History Headscratchers / TheVillage

1st Sep '17 6:58:33 PM Delphi
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* In the time period the village based itself on, wood was an incredibly important resource that was harvested almost constantly. But they're not allowed in the woods. If it was "don't go in the woods ''at night,"'' I could understand it, but they can't go in them ''at all.'' So how do they survive the winter when they can't got in the woods to get firewood? Or cook their food, or make new houses or tools?

to:

* In the time period the village based itself on, wood was an incredibly important resource that was harvested almost constantly. But they're not allowed in the woods. If it was "don't go in the woods ''at night,"'' I could understand it, but they can't go in them ''at all.'' So how do they survive the winter when they can't got go in the woods to get firewood? Or cook their food, or make new houses or tools?
1st Sep '17 6:56:51 PM Delphi
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* In the time period the village based itself on, wood was an incredibly important resource that was harvested almost constantly. But they're not allowed in the woods. If it was "don't go in the woods ''at night,"'' I could understand it, but they can't go in them ''at all.'' So how do they survive the winter when they can't got in the woods to get firewood? Or cook their food, or make new houses or tools?
* So the village founders wanted to get away from a corrupt modern society, I get it. But why couldn't they take medicine with them? I know it was the seventies, but iirc Lucius didn't need anything fancy, just a simple antibiotic. They couldn't have taken some of those with them? Especially since, as pointed out above, a small isolated village would be very vulnerable to disease.
31st Aug '17 3:35:33 PM Darkmage7280
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** It did tricked me, when I watched the movie I was like: OMG there was a creature after all!
22nd Jun '16 12:29:39 AM Luppercus
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

***They don't see airplanes cause is a no-fly zone.
**Here's the thing; even profesional actors find easier to play papers they're familiar with. It's one of the thing people advice you in drama class; use something you know, use experiences of your own life when making the character. I someone is playing a man who lost his wife and you the closest thing you have is your grandma's death when you were 8, use it. So, for non-profesional actors it will be even harder to keep a masquerade in a time they're not familiar and/or is completely invented.


Added DiffLines:

***Or when she is scared as sh**t.
22nd Jun '16 12:13:37 AM Luppercus
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

**Am I wrong or isnt that the Chinese Great Wall is the only man-made thing that you can see from space and an astranaut hardly would be able to see an small town made of wood? I know they have telescopes but they'll have to be looking for something very specific in a very specific area to spot the town, same case with Google Earth.
22nd Jun '16 12:06:44 AM Luppercus
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

***It did tricked me, when I watched the movie I was like: OMG there was a creature after all!
17th Feb '16 7:43:48 PM cheedo
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** It's probably just a case of poor directing. This is a Shyamalan movie we're talking about.
18th Aug '15 10:19:25 AM fearlessnikki
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** It seems that the "safe colour" is a lot like the white flag in combat. You wave it only when you're surrendering to the enemy. You don't walk around waving it on the battlefield to stop the enemy from attacking you. Those We Don't Speak Of are known as unpredictable, so in the minds of the villagers - if they abuse the safe colour privilege then the creatures might become more violent. In the film it seems more as if yellow is only worn by the guards at the border - as an indicator that they're just standing at their post with no ill intentions.



* Ivy has AuraSight and she implies that everyone has a unique color. How didn't she recognize the monster?

to:

** Here's the thing: note how Kitty and Ivy are watching the children that night, with no sign of the parents. That means they are the ones specifically wearing the costumes. So they know that Ivy is blind and so they'd have to get closer to her to let her know there. Plus whoever it was probably moved fast because they could see Lusius coming and knew he would help Ivy. When it's not Ivy they're attacking, they presumably just keep their distance.
* Ivy has AuraSight AuraVision and she implies that everyone has a unique color. How didn't she recognize the monster?monster?
** Ivy actually says that only ''some'' people she knows give off a colour. Noah is not one of those - she mentions her father and Lusius when she is telling him about it. Noah is there while she is talking about this, so if he gave off a colour, she would have referred to him too. This is foreshadowed when Noah is hiding in the closet and she doesn't know he's there. So she doesn't recognise the monsters because the people under the costumes aren't those who have colours.
** Or it might just be hard for her to see the colour while they're hiding under a costume. It covers the entire body.
21st Jun '15 6:51:06 PM EgoProxy
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Ivy has AuraSight and she implies that everyone has a unique color. How didn't she recognize the monster?
25th Apr '15 1:50:31 AM AimlessMeadering
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** They can't make synthetic paints, and since the houses are wooden, that's what they would need. Yellow ''dyes'' would be more accessible, but the Elders are strongly invested in keeping people out of the woods and their primary tool for that is fear. If they let people go around casually wearing yellow talismans, eventually somebody would get bold enough to go into them, or worse, they'd experience some misfortune when no one was looking and realize that the "safe color" is complete BS.
This list shows the last 10 events of 24. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Headscratchers.TheVillage