Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / XmenFirstClass

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''X-Men: First Class'' is the [[Film/XMenOriginsWolverine second]] {{prequel}} in the ''Film/XMenFilmSeries'' set in [[TheSixties 1962]] [[AlternateHistory during the]] [[UsefulNotes/HistoryOfTheColdWar Cuban Missile Crisis]].

to:

''X-Men: First Class'' is the [[Film/XMenOriginsWolverine second]] {{prequel}} in the ''Film/XMenFilmSeries'' ''Franchise/XMenFilmSeries'' set in [[TheSixties 1962]] [[AlternateHistory during the]] [[UsefulNotes/HistoryOfTheColdWar Cuban Missile Crisis]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* VengeanceFeelsEmpty: the warning Charles gives to Erik.
- Professor Charles Xavier : Listen to me very carefully, my friend. Killing Shaw will not bring you peace.
- Erik Lehnsherr : Peace was never an option.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FaceDeathWithDignity: After Magneto gains control of the missiles and sends them right back towards the warships, the American captain remarks it's been an honor serving with his crew, while the Russian captain thanks his men for their service.

Changed: 495

Removed: 482

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
General clarification on work content


* TheFarmerAndTheViper:
** Charles believed that he could help the emotionally damaged Erik find some measure of peace and happiness by offering the latter friendship and a home, but [[spoiler:Erik repays Charles' kindness with betrayal, abandonment, and a permanent (if accidental) spinal cord injury]].
** Xavier believes that humanity as a whole will accept them because they desire peaceful coexistence. [[spoiler:As soon as they avert a mutually destructive nuclear war, both sides open fire on them.]]

to:

* TheFarmerAndTheViper:
**
TheFarmerAndTheViper: Poor, poor Charles Xavier. He believed that he could help the emotionally damaged Erik find some measure of peace and happiness by offering the latter friendship and a home, but [[spoiler:Erik repays Charles' kindness with betrayal, abandonment, and a permanent (if accidental) spinal cord injury]].
** Xavier believes
injury]]. He believed that humanity as a whole will accept them because they desire peaceful coexistence. [[spoiler:As soon as they avert a mutually destructive nuclear war, both sides open fire on them.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PayEvilUntoEvil: Much of the film is composed of Erik (later Magneto) doing this. He's Jewish, as a child he and his family are sent to Auschwitz, and a Nazi there (who we later find out is the mutant Sebastian Shaw) murders Erik's mother when Erik is unable to use his (latent) powers. As an adult, the first part of the film has Erik hunting down, torturing and murdering Nazis and their supporters. At the end of the movie [[spoiler:he gives Shaw a very KarmicDeath - the film clearly intends it to be a JumpingOffTheSlipperySlope moment, but Shaw's such a dangerous madman that he deserves such a kick, especially as there's little reason to believe Shaw could be safely captured. ''Then'' the US and Soviet militaries try to murder the mutants who just saved them from nuclear war, and Erik turns their missiles back on them]]. Paying evil to evil is his personal philosophy, contrasting with Charles' pay-good-unto-evil-and-maybe-they'll-have-a-change-of-heart ethos (and influenced by the fact that Erik's seen a lot more of evil than [[WideEyedIdealist Charles has at this point]]), and it's a substantial part of what ultimately separates them.

to:

* PayEvilUntoEvil: Much of the film is composed of Erik (later Magneto) doing this. He's Jewish, as a child he and his family are sent to Auschwitz, and a Nazi there (who we later find out is the mutant Sebastian Shaw) murders Erik's mother when Erik is unable to use his (latent) powers. As an adult, the first part of the film has Erik hunting down, torturing and murdering Nazis and their supporters. At the end of the movie [[spoiler:he gives Shaw a very KarmicDeath - KarmicDeath-- the film clearly intends it to be a JumpingOffTheSlipperySlope moment, but Shaw's such a dangerous madman that he deserves such a kick, especially as there's little reason to believe Shaw could be safely captured. ''Then'' the US and Soviet militaries try to murder the mutants who just saved them from nuclear war, and Erik turns their missiles back on them]]. Paying evil to evil is his personal philosophy, contrasting with Charles' pay-good-unto-evil-and-maybe-they'll-have-a-change-of-heart ethos (and influenced by the fact that Erik's seen a lot more of evil than [[WideEyedIdealist Charles has at this point]]), and it's a substantial part of what ultimately separates them.



