Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / Zulu

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ImpromptuFortress: The film focuses on a small company's worth of British soldiers turn a modest Swedish mission house-turned-military hospital into a well-fortified outpost that successfully faced off against an assault of approximately 4000 Zulu warriors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Based on true events, the film is the story of a LastStand that the defenders managed to win. The Battle of Rorke's Drift was the result of the Battle of Isandlwana, at which the British expeditionary force of 2000 sent to crush the Zulus had been destroyed through a combination of skilled Zulu leadership of fearless legions of warriors [[GeneralFailure and the incompetence of British commanders.]] 139 British soldiers in a farmstead, assigned there to protect the wounded (who numbered about one third of the 139) held out against 4-5,000 Zulus for 12 hours. The battle is held to this day as one of the very best defences in all history. Eleven of the soldiers were awarded the Victoria Cross (the highest possible decoration for bravery), the highest number of this medal ever awarded for a single action.

to:

Based on true events, the film is the story of a LastStand that the defenders managed to win. The Battle of Rorke's Drift was the result of the Battle of Isandlwana, at which the British expeditionary force of 2000 2,000 sent to crush the Zulus had been destroyed through a combination of skilled Zulu leadership of fearless legions of warriors [[GeneralFailure and the incompetence of British commanders.]] 139 British soldiers in a farmstead, assigned there to protect the wounded (who numbered about one third of the 139) held out against 4-5,000 Zulus for 12 hours. The battle is held to this day as one of the very best defences in all history. Eleven of the soldiers were awarded the Victoria Cross (the highest possible decoration for bravery), the highest number of this medal ever awarded for a single action.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OnlySaneMan: Several characters occupy this position. Bishop Colenso who tries to talk Bartle Frere out of starting the war. Durnford, being seemingly the only high ranking officer to understand and how to fight the Zulus. Hamilton-Brown, who is openly disgusted by Chelmsford's arrogance and refusal to tend to his soldiers' well being. Harford, who desperately tries to get reinforcements sent to the outnumbered Pulliene and is continually rebuffed, and finally reporter Norris Newman who correctly predicts exactly what's going to happen when Chelmsford splits his forces.

to:

* OnlySaneMan: Several characters occupy this position. Bishop Colenso who tries to talk Bartle Frere out of starting the war. Durnford, being seemingly the only high ranking officer to understand and how to fight the Zulus. Hamilton-Brown, who is openly disgusted by Chelmsford's arrogance and refusal to tend to his soldiers' well being. Harford, who desperately tries to get reinforcements sent to the outnumbered Pulliene and is continually rebuffed, and finally reporter Norris Newman who correctly predicts exactly what's going to happen when Chelmsford splits his forces.

Added: 823

Removed: 307

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeroOfAnotherStory: In the final scene, as Chelmsford and his escort discover the overrun camp, Crealock informs Chelmsford that he's ridden a little way along the track that leads to Rorke's Drift -- "The sky above is red with fire," as the characters of the original film are currently fighting for their lives.
* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Quartermaster Edward Bloomfield is portrayed as an incompetent fool who is in part responsible for the slaughter at Isandlwana due to refusing to hand bullets to soldiers out of turn even when they're being overrun by Zulus. This is a common myth about the battle based on the fact that Durnford's native troops ran out of ammunition, but in reality this was due to the distance from camp wreaking havoc on the supply lines, not any mishandling of the supply on Bloomfield's part.



* SequelHook: In the final scene, as Chelmsford and his escort discover the overrun camp, Crealock informs Chelmsford that he's ridden a little way along the track that leads to Rorke's Drift -- "The sky above is red with fire," as the characters of the original film are currently fighting for their lives.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalHeroUpgrade: The film's version of King Cetshwayo is shown as having a good relationship with Otto With to the point of having one of his men executed to help them escape from Zululand after the outbreak of the war. The real Cetshwayo was hostile towards the Witts, and did not help them to escape but rather banished them after a falling-out.

to:

* HistoricalHeroUpgrade: The film's version of King Cetshwayo is shown as having a good relationship with Otto With Witt to the point of having one of his men executed to help them escape from Zululand after the outbreak of the war. The real Cetshwayo was hostile towards the Witts, and did not help them to escape but rather banished them after a falling-out.

