History Headscratchers / GleeSeason3

4th Jan '17 6:55:57 PM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* The show is turning into HighSchoolMusical with slightly better writing. I first got into Glee because it was High School Musical except portrayed realistically, with much better music and writing. Maybe this is just a one-off thing, but Britanny's performance just seemed a little too contrived. I'm willing to write off the unrealisticness of the band and the Piano Man, but that excessively complicated choreography was just too much. I get that it's supposed to be portrayed as a music video, like Mercedes' first audition was, but when you get a huge group performing like that it loses its artistic merit.

to:

* The show is turning into HighSchoolMusical ''Film/HighSchoolMusical'' with slightly better writing. I first got into Glee because it was High School Musical except portrayed realistically, with much better music and writing. Maybe this is just a one-off thing, but Britanny's Brittany's performance just seemed a little too contrived. I'm willing to write off the unrealisticness of the band and the Piano Man, but that excessively complicated choreography was just too much. I get that it's supposed to be portrayed as a music video, like Mercedes' first audition was, but when you get a huge group performing like that it loses its artistic merit.
18th Dec '16 6:54:05 PM Discar
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** Emma and Bieste, two adults portrayed as having problems that are shown by them not having lost it yet. They're also [[AManIsNotAVirgin women]].

to:

*** Emma and Bieste, two adults portrayed as having problems that are shown by them not having lost it yet. They're also [[AManIsNotAVirgin [[DoubleStandard women]].
12th Nov '16 4:01:08 PM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Glee, Kentucky created/raised a lot of stars. Its not a musical and acting dead zone. BillyRayCyrus, MileyCyrus, TomCruise, JohnnyDepp, Laura Bell Bundy, Creator/GeorgeClooney.

to:

* Glee, Kentucky created/raised a lot of stars. Its not a musical and acting dead zone. BillyRayCyrus, MileyCyrus, TomCruise, JohnnyDepp, Music/BillyRayCyrus, Music/MileyCyrus, Creator/TomCruise, Creator/JohnnyDepp, Laura Bell Bundy, Creator/GeorgeClooney.
21st Oct '16 8:20:19 PM Ferot_Dreadnaught
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** I always figured that since we hear in the beginning of the episode that Sebastian's father is a state's attorney, it would be harder to get him charged since his father could lean on the police/judges to get his son off the charges, so ND may have factored that into their calculations. [[RuleOfDrama Or]] [[TheyJustDidntCare something.]] But definitely factoring Daddy Smythe's influence in.

to:

** I always figured that since we hear in the beginning of the episode that Sebastian's father is a state's attorney, it would be harder to get him charged since his father could lean on the police/judges to get his son off the charges, so ND may have factored that into their calculations. [[RuleOfDrama Or]] [[TheyJustDidntCare something.]] something. But definitely factoring Daddy Smythe's influence in.
20th Oct '16 8:40:14 PM Ferot_Dreadnaught
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Considering they sang I Kissed a Girl in an episode about a lesbian coming to terms with her sexuality, [[TheyJustDidntCare it rather seems like they aren't even thinking about their song selections in and out of universe.]]

to:

** Considering they sang I Kissed a Girl in an episode about a lesbian coming to terms with her sexuality, [[TheyJustDidntCare it rather seems like they aren't even thinking about their song selections in and out of universe.]]
18th Oct '16 3:51:04 PM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Lima has 10 high schools in it, not counting [=McKinley=] , which isn't real. It was flown in from [[FreaksAndGeeks a suburb of Detroit]], and before that it was in whatever the hell town TheWonderYears takes place in. And after those two it was near NYC, and [[FinalDestination some students were killed in a rollercoaster crash during Graduation Carnival]].

to:

** Lima has 10 high schools in it, not counting [=McKinley=] , which isn't real. It was flown in from [[FreaksAndGeeks [[Series/FreaksAndGeeks a suburb of Detroit]], and before that it was in whatever the hell town TheWonderYears takes place in. And after those two it was near NYC, and [[FinalDestination some students were killed in a rollercoaster crash during Graduation Carnival]].
23rd Aug '16 12:02:50 PM bjshipley1
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** Why was Mike siding with Rachel over his own girlfriend? Because Rachel is the {{DesignatedHero}}ine. Or at least, that's the reason in the writer's room.

to:

