Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / FullMetalAlchemist

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The King may have had the whole population move to within the boundaries of the circle so they could take advantage of the new "irrigation channels" he'd made. It is entirely plausible that some people ''did'' flee. Possibly, anyone who fled in large enough numbers to be noticed (like a village) might be branded traitors and killed, which would discourage anyone else from fleeing in numbers larger than a family unit--and since the destinations would be places like Xing, Amestris, and Amestris' neighbors, their Xerxian ethnic markers would just fade out through the generations. Alternatively, any large group of Xerxians who ''did'' escape in numbers enough to still maintain a gold-eyed, blond population would stay the hell away from anyone else after finding out everyone else in their homeland was dead, so there might be some enclave in Xing that nobody outside knows about.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** You also have to account for the chain of command. Whether they saw the whole process or just a part of it (or even as little as the border guards dropping to the floor), they didn't know what to do in that scenario, because no one in those countries could know what's happening. By the time any of their higher-ups came to a conclusion, the whole event might've been over already.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Bugged phone lines]]
* Hughes doesn't call Roy on a military phone to tell him what he's figured out, since he thinks the phones might be bugged. Instead, he calls Roy from a civilian phone booth. But ''Roy's'' phone is still a military line, so why wouldn't Hughes think that was bugged too? The most secure method would be to talk to Roy in person, ideally not in a military building.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Are you serious? Manga Wrath is the coolest and more badass thing known to man. What if he doesn't ''act angry''? I don't think "Wrath" is supposed to represent "angry" in an "I'm pissed off" way. He embodies a way deeper (and scarier) hatred and bloodlust, what with directing a genocide of massive proportions and being an unstoppable killing machine in close quarters combat. His Wrath is more of an embodiment of the merciless ire of war. And all this while looking a lot like a distant relative of [[VideoGame/MetalGearSolid3 Big Boss]]. It just doesn't get much better.

to:

** Are you serious? Manga Wrath is the coolest and more badass thing known to man. What if he doesn't ''act angry''? I don't think "Wrath" is supposed to represent "angry" in an "I'm pissed off" way. He embodies a way deeper (and scarier) hatred and bloodlust, what with directing a genocide of massive proportions and being an unstoppable killing machine in close quarters combat. His Wrath is more of an embodiment of the merciless ire of war. And all this while looking a lot like a distant relative of [[VideoGame/MetalGearSolid3 [[VideoGame/MetalGearSolid3SnakeEater Big Boss]]. It just doesn't get much better.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If [[spoiler:Father]]'s grand plan is to [[spoiler:consume all the souls of Amestris in preparation for... um...[[WhatDoYouMeanItWasntMadeOnDrugs wrenching open the sky and eating God]],]] then why did he bother creating [[spoiler:the puppet army]]? It doesn't seem to factor into his strategy at all.

to:

* If [[spoiler:Father]]'s grand plan is to [[spoiler:consume all the souls of Amestris in preparation for... um...[[WhatDoYouMeanItWasntMadeOnDrugs wrenching open the sky and eating God]],]] God,]] then why did he bother creating [[spoiler:the puppet army]]? It doesn't seem to factor into his strategy at all.

Added: 1064

Changed: 12

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added a Headscratcher.


** Presuming Tucker even knew of such parrots? Even if he had, how would he have gotten ahold of any to experiment with? We don't know what kind of Africa equivalent FMA has, but even if the continents were all exactly the same as ours, they would have to get them from the south, past Aerugo, which has been actively at war with Amestris for years. Humans are his best option for talking, let alone intelligent chimeras. (Chimeri?)

to:

** Presuming Tucker even knew of such parrots? Even if he had, how would he have gotten ahold of any to experiment with? We don't know what kind of Africa equivalent FMA has, but even if the continents were all exactly the same as ours, they would have to get them from the south, past Aerugo, which has been actively at war with Amestris for years. Humans are his best option for talking, let alone intelligent chimeras. (Chimeri?)


