Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / GoldFinger

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Headscratchers for ''Film/{{Goldfinger}}''.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* So why did Oddjob crush the Lincoln Continental? Mr. Solo was already dead. He could have just driven it back.
** Goldfinger didn't want to let that wonderful pun go to waste.
** This is explained if you listen to Goldfinger's next line. He says something to the effect of separating his gold from Mister Solo. Considering the fact that he personally owns multiple smelting facilities, he was likely going to melt the car down, separate out the gold and other metals, and thus totally get rid of all evidence.
** More FridgeBrilliance: ''the car had Bond's homing device in it''. So, whoever was tracking it would make a tragic discovery.
*** There were two homing devices: the larger one that Bond put into Goldfinger's European car to track him in Switzerland, and the smaller one that fits in his shoe (which he slipped into Solo's pocket). Goldfinger likely didn't know about the homing device (except maybe the larger one once they started to dismantle his car), and it's unlikely he was trying to prevent Bond from getting a message out because he didn't know Bond had escaped until they had gotten to the car; Goldfinger had likely already planned to killed whichever mob boss that tried to leave. Also, the homing device, which was being tracked by Felix, stopped immediately once the car was crushed.
** More practically, destroying compromised vehicles and bodies in smashers is a common tactic in wet works. Even if people know Solo is missing, not having his car or body be identifiable would help.
* [[http://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/great-movie-goldfinger-1964 In his review]], Creator/RogerEbert famously pointed out that the scene where Goldfinger explains his plot to the Mafia heads and then kills them has no purpose, since he's just going to kill them all anyway, he has no idea Bond's listening in [[spoiler: and it's not even his real plan]]. He concludes that Goldfinger simply spent a huge amount of money on making the models and films for it and just wanted to show it off to someone.
** This is a contingency plan made clearer by the fact that all the criminals clearly don't like being together, but together provided all the materials for the supposed heist. Goldfinger expected his lair to be found eventually, and he essentially framed the missing gangster as the mastermind by hiding the body and killing the others. Remember, Goldfinger had a plan to escape -- had Bond not survived, Goldfinger would have covered his tracks so well that MI-6 would have been right back at square one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

****The movie clearly shows her enjoying it and not just pretending to do so. That gets even more clear later in the movie when she willingly makes out with Bond. Also his scumbag behaviour is not something to be seen as morally acceptable. That guy murders for a living. He is not a moral person.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

****Okay, first of all. The movie version has no actual hints towards homosexuality. She just claims to not be interested in Bond. Secondle, Bond was never supposed to be seen as "heroic". He is and was always a horrible role model. He was shown as a drinker, smoker, gambler, casual murderer. Definitely not a role model.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** That's it exactly - specifically, collateral damage to the control room. Goldfinger wants to get into the vault, and he can't do that if the controls are damaged - they're NEVER getting through that door if it's sealed. To move it they needed heavy duty steel chains and a truck - it looking 'flimsy' is just a bad film prop. It's sturdy enough that he doesn't want to risk the amount of explosive it would take to make a hole big enough for the bomb.

to:

*** That's it exactly - specifically, collateral damage to the control room. Goldfinger wants to get into the vault, and he can't do that if the controls are damaged - they're NEVER getting through that vault door if it's sealed. To move it the 'flimsy' door they needed heavy duty steel chains and a truck - it looking 'flimsy' is just a bad film prop. It's sturdy enough that he doesn't want to risk the amount of explosive it would take to make a hole big enough for the bomb.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** That's it exactly - specifically, collateral damage to the control room. Goldfinger wants to get into the vault, and he can't do that if the controls are damaged - they're NEVER getting through that door if it's sealed. To move it they needed heavy duty steel chains and a truck - it looking 'flimsy' is just a bad film prop. It's sturdy enough that he doesn't want to risk the amount of explosive it would take to make a hole big enough for the bomb.


Added DiffLines:

** What other explanation CAN she offer? She looks over at his car and sees its pristine, and her car is absolutely destroyed. What explanation can a civilian offer other than some kind of defect or a freak accident?