* PersonalHateBeforeCommonGoals: At the end of the film, main villain Sebastian Shaw is still trying to convince Magneto that they are on the same side, even while their climactic battle is taking place. Magneto finally admits that he thinks Shaw is right. That the experiences he put him through as a kid made him stronger, and that he made him the man that he is today. And that his idea of mutants taking the initiative, attacking the humans before they could try to wipe mutants out, is the right one. But just as Magneto takes the initiative of the fight, he reveals his one problem: Shaw still killed his mother. Cue to Magneto putting a coin through Shaw's head.

to:

* PersonalHateBeforeCommonGoals: At the end of the film, main villain Sebastian Shaw is still trying to convince Magneto that they are on the same side, even while their climactic battle is taking place. Magneto finally admits that he thinks Shaw is right. That right: the experiences he put him through as a kid made him stronger, and that he made him the man that he is today. And that today; his idea of mutants taking the initiative, attacking the humans before they could try to wipe mutants out, is the right one. But just as Magneto takes the initiative of the fight, he reveals his one problem: Shaw still killed his mother. Cue to Magneto putting a coin through Shaw's head.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ItsNotAboutTheRequest: [[spoiler:When Shaw makes a WeCanRuleTogether pitch to Erik, Erik notes that he actually agrees with Shaw's point of view about an inevitable human vs mutant conflict. However, since Shaw is the Nazi who tortured him in a concentration camp and killed his mother, Erik wants nothing to do with Shaw despite having no disagreement with what Shaw says and wants to do.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* DisabledLoveInterest: It's hinted that [[spoiler:Charles briefly had a romance with Moira after his spinal cord injury, but he is forced to end their relationship to protect himself and his students from the CIA]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking new trope.

Added DiffLines:

* TheFirstSuperheroes: Being a timeline reboot of the film series, the mutants are reintroduced. In this case, mutants exist in modern times (1960s), but few and far between. Some already joined forces as the secretive Hellfire Club with the intent to influence the political fate of nations, while Xavier, Mystique and Magneto (who were already shown to have their powers from childhood/early adolescence) meet Hank [=McCoy=] (in this continuity, a CIA aide) and use his Cerebro creation to gather a handful of mutants. The mutant groups clash during the Cuban Missile Crisis (1962).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseGunSafety: To test the depth of his magnetic manipulation, Erik demands Charles fire his (M1911) handgun at him. Basic rule of gun safety is you NEVER point a gun at someone or something you are not intending to destroy, even firing guns at people with body armor on is frowned upon as reckless. Making it worse is Erik boasts about how his magnetism is so powerful he would even be able to block the bullet at point blank range, and forces Charles to stick the gun up against his head. Problem here is that even if by some miracle Erik had the reaction time necessary to stop a bullet at that range, guns release enormous amounts of flame out of the tip of the barrel, because that gas propellant is what is shoving the bullet out of the gun's barrel. Magnetism would not allow Erik to block the flame, and his face would be scorched with 2nd and third degree burns, most likely killing him in the process. Charles thankfully has enough common sense to put the gun away and not listen to Erik's insane demand... though given how much of a menace Magneto is later on, maybe he should have.

Changed: 262

Removed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added example(s)


%%



** Telling Magneto that men were [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YH_VtXj6c2o&feature=related "Just following orders"]] sends him into a murderous rage.

to:

** Telling Magneto that men were trying to kill him are [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YH_VtXj6c2o&feature=related "Just following orders"]] sends him into a murderous rage.



-->'''Xavier''': The point between [[UnstoppableRage rage]] and [[DissonantSerenity serenity]].

to:

-->'''Xavier''': The point True focus lies somewhere between [[UnstoppableRage rage]] and [[DissonantSerenity serenity]].



* EnemyMine: The ending implies that the Americans and Soviets have found a common enemy in the mutants.

to:

* EnemyMine: Magneto invokes this between the X-Men and the Hellfire Club against "the real enemy"...humans. The ending implies that the Americans and Soviets have found a common enemy in the mutants.



** When we first see Xavier as a kid, the framed photos on his night table are of Charles Darwin, Hedy Lamarr (who was both a Hollywood sex symbol and the [[http://www.theguardian.com/theguardian/shortcuts/2011/dec/04/hedy-lamarr-wifi co-inventor of a radio-guided torpedo system]]) and Albert Einstein. He would later grow up to be a scientist with an appreciation for both brains and beauty.

to:

** When we first see Xavier as a kid, the framed photos on his night table are of Charles Darwin, Hedy Lamarr Creator/HedyLamarr (who was both a Hollywood sex symbol and the [[http://www.theguardian.com/theguardian/shortcuts/2011/dec/04/hedy-lamarr-wifi co-inventor of a radio-guided torpedo system]]) and Albert Einstein.UsefulNotes/AlbertEinstein. He would later grow up to be a scientist with an appreciation for both brains and beauty.



* JustFollowingOrders: One of the Nazis that Erik confronts trots out this line as an excuse for their actions. It's clearly a desperate last attempt at placation, the fact that he says this just after Erik deflects the ''Nazi dagger'' he tried to stab him with does little to help his case.
** Charles later makes the mistake of echoing it while trying to calm Magneto down. Definitely an OhCrap moment for the audience when he says it.
-->'''Magneto:''' [[ShutUpKirk I've been at the mercy of men just following orders. Never again.]]

to:

* JustFollowingOrders: One of the Nazis that attacks Erik confronts trots out this line as an excuse for their actions. It's clearly a desperate last attempt at placation, the fact that he says this just after Erik deflects the ''Nazi dagger'' he tried to stab him with does little to help his case.
** Charles later makes the mistake of echoing it this while trying to calm Magneto down. Definitely an OhCrap moment for the audience when he says it.
-->'''Magneto:''' [[ShutUpKirk I've been at the mercy of men just "just following orders.orders". Never again.]]



