPunk variety (but also relatively [[MohsScaleOfScienceFictionHardness realistic]] realistic in that they are neither humanoid nor particularly intelligent). Saraksh is mostly at a 20th-century level of development, but has [[SchizoTech unusually advanced]] computer and nuclear technology -- so autonomous nuclear-powered robots were used during the War that turned it into a CrapsackWorld. When Maxim arrives, the planet's wilderness is filled with rusting, malfunctioning machines that are still attempting to follow their original instructions, attacking anything they perceive as an enemy while leaking poisonous radiation wherever they go. Maxim is originally stranded when his starship is shot down by an autonomous AA platform. He later comes across a rusting, highly radioactive robot tank rumbling through the landscape; fortunately it is too stupid and broken down to react to Maxim's presence. The evil government routinely sends political prisoners into the wilderness to try and disarm all the dangerous machinery, which generally amounts to a death sentence.

Added: 157

Removed: 171

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HappinessIsMandatory: The government is oppressive, highly corrupt and very incompetent, but still totally approved by the citizens - thank to MindControl.



* ZeroPercentApprovalRating: Averted. The government is oppressive, highly corrupt and very incompetent, but still totally approved by the citizens - thank to MindControl.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PunchClockVillain: The chilling effect of this trope played seriously is briefly explored. A captured insurgent sneeringly tells his interrogators that their hate and passion makes them ineffective at cracking him, because it's just too easy for him to see them as enemies who must be defied. Now, when he had been tortured by some small-time drones, who didn't give a shit about him or the reasons he'd been tortured for, and showed more passion at filing the accompanying paperwork or cursing their wretched pay than at sawing off his arm, then he'd been terrified to the bone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* BadassGrandpa: The statesman [[OnlyKnownByTheirNickname known as]] "The Wild Boar".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not a trope


* GermanRussians: Maxim Kammerer himself. He's ethnically German but lived in Leningrad (Moscow in the movie).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Prisoners of Power'' (original Russian title: ''Обитаемый остров'', lit. ''Inhabited Island'') is the sixth novel by the Creator/StrugatskyBrothers to be set in the Franchise/NoonUniverse. First serialized in a magazine in 1969, published in book form in 1971.

to:

''Prisoners of Power'' (original Russian title: ''Обитаемый остров'', lit. ''Inhabited Island'') is the sixth novel by the Creator/StrugatskyBrothers to be set in the Franchise/NoonUniverse.Literature/NoonUniverse. First serialized in a magazine in 1969, published in book form in 1971.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GermanRussians: Maxim Kammerer himself. He's ethnically German but lived in Leningrad (Moscow in the movie).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* KillerRobot: Of a UsedFuture, DieselPunk variety. Saraksh is mostly at a 20th-century level of development, but has [[SchizoTech unusually advanced]] computer and nuclear technology -- so autonomous nuclear-powered robots were used during the War that turned it into a CrapsackWorld. When Maxim arrives, the planet's wilderness is filled with rusting, malfunctioning machines that are still attempting to follow their original instructions, attacking anything they perceive as an enemy while leaking poisonous radiation wherever they go. Maxim is originally stranded when his starship is shot down by an autonomous AA platform. He later comes across a rusting, highly radioactive robot tank rumbling through the landscape; fortunately it is too stupid and broken down to react to Maxim's presence. The evil government routinely sends political prisoners into the wilderness to try and disarm all the dangerous machinery, which generally amounts to a death sentence.

to:

* KillerRobot: Of a UsedFuture, DieselPunk variety.variety (but also relatively [[MohsScaleOfScienceFictionHardness realistic]] in that they are neither humanoid nor particularly intelligent). Saraksh is mostly at a 20th-century level of development, but has [[SchizoTech unusually advanced]] computer and nuclear technology -- so autonomous nuclear-powered robots were used during the War that turned it into a CrapsackWorld. When Maxim arrives, the planet's wilderness is filled with rusting, malfunctioning machines that are still attempting to follow their original instructions, attacking anything they perceive as an enemy while leaking poisonous radiation wherever they go. Maxim is originally stranded when his starship is shot down by an autonomous AA platform. He later comes across a rusting, highly radioactive robot tank rumbling through the landscape; fortunately it is too stupid and broken down to react to Maxim's presence. The evil government routinely sends political prisoners into the wilderness to try and disarm all the dangerous machinery, which generally amounts to a death sentence.