Added DiffLines:

** Simply bribed/blackmailed one of the operators that knew it then disposed of him. Or alternately, the Chinese government got it for him through underhanded means.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Pussy finding out about the lethality of the gas and that Goldfinger was lying to her is indeed why she turns in the film. Bond tells her in the same sex scene.

to:

** Pussy finding out about the lethality of the gas and that Goldfinger was lying to her is indeed why she turns in the film. Bond tells her in the same sex scene. She then went to Felix.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Pussy finding out about the lethality of the gas and that Goldfinger was lying to her is indeed why she turns in the film. Bond tells her in the same sex scene.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Film/Spaceballs It was the same as his combination for his luggage]]

to:

** [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Film/Spaceballs It was the same as his the combination for his luggage]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Film/Spaceballs It was the same as his combination for his luggage]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Only way Tilly would've known is if Tilly, and not the actress read the script. Or Bond is such a bad "Secret Agent" that even a random motorist can recognize him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Only way Tilly would've known is if Tilly, and not the actress read the script. Or Bond is the worst "Secret Agent

Added DiffLines:

** Because as far she knew, he was just another motorist and had no reason to think his car was capable of doing that.

Added: 4

Changed: 119

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* After Oddjob kills the gangster, why doesn't he take the gold out of the trunk of the car before crushing it? Wouldn't that be easier than extracting it later?

to:

* After Oddjob kills the gangster, Mr. Solo, why doesn't he take the gold out of the trunk of the car before crushing it? Wouldn't that be easier than extracting it later?



*** Exactly! Watching this and being confused about why it doesn't hold to modern sensibilities is like reading 'Le Morte d'Arthur' and wondering why it has such a huge boner for Christianity. There are so many more forces in effect on these works, political, economic and cultural, that have shifted since their creation, that it is easier to view them as artefacts of history than moral stories.

to:

*** Exactly! Watching this and being confused about why it doesn't hold to modern sensibilities is like reading 'Le ''Le Morte d'Arthur' d'Arthur'' and wondering why it has such a huge boner for Christianity. There are so many more forces in effect on these works, political, economic and cultural, that have shifted since their creation, that it is easier to view them as artefacts of history than moral stories.



** I've always thought there was a level of ActorAllusion that mitigates it somewhat, but gets lost outside the UK, and due to the years since the film's release. At the time ''Goldfinger'' came out, Honor Blackman was best known as [[Series/TheAvengers1960s the Avenger Cathy Gale]] and as a judo black-belt. So there was probably a certain perception that nobody throws Honor Blackman around unless she ''lets'' them do it. (An accurate perception, too. Honor Blackman's a real-life badass, and could probably take Connery in a fight.) Certainly Blackman doesn't play the scene like she's ''really'' being forced - Pussy seems to enjoy (genuinely, non-[[DeadlyEuphemism euphemistically]]) "playing hard to get".

to:

** I've always thought there was a level of ActorAllusion that mitigates it somewhat, but gets lost outside the UK, and due to the years since the film's release. At the time ''Goldfinger'' came out, Honor Blackman Creator/HonorBlackman was best known as [[Series/TheAvengers1960s the Avenger Cathy Gale]] and as a judo black-belt. So there was probably a certain perception that nobody throws Honor Blackman around unless she ''lets'' them do it. (An accurate perception, too. Honor Blackman's a real-life badass, and could probably take Connery in a fight.) Certainly Blackman doesn't play the scene like she's ''really'' being forced - Pussy seems to enjoy (genuinely, non-[[DeadlyEuphemism euphemistically]]) "playing hard to get".



** It’s entirely true that James Bond muddle’s through the entire movie and barely influences the outcome. Auric Goldfinger is always one step ahead of our hapless hero – and that’s what makes it awesome. Goldfinger’s plan isn’t particularly less common sense than most Bond Villain plots. . .

to:

** It’s It's entirely true that James Bond muddle’s muddles through the entire movie and barely influences the outcome. Auric Goldfinger is always one step ahead of our hapless hero – and that’s what makes it awesome. Goldfinger’s plan isn’t particularly less common sense than most Bond Villain plots. . .plots...



* The mook Oddjob throws over the balcony in the Fort Knox vault after they get locked in has a gun. Why does Bond make no effort to retrieve it? Bond could have shot Oddjob then taken the key to unlock himself. Or circled back to get it later?

to:

* The mook Oddjob throws over the balcony in the Fort Knox vault after they get locked in Kisch has a gun. Why does Bond make no effort to retrieve it? Bond could have shot Oddjob then taken the key to unlock himself. Or circled back to get it later?



