History Headscratchers / WinxClub

12th May '17 4:10:57 PM fairygirl567
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

**** I agree with that too, I know the creator mentioned that witches and fairies can change and stuff like that, but it's problematic to me that two witches on the show, one being a villain, became good guys by deciding to become fairies and not just be good witches. There are good and bad wizards on the show who never change their powers, so why witches and fairies?
12th May '17 4:06:08 PM fairygirl567
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Honestly, she could be the age of a normal adult or she could be over hundreds of years old. It's shown in the show that magical beings, like fairies, age slower. Faragonda turned out to be at least over a 100 years old so it could go either way.


Added DiffLines:

*** It still kind of gives off unfortunate implications since two witches, Mirta and the 6th season villain Selina, have decided to become fairies at the end instead of just being good witches and using their powers for good. It's obivious they aren't trying to be mean or biased towards witches, though.
12th May '17 3:54:13 PM fairygirl567
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Um... nothing really major just something I know that bothers fans including me, Bloom acts so coldly towards her adopted parents after finding out about said adoption and starts calling them Mike and Vannessa but is so close to her real ones who she barley knows. I found this weird because Bloom's adopted parents treated her well and loved them but after finding out the truth she treated them like they were always her foster parents. Now I don't know any adopted people so I'm not sure this 100% realistic but on the other hand this could be how some adopted kids act so it's not my place to judge I'm just glad her real parents were super nice and fun because if they weren't I don't know what I'd do then. I'm glad her adopted parents are still in the picture though so at least she can say she has 4 parents to love! Lucky Mary Sue :)

to:

*** Hi, I'm the person who posted the explanation that Miele might have been 10 or 13 in her first appearance and that's why she was 16 in the sixth season. Yeah after reading the reply to my stupid explanation, I have to agree that my reason makes no sense and is just wild guessing. Even if the aging is different for fairies, which it isn't since Bloom, Roxy and Selenia aged like normal teenage girls, I doubt a ten-year-old would be the size of a six-year-old unless she had a medical condition. I figured out, or guessed, that the writers wanted to bring this character back, but they needed a good reason so they bumped her age to 16, this is just wild guessing again, but it makes more sense than my old explanation. Sorry.
* Um... nothing really major just something I know that bothers fans including me, Bloom acts so coldly towards her adopted parents after finding out about said adoption and starts calling them Mike and Vannessa but is so close to her real ones who she barley barely knows. I found this weird because Bloom's adopted parents treated her well and loved them but after finding out the truth she treated them like they were always her foster parents. Now I don't know any adopted people so I'm not sure this 100% realistic but on the other hand this could be how some adopted kids act so it's not my place to judge I'm just glad her real parents were super nice and fun because if they weren't I don't know what I'd do then. I'm glad her adopted parents are still in the picture though so at least she can say she has 4 parents to love! Lucky Mary Sue :)



* Why don't we ever see Daphne as a stronger fighter? In the fights this troper has seen, she always seems to be at the same level as the Winx and has had to wait for Bloom to bail them all out of a fight in at least one case. But she's a nymph, and should be a whole lot more powerful then any of the Winx. Why don't we ever see her put that nymph mask back and start curbstomping the villains who attack.

to:

* Why don't we ever see Daphne as a stronger fighter? In the fights this troper has seen, she always seems to be at the same level as the Winx and has had to wait for Bloom to bail them all out of a fight in at least one case. But she's a nymph, and should be a whole lot more powerful then than any of the Winx. Why don't we ever see her put that nymph mask back and start curbstomping the villains who attack.attack?
** My guess is they wanted to focus more on the Winx club girls and decided to have Daphne be the faithful big sister.


Added DiffLines:

** Basically negative continuity. Which isn't really a bad thing, it's just they seemed to want to add in a new villain who knew Bloom and that was the best way to explain it.


Added DiffLines:

*A minor gripe that still bothers me, but why did they marry Daphne off to some random guy? I know he happened to be Sky's cousin, which also isn't explained well and also comes off as weird since that's still Sky's cousin. Wouldn't Bloom find that odd and weird? And if the math is done right, they were only together for a month and a half, at most. To be fair, in history people have gotten married after a short time of being together... some quicker then others, but Daphne just got brought back to life after 18 years of being a spirit. Shouldn't she be, like, preparing to rule her kingdom? Or marrying an actual prince on Domino to help rebuild the kingdom? I know this isn't a huge thing, but it really bothers me. Sorry for complaining if it bothers anyone.
26th Apr '17 10:26:03 AM sailorjade125
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Why didn't Bloom try to use [[ForgottenPhlebotinum her healing powers]] to save Nabu?

to:

* Why didn't Bloom try to use [[ForgottenPhlebotinum [[Forgotten Phlebotinum her healing powers]] to save Nabu?