Added: 2373

Changed: 393

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AfterTheEnd: The HumanAliens of Saraksh are the survivors of a nuclear war, and live in this kind of setting. Everything is radioactive, the countryside is filled with rusting, malfunctioning {{Killer Robot}}s, the world is divided between savage regimes squabbling over the remaining habitable scraps of land, and the best hope for preserving civilization may be a horribly oppressive dictatorial state that employs MindControl to keep its subjects in line. At one point in the story Maxim comes across old photos from before the war, showing a lush, beautiful planet filled with happy, prosperous people; he actually becomes ''angry'' thinking about how Saraksh's inhabitants ruined their world.



* ApocalypseHow: Saraksh's nuclear war was a Planetary Scale / Societal Disruption variety. Industrial civilization survives, but not in a particularly pleasant form, and doesn't seem likely to recover any time soon.



* DieselPunk: Saraksh's [[TheAestheticsOfTechnology aesthetic]] [[PlanetOfHats hat]].

to:

* CrapsackWorld: The story is a {{Robinsonade}} -- but instead of being stranded on a desert island, the protagonist is stranded on a horrible, ruined planet full of radiation, killer robots, oppressive dictatorial regimes, mind control technology, and the threat of a ''second'' nuclear war. No-one here is having a good time -- even the despots at the top of the social hierarchy must suffer.
* DieselPunk: Saraksh's [[TheAestheticsOfTechnology aesthetic]] [[PlanetOfHats hat]].hat]], with some UsedFuture mixed in.


Added DiffLines:

* KillerRobot: Of a UsedFuture, DieselPunk variety. Saraksh is mostly at a 20th-century level of development, but has [[SchizoTech unusually advanced]] computer and nuclear technology -- so autonomous nuclear-powered robots were used during the War that turned it into a CrapsackWorld. When Maxim arrives, the planet's wilderness is filled with rusting, malfunctioning machines that are still attempting to follow their original instructions, attacking anything they perceive as an enemy while leaking poisonous radiation wherever they go. Maxim is originally stranded when his starship is shot down by an autonomous AA platform. He later comes across a rusting, highly radioactive robot tank rumbling through the landscape; fortunately it is too stupid and broken down to react to Maxim's presence. The evil government routinely sends political prisoners into the wilderness to try and disarm all the dangerous machinery, which generally amounts to a death sentence.


Added DiffLines:

* UsedFuture: The planet Saraksh has some of this aesthetic, especially when we see the machinery left over from the War that turned it into a CrapsackWorld -- much of it still functioning, but very much worse for the wear. Provides a contrast to the 22nd-century Earth that is Maxim's homeworld -- which is more at a CrystalSpiresAndTogas level of development by this point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SchizoTech: Sarakshians have roughly World War II level tech and science, but their astronomical knowledge and worldview are practically at a prehistoric level due to the above mentioned atmospheric phenomenon. That also made them unable to work out normal flight physics and aviation is almost non-existent. However, they have achieved remarkable progress in nuclear physics and neurological sciences.

to:

* SchizoTech: Sarakshians have roughly World War II level tech and science, but their astronomical knowledge and worldview are practically at a prehistoric level due to the above mentioned atmospheric phenomenon. That also phenomenon (i.e. they believe they live on the ''inner surface'' of a sphere, and have no concept of "space" or even "celestial bodies"). This made it impossible for them unable to work out normal ballistic flight physics and their aviation technology is almost non-existent. very primitive. However, they have achieved remarkable progress in nuclear physics physics, computers, and the neurological sciences.sciences. Hence an otherwise 20th-century-type civilization with ''mind control'' technology -- and surrounded by scrap piles filled with autonomous, nuclear-powered {{Killer Robot}}s left over from their last war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LiteraryAllusionTitle: The original Russian title -- ''Inhabited Island'' -- is a reference to ''Literature/RobinsonCrusoe'' and other {{Robinsonade}} stories. Crusoe was stranded on a DesertedIsland, a term usually rendered in Russian as "an ''uninhabited island''." Maxim is stranded on a "desert island" as well, but this island is ''anything but'' "uninhabited" -- which turns out to be his main problem.all

to:

* LiteraryAllusionTitle: The original Russian title -- ''Inhabited Island'' -- is a reference to ''Literature/RobinsonCrusoe'' and other {{Robinsonade}} stories. Crusoe was stranded on a DesertedIsland, DesertedIsland -- a term trope usually rendered in Russian as "an ''uninhabited island''." Maxim is stranded on a "desert island" as well, but this island is ''anything but'' anything but "uninhabited" -- which turns out to be his main problem.all
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's a Cool Plane to the natives, but Anton, used to 22nd-century Earth technology, regards it as [[TheAllegedCar The Alleged Plane]].

to:

** It's a Cool Plane to the natives, but Anton, Maxim, used to 22nd-century Earth technology, regards it as [[TheAllegedCar The Alleged Plane]].