Added DiffLines:

[[folder:The complete annihilation of Xerxes]]
* How did all of Xerxes get annihilated? I mean, unlike Artemis, [[spoiler:Xerxes wasn't ''purpose designed'' to be a transmutation circle, so it would presumably not be approximately a circle without at least a few villages outside of the circle. Assuming that to be the case, how would the circle get the ''entire'' population]]? While one could argue that [[spoiler:Father eliminated these villages for extra "fuel," he would have to reach multiple such locations before people fled]]. Additionally, the only remains of Xerxes which survive by the time the main story takes place are buildings such as the palace (which makes sense given that Xerxes is a FantasyCounterpartCulture to Ancient Persia, who primarily built in sun-baked brick, with only higher status buildings ever being built in stone), so the archaeology as it is shown doesn't actually explain anything of the actual shape of the country. All things considered, the idea that there isn't at least a small RacialRemnant seems implausible.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Building off this, take Ed and Winry's final conversation, re: giving someone half your life vs. giving it all. According to the laws of equivalent exchange the latter is impossible,or at least unfeasible, while in practical human terms it's the simplest thing in the world. The value of human life and everything that makes it what it is is unquantifiable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Scar wants to kill all state alchemists for a combination of seeing their alchemy as blasphemous and blaming them for the massacre of his people. He's no more discerning than that, he even agrees to let Al go because Al's not a state alchemist. He's also pretty opprotunistic. He wasn't targeting Ed, he was just walking down the street when he heard some call the name of a state alchemist. And with one right in front of him, he obviously goes for the kill.
Tabs MOD

Changed: 10

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Kill Em All was renamed Everybody Dies Ending due to misuse. Dewicking


** That, and I don't get the impression that his powers work really well as a shield anyway. I mean, he can make his body invulnerable, but can't turn himself wide enough to protect others. Also, given that he was already killed by the other homonculi, his goal at this point is to KillEmAll, so sacrificing himself would be the last thing he wanted to do.

to:

** That, and I don't get the impression that his powers work really well as a shield anyway. I mean, he can make his body invulnerable, but can't turn himself wide enough to protect others. Also, given that he was already killed by the other homonculi, his goal at this point is to KillEmAll, kill them, so sacrificing himself would be the last thing he wanted to do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* It doesn't even really matter that Human Transmutation is impossible. Simply seeing the gate and gaining circleless transmutation is something a lot of alchemists would give their right arm for (literally). And sacrificing a body part isn't even necessary if you can provide Truth a philosopher's stone. There's really no reason someone like the gold tooth alchemists who was fully on father's side didn't visit the gate, unless we're just to believe he was kind of shit at alchemy and had that advanced position in father's inner circle purely out of loyalty and not some degree of competency. That they can force it if need be is also a poor excuse as that comes at incredible cost to them. This is a massively critical step in father's plan that could have been twarted if Izumi had just tripped and died. And then he'd need to start all over again and find a new eclipse somewhere. If hed just announced five or ten years earlier that they are removing the restrictions on human transmutation for research purposes and he'd have a list of people signing up to be sacrifices, not just candidates.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Expanding on the above, not only does it bring severe costs to the alchemists, but it ''doesn't even work as intended'' (at least not for bringing people back to life). No wonder such a cost-heavy practice with such bad results would develop taboo status, no amount of government endorsement would be able to change that, so they just play along. And since they can, as shown with Roy, force an alchemist into seeing Truth against their will, they only really needed to keep a handful of strong alchemists around (which the state alchemist program is designed to do), they just luckied out in having four of them that had already experienced Truth on their own and happened to be around.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Please note that this page is for Headscratchers regarding the manga and 2009 anime adaptation entitled Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. For the 2003 anime adaptation see [[Headscratchers/FullMetalAlchemist2003 Headscratchers/FullMetalAlchemistAnime]]

to:

Please note that this page is for Headscratchers regarding the manga and 2009 anime adaptation entitled Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. For the 2003 anime adaptation see [[Headscratchers/FullMetalAlchemist2003 Headscratchers/FullMetalAlchemistAnime]]
Headscratchers.FullmetalAlchemist2003.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Please note that this page is for Headscratchers regarding the manga and 2009 anime adaptation entitled Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. For the 2003 anime adaptation see [[Headscratchers/FullMetalAlchemistAnime Headscratchers/FullMetalAlchemistAnime]]

to:

Please note that this page is for Headscratchers regarding the manga and 2009 anime adaptation entitled Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. For the 2003 anime adaptation see [[Headscratchers/FullMetalAlchemistAnime [[Headscratchers/FullMetalAlchemist2003 Headscratchers/FullMetalAlchemistAnime]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Envy's seeming JokerImmunity. I was a bit bugged when he/she/it is able to trick May into taking him to be "healed" after he/she/it is destroyed to the point of being in the "evil fetus" looking true form. [[spoiler: Roy]] does this again, and the presentation seems to be IfYouKillHImYouWillBeJustLikeHim, [[spoiler:especially in having Scar talk about Roy's desire for revenge as consuming like his own]]. It just bugs me because there isn't any benefit for the heroes to keep Envy alive.

to:

* Envy's seeming JokerImmunity. I was a bit bugged when he/she/it is able to trick May into taking him to be "healed" after he/she/it is destroyed to the point of being in the "evil fetus" looking true form. [[spoiler: Roy]] does this again, and the presentation seems to be IfYouKillHImYouWillBeJustLikeHim, IfYouKillHimYouWillBeJustLikeHim, [[spoiler:especially in having Scar talk about Roy's desire for revenge as consuming like his own]]. It just bugs me because there isn't any benefit for the heroes to keep Envy alive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I don't think Tucker is necessarily stupid or incompetent (this feel more like a meme carried out from the 2003 version, where it was indeed the case). Like someone said before, he is just sociopathic. So, now to my point, just like human transmutation, any type of alchemy that tampers with humans is deemed unethical and illegal. Thus human chimeras are possible, but not something alchemists will perform in the eyes of the public. So, why did the [[spoiler: Nina (and wife)]] chimera looked so inferior to the human chimeras introduced later? Because, as someone said before, he needed people to thing they weren't made from anything but animals. It comes across a little like Fridge Brilliance, but Tucker making talking chimeras with that form is a clever way to not rouse any suspicion. As to why he used [[spoiler: his wife and daughter]], chapter 0, released as promotion for the live-action movie, confirmed he failed the exam several times. After some "misinterpreted" encouraging words from his [[spoiler: wife]], he realized he could use them to make the chimeras talk. In other words, the guy already had quite a few screw loose.

to:

** I don't think Tucker is necessarily stupid or incompetent (this feel more like a meme carried out from the 2003 version, where it was indeed the case). Like someone said before, he is just sociopathic. So, now to my point, just like human transmutation, any type of alchemy that tampers with humans is deemed unethical and illegal. Thus human chimeras are possible, but not something alchemists will perform in the eyes of the public. So, why did the [[spoiler: Nina (and wife)]] chimera looked so inferior to the human chimeras introduced later? Because, as someone said before, he needed people to thing think they weren't made from anything but animals. It comes across a little like Fridge Brilliance, but Tucker making talking chimeras with that form is a clever way to not rouse any suspicion. As to why he used [[spoiler: his wife and daughter]], chapter 0, released as promotion for the live-action movie, confirmed he failed the exam several times. After some "misinterpreted" encouraging words from his [[spoiler: wife]], he realized he could use them to make the chimeras talk. In other words, the guy already had quite a few screw loose.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** I don't think Tucker is necessarily stupid or incompetent (this feel more like a meme carried out from the 2003 version, where it was indeed the case). Like someone said before, he is just sociopathic. So, now to my point, just like human transmutation, any type of alchemy that tampers with humans is deemed unethical and illegal. Thus human chimeras are possible, but not something alchemists will perform in the eyes of the public. So, why did the [[spoiler: Nina (and wife)]] chimera looked so inferior to the human chimeras introduced later? Because, as someone said before, he needed people to thing they weren't made from anything but animals. It comes across a little like Fridge Brilliance, but Tucker making talking chimeras with that form is a clever way to not rouse any suspicion. As to why he used [[spoiler: his wife and daughter]], chapter 0, released as promotion for the live-action movie, confirmed he failed the exam several times. After some "misinterpreted" encouraging words from his [[spoiler: wife]], he realized he could use them to make the chimeras talk. In other words, the guy already had quite a few screw loose.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Jokes at Tucker's incompetence aside, I believe this is the point: He is a potential sacrifice candidate (and well, technically, any state alchemist is labeled as one). The special chapter 0, released for the live-action movie premiere, confirmed Tucker has tried, and failed, the State Alchemist exam several times. Only the talking chimera secured him the title. It is possible the higher-ups and Homunculi saw the lines this guy was willing to cross, thus gave him the title so he could savor some glory, so later he would get more and more over the edge and eventually attempting a full human transmutation just to keep the title.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Foe Yay has been cut


