History DethroningMoment / WebOriginal

30th Mar '17 7:36:08 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/RetsofNoraa: Creator/RoosterTeeth's Creator/AchievementHunter has one in their video for the "Pay Your Respects" achievement in ''VideoGame/BatmanArkhamCity''. The achievement is - literally - paying your respects at the site where Bruce's parents were killed. Being Rooster Teeth, they try to lighten the situation with humor - claiming the chalk outlines make it look like Martha Wayne was giving a blowjob to Thomas when they died - but instead of [[CrossesTheLineTwice crossing the line twice]], it only crosses the line.

to:

* Tropers/RetsofNoraa: Creator/RoosterTeeth's Creator/AchievementHunter has one in their video for the "Pay Your Respects" achievement in ''VideoGame/BatmanArkhamCity''. The achievement is - literally - paying your respects at the site where Bruce's parents were killed. Being Rooster Teeth, they try to lighten the situation with humor - claiming the chalk outlines make it look like Martha Wayne was giving a blowjob to Thomas when they died - but instead of [[CrossesTheLineTwice crossing the line twice]], [[DudeNotFunny it only crosses the line.line]].



* Tropers/SpongeBat1: I think [=AnimatedJames=] is a fairly decent [=animator/writer=], but what absolutely irks me is his [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yPRnhXVMpO0 Teen Titans No]] video. As one of the few people who like ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitansGo'', I had a feeling I might not like the video, but I can understand why some people don't like the show and decided I'd give James the benefit of the doubt. It starts off with James' idea of what the TTG writers are like, and surprise, surprise, they're all blithering jackasses. [[SarcasmMode Great start so far.]] But what pushes it over the edge is when Robin throws a hand grenade into the room and [[GoryDiscretionShot gorily kills the writers]]. [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality And this is treated as a good thing.]] So this video basically implies that the TTG writers deserve to die [[DisproportionateRetribution just because James doesn't think the show is funny]]. [[SarcasmMode But wait, it gets better!]] Towards the end of the video, a random producer says that the writers were all mentally handicapped... What? There's BlackComedy, there's an AuthorTract, and then there's just plain offensiveness, and frankly, James, that line crossed it big time.

to:

* Tropers/SpongeBat1: I think [=AnimatedJames=] is a fairly decent [=animator/writer=], but what absolutely irks me is his [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yPRnhXVMpO0 Teen Titans No]] video. As one of the few people who like ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitansGo'', I had a feeling I might not like the video, but I can understand why some people don't like the show and decided I'd give James the benefit of the doubt. It starts off with James' idea of what the TTG writers are like, and surprise, surprise, they're all blithering jackasses. [[SarcasmMode Great start so far.]] But what pushes it over the edge is when Robin throws a hand grenade into the room and [[GoryDiscretionShot gorily kills the writers]]. [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality And this is treated as a good thing.]] So this video basically implies that the TTG writers deserve to die [[DisproportionateRetribution just because James doesn't think the show is funny]]. [[SarcasmMode But wait, it gets better!]] Towards the end of the video, a random producer says that the writers were all mentally handicapped... What? There's BlackComedy, there's an AuthorTract, and then there's just plain offensiveness, DudeNotFunny, and frankly, James, that line crossed it big time.



* [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: I liked his ''Search for the Worst'' review of the ''WebVideo/{{Fred}}'' Movie Trilogy and even though the bit with his friend Ralphthemoviemaker was good. However, around 30 minutes in, after snarking about a video where Lucas says he doesn't remember filming the "Fred vs. TheAnnoyingOrange" video, he then says that's the result of blackouts and trying to repress memories. Then the video pauses for Ralph to make a [[OverlyLongGag really long]] [[{{Squick}} and unnecessarily uncomfortable]] child molestation joke. It goes on for what feels like forever (it lasts a minute!!), it contradicts some of Alex's points regarding comedy (in that jokes need a punchline to be funny....this one doesn't, it's also very similar to a scene in the movie Alex also criticized for also being drawn-out), and worst of all, it's not funny, not even in the black sort of sense. I know Ralph's bit was produced by himself but there was no need for that joke and it soured the video a bit for me (still a damn good video either way, but good lord) due to how unnecessary and hypocritical it was. Also, Ralph avoids using {{Overly Long Gag}}s in his videos for the most part.

to:

* [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: I liked his ''Search for the Worst'' review of the ''WebVideo/{{Fred}}'' Movie Trilogy and even though the bit with his friend Ralphthemoviemaker was good. However, around 30 minutes in, after snarking about a video where Lucas says he doesn't remember filming the "Fred vs. TheAnnoyingOrange" video, he then says that's the result of blackouts and trying to repress memories. Then the video pauses for Ralph to make a [[OverlyLongGag really long]] [[{{Squick}} and unnecessarily uncomfortable]] child molestation joke. It goes on for what feels like forever (it lasts a minute!!), it contradicts some of Alex's points regarding comedy (in that jokes need a punchline to be funny....this one doesn't, it's also very similar to a scene in the movie Alex also criticized for also being drawn-out), and worst of all, [[DudeNotFunny it's not funny, not even in the black sort of sense.sense]]. I know Ralph's bit was produced by himself but there was no need for that joke and it soured the video a bit for me (still a damn good video either way, but good lord) due to how unnecessary and hypocritical it was. Also, Ralph avoids using {{Overly Long Gag}}s in his videos for the most part.



* @/AxMachina: Deleting my previous Media Man rage, I found some more [[DarthWiki/DethroningMomentOfSuck dethroning moments]] under his belt. In two reviews[[note]][[http://mixedfan8643.deviantart.com/art/The-Media-Man-Reviews-The-Simpsons-428256345 The Simpsons one]], and the [[http://mixedfan8643.deviantart.com/art/The-Media-Man-Reviews-Home-Alone-1-and-2-419401546 Home Alone one]][[/note]], our CausticCritic says he doesn't like a child character because of him being bratty, or too smart for his own good. Now, this could have been something I could've said was a good point...right up until he had a "joke" where he [[WouldHurtAChild killed one of the characters with a nuclear bomb, and another with a rocket launcher.]] And, to top it all of, in one of the comments calling him out on this, he claims that he's "unique" because of it, then tries to explain himself by saying it was his AuthorAvatar saying it and that [[JustJokingJustification it was supposed to be humorously exaggerated.]] Hey, Media Man. [[{{Hypocrite}} Remember how you said that Bart was evil because he's usually an asshole? How can you say that when you yourself joked about murdering children, and showed no regret, guilt or shame towards your actions because it was a "joke"?]]

to:

* @/AxMachina: Deleting my previous Media Man rage, I found some more [[DarthWiki/DethroningMomentOfSuck dethroning moments]] under his belt. In two reviews[[note]][[http://mixedfan8643.deviantart.com/art/The-Media-Man-Reviews-The-Simpsons-428256345 The Simpsons one]], and the [[http://mixedfan8643.deviantart.com/art/The-Media-Man-Reviews-Home-Alone-1-and-2-419401546 Home Alone one]][[/note]], our CausticCritic says he doesn't like a child character because of him being bratty, or too smart for his own good. Now, this could have been something I could've said was a good point...right up until he had a "joke" [[DudeNotFunny "joke"]] where he [[WouldHurtAChild killed one of the characters with a nuclear bomb, and another with a rocket launcher.]] And, to top it all of, in one of the comments calling him out on this, he claims that he's "unique" because of it, then tries to explain himself by saying it was his AuthorAvatar saying it and that [[JustJokingJustification it was supposed to be humorously exaggerated.]] Hey, Media Man. [[{{Hypocrite}} Remember how you said that Bart was evil because he's usually an asshole? How can you say that when you yourself joked about murdering children, and showed no regret, guilt or shame towards your actions because it was a "joke"?]]



From [[CriticalResearchFailure entries that have about as much research in them as the Jimmy McPerson essay]] to jokes that would make Creator/SethMacFarlane shake his head, we count down [[DethroningMomentOfSuck the worst Planet Dolan moments of all time]].

to:

From [[CriticalResearchFailure entries that have about as much research in them as the Jimmy McPerson essay]] to [[DudeNotFunny jokes that would make make]] Creator/SethMacFarlane [[DudeNotFunny shake his head, head]], we count down [[DethroningMomentOfSuck the worst Planet Dolan moments of all time]].



* [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: For me, it's when Proto told commentator Kayden Marx, who is in a financial rut and has started a [=GoFundMe=] to have fans donate money for his insurance, that he deserved to be in said rut. And then he had his fans raid [=youngbloodfantasy91=]'s commentary on him and bring the video to an insane and undeserved amount of dislikes. All because Kayden made a commentary on him that actually makes decent points. [[FlatWhat What.]] Given that I'm barely familiar with Proto's work, [[SarcasmMode talk about a good first impression.]]

to:

* [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: For me, it's when Proto told commentator Kayden Marx, who is in a financial rut and has started a [=GoFundMe=] to have fans donate money for his insurance, that [[DudeNotFunny he deserved to be in said rut.rut]]. And then he had his fans raid [=youngbloodfantasy91=]'s commentary on him and bring the video to an insane and undeserved amount of dislikes. All because Kayden made a commentary on him that actually makes decent points. [[FlatWhat What.]] Given that I'm barely familiar with Proto's work, [[SarcasmMode talk about a good first impression.]]



* DokemonStudios: Now, I enjoy ''WebAnimation/{{Sonic Shorts}}'', and there's always at least one or two shorts that would make me laugh a lot even in the weaker episodes. But the last short in Volume 3 just left a bad taste in my mouth, specifically the ending where after Froggy leaves Big the Cat, [[SuicideasComedy Big hangs himself with his own fishing rod!]] Disregarding the fact that the string or that tree branch would break, due to Big's weight, [[NightmareFuel it's actually more horrifying than the Tails doll shorts!]] Seriously, [[TheScrappy I know people don't like Big,]] and neither do I, but that ending was just unnecessary, and mean spirited, and can just be easily cut out.

to:

* DokemonStudios: Now, I enjoy ''WebAnimation/{{Sonic Shorts}}'', and there's always at least one or two shorts that would make me laugh a lot even in the weaker episodes. But the last short in Volume 3 just left a bad taste in my mouth, specifically the ending where after Froggy leaves Big the Cat, [[SuicideasComedy Big hangs himself with his own fishing rod!]] Disregarding the fact that the string or that tree branch would break, due to Big's weight, [[NightmareFuel it's actually more horrifying than the Tails doll shorts!]] Seriously, [[TheScrappy I know people don't like Big,]] and neither do I, but that ending was just unnecessary, and [[DudeNotFunny mean spirited, spirited]], and can just be easily cut out.



** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy, [[CruelAndUnusualDeath graphic]], [[NightmareFuel brutal and cruel]] as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He [[NauseaFuel cuts a slice off Toothy's face]] ''[[TheWoobie while he was terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me actually cry in genuine sympathy]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits by a fan, [[BodyHorror carves Nutty like an apple]], shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. Seriously, F**K YOU, FLI''Q''PY! You're nothing more than a torturous psychopath who kills people from little to no reason at all! After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the unfunny Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q]]'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]]. And of course Mondo ''had'' to put him in more episodes.

to:

** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy, [[CruelAndUnusualDeath graphic]], [[NightmareFuel brutal and cruel]] as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He [[NauseaFuel cuts a slice off Toothy's face]] ''[[TheWoobie while he was terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me actually cry in genuine sympathy]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits by a fan, [[BodyHorror carves Nutty like an apple]], shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. Seriously, F**K YOU, FLI''Q''PY! You're nothing more than a torturous psychopath who kills people from little to no reason at all! After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the unfunny [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q]]'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]]. And of course Mondo ''had'' to put him in more episodes.



* [=TomPhanto=]: As much as I enjoy the plush videos of WebVideo/SuperMarioLogan, I did not like "Jeffy's Bad Word!" at all. It's about Jeffy, a mentally handicapped kid who was dumped on Mario's doorstep in "Mario The Babysitter!" and has now become one of the most recurring characters, second only to Bowser Jr. I personally dislike Jeffy episodes because most of them are just making [[OnlySaneMan Mario]] a CosmicPlaything. The episode starts off with Mario driving to Walmart and he yells at a homeless guy that gets in his way, accidentally calling him a "faggot". Jeffy then starts saying it because he likes the word. And as expected, the episode is about Mario getting into trouble because Jeffy won't stop saying "faggot". What makes this a [=DMoS=] for me is what happens at the end. Mario gives Jeffy a spanking because he wouldn't stop saying "faggot". Mario is arrested, [[WronglyAccused accused of child molestation]], and is registered as a felon and sex offender, all just for trying to discipline Jeffy. I know Mario's supposed to be a ButtMonkey in this show, but I felt the episode went way too far with the abuse.
** MetaMaster54610: You'd think Logan would have learned his lesson from the fiasco Jeffy's Bad Word caused. He knew full well how loathed that video was, so you'd think he'd know better than to create Jeffy's Bad Word 2.0 in the form of 'Locked Out'. The plot of the video is that Mario is trying to get Jeffy to eat his peas, promising him chocolate cake if he eats his peas. Rather than eating his peas, Jeffy pours them onto his high chair seat and tries to lie to Mario about it. When Mario rightfully denies him chocolate cake for not actually eating his dinner, Jeffy throws a tantrum. Admittedly, it was a dick move to have Mario eat a piece of chocolate cake in front of Jeffy, but what happens next is disproportionate retribution at its finest. Jeffy tricks Mario into going outside, then locks him out so he can steal the cake. He locks all the doors and traps Mario outside. In this video, Jeffy clearly has malicious intent, and knows EXACTLY what he's doing. Mario is locked outside in the cold, trying everything he can to get back inside. And then the Brooklyn Guy shows up, and when he shows up in a Jeffy video, you immediately know Mario is in for a bad time. The Brooklyn Officer thinks that Mario is trying to break into the house, and when he talks to Jeffy about it, the little bastard lies and says he's never seen Mario before in his life. Of course the Brooklyn Guy takes Jeffy's word over Mario's and threatens to arrest him if he ever goes near his OWN HOUSE again. Mario is rightfully PISSED at this point, mumbling threats to assault and murder Jeffy, and honestly, after everything Jeffy's done to him, it's hard to blame him for wanting revenge. He tries to get inside through the air vents, and ends up crashing down on the floor, seemingly unconscious. Jeffy sees Mario lying on the floor, and, infuriatingly, grabs him and LITERALLY THROWS HIM BACK OUTSIDE WITHOUT A WORD. Eventually, Mario BEGS Jeffy to just let him inside, which Jeffy refuses to do unless Mario gets him more chocolate cake. So Mario does get another chocolate cake...Which Mario hides in so that he can get inside. When Mario pops out of the cake, he chases Jeffy in a rage...And gets locked out AGAIN. And of COURSE it ends with him getting arrested and Jeffy getting off scott-free for his actions, because Logan REFUSES to freaking PUNISH this kid for the awful things he does. This is honestly the video that cemented my absolute LOATHING of Jeffy as a character. He's nothing more than a braindead, unfunny little sociopath that exists for the sole purpose of making Mario's life a complete and utter nightmare, and he's WELL AWARE of that fact. I am very disappointed in Logan. I thought he would have known better after the last time he made a video where Mario was unfairly tormented because of Jeffy...

to:

* [=TomPhanto=]: As much as I enjoy the plush videos of WebVideo/SuperMarioLogan, I did not like "Jeffy's Bad Word!" at all. It's about Jeffy, a mentally handicapped kid who was dumped on Mario's doorstep in "Mario The Babysitter!" and has now become one of the most recurring characters, second only to Bowser Jr. I personally dislike Jeffy episodes because most of them are just making [[OnlySaneMan Mario]] a CosmicPlaything. The episode starts off with Mario driving to Walmart and he yells at a homeless guy that gets in his way, accidentally calling him a "faggot". Jeffy then starts saying it because he likes the word. And as expected, the episode is about Mario getting into trouble because Jeffy won't stop saying "faggot". What makes this a [=DMoS=] for me is what happens at the end. Mario gives Jeffy a spanking because he wouldn't stop saying "faggot". Mario is arrested, [[WronglyAccused accused of child molestation]], and is registered as a felon and sex offender, all just for trying to discipline Jeffy. I know Mario's supposed to be a ButtMonkey in this show, but I felt the episode went [[DudeNotFunny way too far far]] with the abuse.
** MetaMaster54610: You'd think Logan would have learned his lesson from the fiasco Jeffy's Bad Word caused. He knew full well how loathed that video was, so you'd think he'd know better than to create Jeffy's Bad Word 2.0 in the form of 'Locked Out'. The plot of the video is that Mario is trying to get Jeffy to eat his peas, promising him chocolate cake if he eats his peas. Rather than eating his peas, Jeffy pours them onto his high chair seat and tries to lie to Mario about it. When Mario rightfully denies him chocolate cake for not actually eating his dinner, Jeffy throws a tantrum. Admittedly, it was a dick move to have Mario eat a piece of chocolate cake in front of Jeffy, but what happens next is disproportionate retribution at its finest. Jeffy tricks Mario into going outside, then locks him out so he can steal the cake. He locks all the doors and traps Mario outside. In this video, Jeffy clearly has malicious intent, and knows EXACTLY ''exactly'' what he's doing. Mario is locked outside in the cold, trying everything he can to get back inside. And then the Brooklyn Guy shows up, and when he shows up in a Jeffy video, you immediately know Mario is in for a bad time. The Brooklyn Officer thinks that Mario is trying to break into the house, and when he talks to Jeffy about it, the little bastard lies and says he's never seen Mario before in his life. Of course the Brooklyn Guy takes Jeffy's word over Mario's and threatens to arrest him if he ever goes near his OWN HOUSE ''own house'' again. Mario is rightfully PISSED ''pissed'' at this point, mumbling threats to assault and murder Jeffy, and honestly, after everything Jeffy's done to him, it's hard to blame him for wanting revenge. He tries to get inside through the air vents, and ends up crashing down on the floor, seemingly unconscious. Jeffy sees Mario lying on the floor, and, infuriatingly, grabs him and LITERALLY THROWS HIM BACK OUTSIDE WITHOUT A WORD. ''literally throws him back outside without a word''. Eventually, Mario BEGS ''begs'' Jeffy to just let him inside, which Jeffy refuses to do unless Mario gets him more chocolate cake. So Mario does get another chocolate cake...Which Mario hides in so that he can get inside. When Mario pops out of the cake, he chases Jeffy in a rage...And gets locked out AGAIN. ''again''. And of COURSE ''course'' it ends with him getting arrested and Jeffy getting off scott-free for his actions, because Logan REFUSES ''refuses'' to freaking PUNISH ''punish'' this kid for the awful things he does. This is honestly the video that cemented my absolute LOATHING ''loathing'' of Jeffy as a character. He's nothing more than a braindead, unfunny little sociopath that exists for the sole purpose of making Mario's life a complete and utter nightmare, and he's WELL AWARE ''well aware'' of that fact. I am very disappointed in Logan. I thought he would have known better after the last time he made a video where Mario was unfairly tormented because of Jeffy...



* Tropers/TommyTiger: There's an awful video on the internet. It revolves about {{WesternAnimation/Tom|and Jerry}} killing Jerry (this video is so messed up I'm not even providing a link!). I don't find Jerry to be mean, unlike other people, but I can understand why some people think of that. It shows Jerry getting killed by Tom with an axe, leading to [[NightmareFuel a pool of blood (no joking) covering him (Jerry)]]. In other words, Jerry gets brutally killed by [[RonTheDeathEater Tom]]. Without a trace of GoryDiscretionShot. [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality And this is treated as a good thing!]] So this video basically implies that [[JerkassWoobie the poor mouse]] deserves to die [[DisproportionateRetribution just because he defends himself from Tom with more meanness than should]]. [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even canon Tom would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the Tom in this video to slaughter Jerry like this because [[FelonyMisdemeanor he (mostly understandably) pesters him]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's totally a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I will never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in that person's criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). This crosses both BlackComedy and AuthorTract, going more into "So funny, I forgot to laugh" territory. Even I'd draw the line at, let say, WesternAnimation/PeppaPig getting her head slammed into a coat hanger, causing her to become paralyzed, then her chest cut open and her still-beating heart being ripped out until she bleeds to death.

to:

* Tropers/TommyTiger: There's an awful video on the internet. It revolves about {{WesternAnimation/Tom|and Jerry}} killing Jerry (this video is so messed up I'm not even providing a link!). I don't find Jerry to be mean, unlike other people, but I can understand why some people think of that. It shows Jerry getting killed by Tom with an axe, leading to [[NightmareFuel a pool of blood (no joking) covering him (Jerry)]]. In other words, Jerry gets brutally killed by [[RonTheDeathEater Tom]]. Without a trace of GoryDiscretionShot. [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality And this is treated as a good thing!]] So this video basically implies that [[JerkassWoobie the poor mouse]] deserves to die [[DisproportionateRetribution just because he defends himself from Tom with more meanness than should]]. [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even canon Tom would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the Tom in this video to slaughter Jerry like this because [[FelonyMisdemeanor he (mostly understandably) pesters him]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's totally a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I will never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in that person's criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). This crosses both BlackComedy and AuthorTract, going more into "So funny, I forgot to laugh" DudeNotFunny territory. Even I'd draw the line at, let say, WesternAnimation/PeppaPig getting her head slammed into a coat hanger, causing her to become paralyzed, then her chest cut open and her still-beating heart being ripped out until she bleeds to death.



** Tropers/{{TommyTiger}}: I absolutely agree. Being Greek, I have read multiple NostalgiaFilter-related comments in Greek dubs of cartoons that came out in the 2000's or earlier in my country (like somebody [[{{Jerkass}} outright stating he'll never let his own children watch these so-called "abominations"]] just because he doesn't like post-2000's cartoons, or someone dropping a ClusterFBomb against said cartoons, which is just offensive) to begin with! And Adam forgot there are also well-received cartoons out nowadays (''WesternAnimation/PhineasAndFerb'', ''WesternAnimation/GravityFalls'', ''WesternAnimation/StevenUniverse'', ''WesternAnimation/WanderOverYonder'', ''WesternAnimation/RegularShow'', ''WesternAnimation/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball'', ''WesternAnimation/AdventureTime'' and ''WesternAnimation/TheLegendOfKorra'' being good examples) and cartoons that came out during his childhood were also bad for the sake of his FantasticRacism. The worst, though, is his [[SmallNameBigEgo pretentiousess]] about the whole thing.
22nd Mar '17 3:51:21 PM Sammettik
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/{{theenglishman}}: I know this will be an unpopular opinion, but to me, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMI1-DDklqE Character Assassination: Authorized]]'' represents the absolute nadir of the channel, and is still their only wrongpurae I can't endure in full. slowbeef's, well, beef with ''VideoGame/MetroidOtherM'' is not undeserved, and while his rants about the game in his LetsPlay of ''VideoGame/MetroidPrime3Corruption'' [[FranchiseOriginalSin were lengthy, passionate and vicious]], [[HandWave it could be chalked up to knee-jerk outrage because he had just finished Other M before starting his playthrough of Prime 3]]. But seeing slowbeef going on a ''very'' personal rant against DarthWiki/FallenCreator Yoshio Sakamoto for two hours ''a full year'' after having last played ''Other M'' was not so endearing, showcasing the worst traits of WebVideo/{{Retsupurae}}'s early work back when they would attack LPers directly. The few jokes that manage to work (mostly courtesy of Diabetus) have no impact because slowbeef just '''will not shut up''' about his hate-boner for Sakamoto, no matter how much the man deserves it. When we already have [[WebVideo/TwoBestFriendsPlay Mat, Pat and Woolie's]] [[https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL72A90C88878A43B7 excellent (and much funnier) video series]] covering the exact same points about ''Other M'''s BadWriting and UnfortunateImplications, without once referring to Sakamoto as a functional illiterate, this video has no reason to exist.

to:

** Tropers/{{theenglishman}}: I know this will be an unpopular opinion, but to me, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMI1-DDklqE Character Assassination: Authorized]]'' represents the absolute nadir of the channel, and is still their only wrongpurae I can't endure in full. slowbeef's, well, beef with ''VideoGame/MetroidOtherM'' is not undeserved, and while his rants about the game in his LetsPlay of ''VideoGame/MetroidPrime3Corruption'' [[FranchiseOriginalSin were lengthy, passionate and vicious]], [[HandWave it could be chalked up to knee-jerk outrage because he had just finished Other M before starting his playthrough of Prime 3]]. But seeing slowbeef going on a ''very'' personal rant against DarthWiki/FallenCreator Yoshio Sakamoto for two hours ''a full year'' after having last played ''Other M'' was not so endearing, showcasing the worst traits of WebVideo/{{Retsupurae}}'s early work back when they would attack LPers directly. The few jokes that manage to work (mostly courtesy of Diabetus) have no impact because slowbeef just '''will will not shut up''' up about his hate-boner for Sakamoto, no matter how much the man deserves it. When we already have [[WebVideo/TwoBestFriendsPlay Mat, Pat and Woolie's]] [[https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL72A90C88878A43B7 excellent (and much funnier) video series]] covering the exact same points about ''Other M'''s BadWriting and UnfortunateImplications, without once referring to Sakamoto as a functional illiterate, this video has no reason to exist.



* Tropers/{{Catmuto}}: With Faulerro's ''[[WebVideo/DanganRonpaAbridgedThing DRAT]]'', I overall enjoyed the few episodes he brought out to date. They made fun of the game and even pointed out things that always bothered me, and also gave the characters alterations or emphasis on their personalities. My [=DMoS=], though, is in Episode 4 when the subject of [[spoiler: Fujisaki Chihiro's gender]] is brought up. Monokuma holds up a sign that says that it will not be further discussed, as Tumblr would get angry at the creator. This could count as a [=DMoS=] to every person on Tumblr who would actually begin to rage at the topic mentioned in the spoiler, but the fact that Faulerro's videos have repeatedly put emphasis on this, bugs me. It never was much of a question to begin with (those who claim otherwise would mostly fall under the MisaimedFandom side) and his emphasizing like he cares a lot what Tumblr people say comes across as him trying way too hard to be 'politically correct' on this subject matter, including the insistence on referring to the character as 'they' instead of gender-pronouns post-revelation.

to:

* Tropers/{{Catmuto}}: With Faulerro's ''[[WebVideo/DanganRonpaAbridgedThing DRAT]]'', I overall enjoyed the few episodes he brought out to date. They made fun of the game and even pointed out things that always bothered me, and also gave the characters alterations or emphasis on their personalities. My [=DMoS=], though, is in Episode 4 when the subject of [[spoiler: Fujisaki Chihiro's gender]] is brought up. Monokuma holds up a sign that says that it will not be further discussed, as Tumblr would get angry at the creator. This could count as a [=DMoS=] to every person on Tumblr who would actually begin to rage at the topic mentioned in the spoiler, but the fact that Faulerro's videos have repeatedly put emphasis on this, bugs me. It never was much of a question to begin with (those who claim otherwise would mostly fall under the MisaimedFandom side) and his emphasizing like he cares a lot what Tumblr people say comes across as him trying way too hard to be 'politically correct' "politically correct" on this subject matter, including the insistence on referring to the character as 'they' instead of gender-pronouns post-revelation.



* Tropers/{{taylorkerekes}}: I enjoy watching WebVideo/TheCartoonHero, as lot of his videos are rather interesting and informative, but his absolute worst moment in my book deals with his Top 20 Most Hated Characters video, particularparticularly Lucy Van Pelt's entry. Now while I can be perfectly understand this character being on anybody's list of characters they despise, even though she is one of my favorite {{Peanuts}} characters, the Hero really goes over the line when he gets to at least two comeuppances that Lucy has received over the years, from Charlie Brown turning invisible on her so he can kick the football (which to me is up for a moral debate) to [[WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy Peter Griffin]] beating her up, the latter of which the Hero declares in a rather devious-sounding tone: "That is so satisfying!" Hold on a goddamn second--You actually enjoyed that? You actually think that even [[WouldHurtAChild children should receive such harsh punishments from grown adults?!!]] I don't care if it's just a cartoon! Seeing Lucy getting beat up by a grown man, no matter how bitchy others say she is, is just as bad as seeing [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wl9y3SIPt7o Judge William Adams mercilessly beat his daughter with a belt]]!

to:

* Tropers/{{taylorkerekes}}: I enjoy watching WebVideo/TheCartoonHero, ''WebVideo/TheCartoonHero'', as lot of his videos are rather interesting and informative, but his absolute worst moment in my book deals with his Top 20 Most Hated Characters video, particularparticularly particularly Lucy Van Pelt's entry. Now while I can be perfectly understand this character being on anybody's list of characters they despise, even though she is one of my favorite {{Peanuts}} characters, the Hero really goes over the line when he gets to at least two comeuppances that Lucy has received over the years, from Charlie Brown turning invisible on her so he can kick the football (which to me is up for a moral debate) to [[WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy Peter Griffin]] beating her up, the latter of which the Hero declares in a rather devious-sounding tone: "That is so satisfying!" Hold on a goddamn second--You actually enjoyed that? You actually think that even [[WouldHurtAChild children should receive such harsh punishments from grown adults?!!]] I don't care if it's just a cartoon! Seeing Lucy getting beat up by a grown man, no matter how bitchy others say she is, is just as bad as seeing [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wl9y3SIPt7o Judge William Adams mercilessly beat his daughter with a belt]]!



** Troper/{{Knightofbalance}}: [[http://antcow.deviantart.com/art/Tifa-chronicles-chap-3-part-1-Punch-war-577598210 This]] and it's two sequels. It's sadistic, cruel, demonizes one character and defiles the other. The only thing it has going for it is that it's well made but that's because it's a comission, meaning the author paid someone to do this. '''(Sigh)'''.

to:

** Troper/{{Knightofbalance}}: [[http://antcow.deviantart.com/art/Tifa-chronicles-chap-3-part-1-Punch-war-577598210 This]] and it's two sequels. It's sadistic, cruel, demonizes one character and defiles the other. The only thing it has going for it is that it's well made but that's because it's a comission, meaning the author paid someone to do this. '''(Sigh)'''.
22nd Mar '17 3:46:45 PM Sammettik
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/{{Gotgunpowder}}: The time he got incredibly offended over the HandOfFate Dealer making a fat joke (Referring to a ring that does something to your food and gold: "Fat and poor, an unusual combination"). I'd normally understand it (to a degree) but it was apparently so irredeemable that he outright banned people disagreeing with him, including long time, dedicated fans, ''and even boasted about this in the comments''. Way to completely alienate your fanbase, Crab.

to:

* Tropers/{{Gotgunpowder}}: The time he got incredibly offended over the HandOfFate Dealer making a fat joke (Referring to a ring that does something to your food and gold: "Fat and poor, an unusual combination"). I'd normally understand it (to a degree) but it was apparently so irredeemable that he outright banned people disagreeing with him, including long time, dedicated fans, ''and and even boasted about this in the comments''.comments. Way to completely alienate your fanbase, Crab.



* Butter: The ''"5 WORST fanbases"'' video. Due to the fact that there are so many terrible fanbases to choose from and so many things that need to be said, the video was basically guaranteed to be awesome, especially since IHE has a history of well-done rants on fans. And what does he do with this amazing concept, that was basically guarenteed to be awesome? He runs it in the ground. [softreturn] First, he makes up three rules to judge how bad these fanbases are. Isn't the whole point of IHE that all his videos are based on his opinions and are not ment to be taken as objectively true or false statements, him trying to back up his placement is going against that and renders his defence of everything just being his opinion null and void, especially since rule #1 and #3 themselves boil down to "it's muh 'pinion". The second rule isn't really legit either. It defines two criterias, how much results you find for the fanbase at r34 and how quickly you cringe when you look at fanart on deviantart. Both criteria are arbitrary; how much results you find at r34 is directly proportional to the franchises popularity (IHE even points that out in the very first entry) and thus irrelevant to the fanbases quality (For example, by that logic RealLife has the worst fanbase somehow), and 'how quickly you cringe' is an extremely trite statement that doesn't really have any meaning. [softreturn] His first entry are gamers, which is incredibly redundant because both VideoGame/SonicTheHedgehog and VideoGame/FiveNightsAtFreddys are video games and are also on the list. His reasons are also very hypocritical; he rants about how gamers will go out of their way to rant about things they know they won't like, just to belittle it, because that's the very thing his own channel is about. He also claims that they are 'entitled', which is a meaningless statement since this is one of those words that don't mean anything without context, context he never gives. [softreturn] Number four is anime, and the very first thing he says about it is that he doesn't know anything about it. Great. He doesn't even bring up a point against the anime fandom. He just cracks a contextless joke about some guy called James and how James ruined his live. That's it. He also doesn't bring up his second rule again, he doesn't even lampshade it this time, he just drops it. [softreturn] Number three is Sonic. Like the anime segment, it feels really rushed, but this time, instead of abandoning rule 2, the entire segment just consists of it. The segment goes like this: Here's the number of images Sonic has on r34, here the number on deviant art. These pictures are cringeworthy *shows pictures that are obvious jokes like a Shadow x Shrek pairing and a picture of a toilet looking like Sonic* [softreturn] Number two are bronies. This is probably the least bad entry on his list, but that doesn't mean it's not flawed. His first complaint is that bronies are 'obsessed', which is another context- and meaningless statement. Another complaint is that there are costumes for it. So all popular media in existance, including Real Life suck, because there are costumes of their characters? He also uses rule 2 again, but it goes against his placement of this fandom. MLP has less results than Sonic. If the only somewhat objective rule states that the Sonic fandom is worse than the MLP one, why is MLP higher on the list? [softreturn] Number one is [=FNaF=]. The first point of his is that people should shut up about it and there are too many videos one YouTube about it. IHE made multiple vidoes about it, talk about hypocricy. His next point is that people are playing it's creepyness down and thus going against the point of it bring a horror game. This is a phenomenon that is present in every media of the horror genre ever. It's a huge double standard to act like the flaws of an entire genre are caused by one fandom; why is it something unusual that most of [=FNaF=]-fan-media are not scary on their own, when the exact same thing is the case for things like Silent Hill, etc., you name it.

to:

* Butter: The ''"5 WORST fanbases"'' video. Due to the fact that there are so many terrible fanbases to choose from and so many things that need to be said, the video was basically guaranteed to be awesome, especially since IHE has a history of well-done rants on fans. And what does he do with this amazing concept, that was basically guarenteed guaranteed to be awesome? He runs it in the ground. [softreturn] First, he makes up three rules to judge how bad these fanbases are. Isn't the whole point of IHE that all his videos are based on his opinions and are not ment to be taken as objectively true or false statements, him trying to back up his placement is going against that and renders his defence of everything just being his opinion null and void, especially since rule #1 and #3 themselves boil down to "it's muh 'pinion". The second rule isn't really legit either. It defines two criterias, how much results you find for the fanbase at r34 and how quickly you cringe when you look at fanart on deviantart. Both criteria are arbitrary; how much results you find at r34 is directly proportional to the franchises popularity (IHE even points that out in the very first entry) and thus irrelevant to the fanbases quality (For example, by that logic RealLife has the worst fanbase somehow), and 'how quickly you cringe' is an extremely trite statement that doesn't really have any meaning. [softreturn] His first entry are gamers, which is incredibly redundant because both VideoGame/SonicTheHedgehog and VideoGame/FiveNightsAtFreddys are video games and are also on the list. His reasons are also very hypocritical; he rants about how gamers will go out of their way to rant about things they know they won't like, just to belittle it, because that's the very thing his own channel is about. He also claims that they are 'entitled', which is a meaningless statement since this is one of those words that don't mean anything without context, context he never gives. [softreturn] Number four is anime, and the very first thing he says about it is that he doesn't know anything about it. Great. He doesn't even bring up a point against the anime fandom. He just cracks a contextless joke about some guy called James and how James ruined his live. That's it. He also doesn't bring up his second rule again, he doesn't even lampshade it this time, he just drops it. [softreturn] Number three is Sonic. Like the anime segment, it feels really rushed, but this time, instead of abandoning rule 2, the entire segment just consists of it. The segment goes like this: Here's the number of images Sonic has on r34, here the number on deviant art. These pictures are cringeworthy *shows pictures that are obvious jokes like a Shadow x Shrek pairing and a picture of a toilet looking like Sonic* [softreturn] Number two are bronies. This is probably the least bad entry on his list, but that doesn't mean it's not flawed. His first complaint is that bronies are 'obsessed', which is another context- and meaningless statement. Another complaint is that there are costumes for it. So all popular media in existance, including Real Life suck, because there are costumes of their characters? He also uses rule 2 again, but it goes against his placement of this fandom. MLP has less results than Sonic. If the only somewhat objective rule states that the Sonic fandom is worse than the MLP one, why is MLP higher on the list? [softreturn] Number one is [=FNaF=]. The first point of his is that people should shut up about it and there are too many videos one YouTube about it. IHE made multiple vidoes about it, talk about hypocricy.hypocrisy. His next point is that people are playing it's creepyness down and thus going against the point of it bring a horror game. This is a phenomenon that is present in every media of the horror genre ever. It's a huge double standard to act like the flaws of an entire genre are caused by one fandom; why is it something unusual that most of [=FNaF=]-fan-media are not scary on their own, when the exact same thing is the case for things like Silent Hill, etc., you name it.
22nd Mar '17 5:29:36 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/TommyTiger: There's an awful video on the internet. It revolves about {{WesternAnimation/Tom|and Jerry}} killing Jerry (this video is so messed up I'm not even providing a link!). I don't find Jerry to be mean, unlike other people, but I can understand why some people think of that. It shows Jerry getting killed by Tom with an axe, leading to [[NightmareFuel a pool of blood (no joking) covering him (Jerry)]]. In other words, Jerry gets brutally killed by [[RonTheDeathEater Tom]]. Without a trace of GoryDiscretionShot. [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality And this is treated as a good thing!]] So this video basically implies that [[JerkassWoobie the poor mouse]] deserves to die [[DisproportionateRetribution just because he defends himself from Tom with more meanness than should]]. [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even canon Tom would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the Tom in this video to slaughter Jerry like this because [[FelonyMisdemeanor he (mostly understandably) pesters him]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's totally a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I will never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in that person's criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). This crosses both BlackComedy and AuthorTract, going more into "So funny, I forgot to laugh" territory. Even I'd find the death of my personal {{Scrapp|y}}ies scary and totally not funny at all.

to:

* Tropers/TommyTiger: There's an awful video on the internet. It revolves about {{WesternAnimation/Tom|and Jerry}} killing Jerry (this video is so messed up I'm not even providing a link!). I don't find Jerry to be mean, unlike other people, but I can understand why some people think of that. It shows Jerry getting killed by Tom with an axe, leading to [[NightmareFuel a pool of blood (no joking) covering him (Jerry)]]. In other words, Jerry gets brutally killed by [[RonTheDeathEater Tom]]. Without a trace of GoryDiscretionShot. [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality And this is treated as a good thing!]] So this video basically implies that [[JerkassWoobie the poor mouse]] deserves to die [[DisproportionateRetribution just because he defends himself from Tom with more meanness than should]]. [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even canon Tom would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the Tom in this video to slaughter Jerry like this because [[FelonyMisdemeanor he (mostly understandably) pesters him]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's totally a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I will never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in that person's criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). This crosses both BlackComedy and AuthorTract, going more into "So funny, I forgot to laugh" territory. Even I'd find draw the death of my personal {{Scrapp|y}}ies scary line at, let say, WesternAnimation/PeppaPig getting her head slammed into a coat hanger, causing her to become paralyzed, then her chest cut open and totally not funny at all.her still-beating heart being ripped out until she bleeds to death.
20th Mar '17 6:25:24 PM Bengson26
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/Rossmallo : IHateEverything 's "5 EPIC Ways To Be a YouTube Celebrity! ✔". It's bad enough that at a fair few times it's coming off as whining about the copyright issues he's going through. It's bad enough that he is so utterly openly hostile and confrontational to everything involved. It's bad enough that it's all said in such over the top smugness that it destroys his usual level headed tone. But no, what makes all of this utterly infuriating is "I hold nothing personally against any of the people mentioned, I guess". ....Yeah, no. He shows multiple examples of certain youtubers in the background, calls some out by name, and even insults one of the previously mentioned people in the outtro, after he's said this. While yes, some of the criticisms are valid, this whole bit at the end just makes it come off as "Fuck you, but not
really." Either stand your ground and embrace the backlash or don't say it at all.

to:

* Tropers/Rossmallo : IHateEverything 's "5 EPIC Ways To Be a YouTube Celebrity! ✔". It's bad enough that at a fair few times it's coming off as whining about the copyright issues he's going through. It's bad enough that he is so utterly openly hostile and confrontational to everything involved. It's bad enough that it's all said in such over the top smugness that it destroys his usual level headed tone. But no, what makes all of this utterly infuriating is "I hold nothing personally against any of the people mentioned, I guess". ....Yeah, no. He shows multiple examples of certain youtubers in the background, calls some out by name, and even insults one of the previously mentioned people in the outtro, after he's said this. While yes, some of the criticisms are valid, this whole bit at the end just makes it come off as "Fuck you, but not
not really." Either stand your ground and embrace the backlash or don't say it at all.
19th Mar '17 5:56:32 PM TheNerfGuy
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** GreenFablesInverness: And come season four this show has not gotten any better in its treatment of its characters. While it’s meant to be a throwaway joke, Ruby laughing at Juane’s bunny hoodie is frankly insulting to my intelligence because it is a regression of character development the past few seasons have worked so hard to deconstruct the traditional but toxic stereotyping. One, Juane’s masculinity, or rather lack thereof, is the butt monkey yet again when a key part of his S1 character arc was getting away from poisonous macho man mindset. It’s what almost got him killed against Grimm biting off more than he could chew. And who help him confront his weakness and move on towards self-improvement? Oh yeah, Pyrrha, the girl he cared for and lost and we see a moment later used his memento of her being integrated into his weapon’s shield so a piece of her spirit will remain fighting alongside Team JNRP. The girl who accepted Juane for who he was and was everything she wanted in life; somebody that didn’t put her on a pedestal instead treating her like a real person. As if laughing at Juane wasn’t bad enough, Ruby laughing at the cereal icon is even worse because it’s a brown bunny and who else is a brown bunny? Fan favorite Velvet Scarlatina! The girl who had to fight tooth and nail to prove despite her cute looks she was as lethal as any other huntress. Her weapon is a fusion of every kickass weapon we’ve seen Beacon’s students use. She copies their fighting style into her own combat tactics to take on a horde of Grimm like the badass she is. That her weapon was Monty’s favorite. Remember the faunus girl who got picked on in season 1 by Cardin and his team for her bunny ears to demonstrate what kind of jerks they were and the discrimination faunus face? Yeah, the same group of bullies that would go on to antagonize and blackmail Juane! Yeah, they can make the excuse the deaths of Pyrrha and Penny were “planned from the start to demonstrate no one in safe in the world of Remnant” until they’re blue but this is just mounting evidence that RT doesn’t make an effort to respect their characters, the audience’s intelligence, or even their own writing integrity.
17th Mar '17 11:37:36 AM ldelavina3
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* ldelavina3: It's no secret that every web animation series has its rough times, small or big. ''WebAnimation/{{Sonic Shorts}}'' is no exception, which brings us to their [=DMoS=] to me. The "How To Create Your Own Sonic Fan Character" bit from Volume 6. It pretty much implies that everyone who has made a fan character as lazy, unoriginal people. I know that there are a lot of poorly-made fan characters, but this just feels like a [[TakeThat giant middle finger]] to fan character creators and an unfunny one at that.
** DokemonStudios: Now, I enjoy ''WebAnimation/{{Sonic Shorts}}'', and there's always at least one or two shorts that would make me laugh a lot even in the weaker episodes. But the last short in Volume 3 just left a bad taste in my mouth, specifically the ending where after Froggy leaves Big the Cat, [[SuicideasComedy Big hangs himself with his own fishing rod!]] Disregarding the fact that the string or that tree branch would break, due to Big's weight, [[NightmareFuel it's actually more horrifying than the Tails doll shorts!]] Seriously, [[TheScrappy I know people don't like Big,]] and neither do I, but that ending was just unnecessary, and mean spirited, and can just be easily cut out.

to:

* ldelavina3: It's no secret that every web animation series has its rough times, small or big. ''WebAnimation/{{Sonic Shorts}}'' is no exception, which brings us to their [=DMoS=] to me. The "How To Create Your Own Sonic Fan Character" bit from Volume 6. It pretty much implies that everyone who has made a fan character as lazy, unoriginal people. I know that there are a lot of poorly-made fan characters, but this just feels like a [[TakeThat giant middle finger]] to fan character creators and an unfunny one at that.
**
DokemonStudios: Now, I enjoy ''WebAnimation/{{Sonic Shorts}}'', and there's always at least one or two shorts that would make me laugh a lot even in the weaker episodes. But the last short in Volume 3 just left a bad taste in my mouth, specifically the ending where after Froggy leaves Big the Cat, [[SuicideasComedy Big hangs himself with his own fishing rod!]] Disregarding the fact that the string or that tree branch would break, due to Big's weight, [[NightmareFuel it's actually more horrifying than the Tails doll shorts!]] Seriously, [[TheScrappy I know people don't like Big,]] and neither do I, but that ending was just unnecessary, and mean spirited, and can just be easily cut out.
16th Mar '17 1:06:55 AM ImSpidey2
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/ImSpidey2: I'm not that much of a fan of [=TechRax=]. While I do like some of his videos, I always found his commentary a bit annoying. I unsubscribed to him today however, upon seeing WebVideo/{{Pyrocynical}} trash his latest video, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arVHjiNLDXY Casting Cockroaches + iPhone 7 Plus Molten Aluminum!]]''. NauseaFuel aside, Tara (Tech himself) seems completely ignorant to the cockroaches' suffering (which, by the way, [[HellIsThatNoise you can hear their squeaking as they burn]]), even snickering a few times at them. I always found Tech to be a bit stupid, but this made him hit, as Pyro said, "a new low". And at the end, [[BlatantLies he has the gull to say that they're "asleep" at the end]]. [[{{Squick}} As one just clings to life in the corner of the tray.]] Yeah, you know what? Fuck you, Tara. You just lost a sub, and hopefully thousands more will follow after watching this twisted excuse of "entertainment".

to:

* Tropers/ImSpidey2: I'm not that much of a fan of [=TechRax=]. While I do like some of his videos, I always found his commentary a bit annoying. I unsubscribed to him today however, upon seeing WebVideo/{{Pyrocynical}} trash his latest video, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arVHjiNLDXY Casting Cockroaches + iPhone 7 Plus in Molten Aluminum!]]''. NauseaFuel aside, Tara (Tech himself) seems completely ignorant to the cockroaches' suffering (which, by the way, [[HellIsThatNoise you can hear their squeaking as they burn]]), even snickering a few times at them. I always found Tech to be a bit stupid, but this made him hit, as Pyro said, "a new low". And at the end, [[BlatantLies he has the gull to say that they're "asleep" at the end]]. [[{{Squick}} As one just clings to life in the corner of the tray.]] Yeah, you know what? Fuck you, Tara. You just lost a sub, and hopefully thousands more will follow after watching this twisted excuse of "entertainment".
15th Mar '17 10:00:33 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* [=SenorCornholio=]: I have a small bone to pick with a throwaway line in the WebOriginal/CollegeHumor video, "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNlAZLCGLuU Luigi Finally Snaps]]". The plot of the video involves Luigi [[WhatTheHellHero calling out Mario for basically getting the spotlight while the green plumber always plays second fiddle]]. The video was perfectly fine for the most part, but what [[WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy really grinds my gears]] is this: Mario mentions he at least had VideoGame/LuigisMansion which Luigi says was terrible. Okay, fine; no problem. I like the game, but I can see why others don't. Then Mario says "Luigi, it's-a [[UsefulNotes/NintendoGameCube GameCube]]; all of those games were terrible". [[BigWhat What!?]] And the [=GameCube=] hate apparently doesn't stop with this video; I recall them often repeatedly bashing the system in several videos. Okay, first of all: all [=GameCube=] games are terrible? I don't know about you, but I had fond memories of playing my [=GameCube=], and several others did as well. I remember playing the heck out of VideoGame/SuperMarioSunshine, VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaTheWindWaker, [[VideoGame/SonicAdventure2 Sonic Adventure 2 Battle]], and VideoGame/PaperMarioTheThousandYearDoor. And that's not even going into [[VideoGame/MetroidPrime several other]] [[VideoGame/ResidentEvil6 games that I]] [[VideoGame/StarFoxAssault missed out on]]. In fact, a lot of these "terrible" games have become fan favorites in recent years; heck ''Wind Waker'' got an HD re-release on the UsefulNotes/WiiU. Really, it's like these guys only think that [[TheyChangedItNowItSucks even for the most arbitrary change, the game automatically sucks]]. Second, putting all [=GameCube=] games in the same category of awful is a stupid generalization. I never had any interest in the UsefulNotes/Xbox360; does that mean all Xbox 360 games are terrible because of that? No; it just means I never took an interest in it! Not every [=GameCube=] game is ''Aquaman: Battle For Atlantis'', and not every Xbox 360 game is VideoGame/SonicTheHedgehog2006. I may have merely mentioned this moment because I grew up with a [=GameCube=], but even if I wasn't a [=GameCube=] owner I would be headdesking so hard at this moment.

to:

* [=SenorCornholio=]: I have a small bone to pick with a throwaway line in the WebOriginal/CollegeHumor video, "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNlAZLCGLuU Luigi Finally Snaps]]". The plot of the video involves Luigi [[WhatTheHellHero calling out Mario for basically getting the spotlight while the green plumber always plays second fiddle]]. The video was perfectly fine for the most part, but what [[WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy really grinds my gears]] is this: Mario mentions he at least had VideoGame/LuigisMansion which Luigi says was terrible. Okay, fine; no problem. I like the game, but I can see why others don't. Then Mario says "Luigi, it's-a [[UsefulNotes/NintendoGameCube GameCube]]; all of those games were terrible". [[BigWhat What!?]] And the [=GameCube=] hate apparently doesn't stop with this video; I recall them often repeatedly bashing the system in several videos. Okay, first of all: all [=GameCube=] games are terrible? I don't know about you, but I had fond memories of playing my [=GameCube=], and several others did as well. I remember playing the heck out of VideoGame/SuperMarioSunshine, VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaTheWindWaker, [[VideoGame/SonicAdventure2 Sonic Adventure 2 Battle]], and VideoGame/PaperMarioTheThousandYearDoor. And that's not even going into [[VideoGame/MetroidPrime several other]] [[VideoGame/ResidentEvil6 [[VideoGame/ResidentEvil4 games that I]] [[VideoGame/StarFoxAssault missed out on]]. In fact, a lot of these "terrible" games have become fan favorites in recent years; heck ''Wind Waker'' got an HD re-release on the UsefulNotes/WiiU. Really, it's like these guys only think that [[TheyChangedItNowItSucks even for the most arbitrary change, the game automatically sucks]]. Second, putting all [=GameCube=] games in the same category of awful is a stupid generalization. I never had any interest in the UsefulNotes/Xbox360; does that mean all Xbox 360 games are terrible because of that? No; it just means I never took an interest in it! Not every [=GameCube=] game is ''Aquaman: Battle For Atlantis'', and not every Xbox 360 game is VideoGame/SonicTheHedgehog2006. I may have merely mentioned this moment because I grew up with a [=GameCube=], but even if I wasn't a [=GameCube=] owner I would be headdesking so hard at this moment.
15th Mar '17 9:49:47 PM WhoNeedsAMango
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** GreenFablesInverness: And come season four this show has not gotten any better in its treatment of its characters. While it’s meant to be a throwaway joke, Ruby laughing at Juane’s bunny hoodie is frankly insulting to my intelligence because it is a regression of character development the past few seasons have worked so hard to deconstruct the traditional but toxic stereotyping. One, Juane’s masculinity, or rather lack thereof, is the butt monkey yet again when a key part of his S1 character arc was getting away from poisonous macho man mindset. It’s what almost got him killed against Grimm biting off more than he could chew. And who help him confront his weakness and move on towards self-improvement? Oh yeah, Pyrrha, the girl he cared for and lost and we see a moment later used his memento of her being integrated into his weapon’s shield so a piece of her spirit will remain fighting alongside Team JNRP. The girl who accepted Juane for who he was and was everything she wanted in life; somebody that didn’t put her on a pedestal instead treating her like a real person. As if laughing at Juane wasn’t bad enough, Ruby laughing at the cereal icon is even worse because it’s a brown bunny and who else is a brown bunny? Fan favorite Velvet Scarlatina! The girl who had to fight tooth and nail to prove despite her cute looks she was as lethal as any other huntress. Her weapon is a fusion of every kickass weapon we’ve seen Beacon’s students use. She copies their fighting style into her own combat tactics to take on a horde of Grimm like the badass she is. That her weapon was Monty’s favorite. Remember the faunus girl who got picked on in season 1 by Cardin and his team for her bunny ears to demonstrate what kind of jerks they were and the discrimination faunus face? Yeah, the same group of bullies that would go on to antagonize and blackmail Juane! Yeah, they can make the excuse the deaths of Pyrrha and Penny were “planned from the start to demonstrate no one in safe in the world of Remnant” until they’re blue but this is just mounting evidence that RT doesn’t make an effort to respect their characters, the audience’s intelligence, or even their own writing integrity.
15th Mar '17 11:06:54 AM ImSpidey2
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/ImSpidey2: I'm not that much of a fan of [=TechRax=]. While I do like some of his videos, I always found his commentary a bit annoying. I unsubscribed to him today however, upon seeing WebVideo/{{Pyrocynical}} trash his latest video, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arVHjiNLDXY Casting Cockroaches + iPhone 7 Plus Molten Aluminum!]]''. NauseaFuel aside, Tara (Tech himself) seems completely ignorant to the cockroaches' suffering (which, by the way, [[HellIsThatNoise you can hear their squeaking as they burn]]), even snickering a few times at them. I always found Tech to be a bit stupid, but this made him hit, as Pyro said, "a new low". And at the end, [[BlatantLies he has the gull to say that they're "asleep" at the end]]. [[Squick As one just clings to life in the corner of the tray.]] Yeah, you know what? Fuck you, Tara. You just lost a sub, and hopefully thousands more will follow after watching this twisted excuse of "entertainment".

to:

* Tropers/ImSpidey2: I'm not that much of a fan of [=TechRax=]. While I do like some of his videos, I always found his commentary a bit annoying. I unsubscribed to him today however, upon seeing WebVideo/{{Pyrocynical}} trash his latest video, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arVHjiNLDXY Casting Cockroaches + iPhone 7 Plus Molten Aluminum!]]''. NauseaFuel aside, Tara (Tech himself) seems completely ignorant to the cockroaches' suffering (which, by the way, [[HellIsThatNoise you can hear their squeaking as they burn]]), even snickering a few times at them. I always found Tech to be a bit stupid, but this made him hit, as Pyro said, "a new low". And at the end, [[BlatantLies he has the gull to say that they're "asleep" at the end]]. [[Squick [[{{Squick}} As one just clings to life in the corner of the tray.]] Yeah, you know what? Fuck you, Tara. You just lost a sub, and hopefully thousands more will follow after watching this twisted excuse of "entertainment".
15th Mar '17 11:06:18 AM ImSpidey2
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* I'm not that much of a fan of [=TechRax=]. While I do like some of his videos, I always found his commentary a bit annoying. I unsubscribed to him today however, upon seeing WebVideo/{{Pyrocynical}} trash his latest video, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arVHjiNLDXY Casting Cockroaches + iPhone 7 Plus Molten Aluminum!]]''. NauseaFuel aside, Tara (Tech himself) seems completely ignorant to the cockroaches' suffering (which, by the way, [[HellIsThatNoise you can hear their squeaking as they burn]]), even snickering a few times at them. I always found Tech to be a bit stupid, but this made him hit, as Pyro said, "a new low". And at the end, [[BlatantLies he has the gull to say that they're "asleep" at the end]]. [[Squick As one just clings to life in the corner of the tray.]] Yeah, you know what? Fuck you, Tara. You just lost a sub, and hopefully thousands more will follow after watching this twisted excuse of "entertainment".

to:

* Tropers/ImSpidey2: I'm not that much of a fan of [=TechRax=]. While I do like some of his videos, I always found his commentary a bit annoying. I unsubscribed to him today however, upon seeing WebVideo/{{Pyrocynical}} trash his latest video, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arVHjiNLDXY Casting Cockroaches + iPhone 7 Plus Molten Aluminum!]]''. NauseaFuel aside, Tara (Tech himself) seems completely ignorant to the cockroaches' suffering (which, by the way, [[HellIsThatNoise you can hear their squeaking as they burn]]), even snickering a few times at them. I always found Tech to be a bit stupid, but this made him hit, as Pyro said, "a new low". And at the end, [[BlatantLies he has the gull to say that they're "asleep" at the end]]. [[Squick As one just clings to life in the corner of the tray.]] Yeah, you know what? Fuck you, Tara. You just lost a sub, and hopefully thousands more will follow after watching this twisted excuse of "entertainment".
15th Mar '17 11:02:08 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* I'm not that much of a fan of [=TechRax=]. While I do like some of his videos, I always found his commentary a bit annoying. I unsubscribed to him today however, upon seeing [[WebVideo/{{Pyrocynical}}]] trash his latest video, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arVHjiNLDXY Casting Cockroaches + iPhone 7 Plus Molten Aluminum!]]''. NauseaFuel aside, Tara (Tech himself) seems completely ignorant to the cockroaches' suffering (which, by the way, [[HellIsThatNoise you can hear their squeaking as they burn]]), even snickering a few times at them. I always found Tech to be a bit stupid, but this made him hit, as Pyro said, "a new low". And at the end, [[BlatantLies he has the gull to say that they're "asleep" at the end]]. [[Squick As one just clings to life in the corner of the tray.]] Yeah, you know what? Fuck you, Tara. You just lost a sub, and hopefully thousands more will follow after watching this twisted excuse of "entertainment".

to:

* I'm not that much of a fan of [=TechRax=]. While I do like some of his videos, I always found his commentary a bit annoying. I unsubscribed to him today however, upon seeing [[WebVideo/{{Pyrocynical}}]] WebVideo/{{Pyrocynical}} trash his latest video, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arVHjiNLDXY Casting Cockroaches + iPhone 7 Plus Molten Aluminum!]]''. NauseaFuel aside, Tara (Tech himself) seems completely ignorant to the cockroaches' suffering (which, by the way, [[HellIsThatNoise you can hear their squeaking as they burn]]), even snickering a few times at them. I always found Tech to be a bit stupid, but this made him hit, as Pyro said, "a new low". And at the end, [[BlatantLies he has the gull to say that they're "asleep" at the end]]. [[Squick As one just clings to life in the corner of the tray.]] Yeah, you know what? Fuck you, Tara. You just lost a sub, and hopefully thousands more will follow after watching this twisted excuse of "entertainment".
15th Mar '17 10:58:53 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* I'm not that much of a fan of [=TechRax=]. While I do like some of his videos, I always found his commentary a bit annoying. I unsubscribed to him today however, upon seeing [[WebVideo/Pyrocynical]] trash his latest video, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arVHjiNLDXY Casting Cockroaches + iPhone 7 Plus Molten Aluminum!]]''. NauseaFuel aside, Tara (Tech himself) seems completely ignorant to the cockroaches' suffering (which, by the way, [[HellIsThatNoise you can hear their squeaking as they burn]]), even snickering a few times at them. I always found Tech to be a bit stupid, but this made him hit, as Pyro said, "a new low". And at the end, [[BlatantLies he has the gull to say that they're "asleep" at the end]]. [[Squick As one just clings to life in the corner of the tray.]] Yeah, you know what? Fuck you, Tara. You just lost a sub, and hopefully thousands more will follow after watching this twisted excuse of "entertainment".

to:

* I'm not that much of a fan of [=TechRax=]. While I do like some of his videos, I always found his commentary a bit annoying. I unsubscribed to him today however, upon seeing [[WebVideo/Pyrocynical]] [[WebVideo/{{Pyrocynical}}]] trash his latest video, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arVHjiNLDXY Casting Cockroaches + iPhone 7 Plus Molten Aluminum!]]''. NauseaFuel aside, Tara (Tech himself) seems completely ignorant to the cockroaches' suffering (which, by the way, [[HellIsThatNoise you can hear their squeaking as they burn]]), even snickering a few times at them. I always found Tech to be a bit stupid, but this made him hit, as Pyro said, "a new low". And at the end, [[BlatantLies he has the gull to say that they're "asleep" at the end]]. [[Squick As one just clings to life in the corner of the tray.]] Yeah, you know what? Fuck you, Tara. You just lost a sub, and hopefully thousands more will follow after watching this twisted excuse of "entertainment".
15th Mar '17 12:30:49 AM eneuman96
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* eneuman96 Since I can't just call [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-Wn48geCJ8 Racist Mario]] a Dethroning Animated Short of Suck and call it a day, I'll try to break down the points as to why it's utterly terrible. Let's see...the unfunny shoehorned reference to [[Film/ThePhantomMenace The Phantom Menace]] and the shoehorned {{Franchise/Pokemon}} rape joke...thing that both [[BigLippedAlligatorMoment come right the fuck out of nowhere]]. The unfunny random disgusting violence that has no point at all (it doesn't even manage to be [[BloodyHilarious Bloody Hilarious]] either; it's just more gross and a bad attempt to shock than anything). The [[RuleOfThree unfunny]] lack of any real jokes. It certainly doesn't help that [[SeinfeldIsUnfunny making a violent Mario spoof in this day and age is like beating a dead horse]]. Oh, and the fact that it blatantly displays censored nudity in its thumbnail as a cheap clickbait tactic, [[SexSells which is almost certainly the reason it got so many views.]] One last thing: [[NonIndicativeName how is Mario racist anyway]]? Given that he tries to kill literally everyone on the track and not just the non-Nintendo characters, ''Genocidal Mario'' would be a far more fitting title. Hell, the title sounds like it could have been about Mario becoming bitter and prejudiced towards non-Nintendo characters over the years for stealing his thunder instead of just a batshit insane psychopath in a kart, [[TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot which would have made a far better short than this abomination]]. (EDIT: Looking back at this, I [[LateToThePunchline just realized]] that the "Racist" in the title is probably a pun on the fact that the characters are initially racing each other. Still doesn't change my opinion on everything else, though)
** SenorCornholio: I have recently warmed up to Racist Mario due to the voice clips being used in some of [[Machinima/Supermarioglitchy4sSuperMario64Bloopers SMG4's videos]] (such as [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wjb0FgQqpZA this one]]), but that doesn't change the fact that overall, this video is heavily flawed in more ways than one. I could go on about the unfunny jokes, the nonsensical plot, etc, but what I think makes the whole thing fall apart: the premise. Mario goes insane and starts killing everyone because of all the third-party characters in the current race. Why does this not work? Well firstly, because there has never been a third-party character in a main Mario Kart title. The DLC characters for Mario Kart 8 were all from other Nintendo franchises, and therefore first-party. Secondly, the characters themselves; [[VideoGame/SegaSuperstars Sonic may have been playable in several Sega-themed sports and racing titles]], but the only time he crossed over with Nintendo itself was in VideoGame/SuperSmashBros, which would have actually been a better setting due to [[Franchise/SonicTheHedgehog their]] [[VideoGame/MetalGear own]] [[Franchise/MegaMan selection]] [[VideoGame/PacMan of]] [[Franchise/StreetFighter third]]-[[VideoGame/FinalFantasyVII party]] [[{{VideoGame/Bayonetta}} characters]]. And even then, Knuckles wasn't even playable so that's out. It's like some of these franchises were listed all because of their racing titles, with [[Franchise/StarWars Anakin]] and [[VideoGame/CrashBandicoot Crash's head]] also being standout examples. Thirdly, speaking of Sony, was there an alternate universe I'm not aware of where Sony and Nintendo crossed over and [[VideoGame/LittleBigPlanet Sackboy]] and [[VideoGame/GodOfWar Kratos]] were put into karts? I'll admit that Kratos driving a tiny kart is a funny sight, but what's the point? Ironically, there's one crossover that I doubt Flashgitz even knows he got right, and that's Pac-Man's head on a spear, since he was playable in the Arcade GP games developed by Namco-Bandai. Other than that, the rest of the references are shallow at best and make absolutely no sense at worst. Now if you'll excuse me, I'm gonna go watch [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynKRJt4CDMY the version where all the violence is replaced with The Nutshack]]. It's somehow way better.

to:

* eneuman96 Since I can't just call [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-Wn48geCJ8 Racist Mario]] a Dethroning Animated Short of Suck and call it a day, I'll try to break down the points as to why it's utterly terrible. Let's see...the unfunny shoehorned reference to [[Film/ThePhantomMenace The Phantom Menace]] and the shoehorned {{Franchise/Pokemon}} rape joke...thing that both [[BigLippedAlligatorMoment come right the fuck out of nowhere]]. The unfunny random disgusting violence that has no point at all (it doesn't even manage to be [[BloodyHilarious Bloody Hilarious]] either; it's just more gross and a bad attempt to shock than anything). The [[RuleOfThree unfunny]] lack of any real jokes. It certainly doesn't help that [[SeinfeldIsUnfunny making a violent Mario spoof in this day and age is like beating a dead horse]]. Oh, and the fact that it blatantly displays censored nudity in its thumbnail as a cheap clickbait tactic, [[SexSells which is almost certainly the reason it got so many views.]] One last thing: [[NonIndicativeName how is Mario racist anyway]]? Given that he tries to kill literally everyone on the track and not just the non-Nintendo characters, ''Genocidal Mario'' would be a far more fitting title. Hell, the title sounds like it could have been about Mario becoming bitter and prejudiced towards non-Nintendo characters over the years for stealing his thunder instead of just a batshit insane psychopath in a kart, [[TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot which would have made a far better short than this abomination]]. (EDIT: Looking back at this, I [[LateToThePunchline just realized]] that the "Racist" in the title is probably a pun on the fact that the characters are initially racing each other. Still doesn't change my opinion on everything else, though)
**
SenorCornholio: I have recently warmed up to Racist Mario due to the voice clips being used in some of [[Machinima/Supermarioglitchy4sSuperMario64Bloopers SMG4's videos]] (such as [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wjb0FgQqpZA this one]]), but that doesn't change the fact that overall, this video is heavily flawed in more ways than one. I could go on about the unfunny jokes, the nonsensical plot, etc, but what I think makes the whole thing fall apart: the premise. Mario goes insane and starts killing everyone because of all the third-party characters in the current race. Why does this not work? Well firstly, because there has never been a third-party character in a main Mario Kart title. The DLC characters for Mario Kart 8 were all from other Nintendo franchises, and therefore first-party. Secondly, the characters themselves; [[VideoGame/SegaSuperstars Sonic may have been playable in several Sega-themed sports and racing titles]], but the only time he crossed over with Nintendo itself was in VideoGame/SuperSmashBros, which would have actually been a better setting due to [[Franchise/SonicTheHedgehog their]] [[VideoGame/MetalGear own]] [[Franchise/MegaMan selection]] [[VideoGame/PacMan of]] [[Franchise/StreetFighter third]]-[[VideoGame/FinalFantasyVII party]] [[{{VideoGame/Bayonetta}} characters]]. And even then, Knuckles wasn't even playable so that's out. It's like some of these franchises were listed all because of their racing titles, with [[Franchise/StarWars Anakin]] and [[VideoGame/CrashBandicoot Crash's head]] also being standout examples. Thirdly, speaking of Sony, was there an alternate universe I'm not aware of where Sony and Nintendo crossed over and [[VideoGame/LittleBigPlanet Sackboy]] and [[VideoGame/GodOfWar Kratos]] were put into karts? I'll admit that Kratos driving a tiny kart is a funny sight, but what's the point? Ironically, there's one crossover that I doubt Flashgitz even knows he got right, and that's Pac-Man's head on a spear, since he was playable in the Arcade GP games developed by Namco-Bandai. Other than that, the rest of the references are shallow at best and make absolutely no sense at worst. Now if you'll excuse me, I'm gonna go watch [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynKRJt4CDMY the version where all the violence is replaced with The Nutshack]]. It's somehow way better.



