History Anime / PuellaMagiMadokaMagicaTheMovieRebellion

23rd Apr '17 7:08:37 PM JRads47
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* ATeamFiring: [[spoiler:The shootout between Mami and Homura has neither of the girls hitting each other.]] Justified because [[spoiler:[[ShootTheBullets their bullets kept hitting each other]]]]

to:

* ATeamFiring: [[spoiler:The shootout between Mami and Homura has neither of the girls hitting each other.]] Justified because [[spoiler:[[ShootTheBullets [[spoiler:[[ShootTheBullet their bullets kept hitting each other]]]]other]]]].
23rd Apr '17 7:07:17 PM JRads47
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* ATeamFiring: [[spoiler:The shootout between Mami and Homura has neither of the girls hitting each other.]]

to:

* ATeamFiring: [[spoiler:The shootout between Mami and Homura has neither of the girls hitting each other.]]]] Justified because [[spoiler:[[ShootTheBullets their bullets kept hitting each other]]]]


Added DiffLines:

* EvasiveFightThreadEpisode: The fight between [[spoiler:[[TheGunslinger Homura and Mami]]]] ends with the latter revealing that [[spoiler:[[ActuallyADoombot she actually wasn't fighting]]]], and [[spoiler:Sayaka]] whisking away the former before the fight can continue.
17th Apr '17 3:05:09 PM N.Harmonik
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* BlueWithShock: Homura actually does this when Bebe approaches her in her worm form at the beginning of the Cake Song.
17th Apr '17 2:55:41 PM N.Harmonik
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* RuleOfThree
-->'''Homura:''' "There are three people in this world who don't belong in it. The first one is the [[spoiler:witch who made the labyrinth]]. The second one is [[spoiler:Bebe]], who looks just like [[spoiler:a witch]]. And the third one... is you, who remembers the [[spoiler:witches]]. Who are you? Are you really [[spoiler:Sayaka Miki]]?"

to:

* RuleOfThree
RuleOfThree:
-->'''Homura:''' "There are three people in this world who don't belong in it. The first one is the [[spoiler:witch who made the labyrinth]]. The second one is [[spoiler:Bebe]], who looks just like [[spoiler:a witch]]. And the third one... is you, who remembers the [[spoiler:witches]]. Who are you? Are you really [[spoiler:Sayaka Miki]]?"
17th Apr '17 2:54:14 PM N.Harmonik
Is there an issue? Send a Message


-->'''Homura:''' "There are three people here that should not exist. The first is the [[spoiler:witch who created this labyrinth]]. The second is [[spoiler:Bebe]], who remains in the form [[spoiler:of a witch]]. And the third, you, who remembers the [[spoiler:existence of witches]]. Who are you? Are you really [[spoiler:Sayaka Miki]]?"

to:

-->'''Homura:''' "There are three people here that should not exist. in this world who don't belong in it. The first one is the [[spoiler:witch who created this made the labyrinth]]. The second one is [[spoiler:Bebe]], who remains in the form [[spoiler:of a looks just like [[spoiler:a witch]]. And the third, third one... is you, who remembers the [[spoiler:existence of witches]].[[spoiler:witches]]. Who are you? Are you really [[spoiler:Sayaka Miki]]?"



* SekaikeiGenre: [[spoiler: Reality itself is rewritten several times as a result of Madoka and Homura's relationship.]]

to:

* SekaikeiGenre: [[spoiler: Reality [[spoiler:Reality itself is rewritten several times as a result of Madoka and Homura's relationship.]]



* TookALevelInBadass

to:

* TookALevelInBadassTookALevelInBadass:



** There are also some elements that are implied but not explicitly stated. For example, if the viewer doesn't realize that [[spoiler: [[NotSoOmniscientAfterAll Kyubey's isolation field is implicitly blocking Madoka's omniscience]]]], or that [[spoiler:Madoka is trusting Homura to join her in heaven happily]], it creates the perception of a PlotHole.

to:

** There are also some elements that are implied but not explicitly stated. For example, if the viewer doesn't realize that [[spoiler: [[NotSoOmniscientAfterAll [[spoiler:[[NotSoOmniscientAfterAll Kyubey's isolation field is implicitly blocking Madoka's omniscience]]]], or that [[spoiler:Madoka is trusting Homura to join her in heaven happily]], it creates the perception of a PlotHole.
17th Apr '17 2:48:34 PM N.Harmonik
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Kyubey's line from episode 6, "I just don't get it," became one of the common responses in Japan to all the NonSequitur Madoka [[{{Parody}} parodies]]. Here it is [[spoiler:[[SpeakInUnison spoken in unison]] by countless Incubators as they are [[RainOfArrows shot by Madoka and Homura]].]]

to:

** Kyubey's line from the Japanese version of episode 6, "I just don't get it," became one of the common responses in Japan to all the NonSequitur Madoka [[{{Parody}} parodies]]. Here Here, it is [[spoiler:[[SpeakInUnison spoken in unison]] by countless Incubators as they are [[RainOfArrows shot by Madoka and Homura]].]]



