History Headscratchers / Looper

22nd Apr '16 6:39:47 PM fearlessnikki
Is there an issue? Send a Message



to:

** Film Noir usually involves an AntiHero protagonist or else someone who slowly gets dragged down into the criminal underworld in some way. Endings are bittersweet at best and there's usually a point of no return for the protagonist.
6th Feb '16 6:46:30 AM pittsburghmuggle
Is there an issue? Send a Message


'''BE WARY OF SPOILERS BEYOND THIS POINT.''' '''''THIS IS YOUR ONLY WARNING.'''''
30th Dec '15 1:33:08 PM dmcreif
Is there an issue? Send a Message



to:

[[foldercontrol]]

[[folder:Opening the loop]]




to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:To get away with murder in the future]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder:Complications with Looping]]




to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Closing Joe's Loop and the Rainmaker]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder:Are Loopers really necessary?]]




to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Sara's knowledge of Loopers]]




to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:More on Closing the Loops]]




to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:A Looper preventing his own fate]]




to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Open-ended Loops]]




to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Premature death for a Looper]]




to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Time police]]



** It's implied that there's only one (or a very limited number) time machine and it's controlled by the bad guys. If the legitimate authorities ever got the time machine, they would destroy it. Then they would jail or kill (or something) all of the people involved in the extremely illegal activity. Using it themselves would be counterproductive and reckless. Besides, it's one way time travel and the world from thirty years ago sucked- who'd be willing to go back?

to:

** It's implied that there's only one (or a very limited number) number of) time machine machine(s) and it's controlled by the bad guys. If the legitimate authorities ever got the time machine, they would destroy it. Then they would jail or kill (or something) all of the people involved in the extremely illegal activity. Using it themselves would be counterproductive and reckless. Besides, it's one way time travel and the world from thirty years ago sucked- who'd be willing to go back?




* How is this considered a Sci-Fi Noir? There's barley any Noir elements in the film and the narration ends after the first little while.

to:

\n[[/folder]]

[[folder:Movie genre]]
* How is this considered a Sci-Fi Noir? There's barley barely any Noir elements in the film and the narration ends after the first little while.



[[/folder]]

[[folder:Mob guns are just better]]




to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Signaling to your past self]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder:Tracking a Looper]]




to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Why did the Rainmaker kill Jesse?]]




to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Past!Joe's suicide]]




to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Why send the Loopers back 30 years?]]




to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Abe's future]]




to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Seth and the Rainmaker]]






to:

\n\n[[/folder]]

[[folder:Use of time travel for assassination]]




to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:The doctor]]




to:

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Seth's signal]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder:Abe's need for Joe's silver]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder:The 2044 authorities]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder:Young Joe and Sarah's inactivity]]




* Is Cid really [[spoiler: the Rainmaker]]? I mean, the guy who gave Future!Joe the code might have been wrong. You can't take any information for granted. And as for [[spoiler: Future!Joe's disappearance after Present!Joe kills himself]], isn't it fundamentally because his past self is [[spoiler: dead rather than having anything to do the Rainmaker's (non-)existence]]? After all, [[MindScrew the story]] [[UpToEleven would've been more complicated]] had the [[spoiler: Rainmaker been Cid. If s/he really is Cid, then [[TimeCrash Future!Loopers wouldn't have been sent back, Present!Joe wouldn't have met Future!Joe, and all this wouldn't have happened]]. Then Cid wouldn't have met both Joes and probably lived as normally as possible, resulting in him not becoming evil,]] which would make Future!Joe's return to the present timeline improbable.

to:

\n* Is [[/folder]]

[[folder:Is
Cid really [[spoiler: the Rainmaker]]? Rainmaker?]]
*
I mean, the guy who gave Future!Joe the code might have been wrong. You can't take any information for granted. And as for [[spoiler: Future!Joe's disappearance after Present!Joe kills himself]], isn't it fundamentally because his past self is [[spoiler: dead rather than having anything to do the Rainmaker's (non-)existence]]? After all, [[MindScrew the story]] [[UpToEleven would've been more complicated]] had the [[spoiler: Rainmaker been Cid. If s/he really is Cid, then [[TimeCrash Future!Loopers wouldn't have been sent back, Present!Joe wouldn't have met Future!Joe, and all this wouldn't have happened]]. Then Cid wouldn't have met both Joes and probably lived as normally as possible, resulting in him not becoming evil,]] which would make Future!Joe's return to the present timeline improbable.



