History Headscratchers / TheKillingJoke

27th Jan '18 10:49:10 PM Rubber_Lotus
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** I think you're thinking of ''ComicBook/TheDarkKnightReturns'', which was an {{Elseworlds}}. Batman ''did'' [[spoiler:NeckSnap Joker in that one, but "only" to the point of paralysis; Joker actually mocks him for his restraint before finishing the job himself.]]
7th Nov '17 11:44:21 PM AntMan
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Because it's an amusement park. It was just a normal place for people to have fun before Joker made it a place of evil. Not all amusement parks are controlled by madmen.

to:

** Because it's an amusement park. It was just a normal place for people to have fun before Joker made it a place of evil. Not all amusement parks are controlled by madmen.madmen.
* So why did those thugs go to so much trouble just to rob a ''playing card company?'' The way they talk about it you'd think they were trying to get into Fort Knox. They apparently needed to sneak in through the adjacent building to avoid all the security for a place that makes freaking ''playing cards?''
12th Oct '17 1:55:18 AM Pendrake
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

*the scene of Batman killing Joker by breaking his neck was a completely different story entirely. if i recall correctly, it was pretty close to a mutual kill as well, given Bats had at least four bullet wounds in the chest and stomach. completely unrelated to the Killing Joke though.
9th May '17 1:40:21 AM Golondrina
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* I know I am being incredibly dense right now, but the joke that the joker tells at the end, who is supposed to represent batman and who is supposed to represent the joker?

to:

* I know I am being incredibly dense right now, but the joke that the joker tells at the end, who is supposed to represent batman Batman and who is supposed to represent the joker?



** It's because Batman pities the Joker and thinks he genuinely needs help. That's all. He doesn't (completely) blame the Joker for what he has done here, because he doesn't believe that the Joker is in complete control of his actions, or at least not of the mania that leads him to such actions. He rejects the idea that it all it took was "One Bad Day" to make the Joker like this, but that only means even the Joker failed to realize just how ill he was all this time. That's ''this'' version of the Joker mind- other ones (eg. the MarkHamill Joker), as well as the original Golden Age Joker, are just evil sadists who kill for their own amusement and commit violent crimes for attention and their own ego.

to:

** It's because Batman pities the Joker and thinks he genuinely needs help. That's all. He doesn't (completely) blame the Joker for what he has done here, because he doesn't believe that the Joker is in complete control of his actions, or at least not of the mania that leads him to such actions. He rejects the idea that it all it took was "One Bad Day" to make the Joker like this, but that only means even the Joker failed to realize just how ill he was all this time. That's ''this'' version of the Joker mind- other ones (eg. the MarkHamill Creator/MarkHamill Joker), as well as the original Golden Age Joker, are just evil sadists who kill for their own amusement and commit violent crimes for attention and their own ego.
22nd Mar '17 11:26:09 AM Thecommander236
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* So I guess SupermanStaysOutOfGotham covers why Batman's not calling every superhero he knows to track down the Joker, but why does the World's Greatest Detective need a literal invitation before he checks the local AmusementParkOfDoom, again?

to:

* So I guess SupermanStaysOutOfGotham covers why Batman's not calling every superhero he knows to track down the Joker, but why does the World's Greatest Detective need a literal invitation before he checks the local AmusementParkOfDoom, again?again?
** Because it's an amusement park. It was just a normal place for people to have fun before Joker made it a place of evil. Not all amusement parks are controlled by madmen.
13th Jan '17 1:56:21 PM Rubber_Lotus
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* So I guess SupermanStaysOutOfGotham covers why Batman's not calling every superhero he knows to track down the Joker, but why does the World's Greatest Detective need a literal invitation to check out the local AmusementParkOfDoom, again?

to:

* So I guess SupermanStaysOutOfGotham covers why Batman's not calling every superhero he knows to track down the Joker, but why does the World's Greatest Detective need a literal invitation to check out before he checks the local AmusementParkOfDoom, again?
13th Jan '17 1:55:27 PM Rubber_Lotus
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* The ending is meant to be ambiguous. Maybe the Batman broke Joker's neck - or maybe he didn't. The reader has no sure way of knowing.

to:

* The ending is meant to be ambiguous. Maybe the Batman broke Joker's neck - or maybe he didn't. The reader has no sure way of knowing.knowing.
* So I guess SupermanStaysOutOfGotham covers why Batman's not calling every superhero he knows to track down the Joker, but why does the World's Greatest Detective need a literal invitation to check out the local AmusementParkOfDoom, again?
24th Dec '16 10:48:31 AM Tightwire
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** No, it isn't. The script for the scene says nothing about him breaking his neck, and there's no indication this happens. [[http://www.unleashthefanboy.com/comics/batman-doesnt-kill-joker-in-the-killing-jok/68199 Seriously]]. [[http://comicbook.com/blog/2013/08/17/the-killing-joke-script-proves-batman-didnt-kill-the-joker/ It just plain is not true]]. So please stop using it as an answer, because it's missing the point of the whole story.

to:

*** No, it isn't. The script for the scene says nothing about him breaking his neck, and there's no indication this happens. [[http://www.unleashthefanboy.com/comics/batman-doesnt-kill-joker-in-the-killing-jok/68199 Seriously]]. [[http://comicbook.com/blog/2013/08/17/the-killing-joke-script-proves-batman-didnt-kill-the-joker/ It just plain is not true]]. So please stop using it as an answer, because it's missing the point of the whole story.story.
* The ending is meant to be ambiguous. Maybe the Batman broke Joker's neck - or maybe he didn't. The reader has no sure way of knowing.
30th Nov '16 8:08:31 AM Mr.Phorcys
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

*** Or the Joker knows he's insane, and knows that Batman's offer of help simply will not work for him -- the beam is a path he simply cannot take, and even if he accepted and miraculously managed to get on, he would be afraid that they would give up on him halfway and he would plummet down.
19th Aug '16 10:30:53 PM Shaoken
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

*** It's important to note that Gordon isn't just any man, he's a police commissioner and one of the few members of Gotham PD who has always kept their integrity and upheld the law. Throwing away all of his principles for something as petty as revenge doesn't make him a "real man," if him sticking to the principles that both him and his daughter dedicated their lives to makes you lose respect for him then I question your priorities.
This list shows the last 10 events of 41. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Headscratchers.TheKillingJoke