* This could be either Fridge Brilliance, Horror, or Logic depending on how you look at it. As noted under Lust's OppositeSexClone entry in "Characters" she shares some physical similarities to Father. Now consider that (A) she is the embodiment of Father's lust and (B) [[FoeYay Father based his appearance on Hoenheim]]...

to:

* This could be either Fridge Brilliance, Horror, or Logic depending on how you look at it. As noted under Lust's OppositeSexClone entry in "Characters" she shares some physical similarities to Father. Now consider that (A) she is the embodiment of Father's lust and (B) [[FoeYay Father based his appearance on Hoenheim]]...
Hohenheim...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Prides "Death" is shaky, but we can be definitely sure that he didn't destroy his stone, since that would fully kill him. We can safely assume that the stone was inside his core (The baby that regrew into Selim) and since the core itself was never damaged we can assume that they are still in his stone. So he likely still has his HealingFactor, but shadows are another question, becase we don't know what's the source of that. Ultmmately we don't know what Eduard did to him, that entire scene is really weird.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed links to illegal manga scan sites.


** Lust was [[http://www.onemanga.com/Full_Metal_Alchemist/34/39-40/ wearing a coat]] when she saw Havoc so the rest is probably her skin. I'm pretty sure that with the exceptions of Wrath, Pride and maybe Evny,it's either like this for the rest of the Homunculi or a personal fashion choice.

to:

** Lust was [[http://www.onemanga.com/Full_Metal_Alchemist/34/39-40/ wearing a coat]] coat when she saw Havoc so the rest is probably her skin. I'm pretty sure that with the exceptions of Wrath, Pride and maybe Evny,it's either like this for the rest of the Homunculi or a personal fashion choice.



** The watches do actually have the alchemist's name engraved on them: [[http://www.onemanga.com/Full_Metal_Alchemist/17/14/ observe]] ([[http://mangafox.me/manga/fullmetal_alchemist/v05/c017/15.html updated link]]). And while the military do have State Alchemists' photos [[http://www.onemanga.com/Full_Metal_Alchemist/5/06/ on file]] ([[http://mangafox.me/manga/fullmetal_alchemist/v02/c005/6.html updated link]]), this isn't a digitised world so even if there are copies made it's probably only one or two for an area HQ or something. The soldiers dispatched in ch. 81 come very quickly after Darius makes the withdrawal from the bank, so were probably nearby and decided to go for 'written description and known associate' over rooting around through a filing cabinet after a doubtless out of date photograph. Plus there's no way of knowing if the soldier at the door would have recognised Ed after a moment or so or not, since Ed went BerserkButton on him right away.

to:

** The watches do actually have the alchemist's name engraved on them: [[http://www.onemanga.com/Full_Metal_Alchemist/17/14/ observe]] ([[http://mangafox.me/manga/fullmetal_alchemist/v05/c017/15.html updated link]]). them. And while the military do have State Alchemists' photos [[http://www.onemanga.com/Full_Metal_Alchemist/5/06/ on file]] ([[http://mangafox.me/manga/fullmetal_alchemist/v02/c005/6.html updated link]]), file, this isn't a digitised world so even if there are copies made it's probably only one or two for an area HQ or something. The soldiers dispatched in ch. 81 come very quickly after Darius makes the withdrawal from the bank, so were probably nearby and decided to go for 'written description and known associate' over rooting around through a filing cabinet after a doubtless out of date photograph. Plus there's no way of knowing if the soldier at the door would have recognised Ed after a moment or so or not, since Ed went BerserkButton on him right away.



