History Headscratchers / TreasurePlanet

18th Nov '17 1:26:09 PM sugaricequeen
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* How did Amelia recover so quickly? That blast must have caused some serious injury, which, as stated above, was originally supposed to be bleeding. She even becomes too weak to think straight. But when the pirates capture them, she's completely fine again. Doppler can't heal and I doubt that B.E.N or the pirates had any first-aid kit, and even if the latter ones had, they probably wouldn't help her anyway.

to:

* How did Amelia recover so quickly? That blast must have caused some serious injury, which, as stated above, was originally supposed to be bleeding. She even becomes too weak to think straight. But when the pirates capture them, she's completely fine again. Doppler can't heal and I doubt that B.E.N or the pirates had any first-aid kit, and even if the latter ones had, they probably wouldn't help her anyway.anyway.
** Actually, she's not completely fine after being captured. When she and Doppler take back the Legacy, we see that she's still injured enough to have to leave piloting the ship to him, and she continues to clutch the spot where she was injured with one hand. Mayhaps the weakness that kept her from thinking coherently was her going through the worst part of her recovery, and she'd gotten over it by the time they went looking for the treasure.
29th Oct '17 6:29:44 PM Tightwire
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** My theory is that Silver was planning to let Jim go afterwards and maybe even pay him off to stay quiet. Once he'd found the treasure, he didn't worry about Jim leaving - the only reason he cared about the boat Jim was taking was because all the rest of the treasure was washing away.



** She's supposed to be bleeding but that was cut so I think she had something like shrapnel in her side, probably missed her lung or she might have just been pretending to be fine, [[spoiler: especially when the pirates turned up]] and for her arm, she might have damaged the nerves in her elbow or something so she can hardly move her arm. I once ran into a wall and had to keep my arm in the position of having it in a sling because straightening it out hurt too much. After a while it was fine, like how Amelia's arm was later on in the climax.
** She could bruised her ribs and arm. I once slammed my thumb and finger into my bedpost and it felt like I'd chopped them off. My thumb was sore for a few months after that, so it could be that she just couldn't move her arm without feeling intense pain.
** There was a shot where Amelia clutches her side, and then they look at her palm, which is covered in red blood. It made it right into the theatrical release, but was cut for the general release because Disney really hates blood. If this had been left in, you would have seen that her injury is genuinely life-threatening. Taken out, she just looks like she's sprained something.

to:

** She's supposed to be bleeding but that was cut so I think she had something like shrapnel in her side, probably missed her lung or she might have just been pretending to be fine, [[spoiler: especially when the pirates turned up]] and for her arm, she might have damaged the nerves in her elbow or something so she can hardly move her arm. I once ran into a wall and had to keep my arm in the position of having it in a sling because straightening it out hurt too much. After a while it was fine, like how Amelia's arm was later on in the climax.
** She could bruised her ribs and arm. I once slammed my thumb and finger into my bedpost and it felt like I'd chopped them off. My thumb was sore for a few months after that, so it could be that she just couldn't move her arm without feeling intense pain.
** There was a shot where Amelia clutches her side, and then later they look at her palm, which is covered in red blood. It made it right into the theatrical release, but was cut for the general home release because Disney really hates blood. If this had been left in, you would have seen that her injury is genuinely life-threatening. Taken out, she just looks like she's sprained something.



** I don't see why he couldn't, really...He can turn himself into a miniature pie and throw himself at someone - what's wrong with Jim or Silver lobbing him down off the ship and telling him just to poke somewhere on the glowing green globe that was right nearby? It wouldn't even need to be their home planet that he selected; at that point, in the face of a giant explosion, practically ''anywhere'' would've been optimal.

to:

** I don't see why he couldn't, really... He can turn himself into a miniature pie and throw himself at someone - what's wrong with Jim or Silver lobbing him down off the ship and telling him just to poke somewhere on the glowing green globe that was right nearby? It wouldn't even need to be their home planet that he selected; at that point, in the face of a giant explosion, practically ''anywhere'' would've been optimal.