Added: 1566

Changed: 378

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Averted in the case of Lietenant Bromhead, who is often described as being partially deaf. According to one of the most detailed and comprehensive books on Rorke's Drift, this seems to have been a misinterpretation of primary accounts that after the battle, Bromhead was withdrawn and quiet towards officers attached to reinforcements; these are symptoms that could just as easily be the result of PTSD (which didn't have a name in the 1870s) than deafness. That said, other sources indicate that he did have hearing problems but this did not affect his ability to command men. The line about his father having fought at Waterloo and his great-grandfather having fought with Wolfe at Quebec is historically accurate, for he was indeed the scion of a notable military family.

to:

** Averted in the case of Lietenant Lieutenant Bromhead, who is often described as being partially deaf. According to one of the most detailed and comprehensive books on Rorke's Drift, this seems to have been a misinterpretation of primary accounts that after the battle, Bromhead was withdrawn and quiet towards officers attached to reinforcements; these are symptoms that could just as easily be the result of PTSD (which didn't have a name in the 1870s) than deafness. That said, other sources indicate that he did have hearing problems but this did not affect his ability to command men. The line about his father having fought at Waterloo and his great-grandfather having fought with Wolfe at Quebec is historically accurate, for he was indeed the scion of a notable military family.



* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Henry Hook wasn't the cowardly drunk the film portrayed him as, but a model soldier. His daughter walked out of the premiere when she saw how her father was being portrayed.

to:

* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: HistoricalHeroUpgrade: The film's version of King Cetshwayo is shown as having a good relationship with Otto With to the point of having one of his men executed to help them escape from Zululand after the outbreak of the war. The real Cetshwayo was hostile towards the Witts, and did not help them to escape but rather banished them after a falling-out.
* HistoricalVillainUpgrade:
**
Henry Hook wasn't the cowardly drunk the film portrayed him as, but a model soldier. His daughter walked out of the premiere when she saw how her father was being portrayed. Downplayed as the film does portray him performing bravely when the hour comes and is awarded the Victoria Cross for his heroism, but nevertheless he is still portrayed as initially being a malingerer who's in the hospital because he's faking an injury to get out of fighting, when in reality he was only in the hospital because he'd been ordered there during the battle to protect the wounded. The real Hook was also TheTeetotaler rather than being a drunk.
** The film's version of King Cetshwayo is implied to have directly ordered the attack on the Rorke's Drift missionary station and hospital, when in real life he specifically ordered his men not to attack Rorke's Drift but was ignored.
** The Natal cavalry unit that appears in the film is portrayed as flatly refusing Chard's pleas for help defending Rorke's Drift and withdrawing before the Zulus even arrive. In real life the Natal cavalry who arrived at Rorke's Drift certainly did not refuse to help, participating in the opening stages of the battle and only withdrawing because they ran out of ammunition. As a side note, most of them were black in reality but have undergone a RaceLift to being white Boers in the film.



* ImpaledWithExtremePrejudice: what the British and the Zulus do to each other with spears and bayonets whenever the Zulus' ZergRush manages to get through the British's [[MoreDakka dakka]].

to:

* ImpaledWithExtremePrejudice: what What the British and the Zulus do to each other with spears and bayonets whenever the Zulus' ZergRush manages to get through the British's [[MoreDakka dakka]].


Added DiffLines:

* RaceLift: The Natal cavalry who arrive at Rorke's Drift in the film are composed entirely of white Boers, whilst the equivalent figures in RealLife were mostly black Africans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoreDakka: The chief tactic of the British.

to:

* MoreDakka: The chief tactic of the British.British, in response to the Zulus' ZergRush.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnachronismStew: Due to either a lack of Martini-Henry rifles or .570 blanks, a decent chunk of the weapons wielded by British forces in the film are actually anachronistic Lee-Enfield Mk. Is (introduced in 1895) with the telltale magazine removed. In a similar vein, the revolvers used by the officers are Webley Mk. VIs, which were introduced in 1915. This is due to a lack of functional Beaumont-Adams revolvers, as used in the actual battle.

to:

* AnachronismStew: Due to either a lack of Martini-Henry rifles or .570 blanks, a decent chunk of the weapons wielded by British forces in the film are actually anachronistic Lee-Enfield Mk. Is (introduced in 1895) with the telltale magazine removed. In a similar vein, the revolvers used by the officers are Webley Mk. VIs, [=VIs=], which were introduced in 1915. This is due to a lack of functional Beaumont-Adams revolvers, as used in the actual battle.