* ATeamFiring: [[spoiler: The shootout between Mami and Homura has neither of the girls hitting each other.]]

to:

* ATeamFiring: [[spoiler: The [[spoiler:The shootout between Mami and Homura has neither of the girls hitting each other.]]



*** Later on [[spoiler: when the fake Mitakihara blows up]] there are voices saying "[[http://personal.bgsu.edu/~dcallen/Fort-Da.html Fort! Da!]]", which is a reference to a story by UsefulNotes/SigmundFreud about a boy who made a game of hiding away his toys, Fort meaning "gone" in German, and "Da" meaning there.

to:

*** Later on [[spoiler: when [[spoiler:when the fake Mitakihara blows up]] there are voices saying "[[http://personal.bgsu.edu/~dcallen/Fort-Da.html Fort! Da!]]", which is a reference to a story by UsefulNotes/SigmundFreud about a boy who made a game of hiding away his toys, Fort meaning "gone" in German, and "Da" meaning there.



** At the end, [[spoiler: Sayaka's "I'll never forget" echoes the final line of Homura herself from the original series.]]

to:

** At the end, [[spoiler: Sayaka's "I'll never [[spoiler:Sayaka's "I won't forget" echoes the final line of Homura herself from the original series.]]



* CanonImmigrant: [[spoiler:Homulilly]] from ''VideoGame/PuellaMagiMadokaMagicaPortable''. She got a complete redesign and a suitable expansion for the movie. [[spoiler: Also she's now the "Nutcracker Witch" instead of the "Witch of the Mortal World"... though the latter still fits the events of the movie.]]

to:

* CanonImmigrant: [[spoiler:Homulilly]] from ''VideoGame/PuellaMagiMadokaMagicaPortable''. She got a complete redesign and a suitable expansion for the movie. [[spoiler: Also [[spoiler:Also, she's now the "Nutcracker Witch" instead of the "Witch of the Mortal World"... though the latter still fits the events of the movie.]]



* TheDayTheMusicLied: [[spoiler:Homura is saved from being damned by the Law of Cycles forever]], [[spoiler:Ultimate Madoka descends with her heralds Sayaka and Nagisa]], and an arrange of the calm and beautiful [[spoiler:Sagitta Luminis]] plays... then the music stops, followed by [[spoiler:the love-corrupted Homura usurping and kidnapping Ultimate Madoka, and rewriting the entire universe.]]

to:

* TheDayTheMusicLied: [[spoiler:Homura is saved from being damned by the Law of Cycles forever]], [[spoiler:Ultimate forever, Ultimate Madoka descends with her heralds Sayaka and Nagisa]], and an arrange arrangement of the calm and beautiful [[spoiler:Sagitta Luminis]] plays... then the music stops, followed by [[spoiler:the love-corrupted Homura usurping and kidnapping Ultimate Madoka, and rewriting the entire universe.]]



-->''(to Kyubey)'' [[spoiler: "Huh. I had no idea ''you'' could talk."]]

to:

-->''(to Kyubey)'' [[spoiler: "Huh.[[spoiler:"Huh. I had no idea ''you'' could talk."]]



* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: An early scene has Sayaka getting annoyed at Kyoko because "We offered to help you with it when we got home. It's your own fault for bailing to go watch TV!" They're talking about homework, apparently.

to:

* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: An early scene has Sayaka getting annoyed at Kyoko because "We "I offered to help you with it when we got home. It's your own fault for bailing to go watch TV!" They're talking about homework, apparently.