* Tropers/Rossmallo : IHateEverything 's "5 EPIC Ways To Be a YouTube Celebrity! ✔". It's bad enough that at a fair few times it's coming off as whining about the copyright issues he's going through. It's bad enough that he is so utterly openly hostile and confrontational to everything involved. It's bad enough that it's all said in such over the top smugness that it destroys his usual level headed tone. But no, what makes all of this utterly infuriating is "I hold nothing personally against any of the people mentioned, I guess". ....Yeah, no. He shows multiple examples of certain youtubers in the background, calls some out by name, and even insults one of the previously mentioned people in the outtro, after he's said this. While yes, some of the criticisms are valid, this whole bit at the end just makes it come off as "Fuck you, but not really." Either stand your ground and embrace the backlash or don't say it at all.

to:

* Tropers/Rossmallo : IHateEverything 's "5 EPIC Ways To Be a YouTube Celebrity! ✔". It's bad enough that at a fair few times it's coming off as whining about the copyright issues he's going through. It's bad enough that he is so utterly openly hostile and confrontational to everything involved. It's bad enough that it's all said in such over the top smugness that it destroys his usual level headed tone. But no, what makes all of this utterly infuriating is "I hold nothing personally against any of the people mentioned, I guess". ....Yeah, no. He shows multiple examples of certain youtubers in the background, calls some out by name, and even insults one of the previously mentioned people in the outtro, after he's said this. While yes, some of the criticisms are valid, this whole bit at the end just makes it come off as "Fuck you, but not not
really." Either stand your ground and embrace the backlash or don't say it at all.



* eneuman96: [[TheBestPageInTheUniverse Maddox's]] article [[http://thebestpageintheuniverse.net/c.cgi?u=math "Math doesn't suck, you do."]] Though I'm not normally a fan of Maddox's writing, I can at least respect his more intelligent arguments. This, on the other hand, is pure garbage. Firstly, he says that math is "exactly like cooking: just follow the recipe." Uh, no. If that were the case, famous chefs everywhere would have aced calculus. Even if both are based on following instructions, it's very possible that one may find one of those things less interesting than the other. He then goes on to imply that textbooks teach you everything about math you need to know for your classes, ergo it should be easy. Clearly he didn't go to the schools I or a large number of other students went to. After rambling some factoids that have little to do with his argument, he uses a [[StrawmanFallacy strawman point of view which happens to be easy for him to deride]]: "When will I ever use math in life?" Firstly, nobody says that; people specifically refer to algebra, geometry, calculus and the like, because it's a hugely valid observation that many jobs do not require such advanced concepts. He patronizingly points out that every job DOES involve using math...forgetting to mention that it's simple arithmetic a good deal of the time, which nobody doubts in the first place. Finally, he continues rambling about how math has been important to the advancement of civilization, which is once again [[CaptainObvious something we already have been fully aware of since elementary school]]. Maddox, sucking at math doesn't automatically make you an idiot, because not everyone's brain is as skilled in problem solving as they are in other methods of thinking, and there's only so much that education can do to remedy that. Long story short, it's one of Maddox's shittiest and most misguided arguments for anything ever. It's possible that in some places he's exaggerating the reader's stupidity for the purpose of his Viewers Are Morons schtick, but a lot of the article comes off as the actual man behind the Maddox personality talking, and thus there's no excuse for how poorly the article is thought out.
14th Mar '17 7:48:35 PM ImSpidey2
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* I'm not that much of a fan of TechRax. While I do like some of his videos, I always found his commentary a bit annoying. I unsubscribed to him today however, upon seeing [[WebVideo/Pyrocynical]] trash his latest video, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arVHjiNLDXY Casting Cockroaches + iPhone 7 Plus Molten Aluminum!]]''. NauseaFuel aside, Tech seems completely ignorant to the cockroaches' suffering (which, by the way, [[HellIsThatNoise you can hear their squeaking as they burn]]), even snickering a few times at them. I always found Tech to be a bit stupid, but this made him hit, as Pyro said, "a new low". And at the end, [[BlatantLies he has the gull to say that they're "asleep" at the end]]. Yeah, you know what? Fuck you, TechRax. You just lost a sub, and hopefully thousands more will follow after watching this twisted excuse of "entertainment".

to:

* I'm not that much of a fan of TechRax.[=TechRax=]. While I do like some of his videos, I always found his commentary a bit annoying. I unsubscribed to him today however, upon seeing [[WebVideo/Pyrocynical]] trash his latest video, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arVHjiNLDXY Casting Cockroaches + iPhone 7 Plus Molten Aluminum!]]''. NauseaFuel aside, Tech Tara (Tech himself) seems completely ignorant to the cockroaches' suffering (which, by the way, [[HellIsThatNoise you can hear their squeaking as they burn]]), even snickering a few times at them. I always found Tech to be a bit stupid, but this made him hit, as Pyro said, "a new low". And at the end, [[BlatantLies he has the gull to say that they're "asleep" at the end]]. [[Squick As one just clings to life in the corner of the tray.]] Yeah, you know what? Fuck you, TechRax.Tara. You just lost a sub, and hopefully thousands more will follow after watching this twisted excuse of "entertainment".
14th Mar '17 7:46:44 PM ImSpidey2
Is there an issue? Send a Message


Actually, most of the reasons aren't bad and the author has some good points even though I disagree with them. However, reason #2, "[[http://whatculture.com/film/10-reasons-frozen-definitely-disneys-best-animated-movie-decade.php/10 Elsa Is Kind Of A B*TCH]]" just stinks. It uses BlatantLies and [[MetaphoricallyTrue deliberately misleading half-truths]] to make Elsa look bad. Well, either that or we have a case of CriticalResearchFailure. The author claims that Elsa "was so wrapped up in her own problem she didn’t even notice she was damning an entire kingdom", even though it's obvious from watching the movie that Elsa at that point has no reason to believe her powers can have such devastating effects. He claims that Elsa doesn't even bother to try to thaw the kingdom, but fails to take into account that she has no idea how to do it and that returning to Arendelle would probably just make everything worse. He claims that Elsa shuts Anna out because she doesn't give a damn about her, when the film clearly shows that Elsa cares for Anna and is forced to shut her out to keep her from getting hurt. He also makes it sound like Elsa intentionally [[spoiler:freezes Anna's heart]], even though Elsa doesn't (it happened while she was not thinking straight) and is clearly horrified when she sees what has happened.\\

to:

Actually, most of the reasons aren't bad and the author has some good points even though I disagree with them. However, reason #2, "[[http://whatculture.com/film/10-reasons-frozen-definitely-disneys-best-animated-movie-decade.php/10 Elsa Is Kind Of A B*TCH]]" just stinks. It uses BlatantLies and [[MetaphoricallyTrue deliberately misleading half-truths]] to make Elsa look bad. Well, either that or we have a case of CriticalResearchFailure. The author claims that Elsa "was so wrapped up in her own problem she didn’t didn’t even notice she was damning an entire kingdom", even though it's obvious from watching the movie that Elsa at that point has no reason to believe her powers can have such devastating effects. He claims that Elsa doesn't even bother to try to thaw the kingdom, but fails to take into account that she has no idea how to do it and that returning to Arendelle would probably just make everything worse. He claims that Elsa shuts Anna out because she doesn't give a damn about her, when the film clearly shows that Elsa cares for Anna and is forced to shut her out to keep her from getting hurt. He also makes it sound like Elsa intentionally [[spoiler:freezes Anna's heart]], even though Elsa doesn't (it happened while she was not thinking straight) and is clearly horrified when she sees what has happened.\\


Added DiffLines:

* I'm not that much of a fan of TechRax. While I do like some of his videos, I always found his commentary a bit annoying. I unsubscribed to him today however, upon seeing [[WebVideo/Pyrocynical]] trash his latest video, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=arVHjiNLDXY Casting Cockroaches + iPhone 7 Plus Molten Aluminum!]]''. NauseaFuel aside, Tech seems completely ignorant to the cockroaches' suffering (which, by the way, [[HellIsThatNoise you can hear their squeaking as they burn]]), even snickering a few times at them. I always found Tech to be a bit stupid, but this made him hit, as Pyro said, "a new low". And at the end, [[BlatantLies he has the gull to say that they're "asleep" at the end]]. Yeah, you know what? Fuck you, TechRax. You just lost a sub, and hopefully thousands more will follow after watching this twisted excuse of "entertainment".
13th Mar '17 8:38:14 AM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most [[CausticCritic Caustic Critics]] however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of lists. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater (As you can see in the flavor text). But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every single Franchise/ScoobyDoo remake in existence]]! Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "The original was never any good to begin with, so the franchise should have died years ago!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years despite the original's lack of appeal to him. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, especially if it's a show I don't like. But I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place the entire franchise at #1 on a Worst Remakes list and bash it simply because of it's lifespan and the quality of the original alone. Not to mention that he seems to think that [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] is, like the other remakes he mentions, exactly the same as the original. Oh, and Strider seemed to have [[TookALevelInJerkass taken a level in jerkass]] for this entry. Usually, he just expresses his distaste in a professional and witty manner like the classy DeadpanSnarker he is. Here it sounds more like he's trying to rally all of his viewers against the franchise, what with him having the gall to assume that nobody actively watches [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] anyway, asking "Has any kid ever sat down and said, 'Oh, look! [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] is on!'?", and claiming that kids only watch it when there's nothing better to watch. Excuse me Strider, but I watched both [[spoiler: What's New, Scooby-Doo?]] and [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] regularly when I was a kid and loved them. Again, this is coming from a guy who claims to be fine with people liking something he doesn't. This assumption is not only hypocritical and insulting, it makes no sense. If a series has been remade over 19 times, then it must have some sort of fanbase otherwise it wouldn't have been remade even once! Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I was so disappointed with him, I couldn't bring myself to listen to him re-explain why he hates [[spoiler:Scooby Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/P9NLefklYK8 Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes list]] and skipped over it. (But judging by his added comment of "Forever" in the entry title, he was trying to justify cramming the entire franchise on the top spot of his Worst Remakes list). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".

to:

* Sugarp1e1: Tropers/Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most [[CausticCritic Caustic Critics]] however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of lists. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater (As you can see in the flavor text). But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every single Franchise/ScoobyDoo remake in existence]]! Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "The original was never any good to begin with, so the franchise should have died years ago!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years despite the original's lack of appeal to him. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, especially if it's a show I don't like. But I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place the entire franchise at #1 on a Worst Remakes list and bash it simply because of it's lifespan and the quality of the original alone. Not to mention that he seems to think that [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] is, like the other remakes he mentions, exactly the same as the original. Oh, and Strider seemed to have [[TookALevelInJerkass taken a level in jerkass]] for this entry. Usually, he just expresses his distaste in a professional and witty manner like the classy DeadpanSnarker he is. Here it sounds more like he's trying to rally all of his viewers against the franchise, what with him having the gall to assume that nobody actively watches [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] anyway, asking "Has any kid ever sat down and said, 'Oh, look! [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] is on!'?", and claiming that kids only watch it when there's nothing better to watch. Excuse me Strider, but I watched both [[spoiler: What's New, Scooby-Doo?]] and [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] regularly when I was a kid and loved them. Again, this is coming from a guy who claims to be fine with people liking something he doesn't. This assumption is not only hypocritical and insulting, it makes no sense. If a series has been remade over 19 times, then it must have some sort of fanbase otherwise it wouldn't have been remade even once! Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I was so disappointed with him, I couldn't bring myself to listen to him re-explain why he hates [[spoiler:Scooby Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/P9NLefklYK8 Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes list]] and skipped over it. (But judging by his added comment of "Forever" in the entry title, he was trying to justify cramming the entire franchise on the top spot of his Worst Remakes list). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".
10th Mar '17 1:30:07 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** [=SenorCornholio=]: I have a similar complaint from his [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zJD9B0za9k Pokémon Bootlegs]] video. everything described above applies here: the video is absolutely fantastic. the jokes are on point and gut-bustingly hilarious, but there's one game he could have gone into more detail on, and that's VideoGame/PokemonVietnameseCrystal. He doesn't even go past the opening segment with Professor Oak before switching games. Given that this is a TranslationTrainwreck of [[MemeticMutation memetic degree]], I get that there's probably not much he could say about it that hasn't been said, but that doesn't mean one shouldn't try. [[TheyWasterAPerfectlyGoodPlot He could have at least gotten to]] "[[SugarWiki/CrowningMomentOfFunny BAG FUCK]]" [[TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot or something and ''then'' quit the game in disgust.]] Once again, I feel like this is one of JonTron's best videos that he's put out, but there was just that one thing he should have gone into more detail about, but didn't.

to:

** [=SenorCornholio=]: I have a similar complaint from his [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zJD9B0za9k Pokémon Bootlegs]] video. everything described above applies here: the video is absolutely fantastic. the jokes are on point and gut-bustingly hilarious, but there's one game he could have gone into more detail on, and that's VideoGame/PokemonVietnameseCrystal. He doesn't even go past the opening segment with Professor Oak before switching games. Given that this is a TranslationTrainwreck of [[MemeticMutation memetic degree]], I get that there's probably not much he could say about it that hasn't been said, but that doesn't mean one shouldn't try. [[TheyWasterAPerfectlyGoodPlot [[TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot He could have at least gotten to]] "[[SugarWiki/CrowningMomentOfFunny BAG FUCK]]" [[TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot or something and ''then'' quit the game in disgust.]] Once again, I feel like this is one of JonTron's best videos that he's put out, but there was just that one thing he should have gone into more detail about, but didn't.
10th Mar '17 1:28:27 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** [=SenorCornholio=]: I have a similar complaint from his [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zJD9B0za9k Pokémon Bootlegs]] video. everything described above applies here: the video is absolutely fantastic. the jokes are on point and gut-bustingly hilarious, but there's one game he could have gone into more detail on, and that's VideoGame/PokemonVietnameseCrystal. He doesn't even go past the opening segment with Professor Oak before switching games. Given that this is a TranslationTrainwreck of [[MemeticMutation memetic degree]], I get that there's probably not much he could say about it that hasn't been said, but that doesn't mean one shouldn't try. [[TheyWasterAPerfectlyGoodPlot He could have at least gotten to]] "[[SugarWiki/CrowningMomentOfFunny BAG FUCK]]" [[TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot or something and ''then'' quit the game in disgust.]] Once again, I feel like this is one of JonTron's best videos that he's put out, but there was just that one thing he should have gone into more detail about, but didn't.
9th Mar '17 9:46:12 PM MrMediaGuy2
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/MrMediaGuy2: Normally, I usually have a lot of fun reading the scary stories on r/nosleep. But this story, [[https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/1e91ez/wrong_way_charlie/ Wrong Way Charlie]], is probably the worst thing ever posted there. The story is about a four year-old boy who befriends a kitten, becoming very close to the animal. One day, he runs through the hall and ends up [[spoiler:stepping on the kitten and horribly injuring him. Then the boy's horrified mother [[MercyKill euthanizes the kitten]] by [[ThereIsNoKillLikeOverkill smashing his skull with a hammer]], [[ForcedToWatch right in front of]] both [[HarmfulToMinors the two children]] and the mother cat! All of this is done in graphic detail, with both the kitten meowing in agony and his [[{{Gorn}} brains and skull splattering all over the hallway]].]] The story wasn't scary at all, just [[NauseaFuel nauseating and gross]]. And it didn't even come with a [[ContentWarnings content warning]], unfortunate for a cat-lover like myself. I wonder if this story is the reason nosleep has a new rule about how awful content alone doesn't make a story scary.

to:

* Tropers/MrMediaGuy2: Normally, I usually have a lot of fun reading the scary stories on r/nosleep. But this story, [[https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/1e91ez/wrong_way_charlie/ Wrong Way Charlie]], is probably the worst thing ever posted there. The story is about a four year-old boy who befriends a kitten, becoming very close to the animal. One day, he runs through the hall and ends up [[spoiler:stepping on the kitten and horribly injuring him. Then the boy's horrified mother [[MercyKill euthanizes the kitten]] by [[ThereIsNoKillLikeOverkill smashing his skull with a hammer]], [[ForcedToWatch right in front of]] both [[HarmfulToMinors the two children]] and the mother cat! All of this is done in graphic detail, with disturbing descriptions of both the kitten meowing in agony and his [[{{Gorn}} brains and skull splattering all over the hallway]].]] The story wasn't scary at all, just [[NauseaFuel nauseating and gross]]. And it didn't even come with a [[ContentWarnings content warning]], unfortunate for a cat-lover like myself. I wonder if this story is the reason nosleep has a new rule about how awful content alone doesn't make a story scary.
9th Mar '17 9:45:25 PM MrMediaGuy2
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/MrMediaGuy2: Normally, I usually have a lot of fun reading the scary stories on r/nosleep. But this story, [[https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/1e91ez/wrong_way_charlie/ Wrong Way Charlie]], is probably the worst thing ever posted there. The story is about a four year-old boy who befriends a kitten, becoming very close to the animal. One day, he runs through the hall and ends up [[spoiler:stepping on the kitten and horribly injuring him. Then the boy's horrified mother [[MercyKill euthanizes the kitten]] by smashing his skull with a hammer, right in front of both the two children and the mother cat! All of this is done in graphic detail, with both the kitten meowing in agony and his [[{{Gorn}} brains and skull splattering all over the hallway]].]] The story wasn't scary at all, just [[NauseaFuel nauseating and gross]]. And it didn't even come with a [[ContentWarnings content warning]], unfortunate for a cat-lover like myself. I wonder if this story is the reason nosleep has a new rule about how awful content alone doesn't make a story scary.

to:

* Tropers/MrMediaGuy2: Normally, I usually have a lot of fun reading the scary stories on r/nosleep. But this story, [[https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/1e91ez/wrong_way_charlie/ Wrong Way Charlie]], is probably the worst thing ever posted there. The story is about a four year-old boy who befriends a kitten, becoming very close to the animal. One day, he runs through the hall and ends up [[spoiler:stepping on the kitten and horribly injuring him. Then the boy's horrified mother [[MercyKill euthanizes the kitten]] by [[ThereIsNoKillLikeOverkill smashing his skull with a hammer, hammer]], [[ForcedToWatch right in front of of]] both [[HarmfulToMinors the two children children]] and the mother cat! All of this is done in graphic detail, with both the kitten meowing in agony and his [[{{Gorn}} brains and skull splattering all over the hallway]].]] The story wasn't scary at all, just [[NauseaFuel nauseating and gross]]. And it didn't even come with a [[ContentWarnings content warning]], unfortunate for a cat-lover like myself. I wonder if this story is the reason nosleep has a new rule about how awful content alone doesn't make a story scary.
9th Mar '17 12:02:05 AM BronyoftheOctaves
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* HulkingCetacean: JoshScorcher for "Response to Lily Peet" for completely different reasons than that videos comment section would say i would call it a DMOS ... i used to think he used to be a good person who didnt like the dark side of the internet...then he went to 8chan and Kiwi farms to dig up their posts on Lily Peet they have kept in a stalker-like fashion and THEN in the video tells his fans not to send her death threats and has never called them out like he has done before when they inevitably did (and they linked proof that they did in the comment section of the video) but the fact that he calls himself a Christian and openly went to hate filled sites that stand for everything that Christianity is against disgusts me.

to:

* %%* HulkingCetacean: JoshScorcher for "Response to Lily Peet" for completely different reasons than that videos comment section would say i would call it a DMOS ... i used to think he used to be a good person who didnt like the dark side of the internet...then he went to 8chan and Kiwi farms to dig up their posts on Lily Peet they have kept in a stalker-like fashion and THEN in the video tells his fans not to send her death threats and has never called them out like he has done before when they inevitably did (and they linked proof that they did in the comment section of the video) but the fact that he calls himself a Christian and openly went to hate filled sites that stand for everything that Christianity is against disgusts me.
7th Mar '17 5:51:53 PM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Animeking1108: While I enjoy Beyond The Black Rims by MarzGurl, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Op3UiD0p7o Episode 5]] was a waste of potential when they got to the part about the KingdomHearts HD Remix Collection. They talked about the collection itself for about 30 seconds before going on a 20 minute rant everyone and their mothers has heard about ''Kingdom Hearts 3'' not being made yet. I can pretty much watch the entire segment by going on a forum. They completely ignore the fact that it will contain the [[NoExportForYou Final Mix]], which fans have been waiting eleven years for. They even admit that they don't care how much the side games will clear any potential plot holes out. I expected better from you, Kaylyn.

to:

* Animeking1108: While I enjoy Beyond The Black Rims by MarzGurl, WebVideo/MarzGurl, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Op3UiD0p7o Episode 5]] was a waste of potential when they got to the part about the KingdomHearts HD Remix Collection. They talked about the collection itself for about 30 seconds before going on a 20 minute rant everyone and their mothers has heard about ''Kingdom Hearts 3'' not being made yet. I can pretty much watch the entire segment by going on a forum. They completely ignore the fact that it will contain the [[NoExportForYou Final Mix]], which fans have been waiting eleven years for. They even admit that they don't care how much the side games will clear any potential plot holes out. I expected better from you, Kaylyn.
6th Mar '17 5:22:09 AM JamesAustin
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/ParaChomp: "Search for the Worst: Suicide Squad". I will not argue against negative criticism against Movie/SuicideSquad, it's justified. What I will argue against are the constant questioning of the existence of various characters. One can see them as IHE pointing out them being unnecessary for the film but when he compared Killer Croc to Gorilla Grodd, you could tell that either wasn't the case or he's being too vague with the intentions of his words. There is nothing wrong with either of them as characters in terms of premise, same can be said about Captain Boomerang and Katana. All four of these characters have proven their worth in other pieces of media. There are so many characters who use trick weapons for combat and Katana was as relevant as ever due to WesternAnimation/BewareTheBatman. One of the film's problems are its many unnecessary characters but these characters have been well written in other media and have relevance to the source material which is something IHE doesn't acknowledge. I do realize that I am an IDIOT trying to win such an argument. This is someone who doesn't care about the history of comics nor their characters, only wants a good movie, and uses Aquaman and Kite Man as their Trope/ButtMonkey. Once again, the wound that the UsefulNotes/TheComicsCode has left shows its ugly face proving that even the Trope/DarkerAndEdgier adaptions can't hide it.

to:

* Tropers/ParaChomp: "Search for the Worst: Suicide Squad". I will not argue against negative criticism against Movie/SuicideSquad, ''Film/SuicideSquad2016'', it's justified. What I will argue against are the constant questioning of the existence of various characters. One can see them as IHE pointing out them being unnecessary for the film but when he compared Killer Croc to Gorilla Grodd, you could tell that either wasn't the case or he's being too vague with the intentions of his words. There is nothing wrong with either of them as characters in terms of premise, same can be said about Captain Boomerang and Katana. All four of these characters have proven their worth in other pieces of media. There are so many characters who use trick weapons for combat and Katana was as relevant as ever due to WesternAnimation/BewareTheBatman.''WesternAnimation/BewareTheBatman''. One of the film's problems are its many unnecessary characters but these characters have been well written in other media and have relevance to the source material which is something IHE doesn't acknowledge. I do realize that I am an IDIOT trying to win such an argument. This is someone who doesn't care about the history of comics nor their characters, only wants a good movie, and uses Aquaman and Kite Man as their Trope/ButtMonkey. Once again, the wound that the UsefulNotes/TheComicsCode has left shows its ugly face proving that even the Trope/DarkerAndEdgier adaptions can't hide it.
5th Mar '17 4:15:59 PM frnmmma25
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Frnmmma25: I disliked ''Website/{{TheOnion}}'' 's video about North Korea. It said that the U.S. is just like North Korea. Come on, we're fucked up in a lot of ways, but we don't have concentration camps! My brother said that he expected something better, that it wasn't even funny, and that they really are straying from what they were established to be.

to:

* Frnmmma25: I disliked ''Website/{{TheOnion}}'' 's video about North Korea. Korea, "Onion Explains: The Totalitarian State Of North Korea". It said was actually funny and witty... until all of a sudden it says that the U.S. is just like North Korea. "Where life there is exactly the same as life here." Come on, we're fucked up in a lot of ways, but we don't have concentration camps! Most of our economy doesn't come from prison slave labour, and we don't have a society where the social power is even more strict than the royal/regular power level from hundreds of years ago in Korea. Where almost all of the population is starving to death, and even haircuts are regulated by the police. Where even implying something can land you, your entire family, and the next two generations in prison camps. Even comparing it to the dictatorship that is China is out of line. REFUGEES from North Korea call China a paradise. "Whether it is men with guns keeping you in line, or corporations keeping you pacified with hamburgers and i pads". So you do you not like the police, or just want them to not have guns? It's one thing if it's guns, because at least it means that they are only implying that people with guns can hurt you, never mind that they have guns because a lot of people have guns in order to protect themselves, but if they're implying that we are just as oppressed because we have police, then you have another fucking problem. EVERY fucking country has police, and even in anarchic hellholes there are people who try to police the gangs. Who are you to tell me that we are oppressed because of this? If we're as fucked up as North Korea for having police (does North Korea even have a single non government buisness?) then you might as well call France a shit hellhole as well. Or even Canada. What? They have police. And they also have guns! Even if it's just mocking cynics who call any country better than America just because they don't notice those problems, it seems too spiteful, hateful, and arrogant for it to seem like it, much less get any enjoyment out of it. My brother told me about this, and said that he expected something better, that it wasn't even funny, and that they really are straying from what they were established to be.be. I agree with him.
4th Mar '17 9:35:05 AM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Troper/{{cookieman}}: We have Nyan Cat as fanart, crossovers (with such series as ''MarioKart'', ''RobotUnicornAttack'', and shirts and such). However, when you start to crossover something with [[http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=250305521674671&set=a.192924910746066.42399.132945776743980&type=1&theater 9/11]], then you know there's something wrong. (View at your own risk)

to:

* Troper/{{cookieman}}: We have Nyan Cat as fanart, crossovers (with such series as ''MarioKart'', ''RobotUnicornAttack'', ''VideoGame/MarioKart'', ''VideoGame/RobotUnicornAttack'', and shirts and such). However, when you start to crossover something with [[http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=250305521674671&set=a.192924910746066.42399.132945776743980&type=1&theater 9/11]], then you know there's something wrong. (View at your own risk)



* Uttergenius - Creator/TheQuarterGuy is easily one of my favorite Youtubers. His videos tend to be funny, informative, and all-around entertaining. Unfortunately, there's no excusing this moment from his collab with [=MaverickHunterZero75=], Top Twenty VideoGame/MarioKart Tracks. During the [[VideoGame/MarioKart8 Cloudtop Cruise]] segment in Part 2, Ben (Maverick) takes a moment to listen to the music: it's a [[RecurringRiff remix]] of [[VideoGame/SuperMarioGalaxy "Gusty Garden Galaxy"]]. He then jokes that Super Mario Galaxy 3 has been confirmed. In response, Adam (QG) vehemently shoots down this idea, claiming that the first game didn't need a [[VideoGame/SuperMarioGalaxy2 sequel]]. This moment was completely uncalled for. Not only is bashing a game for simply existing pure HateDumb, but Adam had no right to say that when [[{{Hypocrite}} he's constantly pestering Capcom for a new Mega Man game.]] A pretty low moment from an otherwise awesome youtuber.

to:

* Uttergenius - Creator/TheQuarterGuy is easily one of my favorite Youtubers. His videos tend to be funny, informative, and all-around entertaining. Unfortunately, there's no excusing this moment from his collab with [=MaverickHunterZero75=], Top Twenty VideoGame/MarioKart ''VideoGame/MarioKart'' Tracks. During the [[VideoGame/MarioKart8 Cloudtop Cruise]] segment in Part 2, Ben (Maverick) takes a moment to listen to the music: it's a [[RecurringRiff remix]] of [[VideoGame/SuperMarioGalaxy "Gusty Garden Galaxy"]]. He then jokes that Super Mario Galaxy 3 has been confirmed. In response, Adam (QG) vehemently shoots down this idea, claiming that the first game didn't need a [[VideoGame/SuperMarioGalaxy2 sequel]]. This moment was completely uncalled for. Not only is bashing a game for simply existing pure HateDumb, but Adam had no right to say that when [[{{Hypocrite}} he's constantly pestering Capcom for a new Mega Man game.]] A pretty low moment from an otherwise awesome youtuber.
3rd Mar '17 9:17:13 PM MrMediaGuy2
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Tropers/MrMediaGuy2: Normally, I usually have a lot of fun reading the scary stories on r/nosleep. But this story, [[https://www.reddit.com/r/nosleep/comments/1e91ez/wrong_way_charlie/ Wrong Way Charlie]], is probably the worst thing ever posted there. The story is about a four year-old boy who befriends a kitten, becoming very close to the animal. One day, he runs through the hall and ends up [[spoiler:stepping on the kitten and horribly injuring him. Then the boy's horrified mother [[MercyKill euthanizes the kitten]] by smashing his skull with a hammer, right in front of both the two children and the mother cat! All of this is done in graphic detail, with both the kitten meowing in agony and his [[{{Gorn}} brains and skull splattering all over the hallway]].]] The story wasn't scary at all, just [[NauseaFuel nauseating and gross]]. And it didn't even come with a [[ContentWarnings content warning]], unfortunate for a cat-lover like myself. I wonder if this story is the reason nosleep has a new rule about how awful content alone doesn't make a story scary.
2nd Mar '17 4:34:11 PM shoboni
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/{{shoboni]] I love WebVideo/SomeOrdinaryGamers but Mutahar dropped the ball when he did a video about an alleged [[PedoHunt Youtube Pedophile Ring]] months after another Youtuber named Reignbot that also deals with disturbing online content thoroughly debunked it as fear-mongering and explained how it's actually harmful to spread such hysteria.

to:

* Tropers/{{shoboni]] Tropers/{{shoboni}}: I love WebVideo/SomeOrdinaryGamers but Mutahar dropped the ball when he did a video about an alleged [[PedoHunt Youtube Pedophile Ring]] months after another Youtuber named Reignbot that also deals with disturbing online content thoroughly debunked it as fear-mongering and explained how it's actually harmful to spread such hysteria.
2nd Mar '17 4:33:29 PM shoboni
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Tropers/{{shoboni]] I love WebVideo/SomeOrdinaryGamers but Mutahar dropped the ball when he did a video about an alleged [[PedoHunt Youtube Pedophile Ring]] months after another Youtuber named Reignbot that also deals with disturbing online content thoroughly debunked it as fear-mongering and explained how it's actually harmful to spread such hysteria.
28th Feb '17 6:55:45 AM GreenFablesInverness
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** GreenFablesInverness: And come season four this show has not gotten any better in its treatment of its characters. While it’s meant to be a throwaway joke, Ruby laughing at Juane’s bunny hoodie is frankly insulting to my intelligence because it is a regression of character development the past few seasons have worked so hard to deconstruct the traditional but toxic stereotyping. One, Juane’s masculinity, or rather lack thereof, is the butt monkey yet again when a key part of his S1 character arc was getting away from poisonous macho man mindset. It’s what almost got him killed against Grimm biting off more than he could chew. And who help him confront his weakness and move on towards self-improvement? Oh yeah, Pyrrha, the girl he cared for and lost and we see a moment later used his memento of her being integrated into his weapon’s shield so a piece of her spirit will remain fighting alongside Team JNRP. The girl who accepted Juane for who he was and was everything she wanted in life; somebody that didn’t put her on a pedestal instead treating her like a real person. As if laughing at Juane wasn’t bad enough, Ruby laughing at the cereal icon is even worse because it’s a brown bunny and who else is a brown bunny? Fan favorite Velvet Scarlatina! The girl who had to fight tooth and nail to prove despite her cute looks she was as lethal as any other huntress. Her weapon is a fusion of every kickass weapon we’ve seen Beacon’s students use. She copies their fighting style into her own combat tactics to take on a horde of Grimm like the badass she is. That her weapon was Monty’s favorite. Remember the faunus girl who got picked on in season 1 by Cardin and his team for her bunny ears to demonstrate what kind of jerks they were and the discrimination faunus face? Yeah, the same group of bullies that would go on to antagonize and blackmail Juane! Yeah, they can make the excuse the deaths of Pyrrha and Penny were “planned from the start to demonstrate no one in safe in the world of Remnant” until they’re blue but this is just mounting evidence that RT doesn’t make an effort to respect their characters, the audience’s intelligence, or even their own writing integrity.
27th Feb '17 10:01:14 AM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Sugarp1e1: I agree. What especially ticks me off about this video is hotdiggitydemon feeling the need to AccentuateTheNegative despite finding the reboot SoOkayItsAverage. Which is it? Is it average or is it bad? There's a difference, you know.

to:

** Sugarp1e1: Tropers/{{Sugarp1e1}}: I agree. What especially ticks me off about this video is hotdiggitydemon feeling the need to AccentuateTheNegative despite finding the reboot SoOkayItsAverage. Which is it? Is it average or is it bad? There's a difference, you know.


Added DiffLines:

* Tropers/{{Sugarp1e1}}: The 7th entry of TheMetalBlade5's [[https://youtu.be/LUy-iKZDeNk Top 10 Worst Video Game Reviews I've Seen list]]. In the beginning of the video, he claims that he has no problem with people liking something he doesn't and that he was only going to focus on the reviews themselves. Yet when he gets to his 7th entry, he starts going on this long rant about how [[spoiler:Shadow of Memories]] is an objectively bad game and how everyone who gave it a positive review is wrong. This entry felt more like a review on the game than a review on the reviews it got. And the hypocrisy gets worse at the end of the video when he tells the narrator of the #1 review on the list that he should respect people's opinions on the game. I don't know about you, but telling people their objectively wrong for liking something you don't isn't respecting their opinion. [[MurderArsonAndJaywalking Also, his yelling literally gave me a headache]].
26th Feb '17 8:17:39 AM tvlegend
Is there an issue? Send a Message
26th Feb '17 3:48:45 AM Anicomicgeek
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* ''DethroningMoment/BennettTheSage''


Added DiffLines:

** ''DethroningMoment/BennettTheSage''
22nd Feb '17 11:59:31 AM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** ''SenorCornholio'': Fourthed. I'm honestly the first troper on this segment to have enjoyed this video for the most part, with things like bomb bowling and calling out the Gorons for being such picky eaters being highlights. However, I will admit it had some serious flaws: the points he made were more YMMV than actual bad game design, his jabs at Skyward Sword were unneeded and deviated from the rest of the video entirely, [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking and he said twice that Impa was the one that gave you the letter instead of Zelda]]. However, those aren't my main gripes. See, I could understand talking about Skyward Sword and using Ocarina of Time as a way to show how the ideas adopted in that game ended up forming this "spoiled rich kid" in the series. That's fine...then along comes the part where he talks about A Link Between Worlds. He goes to countless lengths praising how greatly implemented its mechanics were, while taking extra shots at Skyward Sword and Twilight Princess. Hey guys, did you know!? [[CaptainObvious Egoraptor doesn't like 3D Zeldas!]] I just thought he didn't hammer it into your heads enough! And what's more is that, just like his gripes with Skyward Sword, they were really not needed at all. Yes, the Spinner was hardly ever used, and the Magic Armor was a terrible, ''terrible'' item, but did he really need to mention that? It feels more like this segment existed to toot Arin's own horn and complain about more 3D mechanics, and it also felt shoehorned in due to Arin playing the game and liking it. I love [[GirlChanInParadise most]] [[Music/StarBomb of]] [[WebVideo/GameGrumps Arin's]] [[WebAnimation/AwesomeSeries work,]] I enjoy him as a creator, and I know he's a good person in real life, but this was just a dumb moment in an already polarizing review.

to:

** ''SenorCornholio'': Fourthed. I'm honestly the first troper on this segment to have enjoyed this video for the most part, with things like bomb bowling and calling out the Gorons for being such picky eaters being highlights. However, I will admit it had some serious flaws: the points he made were more YMMV than actual bad game design, his jabs at ''[[VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaSkywardSword Skyward Sword Sword]]'' were unneeded and deviated from the rest of the video entirely, [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking and he said twice that Impa was the one that gave you the letter instead of Zelda]]. However, those aren't my main gripes. See, I could understand talking about Skyward Sword and using Ocarina of Time as a way to show how the ideas adopted in that game ended up forming this "spoiled rich kid" in the series. That's fine...then along comes the part where he talks about ''[[VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaALinkBetweenWorlds A Link Between Worlds. Worlds]]''. He goes to countless lengths praising how greatly implemented its mechanics were, while taking extra shots at Skyward Sword ''Skyward Sword'' and ''[[VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaTwilightPrincess Twilight Princess.Princess]]''. Hey guys, did you know!? [[CaptainObvious Egoraptor doesn't like 3D Zeldas!]] I just thought he didn't hammer it into your heads enough! And what's more is that, just like his gripes with Skyward Sword, they were really not needed at all. Yes, the Spinner was hardly ever used, and the Magic Armor was a terrible, ''terrible'' item, very situational item (until the HD release where you can get a much bigger wallet, anyway), but did he really need to mention that? any of this? It feels more like this segment existed to toot Arin's own horn and complain about more 3D mechanics, and it also felt shoehorned in due to Arin playing the game ''ABLW'' and liking it. I love [[GirlChanInParadise most]] [[Music/StarBomb of]] [[WebVideo/GameGrumps Arin's]] [[WebAnimation/AwesomeSeries work,]] I enjoy him as a creator, and I know he's a good person in real life, but this was just a dumb pointless moment in an already polarizing review.
18th Feb '17 3:31:33 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** SenorCornholio: I have recently warmed up to Racist Mario due to the voice clips being used in some of [[Machinima/Supermarioglitchy4sSuperMario64Bloopers SMG4's videos]] (such as [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wjb0FgQqpZA this one]]), but that doesn't change the fact that overall, this video is heavily flawed in more ways than one. I could go on about the unfunny jokes, the nonsensical plot, etc, but what I think makes the whole thing fall apart: the premise. Mario goes insane and starts killing everyone because of all the third-party characters in the current race. Why does this not work? Well firstly, because there has never been a third-party character in a main Mario Kart title. The DLC characters for Mario Kart 8 were all from other Nintendo franchises, and therefore first-party. Secondly, the characters themselves; [[VideoGame/SegaSuperstars Sonic may have been playable in several Sega-themed sports and racing titles]], but the only time he crossed over with Nintendo itself was in VideoGame/SuperSmashBros., which would have actually been a better setting due to [[Franchise/SonicTheHedgehog their]] [[VideoGame/MetalGear own]] [[Franchise/MegaMan selection]] [[VideoGame/PacMan of]] [[Franchise/StreetFighter third]]-[[VideoGame/FinalFantasyVII party]] [[{{VideoGame/Bayonetta}} characters]]. And even then, Knuckles wasn't even playable so that's out. It's like some of these franchises were listed all because of their racing titles, with [[Franchise/StarWars Anakin]] and [[VideoGame/CrashBandicoot Crash's head]] also being standout examples. Thirdly, speaking of Sony, was there an alternate universe I'm not aware of where Sony and Nintendo crossed over and [[VideoGame/LittleBigPlanet Sackboy]] and [[VideoGame/GodOfWar Kratos]] were put into karts? I'll admit that Kratos driving a tiny kart is a funny sight, but what's the point? Ironically, there's one crossover that I doubt Flashgitz even knows he got right, and that's Pac-Man's head on a spear, since he was playable in the Arcade GP games developed by Namco-Bandai. Other than that, the rest of the references are shallow at best and make absolutely no sense at worst. Now if you'll excuse me, I'm gonna go watch [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynKRJt4CDMY the version where all the violence is replaced with The Nutshack]]. It's somehow way better.

to:

** SenorCornholio: I have recently warmed up to Racist Mario due to the voice clips being used in some of [[Machinima/Supermarioglitchy4sSuperMario64Bloopers SMG4's videos]] (such as [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wjb0FgQqpZA this one]]), but that doesn't change the fact that overall, this video is heavily flawed in more ways than one. I could go on about the unfunny jokes, the nonsensical plot, etc, but what I think makes the whole thing fall apart: the premise. Mario goes insane and starts killing everyone because of all the third-party characters in the current race. Why does this not work? Well firstly, because there has never been a third-party character in a main Mario Kart title. The DLC characters for Mario Kart 8 were all from other Nintendo franchises, and therefore first-party. Secondly, the characters themselves; [[VideoGame/SegaSuperstars Sonic may have been playable in several Sega-themed sports and racing titles]], but the only time he crossed over with Nintendo itself was in VideoGame/SuperSmashBros., VideoGame/SuperSmashBros, which would have actually been a better setting due to [[Franchise/SonicTheHedgehog their]] [[VideoGame/MetalGear own]] [[Franchise/MegaMan selection]] [[VideoGame/PacMan of]] [[Franchise/StreetFighter third]]-[[VideoGame/FinalFantasyVII party]] [[{{VideoGame/Bayonetta}} characters]]. And even then, Knuckles wasn't even playable so that's out. It's like some of these franchises were listed all because of their racing titles, with [[Franchise/StarWars Anakin]] and [[VideoGame/CrashBandicoot Crash's head]] also being standout examples. Thirdly, speaking of Sony, was there an alternate universe I'm not aware of where Sony and Nintendo crossed over and [[VideoGame/LittleBigPlanet Sackboy]] and [[VideoGame/GodOfWar Kratos]] were put into karts? I'll admit that Kratos driving a tiny kart is a funny sight, but what's the point? Ironically, there's one crossover that I doubt Flashgitz even knows he got right, and that's Pac-Man's head on a spear, since he was playable in the Arcade GP games developed by Namco-Bandai. Other than that, the rest of the references are shallow at best and make absolutely no sense at worst. Now if you'll excuse me, I'm gonna go watch [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynKRJt4CDMY the version where all the violence is replaced with The Nutshack]]. It's somehow way better.
18th Feb '17 3:30:59 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** SenorCornholio: I have recently warmed up to Racist Mario due to the voice clips being used in some of [[Machinima/Supermarioglitchy4sSuperMario64Bloopers SMG4's videos]] (such as [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wjb0FgQqpZA this one]]), but that doesn't change the fact that overall, this video is heavily flawed in more ways than one. I could go on about the unfunny jokes, the nonsensical plot, etc, but what I think makes the whole thing fall apart: the premise. Mario goes insane and starts killing everyone because of all the third-party characters in the current race. Why does this not work? Well firstly, because there has never been a third-party character in a main Mario Kart title. The DLC characters for Mario Kart 8 were all from other Nintendo franchises, and therefore first-party. Secondly, the characters themselves; [[VideoGame/SegaSuperstars Sonic may have been playable in several Sega-themed sports and racing titles]], but the only time he crossed over with Nintendo itself was in VideoGame/SuperSmashBros. And even then, Knuckles wasn't even playable so that's out. It's like some of these franchises were listed all because of their racing titles, with [[Franchise/StarWars Anakin]] and [[VideoGame/CrashBandicoot Crash's head]] also being standout examples. Thirdly, speaking of Sony, was there an alternate universe I'm not aware of where Sony and Nintendo crossed over and [[VideoGame/LittleBigPlanet Sackboy]] and [[VideoGame/GodOfWar Kratos]] were put into karts? I'll admit that Kratos driving a tiny kart is a funny sight, but what's the point? Ironically, there's one crossover that I doubt Flashgitz even knows he got right, and that's Pac-Man's head on a spear, since he was playable in the Arcade GP games developed by Namco-Bandai. Other than that, the rest of the references are shallow at best and make absolutely no sense at worst. Now if you'll excuse me, I'm gonna go watch [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynKRJt4CDMY the version where all the violence is replaced with The Nutshack]]. It's somehow way better.

to:

** SenorCornholio: I have recently warmed up to Racist Mario due to the voice clips being used in some of [[Machinima/Supermarioglitchy4sSuperMario64Bloopers SMG4's videos]] (such as [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wjb0FgQqpZA this one]]), but that doesn't change the fact that overall, this video is heavily flawed in more ways than one. I could go on about the unfunny jokes, the nonsensical plot, etc, but what I think makes the whole thing fall apart: the premise. Mario goes insane and starts killing everyone because of all the third-party characters in the current race. Why does this not work? Well firstly, because there has never been a third-party character in a main Mario Kart title. The DLC characters for Mario Kart 8 were all from other Nintendo franchises, and therefore first-party. Secondly, the characters themselves; [[VideoGame/SegaSuperstars Sonic may have been playable in several Sega-themed sports and racing titles]], but the only time he crossed over with Nintendo itself was in VideoGame/SuperSmashBros., which would have actually been a better setting due to [[Franchise/SonicTheHedgehog their]] [[VideoGame/MetalGear own]] [[Franchise/MegaMan selection]] [[VideoGame/PacMan of]] [[Franchise/StreetFighter third]]-[[VideoGame/FinalFantasyVII party]] [[{{VideoGame/Bayonetta}} characters]]. And even then, Knuckles wasn't even playable so that's out. It's like some of these franchises were listed all because of their racing titles, with [[Franchise/StarWars Anakin]] and [[VideoGame/CrashBandicoot Crash's head]] also being standout examples. Thirdly, speaking of Sony, was there an alternate universe I'm not aware of where Sony and Nintendo crossed over and [[VideoGame/LittleBigPlanet Sackboy]] and [[VideoGame/GodOfWar Kratos]] were put into karts? I'll admit that Kratos driving a tiny kart is a funny sight, but what's the point? Ironically, there's one crossover that I doubt Flashgitz even knows he got right, and that's Pac-Man's head on a spear, since he was playable in the Arcade GP games developed by Namco-Bandai. Other than that, the rest of the references are shallow at best and make absolutely no sense at worst. Now if you'll excuse me, I'm gonna go watch [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynKRJt4CDMY the version where all the violence is replaced with The Nutshack]]. It's somehow way better.
18th Feb '17 3:22:06 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** SenorCornholio: I have recently warmed up to Racist Mario due to the voice clips being used in some of [[Machinima/Supermarioglitchy4sSuperMario64Bloopers SMG4's videos]], but that doesn't change the fact that overall, this video is heavily flawed in more ways than one. I could go on about the unfunny jokes, the nonsensical plot, etc, but what I think makes the whole thing fall apart: the premise. Mario goes insane and starts killing everyone because of all the third-party characters in the current race. Why does this not work? Well firstly, because there has never been a third-party character in a main Mario Kart title. The DLC characters for Mario Kart 8 were all from other Nintendo franchises, and therefore first-party. Secondly, the characters themselves; [[VideoGame/SegaSuperstars Sonic may have been playable in several Sega-themed sports and racing titles]], but the only time he crossed over with Nintendo itself was in VideoGame/SuperSmashBros. And even then, Knuckles wasn't even playable so that's out. It's like some of these franchises were listed all because of their racing titles, with [[Franchise/StarWars Anakin]] and [[VideoGame/CrashBandicoot Crash's head]] also being standout examples. Thirdly, speaking of Sony, was there an alternate universe I'm not aware of where Sony and Nintendo crossed over and [[VideoGame/LittleBigPlanet Sackboy]] and [[VideoGame/GodOfWar Kratos]] were put into karts? I'll admit that Kratos driving a tiny kart is a funny sight, but what's the point? Ironically, there's one crossover that I doubt Flashgitz even knows he got right, and that's Pac-Man's head on a spear, since he was playable in the Arcade GP games developed by Namco-Bandai. Other than that, the rest of the references are shallow at best and make absolutely no sense at worst. Now if you'll excuse me, I'm gonna go watch [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynKRJt4CDMY the version where all the violence is replaced with The Nutshack]]. It's somehow way better.

to:

** SenorCornholio: I have recently warmed up to Racist Mario due to the voice clips being used in some of [[Machinima/Supermarioglitchy4sSuperMario64Bloopers SMG4's videos]], videos]] (such as [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wjb0FgQqpZA this one]]), but that doesn't change the fact that overall, this video is heavily flawed in more ways than one. I could go on about the unfunny jokes, the nonsensical plot, etc, but what I think makes the whole thing fall apart: the premise. Mario goes insane and starts killing everyone because of all the third-party characters in the current race. Why does this not work? Well firstly, because there has never been a third-party character in a main Mario Kart title. The DLC characters for Mario Kart 8 were all from other Nintendo franchises, and therefore first-party. Secondly, the characters themselves; [[VideoGame/SegaSuperstars Sonic may have been playable in several Sega-themed sports and racing titles]], but the only time he crossed over with Nintendo itself was in VideoGame/SuperSmashBros. And even then, Knuckles wasn't even playable so that's out. It's like some of these franchises were listed all because of their racing titles, with [[Franchise/StarWars Anakin]] and [[VideoGame/CrashBandicoot Crash's head]] also being standout examples. Thirdly, speaking of Sony, was there an alternate universe I'm not aware of where Sony and Nintendo crossed over and [[VideoGame/LittleBigPlanet Sackboy]] and [[VideoGame/GodOfWar Kratos]] were put into karts? I'll admit that Kratos driving a tiny kart is a funny sight, but what's the point? Ironically, there's one crossover that I doubt Flashgitz even knows he got right, and that's Pac-Man's head on a spear, since he was playable in the Arcade GP games developed by Namco-Bandai. Other than that, the rest of the references are shallow at best and make absolutely no sense at worst. Now if you'll excuse me, I'm gonna go watch [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynKRJt4CDMY the version where all the violence is replaced with The Nutshack]]. It's somehow way better.
18th Feb '17 3:18:51 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* [=SenorCornholio=]: I have a small bone to pick with a throwaway line in the WebOriginal/CollegeHumor video, "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNlAZLCGLuU Luigi Finally Snaps]]". The plot of the video involves Luigi [[WhatTheHellHero calling out Mario for basically getting the spotlight while the green plumber always plays second fiddle]]. The video was perfectly fine for the most part, but what [[WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy really grinds my gears]] is this: Mario mentions he at least had VideoGame/LuigisMansion which Luigi says was terrible. Okay, fine; no problem. I like the game, but I can see why others don't. Then Mario says "Luigi, it's-a [[UsefulNotes/NintendoGameCube GameCube]]; all of those games were terrible". [[BigWhat What!?]] And the [=GameCube=] hate apparently doesn't stop with this video; I recall them often repeatedly bashing the system in several videos. Okay, first of all: all [=GameCube=] games are terrible? I don't know about you, but I had fond memories of playing my [=GameCube=], and several others did as well. I remember playing the heck out of VideoGame/SuperMarioSunshine, VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaTheWindWaker, [[VideoGame/SonicAdventure2 Sonic Adventure 2 Battle]], and VideoGame/PaperMarioTheThousandYearDoor. And that's not even going into [[VideoGame/MetroidPrime several other]] [[VideoGame/ResidentEvil6 games that I]] [[VideoGame/StarFoxAssault missed out on]]. In fact, a lot of these "terrible" games have become fan favorites in recent years; heck ''Wind Waker'' got an HD re-release on the UsefulNotes/WiiU. Really, it's like these guys only think that [[TheyChangedItNowItSucks even for the most arbitrary change, the game automatically sucks]]. Second, putting all [=GameCube=] games in the same category of awful is a stupid generalization. I never had any interest in the UsefulNotes/Xbox360; does that mean all Xbox 360 games are terrible because of that? No; it just means I never took an interest in it! I may have merely mentioned this moment because I grew up with a [=GameCube=], but even if I wasn't a [=GameCube=] owner I would be headdesking so hard at this moment.