Changed: 114

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnachronismStew: Due to either a lack of Martini-Henry rifles or .570 blanks, a decent chunk of the weapons wielded by British forces in the film are actually anachronistic Lee-Enfield Mark is with the telltale magazine removed, as well as Webley Mk. VI revolvers, not introduced until 1915. This is due to a lack of functional Beaumont-Adams revolvers used in the actual battle.

to:

* AnachronismStew: Due to either a lack of Martini-Henry rifles or .570 blanks, a decent chunk of the weapons wielded by British forces in the film are actually anachronistic Lee-Enfield Mark is Mk. Is (introduced in 1895) with the telltale magazine removed, as well as removed. In a similar vein, the revolvers used by the officers are Webley Mk. VI revolvers, not VIs, which were introduced until in 1915. This is due to a lack of functional Beaumont-Adams revolvers revolvers, as used in the actual battle.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*AdaptationalJerkass: Private Henry Hook is potrayed as an obnoxious, insubordinant malingerer who fakes illness to escape duty, only to becoming a brave fighter and a good soldier in the final scene. There's nothing to suggest that Private Hook was anything but a good soldier throughout his career, and his children were angered and disgusted by film's portrayal of their father.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Zulu'' is a classic 1964 war film set during the UsefulNotes/AngloZuluWar, directed by Cy Endfield and featuring Creator/MichaelCaine in his breakout film role. The cast also includes Stanley Baker, Jack Hawkins, Ulla Jacobsson, Creator/PatrickMagee and James Booth. Creator/RichardBurton provides the narration for the opening and closing scenes.

to:

''Zulu'' is a classic 1964 war film set during the UsefulNotes/AngloZuluWar, directed by Cy Endfield and featuring Creator/MichaelCaine in his breakout film role. The cast also includes Stanley Baker, Creator/StanleyBaker, Jack Hawkins, Ulla Jacobsson, Creator/PatrickMagee and James Booth. Creator/RichardBurton provides the narration for the opening and closing scenes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DuelWielding: Schiess dual wields his bayoneted rifle and his ''crutch''.

to:

* DuelWielding: DualWielding: Schiess dual wields his bayoneted rifle and his ''crutch''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DuelWielding: Schiess dual wields his bayoneted rifle and his ''crutch''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BothSidesHaveAPoint: While our sympathies are with the protagonists who are obviously trying to avoid being slaughtered, at the same time the film deliberately avoids vilifying the Zulu forces; they're fighting back against the Boers and the British Empire trying to take their land, and the foot soldiers are following their leaders' orders just as much as the British solders are obeying their superior officers.

to:

* BothSidesHaveAPoint: While our sympathies are with the protagonists in Rorke's Drift who are obviously trying to avoid being slaughtered, at the same time the film deliberately avoids vilifying the Zulu forces; they're forces. They're fighting back against the Boers and the British Empire trying to take their land, and the foot soldiers are following their leaders' orders just as much as the British solders are obeying their superior officers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Zulu Dawn'' is a classic 1964 war film set during the UsefulNotes/AngloZuluWar, directed by Cy Endfield and featuring Creator/MichaelCaine in his breakout film role. The cast also includes Stanley Baker, Jack Hawkins, Ulla Jacobsson, Creator/PatrickMagee and James Booth. Creator/RichardBurton provides the narration for the opening and closing scenes.

to:

''Zulu Dawn'' ''Zulu'' is a classic 1964 war film set during the UsefulNotes/AngloZuluWar, directed by Cy Endfield and featuring Creator/MichaelCaine in his breakout film role. The cast also includes Stanley Baker, Jack Hawkins, Ulla Jacobsson, Creator/PatrickMagee and James Booth. Creator/RichardBurton provides the narration for the opening and closing scenes.