** It's very possible that Ed is a natural lefty in the first anime (from which that scene comes, and is already after the transmutation), not in the manga. Proof; in the last panel, Ed is writing out the formula with his right hand. http://www.mangafox.com/manga/fullmetal_alchemist/v006/c023/18.html

to:

** It's very possible that Ed is a natural lefty in the first anime (from which that scene comes, and is already after the transmutation), not in the manga. Proof; in the last panel, Ed is writing out the formula with his right hand. http://www.mangafox.com/manga/fullmetal_alchemist/v006/c023/18.html

Added: 1346

Changed: 68

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Answered the "Shadows" question.


** Correction: As discussed elsewhere on this page, under "Human Transmutation definition", creating a chimera, and other Bio-alchemy, do ''not'' count as human transmutation, so there was never a risk of Tucker seeing Truth. I personally doubt the military, even the higher-ups (I doubt they barely even knew who Tucker ''was'' beyond "that chimera-alchemist"), knew about what Tucker did, but the possibility of some minor benefit from Tucker's work is quite likely the reason the military kept him on, alongside his "talking chimera breakthrough". Tucker basically conned his way into prestige by claiming to have done something that is ''technically'' possible (any living thing could potentially speak like a human if it had the necessary brain development and a mouth able to form the right sounds), but had never before/has not been done, but in reality, he did it by doing something so immoral and unexpected that nobody in the military at the level he interacted with suspected it (and honestly, who would ''want'' or be ''able'' to think that an apparent family man, like Tucker appeared to be, would just on the spot use his loving wife as experiment material?) and after that I'm guessing he made excuses on why he couldn't just keep doing it, so they let him keep tinkering with animals, giving them a demonstration of bio-alchemy in case anyone was interested in that field, and waiting on him to reproduce his "breakthrough". The rest we see for ourselves...

to:

** *** Correction: As discussed elsewhere on this page, under "Human Transmutation definition", creating a chimera, and other Bio-alchemy, do ''not'' count as human transmutation, so there was never a risk of Tucker seeing Truth. I personally doubt the military, even the higher-ups (I doubt they barely even knew who Tucker ''was'' beyond "that chimera-alchemist"), knew about what Tucker did, but the possibility of some minor benefit from Tucker's work is quite likely the reason the military kept him on, alongside his "talking chimera breakthrough". Tucker basically conned his way into prestige by claiming to have done something that is ''technically'' possible (any living thing could potentially speak like a human if it had the necessary brain development and a mouth able to form the right sounds), but had never before/has not been done, but in reality, he did it by doing something so immoral and unexpected that nobody in the military at the level he interacted with suspected it (and honestly, who would ''want'' or be ''able'' to think that an apparent family man, like Tucker appeared to be, would just on the spot use his loving wife as experiment material?) material? At least, without any direct reasons for suspicion like Edward had) and after that I'm guessing he made excuses on why he couldn't just keep doing it, so they let him keep tinkering with animals, giving them a demonstration of bio-alchemy in case anyone was interested in that field, and waiting on him to reproduce his "breakthrough". The rest we see for ourselves...


