Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Clonus

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "A small civilization" that is about as big and well equipped as your average college campus housing and feeding maybe a few thousand, except all the 'students' are docile human cattle who are providing free labor without question with funding provided by the most powerful and wealthy who see it as a means of saving their own lives? "Peak physical condition" consists of providing nutritious meals, regular medical checkups and telling them to exercise all the time. Most people are going to be in excellent physical shape under those conditions. There would be staff to employ, like guards, sure but Clonus wouldn't cost much more to run than the average college campus or state prison. Probably less because again the inmates are docile human cattle. And security at Clonus was actually terrible.

to:

** "A small civilization" that is about as big and well equipped as your average college campus housing and feeding maybe a few thousand, except all the 'students' are docile human cattle who are providing free labor without question with funding provided by the most powerful and wealthy who see it as a means of saving their own lives? "Peak physical condition" consists of providing nutritious meals, regular medical checkups and telling them to exercise all the time. Most people are going to be in excellent physical shape under those conditions. There would be staff to employ, like guards, guards and medical staff, sure but Clonus wouldn't cost much more to run than the average college campus or state prison. Probably less because again the inmates are docile human cattle. And security at Clonus was actually terrible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Regardless of how justified Richard's suspensions are, the scene still serves to tell the audience that the guards are clandestinely moving cargo from place to place, and the audience will (perhaps correctly) guess that the cargo is either dead or unconscious bodies, all the more because it later ties into Lena's experience of seeing a dead body of one of the clones being transported.

to:

** Regardless of how justified Richard's suspensions suspicions are, the scene still serves to tell the audience that the guards are clandestinely moving hidden cargo from place to place, and the audience will (perhaps correctly) guess that the cargo is either dead or unconscious bodies, bodies of the clones (or parts of them), all the more because it later ties into Lena's experience of seeing a dead body of one of the clones being transported.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Regardless of how justified Richard's suspensions are, the scene still serves to tell the audience that the guards are clandestinely moving cargo from place to place, and the audience will (perhaps correctly) guess that the cargo is either dead or unconscious bodies, all the more because it later ties into Lena's experience of seeing a dead body of the one of the clones being transported.

to:

** Regardless of how justified Richard's suspensions are, the scene still serves to tell the audience that the guards are clandestinely moving cargo from place to place, and the audience will (perhaps correctly) guess that the cargo is either dead or unconscious bodies, all the more because it later ties into Lena's experience of seeing a dead body of the one of the clones being transported.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Regardless of how justified Richard's suspensions are, the scene still serves to tell the audience that the guards are clandestinely moving cargo from place to place, and the audience will (perhaps correctly) guess that the cargo is either dead or unconscious bodies, all the more because it later ties into Lena's experience of seeing a dead body of the one of the clones being transported.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They only currently have technology to do whole person cloning, and not selective cloning of organs, in the same way they don't have the technology for force-growing clones to save time, and have to wait for the clones to develop the old-fashioned way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "A small civilization" that is about as big and well equipped as your average college campus housing and feeding maybe a few thousand, except all the 'students' are docile human cattle who are providing free labor without question with funding provided by the most powerful and wealthy who see it as a means of saving their own lives? "Top physical shape" consists of providing nutritious meals, regular medical checkups and telling them to exercise. There would be staff to employ, like guards, sure but Clonus wouldn't cost much more to run than the average college campus or state prison. And security at Clonus was actually terrible.

to:

** "A small civilization" that is about as big and well equipped as your average college campus housing and feeding maybe a few thousand, except all the 'students' are docile human cattle who are providing free labor without question with funding provided by the most powerful and wealthy who see it as a means of saving their own lives? "Top "Peak physical shape" condition" consists of providing nutritious meals, regular medical checkups and telling them to exercise.exercise all the time. Most people are going to be in excellent physical shape under those conditions. There would be staff to employ, like guards, sure but Clonus wouldn't cost much more to run than the average college campus or state prison. Probably less because again the inmates are docile human cattle. And security at Clonus was actually terrible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "A small civilization" that is about as big and well equipped as your average college campus housing and feeding maybe a few thousand, except all the 'students' are docile human cattle who are providing free labor without question with funding provided by the most powerful and wealthy who see it as a means of saving their own lives? Clones wouldn't cost much more to run than the average college campus or state prison. And security at Clonus was actually terrible.

to:

** "A small civilization" that is about as big and well equipped as your average college campus housing and feeding maybe a few thousand, except all the 'students' are docile human cattle who are providing free labor without question with funding provided by the most powerful and wealthy who see it as a means of saving their own lives? Clones "Top physical shape" consists of providing nutritious meals, regular medical checkups and telling them to exercise. There would be staff to employ, like guards, sure but Clonus wouldn't cost much more to run than the average college campus or state prison. And security at Clonus was actually terrible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "A small civilization" that is about as big and well equipped as your average college campus housing and feesing maybe a few thousand, except all the 'students' are docile human cattle who are providing free labor without question with funding provided by the most powerful and wealthy who see it as a means of saving their own lives? Clones wouldn't cost much more to run than the average state prison. And security at Clonus was actually terrible.