*** Why was Mike siding with Rachel over his own girlfriend? Because Rachel is the {{DesignatedHero}}ine.[[DesignatedHero Designated Heroine]]. Or at least, that's the reason in the writer's room.
30th Jun '16 9:14:56 PM H.N.Levian
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Could Finn have predicted that his comments would be used in a nationally-televised smear campaign? No. Could he have predicted that, in that crowded hallway, there was a possibility that the wrong person might overhear and use that information somehow? Yes, and he should have.
9th Jun '16 6:20:20 AM TheOneWhoTropes
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** He was playing a {{Retraux}} flirty-but-sexless "Hi, this is my HeterosexualLifePartner, welcome to our amazing home!" amalgam of different variety special hosts (and narrators). Practically everything he ''did'' was [[GettingCrapPastTheRadar subversively breaking character]], including the diamond necklace subplot. Artie's movie was supposed to fill an entire evening of airtime (the Yule Log video is two to four hours long, I expect a typical Christmas Eve live special to run for at least one hour, if not two), and the part of the show that we saw was only about ten or fifteen minutes long, and Kurt made a comment that the oven wasn't even started yet (in-story) but they had a turkey by the end of it, so there was probably either some DeusExMachina or [[WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief enough time to make people think they cooked a turkey]]. Also, Rory ''did'' [[ACharlieBrownChristmas go majorly off-script]].

to:

** He was playing a {{Retraux}} flirty-but-sexless "Hi, this is my HeterosexualLifePartner, welcome to our amazing home!" amalgam of different variety special hosts (and narrators). Practically everything he ''did'' was [[GettingCrapPastTheRadar subversively breaking character]], including the diamond necklace subplot. Artie's movie was supposed to fill an entire evening of airtime (the Yule Log video is two to four hours long, I expect a typical Christmas Eve live special to run for at least one hour, if not two), and the part of the show that we saw was only about ten or fifteen minutes long, and Kurt made a comment that the oven wasn't even started yet (in-story) but they had a turkey by the end of it, so there was probably either some DeusExMachina or [[WillingSuspensionOfDisbelief enough time to make people think they cooked a turkey]]. Also, Rory ''did'' [[ACharlieBrownChristmas [[WesternAnimation/ACharlieBrownChristmas go majorly off-script]].
30th May '16 1:01:55 PM Josef5678
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** But as of 3x09 we know (but then again we don't) that he has financial issues. The scene where he gives his present to Kurt and explains it will be in the [=DVDs=], so it's official. And this troper finds it likely that Blaine's economic problems will be brought up again in the show ''at least'' as a minor plot point/arc, if not a major one. So, could this be a case of FridgeBrilliance, since we know Dalton is very expensive? Maybe he really wanted to go to McKinley because of his love for Kurt, but that also came at just the right time as he needed to transfer to a more affordable school?

to:

** But as of 3x09 we know (but then again we don't) that he has financial issues. The scene where he gives his present to Kurt and explains it will be in the [=DVDs=], so it's official. And this troper finds it likely that Blaine's economic problems will be brought up again in the show ''at least'' as a minor plot point/arc, if not a major one. So, could this be a case of FridgeBrilliance, since we know Dalton is very expensive? Maybe he really wanted to go to McKinley [=McKinley=] because of his love for Kurt, but that also came at just the right time as he needed to transfer to a more affordable school?



*** That was at Mckinley, though. They have a terrible football team, so Finn was probably just naturally talented enough compared to everyone else to get the spot despite only being a sophomore. In Quinn's case, it was probably that the former head cheerleader had graduated the previous year and when the spot opened up Quinn was the only one capable of impressing Sue enough to get it. It makes no sense for a sophomore to be the star at Dalton because the Warblers are good and well established and have a clear hierarchy and pure talent alone is not enough to pull you up that hierarchy. In fact, Blaine told Kurt that he needed to stop showing off how good he is LESS so that he'll fit in (which is exactly the opposite of what Blaine does...). The two schools are completely different and it's still inconsistent with what we've seen of Dalton.
*** My reaction to hearing Blaine say he's a Junior caused me to let out a FlatWhat, but I have a possible explanation - if Blaine's bounced around between schools (Dalton, McKinley, and it seems like he went to a different school before Dalton), credit requirements may have been different enough to leave him behind a year. It's an imperfect solution, of course, but it's keeping my blood pressure under control.

to:

*** That was at Mckinley, [=Mckinley=], though. They have a terrible football team, so Finn was probably just naturally talented enough compared to everyone else to get the spot despite only being a sophomore. In Quinn's case, it was probably that the former head cheerleader had graduated the previous year and when the spot opened up Quinn was the only one capable of impressing Sue enough to get it. It makes no sense for a sophomore to be the star at Dalton because the Warblers are good and well established and have a clear hierarchy and pure talent alone is not enough to pull you up that hierarchy. In fact, Blaine told Kurt that he needed to stop showing off how good he is LESS so that he'll fit in (which is exactly the opposite of what Blaine does...). The two schools are completely different and it's still inconsistent with what we've seen of Dalton.
*** My reaction to hearing Blaine say he's a Junior caused me to let out a FlatWhat, but I have a possible explanation - if Blaine's bounced around between schools (Dalton, McKinley, [=McKinley=], and it seems like he went to a different school before Dalton), credit requirements may have been different enough to leave him behind a year. It's an imperfect solution, of course, but it's keeping my blood pressure under control.



