History Headscratchers / DowntonAbbey

16th Jun '17 3:18:52 PM habby
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Even with the injury, her objections make little sense given the social aftermath of WWI. England had a "surplus" of about two million women, and around 30% of Edith's generation never married at all. Strallan was injured, but was able to live independently, and was a far better alternative to staying single.
** You may be underestimating how people used to feel about cripples. Among the upper class, it was a life-ending deal.

to:

** *** Even with the injury, her objections make little sense given the social aftermath of WWI. England had a "surplus" of about two million women, and around 30% of Edith's generation never married at all. Strallan was injured, but was able to live independently, and was a far better alternative to staying single.
** **** You may be underestimating how people used to feel about cripples. Among the upper class, it was a life-ending deal.deal.
** Note also Strallan's oft-professed reluctance the second time around, he repeatedly told Robert and other members of the family (presumably including Violet) about his concerns well before the wedding.



** Carlisle never went through with it -- he threatened it, but by the time they call quits on their relationship in the Series 1 Christmas Special, he has calmed down a lot and leaves Downton with a fairly triumphant comment about he how will re-sell Haxby Park (the house he bought for he and Mary) at a profit. As a man motivated by money, this softens the blow of losing Mary.

to:

** Carlisle never went through with it -- he threatened it, but by the time they call quits on their relationship in the Series 1 2 Christmas Special, he has calmed down a lot and leaves Downton with a fairly triumphant comment about he how will re-sell Haxby Park (the house he bought for he and Mary) at a profit. As a man motivated by money, this softens the blow of losing Mary.
*** To add, Carlisle's motivation for most of his behaviour/threats was desperately trying to keep Mary one way or another. Once he knew she was gone, it almost seemed to be a weight off his shoulders.
16th Jun '17 2:52:30 PM LupineMoon
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Purely anecdotal, but in my experience Jews who don't keep kosher are just as proud of their faith as those who do. Given the amount of persecution they've been through, they kind of have to be.

to:

** Purely anecdotal, but in my experience Jews who don't keep kosher are just as proud of their faith as those who do. Given the amount of persecution they've been through, they kind of have to be.be.

* Did Anthony Strallan reimburse the Crawleys the cost of the wedding after he jilted Edith at the altar?
14th Apr '17 4:09:29 AM YankeeDave
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tea with milk is kosher as kosher is about separating meat and dairy. It's also very likely that Lord Sinderby isn't very strict as Jews who are strict about keeping kosher generally don't accept the hospitality of non-Jews. This is due to the unavoidable contamination of dairy and meat in not just food preparation but with the china, silverware etc.

to:

** Tea with milk is kosher as kosher is about separating meat and dairy. It's also very likely that Lord Sinderby isn't very strict as Jews who are strict about keeping kosher generally don't accept the hospitality of non-Jews. This is due to the unavoidable contamination of dairy and meat in not just food preparation but with the china, silverware etc.etc.
** Purely anecdotal, but in my experience Jews who don't keep kosher are just as proud of their faith as those who do. Given the amount of persecution they've been through, they kind of have to be.
20th Mar '17 2:54:23 PM ivymutant
Is there an issue? Send a Message



to:

** No, she would be Marchioness Hexham because a Marquess, who she is marrying, outranks an Earl, who she is the daughter of. The higher ranked title takes precedence. However, she would be addressed as Lady Hexham in conversation. Because British titles are weird and like to call everyone Lord/Lady in many circumstances, whatever their actual rank.
12th Mar '17 7:23:08 PM LupineMoon
Is there an issue? Send a Message



to:

** OP here. So does that mean that because - if I understand correctly - Bertie Pelham as the Marquess of Hexham who outranks her, she is Lady Hexham and not Lady Edith?
20th Dec '16 11:06:43 AM Xtifr
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** They should use ReversePsychology while they were at it like the fathers in ''TheFantasticks'': forbid the children from each other ''because'' they wanted to get them together.

to:

** They should use ReversePsychology while they were at it like the fathers in ''TheFantasticks'': ''Theatre/TheFantasticks'': forbid the children from each other ''because'' they wanted to get them together.
11th Oct '16 3:05:36 PM cjay
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Was it ever explained where the girls' names came from? It's absolutely bizarre that a man who hates (or at least is extremely suspicious of) Catholocism would name his first daughter Mary, isn't it?

to:

* Was it ever explained where the girls' names came from? It's absolutely bizarre that a man who hates (or at least is extremely suspicious of) Catholocism Catholicism would name his first daughter Mary, isn't it?