** Strings of Suspense: twice in the film's last 15 minutes. Both are Charles imploring Magneto to spare first Shaw, then the [=US=] and [=USSR=] navies.

to:

** Strings of Suspense: twice Twice in the film's last 15 minutes. Both are Charles imploring Magneto to spare first Shaw, then the [=US=] and [=USSR=] navies.



* MoralMyopia: Sebastian Shaw tells Erik the justification for his plan to [[spoiler:start a nuclear war that would probably kill hundreds of millions or billions of people]]. Erik then says, [[spoiler:"I agree with everything you say. Unfortunately, you killed my mother." Erik then kills him in a KarmicDeath]].

to:

* MoralMyopia: Sebastian Shaw tells Erik the justification for his plan to [[spoiler:start a nuclear war that would probably kill hundreds of millions or billions of people]]. Erik then says, [[spoiler:"I agree with everything you say.said. Unfortunately, you killed my mother." Erik then kills gives him in a KarmicDeath]].



** For any audience member who knows [[UsefulNotes/NaziGermany what made it famous]], the moment when the last line in [[spoiler:Charles's 'please don't kill those people' speech to Erik is [[JustFollowingOrders "they were just following orders."]]]]

to:

** For any audience member who knows [[UsefulNotes/NaziGermany what made it famous]], the moment when the last line in [[spoiler:Charles's 'please don't kill those people' speech to Erik is [[JustFollowingOrders "they were just {{just following orders."]]]]orders}}."]]



* OpenMouthInsertFoot: Charles urging Erik to show mercy to two navies that just fired on them because the sailors aboard said ships were "[[JustFollowingOrders just following orders]]" is probably the worst thing he could have said to a Holocaust survivor.

to:

* OpenMouthInsertFoot: Charles urging Erik to show mercy to two navies that just fired on them because the sailors aboard said ships were "[[JustFollowingOrders just "{{just following orders]]" orders}}" is probably the worst thing he could have said to a Holocaust survivor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* TranslationConvention: Averted for the most part: All the scenes with the Nazis/the Swiss bankteller/former German soldiers as well as the scenes with the Russians are spoken in German, French, Spanish, and Russian where appropriate, with subtitles in English. A couple scenes use the technique of starting in foreign language, then shifting to English for the last few (and most dramatically important) lines. Unfortunately, the actors have trouble with pronunciation and accents.
** This is a {{Narm}} source for Germans, because of the accents. 'Evolution', while written the same in german and english, has the stress ''just'' the other way around.
** The scene in Argentina is a notable exception thanks to all actors involved being German, or of German origin in the case of Fassbender.
** Argentina (particularly in the Buenos Aires province, where Villa Gessel is located) has a distinctive local accent, but the few Spanish lines shown there were delivered Spain-style, which is a very different accent.
Willbyr MOD

Added: 628

Changed: 171

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
crosswicking a new trope


%%%Administrivia/ZeroContextExample entries are NOT allowed on wiki pages. All such entries have been commented out. Add context to the entries before uncommenting them.

to:

%%%Administrivia/ZeroContextExample %%
%%
%%
%% Administrivia/ZeroContextExample
entries are NOT allowed on wiki pages. All such entries have been commented out. out.
%%
Add context to the entries before uncommenting them.



%% Removing comments without adding context or adding new Zero Context Examples will anger the mods

to:

%% Removing comments without adding context or adding new Zero Context Examples will anger the mods
mods.
%%
%%


Added DiffLines:

* DramaticSpineInjury: After Magneto turns the US and Soviet shells and missiles back toward their ships, Moira [=MacTaggert=] tries to shoot him. Her first bullet just bounces off the helmet he took from Shaw, and Magneto deflects the other bullets effortlessly, but the last hits Xavier in the back. Xavier [[SlowMotionFall falls in agony]], and although Magneto is able to extract the bullet, the damage is done and Xavier's legs become paralyzed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
disambiguated, ZCE example


* CoolGun:
** Moira [=MacTaggert=] uses a Walther PPK as her sidearm.
** An [=M1911A1=] is featured prominently in a scene in which Magneto asks Xavier to shoot him in the head, as he can stop the bullet before it hits him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Prequel}}: This movie serves as a prequel to the original X-Men trilogy. With the release of ''Days of Future Past'', it became the start of a new series. However, due to continuity issues, it works better as a reboot.

to:

* {{Prequel}}: This movie serves as a prequel to the original X-Men trilogy. With the release of ''Days of Future Past'', it became the start of a new series. However, due to continuity issues, it works better as a reboot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* BackseatChangingRoom: PlayedWith. Agent Moira [=McTaggart=] needs to infiltrate the Hellfire Club, but the CIA didn't really have any plans for how to get her inside. Noticing a bunch of scantily-clad women marching in a line inside as part of the entertainment, Moira quickly strips down and dashes out of the backseat of the car to fall in line, allowing her to get inside without anyone questioning it.

Top