* Is anyone getting as mad about Kurt's character as I have been in the last two episodes? He had to get told by his dad that he is manipulative and needs to calm down in "Duets", but he is back to being manipulative, especially in regards to his relationship with Blaine. First, he convinced Blaine to transfer to McKinley despite all the reasons mentioned above. Now, when they are trying to put on a production of Theatre/WestSideStory, Kurt basically acts like it would be awful if Blaine auditioned for Tony because Kurt wants to be Tony really bad. This somehow makes Blaine decide to audition solely to be any male that isn't Tony, and yet, when the directors ask him to read for Tony, we have to see Kurt acting really betrayed and hurt. I know Kurt has issues with being seen as only the camp gay performer, but I don't think he has the right to bitch to his boyfriend about trying for something Kurt wants. If Kurt isn't right for the role, he shouldn't get it. That's how theater works, and it is frustrating to see him act like it is so awful if Blaine doesn't do what he asks.

to:

* Is anyone getting as mad about Kurt's character as I have been in the last two episodes? He had to get told by his dad that he is manipulative and needs to calm down in "Duets", but he is back to being manipulative, especially in regards to his relationship with Blaine. First, he convinced Blaine to transfer to McKinley [=McKinley=] despite all the reasons mentioned above. Now, when they are trying to put on a production of Theatre/WestSideStory, Kurt basically acts like it would be awful if Blaine auditioned for Tony because Kurt wants to be Tony really bad. This somehow makes Blaine decide to audition solely to be any male that isn't Tony, and yet, when the directors ask him to read for Tony, we have to see Kurt acting really betrayed and hurt. I know Kurt has issues with being seen as only the camp gay performer, but I don't think he has the right to bitch to his boyfriend about trying for something Kurt wants. If Kurt isn't right for the role, he shouldn't get it. That's how theater works, and it is frustrating to see him act like it is so awful if Blaine doesn't do what he asks.



* My first time using this website, so forgive me if I do it wrong, but I think it made perfect sense. When I was in a new school for one grade only (8th), a boy in the same town who I had gone to elementary school with and now went to a different school than I, committed suicide at the age of 12. I remember clearly finding out because I had been anxious about it being school picture day. I remember the principal and vice principal coming to our classroom just minutes before and talking about Brighton Brown. He asked if we knew about what happened (it had been on the local news, but I hadn't heard), and explained that he had tragically taken his own life. The reasons schools address this is pretty valid: yes, it could prompt other students to hurt themselves, but also because a lot of people that knew him were slightly traumatized by the news, and the principal/teachers wanted us to know that if anyone needed to talk about it, out of school guidance counselors could come in and speak to us one-on-one if we had questions, thoughts, etc. It makes sense that the McKinley staff would want to address it as delicately as possible before EVERYONE found out via the Internet, because, as they put it, Karofsky still had friends at McKinley (not Azimio, obviously) who either didn't know he was gay at that point, or still liked him. I don't know how it works at other schools, but that episode struck as very Truth In Television for me.

to:

* My first time using this website, so forgive me if I do it wrong, but I think it made perfect sense. When I was in a new school for one grade only (8th), a boy in the same town who I had gone to elementary school with and now went to a different school than I, committed suicide at the age of 12. I remember clearly finding out because I had been anxious about it being school picture day. I remember the principal and vice principal coming to our classroom just minutes before and talking about Brighton Brown. He asked if we knew about what happened (it had been on the local news, but I hadn't heard), and explained that he had tragically taken his own life. The reasons schools address this is pretty valid: yes, it could prompt other students to hurt themselves, but also because a lot of people that knew him were slightly traumatized by the news, and the principal/teachers wanted us to know that if anyone needed to talk about it, out of school guidance counselors could come in and speak to us one-on-one if we had questions, thoughts, etc. It makes sense that the McKinley [=McKinley=] staff would want to address it as delicately as possible before EVERYONE found out via the Internet, because, as they put it, Karofsky still had friends at McKinley [=McKinley=] (not Azimio, obviously) who either didn't know he was gay at that point, or still liked him. I don't know how it works at other schools, but that episode struck as very Truth In Television for me.



** Blaine went to a private school that probably cost $30,000 a year. Even if he flew weekly it would cost a lot less then $30,000 over the course of the year. What I wonder is what in-universe reason will they come up with for Blain staying at McKinley next year without Kurt. A school like Dalton would look way better on his college transcripts then the local public school.

to:

** Blaine went to a private school that probably cost $30,000 a year. Even if he flew weekly it would cost a lot less then $30,000 over the course of the year. What I wonder is what in-universe reason will they come up with for Blain staying at McKinley [=McKinley=] next year without Kurt. A school like Dalton would look way better on his college transcripts then the local public school.
This list shows the last 10 events of 909. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Headscratchers.GleeSeason3