Follow TV Tropes

Following

History DieForOurShip / SouthPark

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A long long time ago when TheMovie was new, Gregory used to get this from Stan/Wendy fans. That's all ancient history now.
* Token, oddly enough, got hate from people that DIDN'T necessarily ship Stan/Wendy, but still hated him for trying to "steal away" what Stan was [[WhereDaWhiteWomenAt "enti]][[EntitledToHaveYou tled"]] to. This resulted in some gross racist comments and a few bashfics where Token got derailed into a drug-dealing JerkJock or ScaryBlackMan who would steal any girl Stan wanted JUST to spite him. These days, things may be a little better for him, as he is no longer dating Wendy and usually [[TokenMinorityCouple gets paired with Nichole]] instead.

to:

* A long long time ago when TheMovie was new, Gregory used to get this from Stan/Wendy fans. That's all ancient history now.
now, since Gregory is a OneShotCharacter, and later seasons have established Tolkien and Bridon as the main targets of Stan's jealousy.
* Token, Tolkien, oddly enough, got hate from people that DIDN'T necessarily ship Stan/Wendy, but still hated him for trying to "steal away" what Stan was [[WhereDaWhiteWomenAt "enti]][[EntitledToHaveYou tled"]] to. This resulted in some gross racist comments and a few bashfics where Token Tolkien got derailed into a drug-dealing JerkJock or ScaryBlackMan who would steal any girl Stan wanted JUST to spite him. These days, things may be a little better for him, as he is no longer dating Wendy and usually [[TokenMinorityCouple gets paired with Nichole]] instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
wrong trpoe


* This also would happen in some Kyle/Wendy fanworks, where those for the pairing felt Wendy deserved a more intelligent boyfriend like Kyle. As a result, they would do what they could to portray Stan as abusive or cold to make Kyle look like the better option. Oddly, it's quite the reversal of what happened with pro-Stan/Kyle stories that demonized Wendy, and seems to fall almost in line with the aforementioned "FetishizedAbuser Stan" or "DumbJock Stan" that typically appears in pro-Kyle/Cartman or Cartman/Wendy fanworks.

to:

* This also would happen in some Kyle/Wendy fanworks, where those for the pairing felt Wendy deserved a more intelligent boyfriend like Kyle. As a result, they would do what they could to portray Stan as abusive or cold to make Kyle look like the better option. Oddly, it's quite the reversal of what happened with pro-Stan/Kyle stories that demonized Wendy, and seems to fall almost in line with the aforementioned "FetishizedAbuser "DomesticAbuse Stan" or "DumbJock Stan" that typically appears in pro-Kyle/Cartman or Cartman/Wendy fanworks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trope merge


* This also would happen in some Kyle/Wendy fanworks, where those for the pairing felt Wendy deserved a more intelligent boyfriend like Kyle. As a result, they would do what they could to portray Stan as abusive or cold to make Kyle look like the better option. Oddly, it's quite the reversal of what happened with pro-Stan/Kyle stories that demonized Wendy, and seems to fall almost in line with the aforementioned "BastardBoyfriend Stan" or "DumbJock Stan" that typically appears in pro-Kyle/Cartman or Cartman/Wendy fanworks.

to:

* This also would happen in some Kyle/Wendy fanworks, where those for the pairing felt Wendy deserved a more intelligent boyfriend like Kyle. As a result, they would do what they could to portray Stan as abusive or cold to make Kyle look like the better option. Oddly, it's quite the reversal of what happened with pro-Stan/Kyle stories that demonized Wendy, and seems to fall almost in line with the aforementioned "BastardBoyfriend "FetishizedAbuser Stan" or "DumbJock Stan" that typically appears in pro-Kyle/Cartman or Cartman/Wendy fanworks.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* More recently, [[FoeYay Kyle/Cartman]] writers have taken to writing what are essentially anti-[[HeterosexualLifePartners Stan/Kyle]] fics that either a) have Stan die and Cartman swoop in to woo Kyle, or b) [[RonTheDeathEater change Stan's character beyond the point of recognition]], making Kyle turn to Cartman for friendship/romance.