* LiteraryAllusionTitle: The original title was a play off ''Literature/RobinsonCrusoe''. Like Crusoe, Maxim is stranded on an unknown island, but this island is anything but uninhabited.

to:

* LiteraryAllusionTitle: The original Russian title -- ''Inhabited Island'' -- is a reference to ''Literature/RobinsonCrusoe'' and other {{Robinsonade}} stories. Crusoe was stranded on a play off ''Literature/RobinsonCrusoe''. Like Crusoe, DesertedIsland, a term usually rendered in Russian as "an ''uninhabited island''." Maxim is stranded on an unknown island, a "desert island" as well, but this island is anything but uninhabited.''anything but'' "uninhabited" -- which turns out to be his main problem.all
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's a Cool Plane to the natives, but Anton, used to 22nd-century Earth technology, regards it as [[TheAllegedCar The Alleged Plane]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Island Empire is obviously based on ImperialJapan.

to:

** Island Empire is obviously based on ImperialJapan.UsefulNotes/ImperialJapan.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AdaptationExplanationExtrication: The [[spoiler: "Dummkopf! Rotznase!"]] WhamLine doesn't have such an effect in the 2009 movie, since it's said with such a hard Russian accent that you won't at first realize it's in [[spoiler: German]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhamLine: "Dummkopf! Rotznase!" [[spoiler:This line is uttered by the Stranger, the supposed mastermind behind TheGovernment's tyranny on Saraksh, in ''German''--a Terran language, revealing him to Maxim as a fellow Earthling.]]

to:

* WhamLine: "Dummkopf! Rotznase!" [[spoiler:This line is uttered by the Stranger, the supposed mastermind behind TheGovernment's tyranny on Saraksh, in ''German''--a Terran language, revealing him to Maxim himself as a fellow Earthling.(very pissed-off) Earthling to Maxim.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatTheHellHero: [[spoiler:An unusual version in which Maxim and Rudolf (The Stranger who was one of the figures in charge) end up hurling that at each other - The Stranger for Maxim's [[DidNotThinkThisThrough hasty and hotheaded way of waging a revolution]], and Maxim back at him for [[TheEndJustifiesTheMeans cooperating with a tyrannical, genocidal, mind-controlling government]] to prevent anarchy]].]]

to:

* WhatTheHellHero: [[spoiler:An unusual version in which Maxim and Rudolf (The Stranger who was one of the figures in charge) end up hurling that at each other - The Stranger for Maxim's [[DidNotThinkThisThrough hasty and hotheaded way of waging a revolution]], and Maxim back at him for [[TheEndJustifiesTheMeans cooperating with a tyrannical, genocidal, mind-controlling government]] to prevent anarchy]].anarchy.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhamLine: [[spoiler: "Dummkopf! Rotznase!"]]
* WhatTheHellHero: [[An unusual version in which Maxim and Rudolf (The Stranger who was one of the figures in charge) end up hurling that at each other - The Stranger for Maxim's [[DidNotThinkThisThrough hasty and hotheaded way of waging a revolution]], and Maxim back at him for [[TheEndJustifiesTheMeans cooperating with a tyrannical, genocidal, mind-controlling government]] to prevent anarchy]].

to:

* WhamLine: [[spoiler: "Dummkopf! Rotznase!"]]
Rotznase!" [[spoiler:This line is uttered by the Stranger, the supposed mastermind behind TheGovernment's tyranny on Saraksh, in ''German''--a Terran language, revealing him to Maxim as a fellow Earthling.]]
* WhatTheHellHero: [[An [[spoiler:An unusual version in which Maxim and Rudolf (The Stranger who was one of the figures in charge) end up hurling that at each other - The Stranger for Maxim's [[DidNotThinkThisThrough hasty and hotheaded way of waging a revolution]], and Maxim back at him for [[TheEndJustifiesTheMeans cooperating with a tyrannical, genocidal, mind-controlling government]] to prevent anarchy]].]]