to:

* [=SenorCornholio=]: I have a small bone to pick with a throwaway line in the WebOriginal/CollegeHumor video, "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNlAZLCGLuU Luigi Finally Snaps]]". The plot of the video involves Luigi [[WhatTheHellHero calling out Mario for basically getting the spotlight while the green plumber always plays second fiddle]]. The video was perfectly fine for the most part, but what [[WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy really grinds my gears]] is this: Mario mentions he at least had VideoGame/LuigisMansion which Luigi says was terrible. Okay, fine; no problem. I like the game, but I can see why others don't. Then Mario says "Luigi, it's-a [[UsefulNotes/NintendoGameCube GameCube]]; all of those games were terrible". [[BigWhat What!?]] And the [=GameCube=] hate apparently doesn't stop with this video; I recall them often repeatedly bashing the system in several videos. Okay, first of all: all [=GameCube=] games are terrible? I don't know about you, but I had fond memories of playing my [=GameCube=], and several others did as well. I remember playing the heck out of VideoGame/SuperMarioSunshine, VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaTheWindWaker, [[VideoGame/SonicAdventure2 Sonic Adventure 2 Battle]], and VideoGame/PaperMarioTheThousandYearDoor. And that's not even going into [[VideoGame/MetroidPrime several other]] [[VideoGame/ResidentEvil6 games that I]] [[VideoGame/StarFoxAssault missed out on]]. In fact, a lot of these "terrible" games have become fan favorites in recent years; heck ''Wind Waker'' got an HD re-release on the UsefulNotes/WiiU. Really, it's like these guys only think that [[TheyChangedItNowItSucks even for the most arbitrary change, the game automatically sucks]]. Second, putting all [=GameCube=] games in the same category of awful is a stupid generalization. I never had any interest in the UsefulNotes/Xbox360; does that mean all Xbox 360 games are terrible because of that? No; it just means I never took an interest in it! Not every [=GameCube=] game is ''Aquaman: Battle For Atlantis'', and not every Xbox 360 game is VideoGame/SonicTheHedgehog2006. I may have merely mentioned this moment because I grew up with a [=GameCube=], but even if I wasn't a [=GameCube=] owner I would be headdesking so hard at this moment.
17th Feb '17 5:04:21 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* [=SenorCornholio=]: I have a small bone to pick with a throwaway line in the WebOriginal/CollegeHumor video, "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNlAZLCGLuU Luigi Finally Snaps]]". The plot of the video involves Luigi [[WhatTheHellHero calling out Mario for basically getting the spotlight while the green plumber always plays second fiddle]]. The video was perfectly fine for the most part, but what [[WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy really grinds my gears]] is this: Mario mentions he at least had VideoGame/LuigisMansion which Luigi says was terrible. Okay, fine; no problem. I like the game, but I can see why others don't. Then Mario says "Luigi, it's-a [[UsefulNotes/NintendoGameCube GameCube]]; all of those games were terrible". [[BigWhat What!?]] And the [=GameCube=] hate apparently doesn't stop with this video; I recall them often repeatedly bashing the system in several videos. Okay, first of all: all [=GameCube=] games are terrible? I don't know about you, but I had fond memories of playing my [=GameCube=], and several others did as well. I remember playing the heck out of VideoGame/SuperMarioSunshine, VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaThewindWaker, [[VideoGame/SonicAdventure2 Sonic Adventure 2 Battle]], and VideoGame/PaperMarioTheThousandYearDoor. And that's not even going into [[VideoGame/MetroidPrime several other]] [[VideoGame/ResidentEvil6 games that I]] [[VideoGame/StarFoxAssault missed out on]]. In fact, a lot of these "terrible" games have become fan favorites in recent years; heck ''Wind Waker'' got an HD re-release on the UsefulNotes/WiiU. Really, it's like these guys only think that [[TheyChangedItNowItSucks even for the most arbitrary change, the game automatically sucks]]. Second, putting all [=GameCube=] games in the same category of awful is a stupid generalization. I never had any interest in the UsefulNotes/Xbox360; does that mean all Xbox 360 games are terrible because of that? No; it just means I never took an interest in it! I may have merely mentioned this moment because I grew up with a [=GameCube=], but even if I wasn't a [=GameCube=] owner I would be headdesking so hard at this moment.

to:

* [=SenorCornholio=]: I have a small bone to pick with a throwaway line in the WebOriginal/CollegeHumor video, "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNlAZLCGLuU Luigi Finally Snaps]]". The plot of the video involves Luigi [[WhatTheHellHero calling out Mario for basically getting the spotlight while the green plumber always plays second fiddle]]. The video was perfectly fine for the most part, but what [[WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy really grinds my gears]] is this: Mario mentions he at least had VideoGame/LuigisMansion which Luigi says was terrible. Okay, fine; no problem. I like the game, but I can see why others don't. Then Mario says "Luigi, it's-a [[UsefulNotes/NintendoGameCube GameCube]]; all of those games were terrible". [[BigWhat What!?]] And the [=GameCube=] hate apparently doesn't stop with this video; I recall them often repeatedly bashing the system in several videos. Okay, first of all: all [=GameCube=] games are terrible? I don't know about you, but I had fond memories of playing my [=GameCube=], and several others did as well. I remember playing the heck out of VideoGame/SuperMarioSunshine, VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaThewindWaker, VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaTheWindWaker, [[VideoGame/SonicAdventure2 Sonic Adventure 2 Battle]], and VideoGame/PaperMarioTheThousandYearDoor. And that's not even going into [[VideoGame/MetroidPrime several other]] [[VideoGame/ResidentEvil6 games that I]] [[VideoGame/StarFoxAssault missed out on]]. In fact, a lot of these "terrible" games have become fan favorites in recent years; heck ''Wind Waker'' got an HD re-release on the UsefulNotes/WiiU. Really, it's like these guys only think that [[TheyChangedItNowItSucks even for the most arbitrary change, the game automatically sucks]]. Second, putting all [=GameCube=] games in the same category of awful is a stupid generalization. I never had any interest in the UsefulNotes/Xbox360; does that mean all Xbox 360 games are terrible because of that? No; it just means I never took an interest in it! I may have merely mentioned this moment because I grew up with a [=GameCube=], but even if I wasn't a [=GameCube=] owner I would be headdesking so hard at this moment.
17th Feb '17 5:03:08 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* [=SenorCornholio=]: I have a small bone to pick with a throwaway line in the WebOriginal/CollegeHumor video, "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNlAZLCGLuU Luigi Finally Snaps]]". The plot of the video involves Luigi [[WhatTheHellHero calling out Mario for basically getting the spotlight while the green plumber always plays second fiddle]]. The video was perfectly fine for the most part, but what [[WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy really grinds my gears]] is this: Mario mentions he at least had VideoGame/LuigisMansion which Luigi says was terrible. Okay, fine; no problem. I like the game, but I can see why others don't. Then Mario says "Luigi, it's-a UsefulNotes/GameCube; all of those games were terrible". [[BigWhat What!?]] And the GameCube hate apparently doesn't stop there; I recall them often repeatedly bashing the system in several videos. Okay, first of all: all GameCube games are terrible? I don't know about you, but I had fond memories of playing my GameCube, and several others did as well. I remember playing the heck out of VideoGame/SuperMarioSunshine, VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaThewindWaker, [[VideoGame/SonicAdventure2 Sonic Adventure 2 Battle]], and VideoGame/PaperMarioTheThousandYearDoor. And that's not even going into [[VideoGame/MetroidPrime several other]] [[VideoGame/ResidentEvil6 games that I]] [[VideoGame/StarFoxAssault missed out on]]. In fact, a lot of these "terrible" games have become fan favorites in recent years; heck ''Wind Waker'' got an HD release on the Wii U. Really, it's like these guys only think that [[TheyChangedItNowItSucks even for the most arbitrary change, the game automatically sucks]]. Second, putting all GameCube games in the same category of awful is a stupid generalization. I never had any interest in the Xbox 360; does that mean all Xbox 360 games are terrible because of that? No; it just means I never took an interest in it! I may have merely mentioned this moment because I grew up with a GameCube, but even if I wasn't a GameCube owner I would be headdesking so hard at this moment.

to:

* [=SenorCornholio=]: I have a small bone to pick with a throwaway line in the WebOriginal/CollegeHumor video, "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNlAZLCGLuU Luigi Finally Snaps]]". The plot of the video involves Luigi [[WhatTheHellHero calling out Mario for basically getting the spotlight while the green plumber always plays second fiddle]]. The video was perfectly fine for the most part, but what [[WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy really grinds my gears]] is this: Mario mentions he at least had VideoGame/LuigisMansion which Luigi says was terrible. Okay, fine; no problem. I like the game, but I can see why others don't. Then Mario says "Luigi, it's-a UsefulNotes/GameCube; [[UsefulNotes/NintendoGameCube GameCube]]; all of those games were terrible". [[BigWhat What!?]] And the GameCube [=GameCube=] hate apparently doesn't stop there; with this video; I recall them often repeatedly bashing the system in several videos. Okay, first of all: all GameCube [=GameCube=] games are terrible? I don't know about you, but I had fond memories of playing my GameCube, [=GameCube=], and several others did as well. I remember playing the heck out of VideoGame/SuperMarioSunshine, VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaThewindWaker, [[VideoGame/SonicAdventure2 Sonic Adventure 2 Battle]], and VideoGame/PaperMarioTheThousandYearDoor. And that's not even going into [[VideoGame/MetroidPrime several other]] [[VideoGame/ResidentEvil6 games that I]] [[VideoGame/StarFoxAssault missed out on]]. In fact, a lot of these "terrible" games have become fan favorites in recent years; heck ''Wind Waker'' got an HD release re-release on the Wii U.UsefulNotes/WiiU. Really, it's like these guys only think that [[TheyChangedItNowItSucks even for the most arbitrary change, the game automatically sucks]]. Second, putting all GameCube [=GameCube=] games in the same category of awful is a stupid generalization. I never had any interest in the Xbox 360; UsefulNotes/Xbox360; does that mean all Xbox 360 games are terrible because of that? No; it just means I never took an interest in it! I may have merely mentioned this moment because I grew up with a GameCube, [=GameCube=], but even if I wasn't a GameCube [=GameCube=] owner I would be headdesking so hard at this moment.
17th Feb '17 4:54:39 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* [=SenorCornholio=]: I have a small bone to pick with a throwaway line in the WebOriginal/CollegeHumor video, "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNlAZLCGLuU Luigi Finally Snaps]]". The plot of the video involves Luigi [[WhatTheHellHero calling out Mario for basically getting the spotlight while the green plumber always plays second fiddle]]. The video was perfectly fine for the most part, but what [[WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy really grinds my gears]] is this: Mario mentions he at least had VideoGame/LuigisMansion which Luigi says was terrible. Okay, fine; no problem. I like the game, but I can see why others don't. Then Mario says "Luigi, it's-a UsefulNotes/GameCube; all of those games were terrible]]". [[BigWhat What!?]] And the GameCube hate apparently doesn't stop there; I recall them often repeatedly bashing the system in several videos. Okay, first of all: all GameCube games are terrible? I don't know about you, but I had fond memories of playing my GameCube, and several others did as well. I remember playing the heck out of VideoGame/SuperMarioSunshine, VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaThewindWaker, [[VideoGame/SonicAdventure2 Sonic Adventure 2 Battle]], and VideoGame/PaperMarioTheThousandYearDoor. And that's not even going into [[VideoGame/MetroidPrime several other]] [[VideoGame/ResidentEvil6 games that I]] [[VideoGame/StarFoxAssault missed out on]]. In fact, a lot of these "terrible" games have become fan favorites in recent years; heck ''Wind Waker'' got an HD release on the Wii U. Really, it's like these guys only think that [[TheyChangedItNowItSucks even for the most arbitrary change, the game automatically sucks]]. Second, putting all GameCube games in the same category of awful is a stupid generalization. I never had any interest in the Xbox 360; does that mean all Xbox 360 games are terrible because of that? No; it just means I never took an interest in it! I may have merely mentioned this moment because I grew up with a GameCube, but even if I wasn't a GameCube owner I would be headdesking.

to:

* [=SenorCornholio=]: I have a small bone to pick with a throwaway line in the WebOriginal/CollegeHumor video, "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNlAZLCGLuU Luigi Finally Snaps]]". The plot of the video involves Luigi [[WhatTheHellHero calling out Mario for basically getting the spotlight while the green plumber always plays second fiddle]]. The video was perfectly fine for the most part, but what [[WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy really grinds my gears]] is this: Mario mentions he at least had VideoGame/LuigisMansion which Luigi says was terrible. Okay, fine; no problem. I like the game, but I can see why others don't. Then Mario says "Luigi, it's-a UsefulNotes/GameCube; all of those games were terrible]]".terrible". [[BigWhat What!?]] And the GameCube hate apparently doesn't stop there; I recall them often repeatedly bashing the system in several videos. Okay, first of all: all GameCube games are terrible? I don't know about you, but I had fond memories of playing my GameCube, and several others did as well. I remember playing the heck out of VideoGame/SuperMarioSunshine, VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaThewindWaker, [[VideoGame/SonicAdventure2 Sonic Adventure 2 Battle]], and VideoGame/PaperMarioTheThousandYearDoor. And that's not even going into [[VideoGame/MetroidPrime several other]] [[VideoGame/ResidentEvil6 games that I]] [[VideoGame/StarFoxAssault missed out on]]. In fact, a lot of these "terrible" games have become fan favorites in recent years; heck ''Wind Waker'' got an HD release on the Wii U. Really, it's like these guys only think that [[TheyChangedItNowItSucks even for the most arbitrary change, the game automatically sucks]]. Second, putting all GameCube games in the same category of awful is a stupid generalization. I never had any interest in the Xbox 360; does that mean all Xbox 360 games are terrible because of that? No; it just means I never took an interest in it! I may have merely mentioned this moment because I grew up with a GameCube, but even if I wasn't a GameCube owner I would be headdesking. headdesking so hard at this moment.
17th Feb '17 4:53:01 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* [=SenorCornholio=]: I have a small bone to pick with a throwaway line in the WebOriginal/CollegeHumor video, "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nNlAZLCGLuU Luigi Finally Snaps]]". The plot of the video involves Luigi [[WhatTheHellHero calling out Mario for basically getting the spotlight while the green plumber always plays second fiddle]]. The video was perfectly fine for the most part, but what [[WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy really grinds my gears]] is this: Mario mentions he at least had VideoGame/LuigisMansion which Luigi says was terrible. Okay, fine; no problem. I like the game, but I can see why others don't. Then Mario says "Luigi, it's-a UsefulNotes/GameCube; all of those games were terrible]]". [[BigWhat What!?]] And the GameCube hate apparently doesn't stop there; I recall them often repeatedly bashing the system in several videos. Okay, first of all: all GameCube games are terrible? I don't know about you, but I had fond memories of playing my GameCube, and several others did as well. I remember playing the heck out of VideoGame/SuperMarioSunshine, VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaThewindWaker, [[VideoGame/SonicAdventure2 Sonic Adventure 2 Battle]], and VideoGame/PaperMarioTheThousandYearDoor. And that's not even going into [[VideoGame/MetroidPrime several other]] [[VideoGame/ResidentEvil6 games that I]] [[VideoGame/StarFoxAssault missed out on]]. In fact, a lot of these "terrible" games have become fan favorites in recent years; heck ''Wind Waker'' got an HD release on the Wii U. Really, it's like these guys only think that [[TheyChangedItNowItSucks even for the most arbitrary change, the game automatically sucks]]. Second, putting all GameCube games in the same category of awful is a stupid generalization. I never had any interest in the Xbox 360; does that mean all Xbox 360 games are terrible because of that? No; it just means I never took an interest in it! I may have merely mentioned this moment because I grew up with a GameCube, but even if I wasn't a GameCube owner I would be headdesking.
15th Feb '17 11:22:26 AM CaptainTedium
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/CaptainTedium: I nominate ''Scientifically Accurate WesternAnimation/CatDog'' as the absolute worst of this shit. I was sick of the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series long ago because of all the works of fiction that were shamelessly defiled, but finding out that they did a "Scientifically Accurate" version of ''[=CatDog=]'' while doing a Google Images search on the Nickelodeon series made me just a little bit curious. I instantly regretted watching the video after seeing all the gross and disgusting jokes they made on what would happen in real life if a dog and a cat were surgically grafted together. For one, Cat and Dog were ConjoinedTwins rather than a canine and a feline sewn together, so this abominable video kind of [[ShallowParody misses the point of why Cat and Dog shared a body]]. Second, it really adds nothing new to the table and is just another unwatchable mess of applying RealityEnsues and {{Deconstruction}} to works where the laws of physics and reality weren't very important to begin with. Third, it was a needlessly spiteful and petty TakeThat to have Creator/Nickelodeon appear in the video as Nickel''odious''. Seeing this has made me swear off the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series for good. I shudder to think what they'd do with Mickey Mouse.

to:

* Tropers/CaptainTedium: I nominate ''Scientifically Accurate WesternAnimation/CatDog'' as the absolute worst of this shit. I was sick of the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series long ago because of all the works of fiction that were shamelessly defiled, but finding out that they did a "Scientifically Accurate" version of ''[=CatDog=]'' while doing a Google Images search on the Nickelodeon series made me just a little bit curious. I instantly regretted watching the video after seeing all the gross and disgusting jokes they made on what would happen in real life if a dog and a cat were surgically grafted together. For one, Cat and Dog were ConjoinedTwins rather than a canine and a feline sewn together, so this abominable video kind of [[ShallowParody misses the point of why Cat and Dog shared a body]]. Second, it really adds nothing new to the table and is just another unwatchable mess of applying RealityEnsues and {{Deconstruction}} to works where the laws of physics and reality weren't very important to begin with. Third, it was a needlessly spiteful and petty TakeThat to have Creator/Nickelodeon Creator/{{Nickelodeon}} appear in the video as Nickel''odious''. Seeing this has made me swear off the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series for good. I shudder to think what they'd do with Mickey Mouse.
15th Feb '17 11:20:34 AM CaptainTedium
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/CaptainTedium: I nominate ''Scientifically Accurate WesternAnimation/CatDog'' as the absolute worst of this shit. I was sick of the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series long ago because of all the works of fiction that were shamelessly defiled, but finding out that they did a "Scientifically Accurate" version of ''[=CatDog=]'' while doing a Google Images search on the Nickelodeon series made me just a little bit curious. I instantly regretted watching the video after seeing all the gross and disgusting jokes they made on what would happen in real life if a dog and a cat were surgically grafted together. For one, Cat and Dog were ConjoinedTwins rather than a canine and a feline sewn together, so this abominable video kind of [[ShallowParody misses the point of why Cat and Dog shared a body]]. Second, it really adds nothing new to the table and is just another unwatchable mess of applying RealityEnsues and {{Deconstruction}} to works where the laws of physics and reality weren't very important to begin with. Seeing this has made me swear off the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series for good. I shudder to think what they'd do with Mickey Mouse.

to:

* Tropers/CaptainTedium: I nominate ''Scientifically Accurate WesternAnimation/CatDog'' as the absolute worst of this shit. I was sick of the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series long ago because of all the works of fiction that were shamelessly defiled, but finding out that they did a "Scientifically Accurate" version of ''[=CatDog=]'' while doing a Google Images search on the Nickelodeon series made me just a little bit curious. I instantly regretted watching the video after seeing all the gross and disgusting jokes they made on what would happen in real life if a dog and a cat were surgically grafted together. For one, Cat and Dog were ConjoinedTwins rather than a canine and a feline sewn together, so this abominable video kind of [[ShallowParody misses the point of why Cat and Dog shared a body]]. Second, it really adds nothing new to the table and is just another unwatchable mess of applying RealityEnsues and {{Deconstruction}} to works where the laws of physics and reality weren't very important to begin with. Third, it was a needlessly spiteful and petty TakeThat to have Creator/Nickelodeon appear in the video as Nickel''odious''. Seeing this has made me swear off the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series for good. I shudder to think what they'd do with Mickey Mouse.
14th Feb '17 7:01:53 PM CoCage
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** [=CoCage=]: Max's buddy, Simmons isn't perfect either, a guy known for being a know-it-all and opinionated. In their Super Nintendo stream on twitch (the one with the Power Ranges SNES fighting game), Simmons goes on rant about how people who enjoy ''Anime/KillLaKill'' forces themselves to like it. What's worse he take's Miyazaki's "Anime was a mistake" quote out of context and uses thus as his argument on why the show was bad including low budget animation but high quality fight scenes, and not a good story. The only problem is that this is hypocrisy to its highest degree as many (old) anime that Simmons and his pals enjoy suffer from this. While I prefer most old-school anime similar to them, I won't go out of my way to insult people for liking a decent show. What's funny is all the problems he criticizes for Kill La Kill, the same thing happens in ''Attack on Titan''; an anime he enjoys. ''[=AoT=]'' has all the same problems budget, but on animation (still higher quality compared to Kill La Kill), and a story with interesting premise, but horrible execution. The only difference is Kill La Kill at least had a planned beginning, middle, and end with characters that actually develop, while Attack on Titan suffers the same problems from other long running anime. I call it ''Dragonball Z'', ''Bleach'', or ''One Piece'' syndrome. Simmons if you don't like certain shows or any media in general, that's fine and dandy, but don't act like your opinion is an undisputed fact. This is why I don't watch his solo streams or take most things he's says with a grain of salt.

to:

** [=CoCage=]: Max's buddy, Simmons isn't perfect either, either; a guy known for being a know-it-all and opinionated. In their Super Nintendo stream on twitch (the one with the Power Ranges SNES fighting game), Simmons goes on rant about how people who enjoy ''Anime/KillLaKill'' forces themselves to like it. What's worse he take's Miyazaki's "Anime was a mistake" mistake..." quote out of context and uses thus this as his argument on why the show was bad including low budget animation but high quality fight scenes, and not a good story. The only problem is that this is hypocrisy to its highest degree as many (old) anime that Simmons and his pals enjoy suffer from this. While I prefer most old-school anime similar to them, I won't go out of my way to insult people for liking a decent show. What's funny is all the problems he criticizes for Kill La Kill, the same thing happens in ''Attack on Titan''; an anime he enjoys. ''[=AoT=]'' has all the same problems budget, but problems: cut budget on animation (still higher quality compared to Kill La Kill), except fight scenes, and a story with interesting premise, but horrible execution. The only difference is Kill La Kill at least had a planned beginning, middle, and end with characters that actually develop, while Attack on Titan suffers the same problems from other long running anime. I call it ''Dragonball Z'', ''Bleach'', or ''One Piece'' syndrome. Simmons if you don't like certain shows or any media in general, games, that's fine and dandy, but don't act like your opinion is an undisputed fact. This is why I don't watch his solo streams or take most things he's says with a grain of salt.
14th Feb '17 6:56:25 PM CoCage
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** [=CoCage=]: Max's buddy, Simmons isn't perfect either, a guy known for being a know-it-all and opinionated. In their Super Nintendo stream on twitch (the one with the Power Ranges SNES fighting game), Simmons goes on rant about how people who enjoy ''Anime/KillLaKill'' forces themselves to like it. What's worse he take's Miyazaki's "Anime was a mistake" quote out of context and uses thus as his argument on why the show was bad including low budget animation but high quality fight scenes, and not a good story. The only problem is that this is hypocrisy to its highest degree as many (old) anime that Simmons and his pals enjoy suffer from this. While I prefer most old-school anime similar to them, I won't go out of my way to insult people for liking a decent show. What's funny is all the problems he criticizes for Kill La Kill, the same thing happens in ''Attack on Titan''; an anime he enjoys. ''[=AoT=]'' has all the same problems budget, but on animation (still higher quality compared to Kill La Kill), and a story with interesting premise, but horrible execution. The only difference is Kill La Kill at least had a planned beginning, middle, and end with characters that actually develop, while Attack on Titan suffers the same problems from other long running anime. I call it ''Dragonball Z'', ''Bleach'', or ''One Piece'' syndrome. Simmons if you don't like certain shows or any media in general, that's fine and dandy, but don't act like your opinion is an undisputed fact. This is why I don't watch his solo streams or take most things he's says with a grain of salt.
14th Feb '17 5:28:28 PM FromtheWordsofBR
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: I liked his ''Search for the Worst'' review of the ''WebVideo/{{Fred}}'' Movie Trilogy and even though the bit with his friend Ralphthemoviemaker was decent. However, around 30 minutes in, after snarking about a video where Lucas says he doesn't remember filming the "Fred vs. TheAnnoyingOrange" video, he then says that's the result of blackouts and trying to repress memories. Then the video pauses for Ralph to make a [[OverlyLongGag really long]] [[{{Squick}} and unnecessarily uncomfortable]] child molestation joke. It goes on for what feels like forever (it lasts a minute!!), it contradicts some of Alex's points regarding comedy (in that jokes need a punchline to be funny....this one doesn't, it's also very similar to a scene in the movie Alex also criticized for also being drawn-out), and worst of all, it's not funny, not even in the black sort of sense. I know Ralph's bit was produced by himself but there was no need for that joke and it soured the video a bit for me (still a damn good video either way, but good lord) due to how unnecessary and hypocritical it was.

to:

* [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: I liked his ''Search for the Worst'' review of the ''WebVideo/{{Fred}}'' Movie Trilogy and even though the bit with his friend Ralphthemoviemaker was decent.good. However, around 30 minutes in, after snarking about a video where Lucas says he doesn't remember filming the "Fred vs. TheAnnoyingOrange" video, he then says that's the result of blackouts and trying to repress memories. Then the video pauses for Ralph to make a [[OverlyLongGag really long]] [[{{Squick}} and unnecessarily uncomfortable]] child molestation joke. It goes on for what feels like forever (it lasts a minute!!), it contradicts some of Alex's points regarding comedy (in that jokes need a punchline to be funny....this one doesn't, it's also very similar to a scene in the movie Alex also criticized for also being drawn-out), and worst of all, it's not funny, not even in the black sort of sense. I know Ralph's bit was produced by himself but there was no need for that joke and it soured the video a bit for me (still a damn good video either way, but good lord) due to how unnecessary and hypocritical it was. Also, Ralph avoids using {{Overly Long Gag}}s in his videos for the most part.
13th Feb '17 8:25:16 PM Loekman3
Is there an issue? Send a Message



to:

* Creators do not have the privilege to remove a moment regarding their own work. It's their own opinion and should be treated as a form of criticism. If they do remove it, please report it and readd the moment back.
13th Feb '17 7:36:20 PM MorphinBrony
Is there an issue? Send a Message



to:

WARNING: SURPRISINGLY ENOUGH, THIS IS OUR OPINION. DON'T GET YOUR [[DethroningMomentOfSuck MISTAKES]] IN A TWIST.
13th Feb '17 7:15:27 PM MorphinBrony
Is there an issue? Send a Message


From [[CriticalResearchFailure entries that have about as much research in them as the Jimmy McPerson essay]] to jokes that would make Seth McFarlane shake his head, we count down [[DethroningMomentOfSuck the worst Planet Dolan moments of all time]].

to:

From [[CriticalResearchFailure entries that have about as much research in them as the Jimmy McPerson essay]] to jokes that would make Seth McFarlane Creator/SethMacFarlane shake his head, we count down [[DethroningMomentOfSuck the worst Planet Dolan moments of all time]].
13th Feb '17 3:01:20 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most [[CausticCritic Caustic Critics]] however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of lists. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater (As you can see in the flavor text). But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every single Franchise/ScoobyDoo remake in existence]]! Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "The original was never any good to begin with, so the franchise should have died years ago!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years despite the original's lack of appeal to him. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, especially if it's a show I don't like. But I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place the entire franchise at #1 on a Worst Remakes list and bash it simply because of it's lifespan and the quality of the original alone. Not to mention that he seems to think that [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] is, like the other remakes he mentions, exactly the same as the original. Oh, and Strider seemed to had [[TookALevelInJerkass taken a level in jerkass]] for this entry. Usually, he just expresses his distaste in a professional and witty manner like the classy DeadpanSnarker he is. Here it sounds more like he's trying to rally all of his viewers against the franchise, what with him having the gall to assume that nobody actively watches [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] anyway, asking "Has any kid ever sat down and said, 'Oh, look! [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] is on!'?", and claiming that kids only watch it when there's nothing better to watch. Excuse me Strider, but I watched both [[spoiler: What's New, Scooby-Doo?]] and [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] regularly when I was a kid and loved them. Again, this is coming from a guy who claims to be fine with people liking something he doesn't. This assumption is not only hypocritical and insulting, it makes no sense. If a series has been remade over 19 times, then it must have some sort of fanbase otherwise it wouldn't have been remade even once! Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I was so disappointed with him, I couldn't bring myself to listen to him re-explain why he hates [[spoiler:Scooby Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/P9NLefklYK8 Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes list]] and skipped over it. (But judging by his added comment of "Forever" in the entry title, he was trying to justify cramming the entire franchise on the top spot of his Worst Remakes list). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".

to:

* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most [[CausticCritic Caustic Critics]] however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of lists. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater (As you can see in the flavor text). But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every single Franchise/ScoobyDoo remake in existence]]! Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "The original was never any good to begin with, so the franchise should have died years ago!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years despite the original's lack of appeal to him. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, especially if it's a show I don't like. But I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place the entire franchise at #1 on a Worst Remakes list and bash it simply because of it's lifespan and the quality of the original alone. Not to mention that he seems to think that [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] is, like the other remakes he mentions, exactly the same as the original. Oh, and Strider seemed to had have [[TookALevelInJerkass taken a level in jerkass]] for this entry. Usually, he just expresses his distaste in a professional and witty manner like the classy DeadpanSnarker he is. Here it sounds more like he's trying to rally all of his viewers against the franchise, what with him having the gall to assume that nobody actively watches [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] anyway, asking "Has any kid ever sat down and said, 'Oh, look! [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] is on!'?", and claiming that kids only watch it when there's nothing better to watch. Excuse me Strider, but I watched both [[spoiler: What's New, Scooby-Doo?]] and [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] regularly when I was a kid and loved them. Again, this is coming from a guy who claims to be fine with people liking something he doesn't. This assumption is not only hypocritical and insulting, it makes no sense. If a series has been remade over 19 times, then it must have some sort of fanbase otherwise it wouldn't have been remade even once! Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I was so disappointed with him, I couldn't bring myself to listen to him re-explain why he hates [[spoiler:Scooby Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/P9NLefklYK8 Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes list]] and skipped over it. (But judging by his added comment of "Forever" in the entry title, he was trying to justify cramming the entire franchise on the top spot of his Worst Remakes list). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".
13th Feb '17 3:00:20 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most [[CausticCritic Caustic Critics]] however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of lists. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater (As you can see in the flavor text). But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every single Franchise/ScoobyDoo remake in existence]]! Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "The original was never any good to begin with, so the franchise should have died years ago!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years despite the original's lack of appeal to him. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, especially if it's a show I don't like. But I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place the entire franchise at #1 on a Worst Remakes list and bash it simply because of it's lifespan and the quality of the original alone. Not to mention that he seems to think that [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] is, like the other remakes he mentions, exactly the same as the original. Oh, and Strider seemed to had TakenALevelInJerkass for this entry. Usually, he just expresses his distaste in a professional and witty manner like the classy DeadpanSnarker he is. Here it sounds more like he's trying to rally all of his viewers against the franchise, what with him having the gall to assume that nobody actively watches [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] anyway, asking "Has any kid ever sat down and said, 'Oh, look! [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] is on!'?", and claiming that kids only watch it when there's nothing better to watch. Excuse me Strider, but I watched both [[spoiler: What's New, Scooby-Doo?]] and [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] regularly when I was a kid and loved them. Again, this is coming from a guy who claims to be fine with people liking something he doesn't. This assumption is not only hypocritical and insulting, it makes no sense. If a series has been remade over 19 times, then it must have some sort of fanbase otherwise it wouldn't have been remade even once! Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I was so disappointed with him, I couldn't bring myself to listen to him re-explain why he hates [[spoiler:Scooby Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/P9NLefklYK8 Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes list]] and skipped over it. (But judging by his added comment of "Forever" in the entry title, he was trying to justify cramming the entire franchise on the top spot of his Worst Remakes list). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".

to:

* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most [[CausticCritic Caustic Critics]] however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of lists. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater (As you can see in the flavor text). But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every single Franchise/ScoobyDoo remake in existence]]! Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "The original was never any good to begin with, so the franchise should have died years ago!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years despite the original's lack of appeal to him. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, especially if it's a show I don't like. But I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place the entire franchise at #1 on a Worst Remakes list and bash it simply because of it's lifespan and the quality of the original alone. Not to mention that he seems to think that [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] is, like the other remakes he mentions, exactly the same as the original. Oh, and Strider seemed to had TakenALevelInJerkass [[TookALevelInJerkass taken a level in jerkass]] for this entry. Usually, he just expresses his distaste in a professional and witty manner like the classy DeadpanSnarker he is. Here it sounds more like he's trying to rally all of his viewers against the franchise, what with him having the gall to assume that nobody actively watches [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] anyway, asking "Has any kid ever sat down and said, 'Oh, look! [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] is on!'?", and claiming that kids only watch it when there's nothing better to watch. Excuse me Strider, but I watched both [[spoiler: What's New, Scooby-Doo?]] and [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] regularly when I was a kid and loved them. Again, this is coming from a guy who claims to be fine with people liking something he doesn't. This assumption is not only hypocritical and insulting, it makes no sense. If a series has been remade over 19 times, then it must have some sort of fanbase otherwise it wouldn't have been remade even once! Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I was so disappointed with him, I couldn't bring myself to listen to him re-explain why he hates [[spoiler:Scooby Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/P9NLefklYK8 Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes list]] and skipped over it. (But judging by his added comment of "Forever" in the entry title, he was trying to justify cramming the entire franchise on the top spot of his Worst Remakes list). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".
13th Feb '17 1:39:32 PM TheFarmboy
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** SCPIhpkmn: I have far less kind things to say about Jontron. On a recent live stream (recent as of mid-February 2017), he went off on a political tirade about... well, let's just say that it was rather offensive and leave it at that. I find it impossible to enjoy his work now that I know that he's a close-minded jackoff, and this is a perfect example of why content creators shouldn't let their politics mix with their work. Not helping matters is the fact that most of the comments sections on his videos are now filled with support from groups that are... exercising the RuleOfCautiousEditingJudgement here... better suited to Jackson, Mississippi circa the 1960s than the modern zeitgeist. TL;DR: Fuck off, Jontron.
12th Feb '17 11:55:24 PM vexer
Is there an issue? Send a Message


[[/folder]

to:

[[/folder]
[[/folder]]
12th Feb '17 11:54:02 PM vexer
Is there an issue? Send a Message



to:

[[/folder]
12th Feb '17 11:52:14 PM vexer
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Extra Credits]]
* Vexer Normally I love the EC guys, but sometimes they can really go off the deep end(I.E. their videos about "Hatred" and "Call of Juarez: The Cartel"), but by far their absolute worst episode bar none would have to be "The Division: Problematic Meaning in Mechanics" which is the worst case of CriticalResearchFailure and PoliticalCorrectnessGoneMad that i've ever seen. It's abundantly clear that the EC guys only played the game for a couple of hours, as they claim the game is about gunning down innocent civilians, which is a blatant lie as all the NPCs you have to kill are hostile to you from the start and all belong to violent gangs which kill and terrorize innocent people. They also assume that the game is "racist" cause the enemies wear hoodies, they apparently did not take into consideration that the game was made by a Swedish developer, so it's very likely they did not realize that people would misinterpret it. The EC guys also painfully try and make a case about how the game is supporting Totalitarianism, which it clearly is not since society itself has collapsed, also their points about being "judge jury and executioner" fall flat considering New York is under martial law, which means due process is suspended. I could go on and on about how many errors that video has, but my overall point is that the EC guys were letting emotion overtake logic and completely failing to do any actual research on the game itself, and in the past EC were good about responding to criticism from people about their videos, but not anymore it seems, as they never apologized for the inaccuracies in this video or the ones in the "Cartel" and "Hatred" episodes.
12th Feb '17 5:12:33 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation of the original WesternAnimation/TheRealGhostbusters with clear ties to its predecessor, and WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list despite being the first Franchise/SonicTheHedgehog cartoon ever aired (and though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do, it sadly qualifies more than AoSTH for this list due to having similarities to WesternAnimation/SonicSatAM and [[ComicBook/ArchieComicsSonicTheHedgehog the comics]], the former of which was heavily anticipated for a comeback after its SequelHook). And apparently, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ViPq-aJKB0c I am not alone]] [[https://youtu.be/JvXKtIpkbuw in thinking this]]. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice. RebelTaxi might have also put the entire franchise on his list of worst remakes because he also wanted it to just die already, but at least he didn't put it at numero freaking uno (Plus, it was PlayedForLaughs). Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't; instead he goes through a long laundry list of "remakes" that aren't even listed in how bad they are. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise; also very easy to do as [[spoiler: Mystery Incorporated]] was included in the rundown (quick update: as of his "Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes" list, he has watched [[spoiler:Mystery Inc.]] and found it refreshing; strike off for that one). I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.

to:

** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation of the original WesternAnimation/TheRealGhostbusters with clear ties to its predecessor, and WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list despite being the first Franchise/SonicTheHedgehog cartoon ever aired (and though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do, it sadly qualifies more than AoSTH [=AoSTH=] for this list due to having similarities to WesternAnimation/SonicSatAM and [[ComicBook/ArchieComicsSonicTheHedgehog the comics]], the former of which was heavily anticipated for a comeback after its SequelHook). And apparently, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ViPq-aJKB0c I am not alone]] [[https://youtu.be/JvXKtIpkbuw in thinking this]]. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice. RebelTaxi might have also put the entire franchise on his list of worst remakes because he also wanted it to just die already, but at least he didn't put it at numero freaking uno (Plus, it was PlayedForLaughs). Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't; instead he goes through a long laundry list of "remakes" that aren't even listed in how bad they are. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise; also very easy to do as [[spoiler: Mystery Incorporated]] was included in the rundown (quick update: as of his "Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes" list, he has watched [[spoiler:Mystery Inc.]] and found it refreshing; strike off for that one). I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.
12th Feb '17 5:11:40 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** SenorCornholio: I have recently warmed up to Racist Mario due to the voice clips being used in some of [[Machinima/Supermarioglitchy4sSuperMario64Bloopers SMG4's videos]], but that doesn't change the fact that overall, this video is heavily flawed in more ways than one. I could go on about the unfunny jokes, the nonsensical plot, etc, but what I think makes the whole thing fall apart: the premise. Mario goes insane and starts killing everyone because of all the third-party characters in the current race. Why does this not work? Well firstly, because there has never been a third-party character in a main Mario Kart title. The DLC characters for Mario Kart 8 were all from other Nintendo franchises, and therefore first-party. Secondly, the characters themselves; [[VideoGame/SegaSuperstars Sonic may have been playable in several Sega-themed sports and racing titles]], but the only time he crossed over with Nintendo itself was in VideoGame/SuperSmashBros. And even then, Knuckles wasn't even playable so that's out. It's like some of these franchises were listed all because of their racing titles, [[Franchise/StarWars Anakin]] and [[VideoGame/CrashBandicoot Crash's head]] also being standout examples. Thirdly, speaking of Sony, was there an alternate universe I'm not aware of where Sony and Nintendo crossed over and [[VideoGame/LittleBigPlanet Sackboy]] and [[VideoGame/GodOfWar Kratos]] were put into karts? I'll admit that Kratos driving a tiny kart is a funny sight, but what's the point? Ironically, there's one crossover that I doubt Flashgitz even knows he got right, and that's Pac-Man's head on a spear, since he was playable in the Arcade GP games developed by Namco-Bandai. Other than that, the rest of the references are shallow at best and make absolutely no sense at worst. Now if you'll excuse me, I'm gonna go watch [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynKRJt4CDMY the version where all the violence is replaced with The Nutshack]]. It's somehow way better.

to:

** SenorCornholio: I have recently warmed up to Racist Mario due to the voice clips being used in some of [[Machinima/Supermarioglitchy4sSuperMario64Bloopers SMG4's videos]], but that doesn't change the fact that overall, this video is heavily flawed in more ways than one. I could go on about the unfunny jokes, the nonsensical plot, etc, but what I think makes the whole thing fall apart: the premise. Mario goes insane and starts killing everyone because of all the third-party characters in the current race. Why does this not work? Well firstly, because there has never been a third-party character in a main Mario Kart title. The DLC characters for Mario Kart 8 were all from other Nintendo franchises, and therefore first-party. Secondly, the characters themselves; [[VideoGame/SegaSuperstars Sonic may have been playable in several Sega-themed sports and racing titles]], but the only time he crossed over with Nintendo itself was in VideoGame/SuperSmashBros. And even then, Knuckles wasn't even playable so that's out. It's like some of these franchises were listed all because of their racing titles, with [[Franchise/StarWars Anakin]] and [[VideoGame/CrashBandicoot Crash's head]] also being standout examples. Thirdly, speaking of Sony, was there an alternate universe I'm not aware of where Sony and Nintendo crossed over and [[VideoGame/LittleBigPlanet Sackboy]] and [[VideoGame/GodOfWar Kratos]] were put into karts? I'll admit that Kratos driving a tiny kart is a funny sight, but what's the point? Ironically, there's one crossover that I doubt Flashgitz even knows he got right, and that's Pac-Man's head on a spear, since he was playable in the Arcade GP games developed by Namco-Bandai. Other than that, the rest of the references are shallow at best and make absolutely no sense at worst. Now if you'll excuse me, I'm gonna go watch [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynKRJt4CDMY the version where all the violence is replaced with The Nutshack]]. It's somehow way better.



** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list despite being the first Franchise/SonicTheHedgehog cartoon ever aired (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation of the original WesternAnimation/TheRealGhostbusters with clear ties to its predecessor. And apparently, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ViPq-aJKB0c I am not alone]] [[https://youtu.be/JvXKtIpkbuw in thinking this]]. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice. RebelTaxi might have also put the entire franchise on his list of worst remakes because he also wanted it to just die already, but at least he didn't put it at numero freaking uno (Plus, it was PlayedForLaughs). Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't; instead he goes through a long laundry list of "remakes" that aren't even listed in how bad they are. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise; also very easy to do as [[spoiler: Mystery Incorporated]] was included in the rundown (quick update: as of his "Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes" list, he has watched [[spoiler:Mystery Inc.]] and found it refreshing; strike off for that one). I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.

to:

** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation of the original WesternAnimation/TheRealGhostbusters with clear ties to its predecessor, and WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list despite being the first Franchise/SonicTheHedgehog cartoon ever aired (though (and though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do), do, it sadly qualifies more than AoSTH for this list due to having similarities to WesternAnimation/SonicSatAM and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation of [[ComicBook/ArchieComicsSonicTheHedgehog the original WesternAnimation/TheRealGhostbusters with clear ties to comics]], the former of which was heavily anticipated for a comeback after its predecessor.SequelHook). And apparently, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ViPq-aJKB0c I am not alone]] [[https://youtu.be/JvXKtIpkbuw in thinking this]]. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice. RebelTaxi might have also put the entire franchise on his list of worst remakes because he also wanted it to just die already, but at least he didn't put it at numero freaking uno (Plus, it was PlayedForLaughs). Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't; instead he goes through a long laundry list of "remakes" that aren't even listed in how bad they are. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise; also very easy to do as [[spoiler: Mystery Incorporated]] was included in the rundown (quick update: as of his "Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes" list, he has watched [[spoiler:Mystery Inc.]] and found it refreshing; strike off for that one). I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.
12th Feb '17 2:27:12 PM Wyldchyld
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/{{Jonn}}: ''anachronauts'' arc 3, fs03. The female elf Nel was rescued by and fell in love with space-girl Una, [[IncompatibleOrientation who is straight]]. Okay, plenty of healthy relationships have grown out of a RescueRomance. She doesn't tell her. Okay, that's reasonable. Nel [[http://xkcd.com/513/ decides to devote her life to being Una's best friend]]. [[UnfortunateImplications Um, what?]] Nel never gets any significant characterization, background, or personality traits other than being in love with Una. [[SatelliteLoveInterest Hmm]]. [[spoiler:Nel is tempted by a genie to kill one of the other Anachronauts in order to have Una. She refuses, saying that she'd rather have Una naturally. You go, girl. And then in fs03, Una gets her hands on the sense-recording earrings Nel has been wearing since the beginning of the arc, and is able to effectively be Nel as she talked to the Genie, including her declaration of love. She re-evaluates her interactions with Nel, and then instantly realizes she loves her. Please note that Una has been exclusively heterosexual up to this point, and realizing she likes girls in general and loves Nel in particular is portrayed as [[SuddenlySexuality basically flipping a switch]]. Oh, and the author pretty clearly [[AuthorAppeal has a fetish for lesbians]], as it popped up in his earlier ''SailorNothing'', and in an aside in arc 2. Their friendship is written as exactly that; a friendship, with no romantic or sexual tension. Compared to the other romances in the series, which are written much more organically, it seems more like a StrangledByTheRedString RomanticPlotTumor than an actual romance. Nel and Una are given some "private time" at the end of that chapter, which would be ideal for showing their conversation before the inevitable sex and underlining the fact that they actually do have feelings for each other, except we never get to see it.]] Did I mention that there had been no other significant LGBT characters in the series up to that point? Yes, that's right, the only known homosexual is there for solely for the purpose of FetishFuel. It's kinda creepy, and I couldn't read the series after that.

to:

* Tropers/{{Jonn}}: ''anachronauts'' arc 3, fs03. The female elf Nel was rescued by and fell in love with space-girl Una, [[IncompatibleOrientation who is straight]]. Okay, plenty of healthy relationships have grown out of a RescueRomance. She doesn't tell her. Okay, that's reasonable. Nel [[http://xkcd.com/513/ decides to devote her life to being Una's best friend]]. [[UnfortunateImplications Um, what?]] Nel never gets any significant characterization, background, or personality traits other than being in love with Una. [[SatelliteLoveInterest Hmm]]. [[spoiler:Nel is tempted by a genie to kill one of the other Anachronauts in order to have Una. She refuses, saying that she'd rather have Una naturally. You go, girl. And then in fs03, Una gets her hands on the sense-recording earrings Nel has been wearing since the beginning of the arc, and is able to effectively be Nel as she talked to the Genie, including her declaration of love. She re-evaluates her interactions with Nel, and then instantly realizes she loves her. Please note that Una has been exclusively heterosexual up to this point, and realizing she likes girls in general and loves Nel in particular is portrayed as [[SuddenlySexuality basically flipping a switch]]. Oh, and the author pretty clearly [[AuthorAppeal has a fetish for lesbians]], as it popped up in his earlier ''SailorNothing'', and in an aside in arc 2. Their friendship is written as exactly that; a friendship, with no romantic or sexual tension. Compared to the other romances in the series, which are written much more organically, it seems more like a StrangledByTheRedString RomanticPlotTumor than an actual romance. Nel and Una are given some "private time" at the end of that chapter, which would be ideal for showing their conversation before the inevitable sex and underlining the fact that they actually do have feelings for each other, except we never get to see it.]] Did I mention that there had been no other significant LGBT characters in the series up to that point? Yes, that's right, the only known homosexual is there for solely for the purpose of FetishFuel.catering to {{fetish}}es. It's kinda creepy, and I couldn't read the series after that.
12th Feb '17 1:20:32 AM SCPIhpkmn
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** SCPIhpkmn: I have far less kind things to say about Jontron. On a recent live stream (recent as of mid-February 2017), he went off on a political tirade about... well, let's just say that it was rather offensive and leave it at that. I find it impossible to enjoy his work now that I know that he's a close-minded jackoff, and this is a perfect example of why content creators shouldn't let their politics mix with their work. Not helping matters is the fact that most of the comments sections on his videos are now filled with support from groups that are... exercising the RuleOfCautiousEditingJudgement here... better suited to Jackson, Mississippi circa the 1960s than the modern zeitgeist. TL;DR: Fuck off, Jontron.
11th Feb '17 10:03:01 PM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Sugarp1e1: Another commentator by the name of Doodletones has commentated on videos against Mr. Enter before (defending him despite not liking him anymore) and the way she sums up those videos can be applied here; "Mr. Enter is wrong because he's Mr. Enter". Seriously, it feels like this guy is only bad-mouthing these shows because Mr. Enter likes them and nothing else. Sure, he tries to argue, but his aruguments boil down to "I don't like these shows, therefore they're overrated bullshit". And that's ignoring the hypocrisy. He gets on Enter's case for being immature, yet he judges ''Steven Universe'' solely on the worst of its fanbase alone. I'm not even a big fan of Mr. Enter (who is, at best, a GuiltyPleasure of mine), and this still bothered me.
11th Feb '17 8:47:50 AM shonengirl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** shonengirl: Third. This is hands down, the worst thing in the history of his channel. Two things I [[BerserkButton absolutely hate]] are when reviewers seem to know little about what they're talking about, and when they lump things of varying quality into one mass and declare them all bad/judge them all solely on the quality of some of them or an unfortunate DorkAge. Basically, I despise CriticalResearchFailure... And him putting every single [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] reboot on that list just screamed both of these things. Okay Strider, what about the Tom and Jerry, Ninja Turtles, anything Mickey Mouse related, and Looney Toons reboots, are ''they'' bad too because their franchises have been around for a long time and have truckloads of reboots? No? Actually, what ''about'' Tom and Jerry? It's also a Hanna-Barbera franchise that has been around forever, if not even longer than [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]], but he conveniently forgets that, doesn't he? There are many LongRunners that continue to be loved to this day, so by this logic they're all bad simply because they've been around to see the civil rights movement... [[SarcasmMode Sure, Strider, sure]]. [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] was actually pretty solid and had deviated quite a bit from the normal episodic format, not to mention the series fills in a western animation niche that doesn't get filled often in the modern day, the genre of mystery. The only other modern cartoon in this genre I can think of is Gravity Falls, which ended, while [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] will continue filling this niche with a fresh new take every time. Oh yeah, what about counting movies as reboots? ...Huh?! I've disagreed with him before, sure, but respected his opinion because he's a genuinely nice person and entertaining on top of it; this was the only time I ever cringed at this guy's content ever. I'm not even a huge fan of [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]], but this was just bad! It just really reminds me of those people who think Pokémon is a series consisting of the same game released over and over again, or whining that Nintendo has no innovation despite many of their franchises evolving over the years. To make it worse, I criticised him for this, and if I didn't accidentally delete it, he apparently removed my comment. Come on, Strider, I expect more from you! Oh yeah, and [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking how the hell is Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog a reboot?! Shouldn't video game adaptations have a list of their own?]]

to:

** shonengirl: Third. This is hands down, the worst thing in the history of his channel. Two things I [[BerserkButton absolutely hate]] are when reviewers seem to know little about what they're talking about, and when they lump things of varying quality into one mass and declare them all bad/judge them all solely on the quality of some of them or an unfortunate DorkAge. Basically, I despise CriticalResearchFailure... And him putting every single [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] reboot on that list just screamed both of these things. Okay Strider, what about the Tom and Jerry, Ninja Turtles, anything Mickey Mouse related, and Looney Toons reboots, are ''they'' bad too because their franchises have been around for a long time and have truckloads of reboots? No? Actually, what ''about'' Tom and Jerry? It's also a Hanna-Barbera franchise that has been around forever, if not even longer than [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]], but he conveniently forgets that, doesn't he? There are many LongRunners that continue to be loved to this day, so by this logic they're all bad simply because they've been around to see the civil rights movement... [[SarcasmMode Sure, Strider, sure]]. [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] was actually pretty solid and had deviated quite a bit from the normal episodic format, not to mention the series fills in a western animation niche that doesn't get filled often in the modern day, the genre of mystery. The only other modern cartoon in this genre I can think of is Gravity Falls, which ended, while [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] will continue filling this niche with a fresh new take every time. Oh yeah, what about counting movies as reboots? ...Huh?! I've disagreed with him before, sure, but respected his opinion because he's he seems like a genuinely nice person and is entertaining on top of it; this was the only time I ever cringed at this guy's content ever. I'm not even a huge fan of [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]], but this was just bad! It just really reminds me of those people who think Pokémon is a series consisting of the same game released over and over again, or whining that Nintendo has no innovation despite many of their franchises evolving over the years. To make it worse, I criticised criticized him for this, and if I didn't accidentally delete it, he apparently removed my comment. Come on, Strider, I expect more from you! Oh yeah, and [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking how the hell is Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog a reboot?! Shouldn't video game adaptations have a list of their own?]]



** shonengirl: The above two don't really bother me that much, since I know where he's coming from, except for the joke, but still it was just somewhat tasteless. However, his review of ''Anime/PokemonOrigins'' was just poorly made. Highlights include mistaking the year the first Pokemon games were released as 1995 (it's actually 1996, and to make this worse this was shown in a clip in the video itself) and mistaking 2015 as its 20th anniversary (so this wasn't a script error either), questioning why Team Rocket needs scientists and wild Pokemon to create and test the Master Ball, and apparently not knowing who Red, one of the most well-known and well-loved characters in the fandom, to the point of being a MemeticBadass, is. The worst and most cringeworthy part, however, has to be him seeing ''Origins'' being TruerToTheText of the original games as a flaw, and that it takes away the "charm" of the anime. Um... [[CompletelyMissingThePoint That's the point, bro]]. It's supposed to be a more faithful adaptation. Stop thinking about the main anime, that has almost nothing to do with ''Origins'', an adaptation of game canon, and the two should be kept as far, far away from eachother as possible. Anyone who is familiar with the Pokemon fandom will tell you that mixing up the games and anime is a major BerserkButton for many fans of the games, and it highly annoys me as well. You know why many fans of the games hate the anime? One of the reasons is that it deviates from the games so much like some obscure spinoff manga that never saw light outside of Japan, despite it being the face of the franchise to the general public. I don't hate the anime necessarily, but he's essentially saying it should have copied the style of the anime because... Togo berries and a vague "charm". Question, wouldn't that make ''Origins'' pointless? Also, people should just play the games to experience the story? I'm sorry... [[FlatWhat What]]. ...Excuse me, [[BigWhat WHAT?!]] Um, ok, then I guess every adaptation ever has no reason to exist! *facepalm* As if ''Origins'' doesn't have charm on its own. Hero, you obviously haven't been involved with the games in a long time, or at least are one of those extremely casual fans that still thinks the anime is the WordOfGod. I like your reviews usually, but please get gud, please.

to:

** shonengirl: Creator/{{shonengirl}}: The above two don't really bother me that much, since I know where he's coming from, except for the joke, but still it was and at worse find them just somewhat tasteless. However, his review of ''Anime/PokemonOrigins'' was just poorly made. Highlights include mistaking the year the first Pokemon games were released as 1995 (it's actually 1996, and to make this worse this was shown in a clip in the video itself) and mistaking 2015 as its 20th anniversary (so this wasn't a script error either), questioning why Team Rocket needs scientists and wild Pokemon to create and test the Master Ball, and apparently not knowing who Red, one of the most well-known and well-loved characters in the fandom, to the point of being a MemeticBadass, is. The worst and most cringeworthy part, however, has to be him seeing ''Origins'' being TruerToTheText of the original games as a flaw, and that it takes away the "charm" of the anime. Um... [[CompletelyMissingThePoint That's the point, bro]]. It's supposed to be a more faithful adaptation. Stop thinking about the main anime, that has almost nothing to do with ''Origins'', an adaptation of game canon, and the two should be kept as far, far away from eachother as possible. Anyone who is familiar with the Pokemon fandom will tell you that mixing up the games and anime is a major BerserkButton for many fans of the games, and it highly annoys me as well. You know why many fans of the games hate the anime? One of the reasons is that it deviates from the games so much like some obscure spinoff manga that never saw light outside of Japan, despite it being the face of the franchise to the general public. I don't hate the anime necessarily, but he's essentially saying it should have copied the style of the anime because... Togo berries and a vague "charm". Question, wouldn't that make ''Origins'' pointless? Also, people should just play the games to experience the story? I'm sorry... [[FlatWhat What]]. ...Excuse me, [[BigWhat WHAT?!]] Um, ok, then I guess every adaptation ever has no reason to exist! The ''Harry Potter'' movies? Pointless! Comic book movies? Pointless! The ''Lord of the Rings'' film series? Pointless! *facepalm* As if ''Origins'' doesn't have charm on its own.own; I know I'm not the only one who finds the artstyle of the movie/miniseries extremely charming. Hero, you obviously haven't been involved with the games in a long time, or at least are one of those extremely casual fans that still thinks the anime is the WordOfGod. I didn't feel anywhere near the same passion that, say, [[WebShow/AtopTheFourthWall Linkara]] had (by the way, I highly recommend him regarding internet personalities talking about Pokemon). I like your reviews usually, but please get gud, please.please.



