Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / FallingSkies

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removal of What An Idiot potholes per Wick Cleaning Projects


* Just how in the [[WebVideo/HellsingUltimateAbridged blood-soaked protestant Hell]] did Mason's needle penetrate Scorch's armor, ''which has been shown to block bullets'' beforehand? And how did Scorch remotely think it was a good idea to track down Mason ''[[WhatAnIdiot without any guards]]''?

to:

* Just how in the [[WebVideo/HellsingUltimateAbridged blood-soaked protestant Hell]] did Mason's needle penetrate Scorch's armor, ''which has been shown to block bullets'' beforehand? And how did Scorch remotely think it was a good idea to track down Mason ''[[WhatAnIdiot without ''without any guards]]''?guards''?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Critical Research Failure is a disambiguation page


* Small problem I had with the American Revolution analogy: Tom repeatedly talks about making a big enough problem for the invaders was what will drive them away, same as the American Revolution. Except one teeny, tiny, problem with that: [[CriticalResearchFailure That isn't how the war ended,]] the British left because while they were establishing their empire, they pissed off the French, Spanish, and a good few other equally powerful empires, who promptly pushed them into Canada. So is that Tom's plan? Wait until ''other'' equally powerful and possibly also evil Alien empires decides to get revenge on the Skitters for some wrong they did to them? Because otherwise, as sad as it is, Pope would be right, being a pain in their invaders ass will just repeat the Indian wars: Thousands of more Skitters will come and LeaveNoSurvivors.

to:

* Small problem I had with the American Revolution analogy: Tom repeatedly talks about making a big enough problem for the invaders was what will drive them away, same as the American Revolution. Except one teeny, tiny, problem with that: [[CriticalResearchFailure That isn't how the war ended,]] ended, the British left because while they were establishing their empire, they pissed off the French, Spanish, and a good few other equally powerful empires, who promptly pushed them into Canada. So is that Tom's plan? Wait until ''other'' equally powerful and possibly also evil Alien empires decides to get revenge on the Skitters for some wrong they did to them? Because otherwise, as sad as it is, Pope would be right, being a pain in their invaders ass will just repeat the Indian wars: Thousands of more Skitters will come and LeaveNoSurvivors.

Changed: 25

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Disambiguated


* Small problem I had with the American Revolution analogy: Tom repeatedly talks about making a big enough problem for the invaders was what will drive them away, same as the American Revolution. Except one teeny, tiny, problem with that: [[CriticalResearchFailure That isn't how the war ended,]] the British left because while they were establishing their empire, they pissed off the French, Spanish, and a good few other equally powerful empires, who promptly pushed them into Canada. So is that Tom's plan? Wait until ''other'' equally powerful and possibly also evil Alien empires decides to get revenge on the Skitters for some wrong they did to them? Because otherwise, as sad as it is, Pope would be right, being a pain in their invaders ass will just repeat the Indian wars: Thousands of more Skitters will come and KillThemAll.

to:

* Small problem I had with the American Revolution analogy: Tom repeatedly talks about making a big enough problem for the invaders was what will drive them away, same as the American Revolution. Except one teeny, tiny, problem with that: [[CriticalResearchFailure That isn't how the war ended,]] the British left because while they were establishing their empire, they pissed off the French, Spanish, and a good few other equally powerful empires, who promptly pushed them into Canada. So is that Tom's plan? Wait until ''other'' equally powerful and possibly also evil Alien empires decides to get revenge on the Skitters for some wrong they did to them? Because otherwise, as sad as it is, Pope would be right, being a pain in their invaders ass will just repeat the Indian wars: Thousands of more Skitters will come and KillThemAll.LeaveNoSurvivors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Kill Them All is no longer a trope


*** Which was also used in Transformers 3: The Decepticon invaders make a statement by first forcing the humans to give up the one thing that could save them ([[spoiler: The Autobots]]), seemingly destroy their only possible saviors in front of them after they gave them up, so they can't get them back, and then [[KillThemAll kill everything in one of the bigger cities,]] and use it as a base of comand, effictivly demoralizing the human race. The show has a lot of parrellels to TFormers 3, probably because Steven Speilberg was in on both's creation.

to:

*** Which was also used in Transformers 3: The Decepticon invaders make a statement by first forcing the humans to give up the one thing that could save them ([[spoiler: The Autobots]]), seemingly destroy their only possible saviors in front of them after they gave them up, so they can't get them back, and then [[KillThemAll kill everything in one of the bigger cities,]] cities, and use it as a base of comand, effictivly demoralizing the human race. The show has a lot of parrellels to TFormers 3, probably because Steven Speilberg was in on both's creation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I guess TheLawsAndCustomsOfWar are out the window on the human side, too. When [[spoiler: Karen]] comes under a white flag to talk, Tom summarily shoots [[spoiler: her]]. This is '''absolutely'' prohibited. Of course, given the atrocities of the other side, being conscientious is tantamount to suicide, but still. On the other hand, [[spoiler: Karen]] brought a Mech to the meeting, which would also be prohibited (Mechs being tantamount to heavy armor).