* EarnYourHappyEnding: Homura, after being put through so much hell, ''finally'' gets to save Madoka. Heck, even the other characters get in on it: [[spoiler: the movie ends with every single character alive, well and happy, including Nagisa, and Kyubey getting a long-overdue dose of LaserGuidedKarma. Of course, considering [[WellIntentionedExtremist the methods]] Homura used to earn said happy ending, ie breaking Madoka off from the Law of Cycles and erasing everyone's memories without their go-ahead, whether the cost was worth it or not is an argument for the ages.]]

to:

* EarnYourHappyEnding: Homura, after being put through so much hell, ''finally'' gets to save Madoka. Heck, even the other characters get in on it: [[spoiler: the [[spoiler:the movie ends with every single character alive, well and happy, including Nagisa, and Kyubey getting a long-overdue dose of LaserGuidedKarma. Of course, considering [[WellIntentionedExtremist the methods]] Homura used to earn said happy ending, ie breaking Madoka off from the Law of Cycles and erasing everyone's memories without their go-ahead, whether the cost was worth it or not is an argument for the ages.]]



* EldritchAbomination: Judging from [[spoiler: Homura]]'s BreakingSpeech towards Kyubey, either the "magic" they unleashed into the world or indeed human emotions themselves seem to be this.
** HumansAreCthulhu: Implied in the anime, with Kyubey claiming that [[HumanityIsInsane human emotion is mental disorder]], and yet his kind manipulates magic that came from emotion, because the magic disobeys the thermodynamic law, which is illogical for the rationalization they can comprehend. In this movie, not only the do the girls that he seeks to manipulate fight back with sheer force of will and emotion [[spoiler:to the point of betraying their karmic destiny of FateWorseThanDeath in [[FaustianRebellion their]] [[AscendToAHigherPlaneOfExistence own]] [[DrivenToSuicide way]], one of them uses ThePowerOfLove ''so hard'' she remakes the reality with the entire Incubator race as her slaves with no way to get out of the situation. Cue mass "I don't get it" from the Incubators.]]

to:

* EldritchAbomination: Judging from [[spoiler: Homura]]'s [[spoiler:Homura]]'s BreakingSpeech towards Kyubey, either the "magic" they unleashed into the world or indeed human emotions themselves seem to be this.
** HumansAreCthulhu: Implied in the anime, with Kyubey claiming that [[HumanityIsInsane human emotion is a mental disorder]], and yet his kind manipulates magic that came from emotion, because the magic disobeys the thermodynamic law, which is illogical for the rationalization they can comprehend. In this movie, not only the do the girls that he seeks to manipulate fight back with sheer force of will and emotion [[spoiler:to the point of betraying their karmic destiny of FateWorseThanDeath in [[FaustianRebellion their]] [[AscendToAHigherPlaneOfExistence own]] [[DrivenToSuicide way]], one of them uses ThePowerOfLove ''so hard'' hard'', she remakes the reality with the entire Incubator race as her slaves with no way to get out of the situation. Cue mass "I don't get it" "This is so illogical" from the Incubators.]]



* EndOfAnAge: [[spoiler: [[WhamEpisode Madoka's reign as goddess comes to an end.]]]]

to:

* EndOfAnAge: [[spoiler: [[WhamEpisode [[spoiler:[[WhamEpisode Madoka's reign as goddess comes to an end.]]]]



* ExactWords: [[spoiler: Madoka wished to erase all witches before they were born. Homulilly exists because she's still in Homura's soul gem; in other words, she hasn't been born yet. Oktavia and Charlotte were never truly born, but were absorbed into the Law of Cycles along with Sayaka and Nagisa, which is why Sayaka can summon Oktavia and Nagisa can become Charlotte.]]
** [[spoiler:She also wished to do so ''with her own two hands''. Hence why she's powerless to do anything when Homura reaches out and grabs her hands just short of the Homura's soul gem]].
** [[spoiler: If Kyubey can block the Law of Cycles, then why does he keep Homura's soul gem from becoming a grief seed? Simply put, he can't do one without the other, until he can observe the Law of Cycles.]]
** [[spoiler: Homura's wish was to be powerful enough to protect Madoka -- and for them to essentially switch roles. Boy, did she get it.]]

to:

* ExactWords: [[spoiler: Madoka [[spoiler:Madoka wished to erase all witches before they were born. Homulilly exists because she's still in Homura's soul gem; in other words, she hasn't been born yet. Oktavia and Charlotte were never truly born, but were absorbed into the Law of Cycles along with Sayaka and Nagisa, which is why Sayaka can summon Oktavia and Nagisa can become Charlotte.]]
** [[spoiler:She also wished to do so ''with her own two hands''.hands'' (at least, in the Japanese version). Hence why she's powerless to do anything when Homura reaches out and grabs her hands just short of the Homura's soul gem]].
** [[spoiler: If [[spoiler:If Kyubey can block the Law of Cycles, then why does he keep Homura's soul gem from becoming a grief seed? Simply put, he can't do one without the other, until he can observe the Law of Cycles.]]
** [[spoiler: Homura's [[spoiler:Homura's wish was to be powerful enough to protect Madoka -- and for them to essentially switch roles. Boy, did she get it.]]