to:

* More recently, [[FoeYay [[FoeYayShipping Kyle/Cartman]] writers have taken to writing what are essentially anti-[[HeterosexualLifePartners Stan/Kyle]] fics that either a) have Stan die and Cartman swoop in to woo Kyle, or b) [[RonTheDeathEater change Stan's character beyond the point of recognition]], making Kyle turn to Cartman for friendship/romance.

Changed: 1274

Removed: 297

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cutting some irrelevant stuff


* Token, oddly enough, got hate from people that DIDN'T necessarily ship Stan/Wendy, but still hated him for trying to "steal away" what Stan was [[WhereDaWhiteWomenAt "enti]][[EntitledToHaveYou tled"]] to. This resulted in some gross racist comments and a few bashfics where Token got derailed into a drug-dealing JerkJock or ScaryBlackMan who would steal any girl Stan wanted JUST to spite him. These days, things may be a little better for him, as he is no longer dating Wendy (although as of "Skank Hunt", [[spoiler:[[ShipSinking no pairing is canon anymore]] outside of Craig/Tweek and Cartman/Heidi later on]]).
** Though apparently as of "The Fractured But Whole" [[spoiler:Stan/Wendy is canon again]].
* Out of all the female characters from ''WesternAnimation/SouthPark'', Estella gets the worst of them from the Damien/Pip fans for "being a snooty bitch to Pip", even though it's not like Damien ever treated Pip any different or better.
** This is especially bizarre because Estella is only seen in a WholePlotReference of ''Literature/GreatExpectations;'' as far as we know, she doesn't actually exist in the "real" ''South Park'' universe, so it's not like you ''need'' to vilify her for your ship.
* As of Season 20, Heidi has fallen victim to this, as Kyle/[[spoiler:Cartman]] fans are angry at her for [[spoiler:dating Cartman]].
* Also in Season 20, Butters has received a torrent of scorn from [[spoiler:Cartman/Heidi fans, after Cartman became distrustful of her due to Butters' influence]].

to:

* Token, oddly enough, got hate from people that DIDN'T necessarily ship Stan/Wendy, but still hated him for trying to "steal away" what Stan was [[WhereDaWhiteWomenAt "enti]][[EntitledToHaveYou tled"]] to. This resulted in some gross racist comments and a few bashfics where Token got derailed into a drug-dealing JerkJock or ScaryBlackMan who would steal any girl Stan wanted JUST to spite him. These days, things may be a little better for him, as he is no longer dating Wendy (although as of "Skank Hunt", [[spoiler:[[ShipSinking no pairing is canon anymore]] outside of Craig/Tweek and Cartman/Heidi later on]]).
** Though apparently as of "The Fractured But Whole" [[spoiler:Stan/Wendy is canon again]].
usually [[TokenMinorityCouple gets paired with Nichole]] instead.
* Out of all the female characters from ''WesternAnimation/SouthPark'', Estella gets the worst of them from the Damien/Pip fans for "being a snooty bitch to Pip", even though it's not like Damien ever treated Pip any different or better.
**
better. This is especially bizarre because Estella is only seen in a WholePlotReference of ''Literature/GreatExpectations;'' as far as we know, she doesn't actually exist in the "real" ''South Park'' universe, so it's not like you ''need'' to vilify her for your ship.
* As of Season 20, Heidi has fallen victim to this, as Kyle/[[spoiler:Cartman]] Kyle/Cartman fans are angry at her for [[spoiler:dating Cartman]].
dating Cartman.
* Also in Season 20, Butters has received a torrent of scorn from [[spoiler:Cartman/Heidi Cartman/Heidi fans, after Cartman became distrustful of her due to Butters' influence]].influence.

Top