Added: 86

Changed: 19

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving from trivia page.


A classic 1964 war film set during the UsefulNotes/AngloZuluWar, directed by Cy Endfield and featuring Creator/MichaelCaine in his breakout film role. The cast also includes Stanley Baker, Jack Hawkins, Ulla Jacobsson, Creator/PatrickMagee and James Booth. Creator/RichardBurton provides the narration for the opening and closing scenes.

to:

A ''Zulu Dawn'' is a classic 1964 war film set during the UsefulNotes/AngloZuluWar, directed by Cy Endfield and featuring Creator/MichaelCaine in his breakout film role. The cast also includes Stanley Baker, Jack Hawkins, Ulla Jacobsson, Creator/PatrickMagee and James Booth. Creator/RichardBurton provides the narration for the opening and closing scenes.


Added DiffLines:

* AndStarring: The opening cast roll ends with "And introducing Creator/MichaelCaine".

Added: 108

Removed: 108

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Sorry.


* WhiteAndGreyMorality: The Zulus are fighting for their land, whereas the English are defending a hospital.



* WhiteAndGreyMorality: The Zulus are fighting for their land, whereas the English are defending a hospital.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhiteAndGreyMorality: The Zulus are fighting for their land, whereas the English are defending a hospital.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnsignNewbie: Bromhead, though in {{Real Life}} both he and Lieutenant Chard were [[InvertedTrope inversions]]: they were ''old'' for their rank, having been repeatedly [[PassedOverPromotion passed over for promotion]] as [[{{Irony}} unlikely to amount to much]]. It's often claimed that Bromhead was at least partially deaf, but the latest authoritative study of the 1879 campaign suggests this was a misinterpretation of Bromhead suffering from PTSD in the immediate aftermath of the battle.

to:

* EnsignNewbie: Bromhead, though in {{Real Life}} both he and Lieutenant Chard were [[InvertedTrope inversions]]: they were ''old'' for their rank, having been repeatedly [[PassedOverPromotion passed over for promotion]] as [[{{Irony}} unlikely to amount to much]]. It's often claimed that Bromhead was at least partially deaf, but the latest authoritative study of the 1879 campaign suggests this was a misinterpretation of Bromhead suffering from PTSD in the immediate aftermath of the battle. At the end of the film the erstwhile confident and collected Chard reveals he's just as green as Bromhead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A classic 1964 war film set during the UsefulNotes/AngloZuluWar, directed by Cy Endfield and featuring Creator/MichaelCaine in his breakout film role. The cast also includes Stanley Baker, Jack Hawkins, Ulla Jacobsson, and James Booth.

to:

A classic 1964 war film set during the UsefulNotes/AngloZuluWar, directed by Cy Endfield and featuring Creator/MichaelCaine in his breakout film role. The cast also includes Stanley Baker, Jack Hawkins, Ulla Jacobsson, Creator/PatrickMagee and James Booth.
Booth. Creator/RichardBurton provides the narration for the opening and closing scenes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DecoyProtagonist: The film starts off with missionary Otto Witt and his daughter Margareta watching a mass Zulu marriage ceremony. You'd be forgiven for thinking that they'll be more involved in the plot of the film, especially given how prominently their actors' names (Jack Hawkins and Ulla Jacobsson) are in the credits, but the attention soon switches to the soldiers at Rourke's Drift.

to:

* DecoyProtagonist: The film starts off with missionary Otto Witt and his daughter Margareta watching a mass Zulu marriage ceremony. You'd be forgiven for thinking that they'll be more involved in the plot of the film, especially given how prominently their actors' names (Jack Hawkins and Ulla Jacobsson) are in the credits, but the attention soon switches to the soldiers at Rourke's Drift.Drift and the Witts escape from the battle (and the story) at around the halfway mark.