* FaustianRebellion: Homura's been running one since the beginning against Kyubey, but the weasel has always managed to stay one step ahead of her. [[spoiler: Come the end of the movie, she manages to clinch it by becoming an even badder Devil than he is.]]

to:

* FaustianRebellion: Homura's been running one since the beginning against Kyubey, but the weasel has always managed to stay one step ahead of her. [[spoiler: Come [[spoiler:Come the end of the movie, she manages to clinch it by becoming an even badder Devil than he is.]]



** After [[spoiler:Hitomi's]] Nightmare, all the non-named characters are rendered [[FacelessMasses without a face]], while at the beginning everyone had one. [[spoiler: The fact the shift (marking the first cracks in the illusion) happens only after Homura starts feeling that something isn't right is the first hint that she's somehow connected to said illusionary world, and later that she's the witch generating the barrier.]]

to:

** After [[spoiler:Hitomi's]] Nightmare, all the non-named characters are rendered [[FacelessMasses without a face]], while at the beginning everyone had one. [[spoiler: The [[spoiler:The fact the shift (marking the first cracks in the illusion) happens only after Homura starts feeling that something isn't right is the first hint that she's somehow connected to said illusionary world, and later that she's the witch generating the barrier.]]



* HumansAreCthulhu: Let's break it down: [[spoiler: The Incubators have great powers but don't really comprehend human emotions, the source of magic and their major fuel source for ending entropy. The Incubators are aliens beyond human comprehension, but are themselves toying around with something beyond ''their'' comprehension. Madoka becoming an intangible god was bad enough, but Homura turning into an all-too-real devil to rewrite the universe using the power of love blows their minds. Kyubey says "Human emotions are too dangerous!" in the closest he's come to an emotional breakdown, and if they had no concept of terror before (due to their infinite respawn abilities), they certainly do now, as Homura has infinite power to crush their infinite bodies.]]

to:

* HumansAreCthulhu: Let's break it down: [[spoiler: The [[spoiler:The Incubators have great powers but don't really comprehend human emotions, the source of magic and their major fuel source for ending entropy. The Incubators are aliens beyond human comprehension, but are themselves toying around with something beyond ''their'' comprehension. Madoka becoming an intangible god was bad enough, but Homura turning into an all-too-real devil to rewrite the universe using the power of love blows their minds. Kyubey says "Human emotions are too dangerous!" in the closest he's come to an emotional breakdown, and if they had no concept of terror before (due to their infinite respawn abilities), they certainly do now, as Homura has infinite power to crush their infinite bodies.]]



* IronicEcho: When Madoka made her wish, Kyubey asks if she intends to become a god; she replies by saying she doesn't care what she becomes, as long as her wish gets granted. [[spoiler: Homura says she doesn't care what form she takes, just before she ascends to become Akuma Homura.]]

to:

* IronicEcho: When Madoka made her wish, Kyubey asks if she intends to become a god; she replies by saying she doesn't care what she becomes, as long as her wish gets granted. [[spoiler: Homura [[spoiler:Homura says she doesn't care what form she takes, just before she ascends to become Akuma Homura.]]



** In the middle of the movie Homura mentally berates [[spoiler: the unknown person who trapped the magical girls in her witch barrier. She thinks that the magical girl responsible abandoned her duty to fight wraiths out of weakness, and is making a farce out of Madoka's sacrifice.]] She even says ThisIsUnforgivable twice. [[spoiler: Soon after, Homura learns that [[TomatoInTheMirror she was the witch all along]].]] Incidentally, this is also the scene where there are girls throwing tomatoes while shouting "Gott ist tot!" [[spoiler: and it's suggested they're throwing them at a picture of Ultimate Madoka, and/or Homura herself. The implication is that Homura resents Madoka's sacrifice despite talking about how important it was, and regrets letting her do it, even though she tries to destroy herself to prevent Kyubey from undoing it.]]

to:

** In the middle of the movie Homura mentally berates [[spoiler: the [[spoiler:the unknown person who trapped the magical girls in her witch barrier. She thinks that the magical girl responsible abandoned her duty to fight wraiths out of weakness, and is making a farce out of Madoka's sacrifice.]] She even says ThisIsUnforgivable twice. [[spoiler: Soon after, Homura learns that [[TomatoInTheMirror she was the witch all along]].]] Incidentally, this is also the scene where there are girls throwing tomatoes while shouting "Gott ist tot!" [[spoiler: and [[spoiler:and it's suggested they're throwing them at a picture of Ultimate Madoka, and/or Homura herself. The implication is that Homura resents Madoka's sacrifice despite talking about how important it was, and regrets letting her do it, even though she tries to destroy herself to prevent Kyubey from undoing it.]]