* How did Amelia recover so quickly? That blast must have caused some sirious injury, which, as stated above, was originally supposed to be bleeding. She even becomes too weak to think straight. But when the pirates capture them, she's completely fine again. Doppler can't heal and I doubt that B.E.N or the pirates had any first-aid kit, and even if the latter ones had, they probably wouldn't help her anyway.

to:

* How did Amelia recover so quickly? That blast must have caused some sirious serious injury, which, as stated above, was originally supposed to be bleeding. She even becomes too weak to think straight. But when the pirates capture them, she's completely fine again. Doppler can't heal and I doubt that B.E.N or the pirates had any first-aid kit, and even if the latter ones had, they probably wouldn't help her anyway.
21st Sep '17 9:13:22 AM koltai91
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** My idea on this one is that Billy Bones was Flint's most loyal man. I think that either Flint asked him to take the orb and leave him in the core before setting up the trap, or, some time after Flint 's death, Bones returned to the planet and tried to take the orb to safety. The rest of the crew propably died, but we don't know how long these lizard people live, and there's no way Bones was just a random sailor, because a random sailor wouldn't know the orb is important, and would just give it away to the cyborg who is interested.

to:

** My idea on this one is that Billy Bones was Flint's most loyal man. I think that either Flint asked him to take the orb and leave him in the core before setting up the trap, or, some time after Flint 's death, Bones returned to the planet and tried to take the orb to safety. The rest of the crew propably died, but we don't know how long these lizard people live, and there's no way Bones was just a random sailor, sailor who just happened to stumble into the map, because a random sailor wouldn't know the orb is important, and would just give it away to the cyborg who is interested.
21st Sep '17 9:12:04 AM koltai91
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

**My idea on this one is that Billy Bones was Flint's most loyal man. I think that either Flint asked him to take the orb and leave him in the core before setting up the trap, or, some time after Flint 's death, Bones returned to the planet and tried to take the orb to safety. The rest of the crew propably died, but we don't know how long these lizard people live, and there's no way Bones was just a random sailor, because a random sailor wouldn't know the orb is important, and would just give it away to the cyborg who is interested.
21st Sep '17 8:55:30 AM koltai91
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* How did Amelia recover so quickly? That blast must have caused some sirious injury, which, as stated above, was originally supposed to be bleeding. She even becomes too weak to think straight. But when the pirates capture them, she's completely fine again. Doppler can't heal and I doupt that B.E.N or the pirates had any first-aid kit, and even if the latter ones had, they probably wouldn't help her anyway.

to:

* How did Amelia recover so quickly? That blast must have caused some sirious injury, which, as stated above, was originally supposed to be bleeding. She even becomes too weak to think straight. But when the pirates capture them, she's completely fine again. Doppler can't heal and I doupt doubt that B.E.N or the pirates had any first-aid kit, and even if the latter ones had, they probably wouldn't help her anyway.
21st Sep '17 8:54:58 AM koltai91
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** There just seems to be so many types of aliens. No two aliens seem to be of the same species (although Doppler and Captain Amelia are debatable). Humans, like these aliens, are spread out all over the galaxy. There could well be humans on Montressor. Perhaps if Jim wanted to meet human girls, he could... well, go on an intergalactic dating site.

to:

** There just seems to be so many types of aliens. No two aliens seem to be of the same species (although Doppler and Captain Amelia are debatable). Humans, like these aliens, are spread out all over the galaxy. There could well be humans on Montressor. Perhaps if Jim wanted to meet human girls, he could... well, go on an intergalactic dating site.site.
*How did Amelia recover so quickly? That blast must have caused some sirious injury, which, as stated above, was originally supposed to be bleeding. She even becomes too weak to think straight. But when the pirates capture them, she's completely fine again. Doppler can't heal and I doupt that B.E.N or the pirates had any first-aid kit, and even if the latter ones had, they probably wouldn't help her anyway.
1st Jun '17 4:09:47 PM Tightwire
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Why are Jim and his mother (and father) the only human characters in the film? Dr. Doppler, Amelia, Silver, Scroop, the other crew members, and the people in the inn and at the spaceport all seem to be aliens - where did Jim's family come from? Are they the last of their kind?

