History Headscratchers / TheFairlyOddParents

21st Sep '17 5:28:38 PM abcdef-no
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Why can't other children find out about fairies?
7th Aug '17 5:20:33 PM sugaricequeen
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** I understand the out-of-universe explanation. However, as I said, it's incredibly easy to just erase the memories of the person who found out. If Trixie, A.J or whoever found out, their memories could be erased.

to:

*** I understand the out-of-universe explanation. However, as I said, it's incredibly easy to just erase the memories of the person who found out. If Trixie, A.J or whoever found out, their memories could be erased.erased.
*** In-universe, it could be the fairies' way of teaching godchildren maturity, responsibility, and the idea of consequences, or just to ensure that the existence of fairies is assurably and undeniably kept a secret. Or probably both. If a child gets the idea that they can tell whoever they want about their fairies and it wouldn't matter, he or she might end up telling so many people that things get out of hand. The memory wipe might miss someone, or someone will record something or write something down. The fairies might be able to fix everything in the event that this happens, but it's too much work and carries too many risks, along with just being a needless waste of their time because of one kid's mistake.
2nd Jun '17 11:46:44 AM Tambry161
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** I understand the out-of-universe explanation. However, as I said, it's incredibly easy to just erase the memories of the person who found out. If Trixie, A.J or whoever found out, their memories can be erased.

to:

*** I understand the out-of-universe explanation. However, as I said, it's incredibly easy to just erase the memories of the person who found out. If Trixie, A.J or whoever found out, their memories can could be erased.
2nd Jun '17 11:46:04 AM Tambry161
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** To give reasons to constrain possible episode plots & not have hundreds of stories where Cosmo & Wanda hang out with Trixie, and A.J., and all that. If you're​ looking for an InUniverse explanation, I've got nothing.

to:

** To give reasons to constrain possible episode plots & not have hundreds of stories where Cosmo & Wanda hang out with Trixie, and A.J., and all that. If you're​ looking for an InUniverse explanation, I've got nothing.nothing.
*** I understand the out-of-universe explanation. However, as I said, it's incredibly easy to just erase the memories of the person who found out. If Trixie, A.J or whoever found out, their memories can be erased.
26th May '17 12:42:57 PM YasminPerry
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** To give reasons to constrain possible episode plots & not have hundreds of stories where Cosmo & Wanda hang out with Trixie and A.J. and all that. If you looking for an InUniverse explanation, I've got nothing.

to:

** To give reasons to constrain possible episode plots & not have hundreds of stories where Cosmo & Wanda hang out with Trixie Trixie, and A.J. , and all that. If you you're​ looking for an InUniverse explanation, I've got nothing.
26th May '17 12:41:59 PM YasminPerry
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Why does Fairy Court have to take away child's fairies if they reveal their existence? ''Meet Oddparents'' shows and lampshades how easy it is to just erase memories of the person who found out. Kids are kids, they aren't good at keeping secrets and if you take their faires away for something like that, they will become miserable again. I just find it weird...

to:

* Why does Fairy Court have to take away child's fairies if they reveal their existence? ''Meet Oddparents'' shows and lampshades how easy it is to just erase memories of the person who found out. Kids are kids, they aren't good at keeping secrets and if you take their faires away for something like that, they will become miserable again. I just find it weird...weird...
** To give reasons to constrain possible episode plots & not have hundreds of stories where Cosmo & Wanda hang out with Trixie and A.J. and all that. If you looking for an InUniverse explanation, I've got nothing.
14th May '17 4:09:43 PM Tambry161
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* "Most Wanted Wish": I can easily believe "I wish I was the most wanted kid in the world" would be allowed by the rules... but how can making every girl want him romantically be one of the effects of that wish? That pretty blatantly violates the "no affecting true love" rule.

to:

* "Most Wanted Wish": I can easily believe "I wish I was the most wanted kid in the world" would be allowed by the rules... but how can making every girl want him romantically be one of the effects of that wish? That pretty blatantly violates the "no affecting true love" rule.rule.

* Why does Fairy Court have to take away child's fairies if they reveal their existence? ''Meet Oddparents'' shows and lampshades how easy it is to just erase memories of the person who found out. Kids are kids, they aren't good at keeping secrets and if you take their faires away for something like that, they will become miserable again. I just find it weird...
14th May '17 4:03:25 PM Tambry161
Is there an issue? Send a Message



* If [[Voodoo Dolls You Doo dolls]] are so dangerous, and fairies intentionally keep them secret from godkids, why aren't You Doo doll wishes prohibited by Da Rules? The book only give a warning of being dangerous, and Timmy almost ''died'' because his own You Doo doll was about to be destroyed in a wood chipper! Seems rather half-assed to keep it a secret but not actually ban the wish...

to:

\n** You know how Da Rules say that your wishes can't actually hurt anyone? I always kind of assumed that Cosmo and Wanda didn't cause the assassination, [[LoopholeAbuse they just did something that influenced it. Whatever it was, Maryanne got away with it.]]

* If [[Voodoo Dolls You Doo dolls]] dolls are so dangerous, and fairies intentionally keep them secret from godkids, why aren't You Doo doll wishes prohibited by Da Rules? The book only give a warning of being dangerous, and Timmy almost ''died'' because his own You Doo doll was about to be destroyed in a wood chipper! Seems rather half-assed to keep it a secret but not actually ban the wish...
8th May '17 6:07:37 AM Julia1984
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* If [[Voodoo Dolls You Doo dolls]] are so dangerous, and fairies intentionally keep them secret from godkids, why aren't You Doo doll wishes prohibited by Da Rules? The book only give a warning of being dangerous, and Timmy almost ''died'' because his own You Doo doll was about to be destroyed in a wood chipper! Seems rather half-assed to keep it a secret but not actually ban the wish...

to:

* If [[Voodoo Dolls You Doo dolls]] are so dangerous, and fairies intentionally keep them secret from godkids, why aren't You Doo doll wishes prohibited by Da Rules? The book only give a warning of being dangerous, and Timmy almost ''died'' because his own You Doo doll was about to be destroyed in a wood chipper! Seems rather half-assed to keep it a secret but not actually ban the wish...wish...

* "Most Wanted Wish": I can easily believe "I wish I was the most wanted kid in the world" would be allowed by the rules... but how can making every girl want him romantically be one of the effects of that wish? That pretty blatantly violates the "no affecting true love" rule.
29th Apr '17 6:38:12 PM Kishou
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* From "Hassle in the Castle": Several episodes ("Timmy's Secret Wish" and "The Secret Origin of Denzel Crocker" for starters) make it clear that once a godkid loses their godparents, everything they ever wished for is undone. So when Maryanne lost Cosmo and Wanda, why wasn't the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand undone? Why did that stay a part of history?

to:

* From "Hassle in the Castle": Several episodes ("Timmy's Secret Wish" and "The Secret Origin of Denzel Crocker" for starters) make it clear that once a godkid loses their godparents, everything they ever wished for is undone. So when Maryanne lost Cosmo and Wanda, why wasn't the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand undone? Why did that stay a part of history?history?

* If [[Voodoo Dolls You Doo dolls]] are so dangerous, and fairies intentionally keep them secret from godkids, why aren't You Doo doll wishes prohibited by Da Rules? The book only give a warning of being dangerous, and Timmy almost ''died'' because his own You Doo doll was about to be destroyed in a wood chipper! Seems rather half-assed to keep it a secret but not actually ban the wish...
This list shows the last 10 events of 280. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Headscratchers.TheFairlyOddParents