** Daisy also has a secure job that provides roof and food, and apparently no dependant family members. It's not as if she's in a similar situation to Ethel, on the verge of starvation.

to:

** Daisy also has a secure job that provides roof and food, and apparently no dependant dependent family members. It's not as if she's in a similar situation to Ethel, on the verge of starvation.



* In the season 5 Christmas special, Lord Sinderby rudely barks at Thomas to bring him milk for his tea, but I thought Jewish people weren't supposed to mix dairy with other food? Like, I understand that not every Jewish person keeps kosher, but Sinderby is so vociferous in his defence of his faith and traditions it seems like he would. Is it just an oversight on the part of the writers?
** Tea with milk is kosher as kosher is about seperating meat and dairy. It's also very likely that Lord Sinderby isn't very strict as Jews who are strict about keeping kosher generally don't accept the hospitality of non-Jews. This is due to the unavoidable contamination of dairy and meat in not just food preparation but with the china, silverware etc.

to:

* In the season 5 Christmas special, Lord Sinderby rudely barks at Thomas to bring him milk for his tea, but I thought Jewish people weren't supposed to mix dairy with other food? Like, I understand that not every Jewish person keeps kosher, but Sinderby is so vociferous in his defence defense of his faith and traditions it seems like he would. Is it just an oversight on the part of the writers?
** Tea with milk is kosher as kosher is about seperating separating meat and dairy. It's also very likely that Lord Sinderby isn't very strict as Jews who are strict about keeping kosher generally don't accept the hospitality of non-Jews. This is due to the unavoidable contamination of dairy and meat in not just food preparation but with the china, silverware etc.
2nd Sep '16 8:11:07 AM kundoo
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** O'Brien amd Thomas only fell out in the beginning of the third season which takes place three years after Season 2, episode 3. They were on friendly terms before that so there's plenty of time for her to tell him her secret offscreen.

to:

** O'Brien amd and Thomas only fell out in the beginning of the third season which takes place three years after Season 2, episode 3. They were on friendly terms before that that, so there's plenty of time for her to tell him her secret offscreen.
2nd Sep '16 8:10:15 AM kundoo
Is there an issue? Send a Message



to:

** O'Brien amd Thomas only fell out in the beginning of the third season which takes place three years after Season 2, episode 3. They were on friendly terms before that so there's plenty of time for her to tell him her secret offscreen.
10th Feb '16 9:03:41 PM KatanaGeldar
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* In the season 5 Christmas special, Lord Sinderby rudely barks at Thomas to bring him milk for his tea, but I thought Jewish people weren't supposed to mix dairy with other food? Like, I understand that not every Jewish person keeps kosher, but Sinderby is so vociferous in his defence of his faith and traditions it seems like he would. Is it just an oversight on the part of the writers?

to:

* In the season 5 Christmas special, Lord Sinderby rudely barks at Thomas to bring him milk for his tea, but I thought Jewish people weren't supposed to mix dairy with other food? Like, I understand that not every Jewish person keeps kosher, but Sinderby is so vociferous in his defence of his faith and traditions it seems like he would. Is it just an oversight on the part of the writers?writers?
**Tea with milk is kosher as kosher is about seperating meat and dairy. It's also very likely that Lord Sinderby isn't very strict as Jews who are strict about keeping kosher generally don't accept the hospitality of non-Jews. This is due to the unavoidable contamination of dairy and meat in not just food preparation but with the china, silverware etc.
This list shows the last 10 events of 81. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Headscratchers.DowntonAbbey