to:

* Why are Jim and his mother (and father) the only human characters in the film? Dr. Doppler, Amelia, Silver, Scroop, the other crew members, and the people in the inn and at the spaceport all seem to be aliens - where did Jim's family come from? Are they the last of their kind?kind?
** There just seems to be so many types of aliens. No two aliens seem to be of the same species (although Doppler and Captain Amelia are debatable). Humans, like these aliens, are spread out all over the galaxy. There could well be humans on Montressor. Perhaps if Jim wanted to meet human girls, he could... well, go on an intergalactic dating site.
29th Sep '16 1:00:19 PM Kassiopeia
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Probably unimportant things, like the kitchen stoves. He was just pulling out plugs at random - if one of them happened to be for something important (and obvious, such as the lights or artificial gravity), he would just plug it back in and try another.



** He says that he lost his ''primary'' memory circuit...So maybe before Flint pulled it, he uploaded his other memories not concerning the booby traps to a secondary memory circuit he had inside him (most likely very quickly and haphazardly, which is why he can only remember bits and pieces of everything later on), and that was where his future memories were stored until Jim reinstalled his primary one.

to:

** He says that he lost his ''primary'' memory circuit...So maybe before Flint pulled it, he uploaded his other memories not concerning the booby traps to a secondary memory circuit he had inside him (most likely very quickly and haphazardly, which is why he can only remember bits and pieces of everything later on), and that was where his future memories were stored until Jim reinstalled his primary one.one.
* Why are Jim and his mother (and father) the only human characters in the film? Dr. Doppler, Amelia, Silver, Scroop, the other crew members, and the people in the inn and at the spaceport all seem to be aliens - where did Jim's family come from? Are they the last of their kind?
19th Sep '16 8:37:48 AM QuarrelsomeChevon
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* B.E.N states the Flint pulled out his memory chip and as a result B.E.N has a poor memory. The question is how could B.E.N have any memory of the past without his memory unit (he mentions remembering Flint's treasure being buried in the center of something and the door opening and closing; memories that would've been stored in his memory chip... which he didn't have at the time)? Also, how could B.E.N have formed any new memories such as remembering where his new home was?

to:

* B.E.N states the Flint pulled out his memory chip and as a result B.E.N has a poor memory. The question is how could B.E.N have any memory of the past without his memory unit (he mentions remembering Flint's treasure being buried in the center of something and the door opening and closing; memories that would've been stored in his memory chip... which he didn't have at the time)? Also, how could B.E.N have formed any new memories such as remembering where his new home was?was?
** He says that he lost his ''primary'' memory circuit...So maybe before Flint pulled it, he uploaded his other memories not concerning the booby traps to a secondary memory circuit he had inside him (most likely very quickly and haphazardly, which is why he can only remember bits and pieces of everything later on), and that was where his future memories were stored until Jim reinstalled his primary one.
4th Sep '16 12:00:38 AM BroTim11
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* When they went to the ship to disable the Cannons, B.E.N did so with difficulty. After the fight with Scroop, B.E.N emreges wrapped in sparking wire and declaring the cannons disabled. What else B.E.N may have disabled? (though maybe this should go in FridgeLogic or FridgeHorror)

to:

* When they went to the ship to disable the Cannons, B.E.N did so with difficulty. After the fight with Scroop, B.E.N emreges wrapped in sparking wire wires and declaring the cannons disabled. What else B.E.N may have disabled? (though maybe this should go in FridgeLogic or FridgeHorror)FridgeHorror)
* B.E.N states the Flint pulled out his memory chip and as a result B.E.N has a poor memory. The question is how could B.E.N have any memory of the past without his memory unit (he mentions remembering Flint's treasure being buried in the center of something and the door opening and closing; memories that would've been stored in his memory chip... which he didn't have at the time)? Also, how could B.E.N have formed any new memories such as remembering where his new home was?
This list shows the last 10 events of 54. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Headscratchers.TreasurePlanet