History Heartwarming / GoneWithTheWind

16th Jul '16 8:02:27 PM toongrrl1990
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* YMMV because of the paternalistic racism, but Charles told Scarlett about how much Uncle Peter shaped his and Melanie's lives after their parents died and were left with a [[TheDitz ditzy]] and [[HystericalWoman shrill]] Aunt and a HeManWomanHater Uncle who berates said Aunt. Peter raised them, made the decision that Charles will attend Harvard instead of just the schools in Atlanta and when Melanie will put her hair up and attend balls.
24th Aug '15 9:21:48 PM Winters15
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* When the Yankees raid Tara and Scarlett keeps her mouth shut - [[MamaBear until they try to take Wade's sword]].
** Scarlett is definitely not a doting mother, especially to her two oldest children. Yet when Yankee troops raid Tara she is devastated but makes no move to protest - until they try to take Wade's sword. Scarlett's genuine reaction, that she can handle seeing them take anything but her little boy's most cherished possession, is both heartwarming and tear-jerking.

to:

* When Scarlett is definitely not a doting mother, especially to her two oldest children. Yet when the Yankees raid Tara and Scarlett keeps her mouth shut - [[MamaBear until they try to take Wade's sword]].
** Scarlett is definitely not a doting mother, especially to her two oldest children. Yet when Yankee troops raid Tara she is devastated but makes no move to protest - until they try to take Wade's sword.
sword]]. Scarlett's genuine reaction, that she can handle seeing them take anything but her little boy's most cherished possession, is both heartwarming and tear-jerking.
13th Jul '15 1:29:37 AM ElegantVamp
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Scarlett is definitely not a doting mother, especially to her two oldest children. Yet when Yankee troops raid Tara she is devastated but makes no move to protest - until they try to take Wade's sword. Scarlett's genuine reaction, that she can handle seeing them take anything but her little boy's most cherished possession, is both heartwarming and tear-jerking.
19th Oct '14 2:42:53 AM Evighet
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** One of the major things that drives her to make more and more money after the war is to make sure Wade will be safe and provided for, that he will be able to attend a good school and that he will have a good inheritance. She completely forgets the social status angle but it's not because she doesn't love her boy, it's because it doesn't occur to her that such a thing would matter anymore.



* When Melanie personally thanks HookerWithAHeartOfGold Belle Watling for providing an alibi for Rhett, Ashley and Dr. Wade after the shantytown raid. Though Belle is concerned about what this might do to Melanie's reputation, Melly dismisses such talk and says she's proud to know Belle.

to:

* When Melanie personally thanks HookerWithAHeartOfGold Belle Watling for providing an alibi for Rhett, Ashley and Dr. Wade Meade after the shantytown raid. Though Belle is concerned about what this might do to Melanie's reputation, Melly dismisses such talk and says she's proud to know Belle.


Added DiffLines:

* During a raid at Tara Melanie first flees with the others but once she's made sure they are safe she returns, even though she's still terribly weak from giving birth, and is the only one to show up and help Scarlett save Tara (also another CrowningMomentOfAwesome for both ladies). Afterward even Scarlett has to admit that her sister-in-law is always there when you need her.
* After Scarlett's miscarriage she does call for Rhett, even though he doesn't know it. Mostly though she calls for Melanie, needing her more than anybody else. It's actually debatable whether Rhett Butler is the great love of her life or if Melanie Wilkes is, albeit in a platonic sense of the word.
* Scarlett is actually very supportive and helpful to Melanie during Beau's birth, including encouraging her to forgo customs and scream as much as she likes. In the movie she's very gentle and understanding when Rhett asks what Melanie wants and she knows it's Ashley's picture and Charles' sword - things a pragmatic like Scarlett would probably feel are completely unimportant at a time like that.
3rd Jul '12 6:44:57 PM KennethMorgan
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* When Melanie personally thanks HookerWithAHeartOfGold Belle Watling for providing an alibi for Rhett, Ashley and Dr. Wade after the shantytown raid. Though Belle is concerned about what this might do to Melanie's reputation, Melly dismisses such talk and says she's proud to know Belle.

to:

* When Melanie personally thanks HookerWithAHeartOfGold Belle Watling for providing an alibi for Rhett, Ashley and Dr. Wade after the shantytown raid. Though Belle is concerned about what this might do to Melanie's reputation, Melly dismisses such talk and says she's proud to know Belle.
* Melanie giving up her wedding ring for the Confederate cause, and a genuinely-touched Rhett redeeming and returning the ring to her.
3rd Jul '12 6:32:23 PM KennethMorgan
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* After the rumours that Scarlett and Ashley are having an affair start, Rhett forces Scarlett to attend Ashley's party by herself in a provocative dress. Melanie's reaction to Scarlett's entrance is to walk over, kiss her on the cheek while complimenting her dress, lead her over to Ashley, and tell him to get Scarlett some punch. This also arguably qualifies as a CrowningMomentOfAwesome on her part for making it absolutely clear in her usual calm, polite way that her trust in her husband and sister-in-law will not be broken by gossip.

to:

* After the rumours that Scarlett and Ashley are having an affair start, Rhett forces Scarlett to attend Ashley's party by herself in a provocative dress. Melanie's reaction to Scarlett's entrance is to walk over, kiss her on the cheek while complimenting her dress, lead her over to Ashley, and tell him to get Scarlett some punch. This also arguably qualifies as a CrowningMomentOfAwesome on her part for making it absolutely clear in her usual calm, polite way that her trust in her husband and sister-in-law will not be broken by gossip. gossip.
* When Melanie personally thanks HookerWithAHeartOfGold Belle Watling for providing an alibi for Rhett, Ashley and Dr. Wade after the shantytown raid. Though Belle is concerned about what this might do to Melanie's reputation, Melly dismisses such talk and says she's proud to know Belle.
24th Apr '12 4:04:55 PM 6
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* After the rumours that Scarlett and Ashley are having an affair start, Rhett forces Scarlett to attend Ashley's party by herself in a provocative dress. Melanie's reaction to Scarlett's entrance is to walk over, kiss her on the cheek while complimenting her dress, lead her over to Ashley, and tell him to get Scarlett some punch. This also arguably qualifies as a CrowningMomentOfAwesome on her part for making it absolutely clear in her usual calm, polite way that her trust in her husband and sister-in-law will not be broken by gossip.
24th Jul '11 2:30:07 AM Pingvin
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* In the book, when the Yankees raid Tara and Scarlett keeps her mouth shut - [[MamaBear until they try to take Wade's sword]].

to:

* In the book, when When the Yankees raid Tara and Scarlett keeps her mouth shut - [[MamaBear until they try to take Wade's sword]].


Added DiffLines:

* When Pork gets shot trying to steal food for everyone at Tara Scarlett tells him how grateful she is to him and promises to buy him a gold watch when she can afford it. When Gerald dies she gives Pork ''his'' watch, knowing how much it would mean.
10th Jul '11 12:41:34 PM Pingvin
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* The talk Rhett and Wade have on the day Bonnie is born.
8th Jul '11 3:42:48 PM Pingvin
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming: In the book, when the Yankees raid Tara and Scarlett keeps her mouth shut - [[MamaBear until they try to take Wade's sword]].

to:

* CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming: In the book, when the Yankees raid Tara and Scarlett keeps her mouth shut - [[MamaBear until they try to take Wade's sword]].
This list shows the last 10 events of 11. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Heartwarming.GoneWithTheWind