Changed: 252

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Otto Witt wasn't a pacifist (he helped the British soldiers plan their defence) or a drunk, and he only left so as to alert his family at his farm a little way away; he also wasn't a widower and had three children at the time, the oldest of whom was seven years old. Also contrary to the film's portrayal, Witt was not well-liked by the Zulu and had been banished from the Kingdom by Cesthawayo before the war broke out.

to:

** Otto Witt wasn't a pacifist (he helped the British soldiers plan their defence) or a drunk, and he only left so as to alert his family at his farm a little way away; he also wasn't a widower and had three children at the time, the oldest of whom was seven years old. Also contrary to the film's portrayal, Witt was not well-liked by the Zulu and had actually been banished from the Kingdom by Cesthawayo before the war broke out.



** Averted in the case of Lietenant Bromhead, who is often described as being partially deaf. According to one of the most detailed and comprehensive books on Rorke's Drift, this seems to have been a misinterpretation of primary accounts that Bromhead was withdrawn and quiet after the battle towards officers attached to reinforcements; these are symptoms that could just as easily be the result of PTSD (which didn't have a name in the 1870s) than deafness. That said, other sources indicate that he did have hearing problems but this did not affect his ability to command men. The line about his father having fought at Waterloo and his great-grandfather having fought with Wolfe at Quebec is historically accurate, for he was indeed the scion of a notable military family.

to:

** Averted in the case of Lietenant Bromhead, who is often described as being partially deaf. According to one of the most detailed and comprehensive books on Rorke's Drift, this seems to have been a misinterpretation of primary accounts that after the battle, Bromhead was withdrawn and quiet after the battle towards officers attached to reinforcements; these are symptoms that could just as easily be the result of PTSD (which didn't have a name in the 1870s) than deafness. That said, other sources indicate that he did have hearing problems but this did not affect his ability to command men. The line about his father having fought at Waterloo and his great-grandfather having fought with Wolfe at Quebec is historically accurate, for he was indeed the scion of a notable military family.



* BadVibrations: "Damn funny. It...it's like a train in the distance."

to:

* BadVibrations: "Damn funny. It...It ... it's like a train in the distance."



* DecoyProtagonist: The film starts off with missionary Otto Witt and his daughter Margareta watching a mass Zulu marriage ceremony. You'd be forgiven for thinking they'll be more involved in the plot of the film, but the attention soon switches to the soldiers at Rourke's Drift.

to:

* DecoyProtagonist: The film starts off with missionary Otto Witt and his daughter Margareta watching a mass Zulu marriage ceremony. You'd be forgiven for thinking that they'll be more involved in the plot of the film, especially given how prominently their actors' names (Jack Hawkins and Ulla Jacobsson) are in the credits, but the attention soon switches to the soldiers at Rourke's Drift.



* EnsignNewbie: Bromhead, though in {{Real Life}} both he and Lieutenant Chard were [[InvertedTrope inversions]]: they were ''old'' for their rank, having been repeatedly [[PassedOverPromotion passed over for promotion]] as [[{{Irony}} unlikely to amount to much]]. It's often claimed that Bromhead was at least partially deaf, but the latest authoritative study of the 1879 campaign suggests this was a misinterpretation of Bromhead suffering PTSD in the immediate aftermath of the battle.

to:

* EnsignNewbie: Bromhead, though in {{Real Life}} both he and Lieutenant Chard were [[InvertedTrope inversions]]: they were ''old'' for their rank, having been repeatedly [[PassedOverPromotion passed over for promotion]] as [[{{Irony}} unlikely to amount to much]]. It's often claimed that Bromhead was at least partially deaf, but the latest authoritative study of the 1879 campaign suggests this was a misinterpretation of Bromhead suffering from PTSD in the immediate aftermath of the battle.



* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Henry Hook wasn't the cowardly drunk the film portrayed him as, but a model soldier.

to:

* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Henry Hook wasn't the cowardly drunk the film portrayed him as, but a model soldier. His daughter walked out of the premiere when she saw how her father was being portrayed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SequelHook: In the final scene, as Chelmsford and his escort discover the overrun camp, Crealock informs Chelmsford that he's ridden a little way along the track to Rorke's Drift -- "The sky above is red with fire," as the characters of the original film are currently fighting for their lives.

to:

* SequelHook: In the final scene, as Chelmsford and his escort discover the overrun camp, Crealock informs Chelmsford that he's ridden a little way along the track that leads to Rorke's Drift -- "The sky above is red with fire," as the characters of the original film are currently fighting for their lives.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Otto Witt wasn't a pacifist (he helped the British soldiers plan their defence) or a drunk, and he only left so as to alert his family at his farm a little while away; he also wasn't a widower and three children at the time, the oldest of whom was seven years old. Also contrary to the film's portrayal, Witt was not well-liked by the Zulu and had been banished from the Kingdom by Cesthawayo before the war broke out.

to:

** Otto Witt wasn't a pacifist (he helped the British soldiers plan their defence) or a drunk, and he only left so as to alert his family at his farm a little while way away; he also wasn't a widower and had three children at the time, the oldest of whom was seven years old. Also contrary to the film's portrayal, Witt was not well-liked by the Zulu and had been banished from the Kingdom by Cesthawayo before the war broke out.

Changed: 87

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ImpaledWithExtremePrejudice: what the British and the Zulus do to each other whenever the Zulus' ZergRush manages to get through the British's [[MoreDakka dakka]].

to:

* ImpaledWithExtremePrejudice: what the British and the Zulus do to each other with spears and bayonets whenever the Zulus' ZergRush manages to get through the British's [[MoreDakka dakka]].



** The audience gets one when we see a group of Zulu warriors lying prone. Then one stands up and points at the fort...with a rifle.

to:

** The audience gets one when we see a group of Zulu warriors lying prone. Then one stands up and points at the fort...with fort ''with a rifle.rifle''.



* SergeantRock: Colour Sergeant Bourne provides the quote at the top of this trope's page; while usually stern with the men, he knows when to show a softer side (like comforting Private Cole when the latter is unnerved by Witt's drunken ranting, and later ensuring that Private Hitch seeks medical attention during the post-battle roll call), helps to ease the tension by [[RealMenLoveJesus quoting Psalm 46]] just before the Zulus attack, and when they ''do'' attack, he kills several of them with his bayonet [[note]] in RealLife, he was actually 23 years old at the time of Rorke's Drift and was the youngest Colour Sergeant in the British Army; for his bravery at Rorke's Drift, he was awarded the Distinguished Conduct Medal (for non-officers, the second-highest decoration after the VC) and was offered a commission but declined, although he was later commissioned, and ended his long military career as a Lieutenant-Colonel [[/note]]. Corporal Allen, although not a sergeant, also qualifies [[note]] he had actually ''been'' a sergeant but was demoted for being drunk on duty some time before Rorke's Drift; he was later promoted back to that rank [[/note]].

to:

* SergeantRock: Colour Sergeant Bourne provides the quote at the top of this trope's page; while usually stern with the men, he knows when to [[ReasonableAuthorityFigure show a softer side side]] (like comforting Private Cole when the latter is unnerved by Witt's drunken ranting, and later ensuring that Private Hitch seeks medical attention during the post-battle roll call), helps to ease the tension by [[RealMenLoveJesus quoting Psalm 46]] just before the Zulus attack, and when they ''do'' attack, he kills several of them with his bayonet [[note]] in RealLife, he was actually 23 years old at the time of Rorke's Drift and was the youngest Colour Sergeant in the British Army; for his bravery at Rorke's Drift, he was awarded the Distinguished Conduct Medal (for non-officers, the second-highest decoration after the VC) and was offered a commission but declined, although he was later commissioned, and ended his long military career as a Lieutenant-Colonel [[/note]]. Corporal Allen, although not a sergeant, also qualifies [[note]] he had actually ''been'' a sergeant but was demoted for being drunk on duty some time before Rorke's Drift; he was later promoted back to that rank [[/note]].