Added: 445

Changed: 443

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhamLine: [[spoiler: "Dumkopf! Rotznase!"]]

to:

* WellIntentionedExtremist: Deconstructed. [[spoiler: The Stranger, TheManBehindTheMan who stands at the top of the government food chain, has been trying to pull Saraksh out of the chaos. However, he only managed to achieve any semblance of order and stability by supporting and blending in with the corrupt dictatorship, which all goes down the drain once Maxim helms the resistance formed by all the malcontents and possibly causes a FullCircleRevolution]].
* WhamLine: [[spoiler: "Dumkopf! Rotznase!"]]"Dummkopf! Rotznase!"]]
* WhatTheHellHero: [[An unusual version in which Maxim and Rudolf (The Stranger who was one of the figures in charge) end up hurling that at each other - The Stranger for Maxim's [[DidNotThinkThisThrough hasty and hotheaded way of waging a revolution]], and Maxim back at him for [[TheEndJustifiesTheMeans cooperating with a tyrannical, genocidal, mind-controlling government]] to prevent anarchy]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
How To Create A Works Page explicitly says "No bolding is used for work titles."


'''''Prisoners of Power''''' (original Russian title: ''Обитаемый остров'', lit. ''Inhabited Island'') is the sixth novel by the Creator/StrugatskyBrothers to be set in the Franchise/NoonUniverse. First serialized in a magazine in 1969, published in book form in 1971.

to:

'''''Prisoners ''Prisoners of Power''''' Power'' (original Russian title: ''Обитаемый остров'', lit. ''Inhabited Island'') is the sixth novel by the Creator/StrugatskyBrothers to be set in the Franchise/NoonUniverse. First serialized in a magazine in 1969, published in book form in 1971.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NiceJobBreakingItHero: [[spoiler: Destroying the Centre, ruining the plan to save the country, not following safety instructions when making planet sweep to begin with.]]

to:

* NiceJobBreakingItHero: [[spoiler: Destroying the Centre, ruining the plan to save the country, not following safety instructions when making planet sweep to begin with.]]]] This has consequences in the larger 'verse, with Maxim's blunder being the final nail in the coffin of the program that allowed private citizens to explore the galaxy on their own. The program is shut down, and exploration is left to the professionals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheDreaded: The White Submarines.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


There are three versions of the novel - the original (all but impossible to find), the censored version (896 corrections) approved by the Soviet government (the basis for all official foreign translations) and the 'restored' version that reverts many -- but not all -- of the changes (the only version still in print). A movie adaptation premiered in Russia in December 2008. It has received [[AdaptationDecay rather poor reviews.]]

to:

There are three versions of the novel - the original (all but impossible to find), the censored version (896 corrections) approved by the Soviet government (the basis for all official foreign translations) and the 'restored' version that reverts many -- but not all -- of the changes (the only version still in print). A movie adaptation premiered in Russia in December 2008. It has received [[AdaptationDecay rather poor reviews.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Minor copy edits


'''''Prisoners of Power''''' (original Russian title: "Обитаемый остров", lit. "Inhabited Island") is the sixth novel by the Creator/StrugatskyBrothers to be set in the Franchise/NoonUniverse. First published in magazine form during 1969, published in book form during 1971.

The protagonist, Maxim Kammerer, is stranded on the AfterTheEnd CrapsackWorld of Saraksh, where the atmosphere has such enormous optical refraction, that the ''horizon seems to bend upwards''. After an atomic war, the planet is divided into several surviving rump empires. And all of them seem to be competing over who can be the most evil. The empire where he lands practices MindControl on the unwashed masses and FantasticRacism against those who can withstand their Mind Control methods. At first Maxim seems a bit of a FishOutOfTemporalWater, just trying to get back home and unable to comprehend the nature of what's happening around him, taking the propoganda at face value. He proceeds to uncover [[PoweredByAForsakenChild the truth]] and tries to improve the situation. How well he succeeds is debatable.

to:

'''''Prisoners of Power''''' (original Russian title: "Обитаемый остров", ''Обитаемый остров'', lit. "Inhabited Island") ''Inhabited Island'') is the sixth novel by the Creator/StrugatskyBrothers to be set in the Franchise/NoonUniverse. First published serialized in a magazine form during in 1969, published in book form during 1971.

in 1971.

The protagonist, Maxim Kammerer, is stranded on the AfterTheEnd CrapsackWorld of Saraksh, Saraksh where the atmosphere has such enormous optical refraction, refraction index that the ''horizon seems to bend upwards''. After an atomic a nuclear war, the planet is divided into several surviving rump empires. And all of them seem to be competing over who can be the most evil. The empire where he lands practices MindControl on the unwashed masses and FantasticRacism against those who can withstand their Mind Control methods. At first Maxim seems a bit of a FishOutOfTemporalWater, just trying to get back home and unable to comprehend the nature of what's happening around him, taking the propoganda at face value. He proceeds to uncover [[PoweredByAForsakenChild the truth]] and tries to improve the situation. How well he succeeds is debatable.



