History Headscratchers / CaptainAmerica

29th May '16 9:04:42 PM Atlasth3rd
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** That's why he has the shield and is an expert at using it.

to:

** That's why he has the shield and is an expert at using it.it.
* If Cap really has been [[spoiler: working for Hydra all along]] how could he lift Thor's hammer?
28th May '16 1:40:38 AM CrypticMirror
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** That's why he has the shield and is an expert at using it.
* How does Cap reconcile being a loyal Hydra operative with beating up all their foot soldiers all the time?

to:

** That's why he has the shield and is an expert at using it.
* How does Cap reconcile being a loyal Hydra operative with beating up all their foot soldiers all the time?
it.
27th May '16 10:49:12 PM K
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** That's why he has the shield and is an expert at using it.

to:

** That's why he has the shield and is an expert at using it.it.
* How does Cap reconcile being a loyal Hydra operative with beating up all their foot soldiers all the time?
16th Nov '15 8:16:49 AM MrDeath
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* How is Cap still alive? He has peak human abilities, a bouncing, indestructible shield, and is one of the best martial artists in the universe, but that doesn't explain how he can take down a dozen armed soldiers. Even Batman needs stealth, psychological tactics, and cleverly placed gadgets but Cap can do it without breaking a sweat. The man isn't bulletproof.

to:

* How is Cap still alive? He has peak human abilities, a bouncing, indestructible shield, and is one of the best martial artists in the universe, but that doesn't explain how he can take down a dozen armed soldiers. Even Batman needs stealth, psychological tactics, and cleverly placed gadgets but Cap can do it without breaking a sweat. The man isn't bulletproof.bulletproof.
** That's why he has the shield and is an expert at using it.
16th Nov '15 12:03:59 AM CDevil
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

*** Actually, they did a montage of his training in the issue that showed his creation; the government brought in all the best experts available to teach him hand to hand combat (specifically boxing and judo), strategy, tactics,etc.
17th Oct '15 8:04:25 PM deadpool616
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* How is Cap still alive? He has peak human abilities, a bouncing, indescribable shield, and is one of the best martial artists in the universe, but that doesn't explain how he can take down a dozen armed soldiers. Even Batman needs stealth, psychological tactics, and cleverly placed gadgets but Cap can do it without breaking a sweat. The man isn't bulletproof.

to:

* How is Cap still alive? He has peak human abilities, a bouncing, indescribable indestructible shield, and is one of the best martial artists in the universe, but that doesn't explain how he can take down a dozen armed soldiers. Even Batman needs stealth, psychological tactics, and cleverly placed gadgets but Cap can do it without breaking a sweat. The man isn't bulletproof.
17th Oct '15 8:03:42 PM deadpool616
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** He had all of WWII and the modern years to learn martial arts. It's not like martial arts is a new thing. Even Western martial arts (like boxing and wrestling), often shown in media to be inferior, can make a man extremely deadly. And to be fair, Captain America is physically stronger and faster than Batman. Batman is the best you can 'realistically' make a human male, but Cap is overall better because he is powered up through the Serum. Cap is shown to be the fastest sprinter, the strongest fighter, the best shot, and whatnot all in one, which Batman couldn't possibly achieve because they involve training different muscles for different specialties.

to:

** He had all of WWII and the modern years to learn martial arts. It's not like martial arts is a new thing. Even Western martial arts (like boxing and wrestling), often shown in media to be inferior, can make a man extremely deadly. And to be fair, Captain America is physically stronger and faster than Batman. Batman is the best you can 'realistically' make a human male, but Cap is overall better because he is powered up through the Serum. Cap is shown to be the fastest sprinter, the strongest fighter, the best shot, and whatnot all in one, which Batman couldn't possibly achieve because they involve training different muscles for different specialties.specialties.
*How is Cap still alive? He has peak human abilities, a bouncing, indescribable shield, and is one of the best martial artists in the universe, but that doesn't explain how he can take down a dozen armed soldiers. Even Batman needs stealth, psychological tactics, and cleverly placed gadgets but Cap can do it without breaking a sweat. The man isn't bulletproof.
23rd Jun '15 6:03:33 PM lorgskyegon
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Dozens of times, though he recently beat up on Punisher during Civil War [[spoiler:Upon learning that Punisher murdered some villains supporting the Anti-Registration resistance forces.]]

to:

** Dozens of times, though he recently beat up on Punisher during Civil War [[spoiler:Upon upon learning that Punisher murdered some villains supporting the Anti-Registration resistance forces.]]forces.
*** It's not really "upon learning" when Frank murdered the villains '''right in front of''' Captain America.
8th Jan '15 11:15:55 AM InertialMass
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Cap has been show time and time again to be one of the greatest hand-to-hand combatants in the Marvel Universe. The problem is that they never really show you where he learned all that. He just takes the formula then, [[InstantExpert boom]], he can suddenly go one-on-one with Franchise/{{Batman}}, who spent 20 years training around the world.

to:

* Cap has been show time and time again to be one of the greatest hand-to-hand combatants in the Marvel Universe. The problem is that they never really show you where he learned all that. He just takes the formula then, [[InstantExpert boom]], he can suddenly go one-on-one with Franchise/{{Batman}}, who spent 20 years training around the world.world.
** He had all of WWII and the modern years to learn martial arts. It's not like martial arts is a new thing. Even Western martial arts (like boxing and wrestling), often shown in media to be inferior, can make a man extremely deadly. And to be fair, Captain America is physically stronger and faster than Batman. Batman is the best you can 'realistically' make a human male, but Cap is overall better because he is powered up through the Serum. Cap is shown to be the fastest sprinter, the strongest fighter, the best shot, and whatnot all in one, which Batman couldn't possibly achieve because they involve training different muscles for different specialties.
8th Jan '15 10:51:01 AM InertialMass
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

**** Him being 'Captain' America is likely TheArtifact, both in and out of universe he was highly successful and publicized during WWII as a 'Captain' so that when they finally defrosted him and cleared up his MIA status he was promoted but the Army could have bent the rules so he still keeps the title of 'Captain' because that's what he was famous as. The only people he's ever shown regularly taking orders from is Nick Fury (head of SHIELD and often shown as Cap's direct superior) or the President (Commander-in-Chief and automatically above Cap no matter what) basically making him a rank unto himself.
This list shows the last 10 events of 54. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Headscratchers.CaptainAmerica