Added DiffLines:

*** This might be WildMassGuessing, but the way ''I'' assume that Pride's "shadows" work is that they genuinely are a non-physical substance that can still interact with the world. Or, to put it another way, Father, and Pride, are both made of a sort of substance that is from "beyond the Gate" and thus is not of the normal matter and energy, similar to souls. That doesn't stop it from ''working'' like regular matter or energy when it needs to, and Pride's form is tied, for one reason or another, to the concept of darkness and light, and thus Pride seems to be merging himself with any and all shadows he can connect to, and thus extend his form and expand his capabilities in the process. In a sense, Pride ''is'' living shadow that happens to inhabit a human-looking container, as does Father. Science, and Alchemy as well it seems, does not work based solely on definitions, only on discovery and explanation of reality. No law is absolute in and of itself, so there can be exceptions, hence why Philospher's Stones are considered "magical" in a sense (because they use souls for fuel, which follows and yet also flouts Equivalent Exchange, which is discussed in length throughout the Fridge page). Heck, Alphonse gives a whole speech about there always being more to learn, and that exceptions are possible, even for the laws of Alchemy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Corrected something new from "Tucker as a State Alchemist"



to:

** Correction: As discussed elsewhere on this page, under "Human Transmutation definition", creating a chimera, and other Bio-alchemy, do ''not'' count as human transmutation, so there was never a risk of Tucker seeing Truth. I personally doubt the military, even the higher-ups (I doubt they barely even knew who Tucker ''was'' beyond "that chimera-alchemist"), knew about what Tucker did, but the possibility of some minor benefit from Tucker's work is quite likely the reason the military kept him on, alongside his "talking chimera breakthrough". Tucker basically conned his way into prestige by claiming to have done something that is ''technically'' possible (any living thing could potentially speak like a human if it had the necessary brain development and a mouth able to form the right sounds), but had never before/has not been done, but in reality, he did it by doing something so immoral and unexpected that nobody in the military at the level he interacted with suspected it (and honestly, who would ''want'' or be ''able'' to think that an apparent family man, like Tucker appeared to be, would just on the spot use his loving wife as experiment material?) and after that I'm guessing he made excuses on why he couldn't just keep doing it, so they let him keep tinkering with animals, giving them a demonstration of bio-alchemy in case anyone was interested in that field, and waiting on him to reproduce his "breakthrough". The rest we see for ourselves...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** I'd guess that it's probably case of raw mass plus whatever energy they need to pull from the movement of tectonic plates in order to move that mass around. We do see that creating a spear from dirt/stone flooring is possible but takes more material then the spear itself is made out of so presumably if you want something more complex like refined metals that are scarcer you need to use more mass to compensate for that. Ideally you use the exact materials you need like all the pieces of a radio or tool which you simply move into place with alchemy but lacking that a sufficient amount of mass can be used to compensate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** His immediate supervisors didn't realize what his original chimera had been made from despite how apparent it is to all of us so they were impressed by his display. Tucker being the consumate liar he was managed to smooth talk his way around the obvious questions probably with excuses about mixing primates with other species. Higher up the chain some of the leadership realied what had probably happened but kept quiet because while Tucker wasn't a great alchemist he might produce something of note again which they could use. After all he did successfully make a human-animal chimera and didn't die or end up with his organs removed in the process meaning he skirted close to the realm of god without getting burned in the process. Relatively speaking it was a miniscule investment for the military that had a chance, if not a great one, of leading to a much bigger pay off down the road and even if it didn't work out they'd have spent maybe enough to house two common soldiers for the same length of time. Small risk, big possible reward, low change of long term negative consequences.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Presuming Tucker even knew of such parrots? Even if he had, how would he have gotten ahold of any to experiment with? We don't know what kind of Africa equivalent FMA has, but even if the continents were all exactly the same as ours, they would have to get them from the south, past Aerugo, which has been actively at war with Amestris for years. Humans are his best option for talking, let alone intelligent chimeras. (Chimeri?)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Why not make a parrot chimera?]]
* Did Shou Tucker never consider using a parrot to make a chimera capable of human speech? Parrots are capable of reproducing human language, and some of the more intelligent varieties (such as African Greys) can understand it to an extent. Obviouly, Tucker had some screws loose, but the thought still should have occured to him.
[[/folder]]

Top