** shonengirl: Hoo boy, his ''Franchise/{{Pokemon}}'' video... Its hard to point out one moment in particular, but it's basically a series of "jokes" (I think) that have been beaten to death, revived, cut up into tiny pieces, beat up again, horn drilled, and incinerated. And I seriously couldn't tell if it was all supposed to be a bunch of jokes or not due to many of the "jokes" (mainly "hurdy durr Pokeymanz is animal abuse!") being things said with complete seriousness before, and it comes off a lot like some cringy noob ranting about something he knows nothing about, or at least has never played since gen I. The blatant CriticalResearchFailure all over the place was just painful to sit through, so much so I had to skip through big chunks of it. This was especially jarring since he pulled up the gen I manual, something only hardcore fans usually do, and actually knew that Red is 11... But yet calls Red "Ash", something that no Pokemon fan over 12 would ever do, and he should be relieved that he wasn't swarmed by rabid Red fans by some miracle. If those were jokes, they weren't funny. It doesn't help that the description made me put my hopes up. The only things that were good or new were the bit about him actually getting Red and Blue's ages right, and the mocking of the deviation of game text from what's said in the manual. Everything else is just so cliche and overdone, and I expect more from him. Not to mention it feels like he's trying to jump on the hype train of second wave Pokemania because he can, and free cash. Get gud, Grade, get gud.

to:

** shonengirl: Troper/((shonengirl)): Hoo boy, his ''Franchise/{{Pokemon}}'' video... Its hard to point out one moment in particular, but it's basically a series of "jokes" (I think) that have already been beaten beat up to death, revived, cut up HM01'd into tiny pieces, beat up again, horn drilled, and incinerated. And I seriously couldn't tell if it was all supposed to be a bunch of jokes or not due to many of the "jokes" (mainly "hurdy durr Pokeymanz is animal abuse!") being things said with complete seriousness before, and it comes off a lot like some cringy noob "scrub" ranting about something he knows nothing about, or at least has never played since gen I. The blatant CriticalResearchFailure all over the place was just painful to sit through, so much so I had to skip through big chunks tiny segments of it. This was especially jarring since he pulled up the gen I manual, something only hardcore fans usually do, and actually knew that Red is 11... But yet calls Red "Ash", something that no Pokemon fan over 12 would ever do, and he should be relieved that he wasn't swarmed by rabid Red fans by some miracle. If those were jokes, they weren't funny. It doesn't help that the description made me put my hopes up. The only things that were good or new were the bit about him actually getting Red and Blue's ages right, and the mocking of the deviation of game text from what's said in the manual. Everything else is just so cliche and overdone, and I expect more from him. Not to mention it feels like he's trying to jump on the hype train of second wave Pokemania because he can, and free cash. Get gud, Grade, get gud.
8th Feb '17 3:58:58 PM pkmon11
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/TT454: His video "I Hate YouTube Drama" made me finally give up on his steadily decaying, miserable channel. The whole video is a directionless, boring, insipid mess strongly lacking in insight regarding the topic he's trying to make a point about, and to add insult to the injury, there's even an entire pointless section where he for no reason phones up some chatline and attempts to have a conversation, and it goes nowhere. It's a complete and utter failure of a video and for me the final nail in the coffin. I was already losing interest in IHE's increasingly bitter videos for quite a while, but this video was such a mind-numbing snore-fest that it made me never want to go back to his channel.

to:

* Tropers/TT454: His video "I Hate YouTube Drama" made me finally give up on his steadily decaying, miserable channel. The whole video is a directionless, boring, insipid mess strongly lacking in insight regarding the topic he's trying to make a point about, and to add insult to the injury, there's even had an entire pointless section where he for no reason phones up some chatline and attempts to have a conversation, and it goes nowhere. It's a complete and utter failure of a video and for me the final nail in the coffin. I was already losing interest in IHE's increasingly bitter videos for quite a while, but this video was such a mind-numbing snore-fest that it made me never want to go back to his channel.nowhere.
7th Feb '17 9:27:37 PM WhoNeedsAMango
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** Everything is awful: Even if she's best off Achilles who died early in life, it still came off as too soon. It's sad no one thought to at least keep her around for a bit longer. I sure hope it's reversed.
7th Feb '17 12:39:33 PM ElSquibbonator
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/CJCroen1393: In Matthew's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y0oP7CK8zl0 "Top 10 Weirdest Dinosaurs You Never Knew Existed"]], he gets to ''Jeholopterus'', which he [[PteroSoarer mistakenly refers to as a dinosaur]] (I gave that a pass, since it's a common mistake), but then he calls it a "prehistoric equivalent to the vampire bat" that bit into bigger dinosaurs to suck their blood. That's right, he cited [[KnowNothingKnowItAll David]] [[SmallNameBigEgo Peters]] and his so-called [[CriticalResearchFailure "research"]]. Come on, Matt! All the other prehistoric animals there were relatively accurate! And there are plenty of weird underrated pterosaurs you could have picked for that! What about ''Nyctosaurus'' and its freaky head-crest and nigh-inability to walk? Or ''Hatzegopteryx'', the largest animal to ever fly that ate small animals for breakfast, lunch and dinner? Or ''Tupandactylus'' which...well, [[http://vignette4.wikia.nocookie.net/reptilepedia/images/0/0b/Tupandactylus_imperator.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20110709133444 just look at it!]]

to:

* Tropers/CJCroen1393: In Matthew's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y0oP7CK8zl0 "Top 10 Weirdest Dinosaurs You Never Knew Existed"]], he gets to ''Jeholopterus'', which he [[PteroSoarer mistakenly refers to as a dinosaur]] (I gave that a pass, since it's a common mistake), but then he calls it a "prehistoric equivalent to the vampire bat" that bit into bigger dinosaurs to suck their blood. That's right, he cited [[KnowNothingKnowItAll David]] [[SmallNameBigEgo Peters]] and his so-called [[CriticalResearchFailure "research"]]. Come on, Matt! All the other prehistoric animals there were relatively accurate! And there are plenty of weird underrated pterosaurs you could have picked for that! What about ''Nyctosaurus'' and its freaky head-crest and nigh-inability to walk? Or ''Hatzegopteryx'', the largest animal to ever fly that ate small animals dinosaurs for breakfast, lunch and dinner? Or ''Tupandactylus'' which...well, [[http://vignette4.wikia.nocookie.net/reptilepedia/images/0/0b/Tupandactylus_imperator.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20110709133444 just look at it!]]


Added DiffLines:

7th Feb '17 6:11:01 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/{{TommyTiger}}: I absolutely agree. Being Greek, I have read multiple NostalgiaFilter-related comments in Greek dubs of cartoons that came out in the 2000's or earlier in my country (like somebody [[{{Jerkass}} outright stating he'll never let his own children watch these so-called "abominations" just because he doens't like post-2000's cartoons, or someone dropping a ClusterFBomb against said cartoons, which is just offensive) to begin with! And Adam forgot there are also well-received cartoons out nowadays (''WesternAnimation/PhineasAndFerb'', ''WesternAnimation/GravityFalls'', ''WesternAnimation/StevenUniverse'', ''WesternAnimation/WanderOverYonder'', ''WesternAnimation/RegularShow'', ''WesternAnimation/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball'', ''WesternAnimation/AdventureTime'' and ''WesternAnimation/TheLegendOfKorra'' being good examples) and cartoons that came out during his childhood were also bad. The worst, though, is his [[SmallNameBigEgo pretentiousess]] about the whole thing.

to:

** Tropers/{{TommyTiger}}: I absolutely agree. Being Greek, I have read multiple NostalgiaFilter-related comments in Greek dubs of cartoons that came out in the 2000's or earlier in my country (like somebody [[{{Jerkass}} outright stating he'll never let his own children watch these so-called "abominations" "abominations"]] just because he doens't doesn't like post-2000's cartoons, or someone dropping a ClusterFBomb against said cartoons, which is just offensive) to begin with! And Adam forgot there are also well-received cartoons out nowadays (''WesternAnimation/PhineasAndFerb'', ''WesternAnimation/GravityFalls'', ''WesternAnimation/StevenUniverse'', ''WesternAnimation/WanderOverYonder'', ''WesternAnimation/RegularShow'', ''WesternAnimation/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball'', ''WesternAnimation/AdventureTime'' and ''WesternAnimation/TheLegendOfKorra'' being good examples) and cartoons that came out during his childhood were also bad.bad for the sake of his FantasticRacism. The worst, though, is his [[SmallNameBigEgo pretentiousess]] about the whole thing.
7th Feb '17 6:07:19 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Tropers/{{TommyTiger}}: I absolutely agree. Being Greek, I have read multiple NostalgiaFilter-related comments in Greek dubs of cartoons that came out in the 2000's or earlier in my country (like somebody [[{{Jerkass}} outright stating he'll never let his own children watch these so-called "abominations" just because he doens't like post-2000's cartoons, or someone dropping a ClusterFBomb against said cartoons, which is just offensive) to begin with! And Adam forgot there are also well-received cartoons out nowadays (''WesternAnimation/PhineasAndFerb'', ''WesternAnimation/GravityFalls'', ''WesternAnimation/StevenUniverse'', ''WesternAnimation/WanderOverYonder'', ''WesternAnimation/RegularShow'', ''WesternAnimation/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball'', ''WesternAnimation/AdventureTime'' and ''WesternAnimation/TheLegendOfKorra'' being good examples) and cartoons that came out during his childhood were also bad. The worst, though, is his [[SmallNameBigEgo pretentiousess]] about the whole thing.
5th Feb '17 8:40:38 PM kenyastarflight
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/{{Kenyastarflight}}: The Bad Webcomics Wiki -- [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin a wiki devoted to reviewing bad webcomics]] -- has long been biased against [[FurryFandom furry]] and {{Animesque}}/manga-esque webcomics, though they'll usually find other flaws to dissect in said webcomics besides the furry/anime-ish aspect. The point where it became a Dethroning Moment was in their Reactions section, where someone wrote a [[http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Angry_Reactions#The_Chronicles_of_Loth rebuttal to the creator's reaction]] to their review of ''Webcomic/ChroniclesOfLoth''. Here the respondent flat-out stated, and I quote (emphasis their's) "It ''is'' furry, and it ''is'' anime, and it ''is'' therefore terrible. Since when was not liking something justification for claiming it's terrible? The people behind the BBW may not be fond of anime or the furry fandom, but claiming that anything furry/anime is terrible just because they don't like it is idiotic. Their anti-furry and anti-anime bias was pretty obvious before, but hearing them flat-out proclaim it was the true DMOS.

to:

* Tropers/{{Kenyastarflight}}: The Bad Webcomics Wiki -- [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin a wiki devoted to reviewing bad webcomics]] -- has long been biased against [[FurryFandom furry]] and {{Animesque}}/manga-esque webcomics, though they'll usually find other flaws to dissect in said webcomics besides the furry/anime-ish aspect. The point where it became a Dethroning Moment was in their Reactions section, where someone wrote a [[http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Angry_Reactions#The_Chronicles_of_Loth rebuttal to the creator's reaction]] to their review of ''Webcomic/ChroniclesOfLoth''. Here the respondent flat-out stated, and I quote (emphasis their's) theirs) "It ''is'' furry, and it ''is'' anime, and it ''is'' therefore terrible. terrible." Since when was not liking something justification for claiming it's terrible? The people behind the BBW may not be fond of anime or the furry fandom, but claiming that anything furry/anime is terrible just because they don't like it is idiotic. Their anti-furry and anti-anime bias was pretty obvious before, but hearing them flat-out proclaim it was the true DMOS.
4th Feb '17 3:18:15 PM kenyastarflight
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/{{Kenyastarflight}}: The Bad Webcomics Wiki -- [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin a wiki devoted to reviewing bad webcomics]] -- has long been biased against [[FurryFandom furry]] and {{Animesque}}/manga-esque webcomics, though they'll usually find other flaws to dissect in said webcomics besides the furry/anime-ish aspect. The point where it became a Dethroning Moment was in their Reactions section, where someone wrote a [[http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Angry_Reactions#The_Chronicles_of_Loth rebuttal to the creator's reaction]] to their review of ''Webcomic/ChroniclesOfLoth''. Here the respondent flat-out stated, and I quote (emphasis there's) "It ''is'' furry, and it ''is'' anime, and it ''is'' therefore terrible. Since when was not liking something justification for claiming it's terrible? The people behind the BBW may not be fond of anime or the furry fandom, but claiming that anything furry/anime is terrible just because they don't like it is idiotic. Their anti-furry and anti-anime bias was pretty obvious before, but hearing them flat-out proclaim it was the true DMOS.

to:

* Tropers/{{Kenyastarflight}}: The Bad Webcomics Wiki -- [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin a wiki devoted to reviewing bad webcomics]] -- has long been biased against [[FurryFandom furry]] and {{Animesque}}/manga-esque webcomics, though they'll usually find other flaws to dissect in said webcomics besides the furry/anime-ish aspect. The point where it became a Dethroning Moment was in their Reactions section, where someone wrote a [[http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Angry_Reactions#The_Chronicles_of_Loth rebuttal to the creator's reaction]] to their review of ''Webcomic/ChroniclesOfLoth''. Here the respondent flat-out stated, and I quote (emphasis there's) their's) "It ''is'' furry, and it ''is'' anime, and it ''is'' therefore terrible. Since when was not liking something justification for claiming it's terrible? The people behind the BBW may not be fond of anime or the furry fandom, but claiming that anything furry/anime is terrible just because they don't like it is idiotic. Their anti-furry and anti-anime bias was pretty obvious before, but hearing them flat-out proclaim it was the true DMOS.
4th Feb '17 3:15:33 PM kenyastarflight
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/Kenyastarflight: The Bad Webcomics Wiki -- [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin a wiki devoted to reviewing bad webcomics]] -- has long been biased against [[FurryFandom furry]] and {{Animesque}}/manga-esque webcomics, though they'll usually find other flaws to dissect in said webcomics besides the furry/anime-ish aspect. The point where it became a Dethroning Moment was in their Reactions section, where someone wrote a [[http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Angry_Reactions#The_Chronicles_of_Loth rebuttal to the creator's reaction]] to their review of ''Webcomic/ChroniclesOfLoth''. Here the respondent flat-out stated, and I quote (emphasis there's) "It ''is'' furry, and it ''is'' anime, and it ''is'' therefore terrible. Since when was not liking something justification for claiming it's terrible? The people behind the BBW may not be fond of anime or the furry fandom, but claiming that anything furry/anime is terrible just because they don't like it is idiotic. Their anti-furry and anti-anime bias was pretty obvious before, but hearing them flat-out proclaim it was the true DMOS.

to:

* Tropers/Kenyastarflight: Tropers/{{Kenyastarflight}}: The Bad Webcomics Wiki -- [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin a wiki devoted to reviewing bad webcomics]] -- has long been biased against [[FurryFandom furry]] and {{Animesque}}/manga-esque webcomics, though they'll usually find other flaws to dissect in said webcomics besides the furry/anime-ish aspect. The point where it became a Dethroning Moment was in their Reactions section, where someone wrote a [[http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Angry_Reactions#The_Chronicles_of_Loth rebuttal to the creator's reaction]] to their review of ''Webcomic/ChroniclesOfLoth''. Here the respondent flat-out stated, and I quote (emphasis there's) "It ''is'' furry, and it ''is'' anime, and it ''is'' therefore terrible. Since when was not liking something justification for claiming it's terrible? The people behind the BBW may not be fond of anime or the furry fandom, but claiming that anything furry/anime is terrible just because they don't like it is idiotic. Their anti-furry and anti-anime bias was pretty obvious before, but hearing them flat-out proclaim it was the true DMOS.
4th Feb '17 3:14:47 PM kenyastarflight
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Tropers/Kenyastarflight: The Bad Webcomics Wiki -- [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin a wiki devoted to reviewing bad webcomics]] -- has long been biased against [[FurryFandom furry]] and {{Animesque}}/manga-esque webcomics, though they'll usually find other flaws to dissect in said webcomics besides the furry/anime-ish aspect. The point where it became a Dethroning Moment was in their Reactions section, where someone wrote a [[http://badwebcomicswiki.shoutwiki.com/wiki/Angry_Reactions#The_Chronicles_of_Loth rebuttal to the creator's reaction]] to their review of ''Webcomic/ChroniclesOfLoth''. Here the respondent flat-out stated, and I quote (emphasis there's) "It ''is'' furry, and it ''is'' anime, and it ''is'' therefore terrible. Since when was not liking something justification for claiming it's terrible? The people behind the BBW may not be fond of anime or the furry fandom, but claiming that anything furry/anime is terrible just because they don't like it is idiotic. Their anti-furry and anti-anime bias was pretty obvious before, but hearing them flat-out proclaim it was the true DMOS.
29th Jan '17 2:05:14 AM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* [=TheLemsterPju=]: I am by no means a recurring watcher of [[RebelTaxi RebelTaxi's]] videos, but one of his videos I have seen had a moment which screamed unnecessary. When he covered The Modifyers in his "Top 10 Failed Animated Pilots" video, you know what one of the first things he does? Adding a scene from Zonesama's hentai video of the main character (Agent Xero) getting tentacle raped by the villain. It is quite obvious that he has a huge fascination for the parody animator, but it served no purpose to the video at all, other than an apparent promotion for Zone, and at the same time makes him come across as a bit of creep.

to:

* [=TheLemsterPju=]: I am by no means a recurring watcher of [[RebelTaxi RebelTaxi's]] videos, but one of his videos I have seen had a moment which screamed unnecessary. When he covered The Modifyers in his "Top 10 Failed Animated Pilots" video, you know what one of the first things he does? Adding a scene from Zonesama's hentai video of the main character (Agent Xero) getting tentacle raped by the villain. It is quite obvious that he has a huge fascination for the parody animator, but it served no purpose to the video at all, other than an apparent promotion for Zone, and at the same time makes him come across as a bit of creep. This did not go without SelfDeprication in later videos.
28th Jan '17 9:38:45 AM CaptainTedium
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/CaptainTedium: I nominate ''Scientifically Accurate WesternAnimation/CatDog'' as the absolute worst of this shit. I was sick of the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series long ago because of all the works of fiction that were shamelessly defiled, but finding out that they did a "Scientifically Accurate" version of ''[=CatDog=]'' while doing a Google Images search on the Nickelodeon series made me just a little bit curious. I instantly regretted watching the video after seeing all the gross and disgusting jokes they made on what would happen in real life if a dog and a cat were surgically grafted together. For one, Cat and Dog were ConjoinedTwins rather than a canine and a feline sewn together, so this abominable video kind of misses the point of why Cat and Dog shared a body. Second, it really adds nothing new to the table and is just another unwatchable mess of applying RealityEnsues and {{Deconstruction}} to works where the laws of physics and reality weren't very important to begin with. I shudder to think what they'd do with Mickey Mouse.

to:

* Tropers/CaptainTedium: I nominate ''Scientifically Accurate WesternAnimation/CatDog'' as the absolute worst of this shit. I was sick of the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series long ago because of all the works of fiction that were shamelessly defiled, but finding out that they did a "Scientifically Accurate" version of ''[=CatDog=]'' while doing a Google Images search on the Nickelodeon series made me just a little bit curious. I instantly regretted watching the video after seeing all the gross and disgusting jokes they made on what would happen in real life if a dog and a cat were surgically grafted together. For one, Cat and Dog were ConjoinedTwins rather than a canine and a feline sewn together, so this abominable video kind of [[ShallowParody misses the point of why Cat and Dog shared a body.body]]. Second, it really adds nothing new to the table and is just another unwatchable mess of applying RealityEnsues and {{Deconstruction}} to works where the laws of physics and reality weren't very important to begin with. Seeing this has made me swear off the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series for good. I shudder to think what they'd do with Mickey Mouse.
28th Jan '17 9:29:32 AM CaptainTedium
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/CaptainTedium: I nominate ''Scientifically Accurate WesternAnimation/CatDog'' as the absolute worst of this shit. I was sick of the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series long ago because of all the works of fiction that were shamelessly defiled, but finding out that they did a "Scientifically Accurate" version of ''[=CatDog=]'' while doing a Google Images search on the Nickelodeon series made me just a little bit curious. I instantly regretted watching the video after seeing all the gross and disgusting jokes they made on what would happen in real life if a dog and a cat were surgically grafted together. For one, Cat and Dog were ConjoinedTwins rather than a canine and a feline sewn together, so this abominable video adds nothing new to the table and is just another unwatchable mess of applying RealityEnsues and {{Deconstruction}} to works where the laws of physics and reality weren't very important to begin with. I shudder to think what they'd do with Mickey Mouse.

to:

* Tropers/CaptainTedium: I nominate ''Scientifically Accurate WesternAnimation/CatDog'' as the absolute worst of this shit. I was sick of the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series long ago because of all the works of fiction that were shamelessly defiled, but finding out that they did a "Scientifically Accurate" version of ''[=CatDog=]'' while doing a Google Images search on the Nickelodeon series made me just a little bit curious. I instantly regretted watching the video after seeing all the gross and disgusting jokes they made on what would happen in real life if a dog and a cat were surgically grafted together. For one, Cat and Dog were ConjoinedTwins rather than a canine and a feline sewn together, so this abominable video kind of misses the point of why Cat and Dog shared a body. Second, it really adds nothing new to the table and is just another unwatchable mess of applying RealityEnsues and {{Deconstruction}} to works where the laws of physics and reality weren't very important to begin with. I shudder to think what they'd do with Mickey Mouse.
28th Jan '17 9:26:41 AM CaptainTedium
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/CaptainTedium: I nominate ''Scientifically Accurate WesternAnimation/CatDog'' as the absolute worst of this shit. I was sick of the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series long ago because of all the works of fiction that were shamelessly defiled, but finding out that they did a "Scientifically Accurate" version of ''[=CatDog=]'' while doing a Google Images search on the series made me just a little bit curious. I instantly regretted watching the video after seeing all the gross and disgusting jokes they made on what would happen in real life if a dog and a cat were surgically grafted together. For one, Cat and Dog were ConjoinedTwins rather than a canine and a feline sewn together, so this abominable video adds nothing new to the table and is just another unwatchable mess of applying RealityEnsues and {{Deconstruction}} to works where the laws of physics and reality weren't very important to begin with. I shudder to think what they'd do with Mickey Mouse.

to:

* Tropers/CaptainTedium: I nominate ''Scientifically Accurate WesternAnimation/CatDog'' as the absolute worst of this shit. I was sick of the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series long ago because of all the works of fiction that were shamelessly defiled, but finding out that they did a "Scientifically Accurate" version of ''[=CatDog=]'' while doing a Google Images search on the Nickelodeon series made me just a little bit curious. I instantly regretted watching the video after seeing all the gross and disgusting jokes they made on what would happen in real life if a dog and a cat were surgically grafted together. For one, Cat and Dog were ConjoinedTwins rather than a canine and a feline sewn together, so this abominable video adds nothing new to the table and is just another unwatchable mess of applying RealityEnsues and {{Deconstruction}} to works where the laws of physics and reality weren't very important to begin with. I shudder to think what they'd do with Mickey Mouse.
28th Jan '17 9:24:17 AM CaptainTedium
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/CaptainTedium: I nominate ''Scientifically Accurate WesternAnimation/CatDog'' as the absolute worst of this shit. I was sick of the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series long ago because of all the works of fiction that were shamelessly defiled, but finding out that they did a "Scientifically Accurate" version of ''[=CatDog=]'' while doing a Google Images search on the series made me just a little bit curious. I instantly regretted watching the video after seeing all the gross and disgusting jokes they made on what would happen in real life if a dog and a cat were surgically grafted together. For one, Cat and Dog were ConjoinedTwins rather than a canine and a feline sewn together, so this abominable video adds nothing new to the table and is just an unwatchable mess of applying RealityEnsues and {{Deconstruction}} to works where the laws of physics and reality weren't very important to begin with. I shudder to think what they'd do with Mickey Mouse.

to:

* Tropers/CaptainTedium: I nominate ''Scientifically Accurate WesternAnimation/CatDog'' as the absolute worst of this shit. I was sick of the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series long ago because of all the works of fiction that were shamelessly defiled, but finding out that they did a "Scientifically Accurate" version of ''[=CatDog=]'' while doing a Google Images search on the series made me just a little bit curious. I instantly regretted watching the video after seeing all the gross and disgusting jokes they made on what would happen in real life if a dog and a cat were surgically grafted together. For one, Cat and Dog were ConjoinedTwins rather than a canine and a feline sewn together, so this abominable video adds nothing new to the table and is just an another unwatchable mess of applying RealityEnsues and {{Deconstruction}} to works where the laws of physics and reality weren't very important to begin with. I shudder to think what they'd do with Mickey Mouse.
28th Jan '17 9:23:08 AM CaptainTedium
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* fluffything: For those unfamiliar, there is a WebAnimation series called ''Scientifically Accurate'' that "parodies" (in the loosest sense of the word possible) classic cartoons, video games, and so forth using "science" (again, loosest sense of the word possible). It only took me one viewing of their ''Scientifically Accurate SonicTheHedgehog'' video to realize just how terrible their attempts at humor are (And, considering they're associated with Fox's "Animation Domination", that should come as no surprise). The DMOS is basically how utterly lazy and juvenile it is. Rather than come up with something clever and witty, the short instead tells such [[SarcasmMode great jokes such as]] "Hedgehogs eat poop!" and the classic "Echidnas have a four-headed penis!". Heck, they don't even try with the ToiletHumor. It's basically just the same "it's gross so it's instantly funny" mentality you'd expect from a twelve year-old boy than what I can only assume is a professional writer and/or animator.

to:

* fluffything: For those unfamiliar, there is a WebAnimation series called ''Scientifically Accurate'' that "parodies" (in the loosest sense of the word possible) classic cartoons, video games, and so forth using "science" (again, loosest sense of the word possible). It only took me one viewing of their ''Scientifically Accurate SonicTheHedgehog'' Franchise/SonicTheHedgehog'' video to realize just how terrible their attempts at humor are (And, considering they're associated with Fox's "Animation Domination", that should come as no surprise). The DMOS is basically how utterly lazy and juvenile it is. Rather than come up with something clever and witty, the short instead tells such [[SarcasmMode great jokes such as]] "Hedgehogs eat poop!" and the classic "Echidnas have a four-headed penis!". Heck, they don't even try with the ToiletHumor. It's basically just the same "it's gross so it's instantly funny" mentality you'd expect from a twelve year-old boy than what I can only assume is a professional writer and/or animator.


Added DiffLines:

* Tropers/CaptainTedium: I nominate ''Scientifically Accurate WesternAnimation/CatDog'' as the absolute worst of this shit. I was sick of the ''Scientifically Accurate'' series long ago because of all the works of fiction that were shamelessly defiled, but finding out that they did a "Scientifically Accurate" version of ''[=CatDog=]'' while doing a Google Images search on the series made me just a little bit curious. I instantly regretted watching the video after seeing all the gross and disgusting jokes they made on what would happen in real life if a dog and a cat were surgically grafted together. For one, Cat and Dog were ConjoinedTwins rather than a canine and a feline sewn together, so this abominable video adds nothing new to the table and is just an unwatchable mess of applying RealityEnsues and {{Deconstruction}} to works where the laws of physics and reality weren't very important to begin with. I shudder to think what they'd do with Mickey Mouse.
26th Jan '17 5:08:19 AM CaptainTedium
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/CaptainTedium: One of the many things on the Internet I am addicted to are cartoon conspiracy theories, mainly because they're fun to read or hear about even when they're clearly a load of bunk. The worst video consisting of a list of cartoon conspiracies I've ever watched, however, would be adamsmasher's four-part Top 100 Cartoon Conspiracy Theories video. There were a lot of flaws, but the absolute worst thing about this four-part video was that several entries weren't even cartoon conspiracies at all and instead consisted of adamsmasher complaining about [[NostalgiaFilter modern cartoons being inferior to older ones]]. It's true that everyone's entitled to their opinion, but adamsmasher wasn't helping his case when he insisted that people who liked today's cartoons [[FanHater were immature twelve-year-olds]], and complaining about modern shows really has nothing to do with cartoon conspiracies at all. Whether he couldn't find 100 interesting cartoon conspiracies or just felt like bashing people who liked what he didn't like, there really was no reason for him to kvetch about modern cartoons being terrible and it was especially appalling that he'd have the gall to generalize everyone who doesn't share his opinion.

to:

* Tropers/CaptainTedium: One of the many things on the Internet I am addicted to are cartoon conspiracy theories, mainly because they're fun to read or hear about even when they're clearly a load of bunk. The worst video consisting of a list of cartoon conspiracies conspiracy theories I've ever watched, however, would be adamsmasher's four-part Top 100 Cartoon Conspiracy Theories video. There were a lot of flaws, but the absolute worst thing about this four-part video was that several entries weren't even cartoon conspiracies conspiracy theories at all and instead consisted of adamsmasher complaining about [[NostalgiaFilter modern cartoons being inferior to older ones]]. It's true that everyone's entitled to their opinion, but adamsmasher wasn't helping his case when he insisted that people who liked today's cartoons [[FanHater were immature twelve-year-olds]], and complaining about modern shows really has nothing to do with cartoon conspiracies conspiracy theories at all. Whether he couldn't find 100 interesting cartoon conspiracies conspiracy theories or just felt like bashing people who liked what he didn't like, there really was no reason for him to kvetch about modern cartoons being terrible and it was especially appalling that he'd have the gall to generalize everyone who doesn't share his opinion.
26th Jan '17 4:57:48 AM CaptainTedium
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/CaptainTedium: One of the many things on the Internet I am addicted to are cartoon conspiracy theories, mainly because they're fun to read or hear about even when they're clearly a load of bunk. The worst video consisting of a list of cartoon conspiracies I've ever watched, however, would be adamsmasher's five-part Top 100 Cartoon Conspiracy Theories video. There were a lot of flaws, but the absolute worst thing about this five-part video was that several entries weren't even cartoon conspiracies at all and instead consisted of adamsmasher complaining about [[NostalgiaFilter modern cartoons being inferior to older ones]]. It's true that everyone's entitled to their opinion, but adamsmasher wasn't helping his case when he insisted that people who liked today's cartoons [[FanHater were immature twelve-year-olds]], and complaining about modern shows really has nothing to do with cartoon conspiracies at all. Whether he couldn't find 100 interesting cartoon conspiracies or just felt like bashing people who liked what he didn't like, there really was no reason for him to kvetch about modern cartoons being terrible and it was especially appalling that he'd have the gall to generalize everyone who doesn't share his opinion.

to:

* Tropers/CaptainTedium: One of the many things on the Internet I am addicted to are cartoon conspiracy theories, mainly because they're fun to read or hear about even when they're clearly a load of bunk. The worst video consisting of a list of cartoon conspiracies I've ever watched, however, would be adamsmasher's five-part four-part Top 100 Cartoon Conspiracy Theories video. There were a lot of flaws, but the absolute worst thing about this five-part four-part video was that several entries weren't even cartoon conspiracies at all and instead consisted of adamsmasher complaining about [[NostalgiaFilter modern cartoons being inferior to older ones]]. It's true that everyone's entitled to their opinion, but adamsmasher wasn't helping his case when he insisted that people who liked today's cartoons [[FanHater were immature twelve-year-olds]], and complaining about modern shows really has nothing to do with cartoon conspiracies at all. Whether he couldn't find 100 interesting cartoon conspiracies or just felt like bashing people who liked what he didn't like, there really was no reason for him to kvetch about modern cartoons being terrible and it was especially appalling that he'd have the gall to generalize everyone who doesn't share his opinion.
26th Jan '17 4:56:48 AM CaptainTedium
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/CaptainTedium: One of the many things on the Internet I am addicted to are cartoon conspiracy theories, mainly because they're fun to read or hear about even when they're clearly a load of bunk. The worst videos consisting of a list of cartoon conspiracies I've ever watched, however, would be adamsmasher's Top 100 Cartoon Conspiracies video series. There were a lot of flaws, but the absolute worst thing about the video series was that several entries weren't even cartoon conspiracies at all and instead consisted of adamsmasher complaining about [[NostalgiaFilter modern cartoons being inferior to older ones]]. It's true that everyone's entitled to their opinion, but adamsmasher wasn't helping his case when he insisted that people who liked modern cartoons [[FanHater were immature twelve-year-olds]], and complaining about modern shows really has nothing to do with cartoon conspiracies at all. Whether he couldn't find 100 interesting cartoon conspiracies or just felt like bashing people who liked what he didn't like, whining about modern media simply has no place in videos about cartoon conspiracy theories and it really isn't cool to generalize everyone who doesn't share your opinion.

to:

* Tropers/CaptainTedium: One of the many things on the Internet I am addicted to are cartoon conspiracy theories, mainly because they're fun to read or hear about even when they're clearly a load of bunk. The worst videos video consisting of a list of cartoon conspiracies I've ever watched, however, would be adamsmasher's five-part Top 100 Cartoon Conspiracies video series. Conspiracy Theories video. There were a lot of flaws, but the absolute worst thing about the this five-part video series was that several entries weren't even cartoon conspiracies at all and instead consisted of adamsmasher complaining about [[NostalgiaFilter modern cartoons being inferior to older ones]]. It's true that everyone's entitled to their opinion, but adamsmasher wasn't helping his case when he insisted that people who liked modern today's cartoons [[FanHater were immature twelve-year-olds]], and complaining about modern shows really has nothing to do with cartoon conspiracies at all. Whether he couldn't find 100 interesting cartoon conspiracies or just felt like bashing people who liked what he didn't like, whining there really was no reason for him to kvetch about modern media simply has no place in videos about cartoon conspiracy theories cartoons being terrible and it really isn't cool was especially appalling that he'd have the gall to generalize everyone who doesn't share your his opinion.
26th Jan '17 2:33:57 AM CaptainTedium
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/CaptainTedium: One of the many things on the Internet I am addicted to are cartoon conspiracy theories, mainly because they're fun to read or hear about even when they're clearly a load of bunk. The worst videos consisting of a list of cartoon conspiracies I've ever watched, however, would be adamsmasher's Top 100 Cartoon Conspiracies video series. There were a lot of flaws, but the absolute worst thing about the videos were that several entries weren't even cartoon conspiracies at all and instead consisted of adamsmasher complaining about [[NostalgiaFilter modern cartoons being inferior to older ones]]. It's true that everyone's entitled to their opinion, but adamsmasher wasn't helping his case when he insisted that people who liked modern cartoons [[FanHater were immature twelve-year-olds]], and complaining about modern shows really has nothing to do with cartoon conspiracies at all. Whether he couldn't find 100 interesting cartoon conspiracies or just felt like bashing people who liked what he didn't like, whining about modern media simply has no place in videos about cartoon conspiracy theories and it really isn't cool to generalize everyone who doesn't share your opinion.

to:

* Tropers/CaptainTedium: One of the many things on the Internet I am addicted to are cartoon conspiracy theories, mainly because they're fun to read or hear about even when they're clearly a load of bunk. The worst videos consisting of a list of cartoon conspiracies I've ever watched, however, would be adamsmasher's Top 100 Cartoon Conspiracies video series. There were a lot of flaws, but the absolute worst thing about the videos were video series was that several entries weren't even cartoon conspiracies at all and instead consisted of adamsmasher complaining about [[NostalgiaFilter modern cartoons being inferior to older ones]]. It's true that everyone's entitled to their opinion, but adamsmasher wasn't helping his case when he insisted that people who liked modern cartoons [[FanHater were immature twelve-year-olds]], and complaining about modern shows really has nothing to do with cartoon conspiracies at all. Whether he couldn't find 100 interesting cartoon conspiracies or just felt like bashing people who liked what he didn't like, whining about modern media simply has no place in videos about cartoon conspiracy theories and it really isn't cool to generalize everyone who doesn't share your opinion.
26th Jan '17 2:29:19 AM CaptainTedium
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/CaptainTedium: One of the many things on the Internet I am addicted to are cartoon conspiracy theories, mainly because they're fun to read or hear about even when they're clearly a load of bunk. The worst videos consisting of a list of cartoon conspiracies I've ever watched, however, would be adamsmasher's Top 100 Cartoon Conspiracies video series. There were a lot of flaws, but the absolute worst thing about the videos were that several entries weren't even cartoon conspiracies at all and instead consisted of adamsmasher complaining about [[NostalgiaFilter modern cartoons being inferior to older ones]]. It's true that everyone's entitled to their opinion, but adamsmasher wasn't helping his case when he insisted that people who liked modern cartoons [[FanHater were immature twelve-year-olds]], and complaining about modern shows really has nothing to do with cartoon conspiracies at all. Whether he couldn't find 100 interesting cartoon conspiracies or just felt like bashing people who liked what he didn't like, whining about modern media simply has no place in videos about cartoon conspiracy theories.

to:

* Tropers/CaptainTedium: One of the many things on the Internet I am addicted to are cartoon conspiracy theories, mainly because they're fun to read or hear about even when they're clearly a load of bunk. The worst videos consisting of a list of cartoon conspiracies I've ever watched, however, would be adamsmasher's Top 100 Cartoon Conspiracies video series. There were a lot of flaws, but the absolute worst thing about the videos were that several entries weren't even cartoon conspiracies at all and instead consisted of adamsmasher complaining about [[NostalgiaFilter modern cartoons being inferior to older ones]]. It's true that everyone's entitled to their opinion, but adamsmasher wasn't helping his case when he insisted that people who liked modern cartoons [[FanHater were immature twelve-year-olds]], and complaining about modern shows really has nothing to do with cartoon conspiracies at all. Whether he couldn't find 100 interesting cartoon conspiracies or just felt like bashing people who liked what he didn't like, whining about modern media simply has no place in videos about cartoon conspiracy theories.theories and it really isn't cool to generalize everyone who doesn't share your opinion.
26th Jan '17 2:27:55 AM CaptainTedium
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Sugarp1e1: I agree. What especially ticks me off about this video is hotdiggitydemon feeling the need to AccenuateTheNegative despite finding the reboot SoOkayItsAverage. Which is it? Is it average or is it bad? There's a difference, you know.

to:

** Sugarp1e1: I agree. What especially ticks me off about this video is hotdiggitydemon feeling the need to AccenuateTheNegative AccentuateTheNegative despite finding the reboot SoOkayItsAverage. Which is it? Is it average or is it bad? There's a difference, you know.know.
* Tropers/CaptainTedium: One of the many things on the Internet I am addicted to are cartoon conspiracy theories, mainly because they're fun to read or hear about even when they're clearly a load of bunk. The worst videos consisting of a list of cartoon conspiracies I've ever watched, however, would be adamsmasher's Top 100 Cartoon Conspiracies video series. There were a lot of flaws, but the absolute worst thing about the videos were that several entries weren't even cartoon conspiracies at all and instead consisted of adamsmasher complaining about [[NostalgiaFilter modern cartoons being inferior to older ones]]. It's true that everyone's entitled to their opinion, but adamsmasher wasn't helping his case when he insisted that people who liked modern cartoons [[FanHater were immature twelve-year-olds]], and complaining about modern shows really has nothing to do with cartoon conspiracies at all. Whether he couldn't find 100 interesting cartoon conspiracies or just felt like bashing people who liked what he didn't like, whining about modern media simply has no place in videos about cartoon conspiracy theories.
16th Jan '17 6:47:33 PM CerotechOmega
Is there an issue? Send a Message




to:

\n[[/folder]]
16th Jan '17 11:08:40 AM Gotgunpowder
Is there an issue? Send a Message


%%* Tropers/{{Gotgunpowder}}: The time he got incredibly offended over the HandOfFate Dealer making a fat joke (Referring to a ring that does something to your food and gold: "Fat and poor, an unusual combination"). I'd normally understand it (to a degree) but it was apparently so irredeemable that he outright banned people disagreeing with him, including long time, dedicated fans, ''and even boasted about this in the comments''. Way to completely alienate your fanbase, Crab.
%%** And another example, by the same troper: In the same Hand Of Fate LP where his in-progress run was deleted for a patch right before the dealer, which made him understandably angry. But he then proceeded to completely slander the entire game for this problem, even after the developers assured him that he was very unlucky and that this normally doesn't happen. To where he basically outright told them to stop making games if they can't code absolutely perfectly. I always found his anger and wit amusing, but I think he might have a problem.
[[/folder]]

to:

%%* * Tropers/{{Gotgunpowder}}: The time he got incredibly offended over the HandOfFate Dealer making a fat joke (Referring to a ring that does something to your food and gold: "Fat and poor, an unusual combination"). I'd normally understand it (to a degree) but it was apparently so irredeemable that he outright banned people disagreeing with him, including long time, dedicated fans, ''and even boasted about this in the comments''. Way to completely alienate your fanbase, Crab.
%%** And another example, by the same troper: In the same Hand Of Fate LP where his in-progress run was deleted for a patch right before the dealer, which made him understandably angry. But he then proceeded to completely slander the entire game for this problem, even after the developers assured him that he was very unlucky and that this normally doesn't happen. To where he basically outright told them to stop making games if they can't code absolutely perfectly. I always found his anger and wit amusing, but I think he might have a problem.
[[/folder]]
Crab.

16th Jan '17 8:00:45 AM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list despite being the first Franchise/SonicTheHedgehog cartoon ever aired (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation of the original WesternAnimation/TheRealGhostbusters with clear ties to its predecessor. And apparently, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ViPq-aJKB0c I am not alone in thinking this]]. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice. RebelTaxi might have also put the entire franchise on his list of worst remakes because he also wanted it to just die already, but at least he didn't put it at numero freaking uno (Plus, it was PlayedForLaughs). Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't; instead he goes through a long laundry list of "remakes" that aren't even listed in how bad they are. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise; also very easy to do as [[spoiler: Mystery Incorporated]] was included in the rundown (quick update: as of his "Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes" list, he has watched [[spoiler:Mystery Inc.]] and found it refreshing; strike off for that one). I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.

to:

** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list despite being the first Franchise/SonicTheHedgehog cartoon ever aired (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation of the original WesternAnimation/TheRealGhostbusters with clear ties to its predecessor. And apparently, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ViPq-aJKB0c I am not alone alone]] [[https://youtu.be/JvXKtIpkbuw in thinking this]]. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice. RebelTaxi might have also put the entire franchise on his list of worst remakes because he also wanted it to just die already, but at least he didn't put it at numero freaking uno (Plus, it was PlayedForLaughs). Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't; instead he goes through a long laundry list of "remakes" that aren't even listed in how bad they are. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise; also very easy to do as [[spoiler: Mystery Incorporated]] was included in the rundown (quick update: as of his "Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes" list, he has watched [[spoiler:Mystery Inc.]] and found it refreshing; strike off for that one). I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.
16th Jan '17 4:03:03 AM jormis29
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* jmac9345: Before I get any flack for this, let me get out that I love WebVideo/{{JonTron}}. He’s one of the greatest and funniest YouTube critics of all time. And although I don’t think he’s had a bad episode per say, he isn’t free from bad moments. For example, I loved both of his Food Games videos as a great, long awaited return to form after StarCade (which was [[CrowningMomentOfAwesome awesome]] and [[FunnyMoments hilarious]] in it’s own right) especially with gems like the [[NotMakingThisUpDisclaimer live horse in his apartment]] and [[spoiler:[[BigLippedAlligatorMoment Grimbo]]]], but there was one aspect of Part 1 that annoyed me. With the Yoshinoya, Global Gladiators, [=McDonald’s Treasure Land Adventure=], and Donald Magical World (especially the former and latter) segments, he barely touched on the games, gameplay wise. Granted, Jon does tend to focus more on comedy rather than actual reviewing, but I feel that he could’ve went a bit more in depth with the games instead of just briefly skimming over them, making a joke, and moving on. It didn’t taint the video for me, I just wish there was a bit more depth to it.

to:

* jmac9345: Before I get any flack for this, let me get out that I love WebVideo/{{JonTron}}. He’s one of the greatest and funniest YouTube critics of all time. And although I don’t think he’s had a bad episode per say, he isn’t free from bad moments. For example, I loved both of his Food Games videos as a great, long awaited return to form after StarCade [=StarCade=] (which was [[CrowningMomentOfAwesome awesome]] and [[FunnyMoments hilarious]] in it’s own right) especially with gems like the [[NotMakingThisUpDisclaimer live horse in his apartment]] and [[spoiler:[[BigLippedAlligatorMoment Grimbo]]]], but there was one aspect of Part 1 that annoyed me. With the Yoshinoya, Global Gladiators, [=McDonald’s Treasure Land Adventure=], and Donald Magical World (especially the former and latter) segments, he barely touched on the games, gameplay wise. Granted, Jon does tend to focus more on comedy rather than actual reviewing, but I feel that he could’ve went a bit more in depth with the games instead of just briefly skimming over them, making a joke, and moving on. It didn’t taint the video for me, I just wish there was a bit more depth to it.
16th Jan '17 12:39:17 AM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list despite being the first Franchise/SonicTheHedgehog cartoon ever aired (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation of the original WesternAnimation/TheRealGhostbusters with clear ties to its predecessor. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice. RebelTaxi might have also put the entire franchise on his list of worst remakes because he also wanted it to just die already, but at least he didn't put it at numero freaking uno (Plus, it was PlayedForLaughs). Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't; instead he goes through a long laundry list of "remakes" that aren't even listed in how bad they are. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise; also very easy to do as [[spoiler: Mystery Incorporated]] was included in the rundown (quick update: as of his "Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes" list, he has watched [[spoiler:Mystery Inc.]] and found it refreshing; strike off for that one). I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.

to:

** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list despite being the first Franchise/SonicTheHedgehog cartoon ever aired (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation of the original WesternAnimation/TheRealGhostbusters with clear ties to its predecessor. And apparently, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ViPq-aJKB0c I am not alone in thinking this]]. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice. RebelTaxi might have also put the entire franchise on his list of worst remakes because he also wanted it to just die already, but at least he didn't put it at numero freaking uno (Plus, it was PlayedForLaughs). Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't; instead he goes through a long laundry list of "remakes" that aren't even listed in how bad they are. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise; also very easy to do as [[spoiler: Mystery Incorporated]] was included in the rundown (quick update: as of his "Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes" list, he has watched [[spoiler:Mystery Inc.]] and found it refreshing; strike off for that one). I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.
16th Jan '17 12:36:42 AM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most [[CausticCritic Caustic Critics]] however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of lists. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater (As you can see in the flavor text). But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every single Scooby-Doo remake in existence]]! Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "The original was never any good to begin with, so the franchise should have died years ago!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years despite the original's lack of appeal to him. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, especially if it's a show I don't like. But I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place the entire franchise at #1 on a Worst Remakes list and bash it simply because of it's lifespan and the quality of the original alone. Not to mention that he seems to think that [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] is, like the other remakes he mentions, exactly the same as the original. Oh, and Strider seemed to had TakenALevelInJerkass for this entry. Usually, he just expresses his distaste in a professional and witty manner like the classy DeadpanSnarker he is. Here it sounds more like he's trying to rally all of his viewers against the franchise, what with him having the gall to assume that nobody actively watches [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] anyway, asking "Has any kid ever sat down and said, 'Oh, look! [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] is on!'?", and claiming that kids only watch it when there's nothing better to watch. Excuse me Strider, but I watched both [[spoiler: What's New, Scooby-Doo?]] and [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] regularly when I was a kid and loved them. Again, this is coming from a guy who claims to be fine with people liking something he doesn't. This assumption is not only hypocritical and insulting, it makes no sense. If a series has been remade over 19 times, then it must have some sort of fanbase otherwise it wouldn't have been remade even once! Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I was so disappointed with him, I couldn't bring myself to listen to him re-explain why he hates [[spoiler:Scooby Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/P9NLefklYK8 Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes list]] and skipped over it. (But judging by his added comment of "Forever" in the entry title, he was trying to justify cramming the entire franchise on the top spot of his Worst Remakes list). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".
** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice. RebelTaxi might have also put the entire franchise on his list of worst remakes because he also wanted it to just die already, but at least he didn't put it at numero freaking uno (Plus, it was PlayedForLaughs). Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't; instead he goes through a long laundry list of "remakes" that aren't even listed in how bad they are. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise; also very easy to do as [[spoiler: Mystery Incorporated]] was included in the rundown (quick update: as of his "Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes" list, he has watched [[spoiler:Mystery Inc.]] and found it refreshing; strike off for that one). I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.

to:

* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most [[CausticCritic Caustic Critics]] however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of lists. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater (As you can see in the flavor text). But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every single Scooby-Doo Franchise/ScoobyDoo remake in existence]]! Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "The original was never any good to begin with, so the franchise should have died years ago!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years despite the original's lack of appeal to him. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, especially if it's a show I don't like. But I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place the entire franchise at #1 on a Worst Remakes list and bash it simply because of it's lifespan and the quality of the original alone. Not to mention that he seems to think that [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] is, like the other remakes he mentions, exactly the same as the original. Oh, and Strider seemed to had TakenALevelInJerkass for this entry. Usually, he just expresses his distaste in a professional and witty manner like the classy DeadpanSnarker he is. Here it sounds more like he's trying to rally all of his viewers against the franchise, what with him having the gall to assume that nobody actively watches [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] anyway, asking "Has any kid ever sat down and said, 'Oh, look! [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] is on!'?", and claiming that kids only watch it when there's nothing better to watch. Excuse me Strider, but I watched both [[spoiler: What's New, Scooby-Doo?]] and [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] regularly when I was a kid and loved them. Again, this is coming from a guy who claims to be fine with people liking something he doesn't. This assumption is not only hypocritical and insulting, it makes no sense. If a series has been remade over 19 times, then it must have some sort of fanbase otherwise it wouldn't have been remade even once! Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I was so disappointed with him, I couldn't bring myself to listen to him re-explain why he hates [[spoiler:Scooby Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/P9NLefklYK8 Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes list]] and skipped over it. (But judging by his added comment of "Forever" in the entry title, he was trying to justify cramming the entire franchise on the top spot of his Worst Remakes list). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".
** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list despite being the first Franchise/SonicTheHedgehog cartoon ever aired (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation.continuation of the original WesternAnimation/TheRealGhostbusters with clear ties to its predecessor. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice. RebelTaxi might have also put the entire franchise on his list of worst remakes because he also wanted it to just die already, but at least he didn't put it at numero freaking uno (Plus, it was PlayedForLaughs). Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't; instead he goes through a long laundry list of "remakes" that aren't even listed in how bad they are. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise; also very easy to do as [[spoiler: Mystery Incorporated]] was included in the rundown (quick update: as of his "Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes" list, he has watched [[spoiler:Mystery Inc.]] and found it refreshing; strike off for that one). I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.
15th Jan '17 8:38:03 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


Alright, Strider. Now it's our turn to criticize you. [[VideoGame/SuperMarioBrothers *Black Boo chirps*]] It's time to look at the [[DarthWiki/DethroningMomentOfSuck worst moments]] of PhantomStrider's videos; as pleasant and generally upbeat of a reviewer as he is, even he isn't immune to criticisms and can pull out a polarizing moment from time to time. These moments might have him [[CriticalResearchFailure get a piece of information wrong]]. Or maybe his usual bias go from understandable to BiasSteamroller levels. As always, if you happen to like the entries on this page, that's great! It's just our silly, personal opinions, so take these with a pinch of salt. Anyway, onto the countdown:

to:

Alright, Strider. Now it's our turn to criticize you. [[VideoGame/SuperMarioBrothers *Black Boo chirps*]] It's time to look at the [[DarthWiki/DethroningMomentOfSuck worst moments]] of PhantomStrider's videos; as pleasant and generally upbeat of a reviewer as he is, even he isn't immune to criticisms and can pull out a polarizing moment from time to time. These moments might have him [[CriticalResearchFailure get a piece of information wrong]]. Or maybe his usual bias go goes from understandable to BiasSteamroller levels. As always, if you happen to like the entries on this page, that's great! It's just our silly, personal opinions, so take these with a pinch of salt. Anyway, onto the countdown:
15th Jan '17 1:51:44 PM Asue
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old voice actresses back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of [[SmallNameBigEgo pretentiousness]]) and made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist piece of crap while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Franchise/StarWars Star Wars'' at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)

to:

* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old voice actresses back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of [[SmallNameBigEgo pretentiousness]]) and made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist piece of crap while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Franchise/StarWars Star Wars'' ''Franchise/StarWars'' at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)
15th Jan '17 1:51:05 PM Asue
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old voice actresses back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of [[SmallNameBigEgo pretentiousness]]) and made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist piece of crap while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars'' at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)

to:

* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old voice actresses back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of [[SmallNameBigEgo pretentiousness]]) and made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist piece of crap while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars ''Franchise/StarWars Star Wars'' at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)
15th Jan '17 1:50:06 PM Asue
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old voice actresses back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of [[SmallNameBigEgo pretentiousness]]) and made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist piece of crap while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)

to:

* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old voice actresses back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of [[SmallNameBigEgo pretentiousness]]) and made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist piece of crap while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars Wars'' at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)
14th Jan '17 10:31:02 PM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message


[[folder: ScrewAttack]]
* Bengson26: ScrewAttack's Top 5 Free-To-Play Games has this moment. Here, Nick says that in ''VideoGame/TeamFortress2'' (I'm really talking about [=TF2=] a lot here, huh?), weapons with real advantages are locked behind a paywall. This just reeks with CriticalResearchFailure. First off, while admittedly there is a massive market for weapons in [=TF2=], you could get weapons at random via a drop system. Second, none of the weapons have real advantages since they're sidegrades. Screwattack, there's a rule whenever you make Top 10 lists. It's called do your fucking research!
* Sugarp1e1: I didn't appreciate the seventh entry of ScrewAttack's [[https://youtu.be/fZuki3QTb2s Top 10 Worst Cartoons Based on Video Games list]]; [[spoiler:BlazBlue: Alter Memory.]] It's not the fact that Nervous Nick doesn't like [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] that's the problem (I've never even played the game or watched the anime). As with my PhantomStrider entry above, my problem with this list is his reason for putting it on the list as well as his elitist attitude about the whole thing. He starts the entry off by making it clear that he doesn't like the game's world or story, having a very PlayTheGameSkipTheStory attitude about it. Okay, fine. But judging by the clips of the anime he used, [[spoiler:Alter Memory]] is actually a pretty faithful adaptation. So why is it bad according to Nick? [[BiasSteamroller Because it's a faithful adaptation of a game he never liked to begin with.]] His bias behind this is clear, what with him spending the entire entry summarizing the story in way that makes it sound even more confusing than it really is (instead of just explaining why he finds it confusing) and ending the entry with him absolutely losing his [[PrecisionFStrike shit]] over how much he hates [[spoiler:BlazBlue]]'s story (especially the whole [[spoiler:StableTimeLoop]] plot point), claiming "I see [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] for what it really is! It's a mess! I hate it! That's why it's #7." Um, Nick? [[OpinionMyopia Are you implying that the people who do like the story are idiotic sheep?]] To me, it sounds like he's genuinely proclaiming himself to be [[FanHater better than the fans]] because he can't get past the story. Don't get me wrong; I totally agree that the [[spoiler:StableTimeLoop]] is confusing, especially at the end when [[spoiler:the cycle is finally broken]], but I wouldn't yell at my audience that "The story sucks!" in a way that suggests my subjective opinion is objective fact. And considering how he goes from screaming his lungs out to calmly moving on to #6, it was PlayedForLaughs. You probably also noticed that this DMOS sounds more like I'm talking about the game and not the anime. Nick's tirade was the same way. On top of all that, [[MurderArsonAndJaywalking #7 was the only entry on the list that wasn't an adaptation of a game he liked.]] If he never liked [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] to begin with, then he's in no position to tell us that [[spoiler:Alter Memory]] is a bad adaptation just because it's faithful to the source material.
** keybladeoverlord: In addition to the above statement about this list, I was displeased with how Nervous Nick put not one, but TWO of the Sonic the Hedgehog cartoons on the list. First off, while the two shows in question, Sonic Underground at #8 and The Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog at #3, may not be as great as Sonic SATAM, they still have their fanbases, but it was nothing but nitpicking to an absurd degree, especially when he mentioned the shows' giving Sonic a Trademark Favorite Food which eventually became canon to the games. While I admit both shows had flaws to them, they were still some fun little experiences to watch. I wouldn't be so mad about it if he had stuck to the rule that so many other countdown makers have taken to heart these days, which is the One Entry Per Franchise rule. I also really didn't like his bashing of the Donkey Kong Country cartoon, where any legitimate complaints about the show were drowned out by pointless bitching about things like the show having songs, many of which are liked by a LOT of people and gives the show some of its charm.
[[/folder]]



* Bengson26: ScrewAttack's Top 5 Free-To-Play Games has this moment. Here, Nick says that in ''VideoGame/TeamFortress2'' (I'm really talking about [=TF2=] a lot here, huh?), weapons with real advantages are locked behind a paywall. This just reeks with CriticalResearchFailure. First off, while admittedly there is a massive market for weapons in [=TF2=], you could get weapons at random via a drop system. Second, none of the weapons have real advantages since they're sidegrades. Screwattack, there's a rule whenever you make Top 10 lists. It's called do your fucking research!



