Archived Discussion

This is discussion archived from a time before the current discussion method was installed.

Could someone please speficy which video Spoony talked about Dokuro-chan in? None of them seem to mention it in the title, and I don't want to go through the trouble of watching every single video.

Vulgarity Is Automatically Funny launched as Refuge In Vulgarity Discussion: From YKTTW

Working Title: Vulgarity Is Automatically Funny: From YKTTW

Big T: Removed a bunch of ThisTropers, without altering the meaning. In fact, I'm so sure of that, I'm not even going to quote the old version here.

Caswin: Removing the Alvin and the Chipmunks example. For the record, I didn't even like the gag, but the point is, there was a gag beyond what this article describes.

Lord TNK: Mind telling us what that gag is? Some of us haven't seen the movie.

Prfnoff: I don't care if people want to have me Gannon-Banned for undoing their edits, but deleting entire examples without explanation is not good form. Restored to some extent, though without some of the Complaining About Shows You Don't Like, which is (perhaps) what has been irritating editors.

Trogga: But lots of people will disagree with them. Also, can we decide whenever this is a Subjective Trope?

I'm deleting the Steinbeck example, since he used vulgarity to characterize rather than cover up a lack of comedy (which his works had, but because they weren't comedies).