* SatanIsGood: if a little selfish. But then, who could blame [[spoiler: her]] after all [[spoiler: she]] has been through?

to:

* SatanIsGood: if a little selfish. But then, who could blame [[spoiler: her]] [[spoiler:her]] after all [[spoiler: she]] [[spoiler:she]] has been through?



-->[[spoiler:'''Homura:''']] "I'm sure that this place [[spoiler:is a witch's barrier.]]"
-->[[spoiler:'''Homura:''']] "Since when did I [[spoiler:become a witch?]]"

to:

-->[[spoiler:'''Homura:''']] "I'm sure that this place [[spoiler:is "There's no doubt about it. [[spoiler:This is a witch's barrier.labyrinth.]]"
-->[[spoiler:'''Homura:''']] "Since when "When did I [[spoiler:become a witch?]]"



--->'''[[spoiler:Homura:]]''' ''([[spoiler:after siddenly grabbing Goddess!Madoka by her hands]])'' [[spoiler:Now... I've got you.]]

to:

--->'''[[spoiler:Homura:]]''' ''([[spoiler:after siddenly suddenly grabbing Goddess!Madoka by her hands]])'' [[spoiler:Now... I've got you.]]



* WhamShot

to:

* WhamShotWhamShot:
26th Mar '17 8:58:31 AM SSJKamui
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

*** One line of the ending "kimi no gin no niwa" is about a lost child who finds its way back home. In the bible, there is the "parable of the lost son", which is about losing faith and finding back to god. This allusion fits perfectly to the "Gott ist Tot" allusion, as both are about losing faith in god.
23rd Mar '17 12:38:19 PM N.Harmonik
Is there an issue? Send a Message


->''"In this broken world; doomed to repeat it's tragedies and hatred, I dreamed of someone I knew and saw her familiar smile again."''

to:

->''"In this broken world; doomed to repeat it's its tragedies and hatred, I dreamed of someone I knew and saw her familiar smile again."''
21st Mar '17 5:20:11 PM The12thDoctor
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** Not to mention that part where it says "You touched my heart and it shined, turning so [[TitleDrop colorful]]". At the end of the movie, [[spoiler:Homura's soul gem does indeed turn colorful.]]

to:

*** Not to mention that part where it says "You touched my heart and it shined, turning so [[TitleDrop colorful]]". At the end of the movie, [[spoiler:Homura's soul gem does indeed turn colorful.colorful, out of her unhealthy love for Madoka.]]



--->'''[[spoiler:Homura:]]''' "[[spoiler:Finally... I caught you.]]"
* WhamEpisode: [[spoiler:Homura becomes a demon, suppresses Madoka's powers, takes over the universe, gains control over the Incubators, resurrects everyone, traps Madoka in her personal utopia and tells her that unless she stops being so selfless and duty-following, they'll become enemies.]] All in less than ''thirty minutes''.

to:

--->'''[[spoiler:Homura:]]''' "[[spoiler:Finally... I caught ''([[spoiler:after siddenly grabbing Goddess!Madoka by her hands]])'' [[spoiler:Now... I've got you.]]"
]]
* WhamEpisode: [[spoiler:Homura becomes a demon, suppresses Madoka's powers, takes over the universe, gains control over the Incubators, resurrects everyone, traps Madoka in her personal utopia and tells her that unless she stops being so selfless and duty-following, they'll become enemies.]] All in less than ''thirty minutes''.'''fifteen minutes'''.
7th Mar '17 1:12:24 AM The12thDoctor
Is there an issue? Send a Message


[[quoteright:300:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/madoka_the_rebellion_story_6911.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:300: The nightmare isn't over. [[ArcWords Not yet.]]]]

to:

[[quoteright:300:http://static.[[quoteright:350:http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/madoka_the_rebellion_story_6911.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:300: The
org/pmwiki/pub/images/rebellion.jpg]]
[[caption-width-right:350:The
nightmare isn't over. [[ArcWords Not yet.]]]]
]]]]
This list shows the last 10 events of 770. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Anime.PuellaMagiMadokaMagicaTheMovieRebellion