Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / TheNanny

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A person learns to speak long before they start school, so the above point doesn’t make any sense. Maxwell, Sarah & Niles all being English balanced against American child care workers & the school environment means that the children should have at least some British inflections.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Not necessarily. The other children at school don't necessarily have British accents, and all the kids are old enough that they now spend the majority of their time at school. Kids eventually become more concerned about fitting in with their peers than their parents.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
He is a Republican, he doesn't "identify as".


* What is Max's citizenship situation? In one episode, he mentions being taken to the British embassy while he was abroad. Then again, he identifies as a Republican.

to:

* What is Max's citizenship situation? In one episode, he mentions being taken to the British embassy while he was abroad. Then again, he identifies as is a Republican.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"First off," "second," this is an aggressive way of talking. The question is valid. Saying "they had an American mother" is irrelevant since she's dead.


** First off, they go to an American school, meaning they already spend most of their time surrounded by American accents. Second, the whole reason the show began was that neither the father nor the butler could really handle raising the children, and needed someone to bring in someone who could do the whole messy "raising kids" business for them, thus they hired Series/TheNanny (plus, she had style, she had flair!). Presumably, the kids have gone through a series of American nannies, and that's where they learned their American accents. Heck, by the later parts of the series, the kids have even started learning to speak YiddishAsASecondLanguage and have adopted some of Fran's other speech patterns.
** Children pick up their speech patterns from their peers, not their parents. I mean, think about it; do ''you'' talk the same way as your parents?
** It's also been shown that Sarah (Maxwell's late wife) was American.
** This troper knows an American couple that live in England. Their little kid has a British accent. Generally, while you can pick up accents from your parents, you'll pick up the accent of the area you grow up in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


How does it come to pass that in several episodes, Sylvia refers to herself, Fran, and Yetta as "Fine women." Wouldn't Fine be her married name? Yetta's last name is Rosenberg so wouldn't they be Rosenberg women?

to:

How does it come to pass that in several episodes, Sylvia refers to herself, Fran, and Yetta as "Fine women." Wouldn't Fine be her married name? Yetta's last name is Rosenberg so wouldn't they be Rosenberg women?
* Fine women, or fine
women?

Added: 304

Changed: 342

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Not necessarily. Christmas is an all-day affair, and after opening presents in the morning and having dinner in the afternoon, it's common to watch a holiday special at night with your family. The concert is probably taking place that evening, which is why Maxwell has to travel during the day itself.




to:

** Presumably he has dual citizenship in the United Kingdom and the United States. He was at the very least born to British parents and began life as a British citizen; he probably became an American citizen when he emigrated, but given that the Sheffield family is an old and titled one, he likely held onto his British legal status as well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Or a 19 year-old wunderkind in 1968 when it opened in the West End. May be a false memory, but he mentioned that his first transatlantic crossing was on the [=QE2=], which didn't make its maiden voyage until 1969; Max probably started in the West End before crossing over.

to:

** Or a 19 year-old wunderkind in 1968 when it opened in the West End. May be a false memory, but he mentioned that his first transatlantic crossing was on the [=QE2=], which didn't make its maiden voyage until 1969; Max probably started in the West End before crossing over.over.

How does it come to pass that in several episodes, Sylvia refers to herself, Fran, and Yetta as "Fine women." Wouldn't Fine be her married name? Yetta's last name is Rosenberg so wouldn't they be Rosenberg women?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* What is Max's citizenship situation? In one episode, he mentions being taken to the British embassy while he was abroad. Then again, he identifies as a Republican.

Top