There are three versions of the novel - the original (all but impossible to find), the censored version (896 corrections) approved by the Soviet government (the basis for all official foreign translations) and the 'restored' version that returns lot of original ideas, but left some successful ones (the only version still in print). A movie adaptation premiered in Russia in December 2008. It has received [[AdaptationDecay rather poor reviews.]]

to:

There are three versions of the novel - the original (all but impossible to find), the censored version (896 corrections) approved by the Soviet government (the basis for all official foreign translations) and the 'restored' version that returns lot of original ideas, reverts many -- but left some successful ones not all -- of the changes (the only version still in print). A movie adaptation premiered in Russia in December 2008. It has received [[AdaptationDecay rather poor reviews.]]



* LaResistance: A certain percentage of people have innate PsychicBlockDefense against the mind towers' rays. Said rays, however, cause them horrible head pain. On this account, they are officially declared sub-human and ruthlessly persecuted, the true reason for which being, of course, that they are the only ones who have enough free will to topple the government. Even they, however, have fallen prey to apathy, lack of planning and extremism. [[spoiler: The heads of state are actually this exact kind of people, who just managed to grab viable power in time. Even they suffer from their own mind rays and have scientists relentlessly working on protection - to little effect. Some of resistance members are even recruited by leaders when they need replacement.]]

to:

* LaResistance: A certain percentage of people have innate PsychicBlockDefense against the mind towers' rays. Said rays, however, cause them horrible head pain.headaches. On this account, they are officially declared sub-human and ruthlessly persecuted, the true reason for which being, of course, that they are the only ones who have enough free will to topple the government. Even they, however, have fallen prey to apathy, lack of planning and extremism. [[spoiler: The heads of state are actually this exact kind of people, who just managed to grab viable power in time. Even they suffer from their own mind rays and have scientists relentlessly working on protection - to little effect. Some of resistance members are even recruited by leaders when they need replacement.]]



* LiteraryAllusionTitle: The original title was a play off ''Literature/RobinsonCrusoe''. Like Crusoe, Maxim is stranded on an unknown island, but this island is all ''but'' uninhabited.

to:

* LiteraryAllusionTitle: The original title was a play off ''Literature/RobinsonCrusoe''. Like Crusoe, Maxim is stranded on an unknown island, but this island is all ''but'' anything but uninhabited.



* TheLostWoods: One of the major locations of the book is a huge forest that was once a battlefield for two of the states. By the time of the story, it is filled with minefields, spring guns, autonomous tanks and ballistic missile launchers, most still running on nuclear power and carrying out their patrols. The state, where most of the books story takes place, sends convicts into the forest to disarm the machinery, essentially making the convict camps throughout the woods death camps.

to:

* TheLostWoods: One of the major locations of the book is a huge forest that was once a battlefield for two of the states. By the time of the story, it is filled with minefields, spring camouflaged sentry guns, autonomous tanks and ballistic missile launchers, most still running on nuclear power and carrying out their patrols. The state, where most of the books story takes place, sends convicts into the forest to disarm the machinery, essentially making the convict camps throughout the woods death camps.



* TwistEnding: "Dummkopf! Rotznase!" [[spoiler:It turns out, the Terrans were present on Saraksh the whole time and secretly steered it towards recovery--and Maxim has just ruined their entire plans.]]

to:

* TwistEnding: "Dummkopf! Rotznase!" [[spoiler:It turns out, the Terrans were present on Saraksh the whole time and secretly steered it towards recovery--and Maxim has just ruined their entire plans.plan.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WeAreStrugglingTogether: The mind-controlling totalitarian oligarchy is opposed by what may initially seem to be an unified rebel "Underground". However, to quote the novel itself, "the Underground wasn't a political party. What's more, it wasn't even a front of political parties". Its members couldn't even agree as to whether or not the mind control has to go. Factions range from blatant fascists (who want to overthrow the government and keep the mind control towers) to "biologists" (who just want to destroy the towers, but don't mind keeping the government - so they can't even agree about that), and there are factions within factions as well. It is explicitly pointed out that many prominent Underground leaders are either agents or secret allies of the government. The protagonist ultimately doesn't even bother trying to rally them, instead striking a deal with one of the less secure government leaders for inside information, recruiting a few of the more sensible Underground members and blowing up the mind control center without consulting anybody else. It is implied in later Noonverse novels that he and his allies then had to put down rebellions by some of the other groups, even though the country was already a terrible mess by then due to mind control withdrawal and such.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Island Empire is obviously based on ImperialJapan.

Top