[[/folder]]

[[folder:Why not shoot his own hands off?]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder:The unsolvable paradox]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder:Old Joe's wife]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder:Even More on Joe's Loop]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder:Loopers aren't the most forward-thinking sorts]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder:Joe's headaches]]



[[/folder]]

[[folder:Why do they have to close the loops?]]



** I understand the need to kill the loopers, but why have them kill themselves, and why tell them about it? You could just send them to any old looper, like the rest of the victims. Less incentive to go rogue that way. You could even still have a gold payout attached to a looper be their last hit, just have it be a ''different looper'' than the one you're sending them to.

to:

** I understand the need to kill the loopers, but why have them kill themselves, and why tell them about it? You could just send them to any old looper, like the rest of the victims. Less incentive to go rogue that way. You could even still have a gold payout attached to a looper be their last hit, just have it be a ''different looper'' than the one you're sending them to.to.
[[/folder]]
18th Sep '15 7:13:59 AM Chaos624
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** I think I may have figured this one out. I've spent the past hour thinking about it, so I hope so..... If Young!Joe kills himself, he negates everything that Old!Joe might do, meaning that the Rainmaker never comes into existence. If the Rainmaker never comes into existence, then Old!Joe wouldn't have been sent back and thus, Young!Joe would have just carried on with his life being a Looper. He would have grown old, gotten married, and died normally (maybe). Cid's mother also wouldn't be killed by Old!Joe because Old!Joe wouldn't be sent back, so he never grows up evil, and the lives of Cid and the Loopers are completely separate. Am I missing something?

to:

** I think I may have figured this one out. I've spent the past hour thinking about it, so I hope so..... [[spoiler: If Young!Joe kills himself, he negates everything that Old!Joe might do, meaning that the Rainmaker never comes into existence. If the Rainmaker never comes into existence, then Old!Joe wouldn't have been sent back and thus, Young!Joe would have just carried on with his life being a Looper. He would have grown old, gotten married, and died normally (maybe). Cid's mother also wouldn't be killed by Old!Joe because Old!Joe wouldn't be sent back, so he never grows up evil, and the lives of Cid and the Loopers are completely separate. ]] Am I missing something?


Added DiffLines:

** One way to interpret it is that we are seeing the formation of a StableTimeLoop. Most likely the Rainmaker came to be through similar events happening elsewhere, but the actions of Old!Joe force it into a new configuration that would continue as a loop into all possible futures if Young!Joe didn't put a stop to it. Similar to Film/TheTerminator, John Conner probably had a different father before the [[StableTimeLoop Skynet kicked things off]].
2nd Feb '15 8:11:14 PM DoctorDetective
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** Think about it both ways. Instead of it being a 30 year retirement after you close your loop, your loop gets closed because in 30 years time, you did something to piss off the Syndicate. Remember, Young Joe notices a sharp increase in Closed Loops, because 30 years in the future the Rainmaker has taken over and is rounding all the Loopers up to be killed. A lot of Loopers may not even get 30 years, but the Syndicate lies to make their 'retirement' sound like a fair deal. Particularly good Loopers like Joe might only get their fair 30 years because the Syndicate never has a reason to murder them, but a percieved paradox demands they must be sent back regardless.

to:

*** Think about it both ways. Instead of it being a 30 year retirement after you close your loop, your loop gets closed because in 30 years time, you did something to piss off the Syndicate. Remember, Young Joe notices a sharp increase in Closed Loops, because 30 years in the future the Rainmaker has taken over and is rounding all the Loopers up to be killed. A lot of Loopers may not even get 30 years, but the Syndicate lies to make their 'retirement' sound like a fair deal. Particularly good Loopers like Joe might only get their fair 30 years because the Syndicate never has a reason to murder them, but a percieved paradox demands they must be sent back regardless.regardless.
** I understand the need to kill the loopers, but why have them kill themselves, and why tell them about it? You could just send them to any old looper, like the rest of the victims. Less incentive to go rogue that way. You could even still have a gold payout attached to a looper be their last hit, just have it be a ''different looper'' than the one you're sending them to.
31st Aug '14 7:01:34 PM comkiller
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Someone in fridge proposed this: Older!Joe becomes a looper and one day kills his future self, collects his gold, and goes to FRANCE like he intended, creating a stable time loop. Then Seth botches the closing of his own loop, and so the scene where Abe has Joe in his office and convinces him to go to China instead happens. Old!Joe kills Older!Joe and goes to China, meets his wife, and finds a reason to fight. Old!Joe struggles and goes back in time, knocking out Young!Joe and starting the real plot of the movie.
4th Jul '14 12:00:32 PM Gunslinger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Could be seen as cleaning up loose ends. Could be vengeance. Could just be that they decided it was the best way to accomplish both their money/precious metal laundering goals and run their murder operations... cleaning up old murderers means it's less likely the guy's ever caught by the cops and traced to them.

to:

** Could be seen as cleaning up loose ends. Could be vengeance. Could just be that they decided it was the best way to accomplish both their money/precious metal laundering goals and run their murder operations... cleaning up old murderers means it's less likely the guy's ever caught by the cops and traced to them.them.
*** Think about it both ways. Instead of it being a 30 year retirement after you close your loop, your loop gets closed because in 30 years time, you did something to piss off the Syndicate. Remember, Young Joe notices a sharp increase in Closed Loops, because 30 years in the future the Rainmaker has taken over and is rounding all the Loopers up to be killed. A lot of Loopers may not even get 30 years, but the Syndicate lies to make their 'retirement' sound like a fair deal. Particularly good Loopers like Joe might only get their fair 30 years because the Syndicate never has a reason to murder them, but a percieved paradox demands they must be sent back regardless.
4th Jul '14 11:35:02 AM Gunslinger
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

*** The movie pretty much confirms this since Old Joe arrives 'late' as a result of his struggle with the Syndicate goons in the future. Getting into some slightly harder sci-fi but time travel is ''theoretically'' possibly by manipulating space-time with gravitational forces. A time machine that manipulates space-time by a precise, set amount each time (30 years time and to a specific location) would be less complex than one that is capable of variable space-time manipulation.
4th Jul '14 11:24:08 AM Gunslinger
Is there an issue? Send a Message



to:

*** Do you remember the last time somebody startled you as a practical joke or even just by accident, and for a moment you felt incredibly angry at that person? Give that to a child with an established rotten temper and psychic murder powers.
4th Jul '14 11:10:26 AM Gunslinger
Is there an issue? Send a Message



to:

** It might simply be that Blunderbusses are seen as being inferior to ''any'' weapon a Gat Man has access to. The other thing is Kid Blue is a pretty good example that the Gat Men aren't really ''that'' much better than the Loopers. Most of them are still only being trusted with a six-shooter, but because it's still better than what the Loopers get, they talk the weapon up to mythical levels, and milk it for all it's worth.


Added DiffLines:

*** Being bound, gagged and headbagged also severely limits your options for communication. In addition to that, any targets that know about the Loopers and what's about to happen to them may try and fake a signal. The Syndicate probably circulate stories of Loopers tricked into thinking they're closing their loop, only to be killed by their target because there's no paradox stopping them from doing so.
This list shows the last 10 events of 177. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Headscratchers.Looper