* The one aspect of this film that everyone criticizes, including Sean Connery, is that the entire plot hinged on Bond’s magic penis making Pussy have a [[HeelFaceTurn Heel-Face Turn.]] Putting aside how badly that scene has aged (and even pushed some serious limits in 1964) it seems more believable that Bond could’ve simply had a frank discussion with her that: 1.) She would not be sedating thousands of people but killing them. It’s certainly possible that she didn’t mind participating in a massive heist but would be less likely to commit mass murder. 2.) He knew that Goldfinger had just murdered an entire room full of very powerful men he no longer needed so Pussy and her pilots would likely suffer the same fate. Perhaps a little less dramatic, but less of a DeusExMachina.

to:

* The one aspect of this film that everyone criticizes, including Sean Connery, Creator/SeanConnery, is that the entire plot hinged on Bond’s Bond's magic penis making Pussy have a [[HeelFaceTurn Heel-Face Turn.]] Putting aside how badly that scene has aged (and even pushed some serious limits in 1964) it seems more believable that Bond could’ve could've simply had a frank discussion with her that: 1.) She would not be sedating thousands of people but killing them. It’s It's certainly possible that she didn’t mind participating in a massive heist but would be less likely to commit mass murder. 2.) He knew that Goldfinger had just murdered an entire room full of very powerful men he no longer needed so Pussy and her pilots would likely suffer the same fate. Perhaps a little less dramatic, but less of a DeusExMachina.DeusExMachina.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the book, you're not far off; he was connected to SMERSH and this was in keeping with the Cold War. However, in the movie, as you said, there's no evidence that he has or needs their help -- we see who he's working with in some detail (the book calls them a "Congress of Criminals") and he obviously has more than enough money on his own. If anything, considering how far SPECTRE tends to be silently represented, there's the question of if they ''knew'' and would be okay with such an upheaval going forward or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also, it creates such huge plotholes. Why does Jill die of it if Goldfinger does it to people all the time? Is it only harmful if it stays on too long? And furthermore, if she "slowly suffocates to death in a hospital," why didn't the doctors at least try to remove it? ER physicians sometimes resort to unusual methods to treat unusual injuries; there was an episode of Untold Stories of the ER where cosmetic wax was used to remove cactus spines from a patient's skin. Why couldn't they just buy some paint thinner and attempt to remove the paint if its mere presence on her skin was what was killing her?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added


* How did Goldfinger get the combination to the Fort Knox vault door?

to:

* How did Goldfinger get the combination to the Fort Knox vault door?door?
* The one aspect of this film that everyone criticizes, including Sean Connery, is that the entire plot hinged on Bond’s magic penis making Pussy have a [[HeelFaceTurn Heel-Face Turn.]] Putting aside how badly that scene has aged (and even pushed some serious limits in 1964) it seems more believable that Bond could’ve simply had a frank discussion with her that: 1.) She would not be sedating thousands of people but killing them. It’s certainly possible that she didn’t mind participating in a massive heist but would be less likely to commit mass murder. 2.) He knew that Goldfinger had just murdered an entire room full of very powerful men he no longer needed so Pussy and her pilots would likely suffer the same fate. Perhaps a little less dramatic, but less of a DeusExMachina.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added

Added DiffLines:

** The only reason to have Goldfinger explain his plan to the room full of gangsters was for the audience (and James) to know what was going on. Likewise there was no reason whatsoever to destroy the car. But as Creator/AlfredHitchcock famously said “the audience isn’t thinking about that while they’re watching.”
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Yes, but he's also under orders to watch Goldfinger, presumably in secret. This gives away to Goldfinger that someone has him under surveillance. At this point, Bond has know idea what M's interest is and revealing himself potentially endangers any future operations.

to:

*** Yes, but he's also under orders to watch Goldfinger, presumably in secret. This gives away to Goldfinger that someone has him under surveillance. At this point, Bond has know no idea what M's interest is and revealing himself potentially endangers any future operations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** In addition to the explanation provided by the poster above, Goldfinger likely knows that there is a small risk of this causing a war, but it's a risk he's willing to take.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SPECTRE is absent from this film after being prominently featured in both the previous film and the next one in the series. But is SPECTRE actually financing or supporting Goldfinger's master plan? With all the chaos and economic woes that would follow the irradiating of the US gold supply, that could very well benefit them too.

to:

* SPECTRE is absent from this film after being prominently featured in both the previous film and the next one in the series. But is SPECTRE actually financing or supporting Goldfinger's master plan? With all the chaos and economic woes that would follow the irradiating of the US gold supply, that could very well benefit them too.too.
* How did Goldfinger get the combination to the Fort Knox vault door?

Top