to:

* I guess TheLawsAndCustomsOfWar UsefulNotes/TheLawsAndCustomsOfWar are out the window on the human side, too. When [[spoiler: Karen]] comes under a white flag to talk, Tom summarily shoots [[spoiler: her]]. This is '''absolutely'' prohibited. Of course, given the atrocities of the other side, being conscientious is tantamount to suicide, but still. On the other hand, [[spoiler: Karen]] brought a Mech to the meeting, which would also be prohibited (Mechs being tantamount to heavy armor).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** And that would matter to an alien life form whose tolerances are unknown to us... how? For all we know, they could be some kind of creature like those that live at the bottom of deep-ocean trenches, or hot vents- extremophiles, they're called. Yes, the Skitters and the Slenders (the tall, skinny ones, due to their resemblance to [[TheSlenderManMythos Slender Man,]])) have been shown on Earth, walking around with no problem... but do they have the same lack of problems in other environments?

to:

*** And that would matter to an alien life form whose tolerances are unknown to us... how? For all we know, they could be some kind of creature like those that live at the bottom of deep-ocean trenches, or hot vents- extremophiles, they're called. Yes, the Skitters and the Slenders (the tall, skinny ones, due to their resemblance to [[TheSlenderManMythos [[Franchise/TheSlenderManMythos Slender Man,]])) have been shown on Earth, walking around with no problem... but do they have the same lack of problems in other environments?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** He shoots his argument in the foot when making comparisons like that, its the same argument the militia types in the US talk about popular revolt. Yes a small guerilla force has held off better armies in the past but there were very specific advantages they had that the human rebels here do not. In the case of the American Revolutionaries, they mostly forget about the part where France shippped them weapons and some soldiers, but also used their fleet to blockade certain ports to force the British out. The Vietcong, who lost almost every encounter they had with the US military, had siginificant training and supply help from both China and Russia. The Afghan mujahedeen had alot of American help in getting the Soviets out of their country as well. In the world of Falling Skies, no such help is coming from abroad, they are on their own. They have no manufacturing or food production facilities, so their weapons and supplies are scavenged, and the canned food in existence cannot possibly feed them forever, the ammo laying around would certainly be gone long before the series starts and the guns would be breaking down as well. Without a friendly force supplying them, or at least feeding them ... they would all die or surrender real soon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* If the Espheni invaded earth back in the 6th century, how was a space-faring army defeated by "savages" with swords and arrows? Furthermore, how did no one document a global alien invasion, especially in times from which there is plenty of documentation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It is implied if not outright stated that Scorch had gone rogue on his personal revenge trip, it is possible that he had exhausted all of his resources.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* What happened to the Espheni's motivation? The first Overlord stated that Earth was just in the long line of the empire's conquering, Scorch stated in the second episode of Season 4 that the Espheni came to Earth to escape from a more dangerous enemy themselves, ''and'' [[spoiler: the Espheni Queen states that the only reason for invading Earth was to get revenge for her sister, and it was premeditated the whole time.]] Which is it?!

Added: 131

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


If the Espheni literally have no power left after the destruction of their power core and Volm are still a space-faring race, how is this even a war anymore?

to:

If *If the Espheni literally have no power left after the destruction of their power core and Volm are still a space-faring race, how is this even a war anymore? anymore?
*So the Dornian weapon doesn't affect Ben's spikes then? Aside from it's the last episode and they wanted to end happy... why not?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


If the Espheni literally have no power left after the destruction of their power core and Volm are still a space=faring race, how is this even a war anymore?

to:

If the Espheni literally have no power left after the destruction of their power core and Volm are still a space=faring space-faring race, how is this even a war anymore?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Season Five]]
If the Espheni literally have no power left after the destruction of their power core and Volm are still a space=faring race, how is this even a war anymore?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Just how in the [[WebVideo/HellsingUltimateAbridged blood-soaked protestant Hell]] did Mason's needle penetrate Scorch's armor, ''which has been shown to block bullets'' beforehand? And how did Scorch remotely think it was a good idea to track down Mason ''[[WhatAnIdiot without any guards]]''?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** A year isn't ''that'' far away. Most of these kids are old enough to remember life before the invasion, and it's not like they'd magically forget all that stuff in just a year's time. If the show jumps ahead to the point when most of the children seen on screen were born after the invasion, then the jokes would seem weird.

Top