Added DiffLines:

** Its possible there are some they are just living in hiding from the wizards and was questioning the good idea of telling all nonmagical people of earth that magic exists which the winx were doing. Or back when the back started going after the faires the two sides made of deal that the wizards would leave the witches alone if the witches didn't help the faires.
22nd Dec '16 8:40:07 PM SailorTardis
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** If I remember correctly, she was ambushed and was forced to take the fight to earth.
22nd Nov '16 2:24:23 PM cheedo
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Back to episode 1- was it ever explained exactly what Stella was doing on earth to begin with?
6th Oct '16 11:33:55 PM Asking
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

*** Because a 13-year-old child would ''not'' be that small! Looking young is one thing. Being the size of a toddler is another. Even a ten-year-old child would be taller than that. What you're going into is essentially WildMassGuessing. Nothing in the show suggests fairies age differently than humans. Miele's age in season 3 is never officially stated, so it is possible she was six, give or take a few years. Considering Winx was supposed to end after the first movie, Miele probably was never meant to be seen again, so the writers of the show at that time didn't think to give her a proper age. The current writers have retconned several plot points already, so as the first answerer said, Miele is 16 in season 6 because the writers wanted her to be 16. That's it.
6th Oct '16 11:21:27 PM Asking
Is there an issue? Send a Message



to:

* My question is [[https://le-winx.tumblr.com/post/150437409908/kaye-star-random-thought-that-occurred-to-me here]]. Why would the creators change an already very modest outfit to a less modest one if the girls aren't supposed to be dressing so {{Stripperiffic}} anymore?
21st Aug '16 3:08:53 PM Christy
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Why don't we ever see Daphne as a stronger fighter? In the fights this troper has seen, she always seems to be at the same level as the Winx and has had to wait for Bloom to bail them all out of a fight in at least one case. But she's a nymph, and should be a whole lot more powerful then any of the Winx. Why don't we ever see her put that nymph mask back and start curbstomping the villains who attack?

to:

* Why don't we ever see Daphne as a stronger fighter? In the fights this troper has seen, she always seems to be at the same level as the Winx and has had to wait for Bloom to bail them all out of a fight in at least one case. But she's a nymph, and should be a whole lot more powerful then any of the Winx. Why don't we ever see her put that nymph mask back and start curbstomping the villains who attack?
attack.
* If Roxy was the last Earth fairy, how did Selina go unnoticed by the Black Circle? Bloom's powers hadn't manifested yet but a younger Selina is shown training under Eldora.... on Earth. What the hell?
19th May '16 7:20:46 PM fairygirl567
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Okay, sorry but are we so ignorant about Miele's age that we can't rule that maybe she was 13 in season 3?! I counted and if Flora was 18 in the 3rd season and Miele is in Alfea (Or whatever the school was called) college in season 6 then maybe she was freaking 13! I mean thirteen year old kids can still look young. She might even by 10 or 12 because if you count by season 3 plus the movies she'd be around fifteen if she was ten and seventeen if she was twelve! If she was ten and got into an Alfea college at 15 that would make sense she could've gotten into college early, it can happen. She probably isn't six because if you search for pictures of her doubt she looks around 10, 12 or 13. We can't factor that out, then there's the added part that maybe the people on Flora's planet look different when they age. I hope this didn't come off as rude.
* Um... nothing really major just something I know that bothers fans including me, Bloom acts so coldly towards her adopted parents after finding out about said adoption and starts calling them Mike and Vannessa but is so close to her real ones who she barley knows. I found this weird because Bloom's adopted parents treated her well and loved them but after finding out the truth she treated them like they were always her foster parents. Now I don't know any adopted people so I'm not sure this 100% realistic but on the other hand this could be how some adopted kids act so it's not my place to judge I'm just glad her real parents were super nice and fun because if they weren't idk what I'd do then. I'm glad her adopted parents are still in the picture though so at least she can say she has 4 parents to love! Lucky Mary Sue :)

to:

** Okay, sorry but but... are we so ignorant about Miele's age that we can't rule just suggest that maybe she was 13 in season 3?! 3? I counted and if Flora was 18 in the 3rd season and Miele is in Alfea (Or whatever the school was called) college in season 6 then maybe she was freaking 13! I mean thirteen year old kids can still look young. She might even by 10 or 12 because if you count by season 3 3, plus the movies movies, she'd be around fifteen if she was ten 10 and seventeen if she was twelve! 12! If she was ten and got into an Alfea college at 15 that would make sense sense, she could've gotten into college early, it can happen. She probably isn't Bloom got in pretty easily. She's not six or eight because if you search for pictures of her doubt she looks looking around 10, 12 or 13. We can't factor that out, then out. Then there's the added part that maybe the people on Flora's planet look different when they age. I hope age differently, this didn't come off as rude.
is another universe. This troper is just saying that we shouldn't take out all the options.
* Um... nothing really major just something I know that bothers fans including me, Bloom acts so coldly towards her adopted parents after finding out about said adoption and starts calling them Mike and Vannessa but is so close to her real ones who she barley knows. I found this weird because Bloom's adopted parents treated her well and loved them but after finding out the truth she treated them like they were always her foster parents. Now I don't know any adopted people so I'm not sure this 100% realistic but on the other hand this could be how some adopted kids act so it's not my place to judge I'm just glad her real parents were super nice and fun because if they weren't idk I don't know what I'd do then. I'm glad her adopted parents are still in the picture though so at least she can say she has 4 parents to love! Lucky Mary Sue :):)
** I had found that annoying as well. Sure they didn't tell her she was adopted, but they didn't abuse her and raised her pretty well. I don't exactly get how that relationship works in real life, but I doubt it would be like this.
This list shows the last 10 events of 187. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Headscratchers.WinxClub