to:

** "A small civilization" that is about as big and well equipped as your average college campus housing and feesing feeding maybe a few thousand, except all the 'students' are docile human cattle who are providing free labor without question with funding provided by the most powerful and wealthy who see it as a means of saving their own lives? Clones wouldn't cost much more to run than the average college campus or state prison. And security at Clonus was actually terrible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** "A small civilization" that is about as big and well equipped as your average college campus housing and feesing maybe a few thousand, except all the 'students' are docile human cattle who are providing free labor without question with funding provided by the most powerful and wealthy who see it as a means of saving their own lives? Clones wouldn't cost much more to run than the average state prison. And security at Clonus was actually terrible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*'''Wouldn't it be cheaper and easier to clone a replacement organ than a whole person?'''

Added: 426

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Considering how much money, time and effort it would take to raise of just one clone, would you just throw away a perfectly good source of potential organs to provide for a lesser client? It dosen't take any effort to freeze and store them.
** And just how useful is this whole idea anyway? The vast majority of people will go through life never needing an organ transplant. Think of the hundreds of thousands of dollars and decades of time it takes to raise ''each'' of the clones to adulthood, keep them in peak physical condition, and then preserve them on the off chance that one of the important people they were cloned from needs a liver or something on down the line. With that amount of time and resources, surely more efficient (and humane) methods could be found to secure a compatable replacement part.

to:

** Considering how much money, time and effort it would take to raise of just one clone, would you just throw away a perfectly good source of potential organs to provide for a lesser client? It dosen't doesn't take any effort to freeze and store them.
** And just how useful is this whole idea anyway? The vast majority of people will go through life never needing an organ transplant. Think of the hundreds of thousands of dollars and decades of time it takes to raise ''each'' of the clones to adulthood, keep them in peak physical condition, and then preserve them on the off chance that one of the important people they were cloned from needs a liver or something on down the line. With that amount of time and resources, surely more efficient (and humane) methods could be found to secure a compatable compatible replacement part.


Added DiffLines:

*** Cyclosporine, the first anti-rejection medication, didn't come onto the market until 4 years after this movie was released. The ''only'' organs that wouldn't be rejected within a matter of months or (at most) a few years, were those of an identical twin. Cloning organs for transplant would've seemed like a more viable strategy back then, before any reasonable tissue/blood type match could be made to last for decades.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Senator Knight tells his brother that his second clone is still an infant, meaning he was recently developed for the Senator's future needs. As for his injury from the poker, using his brother's clone made sense, since they'd be genetically compatible, and the Senator's brother (who'd be the original recipient of any transplant) was about to have an unfortunate, fatal accident.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Look, I'm no accounting expert, so I could very well be completely wrong here, but wouldn't the cost of running what's effectively a small civilization of people and keeping every one of them in peak physical condition, all while monitoring their every move, ''very'' quickly outweigh the benefits of this project?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
add one

Added DiffLines:

* Near the beginning of the film, Richard describes via {{flashback}} an incident in which a golf cart driving toward him on a path deliberately drove around the far side of a circle to avoid him, and he states specifically that this was to prevent him from seeing the cart's cargo. But why would he automatically assume this? The flashback clearly shows that Richard was walking in a group of four or five people; couldn't the cart have been simply trying not to run over anybody? Of course, it would be easy to chalk this one up to a paranoid reaction, underscoring Richard's mounting distrust for the powers that be at Clonus; except the film doesn't really play it like that at all, we are to take Richard completely at his word that he was not meant to see what the cart was carrying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***They also have generous donations from their sponsors, who would likely be in the 1%.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Old!Richard is ostensibly murdered by his brother's goons at the end, so why'd they bother freezing Clone!Richard afterwards? His specific organ recipient isn't around anymore. That said, as a clone of his brother Richard's organs would likely be usable in the event that Senator Knight needed anything.
** Considering how much money, time and effort it would take to raise of just one clone, would you just throw away a perfectly good source of potential organs to provide for a lesser client? It dosen't take any effort to freeze and store them.
** And just how useful is this whole idea anyway? The vast majority of people will go through life never needing an organ transplant. Think of the hundreds of thousands of dollars and decades of time it takes to raise ''each'' of the clones to adulthood, keep them in peak physical condition, and then preserve them on the off chance that one of the important people they were cloned from needs a liver or something on down the line. With that amount of time and resources, surely more efficient (and humane) methods could be found to secure a compatable replacement part.
*** It's the Illuminati, they have resources to burn. Plus the other possible uses for clones had yet to be explored, not just potential organ donors but also infiltrators, cloned armies, slave labor. Those scientists weren't just content to let the clones grow up, they were also "monitoring their interaction," performing all kinds of experiments. Clonus is described as a "self-supporting center of research" after all.
*** Transplants might be more popular if there was no chance of rejection (clones being genetically identical to the progenitor, though I doubt it's that simple) and there was a larger supply of organs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Old!Richard is ostensibly murdered by his brother's goons at the end, so why'd they bother freezing Clone!Richard afterwards? His specific organ recipient isn't around anymore. That said, as a clone of his brother Richard's organs would likely be usable in the event that Senator Knight needed anything.
** Considering how much money, time and effort it would take to raise of just one clone, would you just throw away a perfectly good source of potential organs to provide for a lesser client? It dosen't take any effort to freeze and store them.
** And just how useful is this whole idea anyway? The vast majority of people will go through life never needing an organ transplant. Think of the hundreds of thousands of dollars and decades of time it takes to raise ''each'' of the clones to adulthood, keep them in peak physical condition, and then preserve them on the off chance that one of the important people they were cloned from needs a liver or something on down the line. With that amount of time and resources, surely more efficient (and humane) methods could be found to secure a compatable replacement part.
*** It's the Illuminati, they have resources to burn. Plus the other possible uses for clones had yet to be explored, not just potential organ donors but also infiltrators, cloned armies, slave labor. Those scientists weren't just content to let the clones grow up, they were also "monitoring their interaction," performing all kinds of experiments. Clonus is described as a "self-supporting center of research" after all.
*** Transplants might be more popular if there was no chance of rejection (clones being genetically identical to the progenitor, though I doubt it's that simple) and there was a larger supply of organs.

