Archived Discussion

This is discussion archived from a time before the current discussion method was installed.

Radical Taoist: The full quote from A Feast For Crows wherein Jaime describes Ser Arthur Dayne's fight with the Smiling Knight would be perfect for this page. The fight itself is referenced in Thunderbolt Iron. Just the end is wicked, but it's insufficient.
"It's your white sword I want," said the Smiling Knight. "Then you shall have it, ser," the Sword in the Morning replied, and made an end of things.

Jack Butler: I went ahead and added it. Hope you don't mind.
  • Oh I don't mind, I just think only the full quote does it justice. I'll add it myself as soon as I can find that passage in AFFC.

Anonymous Apathy: Deleted "Kuwabara's Jigen Tou from YuYu Hakusho has the explicit power to cut through anything, including dimensional barriers" because it's an energy sword.

Nate The Great: Could somebody clean up the energy blades and magic swords? I stated in the YKTTW, those things don't belong here. Put them into Clean Cut if you must, but an Absurdly Sharp Blade must have a mundane origin to qualify. Energy and magic aren't "sharp" in the strictest sense of the word.

T Beholder: With magic blades, YMMV