History Headscratchers / MarioKart

21st Jun '16 2:09:34 AM Sammettik
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Why is it that if you, the player character, score above third place, everyone who participated shows up to the ceremony, but if you manage to score lower, your character is just left to sit out alone?
* Why is there an outcry against Baby Rosalina in ''Mario Kart 8'', on the basis that her being there as a baby is a ContinuitySnarl? The fact that she looks different than she did as a child in her storybook, that's fine, but the ''Mario Kart'' games aren't a part of the main series' canon. (What little there is.) They're all members of their own spinoff series.
** It's the principle of the matter. Besides, define "spin-off" in terms of Mario. Most of the story is Rosalina's Storybook and spin-offs. There's a reason the [[WikiRule Mario Wiki]] doesn't consider ''anything'' canon.
** What I mean is, it's practically its own separate universe. No one questions things like How Link is able to be playable in MK8 or why Bowser is suddenly on friendly enough terms with everyone to go kart-racing, (or what Rosalina herself is even doing there, when she's supposed to be traveling the cosmos caring for the Lumas, and only visits the Mushroom World every 100 years), because it's not canon. (What little there is.)
*** Also, for at least a minor definition, there's clearly supposed to be at least ''some'' canonical relationship between ''Super Mario 64'', ''Super Mario Sunshine'', ''Super Mario Galaxy'', ''Super Mario Galaxy 2'', and ''Luigi's Mansion'', and I've also heard that ''New Super Mario Bros. Wii'' has Peach reference the Star Festival at the end, so if that's true, that game may have a place in there, as well. It's the same as the concept of the mainstream ''Zelda'' games and a spinoff like ''Link's Crossbow Training'' or ''Hyrule Warriors''. And finally, if you're saying that the ''Mario'' series doesn't really have an overall continuity, then why would Baby Rosalina be an issue, anyway?
** Again, it's on principle. The story of how Miyamoto showed contempt for Rosalina's Storybook is (I believe) well-known, and since Baby Rosalina contradicts that, it leaves a bad taste in people's mouths regardless of how it actually came about. And the whole 'nothing is canon' means 'everything is equally canon'. I, for one, believe Mario Kart and Super Mario Galaxy can co-exist in the same canon... which has implications.

to:

* Why is it that if you, the player character, score above third place, everyone who participated shows up to the ceremony, but if you manage to score lower, your character is just left to sit out alone?
* Why is there an outcry against Baby Rosalina in ''Mario Kart 8'', on the basis that her being there as a baby is a ContinuitySnarl? The fact that she looks different than she did as a child in her storybook, that's fine, but the ''Mario Kart'' games aren't a part of the main series' canon. (What little there is.) They're all members of their own spinoff series.
** It's the principle of the matter. Besides, define "spin-off" in terms of Mario. Most of the story is Rosalina's Storybook and spin-offs. There's a reason the [[WikiRule Mario Wiki]] doesn't consider ''anything'' canon.
** What I mean is, it's practically its own separate universe. No one questions things like How Link is able to be playable in MK8 or why Bowser is suddenly on friendly enough terms with everyone to go kart-racing, (or what Rosalina herself is even doing there, when she's supposed to be traveling the cosmos caring for the Lumas, and only visits the Mushroom World every 100 years), because it's not canon. (What little there is.)
*** Also, for at least a minor definition, there's clearly supposed to be at least ''some'' canonical relationship between ''Super Mario 64'', ''Super Mario Sunshine'', ''Super Mario Galaxy'', ''Super Mario Galaxy 2'', and ''Luigi's Mansion'', and I've also heard that ''New Super Mario Bros. Wii'' has Peach reference the Star Festival at the end, so if that's true, that game may have a place in there, as well. It's the same as the concept of the mainstream ''Zelda'' games and a spinoff like ''Link's Crossbow Training'' or ''Hyrule Warriors''. And finally, if you're saying that the ''Mario'' series doesn't really have an overall continuity, then why would Baby Rosalina be an issue, anyway?
** Again, it's on principle. The story of how Miyamoto showed contempt for Rosalina's Storybook is (I believe) well-known, and since Baby Rosalina contradicts that, it leaves a bad taste in people's mouths regardless of how it actually came about. And the whole 'nothing is canon' means 'everything is equally canon'. I, for one, believe Mario Kart and Super Mario Galaxy can co-exist in the same canon... which has implications.
alone?
27th May '16 7:51:02 PM phineas81707
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** Also, for at least a minor definition, there's clearly supposed to be at least ''some'' canonical relationship between ''Super Mario 64'', ''Super Mario Sunshine'', ''Super Mario Galaxy'', ''Super Mario Galaxy 2'', and ''Luigi's Mansion'', and I've also heard that ''New Super Mario Bros. Wii'' has Peach reference the Star Festival at the end, so if that's true, that game may have a place in there, as well. It's the same as the concept of the mainstream ''Zelda'' games and a spinoff like ''Link's Crossbow Training'' or ''Hyrule Warriors''. And finally, if you're saying that the ''Mario'' series doesn't really have an overall continuity, then why would Baby Rosalina be an issue, anyway?

to:

*** Also, for at least a minor definition, there's clearly supposed to be at least ''some'' canonical relationship between ''Super Mario 64'', ''Super Mario Sunshine'', ''Super Mario Galaxy'', ''Super Mario Galaxy 2'', and ''Luigi's Mansion'', and I've also heard that ''New Super Mario Bros. Wii'' has Peach reference the Star Festival at the end, so if that's true, that game may have a place in there, as well. It's the same as the concept of the mainstream ''Zelda'' games and a spinoff like ''Link's Crossbow Training'' or ''Hyrule Warriors''. And finally, if you're saying that the ''Mario'' series doesn't really have an overall continuity, then why would Baby Rosalina be an issue, anyway?anyway?
** Again, it's on principle. The story of how Miyamoto showed contempt for Rosalina's Storybook is (I believe) well-known, and since Baby Rosalina contradicts that, it leaves a bad taste in people's mouths regardless of how it actually came about. And the whole 'nothing is canon' means 'everything is equally canon'. I, for one, believe Mario Kart and Super Mario Galaxy can co-exist in the same canon... which has implications.
27th May '16 11:43:24 AM QuarrelsomeChevon
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** What I mean is, it's practically its own separate universe. No one questions things like How Link is able to be playable in MK8 or why Bowser is suddenly on friendly enough terms with everyone to go kart-racing, (or what Rosalina herself is even doing there, when she's supposed to be traveling the cosmos caring for the Lumas, and only visits the Mushroom World every 100 years), because it's not canon. (What little there is.)

to:

** What I mean is, it's practically its own separate universe. No one questions things like How Link is able to be playable in MK8 or why Bowser is suddenly on friendly enough terms with everyone to go kart-racing, (or what Rosalina herself is even doing there, when she's supposed to be traveling the cosmos caring for the Lumas, and only visits the Mushroom World every 100 years), because it's not canon. (What little there is.))
*** Also, for at least a minor definition, there's clearly supposed to be at least ''some'' canonical relationship between ''Super Mario 64'', ''Super Mario Sunshine'', ''Super Mario Galaxy'', ''Super Mario Galaxy 2'', and ''Luigi's Mansion'', and I've also heard that ''New Super Mario Bros. Wii'' has Peach reference the Star Festival at the end, so if that's true, that game may have a place in there, as well. It's the same as the concept of the mainstream ''Zelda'' games and a spinoff like ''Link's Crossbow Training'' or ''Hyrule Warriors''. And finally, if you're saying that the ''Mario'' series doesn't really have an overall continuity, then why would Baby Rosalina be an issue, anyway?
27th May '16 11:39:13 AM QuarrelsomeChevon
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** It's the principle of the matter. Besides, define "spin-off" in terms of Mario. Most of the story is Rosalina's Storybook and spin-offs. There's a reason the [[WikiRule Mario Wiki]] doesn't consider ''anything'' canon.

to:

** It's the principle of the matter. Besides, define "spin-off" in terms of Mario. Most of the story is Rosalina's Storybook and spin-offs. There's a reason the [[WikiRule Mario Wiki]] doesn't consider ''anything'' canon.canon.
** What I mean is, it's practically its own separate universe. No one questions things like How Link is able to be playable in MK8 or why Bowser is suddenly on friendly enough terms with everyone to go kart-racing, (or what Rosalina herself is even doing there, when she's supposed to be traveling the cosmos caring for the Lumas, and only visits the Mushroom World every 100 years), because it's not canon. (What little there is.)
28th Apr '16 4:03:17 AM phineas81707
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Why is there an outcry against Baby Rosalina in ''Mario Kart 8'', on the basis that her being there as a baby is a ContinuitySnarl? The fact that she looks different than she did as a child in her storybook, that's fine, but the ''Mario Kart'' games aren't a part of the main series' canon. (What little there is.) They're all members of their own spinoff series.

to:

* Why is there an outcry against Baby Rosalina in ''Mario Kart 8'', on the basis that her being there as a baby is a ContinuitySnarl? The fact that she looks different than she did as a child in her storybook, that's fine, but the ''Mario Kart'' games aren't a part of the main series' canon. (What little there is.) They're all members of their own spinoff series.series.
** It's the principle of the matter. Besides, define "spin-off" in terms of Mario. Most of the story is Rosalina's Storybook and spin-offs. There's a reason the [[WikiRule Mario Wiki]] doesn't consider ''anything'' canon.
27th Apr '16 8:01:03 PM QuarrelsomeChevon
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Why is it that if you, the player character, score above third place, everyone who participated shows up to the ceremony, but if you manage to score lower, your character is just left to sit out alone?

to:

* Why is it that if you, the player character, score above third place, everyone who participated shows up to the ceremony, but if you manage to score lower, your character is just left to sit out alone?alone?
* Why is there an outcry against Baby Rosalina in ''Mario Kart 8'', on the basis that her being there as a baby is a ContinuitySnarl? The fact that she looks different than she did as a child in her storybook, that's fine, but the ''Mario Kart'' games aren't a part of the main series' canon. (What little there is.) They're all members of their own spinoff series.
13th Dec '15 12:13:16 PM whisperstar13
Is there an issue? Send a Message
13th Dec '15 12:13:15 PM whisperstar13
Is there an issue? Send a Message
13th Dec '15 12:13:15 PM whisperstar13
Is there an issue? Send a Message
13th Dec '15 12:13:15 PM whisperstar13
Is there an issue? Send a Message
This list shows the last 10 events of 24. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Headscratchers.MarioKart