* Sugarp1e1: I didn't appreciate the seventh entry of ScrewAttack's [[https://youtu.be/fZuki3QTb2s Top 10 Worst Cartoons Based on Video Games list]]; [[spoiler:BlazBlue: Alter Memory.]] It's not the fact that Nervous Nick doesn't like [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] that's the problem (I've never even played the game or watched the anime). As with my PhantomStrider entry above, my problem with this list is his reason for putting it on the list as well as his elitist attitude about the whole thing. He starts the entry off by making it clear that he doesn't like the game's world or story, having a very PlayTheGameSkipTheStory attitude about it. Okay, fine. But judging by the clips of the anime he used, [[spoiler:Alter Memory]] is actually a pretty faithful adaptation. So why is it bad according to Nick? [[BiasSteamroller Because it's a faithful adaptation of a game he never liked to begin with.]] His bias behind this is clear, what with him spending the entire entry summarizing the story in way that makes it sound even more confusing than it really is (instead of just explaining why he finds it confusing) and ending the entry with him absolutely losing his [[PrecisionFStrike shit]] over how much he hates [[spoiler:BlazBlue]]'s story (especially the whole [[spoiler:StableTimeLoop]] plot point), claiming "I see [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] for what it really is! It's a mess! I hate it! That's why it's #7." Um, Nick? [[OpinionMyopia Are you implying that the people who do like the story are idiotic sheep?]] To me, it sounds like he's genuinely proclaiming himself to be [[FanHater better than the fans]] because he can't get past the story. Don't get me wrong; I totally agree that the [[spoiler:StableTimeLoop]] is confusing, especially at the end when [[spoiler:the cycle is finally broken]], but I wouldn't yell at my audience that "The story sucks!" in a way that suggests my subjective opinion is objective fact. And considering how he goes from screaming his lungs out to calmly moving on to #6, it was PlayedForLaughs. You probably also noticed that this DMOS sounds more like I'm talking about the game and not the anime. Nick's tirade was the same way. On top of all that, [[MurderArsonAndJaywalking #7 was the only entry on the list that wasn't an adaptation of a game he liked.]] If he never liked [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] to begin with, then he's in no position to tell us that [[spoiler:Alter Memory]] is a bad adaptation just because it's faithful to the source material.
** keybladeoverlord: In addition to the above statement about this list, I was displeased with how Nervous Nick put not one, but TWO of the Sonic the Hedgehog cartoons on the list. First off, while the two shows in question, Sonic Underground at #8 and The Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog at #3, may not be as great as Sonic SATAM, they still have their fanbases, but it was nothing but nitpicking to an absurd degree, especially when he mentioned the shows' giving Sonic a Trademark Favorite Food which eventually became canon to the games. While I admit both shows had flaws to them, they were still some fun little experiences to watch. I wouldn't be so mad about it if he had stuck to the rule that so many other countdown makers have taken to heart these days, which is the One Entry Per Franchise rule. I also really didn't like his bashing of the Donkey Kong Country cartoon, where any legitimate complaints about the show were drowned out by pointless bitching about things like the show having songs, many of which are liked by a LOT of people and gives the show some of its charm.
14th Jan '17 9:51:29 PM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most [[CausticCritic Caustic Critics]] however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of lists. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater (As you can see in the flavor text). But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every single Scooby-Doo remake in existence]]! Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "The original was never any good to begin with, so the franchise should have died years ago!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years despite the original's lack of appeal to him. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, especially if it's a show I don't like. But I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place the entire franchise at #1 on a Worst Remakes list and bash it simply because of it's lifespan and the quality of the original alone. Not to mention that he seems to think that [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] is, like the other remakes he mentions, exactly the same as the original. Oh, and he even had the gall to assume that nobody actively watches [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] anyway, saying "Has any kid ever sat down and said, 'Oh, look! [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] is on!'?", and claiming that kids only watch it when there's nothing better to watch (I've watched both [[spoiler: What's New, Scooby-Doo?]] and [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] regularly when I was a kid. And loved them). This assumption is not only insulting, but it makes no sense. If a series has been remade over 19 times, then it must have some sort of fanbase otherwise it wouldn't have been remade once! Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I was so disappointed with him, I couldn't bring myself to listen to him re-explain why he hates [[spoiler:Scooby Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/P9NLefklYK8 Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes list]] and skipped over it. (But judging by his added comment of "Forever" in the entry title, he was trying to justify cramming the entire franchise on the top spot of his Worst Remakes list). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".
** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice; even when RebelTaxi also just wants the franchise to die, he didn't put it at numero freaking uno. Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't; instead he goes through a long laundry list of "remakes" that aren't even listed in how bad they are. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise; also very easy to do as [[spoiler: Mystery Incorporated]] was included in the rundown (quick update: as of his "Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes" list, he has watched [[spoiler:Mystery Inc.]] and found it refreshing; strike off for that one). I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.
** shonengirl: Third. This is hands down, the worst thing in the history of his channel. Two things I [[BerserkButton absolutely hate]] are when reviewers seem to know little about what they're talking about, and when they lump things of varying quality into one mass and declare them all bad/judge them all solely on the quality of some of them or an unfortunate DorkAge. Basically, I despise CriticalResearchFailure... And him putting every single [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] reboot on that list just screamed both of these things. Okay Strider, what about the Tom and Jerry, Ninja Turtles, anything Mickey Mouse related, and Looney Toons reboots, are ''they'' bad too because their franchises have been around for a long time and have truckloads of reboots? No? Actually, what ''about'' Tom and Jerry? It's also a Hanna-Barbera franchise that has been around forever, if not even longer than [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]], but he conveniently forgets that, doesn't he? There are many LongRunners that continue to be loved to this day, so by this logic they're all bad simply because they've been around to see the civil rights movement... [[SarcasmMode Sure, Strider, sure]]. [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] was actually pretty solid and had deviated quite a bit from the normal episodic format, not to mention the series fills in a western animation niche that doesn't get filled often in the modern day, the genre of mystery. The only other modern cartoon in this genre I can think of is Gravity Falls, which ended, while [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] will continue filling this niche with a fresh new take every time. Oh yeah, what about counting movies as reboots? ...Huh?! I've disagreed with him before, sure, but respected his opinion because he's a genuinely nice person and entertaining on top of it; this was the only time I ever cringed at this guy's content ever. I'm not even a huge fan of [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]], but this was just ''bad''. It just really reminds me of those people who think Pokémon is a series consisting of the same game released over and over again, or whining that Nintendo has no innovation despite many of their franchises evolving over the years. To make it worse, I criticised him for this, and if I didn't accidentally delete it, he apparently removed my comment. Come on, Strider, I expect more from you! Oh yeah, and [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking how the hell is Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog a reboot?! Shouldn't video game adaptations have a list of their own?]]

to:

* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most [[CausticCritic Caustic Critics]] however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of lists. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater (As you can see in the flavor text). But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every single Scooby-Doo remake in existence]]! Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "The original was never any good to begin with, so the franchise should have died years ago!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years despite the original's lack of appeal to him. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, especially if it's a show I don't like. But I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place the entire franchise at #1 on a Worst Remakes list and bash it simply because of it's lifespan and the quality of the original alone. Not to mention that he seems to think that [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] is, like the other remakes he mentions, exactly the same as the original. Oh, and he even Strider seemed to had TakenALevelInJerkass for this entry. Usually, he just expresses his distaste in a professional and witty manner like the classy DeadpanSnarker he is. Here it sounds more like he's trying to rally all of his viewers against the franchise, what with him having the gall to assume that nobody actively watches [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] anyway, saying asking "Has any kid ever sat down and said, 'Oh, look! [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] is on!'?", and claiming that kids only watch it when there's nothing better to watch (I've watch. Excuse me Strider, but I watched both [[spoiler: What's New, Scooby-Doo?]] and [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] regularly when I was a kid. And kid and loved them). them. Again, this is coming from a guy who claims to be fine with people liking something he doesn't. This assumption is not only hypocritical and insulting, but it makes no sense. If a series has been remade over 19 times, then it must have some sort of fanbase otherwise it wouldn't have been remade even once! Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I was so disappointed with him, I couldn't bring myself to listen to him re-explain why he hates [[spoiler:Scooby Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/P9NLefklYK8 Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes list]] and skipped over it. (But judging by his added comment of "Forever" in the entry title, he was trying to justify cramming the entire franchise on the top spot of his Worst Remakes list). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".
** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice; even when choice. RebelTaxi might have also just wants put the entire franchise on his list of worst remakes because he also wanted it to die, just die already, but at least he didn't put it at numero freaking uno.uno (Plus, it was PlayedForLaughs). Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't; instead he goes through a long laundry list of "remakes" that aren't even listed in how bad they are. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise; also very easy to do as [[spoiler: Mystery Incorporated]] was included in the rundown (quick update: as of his "Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes" list, he has watched [[spoiler:Mystery Inc.]] and found it refreshing; strike off for that one). I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.
** shonengirl: Third. This is hands down, the worst thing in the history of his channel. Two things I [[BerserkButton absolutely hate]] are when reviewers seem to know little about what they're talking about, and when they lump things of varying quality into one mass and declare them all bad/judge them all solely on the quality of some of them or an unfortunate DorkAge. Basically, I despise CriticalResearchFailure... And him putting every single [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] reboot on that list just screamed both of these things. Okay Strider, what about the Tom and Jerry, Ninja Turtles, anything Mickey Mouse related, and Looney Toons reboots, are ''they'' bad too because their franchises have been around for a long time and have truckloads of reboots? No? Actually, what ''about'' Tom and Jerry? It's also a Hanna-Barbera franchise that has been around forever, if not even longer than [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]], but he conveniently forgets that, doesn't he? There are many LongRunners that continue to be loved to this day, so by this logic they're all bad simply because they've been around to see the civil rights movement... [[SarcasmMode Sure, Strider, sure]]. [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] was actually pretty solid and had deviated quite a bit from the normal episodic format, not to mention the series fills in a western animation niche that doesn't get filled often in the modern day, the genre of mystery. The only other modern cartoon in this genre I can think of is Gravity Falls, which ended, while [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] will continue filling this niche with a fresh new take every time. Oh yeah, what about counting movies as reboots? ...Huh?! I've disagreed with him before, sure, but respected his opinion because he's a genuinely nice person and entertaining on top of it; this was the only time I ever cringed at this guy's content ever. I'm not even a huge fan of [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]], but this was just ''bad''. bad! It just really reminds me of those people who think Pokémon is a series consisting of the same game released over and over again, or whining that Nintendo has no innovation despite many of their franchises evolving over the years. To make it worse, I criticised him for this, and if I didn't accidentally delete it, he apparently removed my comment. Come on, Strider, I expect more from you! Oh yeah, and [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking how the hell is Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog a reboot?! Shouldn't video game adaptations have a list of their own?]]



* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old voice actresses back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of [[SmallNameBigEgo pretentiousness]]), which made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist piece of crap while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)

to:

* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old voice actresses back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of [[SmallNameBigEgo pretentiousness]]), which pretentiousness]]) and made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist piece of crap while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.))
** Sugarp1e1: I agree. What especially ticks me off about this video is hotdiggitydemon feeling the need to AccenuateTheNegative despite finding the reboot SoOkayItsAverage. Which is it? Is it average or is it bad? There's a difference, you know.
14th Jan '17 12:30:14 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy, [[CruelAndUnusualDeath graphic]], [[NightmareFuel brutal and cruel]] as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He [[NauseaFuel cuts a slice off Toothy's face]] ''[[TheWoobie while he was terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me actually cry in genuine sympathy]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits by a fan, [[BodyHorror carves Nutty like an apple]], shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. Seriously, F**K YOU, FLIQPY! After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the unfunny Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q]]'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]]. And of course Mondo ''had'' to put him in more episodes.

to:

** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy, [[CruelAndUnusualDeath graphic]], [[NightmareFuel brutal and cruel]] as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He [[NauseaFuel cuts a slice off Toothy's face]] ''[[TheWoobie while he was terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me actually cry in genuine sympathy]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits by a fan, [[BodyHorror carves Nutty like an apple]], shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. Seriously, F**K YOU, FLIQPY! FLI''Q''PY! You're nothing more than a torturous psychopath who kills people from little to no reason at all! After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the unfunny Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q]]'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]]. And of course Mondo ''had'' to put him in more episodes.
13th Jan '17 7:59:18 AM FromtheWordsofBR
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* TommyTiger: When someone at [=KissCartoon=] said he found the song from the episode "The Hero" in ''WesternAnimation/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball'' to be a TearJerker. Now, it could have been something I'd say was a good point, if he didn't say that Gumball needed to get spanked. As indicated by the [[DethroningMoment/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball DMOS page]] for the show, Gumball and Darwin were pelted by Nicole and Anais with cupcakes made of cement and then denied necessities like bathing and food. All they did wrong in the episode was say that Richard didn't amount to much, and even that is [[StrawmanHasAPoint justified]] by the episode "The Job". They didn't deserve to be bullied, no matter what that user said. They also [[NeverLiveItDown deliberately ignore]] [[Heartwarming/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball the boys apologizing to Richard]]. In other words, they think that children should be [[SarcasmMode "rightfully"]] abused for saying all the things Richard failed at. [[{{Jerkass}} Wow.]]
12th Jan '17 7:02:08 AM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most [[CausticCritic Caustic Critics]] however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of lists. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater (As you can see in the flavor text). But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every single Scooby-Doo remake in existence]]! Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "The original was never any good to begin with, so the franchise should have died years ago!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years despite the original's lack of appeal to him. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, especially if it's a show I don't like. But I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place the entire franchise at #1 on a Worst Remakes list and bash it simply because of it's lifespan and the quality of the original alone. Not to mention that he seems to think that [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] is, like the other remakes he mentions, exactly the same as the original. Oh, and he even had the gall to assume that nobody actively watches [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] anyway, saying "Has any kid ever sat down and said, 'Oh, look! [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] is on!'?", and claiming that kids only watch it when there's nothing better to watch (I've watched both [[spoiler: What's New, Scooby-Doo?]] and [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] regularly when I was a kid. And loved them). This assumption is not only insulting, but it makes no sense. If a series has been remade over 19 times, then it must have some sort of fanbase otherwise it wouldn't have been remade once! Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I was so disappointed with him, I couldn't bring myself to listen to him re-explain why he hates [[spoiler:Scooby Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/P9NLefklYK8 Top 10 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes list]] and skipped over it. (But judging by his added comment of "Forever" in the entry title, he was trying to justify cramming the entire franchise on the top spot of his Worst Remakes list). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".

to:

* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most [[CausticCritic Caustic Critics]] however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of lists. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater (As you can see in the flavor text). But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every single Scooby-Doo remake in existence]]! Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "The original was never any good to begin with, so the franchise should have died years ago!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years despite the original's lack of appeal to him. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, especially if it's a show I don't like. But I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place the entire franchise at #1 on a Worst Remakes list and bash it simply because of it's lifespan and the quality of the original alone. Not to mention that he seems to think that [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] is, like the other remakes he mentions, exactly the same as the original. Oh, and he even had the gall to assume that nobody actively watches [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] anyway, saying "Has any kid ever sat down and said, 'Oh, look! [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] is on!'?", and claiming that kids only watch it when there's nothing better to watch (I've watched both [[spoiler: What's New, Scooby-Doo?]] and [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] regularly when I was a kid. And loved them). This assumption is not only insulting, but it makes no sense. If a series has been remade over 19 times, then it must have some sort of fanbase otherwise it wouldn't have been remade once! Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I was so disappointed with him, I couldn't bring myself to listen to him re-explain why he hates [[spoiler:Scooby Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/P9NLefklYK8 Top 10 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes list]] and skipped over it. (But judging by his added comment of "Forever" in the entry title, he was trying to justify cramming the entire franchise on the top spot of his Worst Remakes list). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".
12th Jan '17 6:56:51 AM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most [[CausticCritic Caustic Critics]] however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of lists. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater (As you can see in the flavor text). But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every Scooby-Doo remake in existence]]! Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "the series won't just die already!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, but I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place it at #1 on a Worst Remakes list and bash it simply because of that one fact. Someone in the comments section called him out on this and even accused him of only including all of the remakes simply because he didn't like the original (he never replied). Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I was so disappointed with him, I couldn't bring myself to listen to him re-explain why he hates [[spoiler:Scooby Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/P9NLefklYK8 Top 10 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes list]] and skipped over it. (But judging by his added comment of "Forever" in the entry title, he was trying to justify cramming the entire franchise on the top spot of his Worst Remakes list). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".

to:

* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most [[CausticCritic Caustic Critics]] however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of lists. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater (As you can see in the flavor text). But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every single Scooby-Doo remake in existence]]! Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "the series won't just die already!" "The original was never any good to begin with, so the franchise should have died years ago!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years. years despite the original's lack of appeal to him. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, but especially if it's a show I don't like. But I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place it the entire franchise at #1 on a Worst Remakes list and bash it simply because of that one fact. Someone in it's lifespan and the comments section called him out on this and even accused him quality of only including all of the remakes simply because he didn't like the original (he never replied). alone. Not to mention that he seems to think that [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] is, like the other remakes he mentions, exactly the same as the original. Oh, and he even had the gall to assume that nobody actively watches [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] anyway, saying "Has any kid ever sat down and said, 'Oh, look! [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] is on!'?", and claiming that kids only watch it when there's nothing better to watch (I've watched both [[spoiler: What's New, Scooby-Doo?]] and [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] regularly when I was a kid. And loved them). This assumption is not only insulting, but it makes no sense. If a series has been remade over 19 times, then it must have some sort of fanbase otherwise it wouldn't have been remade once! Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I was so disappointed with him, I couldn't bring myself to listen to him re-explain why he hates [[spoiler:Scooby Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/P9NLefklYK8 Top 10 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes list]] and skipped over it. (But judging by his added comment of "Forever" in the entry title, he was trying to justify cramming the entire franchise on the top spot of his Worst Remakes list). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".
12th Jan '17 5:59:37 AM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message


Alright, Strider. Now it's our turn to criticize you. [[VideoGame/SuperMarioBrothers *Black Boo chirps*]] It's time to look at the [[DarthWiki/DethroningMomentOfSuck worst moments]] of PhantomStrider's videos; as pleasant and generally upbeat of a reviewer as he is, even he isn't immune to criticisms and can pull out a polarizing moment from time to time. These moments might have him [[CriticalResearchFailure get a piece of information wrong]]. Or maybe his usual bias go from understandable to BiasSteamroller levels. As always, if you happen to like the entries on this page, that's great! It's just our silly, personal opinions, so take these with a pinch of salt. Anyway, here we go:

to:

Alright, Strider. Now it's our turn to criticize you. [[VideoGame/SuperMarioBrothers *Black Boo chirps*]] It's time to look at the [[DarthWiki/DethroningMomentOfSuck worst moments]] of PhantomStrider's videos; as pleasant and generally upbeat of a reviewer as he is, even he isn't immune to criticisms and can pull out a polarizing moment from time to time. These moments might have him [[CriticalResearchFailure get a piece of information wrong]]. Or maybe his usual bias go from understandable to BiasSteamroller levels. As always, if you happen to like the entries on this page, that's great! It's just our silly, personal opinions, so take these with a pinch of salt. Anyway, here we go:onto the countdown:
12th Jan '17 5:52:16 AM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message


It's time to look at the [[DarthWiki/DethroningMomentOfSuck worst moments]] of PhantomStrider's videos; as pleasant and generally upbeat of a reviewer as he is, even he isn't immune to criticisms and can pull out a polarizing moment from time to time. If you happen to like the entries on this page, that's great! It's just our silly, personal opinions, so take these with a pinch of salt. Anyway, onto the countdown:
* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most CausticCritics however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of Top 10s. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater ("If you don't think these [[topic of the list]] are bad, that's great! It's just my silly personal opinion. And I'm glad you can enjoy these [[topic]] while I can't.") But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every Scooby-Doo remake in existence!]] Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "the series won't just die already!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, but I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place it at #1 on a Worst Remakes list and bash it simply because of that one fact. Someone in the comments section called him out on this and even accused him of only including all of the remakes simply because he didn't like the original (he never replied). Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I was so disappointed with him, I couldn't bring myself to listen to him re-explain why he hates [[spoiler:Scooby Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/P9NLefklYK8 Top 10 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes list]] and skipped over it. (But judging by his added comment of "Forever" in the entry title, he was either trying to justify cramming the entire franchise on the top spot of his Worst Remakes list and/or telling his viewers that his opinion will never change no matter what). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".

to:

Alright, Strider. Now it's our turn to criticize you. [[VideoGame/SuperMarioBrothers *Black Boo chirps*]] It's time to look at the [[DarthWiki/DethroningMomentOfSuck worst moments]] of PhantomStrider's videos; as pleasant and generally upbeat of a reviewer as he is, even he isn't immune to criticisms and can pull out a polarizing moment from time to time. If These moments might have him [[CriticalResearchFailure get a piece of information wrong]]. Or maybe his usual bias go from understandable to BiasSteamroller levels. As always, if you happen to like the entries on this page, that's great! It's just our silly, personal opinions, so take these with a pinch of salt. Anyway, onto the countdown:
here we go:
* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most CausticCritics [[CausticCritic Caustic Critics]] however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of Top 10s. lists. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater ("If you don't think these [[topic of the list]] are bad, that's great! It's just my silly personal opinion. And I'm glad (As you can enjoy these [[topic]] while I can't.") see in the flavor text). But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every Scooby-Doo remake in existence!]] existence]]! Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "the series won't just die already!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, but I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place it at #1 on a Worst Remakes list and bash it simply because of that one fact. Someone in the comments section called him out on this and even accused him of only including all of the remakes simply because he didn't like the original (he never replied). Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I was so disappointed with him, I couldn't bring myself to listen to him re-explain why he hates [[spoiler:Scooby Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/P9NLefklYK8 Top 10 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes list]] and skipped over it. (But judging by his added comment of "Forever" in the entry title, he was either trying to justify cramming the entire franchise on the top spot of his Worst Remakes list and/or telling his viewers that his opinion will never change no matter what).list). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".
11th Jan '17 11:26:22 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

It's time to look at the [[DarthWiki/DethroningMomentOfSuck worst moments]] of PhantomStrider's videos; as pleasant and generally upbeat of a reviewer as he is, even he isn't immune to criticisms and can pull out a polarizing moment from time to time. If you happen to like the entries on this page, that's great! It's just our silly, personal opinions, so take these with a pinch of salt. Anyway, onto the countdown:
11th Jan '17 11:18:25 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice; even when RebelTaxi also just wants the franchise to die, he didn't put it at numero freaking uno. Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't; instead he goes through a long laundry list of "remakes" that aren't even listed in how bad they are. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise; also very easy to do as [[spoiler: Mystery Incorporated]] was included in the rundown (quick update: as of his "Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes" list, he has watched Mystery Inc. and found it refreshing; strike off for that one). I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.

to:

** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice; even when RebelTaxi also just wants the franchise to die, he didn't put it at numero freaking uno. Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't; instead he goes through a long laundry list of "remakes" that aren't even listed in how bad they are. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise; also very easy to do as [[spoiler: Mystery Incorporated]] was included in the rundown (quick update: as of his "Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes" list, he has watched Mystery Inc. [[spoiler:Mystery Inc.]] and found it refreshing; strike off for that one). I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.
11th Jan '17 11:17:39 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice; even when RebelTaxi also just wants the franchise to die, he didn't put it at numero freaking uno. Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't; instead he goes through a long laundry list of "remakes" that aren't even listed in how bad they are. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise; also very easy to do as [[spoiler: Mystery Incorporated]] was included in the rundown. I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.

to:

** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice; even when RebelTaxi also just wants the franchise to die, he didn't put it at numero freaking uno. Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't; instead he goes through a long laundry list of "remakes" that aren't even listed in how bad they are. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise; also very easy to do as [[spoiler: Mystery Incorporated]] was included in the rundown.rundown (quick update: as of his "Top 5 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes" list, he has watched Mystery Inc. and found it refreshing; strike off for that one). I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.
11th Jan '17 7:20:01 PM Midna
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/{{GAP}} This troper also likes Razorfist's reviews but he notices that Razorfist really lampoon the Metal Gear franchise. In his "Metal Gear Flaccid" vlog video video where he explains his thoughts on the MGS games, he mentions how Metal Gear is singlehandlely responsible for some of the worse trends in gaming despite other games that doing even worse things than MGS. This troper acknowledges that Razorfist is critical of Metal Gear and he does have very solid points but it seems as though that he makes Kojima out to be some blithering failure who couldn't make good game if he tried. Kojima may not be the best of writers but the Metal Gear games are really good games and it isn't as though Metal Gear is the only offender of all the things that he lobbied against it.

to:

** Tropers/{{GAP}} This troper Tropers/{{GAP}}: I also likes like Razorfist's reviews but he notices I notice that Razorfist really lampoon hates the Metal Gear franchise. In his "Metal Gear Flaccid" vlog video video where he explains his thoughts on the MGS games, he mentions how Metal Gear is singlehandlely responsible for some of the worse worst trends in gaming despite other games that doing do even worse things than MGS. This troper acknowledges I acknowledge that Razorfist is critical of Metal Gear and he does have very solid points but it seems as though that he makes Kojima out to be some blithering failure who couldn't make a good game if he tried. Kojima may not be the best of writers but the Metal Gear games are really good games and it isn't as though Metal Gear is the only offender of all the things that he lobbied against it.against.



* InsertCleverNameHere: [=ABrandonToThePast=]'s [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ECrrQzc9Ma4 50 Things Wrong With The Pokemon Anime]] list is definitely one for this troper not only because of just how much nitpicking and CriticalResearchFailure there are, but also forgetting that [[PeripheryHatedom the anime is intended for kids way below his age.]] But the worst moment has to be number 37, in that [[LimitedWardrobe the characters wear the same clothes everyday.]] Not only is that just plain wrong (The main girls have worn a ton of different outfits), but it's probably the laziest choice for a list that I've ever seen in my life, period. Seriously, Brandon? You're going to complain about how they don't change clothes? May I remind you that neither does every fictional cartoon character that's ever existed, and that you're just showing that you ran out of things to bitch about while you were working on this. He says that the anime has been getting worse over years. That's fine, but when you deliberately try and use faulty reasons that are typical upon most anime and cartoons, then congratulations, you've just lost yourself a loyal fan of yours who will not be watching your videos ever again.

to:

* InsertCleverNameHere: [=ABrandonToThePast=]'s [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ECrrQzc9Ma4 50 Things Wrong With The Pokemon Anime]] list is definitely one for this troper me not only because of just how much nitpicking and CriticalResearchFailure there are, but also forgetting that [[PeripheryHatedom the anime is intended for kids way below his age.]] But the worst moment has to be number 37, in that [[LimitedWardrobe the characters wear the same clothes everyday.]] Not only is that just plain wrong (The main girls have worn a ton of different outfits), but it's probably the laziest choice for a list that I've ever seen in my life, period. Seriously, Brandon? You're going to complain about how they don't change clothes? May I remind you that neither does every fictional cartoon character that's ever existed, and that you're just showing that you ran out of things to bitch about while you were working on this. He says that the anime has been getting worse over years. That's fine, but when you deliberately try and use faulty reasons that are typical upon most anime and cartoons, then congratulations, you've just lost yourself a loyal fan of yours who will not be watching your videos ever again.



* Troper/{{kensu}}: {{Website/Snopes}} is a pretty good example of how credulous web users used to be in the '90s and 2000s. Whatever Snopes had to say on any urban myth was gospel; no argument. These days, however, they've mostly been replaced by Wikipedia and various blogs which allow user interaction and fact-checking. The scales fell from this troper's eyes over two myths and the way that the moderators of Snopes handled them. The first is the famous case of The Dating Game, where a housewife gave a ribald response to the question: "what is the strangest place you've ever had sex". Snopes started out saying this was fake, but imagine our surprise when a video of it emerged. Snopes continued to claim the legend was fake, because some (but not all) accounts of the legends involved a black couple, and the couple in the video was white. Basically Snopes was claiming that the legend wasn't true, there just happened to have been another incident that perfectly matched the legend, but wasn't actually the incident that was being referred to. Snopes eventually very reluctantly changed the status of this myth to true. The second case was that of The Wooden Bomb. The original page said this myth was false, citing no references. This was followed with a long paternalistic lecture about how the legend couldn't be true, which makes it pretty clear that they never bothered to research it. It then came out that the legend was true, and it took a very long time for Snopes to acknowledge that. In the interim Snopes went to rather insane lengths to ensure that their site can't be archived, so it's impossible for anyone to see the history of their positions on various myths. Bad form, indeed!

to:

* Troper/{{kensu}}: {{Website/Snopes}} is a pretty good example of how credulous web users used to be in the '90s and 2000s. Whatever Snopes had to say on any urban myth was gospel; no argument. These days, however, they've mostly been replaced by Wikipedia and various blogs which allow user interaction and fact-checking. The scales fell from this troper's my eyes over two myths and the way that the moderators of Snopes handled them. The first is the famous case of The Dating Game, where a housewife gave a ribald response to the question: "what is the strangest place you've ever had sex". Snopes started out saying this was fake, but imagine our surprise when a video of it emerged. Snopes continued to claim the legend was fake, because some (but not all) accounts of the legends involved a black couple, and the couple in the video was white. Basically Snopes was claiming that the legend wasn't true, there just happened to have been another incident that perfectly matched the legend, but wasn't actually the incident that was being referred to. Snopes eventually very reluctantly changed the status of this myth to true. The second case was that of The Wooden Bomb. The original page said this myth was false, citing no references. This was followed with a long paternalistic lecture about how the legend couldn't be true, which makes it pretty clear that they never bothered to research it. It then came out that the legend was true, and it took a very long time for Snopes to acknowledge that. In the interim Snopes went to rather insane lengths to ensure that their site can't be archived, so it's impossible for anyone to see the history of their positions on various myths. Bad form, indeed!
11th Jan '17 6:59:00 PM flamemario12
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/ParaChomp: "Search for the Worst: Suicide Squad". I will not argue against negative criticism against Movie/SuicideSquad, it's justified. What I will argue against are the constant questioning of the existence of various characters. One can see them as IHE pointing out them being unnecessary for the film but when he compared Characters/KillerCroc to Character/GorillaGrodd, you could tell that either wasn't the case or he's being too vague with the intentions of his words. There is nothing wrong with either of them as characters in terms of premise, same can be said about Characters/CaptainBoomerang and Characters/Katana. All four of these characters have proven their worth in other pieces of media. There are so many characters who use trick weapons for combat and Katana was as relevant as ever due to Television/BewareTheBatman. One of the film's problems are its many unnecessary characters but these characters have been well written in other media and have relevance to the source material which is something IHE doesn't acknowledge. I do realize that I am an IDIOT trying to win such an argument. This is someone who doesn't care about the history of comics nor their characters, only wants a good movie, and uses Aquaman and Characters/KiteMan as their Trope/ButtMonkey. Once again, the wound that the UsefulNotes/TheComicsCode has left shows its ugly face proving that even the Trope/DarkerAndEdgier adaptions can't hide it.
* [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: I liked his ''Search for the Worst'' review of the ''WebVideo/{{Fred}}'' Movie Trilogy and even thought the bit with his friend Ralphthemoviemaker was decent. However, around 30 minutes in, after snarking about a video where Lucas says he doesn't remember filming the "Fred vs. TheAnnoyingOrange" video, he then says that's the result of blackouts and trying to repress memories. Then the video pauses for Ralph to make a [[OverlyLongGag really long]] [[{{Squick}} and unnecessarily uncomfortable]] child molestation joke. It goes on for what feels like forever (it lasts a minute!!), it contradicts some of Alex's points regarding comedy (in that jokes need a punchline to be funny....this one doesn't, it's also very similar to a scene in the movie Alex also criticized for also being drawn-out), and worst of all, it's not funny, not even in the black sort of sense. I know Ralph's bit was produced by himself but there was no need for that joke and it soured the video a bit for me (still a damn good video either way, but good lord) due to how unnecessary and hypocritical it was.

to:

* Tropers/ParaChomp: "Search for the Worst: Suicide Squad". I will not argue against negative criticism against Movie/SuicideSquad, it's justified. What I will argue against are the constant questioning of the existence of various characters. One can see them as IHE pointing out them being unnecessary for the film but when he compared Characters/KillerCroc Killer Croc to Character/GorillaGrodd, Gorilla Grodd, you could tell that either wasn't the case or he's being too vague with the intentions of his words. There is nothing wrong with either of them as characters in terms of premise, same can be said about Characters/CaptainBoomerang Captain Boomerang and Characters/Katana.Katana. All four of these characters have proven their worth in other pieces of media. There are so many characters who use trick weapons for combat and Katana was as relevant as ever due to Television/BewareTheBatman.WesternAnimation/BewareTheBatman. One of the film's problems are its many unnecessary characters but these characters have been well written in other media and have relevance to the source material which is something IHE doesn't acknowledge. I do realize that I am an IDIOT trying to win such an argument. This is someone who doesn't care about the history of comics nor their characters, only wants a good movie, and uses Aquaman and Characters/KiteMan Kite Man as their Trope/ButtMonkey. Once again, the wound that the UsefulNotes/TheComicsCode has left shows its ugly face proving that even the Trope/DarkerAndEdgier adaptions can't hide it.
* [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: I liked his ''Search for the Worst'' review of the ''WebVideo/{{Fred}}'' Movie Trilogy and even thought though the bit with his friend Ralphthemoviemaker was decent. However, around 30 minutes in, after snarking about a video where Lucas says he doesn't remember filming the "Fred vs. TheAnnoyingOrange" video, he then says that's the result of blackouts and trying to repress memories. Then the video pauses for Ralph to make a [[OverlyLongGag really long]] [[{{Squick}} and unnecessarily uncomfortable]] child molestation joke. It goes on for what feels like forever (it lasts a minute!!), it contradicts some of Alex's points regarding comedy (in that jokes need a punchline to be funny....this one doesn't, it's also very similar to a scene in the movie Alex also criticized for also being drawn-out), and worst of all, it's not funny, not even in the black sort of sense. I know Ralph's bit was produced by himself but there was no need for that joke and it soured the video a bit for me (still a damn good video either way, but good lord) due to how unnecessary and hypocritical it was.
9th Jan '17 10:10:26 PM Asue
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old voice actresses back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of Small Name, Big Ego ), which made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist piece of crap while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)

to:

* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old voice actresses back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of Small Name, Big Ego ), [[SmallNameBigEgo pretentiousness]]), which made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist piece of crap while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)
9th Jan '17 10:06:25 PM Asue
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old voice actresses back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of ''Small Name, Big Ego''), which made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist piece of crap while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)

to:

* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old voice actresses back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of ''Small Small Name, Big Ego''), Ego ), which made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist piece of crap while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)
9th Jan '17 10:05:33 PM Asue
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old voice actresses back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of ''SmallName,BigEgo''), which made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist PoS while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)

to:

* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old voice actresses back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of ''SmallName,BigEgo''), ''Small Name, Big Ego''), which made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist PoS piece of crap while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)
9th Jan '17 10:04:22 PM Asue
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old voice actresses back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of SmallName,BigEgo), which made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist PoS while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)

to:

* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old voice actresses back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of SmallName,BigEgo), ''SmallName,BigEgo''), which made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist PoS while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)
9th Jan '17 10:03:12 PM Asue
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old VAs back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of Small Name,Big Ego), which made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist PoS while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)

to:

* Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old VAs voice actresses back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of Small Name,Big Ego), SmallName,BigEgo), which made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist PoS while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)
9th Jan '17 10:01:47 PM Asue
Is there an issue? Send a Message


%%* Tropers/TommyTiger: When someone at [=KissCartoon=] said he found the song from the episode "The Hero" in ''WesternAnimation/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball'' to be a TearJerker. Now, it could have been something I'd say was a good point, if he didn't say that Gumball needed to get spanked. As indicated by the [[DethroningMoment/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball DMOS page]] for the show, Gumball and Darwin were pelted by Nicole and Anais with cupcakes made of cement and then denied necessities like bathing and food. All they did wrong in the episode was say that Richard didn't amount to much, and even that is [[StrawmanHasAPoint justified]] by the episode "The Job". They didn't deserve to be bullied, no matter what that user said. They also [[NeverLiveItDown deliberately ignore]] [[Heartwarming/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball the boys apologizing to Richard]]. In other words, they think that children should be [[SarcasmMode "rightfully"]] abused for saying all the things Richard failed at. [[{{Jerkass}} Wow.]]
%%* Tropers/Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old VAs back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of Small Name,Big Ego), which made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist PoS while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)

to:

%%* Tropers/TommyTiger: * TommyTiger: When someone at [=KissCartoon=] said he found the song from the episode "The Hero" in ''WesternAnimation/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball'' to be a TearJerker. Now, it could have been something I'd say was a good point, if he didn't say that Gumball needed to get spanked. As indicated by the [[DethroningMoment/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball DMOS page]] for the show, Gumball and Darwin were pelted by Nicole and Anais with cupcakes made of cement and then denied necessities like bathing and food. All they did wrong in the episode was say that Richard didn't amount to much, and even that is [[StrawmanHasAPoint justified]] by the episode "The Job". They didn't deserve to be bullied, no matter what that user said. They also [[NeverLiveItDown deliberately ignore]] [[Heartwarming/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball the boys apologizing to Richard]]. In other words, they think that children should be [[SarcasmMode "rightfully"]] abused for saying all the things Richard failed at. [[{{Jerkass}} Wow.]]
%%* Tropers/Asue: * Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old VAs back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of Small Name,Big Ego), which made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist PoS while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)
9th Jan '17 10:00:48 PM Asue
Is there an issue? Send a Message
9th Jan '17 9:59:14 PM Asue
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

%%* Tropers/Asue: hotdiggedydemon's [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xCTcUUYCoBk review of The Powerpuff Girls 2016 reboot]] was a massive disappointment. Now, I do admit to like hdd's stuff (through I don't really like his gross jokes). But this was... Ugh. First of all, this review came waaaaaaay after the initial reaction towards the show (in December of 2016, while the show premiered on April 4, eight months earlier), a.k.a it's old news. I wouldn't usually have a problem with someone reviewing something that was reviewed to death, as long as they bring something new to the table. But he didn't. None of his points were any original or felt fresh whatsoever (from ranting about the reboot toning down the violence, which isn't the cartoon's fault but rather because of the MoralGuardians who complained about the original show's violence, to talk about the main characters not getting their old VAs back to the twerking bit). Second, his smug tone during the video made him look like he was trying way too hard to be like "I know better than you, Powerpuff Girls 2016 team" (especially when he actually challenges them to watch this video, which reeks of Small Name,Big Ego), which made me cringe. And third, he was reading too much into the supposed "anti-feminism" stuff (which was made up just to make the show look like a sexist PoS while not even trying to be funny in the process). And this is coming from someone who thought the reboot was "meh". (Also, what was up with that random TakeThat towards ''Frachise/StarWars Star Wars at the end? That was pointless and not even remotely connected to the review at all.)
8th Jan '17 2:46:59 PM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message
8th Jan '17 2:45:48 PM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most CausticCritics however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of Top 10s. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater ("If you don't think these [[topic of the list]] are bad, that's great! It's just my silly personal opinion. And I'm glad you can enjoy these [[topic]] while I can't.") But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every Scooby-Doo remake in existence!]] Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "the series won't just die already!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, but I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place it at #1 on a "Worst Remakes" list and bash it simply because of that one fact. Someone in the comments section called him out on this and even accused him of only including all of the remakes simply because he didn't like the original (he never replied). Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".

to:

* Sugarp1e1: PhantomStrider (real name: Josh Strider) is a CausticCritic from Australia who is often described as a less angry, more forgiving [[TheMysteriousMrEnter Mysterious Mr. Enter]] with better editing. Unlike most CausticCritics however, he does almost all of his reviews in the form of Top 10s. He's also pretty humble, admitting to being biased at times and making it clear in all of the intros to his videos that he's not a FanHater ("If you don't think these [[topic of the list]] are bad, that's great! It's just my silly personal opinion. And I'm glad you can enjoy these [[topic]] while I can't.") But the former didn't become more blatantly obvious than in his [[https://youtu.be/-0MxCQmlmmE Top 10 Worst Cartoon Remakes list]]. It was pretty good for the most part. There's just three things I didn't like and/or understand. 1) I'm confused as to how the [[spoiler:Powerpuff Girls]] reboot wasn't at #10 considering he was the least critical of it compared to the others on the list. 2) I didn't really understand the TakeThat against the trailer for the new Ghostbusters movie. I know that the all-female cast didn't get a very warm welcome, but if there's one thing I know, it's that [[NeverTrustATrailer trailers can't be trusted]]. You don't know if the movie gonna be good regardless of the cast or not. But the DMoS for me is his #1 pick: [[spoiler:every Scooby-Doo remake in existence!]] Look, I don't care if he doesn't like [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]]; that's his opinion. But his reason behind his #1 pick shows just how biased he can be. Strider's criticisms about [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] are legitimate, if debatable (he found the show formulaic, boring and "nothing special"), but his only criticism about all of the remakes that followed was basically "the series won't just die already!" In his defense, if I remember correctly, I think he did mention at some point that he doesn't feel like any of the remakes added anything new or interesting to the series. But even if he did, it was completely overshadowed by his rant about how annoyed he is that the franchise is still going after 40 years. I totally understand where he's coming from; I get pretty surprised myself when I find out something that came out when I was a kid is still going on to this day, but I wouldn't be so annoyed as to place it at #1 on a "Worst Remakes" Worst Remakes list and bash it simply because of that one fact. Someone in the comments section called him out on this and even accused him of only including all of the remakes simply because he didn't like the original (he never replied). Even worse? In his [[https://youtu.be/IlkvxV1laO8 Top 10 Best Disney Movies list]], he references the angry comments he got from this in a gag where he calmly says "[[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] kinda... sucks?" before being pelted by tomatoes. As if he was being totally reasonable with his decision and the viewers were the ones being ridiculous! Can someone please remind him that he specifically described his #2 pick, [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], as "the devil's anus of bad"? If he thinks [[spoiler:the entire Scooby-Doo franchise]] is even worse than [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]], then "it kinda sucks" isn't even close to what he was saying. Not only that, but judging by Strider's comment about [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/N95f7baE0as?list=PLfji1gVKy4fYaePq-q1ox2S24X8VZbelZ Top 10 Worst Cartoon Live Action Remakes list]], he seems to think that the only people who are mad at him for this are the [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] fans. Implying that he genuinely believes that all of those angry comments were from the FanDumb as opposed to some belonging to those who saw just how biased he was being. I was so disappointed with him, I couldn't bring myself to listen to him re-explain why he hates [[spoiler:Scooby Doo]] in his [[https://youtu.be/P9NLefklYK8 Top 10 Cartoons I hate that Everyone Likes list]] and skipped over it. (But judging by his added comment of "Forever" in the entry title, he was either trying to justify cramming the entire franchise on the top spot of his Worst Remakes list and/or telling his viewers that his opinion will never change no matter what). I don't believe in Unsubscribing, so I'll continue to watch his videos. But you'd think somebody who claims to enjoy engaging in intelligent conversation would have a better reason for his #1 pick than "there's too many remakes".
5th Jan '17 8:51:59 AM Midna
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Uttergenius: I'm surprised no one has mentioned Creator/LilyPeet yet. She's basically the Creator/BenCroshaw of the WebVideo/MLPAnalysis community with her [[SmugSnake snide and abrasive attitude]]; so she's bound to be [[LoveItOrHateIt polarizing]]. I'm not a Brony, but I have watched her videos simply out of curiosity -- that is, until his unscripted 3 AM Ramble dated August 2nd, 2016. In it, she states she will never watch ''WesternAnimation/GravityFalls'' because people keep pestering her to watch the show. That's understandable: [[HypeAversion excessive hype can kill one's interest in something]]. But then she says something to the effect of "I'm going to sh*ttalk this show because, f*ck you." Not caving into pressure to watch something is acceptable; threatening to [[ComplainingAboutShowsYouDontWatch badmouth a show he hasn't even seen]] solely to piss off its fans isn't. I'm not even one of the people who was apparently bothering him about ''Gravity Falls'', and I felt insulted by this. But that's not all. She goes on to say that she would have liked to see the show on her own time; but now if she watched it, her experience would be tainted by fans not shutting up about it. You know what this means? [[FanHater She's blaming the fans for ruining the show for her]] [[NeverMyFault rather than her own stubbornness]]. If this were in a scripted video, this wouldn't be much of an issue since this behavior is simply an act, but this was unscripted, [[FridgeHorror meaning this is likely how she acts in real life]]. Peet, if you're going to insult your audience like this, at least keep it confined to your main work where we understand it's all for show, not your unscripted stuff where it can easily be taken at face value.

to:

* Uttergenius: I'm surprised no one has mentioned Creator/LilyPeet yet. She's basically the Creator/BenCroshaw of the WebVideo/MLPAnalysis community with her [[SmugSnake snide and abrasive attitude]]; so she's bound to be [[LoveItOrHateIt polarizing]]. I'm not a Brony, but I have watched her videos simply out of curiosity -- that is, until his her unscripted 3 AM Ramble dated August 2nd, 2016. In it, she states she will never watch ''WesternAnimation/GravityFalls'' because people keep pestering her to watch the show. That's understandable: [[HypeAversion excessive hype can kill one's interest in something]]. But then she says something to the effect of "I'm going to sh*ttalk this show because, f*ck you." Not caving into pressure to watch something is acceptable; threatening to [[ComplainingAboutShowsYouDontWatch badmouth a show he she hasn't even seen]] solely to piss off its fans isn't. I'm not even one of the people who was apparently bothering him her about ''Gravity Falls'', and I felt insulted by this. But that's not all. She goes on to say that she would have liked to see the show on her own time; but now if she watched it, her experience would be tainted by fans not shutting up about it. You know what this means? [[FanHater She's blaming the fans for ruining the show for her]] [[NeverMyFault rather than her own stubbornness]]. If this were in a scripted video, this wouldn't be much of an issue since this behavior is simply an act, but this was unscripted, [[FridgeHorror meaning this is likely how she acts in real life]]. Peet, if you're going to insult your audience like this, at least keep it confined to your main work where we understand it's all for show, not your unscripted stuff where it can easily be taken at face value.
5th Jan '17 8:50:47 AM Midna
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Uttergenius: I'm surprised no one has mentioned Creator/Lily Peet yet. She's basically the Creator/BenCroshaw of the WebVideo/MLPAnalysis community with her [[SmugSnake snide and abrasive attitude]]; so she's bound to be [[LoveItOrHateIt polarizing]]. I'm not a Brony, but I have watched her videos simply out of curiosity -- that is, until his unscripted 3 AM Ramble dated August 2nd, 2016. In it, she states she will never watch ''WesternAnimation/GravityFalls'' because people keep pestering her to watch the show. That's understandable: [[HypeAversion excessive hype can kill one's interest in something]]. But then she says something to the effect of "I'm going to sh*ttalk this show because, f*ck you." Not caving into pressure to watch something is acceptable; threatening to [[ComplainingAboutShowsYouDontWatch badmouth a show he hasn't even seen]] solely to piss off its fans isn't. I'm not even one of the people who was apparently bothering him about ''Gravity Falls'', and I felt insulted by this. But that's not all. She goes on to say that she would have liked to see the show on her own time; but now if she watched it, her experience would be tainted by fans not shutting up about it. You know what this means? [[FanHater She's blaming the fans for ruining the show for her]] [[NeverMyFault rather than her own stubbornness]]. If this were in a scripted video, this wouldn't be much of an issue since this behavior is simply an act, but this was unscripted, [[FridgeHorror meaning this is likely how she acts in real life]]. Peet, if you're going to insult your audience like this, at least keep it confined to your main work where we understand it's all for show, not your unscripted stuff where it can easily be taken at face value.

to:

* Uttergenius: I'm surprised no one has mentioned Creator/Lily Peet Creator/LilyPeet yet. She's basically the Creator/BenCroshaw of the WebVideo/MLPAnalysis community with her [[SmugSnake snide and abrasive attitude]]; so she's bound to be [[LoveItOrHateIt polarizing]]. I'm not a Brony, but I have watched her videos simply out of curiosity -- that is, until his unscripted 3 AM Ramble dated August 2nd, 2016. In it, she states she will never watch ''WesternAnimation/GravityFalls'' because people keep pestering her to watch the show. That's understandable: [[HypeAversion excessive hype can kill one's interest in something]]. But then she says something to the effect of "I'm going to sh*ttalk this show because, f*ck you." Not caving into pressure to watch something is acceptable; threatening to [[ComplainingAboutShowsYouDontWatch badmouth a show he hasn't even seen]] solely to piss off its fans isn't. I'm not even one of the people who was apparently bothering him about ''Gravity Falls'', and I felt insulted by this. But that's not all. She goes on to say that she would have liked to see the show on her own time; but now if she watched it, her experience would be tainted by fans not shutting up about it. You know what this means? [[FanHater She's blaming the fans for ruining the show for her]] [[NeverMyFault rather than her own stubbornness]]. If this were in a scripted video, this wouldn't be much of an issue since this behavior is simply an act, but this was unscripted, [[FridgeHorror meaning this is likely how she acts in real life]]. Peet, if you're going to insult your audience like this, at least keep it confined to your main work where we understand it's all for show, not your unscripted stuff where it can easily be taken at face value.
4th Jan '17 6:08:55 PM Ferot_Dreadnaught
Is there an issue? Send a Message


-->-- [[WebAnimation/IfTheEmperorHadATextToSpeechDevice God-Emperor of Mankind]]

to:

-->-- [[WebAnimation/IfTheEmperorHadATextToSpeechDevice God-Emperor '''God-Emperor of Mankind]]
Mankind''', ''WebAnimation/IfTheEmperorHadATextToSpeechDevice''
4th Jan '17 11:38:34 AM FromtheWordsofBR
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/TommyTiger: When someone at [=KissCartoon=] said he found the song from the episode "The Hero" in ''WesternAnimation/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball'' to be a TearJerker. Now, it could have been something I'd say was a good point, if he didn't say that Gumball needed to get spanked. As indicated by the [[DethroningMoment/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball DMOS page]] for the show, Gumball and Darwin were pelted by Nicole and Anais with cupcakes made of cement and then denied necessities like bathing and food. All they did wrong in the episode was say that Richard didn't amount to much, and even that is [[StrawmanHasAPoint justified]] by the episode "The Job". They didn't deserve to be bullied, no matter what that user said. They also [[NeverLiveItDown deliberately ignore]] [[Heartwarming/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball the boys apologizing to Richard]]. In other words, they think that children should be [[SarcasmMode "rightfully"]] abused for saying all the things Richard failed at. [[{{Jerkass}} Wow.]]

to:

* %%* Tropers/TommyTiger: When someone at [=KissCartoon=] said he found the song from the episode "The Hero" in ''WesternAnimation/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball'' to be a TearJerker. Now, it could have been something I'd say was a good point, if he didn't say that Gumball needed to get spanked. As indicated by the [[DethroningMoment/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball DMOS page]] for the show, Gumball and Darwin were pelted by Nicole and Anais with cupcakes made of cement and then denied necessities like bathing and food. All they did wrong in the episode was say that Richard didn't amount to much, and even that is [[StrawmanHasAPoint justified]] by the episode "The Job". They didn't deserve to be bullied, no matter what that user said. They also [[NeverLiveItDown deliberately ignore]] [[Heartwarming/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball the boys apologizing to Richard]]. In other words, they think that children should be [[SarcasmMode "rightfully"]] abused for saying all the things Richard failed at. [[{{Jerkass}} Wow.]]
4th Jan '17 12:22:23 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/TommyTiger: When someone at KissCartoon said he found the song from the episode "The Hero" in ''WesternAnimation/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball'' to be a TearJerker. Now, it could have been something I'd say was a good point, if he didn't say that Gumball needed to get spanked. As indicated by the [[DethroningMoment/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball DMOS page]] for the show, Gumball and Darwin were pelt by Nicole and Anais with cupcakes made of cement and then denied necessities like bathing and food. All they did wrong in the episode was say that Richard didn't amount to much, and even that is [[StrawmanHasAPoint justified]] by the episode "The Job". They didn't deserve to be bullied, no matter what that user said. They also [[NeverLiveItDown deliberately ignore]] [[Heartwarming/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball the boys apologizing to Richard]]. In other words, they think that children should be [[SarcasmMode "rightfully"]] abused for saying all the things Richard failed at. [[{{Jerkass}} Wow.]]

to:

** * Tropers/TommyTiger: When someone at KissCartoon [=KissCartoon=] said he found the song from the episode "The Hero" in ''WesternAnimation/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball'' to be a TearJerker. Now, it could have been something I'd say was a good point, if he didn't say that Gumball needed to get spanked. As indicated by the [[DethroningMoment/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball DMOS page]] for the show, Gumball and Darwin were pelt pelted by Nicole and Anais with cupcakes made of cement and then denied necessities like bathing and food. All they did wrong in the episode was say that Richard didn't amount to much, and even that is [[StrawmanHasAPoint justified]] by the episode "The Job". They didn't deserve to be bullied, no matter what that user said. They also [[NeverLiveItDown deliberately ignore]] [[Heartwarming/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball the boys apologizing to Richard]]. In other words, they think that children should be [[SarcasmMode "rightfully"]] abused for saying all the things Richard failed at. [[{{Jerkass}} Wow.]]
4th Jan '17 12:14:42 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Tropers/TommyTiger: When someone at KissCartoon said he found the song from the episode "The Hero" in ''WesternAnimation/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball'' to be a TearJerker. Now, it could have been something I'd say was a good point, if he didn't say that Gumball needed to get spanked. As indicated by the [[DethroningMoment/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball DMOS page]] for the show, Gumball and Darwin were pelt by Nicole and Anais with cupcakes made of cement and then denied necessities like bathing and food. All they did wrong in the episode was say that Richard didn't amount to much, and even that is [[StrawmanHasAPoint justified]] by the episode "The Job". They didn't deserve to be bullied, no matter what that user said. They also [[NeverLiveItDown deliberately ignore]] [[Heartwarming/TheAmazingWorldOfGumball the boys apologizing to Richard]]. In other words, they think that children should be [[SarcasmMode "rightfully"]] abused for saying all the things Richard failed at. [[{{Jerkass}} Wow.]]
2nd Jan '17 11:26:37 PM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/TommyTiger: There's an awful video on the internet. It revolves about {{WesternAnimation/Tom|and Jerry}} killing Jerry (this video is so messed up I'm not even providing a link!). I don't find Jerry to be mean, unlike other people, but I can understand why some people think of that. It shows Jerry getting killed by Tom with an axe, leading to [[NightmareFuel a pool of blood (no joking) covering him (Jerry)]]. In other words, Jerry gets brutally killed by Tom. [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality And this is treated as a good thing!]] So this video basically implies that [[JerkassWoobie the poor mouse]] deserves to die [[DisproportionateRetribution just because he defends himself from Tom with more meanness than should]]. [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even canon Tom would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the Tom in this video to slaughter Jerry like this because [[FelonyMisdemeanor he (mostly understandably) pesters him]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's totally a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I will never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in that person's criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). This crosses both BlackComedy and AuthorTract, going more into "offensiveness" territory. Even I'd find the death of my personal {{Scrapp|y}}ies scary and totally not funny at all.

to:

* Tropers/TommyTiger: There's an awful video on the internet. It revolves about {{WesternAnimation/Tom|and Jerry}} killing Jerry (this video is so messed up I'm not even providing a link!). I don't find Jerry to be mean, unlike other people, but I can understand why some people think of that. It shows Jerry getting killed by Tom with an axe, leading to [[NightmareFuel a pool of blood (no joking) covering him (Jerry)]]. In other words, Jerry gets brutally killed by Tom.[[RonTheDeathEater Tom]]. Without a trace of GoryDiscretionShot. [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality And this is treated as a good thing!]] So this video basically implies that [[JerkassWoobie the poor mouse]] deserves to die [[DisproportionateRetribution just because he defends himself from Tom with more meanness than should]]. [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even canon Tom would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the Tom in this video to slaughter Jerry like this because [[FelonyMisdemeanor he (mostly understandably) pesters him]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's totally a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I will never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in that person's criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). This crosses both BlackComedy and AuthorTract, going more into "offensiveness" "So funny, I forgot to laugh" territory. Even I'd find the death of my personal {{Scrapp|y}}ies scary and totally not funny at all.
31st Dec '16 5:35:38 PM HulkingCetacean
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Uttergenius: I'm surprised no one has mentioned Creator/JerryPeet yet. He's basically the Creator/BenCroshaw of the WebVideo/MLPAnalysis community with his [[SmugSnake snide and abrasive attitude]]; so he's bound to be [[LoveItOrHateIt polarizing]]. I'm not a Brony, but I have watched his videos simply out of curiosity -- that is, until his unscripted 3 AM Ramble dated August 2nd, 2016. In it, he states he will never watch ''WesternAnimation/GravityFalls'' because people keep pestering him to watch the show. That's understandable: [[HypeAversion excessive hype can kill one's interest in something]]. But then he says something to the effect of "I'm going to sh*ttalk this show because, f*ck you." Not caving into pressure to watch something is acceptable; threatening to [[ComplainingAboutShowsYouDontWatch badmouth a show he hasn't even seen]] solely to piss off its fans isn't. I'm not even one of the people who was apparently bothering him about ''Gravity Falls'', and I felt insulted by this. But that's not all. He goes on to say that he would have liked to see the show on his own time; but now if he watched it, his experience would be tainted by fans not shutting up about it. You know what this means? [[FanHater He's blaming the fans for ruining the show for him]] [[NeverMyFault rather than his own stubbornness]]. If this were in a scripted video, this wouldn't be much of an issue since this behavior is simply an act, but this was unscripted, [[FridgeHorror meaning this is likely how he acts in real life]]. Peet, if you're going to insult your audience like this, at least keep it confined to your main work where we understand it's all for show, not your unscripted stuff where it can easily be taken at face value.

to:

* Uttergenius: I'm surprised no one has mentioned Creator/JerryPeet Creator/Lily Peet yet. He's She's basically the Creator/BenCroshaw of the WebVideo/MLPAnalysis community with his her [[SmugSnake snide and abrasive attitude]]; so he's she's bound to be [[LoveItOrHateIt polarizing]]. I'm not a Brony, but I have watched his her videos simply out of curiosity -- that is, until his unscripted 3 AM Ramble dated August 2nd, 2016. In it, he she states he she will never watch ''WesternAnimation/GravityFalls'' because people keep pestering him her to watch the show. That's understandable: [[HypeAversion excessive hype can kill one's interest in something]]. But then he she says something to the effect of "I'm going to sh*ttalk this show because, f*ck you." Not caving into pressure to watch something is acceptable; threatening to [[ComplainingAboutShowsYouDontWatch badmouth a show he hasn't even seen]] solely to piss off its fans isn't. I'm not even one of the people who was apparently bothering him about ''Gravity Falls'', and I felt insulted by this. But that's not all. He She goes on to say that he she would have liked to see the show on his her own time; but now if he she watched it, his her experience would be tainted by fans not shutting up about it. You know what this means? [[FanHater He's She's blaming the fans for ruining the show for him]] her]] [[NeverMyFault rather than his her own stubbornness]]. If this were in a scripted video, this wouldn't be much of an issue since this behavior is simply an act, but this was unscripted, [[FridgeHorror meaning this is likely how he she acts in real life]]. Peet, if you're going to insult your audience like this, at least keep it confined to your main work where we understand it's all for show, not your unscripted stuff where it can easily be taken at face value.
31st Dec '16 7:28:05 AM StFan
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Troper/JetpackPercy: For me, it was ''WebVideo/AniMat'''s Top Ten Best and Worst Animated Films of 2013. The video was decent at best (''WesternAnimation/{{Epic}}'', the 3rd Best Film on his list, was one of my worst for 2013), up until he got up to the part where it cost him a subscriber, when he gets to ''{{Cloudy With A Chance Of Meatballs 2}}'', the worst movie in 2013 on the list. Now I don't mind if you don't like the film, but what killed any chance of me watching any more of his videos in the future was when he said that if anyone actually liked this film, then they would need to reconsider their life. Okay, as stated, if you don't like a film, that's okay, but you said in the review of the film itself that you wouldn't try to change anyone's opinion of the film, so why force them to change here? Hypocrite much? Honestly, that one line alone cost you your subscriber, and potentially more of them because of that. By the way, try telling that to people who actually liked the film, and see how many friends/subscribers you get.

to:

* Troper/JetpackPercy: For me, it was ''WebVideo/AniMat'''s Top Ten Best and Worst Animated Films of 2013. The video was decent at best (''WesternAnimation/{{Epic}}'', the 3rd Best Film on his list, was one of my worst for 2013), up until he got up to the part where it cost him a subscriber, when he gets to ''{{Cloudy With A Chance Of Meatballs 2}}'', ''WesternAnimation/CloudyWithAChanceOfMeatballs2'', the worst movie in 2013 on the list. Now I don't mind if you don't like the film, but what killed any chance of me watching any more of his videos in the future was when he said that if anyone actually liked this film, then they would need to reconsider their life. Okay, as stated, if you don't like a film, that's okay, but you said in the review of the film itself that you wouldn't try to change anyone's opinion of the film, so why force them to change here? Hypocrite much? Honestly, that one line alone cost you your subscriber, and potentially more of them because of that. By the way, try telling that to people who actually liked the film, and see how many friends/subscribers you get.
30th Dec '16 10:26:26 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/TommyTiger: There's an awful video on the internet. It revolves about {{WesternAnimation/Tom|and Jerry}} killing Jerry (this video is so messed up I'm not even providing a link!). I don't find Jerry to be mean, unlike other people, but I can understand why some people think of that. It shows Jerry getting killed by Tom with an axe, leading to [[NightmareFuel a pool of blood (no joking) covering him (Jerry)]]. In other words, Jerry gets brutally killed by Tom. [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality And this is treated as a good thing!]] So this video basically implies that [[JerkassWoobie the poor mouse]] deserves to die [[DisproportionateRetribution just because he defends himself from Tom with more meanness than should]]. [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even canon Tom would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the Tom in this video to slaughter Jerry like this because [[FelonyMisdemeanor he (mostly understandably) pesters him]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's totally a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I will never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in that person's criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). This crosses both BlackComedy and AuthorTract, going more into "offensiveness" territory.

to:

* Tropers/TommyTiger: There's an awful video on the internet. It revolves about {{WesternAnimation/Tom|and Jerry}} killing Jerry (this video is so messed up I'm not even providing a link!). I don't find Jerry to be mean, unlike other people, but I can understand why some people think of that. It shows Jerry getting killed by Tom with an axe, leading to [[NightmareFuel a pool of blood (no joking) covering him (Jerry)]]. In other words, Jerry gets brutally killed by Tom. [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality And this is treated as a good thing!]] So this video basically implies that [[JerkassWoobie the poor mouse]] deserves to die [[DisproportionateRetribution just because he defends himself from Tom with more meanness than should]]. [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even canon Tom would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the Tom in this video to slaughter Jerry like this because [[FelonyMisdemeanor he (mostly understandably) pesters him]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's totally a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I will never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in that person's criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). This crosses both BlackComedy and AuthorTract, going more into "offensiveness" territory. Even I'd find the death of my personal {{Scrapp|y}}ies scary and totally not funny at all.
30th Dec '16 9:56:26 AM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Sugarp1e1: The [[spoiler:Warcraft]] entry of [[https://youtu.be/iDe5CkaUGho GameSpot's Worst Reviewed Movies of 2016]] rubbed me the wrong way. For the majority of the list, the narrator of this video spent a decent amount of time for each entry explaining why each movie is bad. [[spoiler:Nine Lives]] isn't funny, [[spoiler:The Do-Over]] is yet another braindead Adam Sandler comedy, [[spoiler:Zoolander 2]] is just a rehash of the original, etc. But for the [[spoiler:Warcraft]] entry, they decide to just show a single clip of what they expected from the movie and compare it to multiple clips from the actual movie, with FlatWhat reactions thrown in-between, to make the classic "This is what we wanted, but this is what we got. Therefore it sucks" argument. While the argument itself isn't bad, the execution was just...lazy and weak. I know that they were trying to invoke the "It speaks for itself" argument and that if the person watching this video was a [[spoiler:WoW]] fan who agreed with GameSpot's opinion of the movie, it most likely would. But what about all the people who never played the game or watched the movie? If they're anything like me, they'd probably be confused as to why they think the movie is bad. What exactly were they trying to say? That the movie was boring? That it was silly? That it didn't feel the games it was adapted from? I'm just guessing here. Call me stupid, but I don't get it. I'm not saying they should've sat down and spelled it out to us, just that they could've explained why the movie is bad instead of just lazily pasting some clips together with little to no review. Also, in the [[spoiler:Zoolander 2]] entry, they state that even Justin Bieber's [[spoiler:death scene]] couldn't save this movie. If the joke ended there, it'd okay. But instead they decide to shoehorn a clip of the infamous scene from CSI where Justin [[spoiler:is shot dead]], despite the fact that CSI has nothing to do with the topic of the list at hand. In other words, they used [[spoiler:Zoolander 2]] as an excuse to pander to Justin Bieber's haters and make a "Justin Bieber must die" joke. That, to me, is the equivalent of making an "MC Hammer is broke" joke: an old joke that just isn't funny anymore.
30th Dec '16 5:01:04 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Tropers/TommyTiger: There's an awful video on the internet. It revolves about {{WesternAnimation/Tom|and Jerry}} killing Jerry (this video is so messed up I'm not even providing a link!). I don't find Jerry to be mean, unlike other people, but I can understand why some people think of that. It shows Jerry getting killed by Tom with an axe, leading to [[NightmareFuel a pool of blood (no joking) covering him (Jerry)]]. In other words, Jerry gets brutally killed by Tom. [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality And this is treated as a good thing!]] So this video basically implies that [[JerkassWoobie the poor mouse]] deserves to die [[DisproportionateRetribution just because he defends himself from Tom with more meanness than should]]. [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even canon Tom would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the Tom in this video to slaughter Jerry like this because [[FelonyMisdemeanor he (mostly understandably) pesters him]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's totally a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I will never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in that person's criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). This crosses both BlackComedy and AuthorTract, going more into "offensiveness" territory.
29th Dec '16 9:52:24 AM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** ''SenorCornholio'': Fourthed. I'm honestly the first troper on this segment to have enjoyed this video for the most part, with things like bomb bowling and calling out the Gorons for being such picky eaters being highlights. However, I will admit it had some serious flaws: the points he made were more YMMV than actual bad game design, his jabs at Skyward Sword were unneeded and deviated from the rest of the video entirely, [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking and he said twice that Impa was the one that gave you the letter instead of Zelda]]. However, those aren't my main gripes. See, I could understand talking about Skyward Sword and using Ocarina of Time as a way to show how the ideas adopted in that game ended up forming this "spoiled rich kid" in the series. That's fine...then along comes the part where he talks about A Link Between Worlds. He goes to countless lengths praising how greatly implemented its mechanics were, while taking extra shots at Skyward Sword and Twilight Princess. Hey guys, did you know!? [[CaptainObvious Egoraptor doesn't like 3D Zeldas!]] I just thought he didn't hammer it into your heads enough! And what's more is that, just like his gripes with Skyward Sword, they were really not needed at all. Yes, the Spinner was hardly ever used, and the Magic Armor was a terrible, ''terrible'' item, but did he really need to mention that? It feels more like this segment existed to toot Arin's own horn and complain about more 3D mechanics, and it also felt shoehorned in due to Arin playing the game and liking it. I love [[GirlChanInParadise most]] [[Music/StarBomb of]] [[WebVideo/GameGrumps Arin's]] [[AwesomeSeries work,]] I enjoy him as a creator, and I know he's a good person in real life, but this was just a dumb moment in an already polarizing review.

to:

** ''SenorCornholio'': Fourthed. I'm honestly the first troper on this segment to have enjoyed this video for the most part, with things like bomb bowling and calling out the Gorons for being such picky eaters being highlights. However, I will admit it had some serious flaws: the points he made were more YMMV than actual bad game design, his jabs at Skyward Sword were unneeded and deviated from the rest of the video entirely, [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking and he said twice that Impa was the one that gave you the letter instead of Zelda]]. However, those aren't my main gripes. See, I could understand talking about Skyward Sword and using Ocarina of Time as a way to show how the ideas adopted in that game ended up forming this "spoiled rich kid" in the series. That's fine...then along comes the part where he talks about A Link Between Worlds. He goes to countless lengths praising how greatly implemented its mechanics were, while taking extra shots at Skyward Sword and Twilight Princess. Hey guys, did you know!? [[CaptainObvious Egoraptor doesn't like 3D Zeldas!]] I just thought he didn't hammer it into your heads enough! And what's more is that, just like his gripes with Skyward Sword, they were really not needed at all. Yes, the Spinner was hardly ever used, and the Magic Armor was a terrible, ''terrible'' item, but did he really need to mention that? It feels more like this segment existed to toot Arin's own horn and complain about more 3D mechanics, and it also felt shoehorned in due to Arin playing the game and liking it. I love [[GirlChanInParadise most]] [[Music/StarBomb of]] [[WebVideo/GameGrumps Arin's]] [[AwesomeSeries [[WebAnimation/AwesomeSeries work,]] I enjoy him as a creator, and I know he's a good person in real life, but this was just a dumb moment in an already polarizing review.
27th Dec '16 3:54:26 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy, [[CruelAndUnusualDeath graphic]], [[NightmareFuel brutal and cruel]] as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He [[NauseaFuel cuts a slice off Toothy's face]] ''[[TheWoobie while he was terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me actually cry in genuine sympathy]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits by a fan, [[BodyHorror carves Nutty like an apple]], shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the unfunny Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q]]'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]]. And of course Mondo ''had'' to put him in more episodes.

to:

** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy, [[CruelAndUnusualDeath graphic]], [[NightmareFuel brutal and cruel]] as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He [[NauseaFuel cuts a slice off Toothy's face]] ''[[TheWoobie while he was terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me actually cry in genuine sympathy]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits by a fan, [[BodyHorror carves Nutty like an apple]], shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. Seriously, F**K YOU, FLIQPY! After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the unfunny Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q]]'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]]. And of course Mondo ''had'' to put him in more episodes.
26th Dec '16 12:17:12 PM PhantomDusclops92
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* HulkingCetacean: JoshScorcher for "Response to Lily Peet" for completely different reasons than that videos comment section would say i would call it a DMOS ... i used to think he used to be a good person who didnt like the dark side of the internet...then he went to 8chan and Kiwi farms to dig up their posts on Lily Peet they have kept in a stalker-like fashion and THEN in the video tells his fans not to send her death threats and has never called them out like he has done before when they inevitably did (and they linked proof that they did in the comment section of the video) but the fact that he calls himself a Christian and openly went to hate filled sites that stand for everything that Christianity is against disgusts me

to:

* HulkingCetacean: JoshScorcher for "Response to Lily Peet" for completely different reasons than that videos comment section would say i would call it a DMOS ... i used to think he used to be a good person who didnt like the dark side of the internet...then he went to 8chan and Kiwi farms to dig up their posts on Lily Peet they have kept in a stalker-like fashion and THEN in the video tells his fans not to send her death threats and has never called them out like he has done before when they inevitably did (and they linked proof that they did in the comment section of the video) but the fact that he calls himself a Christian and openly went to hate filled sites that stand for everything that Christianity is against disgusts meme.
* Tropers/PhantomDusclops92: I just discovered Clay Claymore and his commentary on ''WebOriginal/TheMysteriousMrEnter'''s videos, enjoying his commentary on how much Enter overreacts to stuff... until I got to [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZHnFt9iukJs "MysteriousMrEnter GO (the fuck away)!"]], his commentary on Enter's [[WesternAnimation/TeenTitansGo "The Return of Slade"]] review. As usual, he goes to notice that Enter overreacts, makes unfunny jokes and stuff... until he goes out of border saying that all the shows Enter said he likes in the review (''WesternAnimation/GravityFalls'', ''WesternAnimation/StevenUniverse'', ''WesternAnimation/StarVsTheForcesOfEvil'' and ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'') are overrated crap, basically saying that [[InsaneTrollLogic if you like any of these shows, you're an overreacting manchild]]. I find that offensive.
24th Dec '16 2:45:47 PM Anddrix
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/RetsofNoraa: Creator/RoosterTeeth's Creator/AchievementHunter has one in their video for the "Pay Your Respects" achievement in ''VideoGame/BatmanArkhamCity''. The achievement is - literally - paying your respects at the site where Bruce's parents were killed. Being Rooster Teeth, they try to lighten the situation with humor - claiming the chalk outlines make it look like Martha Wayne was giving a blowjob to Thomas when they died - but instead of [[CrossesTheLineTwice crossing the line twice]], it only [[DudeNotFunny crosses the line]].

to:

* Tropers/RetsofNoraa: Creator/RoosterTeeth's Creator/AchievementHunter has one in their video for the "Pay Your Respects" achievement in ''VideoGame/BatmanArkhamCity''. The achievement is - literally - paying your respects at the site where Bruce's parents were killed. Being Rooster Teeth, they try to lighten the situation with humor - claiming the chalk outlines make it look like Martha Wayne was giving a blowjob to Thomas when they died - but instead of [[CrossesTheLineTwice crossing the line twice]], it only [[DudeNotFunny crosses the line]].line.



* Tropers/SpongeBat1: I think [=AnimatedJames=] is a fairly decent [=animator/writer=], but what absolutely irks me is his [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yPRnhXVMpO0 Teen Titans No]] video. As one of the few people who like ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitansGo'', I had a feeling I might not like the video, but I can understand why some people don't like the show and decided I'd give James the benefit of the doubt. It starts off with James' idea of what the TTG writers are like, and surprise, surprise, they're all blithering jackasses. [[SarcasmMode Great start so far.]] But what pushes it over the edge is when Robin throws a hand grenade into the room and [[GoryDiscretionShot gorily kills the writers]]. [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality And this is treated as a good thing.]] So this video basically implies that the TTG writers deserve to die [[DisproportionateRetribution just because James doesn't think the show is funny]]. [[SarcasmMode But wait, it gets better!]] Towards the end of the video, a random producer says that the writers were all mentally handicapped... What? There's BlackComedy, there's an AuthorTract, and then there's DudeNotFunny, and frankly, James, that line crossed it big time.

to:

* Tropers/SpongeBat1: I think [=AnimatedJames=] is a fairly decent [=animator/writer=], but what absolutely irks me is his [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yPRnhXVMpO0 Teen Titans No]] video. As one of the few people who like ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitansGo'', I had a feeling I might not like the video, but I can understand why some people don't like the show and decided I'd give James the benefit of the doubt. It starts off with James' idea of what the TTG writers are like, and surprise, surprise, they're all blithering jackasses. [[SarcasmMode Great start so far.]] But what pushes it over the edge is when Robin throws a hand grenade into the room and [[GoryDiscretionShot gorily kills the writers]]. [[ProtagonistCenteredMorality And this is treated as a good thing.]] So this video basically implies that the TTG writers deserve to die [[DisproportionateRetribution just because James doesn't think the show is funny]]. [[SarcasmMode But wait, it gets better!]] Towards the end of the video, a random producer says that the writers were all mentally handicapped... What? There's BlackComedy, there's an AuthorTract, and then there's DudeNotFunny, just plain offensiveness, and frankly, James, that line crossed it big time.



* [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: I liked his ''Search for the Worst'' review of the ''WebVideo/{{Fred}}'' Movie Trilogy and even thought the bit with his friend Ralphthemoviemaker was decent. However, around 30 minutes in, after snarking about a video where Lucas says he doesn't remember filming the "Fred vs. TheAnnoyingOrange" video, he then says that's the result of blackouts and trying to repress memories. Then the video pauses for Ralph to make a [[OverlyLongGag really long]] [[{{Squick}} and unnecessarily uncomfortable]] child molestation joke. It goes on for what feels like forever (it lasts a minute!!), it contradicts some of Alex's points regarding comedy (in that jokes need a punchline to be funny....this one doesn't, it's also very similar to a scene in the movie Alex also criticized for also being drawn-out), and worst of all, [[DudeNotFunny it's not funny, not even in the black sort of sense]]. I know Ralph's bit was produced by himself but there was no need for that joke and it soured the video a bit for me (still a damn good video either way, but good lord) due to how unnecessary and hypocritical it was.

to:

* [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: I liked his ''Search for the Worst'' review of the ''WebVideo/{{Fred}}'' Movie Trilogy and even thought the bit with his friend Ralphthemoviemaker was decent. However, around 30 minutes in, after snarking about a video where Lucas says he doesn't remember filming the "Fred vs. TheAnnoyingOrange" video, he then says that's the result of blackouts and trying to repress memories. Then the video pauses for Ralph to make a [[OverlyLongGag really long]] [[{{Squick}} and unnecessarily uncomfortable]] child molestation joke. It goes on for what feels like forever (it lasts a minute!!), it contradicts some of Alex's points regarding comedy (in that jokes need a punchline to be funny....this one doesn't, it's also very similar to a scene in the movie Alex also criticized for also being drawn-out), and worst of all, [[DudeNotFunny it's not funny, not even in the black sort of sense]].sense. I know Ralph's bit was produced by himself but there was no need for that joke and it soured the video a bit for me (still a damn good video either way, but good lord) due to how unnecessary and hypocritical it was.



* @/AxMachina: Deleting my previous Media Man rage, I found some more [[DarthWiki/DethroningMomentOfSuck dethroning moments]] under his belt. In two reviews[[note]][[http://mixedfan8643.deviantart.com/art/The-Media-Man-Reviews-The-Simpsons-428256345 The Simpsons one]], and the [[http://mixedfan8643.deviantart.com/art/The-Media-Man-Reviews-Home-Alone-1-and-2-419401546 Home Alone one]][[/note]], our CausticCritic says he doesn't like a child character because of him being bratty, or too smart for his own good. Now, this could have been something I could've said was a good point...right up until he had a [[DudeNotFunny "joke"]] where he [[WouldHurtAChild killed one of the characters with a nuclear bomb, and another with a rocket launcher.]] And, to top it all of, in one of the comments calling him out on this, he claims that he's "unique" because of it, then tries to explain himself by saying it was his AuthorAvatar saying it and that [[JustJokingJustification it was supposed to be humorously exaggerated.]] Hey, Media Man. [[{{Hypocrite}} Remember how you said that Bart was evil because he's usually an asshole? How can you say that when you yourself joked about murdering children, and showed no regret, guilt or shame towards your actions because it was a "joke"?]]

to:

* @/AxMachina: Deleting my previous Media Man rage, I found some more [[DarthWiki/DethroningMomentOfSuck dethroning moments]] under his belt. In two reviews[[note]][[http://mixedfan8643.deviantart.com/art/The-Media-Man-Reviews-The-Simpsons-428256345 The Simpsons one]], and the [[http://mixedfan8643.deviantart.com/art/The-Media-Man-Reviews-Home-Alone-1-and-2-419401546 Home Alone one]][[/note]], our CausticCritic says he doesn't like a child character because of him being bratty, or too smart for his own good. Now, this could have been something I could've said was a good point...right up until he had a [[DudeNotFunny "joke"]] "joke" where he [[WouldHurtAChild killed one of the characters with a nuclear bomb, and another with a rocket launcher.]] And, to top it all of, in one of the comments calling him out on this, he claims that he's "unique" because of it, then tries to explain himself by saying it was his AuthorAvatar saying it and that [[JustJokingJustification it was supposed to be humorously exaggerated.]] Hey, Media Man. [[{{Hypocrite}} Remember how you said that Bart was evil because he's usually an asshole? How can you say that when you yourself joked about murdering children, and showed no regret, guilt or shame towards your actions because it was a "joke"?]]



From [[CriticalResearchFailure entries that have about as much research in them as the Jimmy McPerson essay]] to [[DudeNotFunny jokes that would make Seth McFarlane shake his head]], we count down [[DethroningMomentOfSuck the worst Planet Dolan moments of all time]].

to:

From [[CriticalResearchFailure entries that have about as much research in them as the Jimmy McPerson essay]] to [[DudeNotFunny jokes that would make Seth McFarlane shake his head]], head, we count down [[DethroningMomentOfSuck the worst Planet Dolan moments of all time]].



* [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: For me, it's when Proto told commentator Kayden Marx, who is in a financial rut and has started a [=GoFundMe=] to have fans donate money for his insurance, that [[DudeNotFunny he deserved to be in said rut]]. And then he had his fans raid [=youngbloodfantasy91=]'s commentary on him and bring the video to an insane and undeserved amount of dislikes. All because Kayden made a commentary on him that actually makes decent points. [[FlatWhat What.]] Given that I'm barely familiar with Proto's work, [[SarcasmMode talk about a good first impression.]]

to:

* [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: For me, it's when Proto told commentator Kayden Marx, who is in a financial rut and has started a [=GoFundMe=] to have fans donate money for his insurance, that [[DudeNotFunny he deserved to be in said rut]].rut. And then he had his fans raid [=youngbloodfantasy91=]'s commentary on him and bring the video to an insane and undeserved amount of dislikes. All because Kayden made a commentary on him that actually makes decent points. [[FlatWhat What.]] Given that I'm barely familiar with Proto's work, [[SarcasmMode talk about a good first impression.]]



* Tropers/{{JHN}}: I'm not really speaking for myself, but for The Escapist. ''WebAnimation/GameDogs'', a WorkCom about 3 dogs who work in a gaming company, had a TonightSomeoneDies event. [[spoiler: In the episode, 2 side characters kill off the female lead, with jokes centered around where it was legal to kill her or not. The fanbase felt that playing death for laughs & the amount of gore featured felt unpleasant, even for those who enjoy BlackComedy. In TheStinger, Roger - TheSmartGuy, kills himself because he felt unhappy being in company, no signs of it before, causing FridgeLogic. Note, that the characters were somewhat well liked, compared to the main character, Chet, who was condsidered TheScrappy (no pun intended). Saying it was DudeNotFunny would be a understatement, even offending those who liked the GoodTroiEpisode, "Knives-R-Us".]]

to:

* Tropers/{{JHN}}: I'm not really speaking for myself, but for The Escapist. ''WebAnimation/GameDogs'', a WorkCom about 3 dogs who work in a gaming company, had a TonightSomeoneDies event. [[spoiler: In the episode, 2 side characters kill off the female lead, with jokes centered around where it was legal to kill her or not. The fanbase felt that playing death for laughs & the amount of gore featured felt unpleasant, even for those who enjoy BlackComedy. In TheStinger, Roger - TheSmartGuy, kills himself because he felt unhappy being in company, no signs of it before, causing FridgeLogic. Note, that the characters were somewhat well liked, compared to the main character, Chet, who was condsidered TheScrappy (no pun intended). Saying it was DudeNotFunny not funny would be a understatement, even offending those who liked the GoodTroiEpisode, "Knives-R-Us".]]



** Tropers/{{theenglishman}}: I know this will be an unpopular opinion, but to me, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMI1-DDklqE Character Assassination: Authorized]]'' represents the absolute nadir of the channel, and is still their only wrongpurae I can't endure in full. slowbeef's, well, beef with ''VideoGame/MetroidOtherM'' is not undeserved, and while his rants about the game in his LetsPlay of ''VideoGame/MetroidPrime3Corruption'' [[FranchiseOriginalSin were lengthy, passionate and vicious]], [[HandWave it could be chalked up to knee-jerk outrage because he had just finished Other M before starting his playthrough of Prime 3]]. But seeing slowbeef going on a ''very'' personal rant against DarthWiki/FallenCreator Yoshio Sakamoto for two hours ''a full year'' after having last played ''Other M'' was not so endearing, showcasing the worst traits of WebVideo/{{Retsupurae}}'s early work [[DudeNotFunny back when they would attack LPers directly]]. The few jokes that manage to work (mostly courtesy of Diabetus) have no impact because slowbeef just '''will not shut up''' about his hate-boner for Sakamoto, no matter how much the man deserves it. When we already have [[WebVideo/TwoBestFriendsPlay Mat, Pat and Woolie's]] [[https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL72A90C88878A43B7 excellent (and much funnier) video series]] covering the exact same points about ''Other M'''s BadWriting and UnfortunateImplications, without once referring to Sakamoto as a functional illiterate, this video has no reason to exist.

to:

** Tropers/{{theenglishman}}: I know this will be an unpopular opinion, but to me, ''[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMI1-DDklqE Character Assassination: Authorized]]'' represents the absolute nadir of the channel, and is still their only wrongpurae I can't endure in full. slowbeef's, well, beef with ''VideoGame/MetroidOtherM'' is not undeserved, and while his rants about the game in his LetsPlay of ''VideoGame/MetroidPrime3Corruption'' [[FranchiseOriginalSin were lengthy, passionate and vicious]], [[HandWave it could be chalked up to knee-jerk outrage because he had just finished Other M before starting his playthrough of Prime 3]]. But seeing slowbeef going on a ''very'' personal rant against DarthWiki/FallenCreator Yoshio Sakamoto for two hours ''a full year'' after having last played ''Other M'' was not so endearing, showcasing the worst traits of WebVideo/{{Retsupurae}}'s early work [[DudeNotFunny back when they would attack LPers directly]].directly. The few jokes that manage to work (mostly courtesy of Diabetus) have no impact because slowbeef just '''will not shut up''' about his hate-boner for Sakamoto, no matter how much the man deserves it. When we already have [[WebVideo/TwoBestFriendsPlay Mat, Pat and Woolie's]] [[https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL72A90C88878A43B7 excellent (and much funnier) video series]] covering the exact same points about ''Other M'''s BadWriting and UnfortunateImplications, without once referring to Sakamoto as a functional illiterate, this video has no reason to exist.



* {{@/Robbie}}: ''Podcast/AnimeWorldOrder'', Episode 85. During Daryl's review of ''Manga/ViolenceJack'', Daryl mentions the explicit, grotesque rape sequences in the Evil Town OVA, and promptly suggests that these scenes are tailored to the Japanese libido. "Japanese men can't get it up unless you've got like a loaded pistol in the girl's mouth being like 'shut the fuck up and enjoy this bitch' as they plead for their life, and blood gushes forth from their crotch because it's more {{Moe}} when you get to bust the hymen..." He goes on to suggest that things like this is why Japanese women are supposedly more interested in foreigners than native Japanese. Even as a sarcastic joke, it is still horribly racist to paint the Japanese as a nation of rapists and freaks because of anime like ''ViolenceJack'', and it stains the reputation of the most prominent podcast on the subject of Japanese animation. Reviewing anime in a humorous fashion certainly works, but mocking Japanese culture because you don't like certain nasty anime slams the DudeNotFunny button so hard it cracks in half.

to:

* {{@/Robbie}}: ''Podcast/AnimeWorldOrder'', Episode 85. During Daryl's review of ''Manga/ViolenceJack'', Daryl mentions the explicit, grotesque rape sequences in the Evil Town OVA, and promptly suggests that these scenes are tailored to the Japanese libido. "Japanese men can't get it up unless you've got like a loaded pistol in the girl's mouth being like 'shut the fuck up and enjoy this bitch' as they plead for their life, and blood gushes forth from their crotch because it's more {{Moe}} when you get to bust the hymen..." He goes on to suggest that things like this is why Japanese women are supposedly more interested in foreigners than native Japanese. Even as a sarcastic joke, it is still horribly racist to paint the Japanese as a nation of rapists and freaks because of anime like ''ViolenceJack'', and it stains the reputation of the most prominent podcast on the subject of Japanese animation. Reviewing anime in a humorous fashion certainly works, but mocking Japanese culture because you don't like certain nasty anime slams the DudeNotFunny not funny button so hard it cracks in half.



* Tropers/{{Midna}}: WebVideo/TheAnnotatedSeries was, and admittedly still is, one of my favorite [=YouTube=] past times (I'm an annotator myself), but some things are kind of hard to forgive; at some point during their simultaneous riffs of ''WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground'' and ''WesternAnimation/TheSuperMarioBrosSuperShow'', they brought in someone - or maybe multiple people - who can best be described as the epitome of [[HateDumb the Revenge Troll]], constantly wishing death, suicide, and all manner of nasty things on the writers. A bit uncomfortable to read (treating them like absolute scum that "doesn't deserve sentience" because they [[DisproportionateRetribution wrote a shitty episode of a kiddie cartoon show]]?), but nothing that overtly offended my sensibilities. Until one of them said that the writers should be "doing the Jailhouse Rock" during an episode of ''TSMBSS''. Granted, it fit with the whole Elvis theme of that episode's live action segment, but either A. they picked an Elvis song title that worked with their desires to see the writers in prison without considering the implications, or B. they just made a [[DudeNotFunny tasteless]] PrisonRape joke, and either way it left a bad taste in my mouth. I still go to, annotate on, and enjoy their channel, but I don't really watch or annotate either of the above series anymore.

to:

* Tropers/{{Midna}}: WebVideo/TheAnnotatedSeries was, and admittedly still is, one of my favorite [=YouTube=] past times (I'm an annotator myself), but some things are kind of hard to forgive; at some point during their simultaneous riffs of ''WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground'' and ''WesternAnimation/TheSuperMarioBrosSuperShow'', they brought in someone - or maybe multiple people - who can best be described as the epitome of [[HateDumb the Revenge Troll]], constantly wishing death, suicide, and all manner of nasty things on the writers. A bit uncomfortable to read (treating them like absolute scum that "doesn't deserve sentience" because they [[DisproportionateRetribution wrote a shitty episode of a kiddie cartoon show]]?), but nothing that overtly offended my sensibilities. Until one of them said that the writers should be "doing the Jailhouse Rock" during an episode of ''TSMBSS''. Granted, it fit with the whole Elvis theme of that episode's live action segment, but either A. they picked an Elvis song title that worked with their desires to see the writers in prison without considering the implications, or B. they just made a [[DudeNotFunny tasteless]] tasteless PrisonRape joke, and either way it left a bad taste in my mouth. I still go to, annotate on, and enjoy their channel, but I don't really watch or annotate either of the above series anymore.



* ldelavina3: It's no secret that every web animation series has its rough times, small or big. ''WebAnimation/{{Sonic Shorts}}'' is no exception, which brings us to their [=DMoS=] to me. The "How To Create Your Own Sonic Fan Character" bit from Volume 6. It pretty much implies that everyone who has made a fan character as lazy, unoriginal people. I know that there are a lot of poorly-made fan characters, but this just feels like a [[TakeThat giant middle finger]] to fan character creators and [[DudeNotFunny an unfunny one at that]].
** DokemonStudios: Now, I enjoy ''WebAnimation/{{Sonic Shorts}}'', and there's always at least one or two shorts that would make me laugh a lot even in the weaker episodes. But the last short in Volume 3 just left a bad taste in my mouth, specifically the ending where after Froggy leaves Big the Cat, [[SuicideasComedy Big hangs himself with his own fishing rod!]] Disregarding the fact that the string or that tree branch would break, due to Big's weight, [[NightmareFuel it's actually more horrifying than the Tails doll shorts!]] Seriously, [[TheScrappy I know people don't like Big,]] and neither do I, but that ending was just unnecessary, and [[DudeNotFunny mean spirited,]] and can just be easily cut out.

to:

* ldelavina3: It's no secret that every web animation series has its rough times, small or big. ''WebAnimation/{{Sonic Shorts}}'' is no exception, which brings us to their [=DMoS=] to me. The "How To Create Your Own Sonic Fan Character" bit from Volume 6. It pretty much implies that everyone who has made a fan character as lazy, unoriginal people. I know that there are a lot of poorly-made fan characters, but this just feels like a [[TakeThat giant middle finger]] to fan character creators and [[DudeNotFunny an unfunny one at that]].
that.
** DokemonStudios: Now, I enjoy ''WebAnimation/{{Sonic Shorts}}'', and there's always at least one or two shorts that would make me laugh a lot even in the weaker episodes. But the last short in Volume 3 just left a bad taste in my mouth, specifically the ending where after Froggy leaves Big the Cat, [[SuicideasComedy Big hangs himself with his own fishing rod!]] Disregarding the fact that the string or that tree branch would break, due to Big's weight, [[NightmareFuel it's actually more horrifying than the Tails doll shorts!]] Seriously, [[TheScrappy I know people don't like Big,]] and neither do I, but that ending was just unnecessary, and [[DudeNotFunny mean spirited,]] spirited, and can just be easily cut out.



* InsertCleverNameHere: As much as I enjoy ''WebVideo/{{Caddicarus}}'' the ending to his Bratz review was just terrible. Basically, he goes to his girlfriend's house in rage and shoots one of her children!! There was no buildup, it came off as [[DudeNotFunny ridiculously unfunny and gruesome]], and it made Caddy look like a complete psychopathic monster. And if that wasn't enough, he forcefully makes the other two daughters bury the game up and they act as if nothing happened! There's CrossingTheLineTwice, and then there's just crossing the line once.

to:

* InsertCleverNameHere: As much as I enjoy ''WebVideo/{{Caddicarus}}'' the ending to his Bratz review was just terrible. Basically, he goes to his girlfriend's house in rage and shoots one of her children!! There was no buildup, it came off as [[DudeNotFunny ridiculously unfunny and gruesome]], gruesome, and it made Caddy look like a complete psychopathic monster. And if that wasn't enough, he forcefully makes the other two daughters bury the game up and they act as if nothing happened! There's CrossingTheLineTwice, and then there's just crossing the line once.



** Tropers/{{Peridonyx}}: And ''Who's Faster: Superman or The Flash?'' suffers from similar mean-spiritedness, except with Superman suddenly becoming a complete JerkSue who abruptly cheats to win, brutally ruins The Flash's life, and then pulls a complete KarmaHoudini via media-manipulation. Why? As out-of-nowhere DisproportionateRetribution against The Flash for his StrawmanHasAPoint rebuttal that his "faster than the speed of light" sounds a lot more impressive than Superman's "faster than a speeding bullet." Textbook DudeNotFunny.

to:

** Tropers/{{Peridonyx}}: And ''Who's Faster: Superman or The Flash?'' suffers from similar mean-spiritedness, except with Superman suddenly becoming a complete JerkSue who abruptly cheats to win, brutally ruins The Flash's life, and then pulls a complete KarmaHoudini via media-manipulation. Why? As out-of-nowhere DisproportionateRetribution against The Flash for his StrawmanHasAPoint rebuttal that his "faster than the speed of light" sounds a lot more impressive than Superman's "faster than a speeding bullet." Textbook DudeNotFunny.



** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy, [[CruelAndUnusualDeath graphic]], [[NightmareFuel brutal and cruel]] as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He [[NauseaFuel cuts a slice off Toothy's face]] ''[[TheWoobie while he was terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me actually cry in genuine sympathy]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits by a fan, [[BodyHorror carves Nutty like an apple]], shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q]]'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]]. And of course Mondo ''had'' to put him in more episodes.

to:

** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy, [[CruelAndUnusualDeath graphic]], [[NightmareFuel brutal and cruel]] as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He [[NauseaFuel cuts a slice off Toothy's face]] ''[[TheWoobie while he was terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me actually cry in genuine sympathy]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits by a fan, [[BodyHorror carves Nutty like an apple]], shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] unfunny Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q]]'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]]. And of course Mondo ''had'' to put him in more episodes.



* [=TomPhanto=]: As much as I enjoy the plush videos of WebVideo/SuperMarioLogan, I did not like "Jeffy's Bad Word!" at all. It's about Jeffy, a mentally handicapped kid who was dumped on Mario's doorstep in "Mario The Babysitter!" and has now become one of the most recurring characters, second only to Bowser Jr. I personally dislike Jeffy episodes because most of them are just making [[OnlySaneMan Mario]] a CosmicPlaything. The episode starts off with Mario driving to Walmart and he yells at a homeless guy that gets in his way, accidentally calling him a "faggot". Jeffy then starts saying it because he likes the word. And as expected, the episode is about Mario getting into trouble because Jeffy won't stop saying "faggot". What makes this a [=DMoS=] for me is what happens at the end. Mario gives Jeffy a spanking because he wouldn't stop saying "faggot". Mario is arrested, [[WronglyAccused accused of child molestation]], and is registered as a felon and sex offender, all just for trying to discipline Jeffy. I know Mario's supposed to be a ButtMonkey in this show, but I felt the episode went [[DudeNotFunny way too far]] with the abuse.

to:

* [=TomPhanto=]: As much as I enjoy the plush videos of WebVideo/SuperMarioLogan, I did not like "Jeffy's Bad Word!" at all. It's about Jeffy, a mentally handicapped kid who was dumped on Mario's doorstep in "Mario The Babysitter!" and has now become one of the most recurring characters, second only to Bowser Jr. I personally dislike Jeffy episodes because most of them are just making [[OnlySaneMan Mario]] a CosmicPlaything. The episode starts off with Mario driving to Walmart and he yells at a homeless guy that gets in his way, accidentally calling him a "faggot". Jeffy then starts saying it because he likes the word. And as expected, the episode is about Mario getting into trouble because Jeffy won't stop saying "faggot". What makes this a [=DMoS=] for me is what happens at the end. Mario gives Jeffy a spanking because he wouldn't stop saying "faggot". Mario is arrested, [[WronglyAccused accused of child molestation]], and is registered as a felon and sex offender, all just for trying to discipline Jeffy. I know Mario's supposed to be a ButtMonkey in this show, but I felt the episode went [[DudeNotFunny way too far]] far with the abuse.
24th Dec '16 2:28:10 PM FromtheWordsofBR
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: I liked his ''Search for the Worst'' review of the ''WebVideo/{{Fred}}'' Movie Trilogy and even thought the bit with his friend Ralphthemoviemaker was decent. However, around 30 minutes in, after snarking about a video where Lucas says he doesn't remember filming the "Fred vs. TheAnnoyingOrange" video, he then says that's the result of blackouts and trying to repress memories. Then the video pauses for Ralph to make a [[OverlyLongGag really long]] [[{{Squick}} and unnecessarily uncomfortable]] child molestation joke. It goes on for what feels like forever (it lasts a minute!!), it contradicts some of Alex's points regarding comedy (in that jokes need a punchline to be funny....this one doesn't, it's also very similar to a scene in the movie Alex also criticized for also being drawn-out), and worst of all, [[DudeNotFunny it's not funny, not even in the black sort of sense]]. I know Ralph's bit was produced by himself but there was no need for that joke and it soured the video a bit for me (still a damn good video either way, but good lord) due to how unnecessary and hypocritical it was.
23rd Dec '16 6:33:53 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy, [[CruelAndUnusualDeath graphic]], [[NightmareFuel brutal and cruel]] as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He [[NauseaFuel cuts a slice off Toothy's face]] ''[[TheWoobie while he was terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, [[BodyHorror carves Nutty like an apple]], shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q]]'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]]. By that point you'd think Mondo would have learned their lesson, but they didn't.

to:

** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy, [[CruelAndUnusualDeath graphic]], [[NightmareFuel brutal and cruel]] as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He [[NauseaFuel cuts a slice off Toothy's face]] ''[[TheWoobie while he was terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), actually cry in genuine sympathy]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, bits by a fan, [[BodyHorror carves Nutty like an apple]], shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q]]'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]]. By that point you'd think And of course Mondo would have learned their lesson, but they didn't.''had'' to put him in more episodes.
19th Dec '16 5:57:10 AM HulkingCetacean
Is there an issue? Send a Message



to:

*HulkingCetacean: JoshScorcher for "Response to Lily Peet" for completely different reasons than that videos comment section would say i would call it a DMOS ... i used to think he used to be a good person who didnt like the dark side of the internet...then he went to 8chan and Kiwi farms to dig up their posts on Lily Peet they have kept in a stalker-like fashion and THEN in the video tells his fans not to send her death threats and has never called them out like he has done before when they inevitably did (and they linked proof that they did in the comment section of the video) but the fact that he calls himself a Christian and openly went to hate filled sites that stand for everything that Christianity is against disgusts me
9th Dec '16 11:16:10 PM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message





[[folder:Animation Domination High-Def]]
* fluffything: For those unfamiliar, there is a WebAnimation series called ''Scientifically Accurate'' that "parodies" (in the loosest sense of the word possible) classic cartoons, video games, and so forth using "science" (again, loosest sense of the word possible). It only took me one viewing of their ''Scientifically Accurate SonicTheHedgehog'' video to realize just how terrible their attempts at humor are (And, considering they're associated with Fox's "Animation Domination", that should come as no surprise). The DMOS is basically how utterly lazy and juvenile it is. Rather than come up with something clever and witty, the short instead tells such [[SarcasmMode great jokes such as]] "Hedgehogs eat poop!" and the classic "Echidnas have a four-headed penis!". Heck, they don't even try with the ToiletHumor. It's basically just the same "it's gross so it's instantly funny" mentality you'd expect from a twelve year-old boy than what I can only assume is a professional writer and/or animator.
* [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: I used to really enjoy ''Scientifically Accurate'', but I knew from the get-go that ''Scientifically Accurate [[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic My Little Pony]]'' was going to be a huge mess. Shockingly enough, though, the brony-bashing is kept to a minimum of one mention of how [[spoiler:[[{{Squick}} Beijing serves horse privates as food]]]] (then again, I didn't mind the brony-bashing line in "Today Was a Good Day on the Internet" because everything else in that one was well-executed and [[EarWorm catchy]]). Unfortunately, the rest of the video is just dull. The accurate stuff isn't as hilariously sick and twisted as the other videos are, being just normal stuff real-life horses do. Sure, other videos do normal descriptions of animals, but it's nowhere near as soul-suckingly humorless as it is in this installment. It's not bad enough to make me quit watching their videos, as ''Animation Domination High-Def'' is responsible for a lot of decent parodies, but it's just a gigantic misstep, and it's kind of ruined the other ''[=SA=]'' videos for me.
* Bengson26: I am going to say this right now: I fucking hate this show. But the one that makes me want to strangle the writer is ''Scientifically Accurate NinjaTurtles''. Right from the get-go, I knew this would be a colossal mess. And I was right. The "turtle dicks" part is pretty much the low point of this "parody". Hell, they don't even bring anything new to the table with the humor except for the "dicks are funny" mentality. This was just a soulless, humorless video from a soulless, humorless series. And people thought the [[Film.TeenageMutantNinjaTurtles2014 2014 film]] ruined childhoods.
* Tropers/CJCroen1393: Scientifically Accurate ''Series/{{Barney}}'', if for no other reason than the fact that the title [[ArtisticLicensePaleontology is a complete and utter lie]]. They evidently got all their ''TyrannosaurusRex'' facts from ''Film/JurassicPark'' (complete with a John Hammond expy), as they depict the titular dinosaur as a giant scaly monstrosity that's constantly stomping around and roaring, messily chewing up small children for shock value ([[SarcasmMode yes, because a 9-ton T. rex is going to love eating scrawny little human children]]) and--to top it all off--they decide to give it a giant penis. Barring the fact that such a huge reproductive organ would kill a female ''T. rex'' if the male tried to mate with her, there is serious doubt cast on the idea that dinosaurs even had external genitalia at all (most modern dinosaurs--besides ducks and certain ratites--certainly don't). This video was about as scientifically accurate as ''WesternAnimation/TheFlintstones''.
* Tropers/TommyTiger: Songs You Didn't Know Have Lyrics: ''VideoGame/SuperMarioWorld'' is horrible. The reason? It paints [[NiceGuy Mario]] into a massive {{Jerkass}}. Not only does it have the [[SarcasmMode original]] "Punching Yoshi on the head" and "Hop off Yoshi" jokes, but it shows the icing on the cake, Mario FlippingTheBird at Yoshi (which is a complete and utter lie, Mario would never do that). The ironic thing? I used to like it, but [[OldShame only because I was being pressured by elementary school and other things]].
[[/folder]]



[[folder:Scientifically Accurate]]
* fluffything: For those unfamiliar, there is a WebAnimation series called ''Scientifically Accurate'' that "parodies" (in the loosest sense of the word possible) classic cartoons, video games, and so forth using "science" (again, loosest sense of the word possible). It only took me one viewing of their ''Scientifically Accurate SonicTheHedgehog'' video to realize just how terrible their attempts at humor are (And, considering they're associated with Fox's "Animation Domination", that should come as no surprise). The DMOS is basically how utterly lazy and juvenile it is. Rather than come up with something clever and witty, the short instead tells such [[SarcasmMode great jokes such as]] "Hedgehogs eat poop!" and the classic "Echidnas have a four-headed penis!". Heck, they don't even try with the ToiletHumor. It's basically just the same "it's gross so it's instantly funny" mentality you'd expect from a twelve year-old boy than what I can only assume is a professional writer and/or animator.
* [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: I used to really enjoy ''Scientifically Accurate'', but I knew from the get-go that ''Scientifically Accurate [[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic My Little Pony]]'' was going to be a huge mess. Shockingly enough, though, the brony-bashing is kept to a minimum of one mention of how [[spoiler:[[{{Squick}} Beijing serves horse privates as food]]]] (then again, I didn't mind the brony-bashing line in "Today Was a Good Day on the Internet" because everything else in that one was well-executed and [[EarWorm catchy]]). Unfortunately, the rest of the video is just dull. The accurate stuff isn't as hilariously sick and twisted as the other videos are, being just normal stuff real-life horses do. Sure, other videos do normal descriptions of animals, but it's nowhere near as soul-suckingly humorless as it is in this installment. It's not bad enough to make me quit watching their videos, as ''Animation Domination High-Def'' is responsible for a lot of decent parodies, but it's just a gigantic misstep, and it's kind of ruined the other ''[=SA=]'' videos for me.
* Bengson26: I am going to say this right now: I fucking hate this show. But the one that makes me want to strangle the writer is ''Scientifically Accurate NinjaTurtles''. Right from the get-go, I knew this would be a colossal mess. And I was right. The "turtle dicks" part is pretty much the low point of this "parody". Hell, they don't even bring anything new to the table with the humor except for the "dicks are funny" mentality. This was just a soulless, humorless video from a soulless, humorless series. And people thought the [[Film.TeenageMutantNinjaTurtles2014 2014 film]] ruined childhoods.
* Tropers/CJCroen1393: Scientifically Accurate ''Series/{{Barney}}'', if for no other reason than the fact that the title [[ArtisticLicensePaleontology is a complete and utter lie]]. They evidently got all their ''TyrannosaurusRex'' facts from ''Film/JurassicPark'' (complete with a John Hammond expy), as they depict the titular dinosaur as a giant scaly monstrosity that's constantly stomping around and roaring, messily chewing up small children for shock value ([[SarcasmMode yes, because a 9-ton T. rex is going to love eating scrawny little human children]]) and--to top it all off--they decide to give it a giant penis. Barring the fact that such a huge reproductive organ would kill a female ''T. rex'' if the male tried to mate with her, there is serious doubt cast on the idea that dinosaurs even had external genitalia at all (most modern dinosaurs--besides ducks and certain ratites--certainly don't). This video was about as scientifically accurate as ''WesternAnimation/TheFlintstones''.
[[/folder]]
7th Dec '16 4:38:52 PM lolface123
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

7th Dec '16 7:38:25 AM crazysamaritan
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* jmac9345: Before I get any flack for this, let me get out that I love WebVideo/{{JonTron}}. He’s one of the greatest and funniest YouTube critics of all time. And although I don’t think he’s had a bad episode per say, he isn’t free from bad moments. For example, I loved both of his Food Games videos as a great, long awaited return to form after StarCade (which was [[CrowningMomentOfAwesome awesome]] and [[FunnyMoments hilarious]] in it’s own right) especially with gems like the [[NotMakingThisUpDisclaimer live horse in his apartment]] and [[spoiler:[[BigLippedAlligatorMoment Grimbo]]]], but there was one aspect of Part 1 that annoyed me. With the Yoshinoya, Global Gladiators, McDonald’s Treasure Land Adventure, and Donald Magical World (especially the former and latter) segments, he barely touched on the games, gameplay wise. Granted, Jon does tend to focus more on comedy rather than actual reviewing, but I feel that he could’ve went a bit more in depth with the games instead of just briefly skimming over them, making a joke, and moving on. It didn’t taint the video for me, I just wish there was a bit more depth to it.

to:

* jmac9345: Before I get any flack for this, let me get out that I love WebVideo/{{JonTron}}. He’s one of the greatest and funniest YouTube critics of all time. And although I don’t think he’s had a bad episode per say, he isn’t free from bad moments. For example, I loved both of his Food Games videos as a great, long awaited return to form after StarCade (which was [[CrowningMomentOfAwesome awesome]] and [[FunnyMoments hilarious]] in it’s own right) especially with gems like the [[NotMakingThisUpDisclaimer live horse in his apartment]] and [[spoiler:[[BigLippedAlligatorMoment Grimbo]]]], but there was one aspect of Part 1 that annoyed me. With the Yoshinoya, Global Gladiators, McDonald’s [=McDonald’s Treasure Land Adventure, Adventure=], and Donald Magical World (especially the former and latter) segments, he barely touched on the games, gameplay wise. Granted, Jon does tend to focus more on comedy rather than actual reviewing, but I feel that he could’ve went a bit more in depth with the games instead of just briefly skimming over them, making a joke, and moving on. It didn’t taint the video for me, I just wish there was a bit more depth to it.
6th Dec '16 9:05:36 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/TommyTiger: I've never watched these, but the "X tells Y (a villain) Something" videos are just awful, because of the disproportionate political rank in the videos. We've had such monstrosities as "[[Disney/TheAristocats Roquefort]] tells [[Disney/AliceInWonderland the Queen of Hearts]] to be quiet", "[[Disney/AGoofyMovie Max]] tells [[Disney/{{Pocahontas}} Governor Ratcliffe]] to get his own life" and [[WesternAnimation/TheFairlyOddParents Vicky]] telling [[Disney/RobinHood Prince John]] BED TWERP" (the last one's particularly dumb, as the one who addresses Prince John is as bad as him, if not worse). However, none of these were the motive for this entry. '''''(CONTINUING LATER)'''''

to:

* Tropers/TommyTiger: I've never watched these, but the "X tells Y (a villain) Something" videos are just awful, because of the disproportionate political rank in the videos. We've had such monstrosities as "[[Disney/TheAristocats Roquefort]] tells [[Disney/AliceInWonderland the Queen of Hearts]] to be quiet", "[[Disney/AGoofyMovie Max]] tells [[Disney/{{Pocahontas}} Governor Ratcliffe]] to get his own life" and [[WesternAnimation/TheFairlyOddParents Vicky]] telling [[Disney/RobinHood Prince John]] BED TWERP" (the last one's particularly dumb, as the one who addresses Prince John is as bad as him, if not worse). However, none of these were the motive for this entry. '''''(CONTINUING LATER)'''''Nope, it was the video "Tommy and Tallulah (I don't know where are they from, but they are freaking ''kids'') tell Prince John to stop and tell him off". I fail to see any logic behind those characters giving the villains a TheReasonYouSuckSpeech. It's a failed attempt at making a MomentOfAwesome that beginned with someone making this kind of video and others hopping on the bandwagon.
6th Dec '16 7:38:31 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Tropers/TommyTiger: I've never watched these, but the "X tells Y (a villain) Something" videos are just awful, because of the disproportionate political rank in the videos. We've had such monstrosities as "[[Disney/TheAristocats Roquefort]] tells [[Disney/AliceInWonderland the Queen of Hearts]] to be quiet", "[[Disney/AGoofyMovie Max]] tells [[Disney/{{Pocahontas}} Governor Ratcliffe]] to get his own life" and [[WesternAnimation/TheFairlyOddParents Vicky]] telling [[Disney/RobinHood Prince John]] BED TWERP" (the last one's particularly dumb, as the one who addresses Prince John is as bad as him, if not worse). However, none of these were the motive for this entry. '''''(CONTINUING LATER)'''''
5th Dec '16 10:58:16 PM ParaChomp
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/ParaChomp: "Search for the Worst: Suicide Squad". I will not argue against negative criticism against Movie/SuicideSquad, it's justified. What I will argue against are the constant questioning of the existence of various characters. One can see them as IHE pointing out them being unnecessary for the film but when he compared Characters/KillerCroc to Character/GorillaGrodd, you could tell that either wasn't the case or he's being too vague with the intentions of his words. There is nothing wrong with either of them as characters in terms of premise, same can be said about Characters/CaptainBoomerang and Characters/Katana. All four of these characters have proven their worth in other pieces of media. There are so many characters who use trick weapons for combat and Katana was as relevant as ever due to Television/BewareTheBatman. One of the film's problems are its many unnecessary characters but these characters have been well written in other media and have relevance to the source material which is something IHE doesn't acknowledge. I do realize that I am an IDIOT trying to win such an argument. This is someone who doesn't care about the history of comics nor their characters, only wants a good movie, and uses Comicbook/Aquaman and Characters/KiteMan as their Trope/ButtMonkey. Once again, the wound that the UsefulNotes/TheComicsCode has left shows its ugly face proving that even the Trope/DarkerAndEdgier adaptions can't hide it.

to:

* Tropers/ParaChomp: "Search for the Worst: Suicide Squad". I will not argue against negative criticism against Movie/SuicideSquad, it's justified. What I will argue against are the constant questioning of the existence of various characters. One can see them as IHE pointing out them being unnecessary for the film but when he compared Characters/KillerCroc to Character/GorillaGrodd, you could tell that either wasn't the case or he's being too vague with the intentions of his words. There is nothing wrong with either of them as characters in terms of premise, same can be said about Characters/CaptainBoomerang and Characters/Katana. All four of these characters have proven their worth in other pieces of media. There are so many characters who use trick weapons for combat and Katana was as relevant as ever due to Television/BewareTheBatman. One of the film's problems are its many unnecessary characters but these characters have been well written in other media and have relevance to the source material which is something IHE doesn't acknowledge. I do realize that I am an IDIOT trying to win such an argument. This is someone who doesn't care about the history of comics nor their characters, only wants a good movie, and uses Comicbook/Aquaman Aquaman and Characters/KiteMan as their Trope/ButtMonkey. Once again, the wound that the UsefulNotes/TheComicsCode has left shows its ugly face proving that even the Trope/DarkerAndEdgier adaptions can't hide it.
5th Dec '16 10:56:05 PM ParaChomp
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/ParaChomp: "Search for the Worst: Suicide Squad". I will not argue against negative criticism against Movie/SuicideSquad, it's justified. What I will argue against are the constant questioning of the existence of various characters. One can see them as IHE pointing out them being unnecessary for the film but when he compared Characters/KillerCroc to Character/GorillaGrodd, you could tell that either wasn't the case or he's being too vague with the intentions of his words. There is nothing wrong with either of them as characters in terms of premise, same can be said about Characters/CaptainBoomerang and Characters/Katana. All four of these characters have proven their worth in other pieces of media. There are so many characters who use trick weapons for combat and Katana was as relevant as ever due to Television/BewareTheBatman. One of the film's problems are its many unnecessary characters but these characters have been well written in other media and have relevance to the source material which is something IHE doesn't acknowledge. I'm an idiot trying to win with such an argument, this is someone who doesn't care about the history of comics or their characters, only wants a good movie, and uses Characters/Aquaman and Characters/KiteMan as their Trope/ButtMonkey. Once again, the wound that the UsefulNotes/TheComicsCode has left shows its ugly face proving that even the Trope/DarkerAndEdgier adaptions can't hide it.

to:

* Tropers/ParaChomp: "Search for the Worst: Suicide Squad". I will not argue against negative criticism against Movie/SuicideSquad, it's justified. What I will argue against are the constant questioning of the existence of various characters. One can see them as IHE pointing out them being unnecessary for the film but when he compared Characters/KillerCroc to Character/GorillaGrodd, you could tell that either wasn't the case or he's being too vague with the intentions of his words. There is nothing wrong with either of them as characters in terms of premise, same can be said about Characters/CaptainBoomerang and Characters/Katana. All four of these characters have proven their worth in other pieces of media. There are so many characters who use trick weapons for combat and Katana was as relevant as ever due to Television/BewareTheBatman. One of the film's problems are its many unnecessary characters but these characters have been well written in other media and have relevance to the source material which is something IHE doesn't acknowledge. I'm I do realize that I am an idiot IDIOT trying to win with such an argument, this argument. This is someone who doesn't care about the history of comics or nor their characters, only wants a good movie, and uses Characters/Aquaman Comicbook/Aquaman and Characters/KiteMan as their Trope/ButtMonkey. Once again, the wound that the UsefulNotes/TheComicsCode has left shows its ugly face proving that even the Trope/DarkerAndEdgier adaptions can't hide it.
5th Dec '16 10:50:12 PM ParaChomp
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/ParaChomp: "Search for the Worst: Suicide Squad". I will not argue against negative criticism against Movie/SuicideSquad, it's justified. What I will argue against are the constant questioning of the existence of various characters. One can see them as IHE pointing out them being unnecessary for the film but when he compared Character/KillerCroc to Character/GorrilaGrodd, you could tell that either wasn't the case or he's being too vague with the intentions of his words. There is nothing wrong with either of them as characters in terms of premise, same can be said about Character/CaptainBoomerang and Character/Katana. All four of these characters have proven their worth in other pieces of media. There are so many characters who use trick weapons for combat and Katana was as relevant as ever due to Television/BewaretheBatman. One of the film's problems are its many unnecessary characters but these characters have been well written in other media and have relevance to the source material which is something IHE doesn't acknowledge. I'm an idiot trying to win with such an argument, this is someone who doesn't care about the history of comics or their characters, only wants a good movie, and uses Character/Aquaman and Character/KiteMan as their Trope/ButtMonkey. Once again, the wound that the UsefulNotes/TheComicsCode has left shows its ugly face proving that even the Trope/DarkerAndEdgier adaptions can't hide it.

to:

* Tropers/ParaChomp: "Search for the Worst: Suicide Squad". I will not argue against negative criticism against Movie/SuicideSquad, it's justified. What I will argue against are the constant questioning of the existence of various characters. One can see them as IHE pointing out them being unnecessary for the film but when he compared Character/KillerCroc Characters/KillerCroc to Character/GorrilaGrodd, Character/GorillaGrodd, you could tell that either wasn't the case or he's being too vague with the intentions of his words. There is nothing wrong with either of them as characters in terms of premise, same can be said about Character/CaptainBoomerang Characters/CaptainBoomerang and Character/Katana.Characters/Katana. All four of these characters have proven their worth in other pieces of media. There are so many characters who use trick weapons for combat and Katana was as relevant as ever due to Television/BewaretheBatman.Television/BewareTheBatman. One of the film's problems are its many unnecessary characters but these characters have been well written in other media and have relevance to the source material which is something IHE doesn't acknowledge. I'm an idiot trying to win with such an argument, this is someone who doesn't care about the history of comics or their characters, only wants a good movie, and uses Character/Aquaman Characters/Aquaman and Character/KiteMan Characters/KiteMan as their Trope/ButtMonkey. Once again, the wound that the UsefulNotes/TheComicsCode has left shows its ugly face proving that even the Trope/DarkerAndEdgier adaptions can't hide it.
5th Dec '16 10:44:05 PM ParaChomp
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Tropers/ParaChomp: "Search for the Worst: Suicide Squad". I will not argue against negative criticism against Movie/SuicideSquad, it's justified. What I will argue against are the constant questioning of the existence of various characters. One can see them as IHE pointing out them being unnecessary for the film but when he compared Character/KillerCroc to Character/GorrilaGrodd, you could tell that either wasn't the case or he's being too vague with the intentions of his words. There is nothing wrong with either of them as characters in terms of premise, same can be said about Character/CaptainBoomerang and Character/Katana. All four of these characters have proven their worth in other pieces of media. There are so many characters who use trick weapons for combat and Katana was as relevant as ever due to Television/BewaretheBatman. One of the film's problems are its many unnecessary characters but these characters have been well written in other media and have relevance to the source material which is something IHE doesn't acknowledge. I'm an idiot trying to win with such an argument, this is someone who doesn't care about the history of comics or their characters, only wants a good movie, and uses Character/Aquaman and Character/KiteMan as their Trope/ButtMonkey. Once again, the wound that the UsefulNotes/TheComicsCode has left shows its ugly face proving that even the Trope/DarkerAndEdgier adaptions can't hide it.
30th Nov '16 7:58:41 AM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Sugarp1e1: I didn't appreciate the seventh entry of ScrewAttack's [[https://youtu.be/fZuki3QTb2s Top 10 Worst Cartoons Based on Video Games list]]; [[spoiler:BlazBlue: Alter Memory.]] It's not the fact that Nervous Nick doesn't like [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] that's the problem (I've never even played the game or watched the anime). As with my PhantomStrider entry above, my problem with this list is his reason for putting it on the list as well as his elitist attitude about the whole thing. He starts the entry off by making it clear that he doesn't like the game's world or story, having a very PlayTheGameSkipTheStory attitude about it. Okay, fine. But judging by the clips of the anime he used, [[spoiler:Alter Memory]] is actually a pretty faithful adaptation. So why is it bad according to Nick? [[BiasSteamroller Because it's a faithful adaptation of a game he never liked to begin with.]] His bias behind this is clear, what with him spending the entire entry summarizing the story in way that makes it sound even more confusing than it really is (instead of just explaining why he finds it confusing) and ending the entry with him absolutely losing his [[PrecisionFStrike shit]] over how much he hates [[spoiler:BlazBlue]]'s story (especially the whole [[spoiler:StableTimeLoop]] plot point), claiming "I see [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] for what it really is! It's a mess! I hate it! That why it's #7." Um, Nick? [[OpinionMyopia Are you implying that the people who do like the story are idiotic sheep?]] To me, it sounds like he's genuinely proclaiming himself to be [[FanHater better than the fans]] because he can't get past the story. Don't get me wrong; I totally agree that the [[spoiler:StableTimeLoop]] is confusing, especially at the end when [[spoiler:the cycle is finally broken]], but I wouldn't yell at my audience that "The story sucks!" in a way that suggests my subjective opinion is objective fact. And considering how he goes from screaming his lungs out to calmly moving on to #6, it was PlayedForLaughs. You probably also noticed that this DMOS sounds more like I'm talking about the game and not the anime. Nick's tirade was the same way. On top of all that, [[MurderArsonAndJaywalking #7 was the only entry on the list that wasn't an adaptation of a game he liked.]] If he never liked [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] to begin with, then he's in no position to tell us that [[spoiler:Alter Memory]] is a bad adaptation just because it's faithful to the source material.

to:

* Sugarp1e1: I didn't appreciate the seventh entry of ScrewAttack's [[https://youtu.be/fZuki3QTb2s Top 10 Worst Cartoons Based on Video Games list]]; [[spoiler:BlazBlue: Alter Memory.]] It's not the fact that Nervous Nick doesn't like [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] that's the problem (I've never even played the game or watched the anime). As with my PhantomStrider entry above, my problem with this list is his reason for putting it on the list as well as his elitist attitude about the whole thing. He starts the entry off by making it clear that he doesn't like the game's world or story, having a very PlayTheGameSkipTheStory attitude about it. Okay, fine. But judging by the clips of the anime he used, [[spoiler:Alter Memory]] is actually a pretty faithful adaptation. So why is it bad according to Nick? [[BiasSteamroller Because it's a faithful adaptation of a game he never liked to begin with.]] His bias behind this is clear, what with him spending the entire entry summarizing the story in way that makes it sound even more confusing than it really is (instead of just explaining why he finds it confusing) and ending the entry with him absolutely losing his [[PrecisionFStrike shit]] over how much he hates [[spoiler:BlazBlue]]'s story (especially the whole [[spoiler:StableTimeLoop]] plot point), claiming "I see [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] for what it really is! It's a mess! I hate it! That That's why it's #7." Um, Nick? [[OpinionMyopia Are you implying that the people who do like the story are idiotic sheep?]] To me, it sounds like he's genuinely proclaiming himself to be [[FanHater better than the fans]] because he can't get past the story. Don't get me wrong; I totally agree that the [[spoiler:StableTimeLoop]] is confusing, especially at the end when [[spoiler:the cycle is finally broken]], but I wouldn't yell at my audience that "The story sucks!" in a way that suggests my subjective opinion is objective fact. And considering how he goes from screaming his lungs out to calmly moving on to #6, it was PlayedForLaughs. You probably also noticed that this DMOS sounds more like I'm talking about the game and not the anime. Nick's tirade was the same way. On top of all that, [[MurderArsonAndJaywalking #7 was the only entry on the list that wasn't an adaptation of a game he liked.]] If he never liked [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] to begin with, then he's in no position to tell us that [[spoiler:Alter Memory]] is a bad adaptation just because it's faithful to the source material.
29th Nov '16 12:40:21 PM Butter
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Butter: The ''"5 WORST fanbases"'' video. Due to the fact that there are so many terrible fanbases to choose from and so many things that need to be said, the video was basically guaranteed to be awesome, especially since IHE has a history of well-done rants on fans. And what does he do with this amazing concept, that was basically guarenteed to be awesome? He runs it in the ground. [softreturn] First, he makes up three rules to judge how bad these fanbases are. Isn't the whole point of IHE that all his videos are based on his opinions and are not ment to be taken as objectively true or false statements, him trying to back up his placement is going against that and renders his defence of everything just being his opinion null and void, especially since rule #1 and #3 themselves boil down to "it's muh 'pinion". The second rule isn't really legit either. It defines two criterias, how much results you find for the fanbase at r34 and how quickly you cringe when you look at fanart on deviantart. Both criteria are arbitrary; how much results you find at r34 is directly proportional to the franchises popularity (IHE even points that out in the very first entry) and thus irrelevant to the fanbases quality (For example, by that logic RealLife has the worst fanbase somehow), and 'how quickly you cringe' is an extremely trite statement that doesn't really have any meaning. [softreturn] His first entry are gamers, which is incredibly redundant because both VideoGame/SonicTheHedgehog and VideoGame/FiveNightsAtFreddys are video games and are also on the list. His reasons are also very hypocritical; he rants about how gamers will go out of their way to rant about things they know they won't like, just to belittle it, because that's the very thing his own channel is about. He also claims that they are 'entitled', which is a meaningless statement since this is one of those words that don't mean anything without context, context he never gives. [softreturn] Number four is anime, and the very first thing he says about it is that he doesn't know anything about it. Great. He doesn't even bring up a point against the anime fandom. He just cracks a contextless joke about some guy called James and how James ruined his live. That's it. He also doesn't bring up his second rule again, he doesn't even lampshade it this time, he just drops it. [softreturn] Number three is Sonic. Like the anime segment, it feels really rushed, but this time, instead of abandoning rule 2, the entire segment just consists of it. The segment goes like this: Here's the number of images Sonic has on r34, here the number on deviant art. These pictures are cringeworthy *shows pictures that are obvious jokes like a Shadow x Shrek pairing and a picture of a toilet looking like Sonic* [softreturn] Number two are bronies. This is probably the least bad entry on his list, but that doesn't mean it's not flawed. His first complaint is that bronies are 'obsessed', which is another context- and meaningless statement. Another complaint is that there are costumes for it. So all popular media in existance, including Real Life suck, because there are costumes of their characters? He also uses rule 2 again, but it goes against his placement of this fandom. MLP has less results than Sonic. If the only somewhat objective rule states that the Sonic fandom is worse than the MLP one, why is MLP higher on the list? [softreturn] Number one is [=FNaF=]. The first point of his is that people should shut up about it and there are too many videos one YouTube about it. IHE made multiple vidoes about it, talk about hypocricy. His next point is that people are playing it's creepyness down and thus going against the point of it bring a horror game. This is a phenomenon that is present in every media of the horror genre ever. It's a huge double standard to act like the flaws of an entire genre are caused by one fandom; why is it something unusual that most of [=FNaF=]-fan-media are not scary on their own, when the exact same thing is the case for things like Silent Hill, etc., you name it.
28th Nov '16 6:07:29 PM Awesomekid42
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Troper/{{Awesomekid42}}: His response to said [=iDubbbzTV=] video was quite possibly the most embarrassing reaction to criticism I've ever seen from a youtuber. Disregarding how he acts as if the original video is meant to be an "exposed video" ([[SarcasmMode because clearly if somebody expresses not liking your content it means that they're trying to expose you]]) the majority of Leafy's video is filled with moments that are just painful to sit through, such as pretending that the chin joke was meant to be a serious point against him, acting as if needlessly long transitions being a small thing somehow means the issue doesn't exists ([[CriticalResearchFailure along with thinking that AIDS and ADHD are the same thing]] but I digress) acting as if criticizing him for not being funny is a worthless criticism by essentially saying "The Weather Channel isn't funny so it's shit" despite Calvin putting a focus on comedy in his videos so being unfunny would actually hurt the quality of the video, and trying to derail Idubzzz's points by taking shots at other videos made by Idubzzz (some several years prior to the original video) that doesn't affects the original criticisms in the slightest.

to:

** Troper/{{Awesomekid42}}: His response to said [=iDubbbzTV=] video was quite possibly the most embarrassing reaction to criticism I've ever seen from a youtuber. Disregarding how he acts as if the original video is meant to be an "exposed video" ([[SarcasmMode because clearly if somebody expresses not liking your content it means that they're trying to expose you]]) the majority of Leafy's video is filled with moments that are just painful to sit through, such as pretending that the chin joke was meant to be a serious point against him, acting as if needlessly long transitions being a small thing somehow means the issue doesn't exists ([[CriticalResearchFailure along with thinking that AIDS and ADHD are the same thing]] but I digress) acting as if criticizing him for not being funny is a worthless criticism by essentially saying "The Weather Channel isn't funny so it's shit" despite Calvin putting a focus on comedy in his videos so being unfunny would actually hurt the quality of the video, and trying to derail Idubzzz's points by taking shots at other videos made by Idubzzz (some several years prior to the original video) that doesn't affects the original criticisms in the slightest. A terrible video filled with points that added nothing of substance that only exists because he couldn't handle being criticized.
28th Nov '16 6:06:00 PM Awesomekid42
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Troper/{{Awesomekid42}}: His response to said [=iDubbbzTV=] video was quite possibly the most embarrassing reaction to criticism I've ever seen from a youtuber. Disregarding how he acts as if the original video is meant to be an "exposed video" ([[SarcasmMode because clearly if somebody expresses not liking your content it means that they're trying to expose you]]) the majority of Leafy's video is filled with moments that are just painful to sit through, such as pretending that the chin joke was meant to be a serious point against him, acting as if needlessly long transitions being a small thing somehow means the issue doesn't exists ([[CriticalResearchFailure along with thinking that AIDS and ADHD are the same thing]] but I digress) acting as if criticizing him for not being funny is a worthless criticism by essentially saying "The Weather Channel isn't funny so it's shit" despite Calvin putting a focus on comedy in his videos so being unfunny would actually hurt the quality of the video, and trying to derail Idubzzz's points by taking shots at other videos made by Idubzzz (some several years prior to the original video) that doesn't affects the original criticisms in the slightest.
28th Nov '16 1:03:43 PM kensu
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Troper/{{kensu}}: {{Website/Snopes}} is a pretty good example of how incredulous web users used to be in the '90s and 2000s. Whatever Snopes had to say on any urban myth was gospel; no argument. These days, however, they've mostly been replaced by Wikipedia and various blogs which allow user interaction and fact-checking. The scales fell from this troper's eyes over two myths and the way that the moderators of Snopes handled them. The first is the famous case of The Dating Game, where a housewife gave a ribald response to the question: "what is the strangest place you've ever had sex". Snopes started out saying this was fake, but imagine our surprise when a video of it emerged. Snopes continued to claim the legend was fake, because some (but not all) accounts of the legends involved a black couple, and the couple in the video was white. Basically Snopes was claiming that the legend wasn't true, there just happened to have been another incident that perfectly matched the legend, but wasn't actually the incident that was being referred to. Snopes eventually very reluctantly changed the status of this myth to true. The second case was that of The Wooden Bomb. The original page said this myth was false, citing no references. This was followed with a long paternalistic lecture about how the legend couldn't be true, which makes it pretty clear that they never bothered to research it. It then came out that the legend was true, and it took a very long time for Snopes to acknowledge that. In the interim Snopes went to rather insane lengths to ensure that their site can't be archived, so it's impossible for anyone to see the history of their positions on various myths. Bad form, indeed!

to:

* Troper/{{kensu}}: {{Website/Snopes}} is a pretty good example of how incredulous credulous web users used to be in the '90s and 2000s. Whatever Snopes had to say on any urban myth was gospel; no argument. These days, however, they've mostly been replaced by Wikipedia and various blogs which allow user interaction and fact-checking. The scales fell from this troper's eyes over two myths and the way that the moderators of Snopes handled them. The first is the famous case of The Dating Game, where a housewife gave a ribald response to the question: "what is the strangest place you've ever had sex". Snopes started out saying this was fake, but imagine our surprise when a video of it emerged. Snopes continued to claim the legend was fake, because some (but not all) accounts of the legends involved a black couple, and the couple in the video was white. Basically Snopes was claiming that the legend wasn't true, there just happened to have been another incident that perfectly matched the legend, but wasn't actually the incident that was being referred to. Snopes eventually very reluctantly changed the status of this myth to true. The second case was that of The Wooden Bomb. The original page said this myth was false, citing no references. This was followed with a long paternalistic lecture about how the legend couldn't be true, which makes it pretty clear that they never bothered to research it. It then came out that the legend was true, and it took a very long time for Snopes to acknowledge that. In the interim Snopes went to rather insane lengths to ensure that their site can't be archived, so it's impossible for anyone to see the history of their positions on various myths. Bad form, indeed!
28th Nov '16 11:00:10 AM FromtheWordsofBR
Is there an issue? Send a Message
28th Nov '16 10:59:54 AM FromtheWordsofBR
Is there an issue? Send a Message


[[folder: Rion "Rhino" Mills]]

* JEFFWONTLEAVE: I personally think that commentary videos get a bad rep nowadays. They have drastically improved from what they were back in 2011 with much more insight and humor. One prime example of this is WebVideo/RionRhinoMills, considered by many to be the best one out there. Which makes his DMOS, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcmurG7bnHc&ab_channel=BunchOfPseudoIntellectuals Response to Mr Enter]] even more painful. The video itself [[{{They Wasted a Perfectly Good Plot}} could have been better]] if it was worked into a main commentary on his channel or People who did the B.O.P commentary on Mr.Enter's troll video did the response, but instead it's just a lazy response that come's across as filler for a {{Massive Multiplayer Crossover}} channel. But the main issue I had with this video that turned it {{From Bad to Worse}} was the last 3 minutes where he tries to come across as {{The Last DJ}} [[{{Anvilicious}} who is trying to help save the poor misinformed fans of this horrible person who made a video he hated on youtube]] instead turned the entire response to a very mean-spirited, arrogant and completely uncalled for rant about Mr.enter. For someone who is well known for being very well reasonable and yet still blunt and to the point, this seemed completely out of character for him and added nothing of value to the commentary. As a person who hated that troll video as much as, if not more so then him, I was completely furious with this video and was considering just giving up on the commentary community all over again, but I decided to give him one more shot and he did win me back. But I'm still not forgiving him for that train wreck any time soon.
** [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: Definitely gonna have to agree. While the actual video in question was actually pretty good (with many good points), this response was just...bleh, especially since both Rion and B.O.P. have done much better videos. It starts out fine, but it would've felt better if it were just a Quickie on Rion's normal channel. And then the last 3 minutes come in. That Last DJ attitude just rubs me the wrong way because he and the others in B.O.P. criticize Johnny for being hypocritical when Rion just did the same thing here (acting egotistical in his hate for Mr. Enter and rallying up all his fans to unsubscribe because of a video he didn't like and [somewhat] attack users who dislike the video, while criticizing Mr. Enter for being egotistical with his hate for trolls). Which is [[OOCIsSeriousBusiness beyond]] [[{{Irony}} mind-numbing]] because he's normally excellent at avoiding {{hypocrisy}}. All in all, it's a rare misstep for a normally flawless commentator, perhaps one of his only ones so far.


Added DiffLines:

* JEFFWONTLEAVE: I personally think that commentary videos get a bad rep nowadays. They have drastically improved from what they were back in 2011 with much more insight and humor. One prime example of this is WebVideo/RionRhinoMills, considered by many to be the best one out there. Which makes his DMOS, [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcmurG7bnHc&ab_channel=BunchOfPseudoIntellectuals Response to Mr Enter]] even more painful. The video itself [[{{They Wasted a Perfectly Good Plot}} could have been better]] if it was worked into a main commentary on his channel or People who did the B.O.P commentary on Mr.Enter's troll video did the response, but instead it's just a lazy response that come's across as filler for a {{Massive Multiplayer Crossover}} channel. But the main issue I had with this video that turned it {{From Bad to Worse}} was the last 3 minutes where he tries to come across as {{The Last DJ}} [[{{Anvilicious}} who is trying to help save the poor misinformed fans of this horrible person who made a video he hated on youtube]] instead turned the entire response to a very mean-spirited, arrogant and completely uncalled for rant about Mr.enter. For someone who is well known for being very well reasonable and yet still blunt and to the point, this seemed completely out of character for him and added nothing of value to the commentary. As a person who hated that troll video as much as, if not more so then him, I was completely furious with this video and was considering just giving up on the commentary community all over again, but I decided to give him one more shot and he did win me back. But I'm still not forgiving him for that train wreck any time soon.
** [=FromtheWordsofBR=]: Definitely gonna have to agree. While the actual video in question was actually pretty good (with many good points), this response was just...bleh, especially since both Rion and B.O.P. have done much better videos. It starts out fine, but it would've felt better if it were just a Quickie on Rion's normal channel. And then the last 3 minutes come in. That Last DJ attitude just rubs me the wrong way because he and the others in B.O.P. criticize Johnny for being hypocritical when Rion just did the same thing here (acting egotistical in his hate for Mr. Enter and rallying up all his fans to unsubscribe because of a video he didn't like and [somewhat] attack users who dislike the video, while criticizing Mr. Enter for being egotistical with his hate for trolls). Which is [[OOCIsSeriousBusiness beyond]] [[{{Irony}} mind-numbing]] because he's normally excellent at avoiding {{hypocrisy}}. All in all, it's a rare misstep for a normally flawless commentator, perhaps one of his only ones so far.
28th Nov '16 5:33:01 AM keybladeoverlord
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** keybladeoverlord: In addition to the above statement about this list, I was displeased with how Nervous Nick put not one, but TWO of the Sonic the Hedgehog cartoons on the list. First off, while the two shows in question, Sonic Underground at #8 and The Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog at #3, may not be as great as Sonic SATAM, they still have their fanbases, but it was nothing but nitpicking to an absurd degree, especially when he mentioned the shows' giving Sonic a Trademark Favorite Food which eventually became canon to the games. While I admit both shows had flaws to them, they were still some fun little experiences to watch. I wouldn't be so mad about it if he had stuck to the rule that so many other countdown makers have taken to heart these days, which is the One Entry Per Franchise rule. I also really didn't like his bashing of the Donkey Kong Country cartoon, where any legitimate complaints about the show were drowned out by pointless bitching about things like the show having songs, many of which are liked by a LOT of people and gives the show some of its charm.
26th Nov '16 6:21:49 PM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Sugarp1e1: I didn't appreciate the seventh entry of ScrewAttack's [[https://youtu.be/fZuki3QTb2s Top 10 Worst Cartoons Based on Video Games list]]; [[spoiler:BlazBlue: Alter Memory.]] It's not the fact that Nervous Nick doesn't like [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] that's the problem (I've never even played the game or watched the anime). As with my PhantomStrider entry above, my problem is his reason for putting it on the list. He starts the entry off by making it clear that he doesn't like the game's world or story, having a very PlayTheGameSkipTheStory attitude about it. Okay, fine. But judging by the clips he used, [[spoiler:Alter Memory]] is actually a pretty faithful adaptation. So why is it bad according to Nick? [[BiasSteamroller Because it's a faithful adaptation of a game he never liked to begin with.]] His bias behind this is clear, what with him spending the entire entry making the story even more confusing than it actually is and ending the entry with him absolutely losing his shit over how much he hates [[spoiler:BlazBlue]]'s story (especially the whole [[spoiler:StableTimeLoop]] plot point), claiming "I see [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] for what it really is! It's a mess! I hate it! That why it's #7." Um, Nick? [[OpinionMyopia Are you implying that the people who do like the story are idiotic sheep?]] Don't get me wrong; I totally agree that the [[spoiler:StableTimeLoop]] is confusing, especially at the end when [[spoiler:the cycle is finally broken]], but I wouldn't scream at my audience telling them "The story sucks!" in a way that suggests my subjective opinion is objective fact. You probably also noticed that this DMOS entry sounds more like I'm talking about the game and not the anime. Nick's tirade was the same way. On top of all that, [[MurderArsonAndJaywalking #7 was the only entry on the list that wasn't an adaptation of a game he liked.]] If he never liked [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] to begin with, then he's in no position to tell us that [[spoiler:Alter Memory]] is a bad adaptation just because it's faithful to the source material.

to:

* Sugarp1e1: I didn't appreciate the seventh entry of ScrewAttack's [[https://youtu.be/fZuki3QTb2s Top 10 Worst Cartoons Based on Video Games list]]; [[spoiler:BlazBlue: Alter Memory.]] It's not the fact that Nervous Nick doesn't like [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] that's the problem (I've never even played the game or watched the anime). As with my PhantomStrider entry above, my problem with this list is his reason for putting it on the list.list as well as his elitist attitude about the whole thing. He starts the entry off by making it clear that he doesn't like the game's world or story, having a very PlayTheGameSkipTheStory attitude about it. Okay, fine. But judging by the clips of the anime he used, [[spoiler:Alter Memory]] is actually a pretty faithful adaptation. So why is it bad according to Nick? [[BiasSteamroller Because it's a faithful adaptation of a game he never liked to begin with.]] His bias behind this is clear, what with him spending the entire entry making summarizing the story in way that makes it sound even more confusing than it actually really is (instead of just explaining why he finds it confusing) and ending the entry with him absolutely losing his shit [[PrecisionFStrike shit]] over how much he hates [[spoiler:BlazBlue]]'s story (especially the whole [[spoiler:StableTimeLoop]] plot point), claiming "I see [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] for what it really is! It's a mess! I hate it! That why it's #7." Um, Nick? [[OpinionMyopia Are you implying that the people who do like the story are idiotic sheep?]] To me, it sounds like he's genuinely proclaiming himself to be [[FanHater better than the fans]] because he can't get past the story. Don't get me wrong; I totally agree that the [[spoiler:StableTimeLoop]] is confusing, especially at the end when [[spoiler:the cycle is finally broken]], but I wouldn't scream yell at my audience telling them that "The story sucks!" in a way that suggests my subjective opinion is objective fact. And considering how he goes from screaming his lungs out to calmly moving on to #6, it was PlayedForLaughs. You probably also noticed that this DMOS entry sounds more like I'm talking about the game and not the anime. Nick's tirade was the same way. On top of all that, [[MurderArsonAndJaywalking #7 was the only entry on the list that wasn't an adaptation of a game he liked.]] If he never liked [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] to begin with, then he's in no position to tell us that [[spoiler:Alter Memory]] is a bad adaptation just because it's faithful to the source material.
26th Nov '16 12:07:02 PM Sugarp1e1
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Sugarp1e1: I didn't appreciate the seventh entry of ScrewAttack's [[https://youtu.be/fZuki3QTb2s Top 10 Worst Cartoons Based on Video Games list]]; [[spoiler:BlazBlue: Alter Memory.]] It's not the fact that Nervous Nick doesn't like [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] that's the problem (I've never even played the game or watched the anime). As with my PhantomStrider entry above, my problem is his reason for putting it on the list. He starts the entry off by making it clear that he doesn't like the game's world or story, having a very PlayTheGameSkipTheStory attitude about it. Okay, fine. But judging by the clips he used, [[spoiler:Alter Memory]] is actually a pretty faithful adaptation. So why is it bad according to Nick? [[BiasSteamroller Because it's a faithful adaptation of a game he never liked to begin with.]] His bias behind this is clear, what with him spending the entire entry making the story even more confusing than it actually is and ending the entry with him absolutely losing his shit over how much he hates [[spoiler:BlazBlue]]'s story (especially the whole [[spoiler:StableTimeLoop]] plot point), claiming "I see [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] for what it really is! It's a mess! I hate it! That why it's #7." Um, Nick? [[OpinionMyopia Are you implying that the people who do like the story are idiotic sheep?]] Don't get me wrong; I totally agree that the [[spoiler:StableTimeLoop]] is confusing, especially at the end when [[spoiler:the cycle is finally broken]], but I wouldn't scream at my audience telling them "The story sucks!" in a way that suggests my subjective opinion is objective fact. You probably also noticed that this DMOS entry sounds more like I'm talking about the game and not the anime. Nick's tirade was the same way. On top of all that, [[MurderArsonAndJaywalking #7 was the only entry on the list that wasn't an adaptation of a game he liked.]] If he never liked [[spoiler:BlazBlue]] to begin with, then he's in no position to tell us that [[spoiler:Alter Memory]] is a bad adaptation just because it's faithful to the source material.
23rd Nov '16 7:25:33 AM ChrisX
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Kira Doom: Not only do I strongly agree here, but I want to point something out here that really bothers me about the whole thing: the super obvious DoubleStandard here. Yeah, the Go!Titans are [[DesignatedHero Designated Heroes]], but the Titans in James' video straight-up [[MoralEventHorizon murdered a bunch of mentally handicapped people]]! [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even the Go!Titans would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the [=AnimatedJames=]!Titans to slaughter people like this because [[DisproportionateRetribution they made]] [[FelonyMisdemeanor a bad reboot]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's]] [[SarcasmMode totally a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I used to be okay ''Teen Titans Go!'', but even though I don't like it anymore, I would never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in his criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). So yeah, because of this (and the other Dethroning Moments here that I also agree with), I'm never watching this guy again.

to:

** Kira Doom: Not only do I strongly agree here, but I want to point something out here that really bothers me about the whole thing: the super obvious DoubleStandard here. Yeah, the Go!Titans are [[DesignatedHero Designated Heroes]], but the Titans in James' video straight-up [[MoralEventHorizon murdered a bunch of mentally handicapped people]]! [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even the Go!Titans would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the [=AnimatedJames=]!Titans to slaughter people like this because [[DisproportionateRetribution they made]] [[FelonyMisdemeanor a bad reboot]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's]] [[SarcasmMode that's totally a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I used to be okay ''Teen Titans Go!'', but even though I don't like it anymore, I would never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in his criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). So yeah, because of this (and the other Dethroning Moments here that I also agree with), I'm never watching this guy again.
23rd Nov '16 7:23:56 AM ChrisX
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Kira Doom: Not only do I strongly agree here, but I want to point something out here that really bothers me about the whole thing: the super obvious DoubleStandard here. Yeah, the Go!Titans are [[DesignatedHero Designated Heroes]], but the Titans in James' video straight-up [[MoralEventHorizon murdered]] [[MoralEventHorizon a bunch of mentally handicapped people]]! [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even the Go!Titans would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the [=AnimatedJames=]!Titans to slaughter people like this because [[DisproportionateRetribution they made]] [[FelonyMisdemeanor a bad reboot]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's]] [[SarcasmMode totally]] [[SarcasmMode a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I used to be okay ''Teen Titans Go!'', but even though I don't like it anymore, I would never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in his criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). So yeah, because of this (and the other Dethroning Moments here that I also agree with), I'm never watching this guy again.

to:

** Kira Doom: Not only do I strongly agree here, but I want to point something out here that really bothers me about the whole thing: the super obvious DoubleStandard here. Yeah, the Go!Titans are [[DesignatedHero Designated Heroes]], but the Titans in James' video straight-up [[MoralEventHorizon murdered]] [[MoralEventHorizon murdered a bunch of mentally handicapped people]]! [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even the Go!Titans would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the [=AnimatedJames=]!Titans to slaughter people like this because [[DisproportionateRetribution they made]] [[FelonyMisdemeanor a bad reboot]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's]] [[SarcasmMode totally]] [[SarcasmMode totally a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I used to be okay ''Teen Titans Go!'', but even though I don't like it anymore, I would never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in his criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). So yeah, because of this (and the other Dethroning Moments here that I also agree with), I'm never watching this guy again.
20th Nov '16 9:07:38 AM CerotechOmega
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Kira Doom: Not only do I strongly agree here, but I want to point something out here that really bothers me about the whole thing: the super obvious DoubleStandard here. Yeah, the Go!Titans are [[DesignatedHero Designated Heroes]], but the Titans in James' video straight-up ''[[MoralEventHorizon murdered]]'' [[MoralEventHorizon a bunch of mentally handicapped people]]! [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even the Go!Titans would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the [=AnimatedJames=]!Titans to slaughter people like this because [[DisproportionateRetribution they made]] [[FelonyMisdemeanor a bad reboot]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's]] ''[[SarcasmMode totally]]'' [[SarcasmMode a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I used to be okay ''Teen Titans Go!'', but even though I don't like it anymore, I would never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in his criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). So yeah, because of this (and the other Dethroning Moments here that I also agree with), I'm never watching this guy again.

to:

** Kira Doom: Not only do I strongly agree here, but I want to point something out here that really bothers me about the whole thing: the super obvious DoubleStandard here. Yeah, the Go!Titans are [[DesignatedHero Designated Heroes]], but the Titans in James' video straight-up ''[[MoralEventHorizon murdered]]'' [[MoralEventHorizon murdered]] [[MoralEventHorizon a bunch of mentally handicapped people]]! [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even the Go!Titans would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the [=AnimatedJames=]!Titans to slaughter people like this because [[DisproportionateRetribution they made]] [[FelonyMisdemeanor a bad reboot]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's]] ''[[SarcasmMode totally]]'' [[SarcasmMode totally]] [[SarcasmMode a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I used to be okay ''Teen Titans Go!'', but even though I don't like it anymore, I would never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in his criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). So yeah, because of this (and the other Dethroning Moments here that I also agree with), I'm never watching this guy again.
18th Nov '16 10:37:11 PM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Kira Doom: Not only do I strongly agree here, but I want to point something out here that really bothers me about the whole thing: the super obvious DoubleStandard here. Yeah, the Go!Titans are [[DesignatedHero Designated Heroes]], but the Titans in James' video straight-up [[MoralEventHorizon murdered]] [[MoralEventHorizon a bunch of mentally handicapped people]]! [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even the Go!Titans would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the [=AnimatedJames=]!Titans to slaughter people like this because [[DisproportionateRetribution they made]] [[FelonyMisdemeanor a bad reboot]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's]] [[SarcasmMode totally]] [[SarcasmMode a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I used to be okay ''Teen Titans Go!'', but even though I don't like it anymore, I would never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in his criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). So yeah, because of this (and the other Dethroning Moments here that I also agree with), I'm never watching this guy again.

to:

** Kira Doom: Not only do I strongly agree here, but I want to point something out here that really bothers me about the whole thing: the super obvious DoubleStandard here. Yeah, the Go!Titans are [[DesignatedHero Designated Heroes]], but the Titans in James' video straight-up [[MoralEventHorizon murdered]] ''[[MoralEventHorizon murdered]]'' [[MoralEventHorizon a bunch of mentally handicapped people]]! [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even the Go!Titans would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the [=AnimatedJames=]!Titans to slaughter people like this because [[DisproportionateRetribution they made]] [[FelonyMisdemeanor a bad reboot]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's]] [[SarcasmMode totally]] ''[[SarcasmMode totally]]'' [[SarcasmMode a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I used to be okay ''Teen Titans Go!'', but even though I don't like it anymore, I would never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in his criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). So yeah, because of this (and the other Dethroning Moments here that I also agree with), I'm never watching this guy again.



** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy, [[CruelAndUnusualDeath graphic]], [[NightmareFuel brutal and cruel]] as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He [[NauseaFuel cuts a slice off Toothy's face]] ''[[TheWoobie while he was terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, [[BodyHorror carves Nutty like an apple]], shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q]]'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]].

to:

** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy, [[CruelAndUnusualDeath graphic]], [[NightmareFuel brutal and cruel]] as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He [[NauseaFuel cuts a slice off Toothy's face]] ''[[TheWoobie while he was terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, [[BodyHorror carves Nutty like an apple]], shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q]]'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]]. By that point you'd think Mondo would have learned their lesson, but they didn't.
17th Nov '16 6:52:30 PM metamaster54610
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** MetaMaster54610: You'd think Logan would have learned his lesson from the fiasco Jeffy's Bad Word caused. He knew full well how loathed that video was, so you'd think he'd know better than to create Jeffy's Bad Word 2.0 in the form of 'Locked Out'. The plot of the video is that Mario is trying to get Jeffy to eat his peas, promising him chocolate cake if he eats his peas. Rather than eating his peas, Jeffy pours them onto his high chair seat and tries to lie to Mario about it. When Mario rightfully denies him chocolate cake for not actually eating his dinner, Jeffy throws a tantrum. Admittedly, it was a dick move to have Mario eat a piece of chocolate cake in front of Jeffy, but what happens next is disproportionate retribution at its finest. Jeffy tricks Mario into going outside, then locks him out so he can steal the cake. He locks all the doors and traps Mario outside. In this video, Jeffy clearly has malicious intent, and knows EXACTLY what he's doing. Mario is locked outside in the cold, trying everything he can to get back inside. And then the Brooklyn Guy shows up, and when he shows up in a Jeffy video, you immediately know Mario is in for a bad time. The Brooklyn Officer thinks that Mario is trying to break into the house, and when he talks to Jeffy about it, the little bastard lies and says he's never seen Mario before in his life. Of course the Brooklyn Guy takes Jeffy's word over Mario's and threatens to arrest him if he ever goes near his OWN HOUSE again. Mario is rightfully PISSED at this point, mumbling threats to assault and murder Jeffy, and honestly, after everything Jeffy's done to him, it's hard to blame him for wanting revenge. He tries to get inside through the air vents, and ends up crashing down on the floor, seemingly unconscious. Jeffy sees Mario lying on the floor, and, infuriatingly, grabs him and LITERALLY THROWS HIM BACK OUTSIDE WITHOUT A WORD. Eventually, Mario BEGS Jeffy to just let him inside, which Jeffy refuses to do unless Mario gets him more chocolate cake. So Mario does get another chocolate cake...Which Mario hides in so that he can get inside. When Mario pops out of the cake, he chases Jeffy in a rage...And gets locked out AGAIN. And of COURSE it ends with him getting arrested and Jeffy getting off scott-free for his actions, because Logan REFUSES to freaking PUNISH this kid for the awful things he does. This is honestly the video that cemented my absolute LOATHING of Jeffy as a character. He's nothing more than a braindead, unfunny little sociopath that exists for the sole purpose of making Mario's life a complete and utter nightmare, and he's WELL AWARE of that fact. I am very disappointed in Logan. I thought he would have known better after the last time he made a video where Mario was unfairly tormented because of Jeffy...
17th Nov '16 4:44:00 PM Peridonyx
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/{{Peridonyx}}: After seeing the teaser for Silly Filly Studios's ''WebAnimation/FallOfTheCrystalEmpire'', I was hyped, especially since [[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic King Sombra]]'s one of my favorite villains. However, the final product ended up dashing that excitement via some pretty lazy writing. For starters, the canon Sombra? A distinguishably CrazyPrepared NoNonsenseNemesis. The SFS version? A chronic VillainBall-holder with glaring SuicidalOverconfidence. Even worse, his out-of-nowhere BadassDecay at the end when [[spoiler:[[[[SuperpoweredEvilSide Nightmare Moon]] suddenly emerges from Princess Luna, invokes an EvilerThanThou CurbStompBattle on him (even though he's portrayed both in canon and here as too powerful for even an individual [[PhysicalGod Alicorn]], thus explaining the good guys' need for an AmplifierArtifact like the Crystal Heart), reduces him to an AintTooProudToBeg wreck (in contrast to the canon version's DefiantToTheEnd reaction pre-defeat), and -- in such a blatant and pointless AssPull -- is revealed as the real one responsible for the Empire's disappearance for 1,000 years (Remember the canon Sombra demonstrating such powerful magic and devious pragmatism via his DeadManSwitch curse on the whole Empire? Nope, turns out it was just a ForTheEvulz moment by the InformedAbility-invoking StarterVillain of the series pilot all along!)]]. While I still like a lot of SFS's other works, it's like they exclusively focused all their efforts on this one's action while just hurriedly trying to give it as much of an ExcusePlot as possible.

to:

* Tropers/{{Peridonyx}}: After seeing the teaser for Silly Filly Studios's ''WebAnimation/FallOfTheCrystalEmpire'', I was hyped, especially since [[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic King Sombra]]'s one of my favorite villains. However, the final product ended up dashing that excitement via some pretty lazy writing. For starters, the canon Sombra? A distinguishably CrazyPrepared NoNonsenseNemesis. The SFS version? A chronic VillainBall-holder with glaring SuicidalOverconfidence. Even worse, his out-of-nowhere BadassDecay at the end when [[spoiler:[[[[SuperpoweredEvilSide [[spoiler:[[SuperpoweredEvilSide Nightmare Moon]] suddenly emerges from Princess Luna, invokes an EvilerThanThou CurbStompBattle on him (even though he's portrayed both in canon and here as too powerful for even an individual [[PhysicalGod Alicorn]], thus explaining the good guys' need for an AmplifierArtifact like the Crystal Heart), reduces him to an AintTooProudToBeg wreck (in contrast to the canon version's DefiantToTheEnd reaction pre-defeat), and -- in such a blatant and pointless AssPull -- is revealed as the real one responsible for the Empire's disappearance for 1,000 years (Remember the canon Sombra demonstrating such powerful magic and devious pragmatism via his DeadManSwitch curse on the whole Empire? Nope, turns out it was just a ForTheEvulz moment by the InformedAbility-invoking StarterVillain of the series pilot all along!)]]. While I still like a lot of SFS's other works, it's like they exclusively focused all their efforts on this one's action while just hurriedly trying to give it as much of an ExcusePlot as possible.
17th Nov '16 4:43:27 PM Peridonyx
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/{{Peridonyx}}: After seeing the teaser for Silly Filly Studios's ''WebAnimation/FallOfTheCrystalEmpire'', I was hyped, especially since [[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic King Sombra]]'s one of my favorite villains. However, the final product ended up dashing that excitement via some pretty lazy writing. For starters, the canon Sombra? A distinguishable, CrazyPrepared NoNonsenseNemesis. The SFS version? A chronic VillainBall-holder with glaring SuicidalOverconfidence. Even worse, his utterly pointless BadassDecay at the end when [[spoiler:Nightmare Moon suddenly emerges from Princess Luna, quickly invokes an EvilerThanThou CurbStompBattle on him (even though he's portrayed both in canon and here as too powerful for even an individual [[PhysicalGod Alicorn]], thus explaining the good guys' dire need for an AmplifierArtifact like the Crystal Heart), reduces him to an AintTooProudToBeg wreck (in contrast to the canon version's clear DefiantToTheEnd reaction pre-defeat), and -- in such a blatant AssPull that really benefits nopony whatsoever -- is ultimately revealed as the real one responsible for the Empire's disappearance (Remember the canon Sombra demonstrating such powerful magic and devious pragmatism via his DeadManSwitch curse on the whole Empire? Nope, turns out that it was actually just a ForTheEvulz moment from the InformedAbility-invoking StarterVillain from the series pilot all along!)]]. While I still like a lot of SFS's other works, it's like they exclusively focused all of their efforts on this one's action while just hurriedly trying to give it as much of an ExcusePlot as possible.

to:

* Tropers/{{Peridonyx}}: After seeing the teaser for Silly Filly Studios's ''WebAnimation/FallOfTheCrystalEmpire'', I was hyped, especially since [[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic King Sombra]]'s one of my favorite villains. However, the final product ended up dashing that excitement via some pretty lazy writing. For starters, the canon Sombra? A distinguishable, distinguishably CrazyPrepared NoNonsenseNemesis. The SFS version? A chronic VillainBall-holder with glaring SuicidalOverconfidence. Even worse, his utterly pointless out-of-nowhere BadassDecay at the end when [[spoiler:Nightmare Moon [[spoiler:[[[[SuperpoweredEvilSide Nightmare Moon]] suddenly emerges from Princess Luna, quickly invokes an EvilerThanThou CurbStompBattle on him (even though he's portrayed both in canon and here as too powerful for even an individual [[PhysicalGod Alicorn]], thus explaining the good guys' dire need for an AmplifierArtifact like the Crystal Heart), reduces him to an AintTooProudToBeg wreck (in contrast to the canon version's clear DefiantToTheEnd reaction pre-defeat), and -- in such a blatant and pointless AssPull that really benefits nopony whatsoever -- is ultimately revealed as the real one responsible for the Empire's disappearance for 1,000 years (Remember the canon Sombra demonstrating such powerful magic and devious pragmatism via his DeadManSwitch curse on the whole Empire? Nope, turns out that it was actually just a ForTheEvulz moment from by the InformedAbility-invoking StarterVillain from of the series pilot all along!)]]. While I still like a lot of SFS's other works, it's like they exclusively focused all of their efforts on this one's action while just hurriedly trying to give it as much of an ExcusePlot as possible.
17th Nov '16 4:35:21 PM Peridonyx
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Tropers/{{Peridonyx}}: After seeing the teaser for Silly Filly Studios's ''WebAnimation/FallOfTheCrystalEmpire'', I was hyped, especially since [[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic King Sombra]]'s one of my favorite villains. However, the final product ended up dashing that excitement via some pretty lazy writing. For starters, the canon Sombra? A distinguishable, CrazyPrepared NoNonsenseNemesis. The SFS version? A chronic VillainBall-holder with glaring SuicidalOverconfidence. Even worse, his utterly pointless BadassDecay at the end when [[spoiler:Nightmare Moon suddenly emerges from Princess Luna, quickly invokes an EvilerThanThou CurbStompBattle on him (even though he's portrayed both in canon and here as too powerful for even an individual [[PhysicalGod Alicorn]], thus explaining the good guys' dire need for an AmplifierArtifact like the Crystal Heart), reduces him to an AintTooProudToBeg wreck (in contrast to the canon version's clear DefiantToTheEnd reaction pre-defeat), and -- in such a blatant AssPull that really benefits nopony whatsoever -- is ultimately revealed as the real one responsible for the Empire's disappearance (Remember the canon Sombra demonstrating such powerful magic and devious pragmatism via his DeadManSwitch curse on the whole Empire? Nope, turns out that it was actually just a ForTheEvulz moment from the InformedAbility-invoking StarterVillain from the series pilot all along!)]]. While I still like a lot of SFS's other works, it's like they exclusively focused all of their efforts on this one's action while just hurriedly trying to give it as much of an ExcusePlot as possible.
17th Nov '16 12:26:42 AM shonengirl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** shonengirl: I actually liked James when I knew only his Sonic vs. MLP videos, but even then they made me roll my eyes at the crude jokes right out of a bad adult cartoon that popped up here and there, and this is the reason I disliked "Amy Rose vs. Pinky Pie". I mean, at least in "Sonic vs. Rainbow Dash" they were mostly quick and fast-paced, and it was action-packed enough to at least make it enjoyable. I would have put the Splatoon vs. de Blob video on here, as it was where I realized that this guy can put out pure crude, cringeworthy material made of nothing but crude, cringeworthy material. But then I found out/was reminded that he did a Pokemon video. You see, I heavily look down on fan animation (the western ones anyway), especially shorts, because 99% of it is just bad attempts at shock humor attached to a well-loved family-friendly franchise, because, well, they're "edgy" or something; I.e. What I like to call "Racist Mario syndrome", or otherwise echo whiny complaints, use "jokes" that have been done to death (though this is connected heavily to Racist Mario syndrome) put everyone [[CharacterDerailment through the character grinder and back again multiple times]] and/or [[KafkaComedy needlessly cruel torment]] because "comedy". Even if a short actually seems to be going fine, it will always have to end on an obligatory stupid gory/gross/"adult" meanspirited joke, I groan, [[FacePalm Palm meets forehead]]. Again. Occasionally I'll see a genuinely funny or even heartwarming animation with clearly much heart put into it, to my pleasant surprise, but if it's a 2D short that's, ironically enough, colored in and fully animated by a big channel with fully "original" content (as opposed to a series of LimitedAnimation sketches, those with an audio source, or comic dubs), there's a big chance it's going to be bad, though despite the reputations of their fanbases My Little Pony and Undertale seem to be exceptions to this (only relatively speaking however). Three common victims of "Were so edgey!1!!" I know of are Mario, Sonic, and Pokemon; and look, the guy who made a blob jizz over 14-year-olds did an animation on the latter! [[SarcasmMode Oh joy!]] And look, it features a cute little mouse tortured painfully and nothing else! Fun! At least he actually uses Red instead of Ash, showing that he isn't yet another person who knows nothing about Pokemon that just made a "parody" anyway, though that might make it just worse. Since it shows he should actually give a [[PrecisionFStrike shit]] about what he's doing. But nope, it's yet another video in the giant mass of "Durr hurr, look, we took an innocent thing and filled it with gore, sex, gross-out, and [[BreadEggsBreadedEggs sexed-up gross-out gore!]] We're so edgy lol" taking up a good part of western web animation. You know what, I haven't seen this video. I may have seen the thumbnail for it before, but I was wise enough not to click on it despite Red's cute, innocent-looking face. But the moment I hear "Pokemon parody" I know something has a good chance of being horrible, and the description above confirms my suspicions, if not being even worse than I expected. Well, I guess the idea is kind of original, but it makes no sense and at its core it's one of way too many cliche, uninspired western "fan" animations. It's times like this I really appreciate what ''Robot Chicken'' did when they parodied Pokemon, showing the inside of a Pokeball as a paradise, despite the crude humor. I have a strong stomach, and poorly-done "adult" gags just make me roll my eyes, so anything meant to be "shocking" is just tedious and boring to me. Guess what animators, you're not doing anything new. It's not even shocking anymore, it's just annoying and irritating, it's not funny, and worst of all, it's cliche, overdone, lazy, and '''boring'''! Stop already!

to:

** shonengirl: I actually liked James when I knew only his Sonic vs. MLP videos, but even then they made me roll my eyes at the crude jokes right out of a bad adult cartoon that popped up here and there, and this is the reason I disliked "Amy Rose vs. Pinky Pie". I mean, at least in "Sonic vs. Rainbow Dash" they were mostly quick and fast-paced, and it was action-packed enough to at least make it enjoyable. I would have put the Splatoon vs. de Blob video on here, as it was where I realized that this guy can put out pure crude, cringeworthy material made of nothing but crude, cringeworthy material. But then I found out/was reminded that he did a Pokemon video. You see, I heavily look down on fan animation parodies (the western ones anyway), especially shorts, because 99% of it is just bad attempts at shock humor attached to a well-loved family-friendly franchise, because, well, they're "edgy" or something; I.e. What I like to call "Racist Mario syndrome", or otherwise echo whiny complaints, use "jokes" that have been done to death (though this is connected heavily to Racist Mario syndrome) syndrome), and put everyone [[CharacterDerailment through the character grinder and back again multiple times]] and/or [[KafkaComedy needlessly cruel torment]] because "comedy". Even if a short actually seems to be going fine, it will always have to end on an obligatory stupid gory/gross/"adult" meanspirited joke, I groan, [[FacePalm Palm meets forehead]]. Again. Occasionally I'll see a genuinely funny or even heartwarming animation one with clearly much heart put into it, to my pleasant surprise, but if it's a 2D short that's, ironically enough, colored in and fully animated by a big channel with fully "original" content (as opposed to a series of LimitedAnimation sketches, those with an audio source, or comic dubs), there's a big chance it's going to be bad, though despite the reputations of their fanbases My Little Pony and Undertale animations seem to be exceptions to this (only relatively speaking however). however... Smile HD and Pony.mov are still things that exist). Three common victims of "Were so edgey!1!!" I know of are Mario, Sonic, and Pokemon; and the more franchises a channel covers, the bigger chance it seems there is it will churn out a bad "[[ShallowParody parody]]" of the latter. And look, the guy who made a blob jizz over 14-year-olds did an animation on the latter! it! [[SarcasmMode Oh joy!]] And look, it features a cute little mouse being tortured painfully and nothing else! Fun! At least he actually uses Red instead of Ash, showing that he isn't yet another person who knows nothing about Pokemon that just made a "parody" anyway, though that might make it just worse. Since it shows he should actually give a [[PrecisionFStrike shit]] about what he's doing. But nope, it's yet another video in the giant mass of "Durr hurr, look, we took an innocent thing and filled it with gore, sex, gross-out, and [[BreadEggsBreadedEggs sexed-up gross-out gore!]] We're so edgy lol" taking up a good part of western web animation.parody videos. You know what, I haven't seen this video. I may have seen the thumbnail for it before, but I was wise enough not to click on it despite Red's cute, innocent-looking face. But the moment I hear "Pokemon parody" I know something has a good chance of being horrible, and the description above confirms my suspicions, if not being even worse than I expected. Well, I guess the idea is kind of original, but it makes no sense ''no sense'' and at its core it's one of way too many cliche, uninspired western "fan" animations. animations/parodies. It's times like this I really appreciate what ''Robot Chicken'' did when they parodied Pokemon, Pokémon, showing the inside of a Pokeball as a paradise, despite the crude humor. I have a strong stomach, and so most poorly-done "adult" gags just make me roll my eyes, so and anything meant to be "shocking" is just tedious and boring to me. Guess what animators, people, you're not doing anything new. It's not even shocking anymore, it's just annoying and irritating, it's not funny, and worst of all, it's cliche, overdone, lazy, and '''boring'''! Stop already!already!
15th Nov '16 10:28:15 PM pgj1997
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/{{Pgj1997}}: Super Mario {{VideoGame/Undertale}} was a giant mess in my opinion. It's exactly what you think it is; Mario ends up in the Underworld, and thinks the mechanics of the Mario games work here. Surprise, they don't. It's basically what you'd expect from Dorkly at this point. One scene in particular really gets on my nerves. We see Mario and Sans in front of Papyrus' dead body, with Mario thinking he'd build himself back together like a Dry Bones, with Sans having distraught look on his face. Now, this would be funny if it weren't for one big glaring issue. They spend almost 30 seconds on this gag, all leading up to no punchline. And this is one-third of the entire video. It's not funny, and Mario's obliviousness certainly doesn't make things better. Also, this is a nitpick, but it's CriticalResearchFailure at its finest. Mario killed Papyrus like I mentioned, and earlier in the video was able to kill Flowey... and yet he somehow got the Pacifist Ending. And these guys call themselves real gamers. So apparently, this video was made to celebrate Undertale's one year anniversary since its initial Steam release. HaHaHaNo.

to:

** Tropers/{{Pgj1997}}: Super Mario {{VideoGame/Undertale}} was a giant mess in my opinion. It's exactly what you think it is; Mario ends up in the Underworld, and thinks the mechanics of the Mario games work here. Surprise, they don't. It's basically what you'd expect from Dorkly at this point. One scene in particular really gets on my nerves. We see Mario and Sans in front of Papyrus' dead body, with Mario thinking he'd build himself back together like a Dry Bones, with and Sans having distraught look on his face. Now, this would be funny if it weren't for one big glaring issue. They spend almost 30 seconds on this gag, all leading up to no punchline. And this is one-third of the entire video. It's not funny, and Mario's obliviousness certainly doesn't make things better. Also, this is a nitpick, but it's CriticalResearchFailure at its finest. Mario killed Papyrus like I mentioned, and earlier in the video was able to kill Flowey... and yet he somehow got the Pacifist Ending. And these guys call themselves real gamers. So apparently, this video was made to celebrate Undertale's one year anniversary since its initial Steam release. HaHaHaNo.
15th Nov '16 6:48:49 PM pgj1997
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Tropers/{{Pgj1997}}: Super Mario {{VideoGame/Undertale}} was a giant mess in my opinion. It's exactly what you think it is; Mario ends up in the Underworld, and thinks the mechanics of the Mario games work here. Surprise, they don't. It's basically what you'd expect from Dorkly at this point. One scene in particular really gets on my nerves. We see Mario and Sans in front of Papyrus' dead body, with Mario thinking he'd build himself back together like a Dry Bones, with Sans having distraught look on his face. Now, this would be funny if it weren't for one big glaring issue. They spend almost 30 seconds on this gag, all leading up to no punchline. And this is one-third of the entire video. It's not funny, and Mario's obliviousness certainly doesn't make things better. Also, this is a nitpick, but it's CriticalResearchFailure at its finest. Mario killed Papyrus like I mentioned, and earlier in the video was able to kill Flowey... and yet he somehow got the Pacifist Ending. And these guys call themselves real gamers. So apparently, this video was made to celebrate Undertale's one year anniversary since its initial Steam release. HaHaHaNo.
13th Nov '16 5:34:49 PM KiraDoom
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/KiraDoom: I was already pretty offended by this just reading it. I hear people praising Markiplier all the time for being a good person, so this seems really [[OutOfCharacterMoment out of character]] of him. But then everything got ''worse''; a while after reading this, I learned that Satoshi Tajiri, the guy who created ''Pokemon'', is autistic. A lot of people who like ''Pokemon'', including myself, are autistic. A lot of aspects of the ''Pokemon'' franchise probably stem from the fact that Tajiri is autistic. So, by insulting both the ''Pokemon'' series and its fanbase... [[FridgeHorror Did Mark, unintentionally, mock a whole bunch of autistic people?]] Now granted, he did this unintentionally (or, at least, I hope it was unintentional), and I may be looking too far into this, but think about it! I couldn't possibly be the only one who sees this! Now, I'm sure Mark is usually nice, and I'm not saying he has to like ''Pokemon''; I'm just saying that he should think before he speaks before he goes offending people, autistic or otherwise.
10th Nov '16 8:12:32 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy, [[CruelAndUnusualDeath graphic]], [[NightmareFuel brutal and cruel]] as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He [[NauseaFuel cuts a slice off Toothy's face]] ''[[TheWoobie while he was terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, [[BodyHorror carves Nutty like an appl]], shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q]]'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]].

to:

** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy, [[CruelAndUnusualDeath graphic]], [[NightmareFuel brutal and cruel]] as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He [[NauseaFuel cuts a slice off Toothy's face]] ''[[TheWoobie while he was terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, [[BodyHorror carves Nutty like an appl]], apple]], shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q]]'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]].
10th Nov '16 7:38:44 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy and cruel as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He cuts a slice off Toothy's face while he was ''[[TheWoobie terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, carves Nutty like an apple, shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q]]'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]].

to:

** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy {{Squick}}-worthy, [[CruelAndUnusualDeath graphic]], [[NightmareFuel brutal and cruel cruel]] as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He [[NauseaFuel cuts a slice off Toothy's face while he was face]] ''[[TheWoobie while he was terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, [[BodyHorror carves Nutty like an apple, appl]], shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q]]'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]].
9th Nov '16 5:50:15 PM dlchen145
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* GF93: Don't get me wrong, I think ''WebVideo/OneMinuteMelee'' is a very good series for the most part, but my personal DMOS has to go to ''"[[VideoGame/MegaManX Zero]] vs. [[Franchise/{{Kirby}} Meta Knight]]"''. It was a great idea for a fight for various reasons (The two not only both being [[HeroesPreferSwords sword-wielding]] mentors and friendly rivals to the main heroes of their respective franchises, but also being [[EnsembleDarkHorse very popular]] [[BadAss and Badass]] characters in their own right), so it'd be a great episode for either this series or a ''WebVideo/DeathBattle'', right? Sadly not. It was a massive disappointment in several respects, and just overall reeked of wasted potential. The fight itself was very pedestrian for the series' usual fast-paced and exciting standards, with neither character (Especially Meta Knight, who is limited to only his basic swordplay and not even allowed to use his ''VideoGame/SuperSmashBros'' moves or abilities despite using the same voice and appearance from there) really being able to do anything much considering their usual amount of powers and abilities that could have come into play, and the animation was nothing spectacular. Dishonorable mention however, has to go to the ending, for the sheer amount of CriticalResearchFailure and OutOfCharacter-ness abound from both characters. [[spoiler: Zero uses the [[ElementalPunch Rekkoha]] to summon lightning, Meta Knight ScreamsLikeALittleGirl (Despite him normally being TheStoic and never reacting to anything in such a way in his own series) and lets his guard down, allowing Zero to inflict a NoHoldsBarredBeatdown which ends with him [[ImpaledWithExtremePrejudice stabbing Meta Knight]] [[EyeScream through]] [[BodyHorror the]] [[FacialHorror face]] with his [[HotBlade superheated]] [[LaserBlade Z-Saber]], before [[HalfTheManHeUsedToBe slashing upward to bisect him vertically]], [[NauseaFuel with blood splattering across the ground from each of the two halves]]]]. Not only is it [[CruelAndUnusualDeath needlessly graphic]] [[NightmareFuel and brutal]] for a series whose fights don't normally end in death, but it goes [[{{OutOfCharacter}} completely against]] [[spoiler: [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold Zero's]] established character, who [[ThreeLawsCompliant outright refuses to kill sentient living beings]]. With that in mind, he could have easily [[BlastingItOutOfTheirHands knocked Meta Knight's sword out of his hand]] [[DefeatByModesty and then sliced his mask off]] from there, which would have been a nice CallBack to how he's defeated in the ''Kirby'' series]]. The worst part however, had to be [[spoiler: Zero's BondOneLiner afterward, quipping "Just like a training program" to the camera [[DissonantSerenity with a big smile]] [[SociopathicHero and a "^_^" expression on his face]] [[AdaptationalVillainy as if he didn't just commit brutal murder]], before just warping away without so much as a second thought about what he'd done. Again, [[KnightInSourArmor the]] [[TheAtoner canon]] [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold Zero]] would never do that.]] Thankfully, [[WinBackTheCrowd they did redeem themselves later on with the next episode]] (''[[Franchise/{{SuperMarioBros}} Bowser]] vs. [[Franchise/{{SonicTheHedgehog}} Doctor Eggman]]''), but even now, it just leaves a bitter taste with the disrespect shown to both characters. In closing- there's "No Research", and then there's just being inexcusably ignorant. At least with ''Hercule Satan vs. Dan Hibiki'' being redone as a ''Death Battle'', there could hopefully be the possibility of it happening with this match as well to properly do the two characters justice.

to:

* GF93: Don't get me wrong, I think ''WebVideo/OneMinuteMelee'' is a very good series for the most part, but my personal DMOS has to go to ''"[[VideoGame/MegaManX Zero]] vs. [[Franchise/{{Kirby}} Meta Knight]]"''. It was a great idea for a fight for various reasons (The two not only both being [[HeroesPreferSwords sword-wielding]] mentors and friendly rivals to the main heroes of their respective franchises, but also being [[EnsembleDarkHorse very popular]] [[BadAss and Badass]] badass characters in their own right), so it'd be a great episode for either this series or a ''WebVideo/DeathBattle'', right? Sadly not. It was a massive disappointment in several respects, and just overall reeked of wasted potential. The fight itself was very pedestrian for the series' usual fast-paced and exciting standards, with neither character (Especially Meta Knight, who is limited to only his basic swordplay and not even allowed to use his ''VideoGame/SuperSmashBros'' moves or abilities despite using the same voice and appearance from there) really being able to do anything much considering their usual amount of powers and abilities that could have come into play, and the animation was nothing spectacular. Dishonorable mention however, has to go to the ending, for the sheer amount of CriticalResearchFailure and OutOfCharacter-ness abound from both characters. [[spoiler: Zero uses the [[ElementalPunch Rekkoha]] to summon lightning, Meta Knight ScreamsLikeALittleGirl (Despite him normally being TheStoic and never reacting to anything in such a way in his own series) and lets his guard down, allowing Zero to inflict a NoHoldsBarredBeatdown which ends with him [[ImpaledWithExtremePrejudice stabbing Meta Knight]] [[EyeScream through]] [[BodyHorror the]] [[FacialHorror face]] with his [[HotBlade superheated]] [[LaserBlade Z-Saber]], before [[HalfTheManHeUsedToBe slashing upward to bisect him vertically]], [[NauseaFuel with blood splattering across the ground from each of the two halves]]]]. Not only is it [[CruelAndUnusualDeath needlessly graphic]] [[NightmareFuel and brutal]] for a series whose fights don't normally end in death, but it goes [[{{OutOfCharacter}} completely against]] [[spoiler: [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold Zero's]] established character, who [[ThreeLawsCompliant outright refuses to kill sentient living beings]]. With that in mind, he could have easily [[BlastingItOutOfTheirHands knocked Meta Knight's sword out of his hand]] [[DefeatByModesty and then sliced his mask off]] from there, which would have been a nice CallBack to how he's defeated in the ''Kirby'' series]]. The worst part however, had to be [[spoiler: Zero's BondOneLiner afterward, quipping "Just like a training program" to the camera [[DissonantSerenity with a big smile]] [[SociopathicHero and a "^_^" expression on his face]] [[AdaptationalVillainy as if he didn't just commit brutal murder]], before just warping away without so much as a second thought about what he'd done. Again, [[KnightInSourArmor the]] [[TheAtoner canon]] [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold Zero]] would never do that.]] Thankfully, [[WinBackTheCrowd they did redeem themselves later on with the next episode]] (''[[Franchise/{{SuperMarioBros}} Bowser]] vs. [[Franchise/{{SonicTheHedgehog}} Doctor Eggman]]''), but even now, it just leaves a bitter taste with the disrespect shown to both characters. In closing- there's "No Research", and then there's just being inexcusably ignorant. At least with ''Hercule Satan vs. Dan Hibiki'' being redone as a ''Death Battle'', there could hopefully be the possibility of it happening with this match as well to properly do the two characters justice.
9th Nov '16 10:50:38 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy and cruel as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He cuts a slice off Toothy's face while he was ''[[TheWoobie terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, carves Nutty like an apple, shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]].

to:

** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy and cruel as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He cuts a slice off Toothy's face while he was ''[[TheWoobie terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, carves Nutty like an apple, shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q'''[[KarmaHoudini q]]'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]].
9th Nov '16 10:42:40 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy and cruel as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He cuts a slice off Toothy's face while he was ''[[TheWoobie terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, carves Nutty like an apple, shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli'''q'''py's part (mostly)]].

to:

** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy and cruel as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He cuts a slice off Toothy's face while he was ''[[TheWoobie terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, carves Nutty like an apple, shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli'''q'''py's Fli]]'''[[KarmaHoudini q'''[[KarmaHoudini py's part (mostly)]].
9th Nov '16 10:39:47 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy and cruel as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He cuts a slice off Toothy's face while he was ''[[TheWoobie terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, carves Nutty like an apple, shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes.

to:

** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy and cruel as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He cuts a slice off Toothy's face while he was ''[[TheWoobie terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, carves Nutty like an apple, shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes.episodes and [[KarmaHoudini lack of comeuppance on Fli'''q'''py's part (mostly)]].
9th Nov '16 10:37:26 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy and cruel as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'')[[note]]. He cuts a slice off Toothy's face while he was ''[[TheWoobie terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, carves Nutty like an apple, shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes.

to:

** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy and cruel as his other murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'')[[note]].''Flaky'') [[/note]]. He cuts a slice off Toothy's face while he was ''[[TheWoobie terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, carves Nutty like an apple, shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes.
9th Nov '16 10:34:34 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy and cruel as his other murders[[note: That is, [[UpToEleven even more]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'')]]. He cuts a slice off Toothy's face while he was ''[[TheWoobie terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, carves Nutty like an apple, shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show.

to:

** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy and cruel as his other murders[[note: murders [[note]] That is, [[UpToEleven even more]] worse]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'')]].''Flaky'')[[note]]. He cuts a slice off Toothy's face while he was ''[[TheWoobie terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, carves Nutty like an apple, shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show.show, because of the [[DudeNotFunny unfunny]] Flippy episodes.
9th Nov '16 10:28:55 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy and cruel as his other murders[[note: That is, [[UpToEleven even more]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'')]]. He cuts a slice off Toothy's face while he was ''[[TheWoobie terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, carves Nutty like an apple, shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it.

to:

** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy and cruel as his other murders[[note: That is, [[UpToEleven even more]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'')]]. He cuts a slice off Toothy's face while he was ''[[TheWoobie terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, carves Nutty like an apple, shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it. After some thought, I gave up on the show.
9th Nov '16 10:26:31 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Tropers/TommyTiger: I was a former fan of HTF, but then I started to hate the show because of some certain person: Fli'''q'''py (not Flippy, he's innocent). Now, I know many people like him, so I'm pretty much one of the only Flippy haters, but I hate him because the episode ''Party Animal'' made me realize that he lost all his likability and would go down in history as one of the most heinous animated characters of all time, possibly just as bad as [[AnimeAndMange/FullmetalAlchemist Sho Tucker]] or even [[Disney/TheHunchbackOfNotreDame Judge Claude Frollo himself]]. So here's what happened: a bloated-up Flaky's quills popped some balloons, and [[SarcasmMode surprisingly]] he flipped-out, killing everybody except Flaky and The Mole (who, aside from being innocent, [[UngratefulBastard had also planned a party for him]]). How he murdered them is as {{Squick}}-worthy and cruel as his other murders[[note: That is, [[UpToEleven even more]] than WesternAnimation/TheItchyAndScratchyShow, because Itchy has mostly murdered Scratchy only, while Flippy has killed more than one innocent person (and sometimes even ''Flaky'')]]. He cuts a slice off Toothy's face while he was ''[[TheWoobie terrified and begging, in true HTF fashion, him to stop]]'' (which [[TearJerker made me cry]]), ties some balloons on Cuddles, getting him sliced to bits, carves Nutty like an apple, shoves Mime in a blender and rolls a barrel with Sniffles and knives in it.
9th Nov '16 10:09:59 AM TommyTiger
Is there an issue? Send a Message
9th Nov '16 1:26:17 AM DrZulu2010
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* Troper/DrZulu2010: I like WebVideo/CinematicExcrement and its reviews. But there is somethng about his Film/FantasticFour2015; mainly when he talks about the rather controversial RaceLift of Johnny Storm from white to black, he says that those who said that are Trump supporters. I hate Trump myself but that's not the point, the point is he generalised people into one group of people even if some of them has legitimate critisism about this change; like how he is black, yet Sue is white, how it goes against 60 years of continuity or if they wanted to have a black Fantastic Four member, why not Reed, Ben or, hell, why not both the Storm siblings. But nope! You don't like the black Johnny Storm, y'all Trump supporters. I'm not against political jokes but, like all jokes, they have to be well written and well executed, not used to soapbox your thoughts on the matter. Let's hope you're gonna take this to a minimum, Smeghead.
6th Nov '16 9:52:47 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** SenorCornholio: I ''have'' recently warmed up to this animation due to the voice clips being used in some of [[Machinima/Supermarioglitchy4sSuperMario64Bloopers SMG4's videos]], but that doesn't change the fact that overall, this video is heavily flawed in more ways than one. I could go on about the unfunny jokes, the nonsensical plot, etc, but what I think makes the whole thing fall apart: the premise. Mario goes insane and starts killing everyone because of all the third-party characters in the current race. Why does this not work? Well firstly, because there has never been a third-party character in a main Mario Kart title. The DLC characters for Mario Kart 8 were all from other Nintendo franchises, and therefore first-party. Secondly, the characters themselves; [[VideoGame/SegaSuperstars Sonic may have been playable in several Sega-themed sports and racing titles]], but the only time he crossed over with Nintendo itself was in VideoGame/SuperSmashBros. And even then, Knuckles wasn't even playable so that's out. It's like some of these franchises were listed all because of their racing titles, [[Franchise/StarWars Anakin]] and [[VideoGame/CrashBandicoot Crash's head]] also being standout examples. Thirdly, speaking of Sony, was there an alternate universe I'm not aware of where Sony and Nintendo crossed over and [[VideoGame/LittleBigPlanet Sackboy]] and [[VideoGame/GodOfWar Kratos]] were put into karts? I'll admit that Kratos driving a tiny kart is a funny sight, but what's the point? Ironically, there's one crossover that I doubt Flashgitz even knows he got right, and that's Pac-Man's head on a spear, since he was playable in the Arcade GP games developed by Namco-Bandai. Other than that, the rest of the references are shallow at best and make absolutely no sense at worst. Now if you'll excuse me, I'm gonna go watch [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynKRJt4CDMY the version where all the violence is replaced with The Nutshack]]. It's somehow way better.

to:

** SenorCornholio: I ''have'' have recently warmed up to this animation Racist Mario due to the voice clips being used in some of [[Machinima/Supermarioglitchy4sSuperMario64Bloopers SMG4's videos]], but that doesn't change the fact that overall, this video is heavily flawed in more ways than one. I could go on about the unfunny jokes, the nonsensical plot, etc, but what I think makes the whole thing fall apart: the premise. Mario goes insane and starts killing everyone because of all the third-party characters in the current race. Why does this not work? Well firstly, because there has never been a third-party character in a main Mario Kart title. The DLC characters for Mario Kart 8 were all from other Nintendo franchises, and therefore first-party. Secondly, the characters themselves; [[VideoGame/SegaSuperstars Sonic may have been playable in several Sega-themed sports and racing titles]], but the only time he crossed over with Nintendo itself was in VideoGame/SuperSmashBros. And even then, Knuckles wasn't even playable so that's out. It's like some of these franchises were listed all because of their racing titles, [[Franchise/StarWars Anakin]] and [[VideoGame/CrashBandicoot Crash's head]] also being standout examples. Thirdly, speaking of Sony, was there an alternate universe I'm not aware of where Sony and Nintendo crossed over and [[VideoGame/LittleBigPlanet Sackboy]] and [[VideoGame/GodOfWar Kratos]] were put into karts? I'll admit that Kratos driving a tiny kart is a funny sight, but what's the point? Ironically, there's one crossover that I doubt Flashgitz even knows he got right, and that's Pac-Man's head on a spear, since he was playable in the Arcade GP games developed by Namco-Bandai. Other than that, the rest of the references are shallow at best and make absolutely no sense at worst. Now if you'll excuse me, I'm gonna go watch [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynKRJt4CDMY the version where all the violence is replaced with The Nutshack]]. It's somehow way better.
6th Nov '16 9:52:17 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** SenorCornholio: I ''have'' recently warmed up to this animation due to the voice clips being used in some of [[Machinima/Supermarioglitchy4sSuperMario64Bloopers SMG4's videos]], but that doesn't change the fact that overall, this video is heavily flawed in more ways than one. I could go on about the unfunny jokes, the nonsensical plot, etc, but what I think makes the whole thing fall apart: the premise. Mario goes insane and starts killing everyone because of all the third-party characters in the current race. Why does this not work? Well firstly, because there has never been a third-party character in a main Mario Kart title. The DLC characters for Mario Kart 8 were all from other Nintendo franchises, and therefore first-party. Secondly, the characters themselves; [[VideoGame/SegaSuperstars Sonic may have been playable in several Sega-themed sports and racing titles]], but the only time he crossed over with Nintendo itself was in VideoGame/SuperSmashBros. And even then, Knuckles wasn't even playable so that's out. It's like some of these franchises were listed all because of their racing titles, [[Franchise/StarWars Anakin]] and [[VideoGame/CrashBandicoot Crash's head]] also being standout examples. Thirdly, speaking of Sony, was there an alternate universe I'm not aware of where Sony and Nintendo crossed over and [[VideoGame/LittleBigPlanet Sackboy]] and [[VideoGame/GodOfWar Kratos]] were put into karts? I'll admit that Kratos driving a tiny kart is a funny sight, but what's the point? Ironically, there's one crossover that I doubt Flashgitz even knows he got right, and that's Pac-Man's head on a spear, since he was playable in the Arcade GP games developed by Namco-Bandai. Other than that, the rest of the references are shallow at best and make absolutely no sense at worst. Now if you'll excuse me, I'm gonna go watch [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynKRJt4CDMY the version where all the violence is replaced with The Nutshack]]. It's somehow way better.
6th Nov '16 9:32:20 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice; even when RebelTaxi also just wants the franchise to die, he didn't put it at numero freaking uno. Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise. I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.

to:

** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice; even when RebelTaxi also just wants the franchise to die, he didn't put it at numero freaking uno. Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't. didn't; instead he goes through a long laundry list of "remakes" that aren't even listed in how bad they are. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise.franchise; also very easy to do as [[spoiler: Mystery Incorporated]] was included in the rundown. I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.
6th Nov '16 9:27:27 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice; even when RebelTaxi also just wants the franchise to die, he didn't put it at numero freaking uno. Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise. I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.

to:

** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing SonicUnderground WesternAnimation/SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice; even when RebelTaxi also just wants the franchise to die, he didn't put it at numero freaking uno. Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise. I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.
6th Nov '16 9:26:13 PM SenorCornholio
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtemeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice; even when RebelTaxi also just wants the franchise to die, he didn't put it at numero freaking uno. Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise. I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.

to:

** SenorCornholio: I second that, though I'm a little more critical on this video. I have more problems in mind, such as AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog WesternAnimation/AdventuresOfSonicTheHedgehog actually being considered a remake for this list (though I do appreciate him not blindly bashing SonicUnderground like most tend to do), and calling WesternAnimation/ExtemeGhostbusters WesternAnimation/ExtremeGhostbusters a remake when it's a continuation. Aside from that, most of the other entries were understandable, then the [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] entry comes up and my eyes light up in confusion for all the reasons listed above. Even as a person who also isn't the biggest fan of [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]], I can say this was a dumb choice; even when RebelTaxi also just wants the franchise to die, he didn't put it at numero freaking uno. Seriously, to put this over the likes of [[spoiler: TeenTitansGo]] and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] is mind-boggling to say the least, since [[spoiler: TTG]] at its worst actually goes out of its way to insult its own critics and [[spoiler: Yo Yogi]] was one of the most 90's-pandering shows of all time. Not even the [[DorkAge worst of]] [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo]] is that bad; at worst it gets stale and repetitive like he says, which would be a good reason to put at least some entries in the franchise on this list, but nowhere near #1. What's more is that he barely mentions most of them aside from the infamous terror of [[spoiler: Shaggy and Scooby-Doo Get a Clue]] and the divisive series that is [[spoiler: Be Cool, Scooby-Doo]] as if he hardly saw any of the other shows. I'd have appreciated it if he said "not all of these are bad, mind you, but the majority tend to be mediocre at best", but he didn't. So now, we have to assume that he blindly hates [[spoiler: the earlier direct to video movies]] and [[spoiler: Scooby-Doo: Mystery Incorporated]], which are considered silver linings in the franchise. I do like PhantomStrider's videos most of the time, but this was quite the big stinker for him. And I sincerely pray it does not occur again.
6th Nov '16 8:47:31 AM Sammettik
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* hydrix: I was and am still a fan of the ''WebVideo/{{Jimquisition}}'', but there is one moment in the episode "you're playing the game wrong" that I do not like. For the most part the episode is pretty good actually. He spends talking about the fact that it is realy stupid of a game creator to force you play the game like how he feels like it and it is pretty nice for the most part... until he starts countering the potential argument that the creators might have that is: "I put 4 or 5 years into this game. It's my baby.". To which he replied: "But like the mother of a down syndrome kid only you are finding it beautiful and you can't expect everyone else to applaud and clap because it can't put its fingers out of its asshole.". It's a massive CriticalResearchFailure to say the least, fortunately Jim has since distanced himself from his early videos like that one.

to:

* hydrix: I was and am still a fan of the ''WebVideo/{{Jimquisition}}'', but there is one moment in the episode "you're playing the game wrong" that I do not like. For the most part the episode is pretty good actually. He spends talking about the fact that it is realy really stupid of a game creator to force you play the game like how he feels like it and it is pretty nice for the most part... until he starts countering the potential argument that the creators might have that is: "I put 4 or 5 years into this game. It's my baby.". To which he replied: "But like the mother of a down syndrome kid only you are finding it beautiful and you can't expect everyone else to applaud and clap because it can't put its fingers out of its asshole.". It's a massive CriticalResearchFailure to say the least, fortunately Jim has since distanced himself from his early videos like that one.
6th Nov '16 8:44:09 AM Sammettik
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** shonengirl: The above two don't really bother me that much, since I know where he's coming from, except for the joke, but still it was just somewhat tasteless. However, his review of ''Anime/PokemonOrigins'' was just poorly made. Highlights include mistaking the year the first Pokemon games were released as 1995 (it's actually 1996, and to make this worse this was ''shown in a clip in the video itself'') and mistaking 2015 as its 20th anniversary (so this wasn't a script error either), questioning why Team Rocket needs scientists and wild Pokemon to create and test the Master Ball, and apparently not knowing who Red, one of the most well-known and well-loved characters in the fandom, to the point of being a MemeticBadass, is. The worst and most cringeworthy part, however, has to be him seeing ''Origins'' being TruerToTheText of the original games as a ''flaw'', and that it takes away the "charm" of the anime. Um... [[CompletelyMissingThePoint That's the point, bro]]. It's supposed to be a more faithful adaptation. Stop thinking about the main anime, that has almost nothing to do with ''Origins'', an adaptation of game canon, and the two should be kept as far, far away from eachother as possible. Anyone who is familiar with the Pokemon fandom will tell you that mixing up the games and anime is a major BerserkButton for many fans of the games, and it highly annoys me as well. You know why many fans of the games hate the anime? One of the reasons is that it deviates from the games so much like some obscure spinoff manga that never saw light outside of Japan, despite it being the face of the franchise to the general public. I don't hate the anime necessarily, but he's essentially saying it should have copied the style of the anime because... Togo berries and a vague "charm". Question, wouldn't that make ''Origins'' pointless? Also, people should just play the games to experience the story? I'm sorry... [[FlatWhat What]]. ...Excuse me, [[BigWhat WHAT?!]] Um, ok, then I guess every adaptation ever has no reason to exist! *facepalm* As if ''Origins'' doesn't have charm on its own. Hero, you obviously haven't been involved with the games in a long time, or at least are one of those extremely casual fans that still thinks the anime is the WordOfGod. I like your reviews usually, but please get gud, please.

to:

** shonengirl: The above two don't really bother me that much, since I know where he's coming from, except for the joke, but still it was just somewhat tasteless. However, his review of ''Anime/PokemonOrigins'' was just poorly made. Highlights include mistaking the year the first Pokemon games were released as 1995 (it's actually 1996, and to make this worse this was ''shown shown in a clip in the video itself'') itself) and mistaking 2015 as its 20th anniversary (so this wasn't a script error either), questioning why Team Rocket needs scientists and wild Pokemon to create and test the Master Ball, and apparently not knowing who Red, one of the most well-known and well-loved characters in the fandom, to the point of being a MemeticBadass, is. The worst and most cringeworthy part, however, has to be him seeing ''Origins'' being TruerToTheText of the original games as a ''flaw'', flaw, and that it takes away the "charm" of the anime. Um... [[CompletelyMissingThePoint That's the point, bro]]. It's supposed to be a more faithful adaptation. Stop thinking about the main anime, that has almost nothing to do with ''Origins'', an adaptation of game canon, and the two should be kept as far, far away from eachother as possible. Anyone who is familiar with the Pokemon fandom will tell you that mixing up the games and anime is a major BerserkButton for many fans of the games, and it highly annoys me as well. You know why many fans of the games hate the anime? One of the reasons is that it deviates from the games so much like some obscure spinoff manga that never saw light outside of Japan, despite it being the face of the franchise to the general public. I don't hate the anime necessarily, but he's essentially saying it should have copied the style of the anime because... Togo berries and a vague "charm". Question, wouldn't that make ''Origins'' pointless? Also, people should just play the games to experience the story? I'm sorry... [[FlatWhat What]]. ...Excuse me, [[BigWhat WHAT?!]] Um, ok, then I guess every adaptation ever has no reason to exist! *facepalm* As if ''Origins'' doesn't have charm on its own. Hero, you obviously haven't been involved with the games in a long time, or at least are one of those extremely casual fans that still thinks the anime is the WordOfGod. I like your reviews usually, but please get gud, please.



** Tropers/KiraDoom: I was already pretty offended by this just reading it. I hear people praising Markiplier all the time for being a good person, so this seems really [[OutOfCharacterMoment out of character]] of him. But then everything got ''worse''; a while after reading this, I learned that Satoshi Tajiri, the guy who created ''Pokemon'', is autistic. A lot of people who like ''Pokemon'', including myself, are autistic. A lot of aspects of the ''Pokemon'' franchise probably stem from the fact that Tajiri is autistic. So, by insulting both the ''Pokemon'' series and its fanbase... [[FridgeHorror Did Mark, unintentionally, mock a whole bunch of autistic people?]] Now granted, he did this ''unintentionally'' (or, at least, I ''hope'' it was unintentional), and I may be looking too far into this, but think about it! I couldn't possibly be the only one who sees this! Now, I'm sure Mark is usually nice, and I'm not saying he has to like ''Pokemon''; I'm just saying that he should think before he speaks before he goes offending people, autistic or otherwise.

to:

** Tropers/KiraDoom: I was already pretty offended by this just reading it. I hear people praising Markiplier all the time for being a good person, so this seems really [[OutOfCharacterMoment out of character]] of him. But then everything got ''worse''; a while after reading this, I learned that Satoshi Tajiri, the guy who created ''Pokemon'', is autistic. A lot of people who like ''Pokemon'', including myself, are autistic. A lot of aspects of the ''Pokemon'' franchise probably stem from the fact that Tajiri is autistic. So, by insulting both the ''Pokemon'' series and its fanbase... [[FridgeHorror Did Mark, unintentionally, mock a whole bunch of autistic people?]] Now granted, he did this ''unintentionally'' unintentionally (or, at least, I ''hope'' hope it was unintentional), and I may be looking too far into this, but think about it! I couldn't possibly be the only one who sees this! Now, I'm sure Mark is usually nice, and I'm not saying he has to like ''Pokemon''; I'm just saying that he should think before he speaks before he goes offending people, autistic or otherwise.



%% It's not a "precision" F strike if you're just using it because you're angry. We have no way of knowing you don't normally use that kind of language. --Midna



* GF93: Don't get me wrong, I think ''WebVideo/OneMinuteMelee'' is a very good series for the most part, but my personal DMOS has to go to ''"[[VideoGame/MegaManX Zero]] vs. [[Franchise/{{Kirby}} Meta Knight]]"''. It was a great idea for a fight for various reasons (The two not only both being [[HeroesPreferSwords sword-wielding]] mentors and friendly rivals to the main heroes of their respective franchises, but also being [[EnsembleDarkHorse very popular]] [[BadAss and Badass]] characters in their own right), so it'd be a great episode for either this series or a ''WebVideo/DeathBattle'', right? Sadly not. It was a massive disappointment in several respects, and just overall reeked of wasted potential. The fight itself was very pedestrian for the series' usual fast-paced and exciting standards, with neither character (Especially Meta Knight, who is limited to only his basic swordplay and not even allowed to use his ''VideoGame/SuperSmashBros'' moves or abilities despite using the same voice and appearance from there) really being able to do anything much considering their usual amount of powers and abilities that could have come into play, and the animation was nothing spectacular. Dishonorable mention however, has to go to the ending, for the sheer amount of CriticalResearchFailure and OutOfCharacter-ness abound from both characters. [[spoiler: Zero uses the [[ElementalPunch Rekkoha]] to summon lightning, Meta Knight ScreamsLikeALittleGirl (Despite him normally being TheStoic and never reacting to anything in such a way in his own series) and lets his guard down, allowing Zero to inflict a NoHoldsBarredBeatdown which ends with him [[ImpaledWithExtremePrejudice stabbing Meta Knight]] [[EyeScream through]] [[BodyHorror the]] [[FacialHorror face]] with his [[HotBlade superheated]] [[LaserBlade Z-Saber]], before [[HalfTheManHeUsedToBe slashing upward to bisect him vertically]], [[NauseaFuel with blood splattering across the ground from each of the two halves]]]]. Not only is it [[CruelAndUnusualDeath needlessly graphic]] [[NightmareFuel and brutal]] for a series whose fights don't normally end in death, but it goes [[{{OutOfCharacter}} completely against]] [[spoiler: [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold Zero's]] established character, who [[ThreeLawsCompliant outright refuses to kill sentient living beings]]. With that in mind, he could have easily [[BlastingItOutOfTheirHands knocked Meta Knight's sword out of his hand]] [[DefeatByModesty and then sliced his mask off]] from there, which would have been a nice CallBack to how he's defeated in the ''Kirby'' series]]. The worst part however, had to be [[spoiler: Zero's BondOneLiner afterward, quipping ''"Just like a training program"'' to the camera [[DissonantSerenity with a big smile]] [[SociopathicHero and a "^_^" expression on his face]] [[AdaptationalVillainy as if he didn't just commit brutal murder]], before just warping away without so much as a second thought about what he'd done. Again, [[KnightInSourArmor the]] [[TheAtoner canon]] [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold Zero]] would never do that.]] Thankfully, [[WinBackTheCrowd they did redeem themselves later on with the next episode]] (''[[Franchise/{{SuperMarioBros}} Bowser]] vs. [[Franchise/{{SonicTheHedgehog}} Doctor Eggman]]''), but even now, it just leaves a bitter taste with the disrespect shown to both characters. In closing- there's "No Research", and then there's just being inexcusably ignorant. At least with ''Hercule Satan vs. Dan Hibiki'' being redone as a ''Death Battle'', there could hopefully be the possibility of it happening with this match as well to properly do the two characters justice.

to:

* GF93: Don't get me wrong, I think ''WebVideo/OneMinuteMelee'' is a very good series for the most part, but my personal DMOS has to go to ''"[[VideoGame/MegaManX Zero]] vs. [[Franchise/{{Kirby}} Meta Knight]]"''. It was a great idea for a fight for various reasons (The two not only both being [[HeroesPreferSwords sword-wielding]] mentors and friendly rivals to the main heroes of their respective franchises, but also being [[EnsembleDarkHorse very popular]] [[BadAss and Badass]] characters in their own right), so it'd be a great episode for either this series or a ''WebVideo/DeathBattle'', right? Sadly not. It was a massive disappointment in several respects, and just overall reeked of wasted potential. The fight itself was very pedestrian for the series' usual fast-paced and exciting standards, with neither character (Especially Meta Knight, who is limited to only his basic swordplay and not even allowed to use his ''VideoGame/SuperSmashBros'' moves or abilities despite using the same voice and appearance from there) really being able to do anything much considering their usual amount of powers and abilities that could have come into play, and the animation was nothing spectacular. Dishonorable mention however, has to go to the ending, for the sheer amount of CriticalResearchFailure and OutOfCharacter-ness abound from both characters. [[spoiler: Zero uses the [[ElementalPunch Rekkoha]] to summon lightning, Meta Knight ScreamsLikeALittleGirl (Despite him normally being TheStoic and never reacting to anything in such a way in his own series) and lets his guard down, allowing Zero to inflict a NoHoldsBarredBeatdown which ends with him [[ImpaledWithExtremePrejudice stabbing Meta Knight]] [[EyeScream through]] [[BodyHorror the]] [[FacialHorror face]] with his [[HotBlade superheated]] [[LaserBlade Z-Saber]], before [[HalfTheManHeUsedToBe slashing upward to bisect him vertically]], [[NauseaFuel with blood splattering across the ground from each of the two halves]]]]. Not only is it [[CruelAndUnusualDeath needlessly graphic]] [[NightmareFuel and brutal]] for a series whose fights don't normally end in death, but it goes [[{{OutOfCharacter}} completely against]] [[spoiler: [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold Zero's]] established character, who [[ThreeLawsCompliant outright refuses to kill sentient living beings]]. With that in mind, he could have easily [[BlastingItOutOfTheirHands knocked Meta Knight's sword out of his hand]] [[DefeatByModesty and then sliced his mask off]] from there, which would have been a nice CallBack to how he's defeated in the ''Kirby'' series]]. The worst part however, had to be [[spoiler: Zero's BondOneLiner afterward, quipping ''"Just "Just like a training program"'' program" to the camera [[DissonantSerenity with a big smile]] [[SociopathicHero and a "^_^" expression on his face]] [[AdaptationalVillainy as if he didn't just commit brutal murder]], before just warping away without so much as a second thought about what he'd done. Again, [[KnightInSourArmor the]] [[TheAtoner canon]] [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold Zero]] would never do that.]] Thankfully, [[WinBackTheCrowd they did redeem themselves later on with the next episode]] (''[[Franchise/{{SuperMarioBros}} Bowser]] vs. [[Franchise/{{SonicTheHedgehog}} Doctor Eggman]]''), but even now, it just leaves a bitter taste with the disrespect shown to both characters. In closing- there's "No Research", and then there's just being inexcusably ignorant. At least with ''Hercule Satan vs. Dan Hibiki'' being redone as a ''Death Battle'', there could hopefully be the possibility of it happening with this match as well to properly do the two characters justice.



* Lord_Chespin: Now, let me make this clear: I do not hate Creepypastas. I admit that, since literally anybody can write them, there are tons of poorly-written ones out there, but there are some decent ones. However, ''Clockwork: Your Time is Up'' has burned me bad, and made me wary of Creepypastas in general. It's ostensibly about the [[DarkAndTroubledPast origin story]] of what could kindly be called a female Jeff the Killer ripoff, and the circumstances that led to her becoming a serial killer. Let's forget the fact that the story uses AbusiveParents and ''[[{{Squick}} incestuous child rape from her brother]]'' for nothing more than shock value and making her rampage justifiable. Let's forget the fact that [[DeusAngstMachina everything goes wrong]] [[DiabolusExMachina for our protagonist]] in an effort to drive her off the deep end, from the aforementioned abuse to bullying. [[RuleOfThree Let's forget]] [[WhatDoYouMeanItsNotSymbolic the shoehorned-in time imagery]]. [[LongList Let's forget]] the how the parents only take her to a therapist ''after'' she sews a smile into her face, and how [[AdultsAreUseless the therapist runs off as soon as Natalie, the protagonist, starts to show signs of insanity.]] [[RunningGag Let's forget]] the author's CriticalResearchFailure about how insane asylums work, ''especially'' the lack of a term of any kind of medication (the author has a doctor use the term ''"mental drugs"'' to describe the anti-psychotics!). [[OverlyLongGag Let's forget]] [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking the fact that the author's first name is the same as Natalie's, implying an]] AuthorAvatar. No, the ''real'' Dethroning Moment of Suck is when, empowered by the doctors [[PlayingWithSyringes sticking needles into her]], Natalie decides to murder her entire family (including her mother, [[DesignatedVillain who did nothing wrong and even tried to stop her abusive dad!]]). The murders are going to be spoilered for {{Squick}}, as they seem like something out of an [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons Itchy and Scratchy cartoon]], but here they are: [[spoiler:for her mother, Natalie slams her head into a coat hanger, causing her to become paralyzed, then cuts open her chest and ''rips out her still-beating heart until she bleeds to death''. The worst part is, [[FromBadToWorse this is the nicest death]]. For her father, the gives him a NoHoldsBarredBeatdown, then squashes him with a bedpost steamroller-style, ''causing him to vomit up all his organs''. Finally, for her brother, she pins him to the wall with her knives, [[EyeScream stabs his eye out with a butter knife]], ''[[{{Fingore}} rips off his toes and fingers,]]'' '''and force-feeds him one of his own fingers until he chokes to death.''' All of this is written in painstaking detail.]] This is presumably supposed to be their karmatic comeuppance, but it just reeks of DisproportionateRetribution- yes, ''even for the incestuous child rapist brother.'' [[RootingForTheEmpire When you begin to pity the incestuous child rapist, it should be a sign that the author's done something horribly, horribly wrong.]] [[AndThereWasMuchRejoicing To the sorrow of pretty much nobody]], the story seems to have been deleted from Wattpad, [[WebVideo/TheNostalgiaCritic but the evil will never truly go away.]]

to:

* Lord_Chespin: Now, let me make this clear: I do not hate Creepypastas. I admit that, since literally anybody can write them, there are tons of poorly-written ones out there, but there are some decent ones. However, ''Clockwork: Your Time is Up'' has burned me bad, and made me wary of Creepypastas in general. It's ostensibly about the [[DarkAndTroubledPast origin story]] of what could kindly be called a female Jeff the Killer ripoff, and the circumstances that led to her becoming a serial killer. Let's forget the fact that the story uses AbusiveParents and ''[[{{Squick}} incestuous child rape from her brother]]'' for nothing more than shock value and making her rampage justifiable. Let's forget the fact that [[DeusAngstMachina everything goes wrong]] [[DiabolusExMachina for our protagonist]] in an effort to drive her off the deep end, from the aforementioned abuse to bullying. [[RuleOfThree Let's forget]] [[WhatDoYouMeanItsNotSymbolic the shoehorned-in time imagery]]. [[LongList Let's forget]] the how the parents only take her to a therapist ''after'' after she sews a smile into her face, and how [[AdultsAreUseless the therapist runs off as soon as Natalie, the protagonist, starts to show signs of insanity.]] [[RunningGag Let's forget]] the author's CriticalResearchFailure about how insane asylums work, ''especially'' especially the lack of a term of any kind of medication (the author has a doctor use the term ''"mental drugs"'' to describe the anti-psychotics!). [[OverlyLongGag Let's forget]] [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking the fact that the author's first name is the same as Natalie's, implying an]] AuthorAvatar. No, the ''real'' real Dethroning Moment of Suck is when, empowered by the doctors [[PlayingWithSyringes sticking needles into her]], Natalie decides to murder her entire family (including her mother, [[DesignatedVillain who did nothing wrong and even tried to stop her abusive dad!]]). The murders are going to be spoilered for {{Squick}}, as they seem like something out of an [[WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons Itchy and Scratchy cartoon]], but here they are: [[spoiler:for her mother, Natalie slams her head into a coat hanger, causing her to become paralyzed, then cuts open her chest and ''rips rips out her still-beating heart until she bleeds to death''.death. The worst part is, [[FromBadToWorse this is the nicest death]]. For her father, the gives him a NoHoldsBarredBeatdown, then squashes him with a bedpost steamroller-style, ''causing him to vomit up all his organs''. Finally, for her brother, she pins him to the wall with her knives, [[EyeScream stabs his eye out with a butter knife]], ''[[{{Fingore}} [[{{Fingore}} rips off his toes and fingers,]]'' '''and fingers,]] and force-feeds him one of his own fingers until he chokes to death.''' death. All of this is written in painstaking detail.]] This is presumably supposed to be their karmatic comeuppance, but it just reeks of DisproportionateRetribution- yes, ''even for the incestuous child rapist brother.'' [[RootingForTheEmpire When you begin to pity the incestuous child rapist, it should be a sign that the author's done something horribly, horribly wrong.]] [[AndThereWasMuchRejoicing To the sorrow of pretty much nobody]], the story seems to have been deleted from Wattpad, [[WebVideo/TheNostalgiaCritic but the evil will never truly go away.]]



* Kablammin45: With all the April Fools Day jokes among games and game companies, there were bound to be a few stinkers. Case in point, [[http://infinityinquirer.com/2016/04/01/retailer-listing-leaks-disney-infinity-3-0-starter-pack-rebundle-gravity-falls-play-set/ this blog relating to]] ''VideoGame/DisneyInfinity'' which stated that the highly requested ''WesternAnimation/GravityFalls'' was getting a Play Set and figures for the game. Obviously it wasn't, and it would have been a very good prank had the poster not snuck an underhanded potshot at the ''Gravity Falls'' fanbase by claiming that WesternAnimation/DarkwingDuck was the only "real" candidate for inclusion in ''Infinity''. Don't get me wrong, I want Darkwing in as much as I want the Pine Twins, but, ugh. If he had just stopped there, the joke would have been pretty funny, but the fact that the poster went out of his way to laugh at the fanbase for believing the prank was real and rubbing his own choice in their faces was just needlessly rude. I almost ''want'' the ''Gravity Falls'' Play Set and figures to become a reality just to see this guy's name be mud. ''Almost...''

to:

* Kablammin45: With all the April Fools Day jokes among games and game companies, there were bound to be a few stinkers. Case in point, [[http://infinityinquirer.com/2016/04/01/retailer-listing-leaks-disney-infinity-3-0-starter-pack-rebundle-gravity-falls-play-set/ this blog relating to]] ''VideoGame/DisneyInfinity'' which stated that the highly requested ''WesternAnimation/GravityFalls'' was getting a Play Set and figures for the game. Obviously it wasn't, and it would have been a very good prank had the poster not snuck an underhanded potshot at the ''Gravity Falls'' fanbase by claiming that WesternAnimation/DarkwingDuck was the only "real" candidate for inclusion in ''Infinity''. Don't get me wrong, I want Darkwing in as much as I want the Pine Twins, but, ugh. If he had just stopped there, the joke would have been pretty funny, but the fact that the poster went out of his way to laugh at the fanbase for believing the prank was real and rubbing his own choice in their faces was just needlessly rude. I almost ''want'' want the ''Gravity Falls'' Play Set and figures to become a reality just to see this guy's name be mud. ''Almost...''



* Riley1sCool- I ''love'' RWBY. Oh, I'm sorry, what was that? [[spoiler: [[EnsembleDarkhorse Penny and Roman?]]]] Okay, [[spoiler: Penny's dead?]] That's screwed up. She was adorable, and the show just killed her for no real reason. [[spoiler: Pyrrha's traumatized?]] Okay, that I can deal with. Wait. What was that? What? [[spoiler: Roman got a PetTheDog moment? Oh, how... wait, and then he goes an RoaringRampageOfRevenge due to Neo's DisneyVillainDeath? Aweso-- and then he dies at the end of his epic speech? Well, at least he probably got a DyingMomentOfAwesome? No? EatenAlive by a griffin? A low-level Grimm? Despite just beating the lead? Unrealisti-- and then said griffin is immediately pwn'd by an entirely unarmed Ruby, despite him having just beaten her half to death? She just... regenerates? Well, we NeverFoundTheBody.]] Wait, what's that in the podcast? [[spoiler: He's KilledOffForReal? Even though he only took two hits? And henceforth has a nigh-full aura? Well, I can't respond to that. The show's trying to be DarkerAndEdgier, and missing it. Wait. I can respond. What the FUCK?!]]

to:

* Riley1sCool- I ''love'' love RWBY. Oh, I'm sorry, what was that? [[spoiler: [[EnsembleDarkhorse Penny and Roman?]]]] Okay, [[spoiler: Penny's dead?]] That's screwed up. She was adorable, and the show just killed her for no real reason. [[spoiler: Pyrrha's traumatized?]] Okay, that I can deal with. Wait. What was that? What? [[spoiler: Roman got a PetTheDog moment? Oh, how... wait, and then he goes an RoaringRampageOfRevenge due to Neo's DisneyVillainDeath? Aweso-- and then he dies at the end of his epic speech? Well, at least he probably got a DyingMomentOfAwesome? No? EatenAlive by a griffin? A low-level Grimm? Despite just beating the lead? Unrealisti-- and then said griffin is immediately pwn'd by an entirely unarmed Ruby, despite him having just beaten her half to death? She just... regenerates? Well, we NeverFoundTheBody.]] Wait, what's that in the podcast? [[spoiler: He's KilledOffForReal? Even though he only took two hits? And henceforth has a nigh-full aura? Well, I can't respond to that. The show's trying to be DarkerAndEdgier, and missing it. Wait. I can respond. What the FUCK?!]]fuck?!]]
4th Nov '16 7:26:50 PM shonengirl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** shonengirl: The above two don't really bother me that much, since I know where he's coming from, except for the joke, but still it was just somewhat tasteless. However, his review of ''Anime/PokemonOrigins'' was just poorly made. Highlights include mistaking the year the first Pokemon games were released as 1995 (it's actually 1996, and to make this worse this was ''shown in a clip in the video itself'') and mistaking 2015 as its 20th anniversary (so this wasn't a script error either), questioning why Team Rocket needs scientists and wild Pokemon to create and test the Master Ball, and apparently not knowing who Red, one of the most well-known and well-loved characters in the fandom, to the point of being a MemeticBadass, is. The worst and most cringeworthy part, however, has to be him seeing ''Origins'' being TruerToTheText of the original games as a ''flaw'', and that it takes away the "charm" of the anime. Um... [[CompletelyMissingThePoint That's the point, bro]]. It's supposed to be a more faithful adaptation. Stop thinking about the main anime, that has almost nothing to do with ''Origins'', and the two should be kept as far, far away from eachother much as possible. Anyone who is familiar with the Pokemon fandom will tell you that mixing game and anime canon is a major BerserkButton for many people, and it highly annoys me as well. You know why many game fans hate the anime? One of the reasons is that it deviates from the games so much it shouldn't even be called an adaptation, behaving like some obscure spinoff manga that never saw light outside of Japan despite it being the face of the franchise to the general public. Also, people should just play the games to experience the story? I'm sorry... [[FlatWhat What]]. ...Excuse me, [[BigWhat WHAT?!]] Um, ok, then I guess every adaptation ever has no reason to exist! *facepalm* As if ''Origins'' doesn't have charm on its own. Hero, you obviously aren't as major of a fan of the series as you claim, or at least are one of those that still thinks the anime is the WordOfGod. Hero, I like your reviews usually, but please get gud, please.

to:

** shonengirl: The above two don't really bother me that much, since I know where he's coming from, except for the joke, but still it was just somewhat tasteless. However, his review of ''Anime/PokemonOrigins'' was just poorly made. Highlights include mistaking the year the first Pokemon games were released as 1995 (it's actually 1996, and to make this worse this was ''shown in a clip in the video itself'') and mistaking 2015 as its 20th anniversary (so this wasn't a script error either), questioning why Team Rocket needs scientists and wild Pokemon to create and test the Master Ball, and apparently not knowing who Red, one of the most well-known and well-loved characters in the fandom, to the point of being a MemeticBadass, is. The worst and most cringeworthy part, however, has to be him seeing ''Origins'' being TruerToTheText of the original games as a ''flaw'', and that it takes away the "charm" of the anime. Um... [[CompletelyMissingThePoint That's the point, bro]]. It's supposed to be a more faithful adaptation. Stop thinking about the main anime, that has almost nothing to do with ''Origins'', an adaptation of game canon, and the two should be kept as far, far away from eachother much as possible. Anyone who is familiar with the Pokemon fandom will tell you that mixing game up the games and anime canon is a major BerserkButton for many people, fans of the games, and it highly annoys me as well. You know why many game fans of the games hate the anime? One of the reasons is that it deviates from the games so much it shouldn't even be called an adaptation, behaving like some obscure spinoff manga that never saw light outside of Japan Japan, despite it being the face of the franchise to the general public. I don't hate the anime necessarily, but he's essentially saying it should have copied the style of the anime because... Togo berries and a vague "charm". Question, wouldn't that make ''Origins'' pointless? Also, people should just play the games to experience the story? I'm sorry... [[FlatWhat What]]. ...Excuse me, [[BigWhat WHAT?!]] Um, ok, then I guess every adaptation ever has no reason to exist! *facepalm* As if ''Origins'' doesn't have charm on its own. Hero, you obviously aren't as major of a fan of haven't been involved with the series as you claim, games in a long time, or at least are one of those extremely casual fans that still thinks the anime is the WordOfGod. Hero, I like your reviews usually, but please get gud, please.
4th Nov '16 7:15:23 PM shonengirl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** shonengirl: The above two don't really bother me that much, since I know where he's coming from, except for the joke, but still it was just somewhat tasteless. However, his review of ''Anime/PokemonOrigins'' was just poorly made. Highlights include mistaking the year Pokemon was first released as 1995 and mistaking 2015 as its 20th anniversary, questing why Team Rocket needs scientists and wild Pokemon to create and test the Master Ball, and apparently not knowing who Red, one of the most well-known and well-loved characters in the series, to the point of being a MemeticBadass, is. The worst and most cringeworthy part, however, has to be him seeing ''Origins'' being a TruerToTheText of the original games as a ''flaw'', and that it takes away the "charm" of the anime. Um... That's the point, bro. It's supposed to be a more faithful adaptation. Stop thinking about the main anime, that has almost nothing to do with ''Origins'', and the two should be kept as far, far away from eachother much as possible. Anyone who is familiar with the Pokemon fandom will tell you that mixing game and anime canon is a major BeserkButton for many people, and it highly annoys me as well. Also, people should just play the games to experience the story? I'm sorry... [[FlatWhat What]]. ...Excuse me, [[BigWhat WHAT?!]] Um, ok, then I guess every adaptation ever has no reason to exist! *facepalm* As if ''Origins'' doesn't have a charm on its own. Hero, you obviously aren't as major of a fan of the series as you claim, or at least are one of those that still thinks the anime is the WordOfGod. Please get gud, please.

to:

** shonengirl: The above two don't really bother me that much, since I know where he's coming from, except for the joke, but still it was just somewhat tasteless. However, his review of ''Anime/PokemonOrigins'' was just poorly made. Highlights include mistaking the year the first Pokemon was first games were released as 1995 (it's actually 1996, and to make this worse this was ''shown in a clip in the video itself'') and mistaking 2015 as its 20th anniversary, questing anniversary (so this wasn't a script error either), questioning why Team Rocket needs scientists and wild Pokemon to create and test the Master Ball, and apparently not knowing who Red, one of the most well-known and well-loved characters in the series, fandom, to the point of being a MemeticBadass, is. The worst and most cringeworthy part, however, has to be him seeing ''Origins'' being a TruerToTheText of the original games as a ''flaw'', and that it takes away the "charm" of the anime. Um... [[CompletelyMissingThePoint That's the point, bro.bro]]. It's supposed to be a more faithful adaptation. Stop thinking about the main anime, that has almost nothing to do with ''Origins'', and the two should be kept as far, far away from eachother much as possible. Anyone who is familiar with the Pokemon fandom will tell you that mixing game and anime canon is a major BeserkButton BerserkButton for many people, and it highly annoys me as well.well. You know why many game fans hate the anime? One of the reasons is that it deviates from the games so much it shouldn't even be called an adaptation, behaving like some obscure spinoff manga that never saw light outside of Japan despite it being the face of the franchise to the general public. Also, people should just play the games to experience the story? I'm sorry... [[FlatWhat What]]. ...Excuse me, [[BigWhat WHAT?!]] Um, ok, then I guess every adaptation ever has no reason to exist! *facepalm* As if ''Origins'' doesn't have a charm on its own. Hero, you obviously aren't as major of a fan of the series as you claim, or at least are one of those that still thinks the anime is the WordOfGod. Please Hero, I like your reviews usually, but please get gud, please.
4th Nov '16 7:03:14 PM shonengirl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** shonengirl: I actually liked James when I knew only his Sonic vs. MLP videos, but even then they made me roll my eyes at the crude jokes right out of a bad adult cartoon that popped up here and there, and this is the reason I disliked "Amy Rose vs. Pinky Pie". I mean, at least in "Sonic vs. Rainbow Dash" they were mostly quick and fast-paced, and it was action-packed enough to at least make it enjoyable. I would have put the Splatoon vs. de Blob video on here, as it was where I realized that this guy can put out pure crude, cringeworthy material made of nothing but crude, cringeworthy material. But then I found out/was reminded that he did a Pokemon video. You see, I heavily look down on fan animation (the western ones anyway), especially shorts, because 99% of it is just bad attempts at shock humor attached to a well-loved family-friendly franchise, because, well, they're "edge" or something; I.e. What I like to call "Racist Mario syndrome", or otherwise echo whiny complaints, use "jokes" that have been done to death (though this is connected heavily to Racist Mario syndrome) put everyone [[CharacterDerailment through the character grinder and back again multiple times]] and/or [[KafkaComedy needlessly cruel torment]] because "comedy". Even if a short actually seems to be going fine, it will always have to end on an obligatory stupid gory/gross/"adult" meanspirited joke, I groan, [[FacePalm Palm meets forehead]]. Again. Occasionally I'll see a genuinely funny or even heartwarming animation with clearly much heart put into it, to my pleasant surprise, but if it's a 2D short that's, ironically enough, colored in and fully animated with fully "original" content (as opposed to a series of LimitedAnimation sketches, those with an audio source, or comic dubs), there's a big chance it's going to be bad, though despite the reputations of their fanbases My Little Pony and Undertale seem to be exceptions to this (only relatively speaking however). Three common victims of "Were so edgey!1!!" I know of are Mario, Sonic, and Pokemon; and look, the guy who made a blob jizz over 14-year-olds did an animation on the latter! [[SarcasmMode Oh joy!]] And look, it features a cute little mouse tortured painfully and nothing else! Fun! At least he actually uses Red instead of Ash, showing that he isn't yet another person who knows nothing about Pokemon that just made a "parody" anyway, though that might make it just worse. Since it shows he should actually give a [[PrecisionFStrike shit]] about what he's doing. But nope, it's yet another video in the giant mass of "Durr hurr, look, we took an innocent thing and filled it with gore, sex, gross-out, and [[BreadEggsBreadedEggs sexed-up gross-out gore!]] We're so edgy lol" taking up a good part of western web animation. You know what, I haven't seen this video. I may have seen the thumbnail for it before, but I was wise enough not to click on it despite Red's cute, innocent-looking face. But the moment I hear "Pokemon parody" I know something has a good chance of being horrible, and the description above confirms my suspicions, if not being even worse than I expected. Well, I guess the idea is kind of original, but at its core it's one of way too many cliche, uninspired western "fan" animations. It's times like this I really appreciate what ''Robot Chicken'' did when they parodied Pokemon, showing the inside of a Pokeball as a paradise, despite the crude humor. I have a strong stomach, and poorly-done "adult" gags just make me roll my eyes, so anything meant to be "shocking" is just tedious and boring to me. Guess what animators, you're not doing anything new. It's not even shocking anymore, it's just annoying and irritating, it's not funny, and worst of all, it's cliche, overdone, lazy, and '''boring'''! Stop already!

to:

** shonengirl: I actually liked James when I knew only his Sonic vs. MLP videos, but even then they made me roll my eyes at the crude jokes right out of a bad adult cartoon that popped up here and there, and this is the reason I disliked "Amy Rose vs. Pinky Pie". I mean, at least in "Sonic vs. Rainbow Dash" they were mostly quick and fast-paced, and it was action-packed enough to at least make it enjoyable. I would have put the Splatoon vs. de Blob video on here, as it was where I realized that this guy can put out pure crude, cringeworthy material made of nothing but crude, cringeworthy material. But then I found out/was reminded that he did a Pokemon video. You see, I heavily look down on fan animation (the western ones anyway), especially shorts, because 99% of it is just bad attempts at shock humor attached to a well-loved family-friendly franchise, because, well, they're "edge" "edgy" or something; I.e. What I like to call "Racist Mario syndrome", or otherwise echo whiny complaints, use "jokes" that have been done to death (though this is connected heavily to Racist Mario syndrome) put everyone [[CharacterDerailment through the character grinder and back again multiple times]] and/or [[KafkaComedy needlessly cruel torment]] because "comedy". Even if a short actually seems to be going fine, it will always have to end on an obligatory stupid gory/gross/"adult" meanspirited joke, I groan, [[FacePalm Palm meets forehead]]. Again. Occasionally I'll see a genuinely funny or even heartwarming animation with clearly much heart put into it, to my pleasant surprise, but if it's a 2D short that's, ironically enough, colored in and fully animated by a big channel with fully "original" content (as opposed to a series of LimitedAnimation sketches, those with an audio source, or comic dubs), there's a big chance it's going to be bad, though despite the reputations of their fanbases My Little Pony and Undertale seem to be exceptions to this (only relatively speaking however). Three common victims of "Were so edgey!1!!" I know of are Mario, Sonic, and Pokemon; and look, the guy who made a blob jizz over 14-year-olds did an animation on the latter! [[SarcasmMode Oh joy!]] And look, it features a cute little mouse tortured painfully and nothing else! Fun! At least he actually uses Red instead of Ash, showing that he isn't yet another person who knows nothing about Pokemon that just made a "parody" anyway, though that might make it just worse. Since it shows he should actually give a [[PrecisionFStrike shit]] about what he's doing. But nope, it's yet another video in the giant mass of "Durr hurr, look, we took an innocent thing and filled it with gore, sex, gross-out, and [[BreadEggsBreadedEggs sexed-up gross-out gore!]] We're so edgy lol" taking up a good part of western web animation. You know what, I haven't seen this video. I may have seen the thumbnail for it before, but I was wise enough not to click on it despite Red's cute, innocent-looking face. But the moment I hear "Pokemon parody" I know something has a good chance of being horrible, and the description above confirms my suspicions, if not being even worse than I expected. Well, I guess the idea is kind of original, but it makes no sense and at its core it's one of way too many cliche, uninspired western "fan" animations. It's times like this I really appreciate what ''Robot Chicken'' did when they parodied Pokemon, showing the inside of a Pokeball as a paradise, despite the crude humor. I have a strong stomach, and poorly-done "adult" gags just make me roll my eyes, so anything meant to be "shocking" is just tedious and boring to me. Guess what animators, you're not doing anything new. It's not even shocking anymore, it's just annoying and irritating, it's not funny, and worst of all, it's cliche, overdone, lazy, and '''boring'''! Stop already!



** shonengirl: Third. This is hands down, the worst thing in the history of his channel. Two things I [[BerserkButton absolutely hate]] are when reviewers seem to know little about what they're talking about, and when they lump things of varying quality into one mass and declare them all bad/judge them all solely on the quality of some of them or an unfortunate DorkAge. Basically, I despise CriticalResearchFailure... And him putting every single [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] reboot on that list just screamed both of these things. Okay Strider, what about the Tom and Jerry, Ninja Turtles, anything Mickey Mouse related, and Looney Toons reboots, are ''they'' bad too because their franchises have been around for a long time and have truckloads of reboots? No? Actually, what ''about'' Tom and Jerry? It's also a Hanna-Barbera franchise that has been around forever, if not even longer than [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]], but he conveniently forgets that, doesn't he? There are many LongRunners that continue to be loved to this day, so by this logic they're all bad simply because they've been around to see the civil rights movement... [[SarcasmMode Sure, Strider, sure]]. [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] was actually pretty solid and had deviated quite a bit from the normal episodic format, not to mention the series fills in a western animation niche that doesn't get filled often in the modern day, the genre of mystery. The only other modern cartoon in this genre I can think of is Gravity Falls, which ended, while [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] will continue filling this niche with a fresh new take every time. Oh yeah, what about counting movies as reboots? ...Huh?! I've disagreed with him before, sure, but respected his opinion because he's a genuinely nice person, and is so reasonable even in his negative lists; this was the only time I ever cringed at this guy's content ever. I'm not even a huge fan of [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]], but this was just ''bad''. It just really reminds me of those people who think Pokémon is a series consisting of the same game released over and over again, or whining that Nintendo has no innovation despite many of their franchises evolving over the years. To make it worse, I criticised him for this, and if I didn't accidentally delete it, he apparently removed my comment. Come on, Strider, I expect more from you! Oh yeah, and [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking how the hell is Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog a reboot?! Shouldn't video game adaptations have a list of their own?]]

to:

** shonengirl: Third. This is hands down, the worst thing in the history of his channel. Two things I [[BerserkButton absolutely hate]] are when reviewers seem to know little about what they're talking about, and when they lump things of varying quality into one mass and declare them all bad/judge them all solely on the quality of some of them or an unfortunate DorkAge. Basically, I despise CriticalResearchFailure... And him putting every single [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] reboot on that list just screamed both of these things. Okay Strider, what about the Tom and Jerry, Ninja Turtles, anything Mickey Mouse related, and Looney Toons reboots, are ''they'' bad too because their franchises have been around for a long time and have truckloads of reboots? No? Actually, what ''about'' Tom and Jerry? It's also a Hanna-Barbera franchise that has been around forever, if not even longer than [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]], but he conveniently forgets that, doesn't he? There are many LongRunners that continue to be loved to this day, so by this logic they're all bad simply because they've been around to see the civil rights movement... [[SarcasmMode Sure, Strider, sure]]. [[spoiler:Mystery Incorporated]] was actually pretty solid and had deviated quite a bit from the normal episodic format, not to mention the series fills in a western animation niche that doesn't get filled often in the modern day, the genre of mystery. The only other modern cartoon in this genre I can think of is Gravity Falls, which ended, while [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]] will continue filling this niche with a fresh new take every time. Oh yeah, what about counting movies as reboots? ...Huh?! I've disagreed with him before, sure, but respected his opinion because he's a genuinely nice person, person and is so reasonable even in his negative lists; entertaining on top of it; this was the only time I ever cringed at this guy's content ever. I'm not even a huge fan of [[spoiler:Scooby-Doo]], but this was just ''bad''. It just really reminds me of those people who think Pokémon is a series consisting of the same game released over and over again, or whining that Nintendo has no innovation despite many of their franchises evolving over the years. To make it worse, I criticised him for this, and if I didn't accidentally delete it, he apparently removed my comment. Come on, Strider, I expect more from you! Oh yeah, and [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking how the hell is Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog a reboot?! Shouldn't video game adaptations have a list of their own?]]



* Troper/{{cookieman}}: We have Nyan Cat as fanart, crossovers (with such series at ''MarioKart'', ''RobotUnicornAttack'', and shirts and such). However, when you start to crossover something with [[http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=250305521674671&set=a.192924910746066.42399.132945776743980&type=1&theater 9/11]], then you know there's something wrong. (View at your own risk)

to:

* Troper/{{cookieman}}: We have Nyan Cat as fanart, crossovers (with such series at as ''MarioKart'', ''RobotUnicornAttack'', and shirts and such). However, when you start to crossover something with [[http://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=250305521674671&set=a.192924910746066.42399.132945776743980&type=1&theater 9/11]], then you know there's something wrong. (View at your own risk)


Added DiffLines:

** shonengirl: The above two don't really bother me that much, since I know where he's coming from, except for the joke, but still it was just somewhat tasteless. However, his review of ''Anime/PokemonOrigins'' was just poorly made. Highlights include mistaking the year Pokemon was first released as 1995 and mistaking 2015 as its 20th anniversary, questing why Team Rocket needs scientists and wild Pokemon to create and test the Master Ball, and apparently not knowing who Red, one of the most well-known and well-loved characters in the series, to the point of being a MemeticBadass, is. The worst and most cringeworthy part, however, has to be him seeing ''Origins'' being a TruerToTheText of the original games as a ''flaw'', and that it takes away the "charm" of the anime. Um... That's the point, bro. It's supposed to be a more faithful adaptation. Stop thinking about the main anime, that has almost nothing to do with ''Origins'', and the two should be kept as far, far away from eachother much as possible. Anyone who is familiar with the Pokemon fandom will tell you that mixing game and anime canon is a major BeserkButton for many people, and it highly annoys me as well. Also, people should just play the games to experience the story? I'm sorry... [[FlatWhat What]]. ...Excuse me, [[BigWhat WHAT?!]] Um, ok, then I guess every adaptation ever has no reason to exist! *facepalm* As if ''Origins'' doesn't have a charm on its own. Hero, you obviously aren't as major of a fan of the series as you claim, or at least are one of those that still thinks the anime is the WordOfGod. Please get gud, please.
3rd Nov '16 10:09:47 PM Sammettik
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Tropers/MathsAngelicVersion: His disrespect for the woman makes me sick. PTSD is a debilitating disorder, and the episodes of reliving the event are very painful. Yet he deliberately invokes one, all while saying he doesn't believe her and that if she's indeed telling the truth, she deserved it ([[DisproportionateRetribution presumably as punishment for being someone he disagrees with]]). Basically, three of the last things a rape victim needs. It's not hard to Google and find out that and why these things shouldn't be done, and it's easy to find sources that confirm that rape victims' pain is very real! Because of this moment, and this moment alone, I won't ever watch another of his videos, and am now ashamed to say that I've done it in the past and liked it. Seriously, fuck this guy. %%I'm normally a Gosh Dang It to Heck type, hence the use of Precision F Strike.
%%It doesn't really matter, since we have know way of knowing that about you otherwise. --Midna

to:

* Tropers/MathsAngelicVersion: His disrespect for the woman makes me sick. PTSD is a debilitating disorder, and the episodes of reliving the event are very painful. Yet he deliberately invokes one, all while saying he doesn't believe her and that if she's indeed telling the truth, she deserved it ([[DisproportionateRetribution presumably as punishment for being someone he disagrees with]]). Basically, three of the last things a rape victim needs. It's not hard to Google and find out that and why these things shouldn't be done, and it's easy to find sources that confirm that rape victims' pain is very real! Because of this moment, and this moment alone, I won't ever watch another of his videos, and am now ashamed to say that I've done it in the past and liked it. Seriously, fuck this guy. %%I'm normally a Gosh Dang It to Heck type, hence the use of Precision F Strike.\n%%It doesn't really matter, since we have know way of knowing that about you otherwise. --Midna
3rd Nov '16 10:09:01 PM Sammettik
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Kira Doom: Not only do I strongly agree here, but I want to point something out here that really bothers me about the whole thing: the super obvious DoubleStandard here. Yeah, the Go!Titans are [[DesignatedHero Designated Heroes]], but the Titans in James' video straight-up ''[[MoralEventHorizon murdered]]'' [[MoralEventHorizon a bunch of mentally handicapped people]]! [[EveryoneHasStandards Not even the Go!Titans would stoop that low!]] But apparently it's okay for the [=AnimatedJames=]!Titans to slaughter people like this because [[DisproportionateRetribution they made]] [[FelonyMisdemeanor a bad reboot]]. [[SarcasmMode Because that's]] ''[[SarcasmMode totally]]'' [[SarcasmMode a reasonable and sane reaction!]] I used to be okay ''Teen Titans Go!'', but even though I don't like it anymore, I would never forgive the blatant [[{{Hypocrite}} hypocrisy]] in his criticism (which was already overly scathing and gruesome to start with). So yeah, because of this (and the other Dethroning Moments here that I also agree with), I'm never watching this guy again.

to:

** Kira Doom: Not only do I strongly agree here, but I want to point something out here that really bothers me about the whole thing: the super obvious DoubleStandard here. Yeah, the Go!Titans are [[DesignatedHero Designated Heroes]], but the Titan