Added: 1436

Changed: 305

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Old!Richard is ostensibly murdered by his brother's goons at the end, so why'd they bother freezing Clone!Richard afterwards? His specific organ recipient isn't around anymore. That said, as a clone of his brother Richard's organs would likely be usable in the event that Senator Knight needed anything.
** Considering how much money, time and effort it would take to raise of just one clone, would you just throw away a perfectly good source of potential organs to provide for a lesser client? It dosen't take any effort to freeze and store them.
** And just how useful is this whole idea anyway? The vast majority of people will go through life never needing an organ transplant. Think of the hundreds of thousands of dollars and decades of time it takes to raise ''each'' of the clones to adulthood, keep them in peak physical condition, and then preserve them on the off chance that one of the important people they were cloned from needs a liver or something on down the line. With that amount of time and resources, surely more efficient (and humane) methods could be found to secure a compatable replacement part.
*** It's the Illuminati, they have resources to burn. Plus the other possible uses for clones had yet to explored, not just potential organ donors but also infilitrators, cloned armies, slave labor. Those scientists were't just content to let the clones grow up, they were also "monitoring their interaction," performing all kinds of experiments. Clonus is described as a "self-supporting center of research" after all.
*** Transplants might be more popular if there was no chance of rejection (clones being genetically identical to the progenitor, though I doubt it's that simple) and there was a larger supply of organs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Well, they do make a big show of how the clones are used for parts at the end of the film. When Knight is confronted about Clonus by the reporter, they go from the sound of a heart rapidly beating to a shot of the frozen Richard with a big cut on his chest. Evidently, they transplanted Richard's heart for the senator, maybe a kind of Avatar-like genetic compatibility thing.

Added: 369

Changed: 370

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Didn't you see the old eye-patched guy's ring? It was a pyramid with an eye in it. That means the Illuminati were running the Clone farm, which means they would probably have access to Applied Phlebotinum like the secrets of Atlantis, Roswell UFO technology, the Ark of the Convenant, and the knowledge from the legions of Hell. Human cloning would be easy for them.



*** Didn't you see the old eye-patched guy's ring? It was a pyramid with an eye in it. That means the Illuminati were running the Clone farm, which means they would probably have access to Applied Phlebotinum like the secrets of Atlantis, Roswell UFO technology, the Ark of the Convenant, and the knowledge from the legions of Hell. Human cloning would be easy for them.

to:

*** Didn't you see the old eye-patched guy's ring? It was a pyramid with an eye in it. That means the Illuminati were running the Clone farm, which means they would probably have access to Applied Phlebotinum like the secrets of Atlantis, Roswell UFO technology, the Ark of the Convenant, and the knowledge from the legions of Hell. Human cloning would be easy for them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Senator Knight gets stabbed in the heart with a poker from his brother, and later is seen perfectly fine at election night. Now earlier Senator Knight said that he had two clones, and had already had a heart transplant from the first one. Did he fix his damaged heart from the second clone or was it in fact his clone speaking at the election night, and not the real Senator Knight?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The guys at Clonus told Senator Knight about his brother's clone escaping with the tape, and probably told him that the clone might try to contact his brother.
*** Didn't you see the old eye-patched guy's ring? It was a pyramid with an eye in it. That means the Illuminati were running the Clone farm, which means they would probably have access to Applied Phlebotinum like the secrets of Atlantis, Roswell UFO technology, the Ark of the Convenant, and the knowledge from the legions of Hell. Human cloning would be easy for them.

Top