** The Zulus appear to be massing again to wipe out the British, but it turns out they're saluting the British for their bravery before departing for good. This is [[ArtisticLicenseHistory a small fabrication]]: in real life the Zulus left because they weren't supposed to be there in the first place -- Prince Dabulamanzi, the Zulu commander of the force that attacked Rorke's Drift, was King Cetshwayo's half-brother, and noted for his rashness and aggressive command behaviour. The attack at Rorke's Drift was actually ''a direct violation of orders from the king'', specifically that the Zulu forces were to act ''only'' in defence of Zululand, and under no circumstances to invade British-held territory. In reality, the Zulus had just disappeared by the dawn after the final attack, and only one more Zulu impi was briefly sighted by the men, retreating about an hour ahead of the British reinforcements.

to:

** The Zulus appear to be massing again to wipe out the British, but it turns out they're saluting the British for their bravery before departing for good. This is [[ArtisticLicenseHistory a small fabrication]]: in real life the Zulus left because they weren't supposed to be there in the first place -- Prince Dabulamanzi, the Zulu commander of the Zulu force that attacked Rorke's Drift, was King Cetshwayo's half-brother, and noted for his rashness and aggressive command behaviour. The attack at Rorke's Drift was actually ''a direct violation of orders from the king'', specifically that the Zulu forces were to act ''only'' in defence of Zululand, and under no circumstances to invade British-held territory. In reality, the Zulus had just disappeared by the dawn after the final attack, and only one more Zulu impi was briefly sighted by the men, retreating about an hour ahead of the British reinforcements.



* DatedHistory: The film depicts a key reason for the British defeat at Isandlwana that the soldiers ran out of ammunition because [[ObstructiveBureaucrat Quartermaster Bloomfield]] dispenses reserve bullets to soldiers in an absurdly slow, "orderly" fashion. This was widely believed when the film went into production, featuring in Donald Morris's popular book ''The Washing of the Spears'' among other accounts of the Zulu War. It appears this story is exaggerated, if not a myth; while Durnford's Native troops did ran out of ammunition, it was mostly because they had been deployed too far from the camp to ensure a steady supply of ammo, not Bloomfield's poor handling of supply.[[note]]A related myth is that Bloomfield and his aides weren't able to open the ammo boxes because the commissary had misplaced their screwdrivers; even if this had been the case, the boxes were easily broken open with rifle butts or other tools.[[/note]] Most British units closer to the main camp were able to keep up a steady stream of fire until they were overrun, as attested by both British and Zulu accounts of the battle, but their lines were spread too thin to properly defend the camp from a coordinated Zulu attack.

to:

* DatedHistory: The film depicts a key reason for the British defeat at Isandlwana that the soldiers ran out of ammunition because [[ObstructiveBureaucrat Quartermaster Bloomfield]] dispenses reserve bullets to soldiers in an absurdly slow, "orderly" fashion. This was widely believed when the film went into production, featuring in Donald Morris's popular book ''The Washing of the Spears'' among other accounts of the Zulu War. It appears this story is exaggerated, if not a myth; while Durnford's Native troops did ''did'' ran out of ammunition, it was mostly because they had been deployed too far from the camp to ensure a steady supply of ammo, it, not Bloomfield's poor handling of the supply.[[note]]A related myth is that Bloomfield and his aides weren't able to open the ammo boxes because the commissary had misplaced their screwdrivers; even if this had been the case, the boxes were easily broken open with rifle butts or other tools.[[/note]] Most British units closer to the main camp were able to keep up a steady stream of fire until they were overrun, as attested by both British and Zulu accounts of the battle, but their lines were spread too thin to properly defend the camp from a coordinated Zulu attack.

Added: 421

Changed: 589

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The portrayal of Private Hook was so offensively wrong (in real life he was a model soldier and a teetotaler) that his daughter walked out of the film premiere.
** Otto Witt wasn't a pacifist (he helped the British soldiers plan their defence) or a drunk, and he only left so as to alert his family at his farm a little while away; he also wasn't a widower and three children at the time, the oldest of whom was seven years old.

to:

** As a result, most of the Zulu firearms at Rorke's Drift were outmoded rifles and muskets purchased from arms traders, rather than Martini-Henrys taken from the British dead at Isandlwana.
** The portrayal of Private Hook was so offensively wrong (in real life he was a model soldier and a teetotaler) that his daughter walked out of the film premiere.
premiere.
** Otto Witt wasn't a pacifist (he helped the British soldiers plan their defence) or a drunk, and he only left so as to alert his family at his farm a little while away; he also wasn't a widower and three children at the time, the oldest of whom was seven years old. Also contrary to the film's portrayal, Witt was not well-liked by the Zulu and had been banished from the Kingdom by Cesthawayo before the war broke out.

Top